High Court · 2025
Case Details
(vii) It is clarified that in all those cases where the claim for regularization was rejected and the writ petition has been allowed by this Court and the matter has been remitted back for fresh consideration, those candidates shall be entitled for their entire salary till their claim is decided afresh. "
4. It is argued that taking into consideration the aforesaid judgment, a Government Order dated 04.10.2024 was also issued by the State-Government which reads as follows:- महत्वपपूरर ससंख्यय-1559/ 15-05-2024-1601 (696) / 2019 टटी०सटी० पቚኔषक, ककष्र ककमयर गकप, ववशቚኔष सवचिव, उ०प० शयसन । सቚኔवय मम, वशकय वनदቚኔशक (मयध्यवमक) उ०प०, पययगरयज । मयध्यवमक वशकय अनकभयग-5 लखनऊ : वदनयसंक 04 अक्टपूबर, 2024 ववषय:- मय0 उच्चि न्ययययलय, इलयहयबयद मम ययजजत ररट ययवचिकय ससं 0- 21492/2023 ववननोद ककमयर शटीवयस्तव व अन्य बनयम उ० प० रयज्य व अन्य कቚኔ सम्बन्ध मम । महनोदय, ककपयय उपयकर्ሹ ववषयक अपनቚኔ पतयसंक सयमयन्य (1) तकतटीय / 17264/2024-25, वदनयसंक 04.10.2024 एवसं पतयसंक सयमयन्य (1) तकतटीय /17773 / 2024-25, वदनयसंक
28.10.2024 कय सन्दभर ्ቇहर करनቚኔ कय क्ቖ करम, जजसकቚኔ मयध्यम सቚኔ मय० उच्चि न्ययययलय, इलयहयबयद मम यनोजजत ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय-21492/2023 मम पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक 30.09.2024 एवसं 03.10.2024 ककी पवत एवसं ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय- 907 / 2024 रयकቚኔश वतपयठटी बनयम उ०प० रयज्य व अन्य मम पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक
07.02.2024 ककी पवत ससंल्ሿ कर पቚኔवषत करतቚኔ हहए पकरर मम अ्ቇतर कययरवयहटी हቚኔतक आदቚኔश/वनदरश पदयन वकयቚኔ जयनቚኔ कय अनकरनोध वकयय गयय हहै। 2- ववषययसंवकत ररट ययवचिकय मम मय० न्ययययलय दयरय वदनयसंक 30.09.2024 कनो ववस्तकत आदቚኔश पयररत वकयय गयय हहै। उ्ሹ आदቚኔश मम तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकरर पर ववचियर करनቚኔ हቚኔतक मय० न्ययययलय दयरय मयपदण्ड / वदशय-वनदरश वनगरत वकयቚኔ गयቚኔ हह। उ्ሹ कቚኔ अवतरर्ሹ सम्पककवत ककी ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय-907 / 2024 मम भटी पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक 07.02.2024 मम मय0 न्ययययलय दयरय तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकरर पर ववचियर करनቚኔ हቚኔतक कवतपय वबन्दक वनधयरररत वकयቚኔ गयቚኔ हहै। 3- ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय-907 / 2024 रयकቚኔश वतपयठटी बनयम उ०प० रयज्य व अन्य मम पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक 07.02.2024 कቚኔ पस्तर-15 मम मय० न्ययययलय दयरय पयररत आदቚኔश/वनधयरररत ववन्दक वनम्नवतत् हहै :- "........15. The Director of Education (Secondary) U.P. shall, therefore, ensure that Regional Selection Committees while rejecting claim of Ad-hoc teachers for regularization must returned findings of fact with reason broadly on following points: (i) Existence of vacancy on the date of selection. (ii) Eligibility of candidate selected on the date of selection. (iii) Approval by the District Inspector of Schools; (iv) If approval under the orders of this Court, justification for such disapproval or withholding of approval prior to intervention of Courts; (v) Status of vacancy as on date;...…"
4. " ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय-21492/2023 ववननोद ककमयर शटीवयस्तव व अन्य बनयम उ० प० रयज्य व अन्य मम पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक 30.09.2024 कቚኔ पस्तर-149 मम मय0 न्ययययलय दयरय अपनቚኔ वनष्कषर कय पवतपयदन वकयय गयय हहै , जजसमम तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकरर पर ववचियर करनቚኔ हቚኔतक मयपदण्ड / वदशय- वनदरश कय वनधयररर वकयय गयय हहै। पस्तर -149 मम पयररत आदቚኔश एवसं वनधयरररत वदशय-वनदरश वनम्नवतत् हहै :- "......149. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the opinion that the matters which have been remitted back to the Regularization Committee shall be considered in the light of the following directions: (i) The Regional Regularization Committee shall accord fresh consideration in all remitted matters within a period of six weeks from the date of remand. (ii) As far as possible, the Regional Regularization Committee shall accord hearing to all the candidates whose claim is under consideration for regularization. (iii) The Committee shall ask all the Management Committees of the Institution to provide necessary documents which are needed for consideration of regularization of the candidates within a period of two weeks from the date of this order. In case the documents are not provided by the Management Committees, the Regularization Committee shall proceed against the institution in question under the provisions of Act of 1921. (iv) The Regularization Committee shall further accord due consideration to provision of Act of 1982 while considering the claim for regularization especially for all those candidates whose case fall under Sections 33-B, 33-C, 33-F, and 33- G. (v) It is further provided that in view of clarification of Government Order dated 26.09.2024, all the candidates whose matters are under consideration before the Regional Regularization Committee, shall be paid their salary which has been stopped pursuant to the order dated 09.11.2023 within a period as prescribed in the clarification order dated 26.09.2024, till their claims are finally decided. (vi) Further all the candidates whose claim has not been decided by the Regularization Committee shall be permitted to work. (vii) It is clarified that in all those cases where the claim for regularization was rejected and the writ petition has been allowed by this Court and the matter has been remitted back for fresh consideration, those candidates shall be entitled for their entire salary till their claim is decided afresh...…
5. उलቚኔखनटीय हहै वक मय० न्ययययलय कय उ्ሹ आदቚኔश मयत वदनयसंक 30.12.2000 तक वनयक्ሹ तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ सम्बन्ध मम हहै, न वक वषर 2000 कቚኔ पश्चियत वनयक्ሹ तदरर वशककोሗ हቚኔतक हहै। इस सस्रवत कनो मय० न्ययययलय नቚኔ अपनቚኔ उ्ሹ आदቚኔश वदनयसंक
30.09.2024 कቚኔ पस्तर-150 मम स्प्ቖ वकयय हहै, जनो वनम्नवतत् हहै :- "...... 150. The directions issued is only pertaining to the appointments made against short term vacancy/ad hoc appointment upto 30.12.2000. Those cases in which appointment has been made post 2000, the judgment and directions given by this Court would not apply." अततः इस सम्बन्ध मम मकझቚኔ यह कहनቚኔ कय वनदቚኔश हहआ हहै वक उपयकर्ሹ पस्तर-3 व 4 मम ववररत ररट ययवचिकयओसं मम पयररत आदቚኔश / वनगरत वदशय-वनदरश कቚኔ आलनोक मम तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकरर पर गकर -दनोष ककी वववቚኔचिनय एवसं सम्पपूरर सकससंगत सयቌኚयोሗ कቚኔ ववश्लቚኔषर कቚኔ सयर मቚኔररट कቚኔ आधयर पर वनयमयनकसयर / वनष्पक एवसं वनववरवयद वनररय लቚኔकर मय० न्ययययलय दयरय वनयत समययवजध कቚኔ अन्तगरत वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकररोሗ कनो वनस्तयररत वकयቚኔ जयनቚኔ हቚኔतक पदቚኔश कቚኔ समस्त मण्डलटीय ससंयक्ሹ वशकय वनदቚኔशकोሗ/मण्डलटीय सवमवतयोሗ कनो आवश्यक वदशय-वनदरश तत्कयल वनगरत करनቚኔ कय क्ቖ करम। भवदटीय, (ककष्र ककमयर गकप) ववशቚኔष सवचिव । ससंख्यय -1559(1)/15-05-2024-1601 (696) / 2019 टटी 0 सटी 0, तवቌኌनयसंक । पवतजलवप समस्त ससंयक्ሹ वशकय वनदቚኔशक (मय०) दयरय वशकय वनदቚኔशक (मय०), उ०प० पययगरयज कनो सपूचिनयरर एवसं आवश्यक कययरवयहटी हቚኔतक पቚኔवषत । आजय सቚኔ, (अशनोक ककमयर) ससंयक्ሹ सवचिव।
5. In this view of the matter, it is argued that since the order impugned has been passed by the Regularization Committee in violation of the law laid down by this Court in the case of Vinod Kumar Srivastava (Supra) as well as the Government Order, the same should be quashed. It is argued that though the petitioner is working continuously but his salary is not being paid.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
7. While going through the order dated 30.04.2024, the Court is of the prima facie opinion that neither any opportunity of hearing has been provided to the petitioner nor the Management Committee of the Institution was directed to provide necessary documents which are needed for consideration of regularization of the petitioner.
8. This fact is also admitted by the learned Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents.
9. In this view of the matter, the order dated 30.04.2024 passed by the Respondent No.2 is liable to be set aside and is hereby set aside. Respondent No.2 is directed to pass a fresh order strictly in accordance with law, specially in terms of the direction given by this Court in the case of Vinod Kumar Srivastava (Supra) as well as Government Order dated 04.10.2024 within a period of three months from the date of presentation of certified copy of this order.
10. It is made clear that since the petitioner is working continuously, he shall be entitled for his salary till his claim is decided afresh.
11. With the aforesaid observations, the writ petition is allowed. Order Date :- 28.7.2025 Asha ASHA High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (Chandra Dhari Singh,J.)
(vii) It is clarified that in all those cases where the claim for regularization was rejected and the writ petition has been allowed by this Court and the matter has been remitted back for fresh consideration, those candidates shall be entitled for their entire salary till their claim is decided afresh. "
4. It is argued that taking into consideration the aforesaid judgment, a Government Order dated 04.10.2024 was also issued by the State-Government which reads as follows:- महत्वपपूरर ससंख्यय-1559/ 15-05-2024-1601 (696) / 2019 टटी०सटी० पቚኔषक, ककष्र ककमयर गकप, ववशቚኔष सवचिव, उ०प० शयसन । सቚኔवय मम, वशकय वनदቚኔशक (मयध्यवमक) उ०प०, पययगरयज । मयध्यवमक वशकय अनकभयग-5 लखनऊ : वदनयसंक 04 अक्टपूबर, 2024 ववषय:- मय0 उच्चि न्ययययलय, इलयहयबयद मम ययजजत ररट ययवचिकय ससं 0- 21492/2023 ववननोद ककमयर शटीवयस्तव व अन्य बनयम उ० प० रयज्य व अन्य कቚኔ सम्बन्ध मम । महनोदय, ककपयय उपयकर्ሹ ववषयक अपनቚኔ पतयसंक सयमयन्य (1) तकतटीय / 17264/2024-25, वदनयसंक 04.10.2024 एवसं पतयसंक सयमयन्य (1) तकतटीय /17773 / 2024-25, वदनयसंक
28.10.2024 कय सन्दभर ्ቇहर करनቚኔ कय क्ቖ करम, जजसकቚኔ मयध्यम सቚኔ मय० उच्चि न्ययययलय, इलयहयबयद मम यनोजजत ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय-21492/2023 मम पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक 30.09.2024 एवसं 03.10.2024 ककी पवत एवसं ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय- 907 / 2024 रयकቚኔश वतपयठटी बनयम उ०प० रयज्य व अन्य मम पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक
07.02.2024 ककी पवत ससंल्ሿ कर पቚኔवषत करतቚኔ हहए पकरर मम अ्ቇतर कययरवयहटी हቚኔतक आदቚኔश/वनदरश पदयन वकयቚኔ जयनቚኔ कय अनकरनोध वकयय गयय हहै। 2- ववषययसंवकत ररट ययवचिकय मम मय० न्ययययलय दयरय वदनयसंक 30.09.2024 कनो ववस्तकत आदቚኔश पयररत वकयय गयय हहै। उ्ሹ आदቚኔश मम तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकरर पर ववचियर करनቚኔ हቚኔतक मय० न्ययययलय दयरय मयपदण्ड / वदशय-वनदरश वनगरत वकयቚኔ गयቚኔ हह। उ्ሹ कቚኔ अवतरर्ሹ सम्पककवत ककी ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय-907 / 2024 मम भटी पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक 07.02.2024 मम मय0 न्ययययलय दयरय तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकरर पर ववचियर करनቚኔ हቚኔतक कवतपय वबन्दक वनधयरररत वकयቚኔ गयቚኔ हहै। 3- ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय-907 / 2024 रयकቚኔश वतपयठटी बनयम उ०प० रयज्य व अन्य मम पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक 07.02.2024 कቚኔ पस्तर-15 मम मय० न्ययययलय दयरय पयररत आदቚኔश/वनधयरररत ववन्दक वनम्नवतत् हहै :- "........15. The Director of Education (Secondary) U.P. shall, therefore, ensure that Regional Selection Committees while rejecting claim of Ad-hoc teachers for regularization must returned findings of fact with reason broadly on following points: (i) Existence of vacancy on the date of selection. (ii) Eligibility of candidate selected on the date of selection. (iii) Approval by the District Inspector of Schools; (iv) If approval under the orders of this Court, justification for such disapproval or withholding of approval prior to intervention of Courts; (v) Status of vacancy as on date;...…"
4. " ररट ययवचिकय ससंख्यय-21492/2023 ववननोद ककमयर शटीवयस्तव व अन्य बनयम उ० प० रयज्य व अन्य मम पयररत आदቚኔश वदनयसंक 30.09.2024 कቚኔ पस्तर-149 मम मय0 न्ययययलय दयरय अपनቚኔ वनष्कषर कय पवतपयदन वकयय गयय हहै , जजसमम तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकरर पर ववचियर करनቚኔ हቚኔतक मयपदण्ड / वदशय- वनदरश कय वनधयररर वकयय गयय हहै। पस्तर -149 मम पयररत आदቚኔश एवसं वनधयरररत वदशय-वनदरश वनम्नवतत् हहै :- "......149. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the opinion that the matters which have been remitted back to the Regularization Committee shall be considered in the light of the following directions: (i) The Regional Regularization Committee shall accord fresh consideration in all remitted matters within a period of six weeks from the date of remand. (ii) As far as possible, the Regional Regularization Committee shall accord hearing to all the candidates whose claim is under consideration for regularization. (iii) The Committee shall ask all the Management Committees of the Institution to provide necessary documents which are needed for consideration of regularization of the candidates within a period of two weeks from the date of this order. In case the documents are not provided by the Management Committees, the Regularization Committee shall proceed against the institution in question under the provisions of Act of 1921. (iv) The Regularization Committee shall further accord due consideration to provision of Act of 1982 while considering the claim for regularization especially for all those candidates whose case fall under Sections 33-B, 33-C, 33-F, and 33- G. (v) It is further provided that in view of clarification of Government Order dated 26.09.2024, all the candidates whose matters are under consideration before the Regional Regularization Committee, shall be paid their salary which has been stopped pursuant to the order dated 09.11.2023 within a period as prescribed in the clarification order dated 26.09.2024, till their claims are finally decided. (vi) Further all the candidates whose claim has not been decided by the Regularization Committee shall be permitted to work. (vii) It is clarified that in all those cases where the claim for regularization was rejected and the writ petition has been allowed by this Court and the matter has been remitted back for fresh consideration, those candidates shall be entitled for their entire salary till their claim is decided afresh...…
5. उलቚኔखनटीय हहै वक मय० न्ययययलय कय उ्ሹ आदቚኔश मयत वदनयसंक 30.12.2000 तक वनयक्ሹ तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ सम्बन्ध मम हहै, न वक वषर 2000 कቚኔ पश्चियत वनयक्ሹ तदरर वशककोሗ हቚኔतक हहै। इस सस्रवत कनो मय० न्ययययलय नቚኔ अपनቚኔ उ्ሹ आदቚኔश वदनयसंक
30.09.2024 कቚኔ पस्तर-150 मम स्प्ቖ वकयय हहै, जनो वनम्नवतत् हहै :- "...... 150. The directions issued is only pertaining to the appointments made against short term vacancy/ad hoc appointment upto 30.12.2000. Those cases in which appointment has been made post 2000, the judgment and directions given by this Court would not apply." अततः इस सम्बन्ध मम मकझቚኔ यह कहनቚኔ कय वनदቚኔश हहआ हहै वक उपयकर्ሹ पस्तर-3 व 4 मम ववररत ररट ययवचिकयओसं मम पयररत आदቚኔश / वनगरत वदशय-वनदरश कቚኔ आलनोक मम तदरर वशककोሗ कቚኔ वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकरर पर गकर -दनोष ककी वववቚኔचिनय एवसं सम्पपूरर सकससंगत सयቌኚयोሗ कቚኔ ववश्लቚኔषर कቚኔ सयर मቚኔररट कቚኔ आधयर पर वनयमयनकसयर / वनष्पक एवसं वनववरवयद वनररय लቚኔकर मय० न्ययययलय दयरय वनयत समययवजध कቚኔ अन्तगरत वववनयवमतटीकरर कቚኔ पकररोሗ कनो वनस्तयररत वकयቚኔ जयनቚኔ हቚኔतक पदቚኔश कቚኔ समस्त मण्डलटीय ससंयक्ሹ वशकय वनदቚኔशकोሗ/मण्डलटीय सवमवतयोሗ कनो आवश्यक वदशय-वनदरश तत्कयल वनगरत करनቚኔ कय क्ቖ करम। भवदटीय, (ककष्र ककमयर गकप) ववशቚኔष सवचिव । ससंख्यय -1559(1)/15-05-2024-1601 (696) / 2019 टटी 0 सटी 0, तवቌኌनयसंक । पवतजलवप समस्त ससंयक्ሹ वशकय वनदቚኔशक (मय०) दयरय वशकय वनदቚኔशक (मय०), उ०प० पययगरयज कनो सपूचिनयरर एवसं आवश्यक कययरवयहटी हቚኔतक पቚኔवषत । आजय सቚኔ, (अशनोक ककमयर) ससंयक्ሹ सवचिव।
5. In this view of the matter, it is argued that since the order impugned has been passed by the Regularization Committee in violation of the law laid down by this Court in the case of Vinod Kumar Srivastava (Supra) as well as the Government Order, the same should be quashed. It is argued that though the petitioner is working continuously but his salary is not being paid.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
7. While going through the order dated 30.04.2024, the Court is of the prima facie opinion that neither any opportunity of hearing has been provided to the petitioner nor the Management Committee of the Institution was directed to provide necessary documents which are needed for consideration of regularization of the petitioner.
8. This fact is also admitted by the learned Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents.
9. In this view of the matter, the order dated 30.04.2024 passed by the Respondent No.2 is liable to be set aside and is hereby set aside. Respondent No.2 is directed to pass a fresh order strictly in accordance with law, specially in terms of the direction given by this Court in the case of Vinod Kumar Srivastava (Supra) as well as Government Order dated 04.10.2024 within a period of three months from the date of presentation of certified copy of this order.
10. It is made clear that since the petitioner is working continuously, he shall be entitled for his salary till his claim is decided afresh.
11. With the aforesaid observations, the writ petition is allowed. Order Date :- 28.7.2025 Asha ASHA High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (Chandra Dhari Singh,J.)