High Court · 2025

Mr. Rakshit Joshi, Advocat e for t he pet it ioner.

2. Mr. Ganesh Dut t Kandpal, Deput y Advocat e General t he St at e of Ut t arakhand / respondent no. 1.

3. Mr. Bhuwan Bhat t , Advocat e respondent no. 3.

4. Mr. Parikshit Saini, Advocat e respondent no. 4. in MBBS 5. Pet it ioner was adm it t ed Course in Governm ent Doon Medical College, Dehradun, during Academ ic Session 2020- 21. According t o him , he could not pass t he First Professional Exam inat ion and now t he College is not perm it t ing him t o appear in t he First Professional Supplem ent ary Exam inat ion.

6. By m eans of pet it ioner has sought reliefs: t his writ pet it ion, following t he com m anding of m andam us “ i. I ssue a writ , rule or direct ion in t he nat ure t he Respondent s t o perm it t he Pet it ioner t o appear in t he fort hcom ing Universit y Supplem ent ary 1st professional MBBS exam inat ion Bat ch 2024 for 10.11.2025 and ( Anat om y) scheduled 11.11.2025, available t he supplem ent ary exam inat ion. ii. I ssue a writ , rule or direct ion in t he t he of m andam us, nat ure Respondent s t he NMC t o give effect Not ificat ion dat ed 11.12.2023 grant ing one addit ional ( m ercy) at t em pt t o MBBS st udent s direct ing t o adm it t ed during t he academ ic year 2020- 21, t he pet it ioner. t he sam e benefit t o ext end t o iii. I ssue a writ , rule and direct ion in t he nat ure of m andam us direct ing t he Respondent No. 4 t o decide t he pet it ioner's represent at ion dat ed 24.07.2025 expedit iously, preferably before t he scheduled dat e of exam inat ion.” Nat ional

7. Mr. Parikshit Saini, learned counsel Medical appearing Com m ission subm it s t hat as pet it ioner is not on t he rolls of Nat ional Medical Com m ission, t herefore, represent at ion, if m ade by him , direct ly t o Nat ional Medical Com m ission would not be ent ert ained. He subm it s t hat if pet it ioner is seeking Medical perm ission Com m ission t he supplem ent ary exam inat ion, as he has failed t o qualify t he First Professional Exam inat ion even aft er five years, t hen t he applicat ion m ade by him has t o be t he rout ed concerned recom m endat ion and ot her det ails of t he pet it ioner. Nat ional appearing t he Principal of t hrough college, wit h

8. Learned counsel for t he pet it ioner subm it s t hat due t o t ragic event s which st ruck fam ily of t he pet it ioner, while he was a t oddler, he becam e orphan and during last five years also, t here were cert ain unfort unat e t o which pet it ioner could not appear in t he exam inat ion. He aut horit ies are not direct ed t o consider pet it ioner’s claim for appearing in t he Supplem ent ary Exam inat ion, pet it ioner would lose t he last hope of his life incident s, due subm it s t hat regard fact s and 9. Having circum st ances of t he writ pet it ion is disposed of wit h libert y t o t he case, t he t o t o t o fut ure. forward in near Nat ional t o appear t o be held t o m ake applicat ion t he pet it ioner Principal of t he concerned college for perm ission t he First Professional Supplem ent ary Exam inat ion, likely I f pet it ioner m akes such applicat ion wit hin t he one week, Principal shall applicat ion Medical Com m ission along wit h all necessary inform at ion/ part iculars of t he pet it ioner wit h his recom m endat ion wit hin next t en days. The Nat ional Medical Com m ission ( Under Graduat e Medicat ion Educat ion Board) shall look int o t he prayer m ade by t he pet it ioner, as recom m ended by t he Principal of t he concerned college and pass necessary orders, as per law, as expedit iously as possible.

10.11.2025 ( M a n o j K u m a r Ti w a r i , J.) Navin NAVEEN CHANDRA DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, 2.5.4.20=3be23325146e76a0642bdf4943fb 9046f487df006da82a131bb4e4403d3c0a15 , postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND, serialNumber=18167EEFB5CA8CFFD421A1 03819DA875643AF56D653D095C6ED9A86 DAAB21CE5, cn=NAVEEN CHANDRA