AGRICULTURE INSURANCE COMPANY OF INDIA LTD v. IRAWA WIO VELLAPPA DASANKOPPA

AGRICULTURE INSURANCE CO. OF INDIA LTD. NO 18. KRISHI BHAVAN. t2ND FLOORI HUDSON CIRCLE. NRUPATUNGA ROAD. BANGALORE REP BY ITS MANAGER SRI V V SUBBARAO (BY SRI D.K. JADHAV, ADV.) AND I. GIRIMALLAPPA VEERAPPA GANIGER MAJOR. 0CC AGRICULTURE RIO SHALAVADI TQ NAVALAGUND DIST DHARWAD PETITIONER 2 THE MANAGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEEN BANK RABNCH SHALAVADI TQ: NAVALAGUND 01ST DHARWAD. ‘RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) RESPONDENTS THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH ThE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT DHARWAD DATED 04’05!2009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO.17 112009 VIDE ANNEXURE-E. “C W.P.61 63512010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURE INSURANCE Co. OF INDIA LTD. NO 18. KRISHI BHAVAN (II HUDSON CIRCLE. NRUPATUNGA ROAD BANGALORE-560001 REP BY ITS MANAGR SRI.V V SUBBA RAO (BY SRI D.K. JADHAV ADV PETITIONER AND I.

3. PARUTAPPA @ PARVATAPPA FAKKIRAPPA NADUVINAHALLI MAJOR OCC:AGRIL. RIO SHALAVADI, TQ:NAVALGUND DISVDHARWAD MANANTAPPA PARUTAPPA @ PARVATAPPA NADUVINAHALLI MAJOR RIBY PARUTAPPA © PARVA NADUVINAHALLI RIO SHALAVADI TO:NAVALGUND DIST: DHARWAD THE MANGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMMEN BANK BRANCH SHALAVADI TQ. NAVALGUND DIST:DHARWAD :RESPONDENTS (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT, DHARWAD. DATED 0410512009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO 172/2009 VIDE ANNEXURE-D W.P.61 63612010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURE INSURANCE CO OF INDIA LTD. NO 18 KRISHI BHAVAN. 2ND FLOOR) 4 _. jI ‘it’ ‘ I r.a 4,_ V ‘ t4 z—’— ‘F. ,1( . I— LI . . — ti,.I 4 t. .. L! _.p1...f. ¶_. M &\t ‘r C L,L.K4 1.4 —. ‘a ‘ I I y..m Jcfp1 ‘. :“C\.NTcR’WR r N “‘CN”F (J:’4 Fi_’ S1e lit 1! ;f’. It r Ni P ‘.iC , j..,’Z-. D ‘ ...— ti” 4%’.L(’I’ 5 —— i’. F IN4sn;r Q’ ‘I NJ ‘ • . h P61637 2010 •3t •i r • ‘4’ I.,. •I b •, • • .v • r .1 4 ‘‘ i . ‘ J I i — p •‘ • . • 4 L’ •. 1 ‘k a ‘V L. i{%,,’i( k “ r :N’I3 :. ‘.. :.,‘ _.,.it - “‘1 •L4 NT ;;.- .I.PF”. %j CI1: 3 I N • -ip ‘L a - hi. N”.! ‘lu a ‘ ,r, r’ - — •. J• - 4 • • 4,1- •.%cx’.!’!— — “13. - ( _!t—’ W P dl 63W201 0 r C I-’ L’i r ,Pj- ..C J’N’ • F NO’-’ ,,TF ri DSi. N bbV,—tOP’ 6De %pw% •p ‘—C i- jr. . • :‘ jd- ,..41 a R • 4Mt”... “t I iE.E “w. .pr S p.r V rt*.. a j%I • •,.e 7j. •.•,_: .‘.. : . — . ..i -IL .1 :‘ — .4’ C. r,14N .1’ IL t.i , p’L— “a. ‘ 1 I .j a I-. •‘‘ ..t. - t. I.’. I ‘, r I / 4 4 ‘6 63...Olv ‘ F, . • • 4 , •i r • • ‘ • % • ‘ I. N k •a_ 4t I F •• N’—’ ‘ It.). it. t.% ‘..Ztt ‘ISV, i. .r. •— r.u - — ‘it ‘‘.C163R”:. fr • Ff’r” rj ,%s •. : I)’.%’ ‘4 -‘ 1¼ • t 9F)r ,r1r.I,r . 2 Li 1F.1 I’ •t.f14., — B kp( r Vail .. i;K1’ • 4 •. ‘i.j .c, C. • ‘ •_. — .15. ; ‘I—i • •‘ ,‘jr • • . 1 .t I. I-- It C • ‘I V tV’ai •.V . • r a ¶,.— • • I—” — 4 fr 1f4(1) ..; C 4 •v I -5 I 4 14 AND I. 2 BASAPPA FAKKIRAPPA TALAWAR AGE : MAJOR 0CC AGRICULTURE RIO. SHALAVADI TO NAVALAGUND DIST DHARWAD THE MANAGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEEN BANK BRANCH: SHALAVADI TO. NAVALAGUND DIST. DHARWAD (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) RESPONDENTS THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT. DHARWAD. DATED 04105/2009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO. 183/2009 VIDE ANNEXURE-D W.P.61 64112010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURE INSURANCE CO. OF INDIA LTD. NO.18, KRISHI BHAVAN ( 2ND FLOOR) HUDSON CIRCLE. NRUPATUNGA ROAD. BANGALORE REP BY ITS MANAGER SRI V V SUBBA RAO (BY SRI D K. JADHAV. ADV.’ AND HONNAPPA YALLAPPA NAYKNUR MAJOR. 0CC AGRICULTURE RIO SHALAVADI TO: NAVALAGUND DIST: DHARWAD

2. THE MANAGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEEN BANK BRANCH SHALAVADI TQ NAVALAGUND DIST DHARWAD (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVEDI :PETITIONER RESPONDENTS S r,..—.r ;b;tfl •\ e j ‘PN. rw •c- —r rrr, — Njl — :t rr - ‘5 1 !.1 ‘I :.-. r •‘ . ‘ ‘i W P 616422O1O - - - _f, I,. •• • tJ ‘rl%! •r y,, •. ..•S2N :k(t1 R FAT •14 ;. A .. c. r ;yc.-,p.N. 5-3 SI’ “S’fl3-c...7 ‘ •‘,.. :. r: :‘‘R .1’. .,4H01’ ‘ / N F,r*’r’’ 1,, f(. 11 J(- a Lrfl SHa-La’ Mry; -r_. • ‘r4 MI’ -Q N r. — I, ta iE. 4 t t • r • • • ‘ . ?- r— •, - • • • 1% — : — F. • . , b - — It tb “61c43 23. b .1 ‘I) ,‘; P4 — :1. “1 — —I • “ ‘ r — ‘1 N I. R 1, b A r,nv, A 4 N iL L — •. IN. _.;‘T i.I-, ‘ Ti-n- t—4-$1 ‘ . r4’. Lr,f i r3 1- 1 ‘,t\ ,.tt s--. •4L’’ r-• •E: \-D 2; r \j —, ) S.’ ‘ . T N - V 4 I I: *.P 61b4412010 - I-. . ‘-4 S - ‘r 7 , r .: .__i— __.- :._ -,••_ -- -— •: :r ,T:1 • • •6_ I I .‘ • • !‘ •,‘ — ‘!..%Ja, ‘J-rr /4 .14 ‘cN ‘ I—’— 4’ ‘‘ 1,, .“ . flF I. L .1 i j’ i.

4.. $ &.jt(.’,r ri.’,i ,4I% . t f — • N 1C r “%t4t’,’ it •r Nb? rç . t• , . • i r’ %j - a)t,r ‘NN. W.P b1237’2010 N - E :\t T . )Ii r ‘C’-4\E .:‘Rr ‘ tI — • I . ç — Ik I. t.: ‘i L F 11’’’ PiS •rL\J. 3 (F’ frj I3r1,.N :. ‘1 ‘Li”) ( •rNirc.- NUf flJ%flJ r. R ‘ “P0 .l i-G P r — • p. f • Il • •

4. 1b a •, •‘ .:u 9r1 F’ •4 . • . — • ‘ I — I LI. .1 4 . . I .0 %. I. ,• I. — • — 4•• ‘I • •• 1 L P • It $ II r - a •r .0 p I 4 P 2 I, C 0 1” AND I.

2. DEVAKKA KARlVAPPA KHANNUR MAJOR. OCC:AGRICULTURE R:O SHALAVADI TQ.NAVALGUND DIST. DHARWAD THE MANAGER, KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEENA BANK BRANCHSHALAVADI TQ:NAVALGUND. DIST:DHARWAD. RESPONDENTS (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT. DHARWAD. DATED 24/0412009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION VIDE ANNEXURE-D. W.P.61 24012010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE CO.INDIA LTD NO 18 KRISHI BHAVAN (IIND FLOOR) HUDSON CIRCLE NRUPATUNGA ROAD BANGALORE - 560001 REP BY ITS MANAGER SRI V V SUBBA RAO 4BY SRi D.K JADHAV ADV AND I. VEERUPAXAPPA BASAPPA MENSINAKAI AGE MINORBY HIS MIG MOTHER dIJAYALAXMI WIO BASAPPA MENSINAKAI 0CC AGRIL R/O SHALAVADI TO NAVALGUND DIST DHARWAD 2 THE MANAGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEEN BRANCH PETITIONER I iS. .• . .11 . —%‘ r • ‘a. .. t5..’4 N’ L • —•1•’ •.•.. —. — S. t. t . I •- ‘.b I • t . — . •..— .. I • DI-, ‘ a • • • • (‘4. WP€1241.20.O L. .Eti (Pt Ft .. KPIS,-” E.;A’ I. k .L .t NY • • ‘

1. ‘cE-r’ •;j ‘%Jrktk.. . • ‘.,‘E- ‘‘ r -ifl •f _rL4_ r 3 1._Jt4 -4I.I1’ V I’ 1’. .‘ .. a-. L•- I- ( 4i — ‘4 S I r I r . ••‘ ‘L I’• —. • • .1. V 2! W.P.61 24212010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE CO.LTD NO.18,KRISHI BHAVAN,(II FLOOR), HUDSON CIRCLE. NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE. RIB ITRS MANAGER. V V SUBBA RAO tBV SRI 0 K JADHAV ADV.) PETITIONER AND I.

2. CHANNAPPA KARIYAPA SAVADI, MAJOR. OCC:AGRICULTURE, RIO SHANWAD, TQ:NAVALGUND, DIST:DHARWAD THE MANAGER, V.S.SBANK NIYAMITH, AT:SHANWAD. TQ:NAVALGUND, DIST:DHARWAD. RESPONDENTS RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT. DHARWAD, DATED 24/04/2009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION VIDE ANNEXURE-D. W.P.61 24312010 BETWEEN RGRICULTURAL INSURANCE CO.LTD NO 18 KRISHI BHAVAN.(II FLOOR) HUDSON CIRCLE. NRUPATUNGA ROAD BANGALORE RtB ITRS MANAGER. V V SUBBA RAO BY SRI D K. JADHAV. ADV; AND I. RAJEEV NAGAPPA KUNDGOL MAJOR, OCC:AGRICULTUTE. PETITIONER i, - pC4’. .I) ‘ .AtF t’ L%jFJ t4...%.’ l C . :r%1J t4 r • • ‘‘ I. • •‘L • -. ‘I 41 r •\ r .T ;N . . c—,, c<: . ‘J “- ‘ 4 V ‘— c-’. ._ I. ‘ ‘ MCE SQ’b IiFT )‘, I rJ ,t4;rq Sr1J ‘ t-’ERr, gLNT 1%K !? ‘ NHA.’kUTL)N ir:-,ljIfr 1k.; : I)- F’ (I —r r E .. : -— 1 T. •)I •F -‘--S W.P.61 244I2OO n... ‘S ‘ 4 • ‘ • Ib e ‘r” 3r.’q r. ,s21-’._ •‘, N IH ‘ I - :— ‘ a.— )—c •%B1ra I J fl - • r,I. J. • F p -I — . • ‘I ‘ • .•. • •:— •-• •. • ‘_; :! •):. •1.. —I • I’... •.. I — •1 F ••

5. .1 W P 61245’20’O 1-• T ‘. ‘•‘ S ‘4 •4 ‘.0 —p

4.. • •r r - ‘ ‘ L .4’- I —. ,r N ,-.‘‘r’ %, —‘F ‘“ ç :1.21 I • I’ ‘NhW ) ,IrTk, J’,s AL U4 ‘ ‘nir’ I E Str.I’.fr. fh.fl,4SI’ F ? p\r ‘. I .k4F tb1!,, ,. .- r e • r — i’r. •, t. I. 1’ 4_i I • t ‘‘ .N ‘ i N ‘ ••‘ p’çiI.j’ —i I • .a •1.4’ - ‘I V • :‘—- • “ ‘Vs b4’461 01’ L ‘4. ‘4 - r — • I I’ I, 24 AND I.

4. GURAPPA FAKKIRAPPA GONNAGAR MAJOR, OCC:AGRICULTURE, RIO ALLAGAWADI, TQ:NAVALGUND, DIST: DHARWAD NINGAPPA FAKKIRAPPA GONNAGAR MAJOR, OCC:AGRICULTURE, RIO ALAGAWADI, TQ:NAVALGUND, DIST:DHARWAD SOMAPPA FAKKIRAPPA GONNAGAR MAJOR, OCC:AGRICULTURE, R/O ALAGAWADI, TQ:NAVALGUND, DIST:DHARWAD THE MANAGER, V.S.S.BANK NIYAMITH, ALAGAWADI, TQ:NAVALGUND,DIST:DHARWAD. :RESPONDENTS (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT, DHARWAD, DATED 2410412009 PASSED IN PEA PETITION VIDE ANNEXURE-E. W.P.6124712010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE CO.LTD NO.18,KRISHI BHAVAN,(II FLOOR), HUDSON CIRCLE, NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE, RIB ITRS MANAGER, V.V.SUBBA RAO. (BY SRI D.K. JADHAV, ADV.) PETITIONER AND I. SIDDLINGAPPA MAHADEVAPPA HADAGALI MAJOR, OCC:AGRICULTURE, RIO PADESUR, TQ:NAVALGUND, 25 DSIT DHARWAD

2. THE MANAGER, SYNDICATE BANK NAVALGUND DIST DHARWAD (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) RESPONDENTS THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT. DHARWAD. DATED 24/04/2009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION VIDE ANNEXURE-D W.P.61 24812010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF INDIA LTD NO.18 KRISHI BHAVAN. (IIND FLOOR). HUDSON CIRCLE NRUPATUNGA ROAD BANGALORE56000I REP BY ITS MANAGER SRI.V.V.SUBBA RAO PETITIONER BY SRI D.K. JADHAV. ADV.) AND MAHADEVAPPA MUDAKAPPA HADAGALI MAJOR, OCC:AGRICULTURE R/O PADESUR. TQ:NAVALGUND DIST DHARWAD

2. THE MANAGER SYNDICATE BANK. BRANCH NAVALGUND TQ:NAVALGUND. DIST:DHARWAD RESPONDENTS (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT 10K ADALAT. DHARWAD DATED 24:0412009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION IIDE ANNEXURE-E. 26 W.P.60783I201 0 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE Co OF INDIA LTD. NO 18 KRISHI BHAVAN (IIND FLOOR) REPRESENTED BY SRI V.V SUBBA RAO HUDSON CIRCLE NRUPATUNGA ROAD BANGALORE -560001. PETITIONER tBVSRIDK JADHAV AD’I AND I.

3. •i SMT SARASWATI WIO BASAPPA PATTAR MAJOR 0CC AGRIL RIO MUGAD TO & DIST DHARWAD SMT RATNAWA BASAPPA PATIAR MAJOR 0CC AGRIL RIO MUGAD TO & DIST DHARWAD SMT SHANKREiNWA BASAPPA PATTAR MAJOR 0CC AGRIL RIO MUGAD TO & DIST DHARWAD THE MANAGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEEN BANK BRANCH MUGAD TO & DIST DHARWAD .RESPONDENTS (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVEDi THIS PETiTION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT, DHARWAD, DATED 1511012008 PASSED IN PLA PETITION VIDE ANNEXURE-D. WP.604031201 0 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF INDIA LTD NO 18 KRISHI BHAVAN (IIND FLOOR) ..iI- ttt.,!L Li ‘“‘t%N p” LJ — _“-E :.‘tVs. r’F— .:. •V •• • i, k ‘z”Z 1’_1.. % ,‘L:)L CS’- ‘I .. AN. “kNC-i S, ..c ., Kj-%— Ni’ ‘4’ F’., ‘ I F .‘FS..NrF’C$ J<E9EP:D S ‘(N 7 ,N .‘—t4E”.’ - 01 r. NC’ r ‘U ‘‘, 4 :L .;‘. :r TL :.;:n,.. •“ .<NEY -c’ ‘ II It t WI ,.‘. < f. .‘t Vf 60404 2010 ‘ ‘i-r. r g • . — . . k2.:L! _I r ‘- -. NLF. — 14 it .lAa,gs • L’t - 1k 4’ p I 14: ,r” ‘i4 VT 14 P I : IS-S C%.. S,-V ‘ I : • ‘ I ‘,‘F tNI r1J %J1j .. •C1 .• Jr414s_N...%1 • .)fr • i.J• , I. • — u’L’.k 4A’( [ ‘ . “-S 1L •‘rca& •C. ..C ‘ :• t-i. r L I\’41..4 a. VS_60406,201 , Vt%j ‘.‘,R’C’a ttJR- - .%S1.1 -NO •D’—N 1tKFS 9 N ErrtSFPJ.t.. F- ;1.Nt’:Eg 5ri :Rc E r,(” F—/ I: Q ); ‘, ) • t:L’% ?F. I’ r iT”. — i.••’• I., ,_sL z. —:.‘—‘—• ‘ • • —;-.n ; •‘ •• : •j .1. I I 1 14 t. — — • ‘ F11.1 ‘.‘——— ‘ • II .4 I • I . 4 •••. r I I. I p — •— — 29 W.P.604071201 0 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL !NSURANCE COMPANY OF INDIA LTD NO.18.KRISHI BHAVAN (IIND FLOOR). REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER SRI V.V. SUBBA RAO HUDSON CIRCLE. NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE. PETITIONER (BY SRI D.K JADHAV. ADV) AND !.

2. SHANTAPPA SANNAVEERAPA TOTAR MAJOR. OCC:AGRICULTURE. RIO SHALAVADI, TQ:NAVALGUND DIST:DHARWAD THE MANAGER KARNATAKA VJKAS GRAMEENA BANK. BRANCH. SHALAVADI TQ:NAVALGUND. DIST:DHARWAD. :RESPONDENTS (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT, DHARWAD, DTD.301112009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO.48012008 VIDE ANNEXURE-E. W.P.604081201 0 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF INDIA LTD. NO.18.KRISHI BHAVAN (IIND FLOOR) REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER SRI V.V. SUBBA RAO HUDSON CIRCLE. NRUPATUNGA ROAD. BANGALORE. :PETITIONER (BY SRI D.K JADHAV. ADV.) AND ‘4 —‘r’..”r 4- C .‘ “C.’ p. ‘t’V R • — I 4 e Li. [- I L ,VA ‘-4 11’ . ‘‘r—r. , — 4s I hr. FPt)’iLE’HS ‘-F-E $trc &t E .1!ON S bLt-L. “siOF —RiCLES , fl. FR Ijj 1 DI-i-RI F#d QM81-1 h fl, <, I ( .J’N TIN Dr T i.K ‘4 L “iN”’ WPO4 1Q rrrvbL ‘.,F T.-W • r •k, 2 JrZAL ‘45UP.-;CF c YiP’-N J ND;- “fl 9 ‘R:’ 31.i,. IAN’ IN[. t E.-.FESENTFD i3. Ts £iA”r OLR SRI :j’lr._ : ‘s 3s”,1 ‘F’D. ‘- N” fr. ‘.. :... ...r I. -N I • ‘.4- -r — —I ‘I. •—i • V • I 1— — SI . a— • I — a, J -: ;,.rL Ti —‘I tNT ‘1 W 646210 1 F S R 1 W.P.61 03012010 BE TWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE CO. OF INDIA LTD. NO.18, KRISHI SHAVAN, (IIND FLOOR), HUDSON CIRCLE, NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE-560001 REP BY ITS MANAGER SHRI.V.V.SUBBA RAO. :PETITIONER (BY SRID K JADHAV, ADV.) AND

1. MALLAPA FAKKIRAPPA HAROBIDI MAJOR. OCCAGRICULTURE RiO MUMMIGATI TO DIST:DHARWAD BY HIS LRS 1(A) SMT PARAVATEWA © PARAWA W/O SHIVANAND HAROBIDI MAJOR. OCC.HOUSEHOLD WORK RiO MUMMIGATTI TO & DIST:DHARWAD 1(B) SANGAMESH SHIVANANAD HAROBIDI MAJOR, OCC:PRIVATE SERVICE, RIO MUMMIGATTI TQ: DIST:DHARWAD 1(C) ROHITA WIO MAHESH MARITAMMAVAR, MAJOR, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD WORK RIO MUMMIGATTI TO: DIST:DHARWAD 1(D) PALAKSHI SHIVANAND HAROBIDI MAJOR. 0CC: STUDENT RIO MUMMIGATTI TO DIST DHARWAD 1(E) SANJAYKUMAR SHIVANAND HAROBIDI MAJOR. 0CC: STUDENT 1% RIO MUMMIGATTI TO: DIST:DHARWAD

2. THE MANAGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEEN BANK, BRANCH :MUGAD, TO & DIST DHARWAD (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED RESPONDENTS THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALATH. DHARWAD. DTD.201212009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO. 24012008 VIDE ANNEXURE-D W.P.6103112010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE CO. OF INDIA LTD. NO.18, KRISHI BHAVAN, (IIND FLOOR), rIUDSON CIRCLE, NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE-56000 1 REP BY ITS MANAGER SHRI.V.V.SUBBA RAO. : PETITIONER (BY SRI D.K. JADHAV. ADV.) AND I. SHIVANAND MALLAPPA HAROBIDI MAJOR, OCC:AGRICULTURE R/O MUMMIGATI TQ:DISTDHARWAD. BY HIS LRS 1(a) SMT PARAVATEWA © PARAWA W/O SHIVANAND HAROBIDI MAJOR. OCCHOUSEHOLD WORK R/O MUMMIGATTI TO & DIST:DHARWAD 1(B) SANGAMESH SHIVANANAD HAROBIDI MAJOR, OCC:PRIVATE SERVICE, 34 RIO MUMMIGATTI TO DISTDHARWAD 1(C; ROHITA WiO MAHESH MARJTAMMAVAR. MAJOR 0CC. HOUSEHOLD WORK RIO MUMMIGATTI TO DISTDHARWAD 1(0) PALAKSHI SHIVANAND HAROBIDI MAJOR. 0CC STUDENT RIO MUMMIGATTI TQ DIST.DHARWAD 1(E) SANJAYKUMAR SHIVANAND HAROBIDI MAJOR. CCC. STUDENT RIO MUMMIGATTI TO: DIST.DHARWAD 2 THE MANAGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEEN BANK. BRANCH :MUGAD. TO & 01ST. DHARWAD. (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) RESPONDENTS THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT, DHARWAD, DTD.2012I2009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO. 241/2008 VIDE ANNEXURE-D. W.P.61 03312010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE CO. OF INDIA LTD. NO.18, KRISHI BHAVAN, (IIND FLOOR), HUDSON CIRCLE, NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE- 560001 REP BY ITS MANAGER SHRI.V.V.SUBBA RAO. :PETITIONER (BY SRI D.K JADHAV ADV’ * 35 AND I.

2. KAREPPA SHANKRAPPA KALKERI MAJOR OCC.AGRICULTURE RIO DEVARAHUBBLLI. TQ. DIST.DHARWAD THE MANAGER VYAVASAYA SEVA SAHAKARI BANK NIYAMIT. NIGADI TO & DIST.DHARWAD. (BY SRIB.K.MALLIGAWAD, ADV. FOR RI; R2 IS SERVED) .RESPONDENTS THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT, DHARWAD, DTD.20!212009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO. 540/2008 VIDE ANNEXURE-D. W.P.61 03412010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE CO. OF INDIA LTD. NO 18. KRISHI BHAVAN (IIND FLOOR) HUDSON CIRCLE. NRUPATUNGA ROAD. BANGALORE-56000 1 REP BY ITS MANAGER SHRI.V.V.SUBBA RAO. (BY SRI D.K JADHAV. ADV) PETITIONER AND I.

2. ANJANNA @ ANJAPPA GANGAPPA SHIVAMMANAVAR MAJOR. OCCAGRICULUTRE RIO NAVALUR TQ & DIST.DHARWAD SHEKAPPA GANGAPPA SHIVAMMANAVAR, MAJOR. OCC:AGRICULTURE RIO NAVALUR TO & DIST:DHARWAD \,;r ; p r%AT...k .P. • • r.c :,ti 14 K\ ‘ ii- • ii ‘ cc’ ••‘••P 1 — F ‘i.E ‘Z”Xi.. tL,.JJ t. 9T’f’ fl•’ ‘ FP •[iit L,t •‘I r.riC.r.:!b,( : -‘ ‘ : PA N , (.14t’flF. s.L1’i A $r’ 1 2 ‘r — J W P 6103512010 ••r’ r ; ;: TJft.Daj (• P-”B4’! I c IkC.LE ‘R• ‘P4,N( rI)M: A C1L’ hEr rs h”i [L F :‘ C. j ‘ — • I. - — t, —Ft • L t .,._1 L1_ •44— .,; r.1 — I.. \: I ‘a a. • •, I t, - • I • .• • g •• !• — •• “‘hr I • • 37 W.P.6Q0891201 0 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF INDIA LTD REP BY ITS MANAGER SHRI.V.V.SUBBA RAO. NO.18, KRISHI BHAVAN. (IIND FLOOR) HUDSON CIRCLE, NRUPATUNGA ROAD BANGALORE-560001. PETITIONER (BY SRI D.K JADHAV. ADV AND

2. SRI MALLAPPA NINGAPPA DUTERI MAJOR. OCC:AGRICULTURE RIO SHALAVADI. TQ:NAVALGUND DIST: DHARWAD THE MANGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEEN BANK BRANCH SHALAVADI TQ:NAVALGUND. DIST. DKARWAD. ... RESPONDENTS (BY SRI S Y SHIVALLI AND SRI.MAHANTA GOUDA, ADVS. FOR Ri: R2-SERVED) THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT. DHARWAD.DTD.3011/2009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO.474/2008 VIDE ANNEXURE-E. W.P.6009012010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE CO. LTD REP BY ITS MANAGER SHRI.V.V SUBBA RAO. NO.18, KRISHI BHAVAN. (IIND FLOOR). HUDSON. CIRCLE. NRUPATUNGA ROAD. BANGALORE-560001 (BY SRI D K.JADHAV ADV. PETITIONER a AND -I i DEVENDRAPPA DEVAPPA 510 SOMAPPA VAGGAR MAJOR. OCC.AGRICULTURE RIO SHALAVADI, TQ:NAVALGUND DIST:DHARWAD THE MANAGER KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEEN BANK BRANCH SHALAVADI. TQ:NAVALGUND DIST:DHARWAD. (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) RESPONDENTS THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT. DHARWAD. DTD 30/112009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO.475/2008 VIDE ANNEXURE-D. W.P..604091201 0 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF INDIA LTD REP BY ITS MANAGER SHRI.V.V SUBBA RAO. NO. 18,KRISHI BHAVAN (IIND FLOOR), HUDSON CIRCLE, NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE. PETITIONER (BY SRI D.K JADHAV ADV) AND I

2. BASAPPA BANNEPPA GADDI MAJOR. OCC:AGRICULTURE. RIO SHALAVADI TO:NAVALGUND DIST:DHARWAD THE MANAGER. KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEENA BANK. BRANCH. SHALAVADI, TO:NAVALGUND. DISTDHARWAD (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) RESPONDENTS •‘4%• ‘Er ‘N.SP \Di ‘iiNi — • •..si; F-’ ‘ ,_3 I. Cf V

4. — I—i 4 I .4 L T 1.. r e—. r.r. ‘I 1% rEfrPeANLtsi ‘flY I. L.a’ W P 6O’.0.2(. F L 4 c j! TAL ‘1.. I(k I C r,S. N rr’v :, 9?’i-’CEF C t,t4 •LE. • — .3 9r4.,*’ ‘‘ ¶,, F.’r iRUF ‘.‘: 1.3 ., r .:)c, ‘Sit L’ ‘E p .r,c L’ • ‘NE t’ 1 I •IP q 3 1, 10P ‘ flf • F. .D’. 3CRIJ.. L . Ui 1)1%’’ ! ‘J.— ..L”. I q. r .a; .%bL F ‘, I r,,.—w s’,N.’ .$ LI- f jI• ;• F ..q,’gj.A4..a —C.%fl1,c I. r r F’. ‘4._d’4 , . a.,.1 • I . ... — .11 Ij • -_: -E’. iyr b041 ‘2010 I. ‘• S ‘%a. ‘‘ I I•1 :1 .H,t— L 4 N .‘ —. t V ir’ : •‘ — t .t. l • tbk-..k IJrc F ! ‘I,_ ..Li I t’ ‘hJ. • ) • ‘‘ • • i - ‘9 JJ .j .(j1’ap,.i ‘9iMs”’r J’ %r JI•n• X •.“ C it J : 4 • • •)F•• • O.ST YtI%z. T [Vs 1. _.11’ N I V s ‘.K ‘-CN.’ t4’ I’ rRAPCI-’ H?I r. T••: — fr ‘> t’t • mE $ ‘“ - — N’” - ‘rr •.I 1 •\ ••• ,14’\j’J’ • r I’ k — •. j•• I -. • Io• :• t-’ C ,-i.•C “•‘: r T’ r — S 1% C%• — — WI 6O412I2OO I. .i •: •‘ I, • j ( .1 ( -I 1 • .111 — • • I’ • I • 41 AND .

2. NAGALINGAPPA MANAPPA BADIGER MAJOR OCCAGRICULTURE RIO SHALAVADI. TQ NAVALGUND DIST: DHARWAD THE MANAGER, KARNATAKA VIKAS GRAMEENA BANK BRANCH. SHALAVADI, TQ:NAVALGUND, DIST:DHARWAD. RESPONDENTS (RESPONDENTS ARE SERVED) THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ART1CLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF PERMANENT LOK ADALAT, DHARWAD, DTD.30/1/2009 PASSED IN PLA PETITION NO 519/2008 VIDE ANNEXURE-E. W.P.6041 312010 BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF INDIA LTD. REP BY ITS MANAGER SHRI.V.V SUBBA RAO. NO. 18,KRISHI BHAVAN (IIND FLOOR), HUDSON CIRCLE, NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE. . :PETITIONER (BY SRI D.K. JADHAV. ADV.) AND ;.

2. TIPPANA VEERAPPA BYAHATTI MAJOR, OCC:AGRICULTURE, R/O SHALAVADI. TQ:NAVALGUND DIST DHARWAD DEVAPPA VEERAPPA BYAHA1TI MAJOR, OCC:AGRICULTURE, R/O SHALAVADI TQ:NAVALGUND DIST.DHARWAD arl%Np,4,.t’I-r sf-’.P.%Na.. i,., •r - t• I- C Sh..Lt,n. j’S’ r’i ,, r L. D r ,,. —. rP .t’t! 3-i;. ?. •...(•. •‘ • I,’ •,• ci, .‘ ,. • • r. 444 Jrcr•.’NDE•.5.rP E’vC3 rH_3E,iy ( IL. •%p! N’”’ •P,0E5 -1 jtC.\ N - aJ,S- — iF YL I rr NN •,••I’, I L..iZSTP.CNN .: n:1.•’ MNNtJOP?rt. .‘ ) c’ ‘1 V.P 62533I23O I- —. a ‘i; NC’-r ‘ - L ‘/ .z. a ‘sr>JnNP 4’ . 1% 1%n ‘N 4 — r — r •. •. C ‘ ‘ I ,c. p ‘I, 4 ‘ P. r 1 • — t••. r. , • . • I I I •

4. 0 It WP 22009 .1 F,, 4, V AND NINCF°’ 5 0 BASAPPA VENKAD! Mt JOB OC’ ACRICO TURF RO KALKERI TO & S DHiP2 AD ‘F MANAGER KARNATKAV’K?’ TRAMEENA BANK MUGI’D ‘JIG iGE TO & D1°T DAHFWAD BY SA1P C CD1KKA NARACUND AD’ FOR P1 SRI R G SUREEAN ADV FOR R2) RESPONDEN T’ THIS PETITION IS El’ ED UNDER ARTICES 26 & 227 O HE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE )QDER O PERMANENT 00K ADALAT DHAR’JJAD DATED 6 2008 FASSED IN QETITION NO 17’2008 BIDE ANNFXUREO W6235 112OIO ACRCULTURE INSURANCE CO OF INDIA CD NO 18 KRISHi EHABAN 3RD ROOF HUDSON C RCt NRUPATUNC RO\D BNGALORF PEP BY 115 MANAGER (BY SF1 P C urNAL ‘0” %NO ‘CT VGNEP BA AEASOBAPFf ‘MM’NcAEVA1 \OEB?MVOR 0CC CR1 RE MUCAD TO & 01ST D8/ FV ‘0 i\NT,.nAsODnIEND;APF El’1 3 £jJ(R 005 RORL P C MU AD TO & U S Cr’ 3 TV C VIA I - 11v DlAPF’ ALiYVPH 152 BYM OH C CR C I C IL)’DTOC STE 4/ WA &L .L)C. b — • •9 .. ‘— — ..- : .4.;. t,lr’.’ I. 4t1r ‘ - — ‘ ‘-LI — c_IC - I -:‘-.i •‘ Fr r r,çi !I:..P.I.I. - s -. , .‘r F?:TIflNS 2 :. vi: ....—h e :.‘- r-I .-L I ‘.LAJ. 4RtE nJ . ‘jNSflftTf(1N (jF ‘IC’A PP4’PJ( nFIF E I— I / :‘E’ Y .P C..E ,is. r :41. 14 F • FT -..‘ t I J’ -a r E I ‘ i ‘ . W. 6235220 - 0EcN uP ‘t - a- ;r L ‘r ‘‘ “S Wçi’W4 fl1b Li %. 3k’ P.41’... .r-’,rr •31,,1 •,$ I -, - C. ... ,. 4— - . I I -‘ at’ - 4 •‘r .

1. I, • •.. . sri” .‘yr ..‘TC. L— - ‘1 1 — 1f, ‘‘ rr. N F N’’e P t- o’_; jN,6202ffi2 I .-,..r ‘,-y’ —, - 11 ‘4 f’4cr- p - ‘T Fi “ I a A r P P.j .I..iL.ia,1. cz’ fl’. -n- •‘i i .‘: -t )R 1’’ “t -r- ,-.. t’ ‘iF II —1 B JC .SHI’c jIJ J, 11M I.)t )fl( ‘-N- ‘L cC.. N- r pats, •- A it-’ I I—’. \ ,,irLry.- :‘‘ ,?JiEls II.’ •‘ ;‘ F tP’ i-- r.r%j I ‘ L • ‘r.•, • •‘ b C ‘ — t’—’. ‘.-:- r’w:.—. 5? —, L’ r F I r •, I - . • -. h.F 6295J-tZt6l;2O1O I.. .• •_ £ ,.;—•• • a... 1 ••• • —. £ .— ) • I •j• •• a J n 47 AND I.

5. ,.

0. FAKKIRAPPA SIO FAKKIRAPPA HUBBALLI, AGE BY MAJOft OCC:AGRIL RIO. LAKAMAPUR. TQ & DIST DHARWAD. MAHARUDRAPPA Sb SIDDAPPA @ SIDDALINGAPPA DHARWAD. AGE BY MAJOR: 0CC. AGRIL RIO LAKAMAPUR TO & 01ST. DHARWAD. IRAPPA 8/0 SIDDAPPA © SIDDALINGAPPA DHARWAD. AGE BY MAJOR 0CC: AGRIL RIO LAKAMAPUR TO & 01ST. OHARWAD. FAKKIRAPPA Sb BASETTAPPA GABBUR AGE BY MAJOR: 0CC. AGRIL R/O LAKAMAPUR TO & 01ST OHARWAD NAGAPPA 8/0 BABU HUBBALLI, AGE BY MAJOR: 0CC: AGRIL R/O LAKAMAPUR TO & 01ST OHARWAD SIDDAWA WIO KEDARAPPA HUBBALLI. AGE :52 YEARS. 0CC HOUSEHOLD WORK R/O LAKAMAPUR TO & 01ST DHARWAD. MAHADEVI WIO SIDDAPPA PAMMANNAVAR. MAJOR. 0CC: AGRI. RIO LAKAMAPUR TO & 01ST. DHARWAD. SHRISHAIL Sb KEDARAPPA HUBBALLI. MAJOR OCC:AGRI RIO LAKAMAPUR TQ&DIST DHARWAD GUTEGEPPA S!O KEDARAPPA HUBBALLI. MAJOR. CCC. AGRI. RIO LAKAMAPUR C. .3’.-, . Pt “ I . i.bp.’...LS C. F r - . • I. 131’S) I1j” ‘b •%.fl •‘%1t kçr. .... I’• ?.‘ r - c .1 I’N GE r 3’N,•• ,T: S—Np •. ‘- C” r”.1- • 3T ..h?’Rb r ‘ It’ “ •44 . ‘ — I F. \JI f% . — %4Esr rr j9 “C .?E CjLE UNrEF F’ tt - F’)t ‘.,flNO iv1 pnjc,,r aS.. rr4cF.4,e ?-‘L •‘ •3EriNC K )tflQ F ‘ s’’ - 2-’;c :‘ 2.’ ‘ W b2354(2010 7 ‘ k ‘ • ‘— ‘:(. r.•t ‘•‘ J 4 — ‘ .L. r r• •• i,r4 , I r • • — • I_ I I’ F L. ‘‘jL 411 rtNK ‘1 b F, ‘k• i•- S • - 5% • — i., C.- ‘l._: 3rF .‘ :4. ;. —. 5 11’ •—‘-• .J. Li .% w1ft r c • ‘.;,N •‘ _ .11 ‘•‘ Drn:;NN— ?. Fr • 0 • r rs-’. 14 3L’ a ‘“IC US.. IEF ‘F- 7 ;j.s. •gj.-. • JI— N\tF}:c i • Lç.5a._ • . , .r -, -. W P 62210-62211 2010 £1 :‘E:N s’ —‘ ?1 S 4i ‘-‘?k’ •. •‘P’ ‘Oe.T Ur SO” CFC t’.C crL,RE•-) .‘11Vy r’A.rt 1(4 Cfr\ ,i.rTi I • F;Z 3I,NP. •&KF.Vi .0% N: • ar4. . rr’ A — ., .1.4 III I. Si .% ‘1 ‘ II \r’ -: ‘ g•’ t. I •t F .i..- It I— ‘p S a e- ‘ • ‘. .5 % . . . a — — .0 F— .1 S h. L.q f•gr.F.r I ) - I C_..k1 •, - •,[‘_; r,. - ‘ . ‘ — . ;— Th-’’ ‘ b :c•’t i-, dv P 62279 6230612010 - ? ,ajJ .t’FFøc j’A\ t • .1 i. - ILk1 H’’iJ — ‘ 1’isu”s CIP:E. %,J”ft 1P PF 0 n ‘(A’; “ .F SP,rt UsN-: -DV. 1t. £ NNrB.”b4’-’ Nat Z .-P” F i3(-” •., C r ‘- ‘-‘p4 4rK’P, Cs_ M ) .. $1 ‘. _iI-. F ‘I.L.’ .. ‘ )F —. I ‘.. ; . ,‘ _I ‘ I .tt; flI-.J . 0Li II ii L ‘ I I :— i- ‘ 3 I.—.. ••j •,• — r’ i - ‘— — 31 %• — L’ - i ,_j I a. r. . .1” ‘II T2 & 01q, ‘Yi-1P”fW s 0E3,APP/ BPSAP°A KAMWO LI AGE MINOR REP BY N G BP Dliii R sIULM PA 34°APFA IcPMADOLL1 a o Y4RIKO°PA DIST ONuRW\D NINGAdVA vVO S’9 kNKRP0CJUDF CHPL LANNt ‘siR sGE MAJOR 0CC 4aRIL I’ I fAR,KOPPA o & 0151 DHAR.vAD T9E MANAGER .(ARNATAAK ViKAS GRPMMENs BANK SHALAVAD BRANCH TO NAVALGUND 01ST DHAwAD “ARAWA WV VEERPPA GANIG -R GLD IC YEARS 0CC 4GR L R’O SHALAWADI NkVALGUND OH! RV’AD SHPN7AJ/A j&IO /EER?BI-’ADRAPPP KOLLI CED at YEARS 0CC A3RIL 1kV SHALAWADI NAVALGUND DHARWW SHIDDMW,i W 0 SHIVAPPA NEEL GUNDP M?JOR 0 iC AGRIL PM SHALAVADI O NAV4LGUND 01ST DNsRWAD • F-AKK kAP” SANKAPPA NEERAL C MAJOR JX AGlL ItO SHALA 140’ TO NAV4LCUND DiV O”ARVAD • ASnP,3n ‘,4eKiRMPPft NE ERA a¼3 M(JO’I. OCCAJRk. R0HiAL’JUI tu Nkv LC UN’i DrT DHAWiAD ‘?RtjF.PKSHM-A -Av’iCIRsPP/” NEEtt’L C,) fr a’ Jul j, .fl3j. i u SnAt, tAU iC N%,tL0’iNDDi Lit g’Jf% q4’4MfI*Ik PF NILR’A I f •.1’jA ‘Q,I-ArLI P t NAVALGL’ND DIT OHAR SAL S sANKPA PAKK1PAPr NE ER4 Gi Mt flR 000 MORt RO SFALAV\D 0 NAVALCUND D rHARWD Y L APPA HDNNAFr’A Ni ;KNUR M \JOR DCC AGRIL 00 SHALAVADI ro NA\ALGUND DO DHn’iAC MAL LAP PA KASHAPPA JALADI Mi JOP 000 AGRIL R 0 SHALAVADI TO NAVALGUND DO Dr4ARWAD BASAPPA CHIKKAPPA ISHARADDI MAJOR 000 AGRII RIO SHALA JADI mO NAVALOUND DIST: DHARWAD RAJESAB B°A1M5’8 SURAKOD MAJOR. oC& \ORIL RIO SHALAVADI IC NAAOUND 01ST DHAPLAO SISA’JARAJ VPERAPA HOSKER MAJOR 000 AGRIr R!O SHALAVAD’ TJ NA.JALGUND Dir DHARWAD LAXMAFPA S,NGAPPA NIDACUNDI MAJOR 0CC AOR L RlO SHALAVAD’ TO NA\/AL3ND D r D1u;RWA NAMINTiPPA\j5HtD/ MAJOR OCC.AGRIL R 0 SHILAJAD1 TO NA’fALGU CIT DnARWPD ANKc’ Mit t Tv? v’’ ) S \S tNAO CD HOSAMANI AGLC.?dlROA to NAJALGUNLJ DO Dr AR”IAC BASAN IGOUD Si ‘DiM LANG0LDA ij5tF 1’ E 4 YEARS CCC AGRIL. P 0 ARH ITT TQ -A UNDr0 LHPP LiD MCJNRiMJ c( vl OVA NiO ‘IEl’B A ,(1 . :t, N-’ r••i •;4,-j .3, fl: ‘S-..’T nc’:. •4_t :‘ ;pr r(1sLi..... —. S •-‘,-‘ — ‘ tN — i,R:L ft (1 C j /T t L ArD 4 IAFI% LP4L k MAJ (.. p/,Rft. flMr ‘—k’) in’ —jC ‘A%3ER r(’-NA.TAK,. VIiA ;r.j\: 4c 2R;.NC’-i & nc. .r): tSAr..’ PPL FNk -‘ ,I rj OR %t d 3R.. • .? - 4fl , I_I ‘ r t.,E’rI. ‘4PF’ j( I’ i ‘4 H’ .1 i c r. — • • :, ,:. : • •. .• ‘h (. • p. I t. 4 TONr’1M C4JN(1t)1 014MW\ti ENKARI’DD’ a 0 M0J0R Oct AOR1 a 0 TO NA ,IjLGUNDA0IST DI4ARWIO KnR’ ‘AD SO HNM”’ kARL’P’’ MAJOR 0CC AG 90 CHILA1 TO NnVALGUNDA’ DtIMV’ NINGAN’ WAJOR OiS AGIL. RO MANSUR DISI OIIARWAD GURUSl00’°’’’ pTfl. “..QA °MT1L YAU ANAGO’. GURUS DDANAG0 MAJOR 0CC AOL RO MANSUR OISTDtteLRWAD NINGAN 44 GURU9D0A0t’0’ MAJOP 0CC AGIL R OMANSUR oir DHARV’ BnSANAG0UDP FAICK RAGOUDA PAT’I. MAJOR 0CC AGIL R 0MP1NSUR DIST OlIARWAD S. FkKtVRAG0’ PAlL s41VANAG01 wJOR ‘)CC AG’ P0 MANS’ ‘R GISt fl14ARWAU ;-fc,UDA FAKK1R14(OAAt MAJ0l 0CC AGIL RIO MANt.JR IST ptiAIUSthO SANGANt r/j1J,A AD VAPPF’ ID PAt’ f%jOR OCR.. AG’ vq, %jfl” ‘R ‘ST • ‘ “ ,01opt” .rt. DA1I MJOR 0’t kc ta u MANSU .g*w*t Pt ‘ rj. LprlEc FsGt A’• Pt ill h.C’ (( A’I pOtMN’’ r t’ ‘‘Q T N— .- q,I •I s.’3L4• :,, — 1 Ic • flr• ..,• j ‘•: ‘n -, N.. L I-’ .: ‘NA K F .,,R .v’.L. S[’ 2 :iRIJ:’..v. F-.11 L H:,.n-:t A’N r a .t%.d..

1.. e. — r as.. . tL.4Z3,... •.,...t., • 3r•;L I :‘ ‘i-— ‘ NE- •-,Cc:. C aN R 41 — ‘ri, it sI:_.:. ;ii s1_ri!t.; - •, ?P. L—t’< —D” I. :F”.1 • N)” 1’ Sw r —c 1’ [ pC. :a’-c ‘C C’ s •; t. — V— V • • I. z. .11 • ‘.: r ‘.?‘‘ • -• • , p — • • • T .f_ • —• 1 a. S •t• d • . • • a •.:, •— •— — • • :‘- 409 6 OO9 ‘I •1. r’A”’ — • • ‘_; ri t,1i1p .4 P .% ••P% e iI• I— ‘: — —. — - ‘-I—., • sii Ui-i--’-’ - ._ k .C’F ‘C. (R1 w’; ‘‘-‘ )N,s,-I .:.p,. ). jT [44’ R ;. .DlL -&22.. rflp.%LQ “4i’4 — Vô .4 -P IPC —. - 4,jflf Dr,3R a FJA ;.I C4J”i’ - DI-:-C c ..: F.T T (Mt’ SO 4 . OrSIP¾S J4-.4J31 \lAjCk • (‘JL %g, ‘ iN S SI t%l ‘.J’C’I L”l .r, ç, ,T.fl( 9f- ‘..J n ) — It IS L... r 1 *s- tIlt’ T Ii. ‘ , F ii ‘4 - r cv.’ •I Il’ ),e’ 4’ - ‘‘.1. I C •“‘ -V (. .‘-_‘t ‘-%. 1% — ‘L ‘. i 1% .. — a 3% “ I W.P 6103212010 ‘R’’ •I% ‘ 6 I tSHi SFiL.4\. I I. L. - • I I ‘ ‘-LC .r. riq; si’E’? “c — .. hMb —F’ t-’_ j. i 1%4 • r • C. ‘1. Th N “ PF [ ‘AJCA Sc..’I.. -çor. a Q SF’ ‘.3C. I CS . F’ “

4.’ • ‘ p:DA’\.:r J i_. ‘ S’-L L1f3r 1T ‘ r.,ç -. t’t - ‘r’. t4MNrP.fr r ‘• T F’ ‘:• 11.1. N. I’ ! !- C •.b a •.

1. • 1 I’ —- I L r •• • • ••, -. ‘1 ‘S (I,” II W’ll..._Lij 14 - . —— - ci- b_t s — r-I: c-.’ :‘ . r b •—j ,1y r. V 4) -p M’ ) tL. E1R pr’ - H.... flEk PFTF. IF.. • Ht SEcPE i-’r. SE•;- S_1,Lk.sPi’ E-e’ .,i. :4j1i £.1AN.a . (t)C1 )h4’ “4’ 1111$ ‘)FJ ‘a /.N3r’A’D% .jF ;r; Dk at’?! , PM.sNEN’ ‘-iF’ ‘)NN’ .tC. (liNt f1?P’... ) jt P,PJ4 - LI IjL$ ‘.E :;‘r’ — _•- I “4 —— r P. ,___ ,. W 66935 66° 3I2OO 1 —‘wi’s 4’ 4 ‘-I — •i I J p >. ; .1 1 — ¶F ., c’r .,Y’ r:t,. .‘f’%h r _ctr1: —-.,..r: -‘6... AL i,..CF C s-RLd:D! T:: F Xli .4. %) ...‘1 JH?RV. •D 3P EPr . 44W’ -L 3$ mR C -‘ /. I. ‘.fl JJ •0 “ :t’tj..... .L.?I ‘ C.I4 -GI “ C. ..C )( ‘.tcC”c •7>. •Ri PPA54’CUr.P .t4. 9 1’ .0 ip’—’-I, If PF.’aj • Q,, — , • ,rl •‘.•• L S 4 .1 - * ‘ •‘ • ‘ ••• A • —a - ?— • —‘ .—‘ I • •— I •. • • i. - t Si’ Oil RIO. SHALAVADI TO: NAVALGUND DIST: DHARWAD SRI.KARIYAPPA BHARMAPPA BANNENNAVAR AGE: MAJOR, 0CC: AGRIL RIO. SHALAVADI TO NAVALGUND 01ST: DHARWAD SRi. KALLAWA HANAMANTHAGOUDA TIRAKANAGOUDAR AGE : MAJOR, 0CC. AGRIL RIO. SHALAVADI TO: NAVALGUND DIST. DHARWAD SRI. SRISALLAPPA VEERAPPA MULAGUNDA AGE MAJOR. 0CC: AGRIL RIO. SHALAVADI TO: NAVALGUND 01ST: DHARWAD SRI. RAHAMANSAB FAKKIRASAB NADAF AGE : MAJOR. 0CC: AGRIL RIO. SHALAVADI TO: NAVALGUND DIST: DHARWAD SRI. BASAPPA SHIDLINGAPPA NIDAGUNDI AGE: MAJOR 0CC AGRIL RIO SHALAVADI TO: NAVALGUND 01ST: DHARWAD SRI.MUDAKAPPA BASAPPA NIDAGUNDI AGE : MAJOR. 0CC: AGRIL RIO SHALAVADI TO NAVALGUND DIST: DHARWAD SRI. SANGAPPA BASAPPA NIDAGUNDI MAJOR. 0CC AGRIL RIO SHALAVADI TO: NAVALGUND DIST DHARWAD SRI. KAREPPA YALLAPPA MORABAD MAJOR OCC:AGRIL RIO. MUGAD TO & DIST: DHARWAD HUCHAWA GURAPPA SHIDDAGIRI AGE: MINOR REP.BY MIG. SMT RUDRAWWAW:O GARAPPASHIDAGIRI H L.

14. ii. U’. :7.

18. IQ R!L p , _:. . •.. :1!iI.’ • ‘; )n—’;’ r.-i , -S ‘IL•k’t t’. ..q •rr ‘:. •f.— •‘ i V b r -‘ it: I •I 1)4 . NR,’$ 1. P S “i 1%4( L —2.. Iflfl • • $54 “. n a. •. • C’...DR’.. r’c ‘n—tr ACt • r jjç •, r — IJt%%)”tt ,\-‘ ‘. V t% tcr3Mre UiiflP •)CC. 4( i• rjr’ Gt r fl% .tJ-’’. <-P ‘ING,Pr4 ‘1, •r.p t:_r •• a 4 T ‘I EE’-Frt .kVK R4C •,q_ •r2p - .., ‘ -C i’ - - ‘ I • I •. Si . . p ‘ ‘a a ••. :- ;3f 11) I. iN’i’— ,- :—“ • r F-.. .4 ;; S t t a. LI %• - - n—s Si. a4 4 r , . •j.,• .. —

4. 4 t _tSc — ‘IL I — :- - I.. I • :.ac..,.,w, c..:. b• I’ 1et’ ‘ — L —, I t ‘a “FL. -i c. -q’r.c. I .. ‘C) -. Tp I A N’ ‘! — ‘.• 4.-; “ r) sp. CPVSd’1T’W 5:r..’7z,, ;. !.• :,‘A :‘ C. I. . - “ML r ‘ iN ‘A NE H 1 rr SEEL— !j,a .; . ‘ttcSIR ‘At, k’P’ . !C ç’ —n’— kIfles..rla..1 •‘: r • L ‘2 N- ,t•”i a, ‘I’ K1 in.’: ‘CC G°’ b.t N ‘fl!). “• A. 1t..Lr r — ‘...j •...JI..’ r.. _r’ z—_. 4;. s’ •! L’i’—r— .J:bv’E .: S.— — A —— \i. L. ‘I U I- ,F: 4 •r t I -a.-. .i--: rH’ 1g_b,_1 L r.. •1— .‘i . - k.. . -_- — P1 a ,P. i() ‘Is N Rh. P IL I ap: SH’:A”P,.. t(ENI.h,.iPC_ NEE—-. •.‘4 ;C- ‘C —G. C S’is’-t..4 •J.-)! Rf.j.r’ ),T %j it. -L c:N.. t’’ Sh S-• .aFPA ‘,-.L* b.. ‘fl flfl F — nI — r’z. .- p • c:,t F’ F ‘-l • —• • • • _. -• •r- Vt’ •. •1-c ••• ‘ —. L-..,. — ‘EL i . _ IL 1, ..s\ :- tp.. • I • • — • • • • V V • —l ••t-. • I— • L1.. ,;r : \.- — INS. ILL?’ F I K ‘ ‘V fl•kO’flrILz •4 —- Lt 110?’ •tfl’•t. %LI. .“ ‘ • .,1II%flF PE- i’rkr’AB NAL.-F — 3rj4,: ST Dn4R”rsi H rAbc T - y,s, N\, ••.fl1 •‘.C .ç,L9 C, !jI$t PI! s.r;j..fl ‘2 N’i. .j:’ . “ ‘4’ L N— ••: C’.: • •r; - • —— ti’s j i\N NP ‘i’• ‘\ !, ( 1 NI A , I-v 1’ I — ,_. • •-i. • p.. • , .!—. • ‘Ii • • •_%_ S • • — :: — — — “ —• IS 45 S C) ‘Ll N’ im tflJ — — r . ,: L’. ..V I _ .‘ II R “R!3j.L! ‘np. r:.:iv.., t; :,Ok S. LP F Si’ s .Ji SS. WkN . Pr’ - e t ‘ifre ‘ic ‘4-t L k. eH,4.r3 •‘ 4’— -;:N’. ‘EF’-c- “-. ..-f’ •flfl. ; • IF- aPf S .AJR f;lnJ:’P DCc ,$—.L r ‘ •tlq_rsiAI !‘‘ ‘ • • 1 R’ F.’ tL ‘Sr. A’ ‘ti J ;i “ ‘ ti-.t -? _, C • • •— ,i—... ‘_.!••l••••.i •,_• ‘ •; • j 1 Al ‘1 • .tt•?4c r.,, •••‘E .1 a 1 •i’< f • ,1. • ‘ :,. it. p i a L kCt- ‘ABA /t .‘ — •i ...—‘L — $ ‘1 ‘ I’ j j1% Fan. .‘iU LI I. Li :.—L It .‘ 511 S SitjLL :.I-I._k-R..R,, P371’Sjl ‘..F.b .J1,R,..: .-t “4 4 v ‘c 4i K’ ‘‘R:.- q R ‘-ESE -EtC..’Ns -F ‘. c1 C iF t2\STIt.flI3N - ND.— “t.’Nt, T1’ [T .st.F .r•w -P’IES -• f-’1At’.-NT . j-... 1 HAP.i4 . T2 ‘4 P 9 TiC (, r 2•C, 13 4.4Oc. ‘OS j ) . I(j$ UI.’ FX r K ‘F ‘SE) N C ‘). W f&91-664O7I2OO9 Ip,S_:t-—, •t. v Q’J5’-l 13’-- J.. •‘:• CR Lt M’jr ,v r. ,t,4a r• . J 1• i.’ ,. Ck t.lf.., I J ,? . , ‘ .1 *4 . b • — I.. N ,t.. p F.

4. .,;— :ut’ ... .4 .;....n ‘- Hr F.NENDR-s SI-.. -: I’ )P %.,iJFI • a a. :‘r.’ r,.i ,x • • • r — %.•4 %F .t•( i—.— r &1-.P .-—,. ‘k-..’. - -: _k4• T. rs f %FVI i2 LI ‘N E9Ti )‘ ‘C f ‘4a r I. -‘ - . 9”.13’p’0? D,iZ.P oI.k:,r• Mk,C crc 3t’L 01’)) :1N’fl”ONNG e & ‘r, DI A. P?NINi*PFA H N .‘f. M5.OP CC.’GIL a’ i % r • a ,I’j C-,T!çj • . I • I J 4.j 4 r ‘:4 )F.r ‘iCC ASRIL 4 A • JP — t t N N’ ‘L t 3; t . — — a; •ci 41 .1 : tP N i C’/ ;.,L • . •j r • • • •, — Is’ • ‘4 L • • I’ . ‘‘c a’.. r •• .. • •r a’ 1 !jl’ I?’ - % .1 Tfl\4) 1 4 , 4.S r :t:_14.&.i , a I P1 j — • P... ‘jtrr, 4 Sf • I. •r’ L.Fr1 — • . L 1. t’ rU3. La C&C. ‘ —c..”_’ • 4pr I%\% •iPfb, ‘ .‘R ‘Gt’UG; 2 ‘I-T,) • ;‘n1 ‘3 .•i 7r’i :: ., JMwb’c ,tnj on ‘l C’k t) A’ H1. U MU-AD Q . •:51PrT’)NI( a r — . P ri. L • A 1 . •... n—Il ‘)c ‘I ••V’’g\’• ct—f It 4 1’ t* “_ s•.d,iJ• I. a p r I’. : fl N V 11% kaj ! •. :, 4 I • 3 — ‘ • • •• a I’ j - a r . . — ,it_t ... 1• P bI c ‘ ‘ F ‘LC’.,JIN ‘I I •r;— - — _._1. ). — I tfl. ti-I-. : “ tC .i’ r’jP I. •.f :‘‘. Ku’ ‘ t “ 2 - i -: ‘t c c’ :( ii tin cft :. • ç••’t •E.• dLt ra ‘c:r d ; .rc’ a •e. .-er ir teit a rcs; • lz.rr •s C 4r( fl ai.ddKo Nt.. • •J1•.— L A’1 ‘r 6 jy t” 1 fl ‘Li , j • )flt ‘ 1r.’1- rr1 r r d; .4F.,. ‘• • • I- , • r_ •‘ I , - I.t • r / • ( • r 4 - n i 3 a P - ‘ P - i D C n 3 n i V c - i 0 s a c 3 W i • a D C n • Z D C a E ° 2 s a . — D C = a 2 - s O ’ - i D C 0 D C a 0 n i D C Pa - ‘ D C D C V . , - i D C v ‘ - 3 5 a 3 D C n r 0 z s O D C p - i 0 n i W o a & c - , m V 0 a 0 c n D C a s O t c - i 0 a ‘ - n i n 2 D C a a 0 p - i V D C t : D o C V 2 D C 0 0 ‘ - a a z 0 Z l f D C D C 0 D C ‘ - V s a < • r ‘ - D C n i D C a P - i 0 z a s O n i 0 m n i r D C s O ‘ - a s O D C n i ‘ - D C . 0 2 D C l f r - s a m 0 D C P - i . s O a z s Q 0 n , n i D C n i D C D C a < . 0 a - a > a D C - i n i D C a 0 z 0 a — D C D n C i a V D C , - I 0 z s O D C a 2 a o 2 a j 9 > t 3 s a D O C s O n i n i s O a Q O 0 & D C 9 a P - i 3 D 5 C 5 s O D C , n 0 2 . ? ! a D C a 0 . ‘ ‘ D C D C • 5 a a 0 p - - ’ - i D C ; s a 0 s a a 0 a D C a c - i < a s a • z D C 3 D C . l f a D C g 3 s a D C . D C a s a 0 1 s a S D C c - i D C o - • w 2 0 0 . ‘ C . 2 o t D C C D C . ‘ - ‘ & n i n i C 3 3 a s a < D C c - a D C . 2 3 o t — D C a s O o n i n i C n i 0 C \ 3 a 0 . - 3 D C n i n i D C D C . a — D C a ° < D C _ D C . r 0 D C 0 c - i D C ‘ - 3 D C I — — m m E a t f z a a 3 t c S ) N 0 D I n c i C ‘ o n D D0I I n i C C n i 0 . i c . t n 0 Z n i D I a i c t f D I W a a % r 9 n i c Z a D I ‘ - . ! 2 i c a 0 z 3 a D I n c S Z o L D I i c D I D I 0 i c D I a o n i D I ’ 3 i c ’3 g n i c o o . 3 n r z a n z 0 D I i c a O t a 0 D I • 3 . ! 2 o t D I D I . — l f — 0 D I 0 a D a I i c Z W J % 0 Z i c D I ‘ - a C i c t f n n a 0 ’ - . I o a 0 z 0 D I < — 0 1 a , D I i c 3 D I Z D I C Z — t f f 3 0 . ‘ D I D I 3 D I n i . 3 — D I a n i D I ‘ - D I . E D 3 I o t f m z e - i • i N C < ‘ “ D I t f > i c 3 i c • D I t f n i 3 i c < . . C D I a . - . . — z D I g 0 D I a 3 D I N a . - I a C o t 3 D I 0 z z D I D I — n i • c c D I n g t f a 0 0 a ! i c • ! D I a a D I t f 0 i c n i a m n a Z n i C C - a t f Z i c ‘ ‘ . Z m a — D z I t f 0 i c D I 2 a D I 3 9 n i 0 z D I m a ‘ T ñ D I a m n i D I J o ‘ a t f ‘ D I D i a Z c o 0 z n i i c i c = n i c n i a n i n 0 Z a • J 4 ‘1 sal. — a c.

4.r. ‘ t1tp I..i:’_ a. II — .. L’ : r — SI. r • , • 1flj-;...jra. rq ‘I: •s Fcr,..c • _ •4 ._J_lI — • 1. •‘—• I•• —‘ %...I ‘fr - Is • .i :.- ‘1 a ..ai. •!. n • —fl. •...LJ .‘J%A — . — I.. .1 •jhr.;cq. V •3 ./• ri tit.c•—’ • - 3” . tt,r 1,r Qfl’k. -I CI I ,‘. flE - :;. .a.,4Jrs ,,c. ,114V 5? ‘‘d - • ç’r ‘—I ;jh rt ‘;- •• t • • •- •_ ‘re’; •a, ‘ ,LIIE - • - .110_a •• (I ( (_i f1 I. • • • I • 1 If 11 1 I consistency in the views of co-equal Benches on same issue, it has been held as follows: 37 That was indeed in conformity with the high traditions, procedures and practices established by the Courts to maintain judicial discipline and decorum. underlying principle being. to avoid conflicting views taken by coordinate Benches of the same court. Except in compelling circumstances, such as where the order of the earlier Bench can be said to be per incuriam. is passed in ignorance of an earlier binding precedent I statutory or constitutional provision, the subsequent Bench would follow the earlier coordinate Bench. in that.

10. In the case of SHANKER RAJU Vs. UNION OF INDIA, reported in (2011) 2 SCC 132, with regard to the binding nature of the decisions, after taking note of the ratio of law in catena of decisions, it has been held as follows:

10. It is a settled principle of law that a judgment. which has held the field for a long time, should not be unsettled The doctrine of stare decisis is expressed in the maxim stare decisis et non quieta movere, which means “to stand by decisions and not to disturb what is settled”. Lord Coke aptly described this in his classic English version as ‘those things which have been so often adjudged ought to rest in peace. The underlying logic of this doctrine is to maintain consistency and avoid uncertainty The guiding philosophy is that a view which has held the field fo; a long time should not be disturbed only because another viev: it- 4 : r ,t’t :““ - : •; ‘1 .: f.- ‘: I- ir p n- -. -‘ C f’s S C ‘.‘r. r t” .L — IlL .)J’• iri’i_-p4tc1 -• n-p’,t-4 ti’e - _)‘:tL.LJ! a.:.:. ..t..tt •. c— , - •. .- a 2’ I’ r ‘P.,,5. rc •c j: ttC.r tas: d i5 .M-’L’i’lg ‘-i ‘..t.; “ nt- •a”: 9 C -d€ ‘ 3 ‘J ‘w re t,fl Ct-’dy :ed’t31i t q ?ha,e’or.- rr. tic. -..fl y -(‘içrt- Pb- r’); 3! stare :je.ri$I’ ‘tac’- as r’ -J -t 0 IT tC4) Aatr ?estc : r -.pat -s ‘h€ ‘ast o’ t’p uec:s”r fri r- r1 ‘ ) pc’c ef I) y . •e-..,s-i ta ena .i’c jta.n’ rt *t- J t1 ea-he dec ‘s’C- j ra — (1 ire s’g€ ; e’ nd° ‘t I - e- •s t , ?c ‘that :as the •e ‘1 I h a - C •11_ ti- - — — - r . a • - - - — — — -r —_ 4 1 —i 1• • ‘A— - —P ‘ e -- - - -- - A I - . —- I. ( f _ a g w i D - a a ‘ - a I D a t 0 g c c : z i 0 a a , 4 t 0 o 2 C a - I ’ - 1 3 a ? z 0 a . ? z 0 a n u - a a a ! ® . ’ 5 . m 0 1 r r ‘ - a t f ( o 0 Z t r ‘ - z a m ‘ - a a m . • . 2 < ‘ a a a a ‘ - , 4 t f ( a D i D a ‘ i D n ‘ • - i Q ; a a £ a c a 0 3 . , - i ‘ - a - 0 z 0 a a ’ r , - 0 n * - . m m C • a5 0 ‘ - i c a 0 0 — r a r ? 0 l f ( . • a 0 a 0 3 i D a , - 9 Z ! ! a a 4 < 3 0 1 . ! Z ’ 2 a 2 a , - a a o a g a a i a c 5 o ‘ - , - . — o a a . - g a a a a 8 0 E a 4 5 0z ) z 1 ( 3 0a a o a 0 o a c I f o 0 * n