High Court
Case Details
1 Neutral Citation No. - 2025:AHC:26936 Judgment Reserved on 11.2.2025 Delivered on 27.2.2025 Court No. - 10 Case :- WRIT - A No. - 37228 of 2009 Petitioner :- Smt. Azara Khatoon Respondent :- State of U.P. and Others Counsel for Petitioner :- B.N. Pandey,Ashish Kumar Singh,Mohammad Hisham Qadeer,Shamim Ahmad Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.,B.N.Mishra,Daya Nand Pandey,F. Ahmad,R.V.Mishra,Sheikh Obaidullah Hon'ble Saurabh Shyam Shamshery,J.
Legal Reasoning
4. In pursuance of an order passed by this Court in the earlier round of litigation, at the first instance claim of the petitioner was allowed by concerned respondent vide order dated 26.7.2008, however it was reviewed on basis of subsequent order passed by this Court vide impugned order dated 30.6.2009 and claim of the petitioner was rejected, whereas claim of the respondent no. 6 was accepted. 5. Main argument of learned counsel for the petitioner is that once claim of the petitioner was accepted by a reasoned order, there was no ground to review it. However, Court is of the opinion that while passing 2 the impugned order, since concerned respondent has taken note that some relevant facts were not brought into notice, when the earlier order was passed, therefore, it could be reviewed and accordingly impugned order was passed on merit after hearing both the parties therefore, said objection of the petitioner is unsustainable. 6. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that he was eligible for the post of Tahtania and reasons assigned in impugned order while rejecting her claim were erroneous. 7. Per Contra learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent no.6 has supported the impugned order and submitted that it was passed on basis of materials available on record which does not require any interference. 8. In order to appreciate rival submissions, it would be relevant to reproduce relevant part of the impugned order since issue involved is about essential qualification of both the parties i.e. the petitioner (Smt. Azara Khatoon) and the respondent no.6 (Sri Ajtab Alam). “ ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 ख敨斏तू䧰勯 स㞐勏 सम्बኌ(cid:17)(cid:18)त सूच䧰勯敨斏 ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 ख敨斏तू䧰勯 䧰勯㞐勏 उ鲦鑽ू (cid:22) वि(cid:24)ष胱澂 सवि(cid:27)त 49.43 1. उ鲦鑽ू इण्टरमीति⸐╖एट परी्ቌ敨斏 (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1997 ्ቚतितशत स㞐勏 परी्ቌ敨斏 उ्ቈी旒漦(cid:22) क履厾 (cid:27)䧬厞। 2. (cid:22) वि(cid:24)ष胱澂 सवि(cid:27)त म(cid:27)敨斏र敨斏्ቖ䁬㠎 बो⸐╖(cid:22) स㞐勏 (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1982 मⷒ⸤ (cid:27)敨斏ईस्कू ल ्ቚतितशत सवि(cid:27)त परी्ቌ敨斏 उ्ቈी旒漦(cid:22) क履厾 (cid:27)䧬厞 तथ敨斏 胱澂ू०पी० बो⸐╖(cid:22) स㞐勏 (cid:22) वि(cid:24)ष胱澂 मⷒ⸤ व्胱澂ኌ56त परी्ቌ敨斏थ7 क㞐勏 रूप मⷒ⸤ 54 मⷒ⸤ उ鲦鑽ू वि(cid:24)ष胱澂6त म鲦鑽रस㞐勏 मⷒ⸤ वि鲦鑽䧰勯敨斏ंक 26.10.1984 को ्ቚथम वि䧰勯胱澂ुवि< (cid:27)ुई (cid:27)䧬厞। ्ቦी आफत敨斏ब आलम क㞐勏 श䧬厞ति्ቌक अभिAल㞐勏ख ंशी परी्ቌ敨斏 (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1995 व्胱澂वि<6त रूप स㞐勏 तृती胱澂 1. अरबी फ敨斏रसी परी्ቌ敨斏, उ०्ቚ० स㞐勏 मु ्ቦ㞐勏旒漦ी मⷒ⸤ उ्ቈी旒漦(cid:22)। 2. स敨斏थ उ्ቈी旒漦(cid:22)। 胱澂ू०पी० बो⸐╖(cid:22) स㞐勏 इण्टरमीति⸐╖एट परी्ቌ敨斏 (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1996 उ鲦鑽ू (cid:22) वि(cid:24)ष胱澂 स㞐勏 50 ्ቚतितशत क㞐勏 ्ቦी आफत敨斏ब आलम 䧰勯㞐勏 विब(cid:27)敨斏र स㞐勏 एस०एस० परी्ቌ敨斏 1985 विCती胱澂 ्ቦ㞐勏旒漦ी उ्ቈी旒漦(cid:22) क履厾, पॉच(cid:24)敨斏 वि(cid:24)ष胱澂 सोशल स敨斏इ(cid:17)स थ敨斏, ्ቚम敨斏旒漦प्ቔ 7-8-1985 को ज敨斏री (cid:27)ुआ। स敨斏थ (cid:27)ी स敨斏थ विब(cid:27)敨斏र इण्टरमीति⸐╖एट एजूक㞐勏 श䧰勯 क敨斏उኌ(cid:17)सल पट䧰勯敨斏 स㞐勏 (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1995 (परी्ቌ敨斏 अ्ቚ䧬厞ल 1995 मⷒ⸤ (cid:27)ुई) इण्टरमीति⸐╖एट परी्ቌ敨斏 विCती胱澂 ्ቦ㞐勏旒漦ी स㞐勏 उ्ቈी旒漦(cid:22) क履厾 अंक त敨斏लिलक敨斏 29.7.1995 को तथ敨斏 ्ቚम敨斏旒漦प्ቔ 7-8-1995 को ज敨斏री (cid:27)ुआ। अरबी फ敨斏रसी म鲦鑽रस敨斏 बो⸐╖(cid:22) स㞐勏 मु ंशी परी्ቌ敨斏 3 (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1995, व्胱澂वि<6त परी्ቌ敨斏थ7 क㞐勏 रूप मⷒ⸤ तृती胱澂 ्ቦ㞐勏旒漦ी स㞐勏 उ्ቈी旒漦(cid:22) विक胱澂敨斏 , जो 12.10.1997 को ज敨斏री (cid:27)ुआ। ्ቦी 6ुल敨斏म मो(cid:27)म्म鲦鑽, ्ቚब(cid:17)(cid:18)क म鲦鑽रस敨斏 ज敨斏विम胱澂敨斏 अरविब胱澂敨斏 त䧰勯(cid:24)ीरूल उलूम 䧰勯ौश(cid:27)र敨斏 जी胱澂䧰勯पुर आजम6ढ 䧰勯㞐勏 अप䧰勯㞐勏 ब胱澂敨斏䧰勯 वि鲦鑽䧰勯敨斏ंक 05.10.2004 मⷒ⸤ जो ज्胱澂㞐勏् (cid:24)5फ वि䧰勯री्ቌक आजम6ढ़ क㞐勏 सम्ቌ ्ቚस्तुत विक胱澂敨斏 6胱澂敨斏 थ敨斏 उसम㞐勏 स्प्ቖ रूप स㞐勏 胱澂(cid:27) क(cid:27)敨斏 (cid:27)䧬厞 विक ्ቦी आफत敨斏ब आलम क履厾 वि䧰勯胱澂ुवि< (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1993-94 मⷒ⸤ 䧰勯(cid:27)ी बኌLक (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1996-97 मⷒ⸤ क履厾 6ई (cid:27)䧬厞। इस ्ቚक敨斏र ्ቦी आफत敨斏ब आलम क履厾 वि䧰勯胱澂ुवि< ्ቚब(cid:17)(cid:18)क क㞐勏 ध्胱澂敨斏䧰勯 क㞐勏 अ䧰勯ुस敨斏र (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1996-97 क㞐勏 सम胱澂 उ䧰勯क履厾 श䧬厞ति्ቌक 胱澂ोग्胱澂त敨斏 अरबी फ敨斏रसी म鲦鑽रस敨斏 म敨斏(cid:17)胱澂त敨斏 ए(cid:24)ं स㞐勏(cid:24)敨斏 वि䧰勯胱澂म敨斏(cid:24)ली 1987 मⷒ⸤ उቤኌPलिखत शतQ क㞐勏 अ䧰勯ुस敨斏र स(cid:27)敨斏०अ० त(cid:27)त敨斏वि䧰勯胱澂敨斏 प鲦鑽 (cid:27)㞐勏तु अ(cid:27)(cid:22)क敨斏री श䧬厞ति्ቌक 胱澂ोग्胱澂त敨斏 रखत㞐勏 थ㞐勏। ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 ख敨斏तू䧰勯 䧰勯㞐勏 म(cid:27)敨斏र敨斏्ቖ䁬㠎 बो⸐╖(cid:22) स㞐勏 (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1982 मⷒ⸤ (cid:27)敨斏ई स्कू ल परी्ቌ敨斏 (उ鲦鑽ू वि(cid:24)ष胱澂 सवि(cid:27)त) विC्ቈी胱澂 ्ቦ㞐勏旒漦ी मⷒ⸤ उ्ቈी旒漦(cid:22) क履厾। वि(cid:24)ष胱澂6त् म鲦鑽रस㞐勏 मⷒ⸤ वि鲦鑽䧰勯敨斏क 26.10.1984 मⷒ⸤ ्ቚथम वि䧰勯胱澂ुवि< क履厾 6ई जबविक संस्थ敨斏 तजीम ज敨斏विम胱澂敨斏 अरविब胱澂敨斏 त䧰勯(cid:24)ीरूल उलूम मो० 䧰勯ौश(cid:27)र敨斏 पो० जी胱澂䧰勯पुर, त(cid:27)सील स6ड़ी ज䧰勯प鲦鑽 आजम6ढ़ क敨斏 पंजीकर旒漦 वि鲦鑽䧰勯敨斏ंक 6 जू䧰勯 1990 (cid:27)ुआ ቤኌजसक履厾 प्ቔ敨斏(cid:24)ली संख्胱澂敨斏 जी0-10344 (cid:27)䧬厞 अथ敨斏(cid:22)त 1990 स㞐勏 पू(cid:24)(cid:22) वि(cid:24)ष胱澂6त म鲦鑽रस㞐勏 ቤኌजस संस्थ敨斏 C敨斏र敨斏 संच敨斏लिलत थ敨斏 उसक敨斏 ज(cid:17)म (cid:27)ी (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1990 मⷒ⸤ (cid:27)ुआ थ敨斏, तो विकसी ्ቚब(cid:17)(cid:18) सविमतित क敨斏 (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1990 स㞐勏 पू(cid:24)(cid:22) अኌस्तत्(cid:24) मⷒ⸤ (cid:27)ो䧰勯㞐勏 क敨斏 ्ቚ् (cid:27)ी 䧰勯(cid:27)ीं उठत敨斏। इस ्ቚक敨斏र ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 ख敨斏तू䧰勯 क履厾 ्ቚथम वि䧰勯胱澂ुवि< जो वि鲦鑽䧰勯敨斏ंक 26.10.1984 鲦鑽श敨斏(cid:22)胱澂ी 6胱澂ी (cid:27)䧬厞 (cid:24)(cid:27) क敨斏Lपवि䧰勯क ए(cid:24)ं ्ቌ㞐勏्ቔ敨斏ति(cid:18)क敨斏र वि(cid:24)(cid:27)ी䧰勯 (cid:27)䧬厞 जो पू旒漦(cid:22)तः अ(cid:24)䧬厞(cid:18) ए(cid:24)ं शू(cid:17)胱澂 (cid:27)䧬厞। आजम6ढ़ 䧰勯㞐勏 अप䧰勯㞐勏 प्ቔ敨斏ंक 58/अ०स०क०/(cid:24)敨斏鲦鑽/2008-09 वि鲦鑽䧰勯敨斏ंक 29.09.2008 म㞐勏 鲦鑽ी 6ई आख्胱澂敨斏 क㞐勏 विब(cid:17)鲦鑽ु सं०- 5 क敨斏 अंश वि䧰勯म्䧰勯 ्ቚक敨斏र (cid:27)䧬厞। ቤኌजल敨斏 अLपसंख्胱澂क कL胱澂敨斏旒漦 अति(cid:18)क敨斏री, “अ(cid:18)ो(cid:27)स्त敨斏्ቌरी C敨斏र敨斏 (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 2005 मⷒ⸤ संस्थ敨斏 क㞐勏 औचक वि䧰勯री्ቌ旒漦 क㞐勏 鲦鑽ौर敨斏䧰勯 ्ቚब(cid:17)(cid:18)क म鲦鑽रस敨斏 C敨斏र敨斏 भिश्ቌक/भिश्ቌ旒漦㞐勏्ቈर कኌम胱澂ों क履厾 वि䧰勯胱澂विमत उपኌस्थतित पंቤኌजक敨斏 ((cid:24)ष(cid:22) 2001) ्ቚस्तुत क履厾 6胱澂ी और तक(cid:22) वि鲦鑽胱澂敨斏 6胱澂敨斏 विक ्ቦी आफत敨斏ब आलम (स०अ०त(cid:27)०) जुल敨斏ई 2001 स㞐勏 संस्थ敨斏 छोड़कर चल㞐勏 6胱澂㞐勏। उ< उपኌस्थतित पंቤኌजक敨斏 क敨斏 सूቌኚमत敨斏 स㞐勏 अ(cid:24)लोक䧰勯 कर䧰勯㞐勏 पर वि䧰勯म्䧰勯敨斏ंविकत तथ्胱澂 उज敨斏6र (cid:27)ुए (cid:27)䧬厞ः- क-जू䧰勯 2001 तक ्ቦी आफत敨斏ब आलम क敨斏 䧰勯敨斏म ्ቅम敨斏ंक 5 पर अंविकत (cid:27)䧬厞 और पूर㞐勏 म敨斏(cid:27) क履厾 वि䧰勯胱澂विमत उपኌस्थतित Aी 鲦鑽ज(cid:22) (cid:27)䧬厞। कु ल 12 अध्胱澂敨斏पक / कम(cid:22)च敨斏रिर胱澂ों क敨斏 䧰勯敨斏म 鲦鑽ज(cid:22) (cid:27)䧬厞 पर(cid:17)तु ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 ख敨斏तू䧰勯 क敨斏 䧰勯敨斏म विकसी Aी ्ቅम敨斏ंक पर अंविकत 䧰勯(cid:27)ीं (cid:27)䧬厞। ख-जुल敨斏ई 2001 मⷒ⸤ ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 ख敨斏तू䧰勯 क敨斏 䧰勯敨斏म कम敨斏ंक 13 पर कर वि鲦鑽胱澂㞐勏 ज敨斏त㞐勏 (cid:27)ैं। ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 क履厾 उपኌस्थतित 鲦鑽ज(cid:22) प敨斏胱澂ी ज敨斏ती (cid:27)䧬厞 जबविक आफत敨斏ब आलम क履厾 उपኌस्थतित क敨斏लम को ख敨斏ली रख敨斏 6胱澂敨斏। ्ቚ(cid:18)敨斏䧰勯敨斏च敨斏胱澂(cid:22) C敨斏र敨斏 䧰勯 तो उ(cid:17)(cid:27)ⷒ⸤ अ䧰勯ुपኌस्थत 鲦鑽ज(cid:22) विक胱澂敨斏 6胱澂敨斏 (cid:27)䧬厞 और 䧰勯 (cid:27)ी कोई विकसी ्ቚक敨斏र क履厾 कोई 䧰勯क敨斏र敨斏त्मक विटप्प旒漦ी (cid:27)ी 鲦鑽ज(cid:22) क履厾 6胱澂ी (cid:27)䧬厞। म敨斏(cid:27) जुल敨斏ई मⷒ⸤ स्ट敨斏फ क履厾 संख्胱澂敨斏 12 स㞐勏 बढ़कर 15 (cid:27)ो ज敨斏ती (cid:27)䧬厞 胱澂(cid:27)ी ्ቅम म敨斏(cid:27) ቤኌसतम्बर 2001 तक चलत敨斏 (cid:27)䧬厞। म敨斏(cid:27) अ5टू बर 2001 क㞐勏 लिलए जो पंቤኌजक敨斏 क敨斏 पृ् ्ቚस्तुत (जो⸐╖敨斏) विक胱澂敨斏 6胱澂敨斏 (cid:27)䧬厞 (cid:24)(cid:27) अ(cid:17)胱澂 पृ्ों स㞐勏 विबLकु ल भिA्ቐ (cid:27)䧬厞। ቤኌजसस㞐勏 इस आशंक敨斏 को पूर敨斏 बल विमलत敨斏 (cid:27)䧬厞 विक जू䧰勯 2001 क㞐勏 ब敨斏鲦鑽 क㞐勏 पृ्ों को ब鲦鑽लकर आफत敨斏ब आलम क敨斏 䧰勯敨斏म ए(cid:24)ं उ䧰勯क履厾 उपኌस्थतित को 6敨斏胱澂ब कर उ䧰勯क履厾 ज6(cid:27) ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 ख敨斏तू䧰勯 क履厾 उपኌस्थतित कू ट रच䧰勯敨斏 C敨斏र敨斏 सम敨斏胱澂ोቤኌजत कर वि鲦鑽胱澂敨斏 6胱澂敨斏 (cid:27)䧬厞। (उ< पंቤኌजक敨斏 क履厾 छ敨斏胱澂敨斏्ቚतित संल्ሿ (cid:27)䧬厞) " (cid:22) 4 अतः उपरो< स㞐勏 स्प्ቖ (cid:27)䧬厞 विक ्ቦी आफत敨斏ब आलम (cid:27)ी म鲦鑽रस敨斏 ज敨斏विम胱澂敨斏 अरविब胱澂敨斏 त䧰勯(cid:24)ीरूल उलूम 䧰勯ौश(cid:27)र敨斏, जी胱澂䧰勯पुर आजम6ढ़ मⷒ⸤ वि(cid:24)ति(cid:18)(cid:24)त वि䧰勯胱澂ु< स(cid:27)敨斏० अध्胱澂敨斏पक (cid:27)䧬厞। जबविक ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 ख敨斏तू䧰勯 C敨斏र敨斏 म鲦鑽रस㞐勏 मⷒ⸤ अप䧰勯ी वि䧰勯胱澂ुवि< क㞐勏 सम्ब(cid:17)(cid:18) मⷒ⸤ जो अभिAल㞐勏ख / स敨斏ቌኚ胱澂 ्ቚस्तुत विक胱澂㞐勏 (cid:27)ैं उसस㞐勏 स्प्ቖ (cid:27)䧬厞 विक ्ቦीमती अजर敨斏 ब敨斏तू䧰勯 स(cid:27)敨斏०अ० त(cid:27)त敨斏वि䧰勯胱澂敨斏 प鲦鑽 पर क敨斏胱澂(cid:22)रत 䧰勯(cid:27)ीं थी। 5胱澂ोंविक ्ቚब(cid:17)(cid:18)तं्ቔ / ्ቚब(cid:17)(cid:18)क म鲦鑽रस敨斏 उपरो< C敨斏र敨斏 उ䧰勯क履厾 वि䧰勯胱澂ुवि< क㞐勏 सम्ब(cid:17)(cid:18) मⷒ⸤ जो अभिAल㞐勏ख ्ቚसूत विक胱澂㞐勏 (cid:24)(cid:27) क敨斏Lपवि䧰勯क ए(cid:24)ं ्ቌ㞐勏्ቔ敨斏ति(cid:18)क敨斏र वि(cid:24)(cid:27)ी䧰勯 (cid:27)䧬厞 जो पू旒漦(cid:22)त胱澂敨斏 शू(cid:17)胱澂 क履厾 ्ቦ㞐勏旒漦ी मⷒ⸤ आत㞐勏 (cid:27)ैं। जबविक ्ቦी आफत敨斏ब आलम क履厾 वि䧰勯胱澂ुवि< (cid:24)ष(cid:22) 1996-97 मⷒ⸤ स(cid:27)敨斏०अ० त(cid:27)त敨斏वि䧰勯胱澂敨斏 क㞐勏 प鲦鑽 पर क履厾 6ई (cid:27)䧬厞 ቤኌजस㞐勏 स्(cid:24)胱澂ं ्ቚब(cid:17)(cid:18)क ्ቦी 6ुल敨斏म मो(cid:27)म्म鲦鑽 䧰勯㞐勏 अप䧰勯㞐勏 ब胱澂敨斏䧰勯 वि鲦鑽䧰勯敨斏ंक 05.10.2004 मⷒ⸤ स्(cid:24)ीक敨斏र विक胱澂敨斏 (cid:27)䧬厞। अतः सम्बኌ(cid:17)(cid:18)क स敨斏ቌኚ胱澂/ अभिAल㞐勏ख जो क敨斏胱澂敨斏(cid:22)ल胱澂 मⷒ⸤ उपलब्(cid:18) कर敨斏胱澂㞐勏 6胱澂㞐勏 (cid:27)䧬厞 क㞐勏 आ(cid:18)敨斏र पर ्ቦी आफत敨斏ब आलम को (cid:27)ी स(cid:27)敨斏० अ० त(cid:27)त敨斏वि䧰勯胱澂敨斏 प鲦鑽 पर वि䧰勯胱澂ुवि< (cid:27)㞐勏त अ(cid:27)(cid:22) प敨斏胱澂敨斏 6胱澂敨斏। " 9. A finding returned in regard to respondent no.6 was that his appointment was of a year 1996-1997 and not of year 1993- 1994 and it was based on a statement of Manager of concerned Madarsa. However, said finding is contrary to stand of said respondent as taken in the earlier round of litigation as well as in counter affidavit filed in present writ petition, wherein it was declared that he was appointed on 12.7.1994. For reference para 4 of counter affidavit is reproduced hereinafter: “4. That a Society namely Tanzeem Jamia Arabia Tanveerul Oloom Mauza Naoshahra, Post Jeanpur, Tehsil Sadar, District Azamgarh was registered on 6.6.1990 which is renewed time to time continuously and the aforesaid society established a Madarsa known as Fantania Madarsa Jamia Arbiya Tanveerul Oloom Naoshahra, Jeanpur (Azamgarh) district Azamgarh (institution) in the same year i.e. 1990 and thereafter on 12.7.1994 the deponent (answering-respondent) was appointed as Assistant Teacher Tahtania in the Institution and he joined the Institution immediately and started working as Assistant Teacher. The recognition of the Institution was granted on 31.3.1995 by the Arbic Farsi Madarsa Board and the provisions of U.P. Ashashiya Arbi Tatha Farsi Madarsa Ki Manyata Avam Seva Niyamawali. And the aforesaid Institution was aided in permanent of the Government Order dated 15.5.2004 by the State Government.” 10. In the aforesaid circumstances, since the respondent no.6 has passed Intermediate exam in 1995 and Munshi in 1995 and certificate was issued 12.10.1997, therefore, he was not eligible for appointment 5 in 1994, therefore, finding returned was perverse as well as the statement of Manager of Madarsa that respondent no. 6 was appointed in 1996-97 was an incorrect statement, therefore, said finding being perverse is set aside and it's legal consequence shall follow. 11. So far as claim of petitioner is concerned, it was rejected on the ground that she was appointed on 26.10.1984, whereas Madrasa in question came into existence in the year 1990. 12. Petitioner in the present writ petition in paragraph number 6 has declared that she was appointed on the post of Tahtania by the Committee of Management of the concerned Madrasa on 26.1.1997 and has not refuted the said finding returned in the impugned order that she was appointed on 26.10.1984, more specifically she has neither accepted it nor denied it. 13. In the present petition, there is no ground available with this Court to interfere with the said finding being based on documents available, therefore, there is no reason to interfere with the said finding returned so far as petitioner is concerned. 14. As referred above, Court has interfered with the finding returned in regard to respondent no.6 is concerned, therefore, this writ petition is accordingly disposed of with the aforesaid modification of impugned order dated 30.6.2009 that neither the petitioner nor the respondent no.6 was eligible for the post of Assistant Teacher Tahtania at the relevant time and its legal consequence shall follow. 15. Registrar (Compliance) to take steps. Order Date :- 27.2.2025 SB Digitally signed by :- SANDEEP BHATTACHARYA High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Arguments
1. Heard Sri Arun Kumar Tiwari, learned counsel for the petitioner, Sri B.N.Mishra and Sri R.V.Mishra, learned counsel for the respondent no.6. 2. This writ petition is pending since 2009 that is more than one and a half decade. 3. The issue before this Court is as to whether petitioner or respondent no. 6 was eligible for appointment on the post of Assistant Teacher Tahtania in the concerned madarsa.