✦ High Court of India · 31 Oct 2025

Dist-Sepahijala, Tripura v. WestAgartala, Sub-Division Sadar, District West Tripura

Case Details High Court of India · 31 Oct 2025

Court

High Court of India

Decided

31 Oct 2025

Bench

Not available

Length

25,588 words

Acts & Sections

A of the Bihar Private Irrigation Works Act 1922 Code of Civil Procedure Constitution of India Indian Penal Code The qualifications in the case of teachers governed by the provisions of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act 2009

Cited in this judgment

S/O.-Sripada Chakraborty, R/O-Tuichindrai, Teliamura, 799205

143. Shyamal Rudra Paul S/O.- Sudhan Rudra Paul, R/O-Hawaibari, Teliamura, 799205

144. Sukanta Sarkar S/O.-Parimal Bikash Sarkar, R/O-Khasiamangal Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, 799205

145. Jayanta Debnath S/O.-Dhananjoy Debnath, R/O-Paschim Gilatali, Gilatali Bazar, Khowai Tripura, 799203

146. Laxmi Bhattacharjee W/O-Jiban Chakraborty, R/O-Ichar Bill, Karailong, Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, 799205

147. Nirmal Debnath S/O.-Bimal Ch. Debnath, R/O-Ichar Bill, Karailong, Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, 799205

148. Suparna Chowdhury D/O- Lt. Nepal Chowdhury, R/O-Chalitabari, Moharchara, Teliamura, Tripura, 799203 Khowai

149. Priyatosh Debnth S/O.-Lt. Manohar Debnath, R/O-Samru Charra, Chebri Khowai Tripura, 799207

150. Swarnalata Karmakar D/O-Lt. Rama Karmakar, R/O-Huplong Charra, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799254

151. Md. Amir Uddin S/O.-Lt. Kabir Mia, North Nayapara, Dharmanagar North Tripura, 799250

152. Jayasri Bhattacharjee W/O-Prosenjit Bhattacharjee, R/O-Kalibari Road, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799250

153. Sampa Deb (Dhar) W/O- Bidhan Dhar, R/O-South Nayapara, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799250

154. Pinki Deb W/O-Asit Deb, R/O-Kameswar, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799253

155. Mrinal Kanti Pal S/O.-Mrityunjoy Pal, R/O-Tarakpur, Kadamtala, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799261

156. Debasish Sen S/O.-Salil Ch. Sen, R/O-South Ganganagar, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799253

157. Rupali Nath (Sharma) W/O-Akshay Nath, R/O-Amtila, Kadamtala, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799261

158. Nirjhar Kanti Das S/O.-Lt. Nikhil Ranjan Das, R/O-Chandrapur Colony, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799251

159. Dipak Nath S/O.-Lt. Digendra Mohan Nath, R/O-Sonarubasa, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799251

160. Dibakar Chakraborty S/O.-Lt. Ranjit Chakraborty, R/O-Kameswar, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799253

161. Subhra Choudhury W/O- Biswarup Bhattacharjee, R/O-Debiprasad Sarani, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799251

162. Archana Rani Debnath D/O-Manoranjan Debnath, R/O-Jalebasa, Panisagar, North Tripura, 799260

163. Babu Kr. Nair S/O.-Lt. Gopi Nair M, R/O-Bagbasa, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799253

164. Sitangshu Datta S/O.- Lt. Gopal Datta, R/O-Baghun, Premtala, Churaibari, North Tripura, 799261

165. Chandan Deb S/O.- Hiralal Deb, R/O-Kadamtala, North Tripura, 799261

166. Ashis Kumar Chakraborty S/O.- Lt. Anukul Ch. Chakraborty, R/O-Madhya Nayapara, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799250

167. Amitabha Pal S/O.- Lt. Anil Kanta Pal, R/O-Madhya Nayapara, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799250

168. Seema Chakraborty (Bhattacharjee) W/O-Dhrubajyoti Bhattacharjee, R/O-Nayapara, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799250

169. Anjana Rani Pal (Saha) W/O-Nepal Saha, R/O-Nidaya, Jatrapur, 799132

170. Atanu Chakraborty S/O.-Satya Ranjan Chakraborty, R/O-South Maheshpur, Kathalia, Jatrapur, Sepahijala Tripura, 799132

171. Panna Acharjee S/O.- Phani Bhushan Acharjee, R/O-Kadamtala, Dharmanagar,799261

172. Rabindra Nath S/O.- Lt. Birendra Nath, R/O- Kadamtala, Dharmanagar,799261

173. Naru Gopal De S/O.-Satish Ch. De, Tarakpur Kadamtala, R/O-Kadamtala, Dharmanagar, 799261

174. Prasanna Tanti S/O.-Sachindra Tanti, R/O- Kadamtala, Dharmanagar, 799261

175. Dipak Barik S/O.-Joynath Baraik, R/O-Satsangam, Ranibari, Dharmanagar, 799261

176. Subhas Chandra Nath S/O.-Lt. Sunil Nath, R/O-Laxmipur, Po-Kherenjuri, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799262

177. Gokul Babu Sinha S/O.-Brajamohan Sinha, R/O- Narendranagar, Damchara, 799256

178. Lakshmi Rani Nath D/O-Lt. Haradhan Debnath, R/O-Uptakhali, Dharmanagar, 799260

179. Sima Nath W/O-Prabir Kanti Nath, R/O-Kadamtala, Dharmanagar, 799261

180. Biplab Majumder S/O.- Lt.Gopal Ch. Majumder, R/O-N.C Nagar, Sonamura, Sipahijala Tripura, 799131

181. Shiuli Begam W/O-Achan Ulla Maishan, R/O-N.C Nagar, Sonamura, Sipahijala Tripura, 799131

182. Dipa Chakraborty (Roychoudhury) W/O- Shibendu Roychoudhury, R/O-Melaghar Thakur Para, Sepahijala Tripura, 799115

183. Anuara Begam W/O- Md. Kabir, R/O-Dhaliai, Sonamura, Sepahijala Tripura, 799131

184. Samir Debnath S/O.-Makhan Debnath, R/O-Mainama, Kulubari Sonamura, Sepahijala Tripura, 799131

185. Benulal Debnath S/O.-Haralal Debnath, R/O-Shibnagar, Takchapara, Melaghar, Sepahijala Tripura, 799115

186. Md. Mustafa S/O.- Abdul Hasem, Dhanpur, Ward No -2, Jatrapur, Sepahijala Tripura, 799132

187. Soma Paul W/O- Usha Ranjan Paul, R/O- South Maheshpur, Kathalia, Sepahijala Tripura, 799132

188. Santosh Pal S/O.-Pramod Pal, R/O-K.K Nagar, Jatrapur, Sepahijala Tripura, 799132

189. Md. SaukatAlam S/O.-Md. Suraj Miah, R/O-Purathal Rajnagar, Madhupur, Sepahijala Tripura, 799100

190. Prasenjit Debnath S/O.-Sampad Debnath, R/O- Induria, Sonamura, Sepahijala Tripura, 799131

191. Taslima Begam W/O-Saheb Uddin, R/O-Sahapur, Rabindranagar, Sonamura Sepahijala Tripura, 799131

192. Kalpana Rani Datta W/O-Biplab Rn. Paul, R/O-Sonamura Hospital Road, Sonamura Sepahijala Tripura, 799131

193. Rajib Kr. Das S/O.-Lt. Niranjan Das, R/O- Dhaliai, Sonamura, Sepahijala Tripura, 799131

194. Dilkish Nahar W/O- Lt. Md. Hossain, Address Routhkhala, Po- Bishalgarh, Ps-Bishalgarh, District – Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102

195. Hasina Begam W/O- Abu Sofian, Address -Village + Po- Dhajanagar, Ps- Bishalgarh, Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102

196. Rina Khatun D/O- Amir Hossen, Address – Village + Po- Bagabasa, Ps- Melaghar, Tripura, Pin-799115 Sepahijala,

197. Jesmin Aktar W/O- Mukles Miah, Address Ghaniamara, Po-Nc Nagar, Ps- Bishalgarh, District - Sepahijala, Tripura-799102

198. Manuara Begam W/O- Sahid Miah, Address - Ghaniamara, Po-N.C. Nagar, Ps-Bishalgarh, District - Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102

199. Monayem Khan S/O.- Lt. Abdul Malek, Address - Ghaniamara, Po-Nc Nagar, Ps-Bishalgarh, District - Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102

200. Alamgir Hossain S/O.- Lt. Mahammed Miah, R/O-Mohanpur, Po-Naba Santi Ganj Bazar, Ps- Takarjala, District - Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin- 799102

201. Manik Miah S/O.- Lt. Abdul Hakim, R/O-Chandranagar, Po- Chandranagar, Ps-Bishalgarh, District - Sepahijala,Tripura, Pin-799102

202. Safik Miah S/O.- Nur Islam, Address Sahapur, Po-Rabindranagar, Ps- Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799131

203. Mafijul Islam S/O.- Kurpan Ali, Address Barnarayan, Po- Bejimara, Ps- Sonamura, District – Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799131

204. Tajul Islam S/O.- Lt. Sirajul Islam, Address – Barnarayan, Po+Ps- Jatrapur, Sonamura, District – Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799131

205. Joynal Abedin S/O.- Ali Aswab, Address – Bashpukur, Po+Ps- Jatrapur, District – Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799132

206. Manir Hossain S/O.- Habil Miah, Address – Sonapur, Po-Rabindranagar, Ps- Sonamura, District – Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799181

207. Rakibul Alam S/O.- Samsul Alam, Address – Ghaniamara, Bishalgarh, Po-Nc Nagar, District – Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102

208. Md Jakir Hossain S/O.- Nabalak Miah, R/O- Durganagar Dis-Sepahijala, Pin-799102

209. Amir Hossain S/O.- Manik Miah, Address – Village + Po- Gazaria, Ps-Bishalgarh, District – Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102

210. Jalil Miah S/O.- Abdul Rabban Miah, Address–Mandab Killa, Po- Lalsingmura, Ps- Bishalgarh, District – Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102

211. Mihir Lal Nath S/O.-Lt. Maniklal Nath, R/O-Bishnupur, Kadamtala, North Tripura, 799261

212. Rina Nath W/O-Rasamoy Nath, R/O-South Amtilla, Kadamtala, North Tripura, 799261

213. Sankar Nath S/O.-Lt. Girish Ch. Nath Pekucheera, Panisagar, North Tripura, 799260

214. Biswajit Sharma Acharjee S/O.-Lt. Dinesh Ch. Sharma Acharjee, R/O-North Ganganagar, Ganganagar, North Tripura, 799253

215. Shyamasree Deb (Dhar) W/O-Amit Dhar, R/O-East Thana Lane, Banamalipur, East Thana, Agartala-799001

216. Asit Dey S/O.-Lt. Abinash, Village + Po-Kanchanbari, Ps-Fatikroy, Unakoti-799288

217. Mintu Malakar S/O.-Lt. Gopesh Malakar, Village + Po-Sonaimuri, Ps-Kumarghat, Unakoti-799264

218. Swapan Kumar Roy S/O.-Lt. Manindra Kumar Roy, Village + Po-Machmara, Unakoti -799263

219. Shipra Sarkar W/O-Sushen Sarkar, Village – Narayanpur, Po-Pecharthal, Unakoti -799263

220. Biswajit Bhattacharjee S/O.- Lt. Basudeb, Village – Shantipur, Po-Pecharthal, Unakoti-799263

221. Nirdhan Nama Sudra S/O.-Lt. Surdhan Nama Sudra, Village + Po-Dudpur Unakoti-799288

222. Shikha Malakar D/O Parendra Malakar, Village + Po-Mashauli Unakoti-799288

223. Laxmi Priya Chakma S/O.-Ajay Chakma, Village + Po-Andhar Cherra, Ps-Pecharthal Unakoti-799263

224. Mangaljyoti Chakma S/O.-Lt Satish Chandra Chakma, Village – Kamalapur, Ps+Po-Pecharthal, Unakoti- 799263

225. Arnika Chakma D/O-Sunitiram Chakma, Village + Po-Dhanicherra Ps-Pecharthal, Unakoti-799263

226. Bijoy Chakma S/O.-Lt. Bandra Chakma, Village Shantinagar Po+Ps-Pecharthal, Unakoti-799263

227. Suman Mahisya Das S/O.-Jogesh Mahisya Das, Village + Po+Ps -Pecharthal Unakoti-799263

228. Kanakprava Chakma D/O-Karna Chakma, Village + Po+Ps –Pecharthal, Unakoti-799263

229. Patichandra Reang S/O.- Surjo Ram Reang, Village - Bagichandra Para Ps+Po-Anandabazar, North Tripura-799270

230. Pnaki Pratim Ghosh S/O.- Lt. Prabir Kanti Ghosh, Village + Po+Ps-Fatikroy, Unakoti-799290

231. Madhumita Roy Nath W/O-Prahlad Deb Nath, Village Kamalapur Po+Ps-Pecharthal, Unakoti-799263

232. Swarup Deb S/O.-Lt. Santosh Chandra Deb, Village + Po+Ps-Pecharthal, Unakoti-799263

233. Binata Sinha D/O-Jagodish Sinha, Village – Assambasti Po-Teghari, Ps-Fatikroy Unakoti- 799290

234. Satyaban Debbarma S/O.- Lt. Man Kumar Debbarma, Village + Po-Lalcherra Ps-Chailengta Ltv, Dhalai Tripura, 799273

235. Khajendra Reang S/O.-Lt Makhanda Reang, Village + Po-Lalcherra Ps-Chailengta Ltv, Dhalai Tripura, 799273

236. Prasenjit Debbarma S/O.-Balendra Debbarma, Village + Po+Ps-Chailengta Ltv, Dhalai Tripura 799273

237. Mathura Debbarma S/O.- Lt Nagendra Debbarma, Village – Dayal Para Po+Ps-Chailengta Ltv, Dhalai Tripura 799273

238. Sadhana Chakraborty (Deb) W/O-Kishor Deb, Village – Sripur Po-Halflong Ps- Dharmanagar, North Tripura- 799254

239. Budhu Pal S/O.-Lt Umesh Pal, Po+Ps-Jatrapur, Sonamura, District – Sepahijala

240. Halima Khatun W/O-Selim Miah, Po+Ps-Jatrapur, Sonamura, District – Sepahijala Pin-799132

241. Sajeda Begam W/O-Manir Hossen, Po+Ps-Jatrapur, Sonamura, District – Sepahijala Pin-799132

242. Manir Hossain S/O.- Kamar Hossain, Vil-Indrinagar, Po+Ps-Melaghar, District – Sepahijala Pin- 799115

243. Bishnu Debnath S/O.-Haralal Debnath, Village – East Nalchar Po+Ps-Melaghar, District – Sepahijala Pin-799115

244. Sanjit Chakraborty S/O.-Prafulla Chakraborty, Village + Po-Laxmipur Ps- Melaghar, District– Sepahijala, Pin-799115

245. Tapan Das S/O.-Haradhan Das, Village + Po-Jumendhepa, Ps- Melaghar Pin-799115

246. Harun Miah S/O.-Nabalak Miah, Village – Sonapur Po-Rabindranagar, District – Sepahijala Pin- 799131

247. Iman Hossain S/O.-Suraj Miah, Village – Aralia Po-Kulu Bari, District – Sepahijala, Pin-799131

248. Khokan Paul S/O.-Anukul Ch. Paul, Village + Po-Bagmara, District – Sepahijala, Pin-799103

249. Atar Islam S/O.-Safik Miah, Village – Kalamkhet, Po-Umai, District – Sepahijala, Pin-799115

250. Bikash Dey S/O.-Lt Prabir Dey, Village + Po-Laxman Nagar, District – Sepahijala, Pin-799115

251. Ratan Deb S/O.-Surja Kanta Deb, Vil-Barnaryan, Po+Ps-Jatrapur, Sonamura, District – Sepahijala, Pin-799131

252. Goutam Das S/O.- Lt. Guranga Ch. Das, R/O- West Pratapgarh, Kabirajtilla, Sadar Agartala Pin-799003

253. Uttam Debnath S/O. -Lt. Monoranjan Debnath, Village – North Brajapur, Po+Ps-Bishalgarh Pin- 799102

254. Prabir Debnath S/O.- Ras Mohan Debnath, R/O-East Dhajanagar, Po- Gakulpur, Ps-RK Pur, Gomati, Tripura, 799114

255. Sushanta Debnath, S/O.- Bhajan Ch. Debnath, Dhajanagar, Po- Gakulpur, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura, 799114.

256. Surajit Dhar S/O.- Lt. Sankar Prasad Dhar, R/O-West Bank of Jagannath Dighi, RK Pur, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799120

257. Dipa Shil D/O- Prantosh Shil, Address -Village + Po- Shalgarh, Udaipur, District – Gomati Tripura, Pin-799114

258. Ashis Sarkar S/O.- Lt. Hiralal Sarkar, Address – Village + Po- Shalgara, Udaipur, District – Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799114

259. Santosh Ch. Sarkar S/O.- Lt. Jatindra Ch. Sarkar, Address – Village + Po- Shalgara, Udaipur, District – Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799114

260. Titu Dey S/O.- Lt. Himangshu Ch. Dey, Village + Po- Murapara, Udaipur, District Gomati, Tripura

261. Kanu Debnath S/O.- Lt. Man Mohan Debnath, Address – Dhajanagar, Ps-R.K Pur, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura, 799114

262. Namita Sarkar D/O- Lt. Kritish Sarkar, Brahmachara, Teliamura, 799205

263. Rina Nath W/O-Lt. Anil Kr. Nath, North Nayapara, Janata Lane, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799250

264. Ajay Kr. Jamatia S/O.- Suresh Kumar Jamatia, Address – Porash Moni Para, Karbook, District – Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799104

265. Kirendra Reang S/O.- Kanuram Reang, Address – Nabajoypara, Po+Ps-Karbook, District – Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799104

266. Jiban Debnath S/O.- Rabindra Debnath, Village + Po- Matabari, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura

267. Rakhi Saha W/O- Ranjit Saha, R/O-RK Pur, Sonamura Chowmuhani, Udaipur, Tripura, Pin-799120 Gomati,

268. Prahar Jamatia S/O.- Bimala Mohan Jamatia, Vill & Po- Shilaghati, Ps- Tripura, Kakraban, Gomati 799105

269. Hadaram Reang S/O.- Rabindra Reang, Address -Naraiha Para, Po+Ps- Karbook, District – Gomati, Tripura

270. Ajin Kr. Jamatia S/O.- Shakti Sadhan Jamatia, Address –Waimuli Bari, South Maharani, Gomati, Tripura, 799103

271. Ram Chandra Jamatia S/O.- Lt. Dhan Hari Jamatia, Address – Dewan Bari, Po- Pitra, District – Gomati Tripura, 799116

272. Sankar Paul S/O.- Krishna Chandra Paul, R/O-Chaigharia, Maharani, Ps-Rk Pur, District – Gomati, Tripura.

273. Litan Dey S/O.-Lt. Panindra Ch. Dey, Town Fulkumari, Udaipur Gomati Tripura Pin-799116

274. Ganesh Shil S/O.- Lt. Binod Shil, Uttar Tulamura, Jitendranagar, Ps-Kakraban, District – Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799105

275. Apu Lodh S/O.- Chitta Ranjan Lodh, Address -Mirza, Udaipur, District – Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799105

276. Biswajit Debnath S/O.- Subash Debnath, Address – Village + Po- Garjanmura, Udaipur, District Gomati, Tripura-799114

277. Ram Krishna Sarkar S/O.- Nibaran Ch. Sarkar, Village + Po- Rani, Udaipur, District –Gomati Tripura, Pin-799105

278. Amal Majumder S/O.- Subash Ch. Majumder, R/O-Uttar Tulamura, Po-Jitendranagar, District Gomati, Tripura,-799105

279. Litan Paul S/O.- Gopal Paul, Tulamura, Po- Jitendranagar, District Gomati, Tripura, Pin- 799105

280. Soukat Ali S/O.- Lt. Rasul Miah, Address – West Bank of Jagannath Dighi,Po-R.K. Pur, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura-799120

281. Nayeb Ali S/O.-Lt. Md. Keramat Ali, Address – Village + Po- Shilghati, Ps-Kakraban, Udaipur, District – Gomati, Tripura-799105

282. Narayani Bhowmik W/O-Sibaprasad Bhowmik, R/O- Udaipur Gomati Tripura, 799114

283. Seuli Choudhary (Rakshit) W/O- Sajal Rakshit, R/O-Rabindra Palli, R.K Pur Gomati Tripura, 799120

284. Rajesh Debbarma S/O.- Nandalal Debbarma, Address-Herma, Po-Rangmala, Ps-Bishramganj, District - Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799103

285. Pranati Debnath Address -North Charilum, Po-Charilum, Ps-Bishalgarh, District-Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799103

286. Bidhan Krishna Das S/O.- Lt. Binod Bihari Das, Address - Village + Po- Purba Laxmibil, Bishalgarh, District - Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102

287. Mani Sankar Debnath S/O.- Lt. Nitai Ch. Debnath, Village + Po- Kamalasagar, Ps-Madhupur, District - Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102

288. Kanak Nath S/O.- Karunamoy Nath, R/O-Saraspur, Kadamtala, 799261

289. Sudip Pal S/O.- Satyaranjan Pal, Tarakpur, North Tripura, 799261

290. Nirmal Kumar Nath S/O.-Lt. Digendra Mohan Nath, R/O-Saraspur, Kadamtala North Tripura, 799261

291. Jaya Datta (Paul) W/O- Nitol Paul, Add- Vivekananda Palli, Po- Amarpur, Ps-Birganj, Dist- Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799101

292. Bapi Gope S/O- Lt. Kalipada Gope, Chargharia, Po- North Maharani, Ps-RK Pur, Dist- Gomati, Tripura.

293. Kajal Ch. Bhowmik S/O-Lt. Tapan Chandra Bhowmik, Add- Chandigarh, Po-Maharani, Udaipur, Dist- Gomati, Tripura-799116

294. Uttam Miah S/O- Habil Miah, Add-Uttar Tulamura, Po-Jitendranagar, Dist-Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799105

295. Sudebi Sarma W/O- Ram Sadhan Bhattacharjee, Tulamura, Po- Jitendranagar, Dist-Gomati, Tripura -799105

296. Hriday Kumari Jamatia D/O- Karna Dayal Jamatia, Add- Nutan Dewan Bari, Po-Pitra, Ps-Killa, Dist- Gomati Tripura-799116

297. Jayanti Kanya Jamatia D/O- Lt. Jayanti Pada Jamatia, Add- Dewan Bari, Po-Pitra, Ps-Killa, Dist- Gomati Tripura-799116

298. Prasanta Das S/O- Lt. Santi Mohan Das, Add- Amtali, Po-Bazar Amtali, Udaipur, Dist-Gomati, Tripura-799105

299. Ramjan Ali S/O- Ali Akbar, Add- Amtali, Po-Amtali, Ps-Kakraban, Dist-Gomati, Tripura- 799105

300. Naresh Datta S/O- Lt. Girendra Datta, South Mirza, Po- Samukcharra, Dist- Gomati, Tripura, Pin- 799105

301. Pintu Debnath S/O- Manik Debnath, East Mirza, Po- East Mirza, Kakraban, Gomati, Tripura, 799105

302. Manik Das S/O- Lt. Dhirendra Ch. Das, Add- Vill+Po-Matabari, Udaipur, Dist-Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799013

303. Suparna Jamatia D/O- Uttam Kumar Jamatia, Add- Ajala Bari, Po- South Maharani, Ps-RK Pur, Gomati Tripura-799013

304. Sukhen Majumder S/O- Lt. Dulal Majumder, Mirza, Upendranagar, Kakraban Gomati Tripura, 799105

305. Siba Prasad Debnath S/O- Biraja Lal Debnath, Vill-Matabari, P/S- Matabari, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura, Pin-799013

306. Pradip Ghosh S/O- Lt. Santosh Ch. Ghosh, Vill- Purba Palatana, P/O- Palatana, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura, Pin-799105

307. Joydeb Das S/O- Lt. Sudhir Ch. Das, Vill- Gangfira, P/O- Jamjuri, Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura, Pin-799105

308. Shyamal Debnath S/O- Lt. Anil Ch. Debnath, Vill- Srinagar, P/O- Srinagar, Sabroom, South Tripura Tripura, Pin-799143

309. Supriya Biswas W/O- Gautam Majumder, Vill- Srinagar, P/O- Srinagar, Sabroom, South Tripura Tripura, Pin-799143

310. Daud Miah S/O- Mofij Miah, Vill- Subash Nagar, P/O- Srinagar, Sabroom, South Tripura, Tripura, Pin-799143

311. Arjun Das S/O- Lt. Badal Das, Vill- Amlighat, P/O- Amlighat, Sabroom, South Tripura Tripura, Pin-799143

312. Jadu Majumder S/O- Lt. Nakul Ch. Majuder, Vill- Dakshin Matabari, P/O- Matabari, Gomati Tripura, Pin-799013 Udaipur,

313. Sadhan Debnath S/O- Ranjit Debnath, Vill- South Murapara, P/O- South Murapara, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura, Pin-799013

314. Abdul Haque S/O- Md. Kurban Ali, Vill- Garjanmura, P/O- Garjanmura, Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura, Pin-799113

315. Bulti Karmakar (Choudhuri) W/O- Goutam Choudhury, Vill- Chanban, P/O- R.K.Pur, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura, Pin-799120

316. Md. Abul Hossen S/O- Ahid Miah, Vill- Rajdharnagar, P/O- Jamjuri Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura, Pin-799116

317. Jaya Choudhury D/O-Santi Ranjan Choudhury, R/O-Abhoynagar, Bilonia South Tripura, 799156

318. Sharmistha Saha W/O- Ripu Saha, R/O-College Square, Po-Sarashima, Belonia, South Tripura, 799155

319. Shipra Datta (Malla) W/O- Sankar Malla, R/O- Debipur, Ps-Belonia, South Tripura, Pin-799155

320. Samir Sarkar S/O- Sadhan Ch. Sarkar, Add- Vill+Po- Krishnanagar, Belonia, Dist-South Tripura- 799156

321. Tapas Baidya S/O- Nepal Baidya, Add- Vill+Po- Debipur, Ps-Belonia, Dist-South Tripura, Pin- 799155

322. Debabrata Das S/O-Lt. Ramani Mohan Das, R/O-West Kalabaria, Maichara Bilonia South Tripura, 799155

323. Supen Debbarma S/O-Manoranjan Debbarma, R/O-Dainmara Para, Dighalia Sidhai, West Tripura, 799211

324. Sujata Debbarma D/O-Manoranjan Debbarma, Dainmara Para, Dighalia Sidhai, West Tripura, 799211

325. Tutan Das S/O-Lt. Ramesh Das, Kukrania, South Nalchar, Melaghar, Sepahijala 799115 Tripura,

326. Chandra Sing Molsom S/O-Lt.Ganga Prasad Molsom, Vill- East Taislong, Taidu Amarpur, Tripura, 799101 Gomati

327. Suman Debbarma S/O-Ratan Debbarma, Kunjabihari Para, Radhakishorepur, West Tripura, 799045

328. Sudhan Debbarma S/O-Lt. Joy Krishna Debbarma, Rabi Charan Para, Dhighalia Lefunga, West Tripura, 799211

329. Biswa Kr. Debbarma S/O- Rabi Debbarma, Maikarpara, Lefunga West Tripura, 799210

330. Uttam Debbarma S/O-Baishak Debbarma, Bairagi Para, Chachu Bazar Sidhi, West Tripura, 799211

331. Narottam Debbarma S/O-Hari Kr. Debbarma, R/O-Doptari Para, Sundar Tilla, Sidhi West Tripura, 799212

332. Tarulata Debbarma D/O-Parimal Debbarma, R/O-Ramdas Thakur Para, Sonaram Bazar, West Tripura, 799212

333. Sachirani Debbarma W/O- Utpal Debbarma, R/O-Maniram Para, Chachu Bazar, West Tripura, 799212

334. Sarajit Debbarma S/O-Lalmohan Debbarma, R/O-Khas Noagaon, Bodhjungnagar, West Tripurra, 799008

335. Saraswati Debbarma D/O-Rabi Charan Debbarma, R/O-Harinmura, Kolai, Kolai, Ambassa, Dhalai Tripura, 799289

336. Arun Murasingh S/O-Pulindra Kr. Murasingh, R/O-Microssapara, Kathalia, Jagatrampur, Sepahijala, Tripura, 799132

337. Pramilla Debbarma D/O-Rabi Debbarma, R/O-Kwchangrai Para, Lefunga West Tripura, 799210

338. Manimoy Debbarma S/O-Rohini Debbarma, R/O-Sepoypara, Lambuchara, West Tripura, 799210

339. Mina Debbarma C/O-Braja Kr. Debbarma, R/O-Ramchandranagar, 799008

340. Bikash Debbarma S/O- Lt. Gouri Kr. Debbarma, R/O-Mahesh Khola, S.K Para (Anandanagar), Amtali, West Tripura, 799004

341. Amali Debbarma D/O- Shukhrai Debbarma, Add- East Ramnagar, Po-Kamalghat, Ps-Lefunga, Pin- 799210

342. Laxmi Nama S/O- Sadhan Nama, R/O-Rajibnagar, Manubazar South Tripura, 799143

343. Bishnu Pada Das S/O-Lt. Santi Ranjan Das, R/O-R.K. Nagar, Natun Palli, Bodhjungnagar, West Tripura, 799008

344. Jayanta Banik S/O-Tapan Kumar Banik, R/O- Purba Gakulnagar, Harishnagar, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala, Tripura, 799102

345. Prabir Sutradhar S/O-Lt. Jogesh Ch. Sutradhar, R/O-Barjala, Agartala, West Tripura, 799002

346. Sanchayita Debbarma D/O-Sumendra Debbarma, R/O-Daldali, Simna, Sidhai, 799212

347. Jantu Das S/O-Lt. Gopal Das, R/O-Jjamirghat, Kamalghat, Lefunga West Tripura, 799210

348. Subrata Das S/O- Lt. Sankar Das, R/O-College Tilla, Professor Para West Tripura, 799004

349. Pradip Das S/O-Sudhir Ch. Das, R/O-Nalgaria, Ranirbazar, West Tripura, 799035

350. Mina Sarkar D/O- Lt.Hiralal Sarkar, R/O-West Dukli, Madhuban, Amtali West Tripura, 799003

351. Debasish Das S/O-Manoranjan Das, R/O-Ranir Gaon Majlishpur, Ranirbazar, West Tripura, 799035

352. Priya Banik D/O- Ratanlal Banik, R/O-Santipara West Tripura-799001

353. Prasanta Sutradhar S/O-Lt. Krishnadhan Sutradhar, R/O-Nalgaria, Ranirbazar, West Tripura, 799035

354. Uttam Sutradhar S/O-Jitendra Sutradhar, R/O-RK Nagar, Bodhjungnagar, Khas Noagaon, West Tripura, 799008

355. Samir Adhikari S/O- Khokan Adhikari, Kawaban, Durganagar, Ranirbazar, West Tripura, 799035

356. Tapash Debnath S/O- Himangshu Debnath, West Noagaon, Ranirbazar, Tripura West Pin-799005

357. Amit Datta S/O-Arun Kr. Datta, Bridyanagar, Kalinagar Road, West Tripura, 799035

358. Abul Kasem S/O-Lt. Alek Hossen, R/O-Telkajala, Melaghar, Sepahijala, Tripura-799115

359. Ajad Hossen S/O- Ali Akbar, R/O- Hirapur, North Maharani, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura-799121

360. Ajay Namasudra S/O-Adhir Namasudra, R/O-Madhya Singichara Khowai-799201

361. Ajit Paul S/O- Amulya Chandra Paul, R/O-Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura-799114

362. Alak Sutradhar S/O- Lt. Haradhan Sutradhar, R/O-West Joynagar, West Tripura-799001

363. Amal Sarkar S/O- Lt Prahlad Sarkar, R/O-Trishabari, Moharcherra, Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura-

364. Amarbir Jamatia S/O- Biswa Narayan Jamatia, R/O-Najila, Dumbur, Komi Pitra, Kila, Udaypur, Gomati-799114

365. Amena Khatun Majumder W/O- Md. Mustak Ahamed, R/O-Routhkhala, Sepahijala-799102

366. Amit Debbarma S/O- Lt. Banshi Debbarma, R/O-Kaman Mura Para, Tripura Engineering College, West Tripura-799055

367. Amit Debbarma S/O- Sukhendu Debbarma, R/O-Takarjala, Sepahijala, Tripura-799102

368. Amrit Debbarma S/O-Pungkhirai Debbarma, R/O-Debendra Chowdhury Para, Balurbandh, Sidhai, West Tripura-799212

369. Anjan Kumar Das S/O-Chandrakanta Das, R/O-B.K Palli Sabroom, Belonia, South Tripura-799143

370. Anjana Das (Saha) W/O-Nabuday Saha, R/O-Manu, LTV Dhalai-799275

371. Anjana Debnath (Sarkar) W/o- Gurudhan Sarkar, R/O-Bashpukur, Jatrapur, Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura- 799132

372. Anuar Hossen S/O-Ali Miah, R/O-Kalikapur, West Tripura-799035

373. Aparna Debbarma D/O-Ranjan Debbarma, R/O-Mandwi Nagar, Agartala, Joy Krishna Kobra Para, Sachindra Nagar, West Tripura-799045

374. Aparna Debnath D/O-Lt Amal Debnath, R/O- Laxmipur, Barpathari, Belonia, South Tripura -799155

375. Aparna Sarkar W/O- Prasanta Roy, R/O- No.1 Town Fulkumari, R.K.Pur, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura-799120

376. Archana Debbarma S/O- Brajendra Debbarma, R/O-Lefunga, West Tripura-799210

377. Arun Telenga S/O-Lt Ramnath Telenga, R/O-West Karangi Cherra, Asharambari, Chama Hour Khowai-799201

378. Ashish Datta S/O-Bimal Datta, R/O-East Charakbai, Santirbazar, South Tripura-799144

379. Asit Suklabaidya S/O-Lt Iresh Suklabaidya, R/O-Sakaibari, Dhamanagar, North-799251

380. Babli Das W/O- Dipak Ch. Das, Dakshin Durgapur, Ratia, Kalyanpur Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura, 799203

381. Baby Chakraborty (Biswas) W/O-Amal Kanti Biswas, R/O-Baganbazar, Kalyanpur, Khowai-799203

382. Bahadur Gour (PH) S/O-Lt Phandi Gour, R/O- Bamancherra, Kamalpur, Dhalai-799286

383. Bapan Debbarma S/O-Krishna Kr. Debbarma, R/O-Chandramani Para, R/O- Balurband, Mohanpur, West Tripura-799212 Sidhai,

384. Basanti Debbarma S/O-Pradhan Debbarma, R/O-Dongarbari, Khowai-799207

385. Benulal Tripura S/O- Bhagahari Tripura, R/O-Rangamura, Jatrapur, Sepahijala, Tripura-799132

386. Bhaskar Nagbanshi S/O-Fagu Nagbanshi, R/O-Chamubasti, Banbazar, Chama Hour, Khowai-799201

387. Bhupesh Ranjan Mallik S/O-Mihir Rn Mallik, R/O-Gamai Bari, Teliamura, Khowai-799205

388. Bidhan Debnath S/O-Narayan Debnath, R/O-Chalita Chari, Harina Bazar, Manu Bazar, South Tripura-799145

389. Bijan Debbarma, S/O-Upendra Deb Brama, R/O- Sarat Chowdhury para, Darogamura, Sidhai, West- Tripura-799212

390. Bijay Chowdhury S/O-Lt Gouri Bhasan Chowdhuri, R/O- Karailong, Teliamura, Khowai-799205

391. Bijoy Debbarma S/O-Rabicharan Debbarma, R/O-Bhati Fatickchara, Kamalghat, Lefunga, West Tripura-799210.

392. Bikash Chandra Das S/O-Subhash Chandra Das, R/O-Shalgarah Beri, Udaipur, Gomati-799105

393. Bikash Debbarma S/O-Padma Kumar Debbarma, R/O-Dugrai Para, Barkathal, Sidhai, West Tripura-

394. Bikram Debbarma S/O-lt-Chandrakant Debbarma, R/O-Kherowa para, Kamal ghat, Lefunga, West- Tripura, Pin 799210

395. Bina Sahа W/O- Lt. Uttam Saha, R/O- Nataji Chowmuni, R.K.Pur, Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura, PIN-799120

396. Biplab Das S/O- Nikunja Kumar Das, Bhuiyar Tilla, Melaghar, Sepahijala, Tripura-799115

397. Biplab Debbarma S/O-Sukramani Debbarma, Rangmala, Bishramganj, Sepahijala-799103

398. Biplab Kanti Paul S/O-Paresh Chandra Paul, R/O-South Chandrapur, R.K. Pur, Gomati Tripura- 799013

399. Biplab Karmakar S/O-Priyatosh Karmakar, R/O-Poultry Road, Udaypur-799120

400. Bishnupada Karmakar S/O – Lt. Nepal Ch. Karmakar, R/O-Jamirghat, Kamalghat, Lefunga, Tripura (West) – 799210

401. Biswajit Banik S/O-Lt Subhash Banik, R/O-Manughat LTV, Dhalai-799275

402. Biswajit Debbarma S/O-Subendra Debbarma, R/O-champlai, Chakmaghat, Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura-799205

403. Bivash Datta S/O-Krishna Mani Datta, Vill+PO-FatickChara, PS- Lefunga Dist-Tripura (W), Pin- 799210

404. Brajagopal Chakraborty S/O-Nagendra Chakraborty, R/O-Ambassa, Dhalai-799289

405. Brajendra Debbarma S/O-Lt.Surjya Kumar Debbarma, R/O-Bania para, Madhu Chowdhury Para, Lefunga, Tripura(W), Pin-799211

406. Chaitan Biswas W/O-Nakul Biswas, Ambassa, Dhalai, Tripura-799289

407. Chandra Debbarma S/O-Rabia Debbarma, Vill-Mokam Para PO-Dighalia, PS-Sidhai Pin-799211

408. Chhanda Rani Bhattacharjee D/O-Partha Sarathi Bhattacharjee, R/O-Manughat, LTV, Dhalai-799275

409. Chitta Debbarma S/O-Ramesh Debbarma, R/O-Dain Mara Para, Lufunga,West Tripura-799211

410. Chittaranjan Sarkar S/O-Santich Sarkar, R/O-Maiganga, Teliamura, Khowai, 799205

411. Debabrata Das S/O-Amrita Lal Das, R/O-Kamalpur, Anandapur-799155

412. Debajit Saha S/O-Lt Jiban Krishna Saha, South Charilam, Bishramganj, Sepahijala, Tripura- 799103

413. Debendra Debbarma S/O- Braja Kumar Debbarma, Harirai Chowdhury Para, Mandwi, West Tripura- 799045

414. Dinamala Debbarma S/O-Chitta Ranjan Debbarma, Vill-Tairaj Bari PO-Barkathal, PS-Sidhai Pin-799211

415. Dinesh Chandra Das S/O-Lt. Surendra Ch. Das, R/O-Chulu Bari Bamancherra, Kamalpur, Dhalai- 799286

416. Dinesh Nag S/O-Lt Digendra Nag, R/O-Aparaskar, Kamalpur, Dhalai-799286

417. Dipakranjan Das S/O-Lt. Sukumar Das, R/O-Chebri Khowai Tripura 799207

418. Dipankar Debnath S/O-Rakhal Debnath, Vill+PO- Uttar Jogendranagar, West Tripura-799004

419. Diptanu Paul S/O-Hariprasanna Paul, R/O-Town Boduali, West Tripura- 799001

420. Dipu Debbarma S/O-Surendra Debbarma, R/O-Simna Colony, P/S-Sidhai, Dist-West Tripura

421. Dulal Das S/O-Lt. Debendra Das, Vill-Jamirghat, PO-Kamalghat, PS- Lefunga, Tripura(W), Pin-799210 Dist-

422. Dulal Debnath S/O-Lt Harendra Ch. Debnath, R/O-Assarampara, Ranirbazar, West Tripura-799035

423. Ganesh Debnath S/O-Lt. Rajendra Debnath, Ashak Palli, Ambassa, Dhalai, Tripura-799289

424. Gouri Banik W/O-Bivash Banik, R/O-Rajibnagar, Guachand, Sabroom, South Tripura, 799143 Pin-

425. Goutam Barman S/O-Nikunja Barman, R/O-Pong Bari, Melaghar, Sepahijala-799115

426. Goutam Mallik S/O- Lt. Abani Mallik, R/O- Dudhpuskarini, Palatana, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura- 799105

427. Goutam Roy S/O-Narayan Roy, R/O-Bijay Nagar, Sabroom, South Tripura-799145

428. Harilal Debnath S/O-Lt Suresh Debnath, R/O- West Golaghati, Kalyanpur, Khowai-799203.

429. Himangshu Sutradhar S/O-Lt Haripada Sutradhar, R/O-West Halhali, Kamalpur, Dhalai-799286

430. Himani Tripura W/O-Matha Mohan Tripura, R/O-Jamircherra, Manu, LTV, Dhalai-799275

431. Ilo Debbarma D/O-Budhiram Debbarma, R/O Bara kutna, Chachu Bazar, Sidhai, Tripura (W) Pin- 799211

432. Indrajit Roy S/O-Dipendra Ch Roy, R/O- Rajnagar, Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura-799205

433. Jadab Shil S/O-Lt. Manmohan Shil, R/O-Rangamati, Birganj, Gomati, Tripura-799101

434. Jahanara Begam W/O- Safigul Islam, R/O-Kolubari, Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura-799131

435. Jakir Mia S/O- Badsha Mia, R/O-No-2 Fulkumari, Banduar, Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura, PIN-799013

436. Jamal Hossain S/O-Suraj Mian, Nadilog, Bishalgarh-799102

437. James Debbarma S/O-Gopal Debbarma, Bishrambari, West Tripura-799035

438. Jamuna Singha S/O-Mrinal Singha, R/O-South Dhaleswar, Agartala, West Tripura-799004

439. Jantu Das S/O- Lt. Manoharan Das, R/O-Thakurmura, Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura-799131

440. Jaya Sarkar D/O-Lt Raj Kishore Sarkar, R/O-Maynarma, Chailengta LTV, Dhalai-799275

441. Jiban Datta S/O-Nishikanta Datta, R/O-Ambassa Colony, Ambassa, Dhalai, Tripura-799289.

442. Joy Kumar Sarkar S/O-Nagendra Sarkar, R/O-R.K.Nagar, Agartala-799008

443. Jyotirmoy Choudhury S/O-Lt Jugendra Choudhury, R/O-Bamancherra, Kamalpur, Dhalai-799286

444. Kabita Debnath W/O-Sanjit Debnath, R/O- Matabari, Udaipur, Gomati-799013

445. Kaishya Ram Reang S/O-Annijoy Reang, South Dhanicherra, Machmarra, Pecharthal, Unakoti Tripura- 799263

446. Kalyan Datta S/O-Lt. Thambaljoy Datta, R/O-Sona Tala, Bamutia, West Tripura-799211

447. Kamal Barman S/O-Nagendra Chandra Barman, Yubarajghat, Melaghar, Sepahijala, Tripura- 799115

448. Kamal Das S/O- Lt. Priya Lal Das, Joy Krishna Kobra Para, Sachindra Nagar, West Tripura- 799045

449. Kamal Krishna Telenga S/O-Lt Bimal Telenga, R/O-Asharambari, Chama Hour, Khowai-799201

450. Kamaljit Debbarma S/O-Sonacharan Debbarma, R/O-Gayang fung, Khowai Tripura 799203

451. Kamini Κalai S/O-Lt. Sampad Kalai, R/O-South Dumacherra, LTV, Dhalai-799275

452. Kartik Laxmi Debbarma S/O-Lt Subendra Debbrma, R/O- South Gakulnagar, Teliamura, Khowai-799205

453. Kinkar Chakma S/O-Sneha Kumar Chakma, R/O-Kinacharanpara, Machmarra, Unakoti Tripura- 799263

454. Kishor Debbarma S/O-Sambhu Debbarma, R/O-Chittaram Kobra Para, Jirania, West Tripura-799045

455. Kishore Debbarma S/O- Lt. Bidhi Debbarma, R/O-Satpara, Shibnagar, Joy Krishna Kobra Para, Sachindra Nagar, West Tripura-799035

456. Kuleswar Singha S/O-Jbunghal Singha, R/O- Gornagar, Samatal Padmabil, Khowi-799201

457. Laili Begam W/O- Lt. Jakir Hossain, Kolubari, Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura-799131

458. Laxman Nama S/O – Haribilash Nama, Vill – Rajibnagar P.O-Guachand Sabroom, South Tripura. – 799143

459. Laxmi Das Baishnab D/O-Lt Gouranga Das Mahanta, R/O- Kumaria Kucha, Melaghar, Sepahijala- 799115

460. Leena Debbarma W/O- Rajendra Debbarma, R/O- Sepoy para, Lembhuchara, Lefunga, West Tripura- 799210

461. Madan Gopal Rupini S/O-Lt Purna Sing Rupini, R/O-Kali Kumar Para, Hadrai Tripura-799205

462. Madhuri Tripura D/O- Lt. Ramani Kumar Tripura, R/O-Thaibong, Sabroom, Jatila Bazar, South Tripura-799145

463. Mandira Das D/O-Lt Hiran Ch Das, R/O-Nabagram, Fulchari, Sabroom, Tripura-799143

464. Mangal Debbarma S/O-Bishram Debbarma, R/O-Haria Kobra Para, Takarjala, Sepahijala-799102

465. Mangal Debbarma S/O-Biswarai Debbarma, Vill-Utla Para, PO-Madhu Chowdhury, PS-Lefunga, Dist-Tripura (W), Pin-799211

466. Manindra Das S/O-Lt Shyamacharan Das, R/O-Matabari, Udaipur, Gomati-799013

467. Manju Laxmi Debbarma S/O –Brajendra Debbarma, R/O-Dugraipara, P/O-Barkathal, Sidhai, West-Tripura- 799211

468. Manjuri Debbarma D/O-Brajalal Debbarma, Chelekhata, Gazaria, Bishalgarh, Sephahijala, Tripura- 799102

469. Manobrata Chowdhury S/O- Lt Jitendra Kr Chowdhury, R/O-Goachand, Harina Bazar Sabrum, South Tripura -799143

470. Matilal Das S/O-Lt. Haralal Das, R/O-South Mura Para, Gomati-799013

471. Md. Abdul Sobhan S/O-Lt Sajid Ali, Vill- Jarjharia PO-Chouraibari, Dharmanagar, North Tripura- 799261

472. Md. Alam S/O-Lt Alkas Mia, R/O-N.C Nagar, Sonamura, Sepahijala-799131

473. Md. Jalil Uddin S/O-Md. Maabashar Ali, Vill- West Chandrapur, PO- Chandrapur, Dharmanagar, North Tripura-799251

474. Md. Khurshed Alam S/O-Lt. Bajlu Miah, R/O-Arabinda Nagar, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala-799102

475. Mithu Das S/O- Lt Rabindra Das, R/O-Lambuchara, Khasiamangal Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, 799205

476. Mithu Das W/O-Sukhendu Ch Paul, R/O-Madhya Satinagar, Dhanpur, Sepahijala-799131

477. Mithun Debnath S/O-Dinesh Ch. Debnath, R/O-East Pratapgarh, Agartala, West Tripura-799004

478. Miton Κapali S/O-Rajeswar Kapali, Vill-Jamirghat Kapali Para, PO-Kamalghat, PS-Lefunga, Dist-Tripura (W) Pin-799210

479. Monalisha Debbarma D/O-Lt.Kusum Debbarma, Vill-Dhupchara, Khowai Tripura-799207

480. Mridul Datta S/O-Lt Basanta Datta, R/O- Bhugor, Bamutia, West Tripura-799211

481. Nabagita Debbarma W/O-Hrikesh Debbarma, R/O-Gagan Chow Para, Chankhala Bazar, Khowai- 799207

482. Namita Reang W/O- Daniel Reang, Vill-Purnajoy Para, PO-Krishnatilla, Unakoti, Tripura-799263

483. Nandalal Debbarma S/O-Anil Debbarma, R/O-Barpachia Para, Sidai, West Tripura-799211

484. Narayan Debnath S/O- Ananta Mohan Debnath, R/O-Charupassa, Krishnapur, Dharmanagar, North Tripura-799253

485. Naresh Tripura S/O-Aswani Kumar Tripura, North Taibandal, Melaghar, Sepahijala, Tripura- 799115

486. Neihrazirhava Kaipeng S/O-Neihronlian Kaiping, R/O-Santang No-2, Taidu, Amarpur, Tripura

487. Nibu Debbarma S/O- Lt Bijoy Debbarma, R/O-Hazamara, Baikunthapur, Sibhai, West, Tripura - 799211

488. Nilmani Debbarma S/O-Sahadeb Deb Barma, R/O-Kata Charra para, Simna, Sidhai mohanpur, West- Tripura, Pin-799212

489. Nirmal Nama S/O-Suresh Nama, R/O-South Charilam, Bishramganj, Sipahijala Tripura-799103

490. Nirmal Sarkar S/O- Srinibash Sarkar, R/O-Machmarra, Pecharthal, Unakoti Tripura-799263

491. Nityananda Debnath S/O-Binod Ch Debnath, R/O-Bhabanipur, Jatanpur, Sepahijala-799132

492. Palash Debbarma S/O-Nagendra Debbarma, R/O-Mangal Sadhu Para, Mandwi, West Tripura-799045

493. Parendra Debbarma S/O-Budhyarai Debbarma, R/O-Shibjoy Para, Sidai West Tripura-799211

494. Parimal Datta S/O-Lt.Brajachand Datta, Vill+PO-Fatikchhara, Dist-Tripura(w) Pin-799210

495. Parimal Debbarma S/O- Ram Kumar Deb Barma, R/O-Daruga mura, Sidhai, West-Tripura, Pin- 799212.

496. Paritosh Deb S/O- Lt. Prantosh Deb, R/O- Lembucharra, Lefunga, West- Tripura

497. Phani Debbarma S/O-Rajendra Debbarma, R/O-Chittaram para, Sidai, West Tripura-799211

498. Phani Debbarma S/O-Rabi Charan Debbarma, R/O-Birmohan Chou Para, Sidai, West Tripura- 799211

499. Piklu Dey S/O- Sadhan Dey, R/O-Ramendra Nagar, Sabrum, South Tripura-799143

500. Pinky Suklabaidya W/O-Manindra Suklabaidya, Manughat, Dhalai, Tripura-799275

501. Pradip Chanda S/O-Prajesh Chanda, Vill& PO- Pratyekroy, Dharmanagar, North Tripura-799251

502. Pradip Debbarma S/O-Lt Daruka Debbarma, R/O-Krishnamohan Kobra Para, Lefunga, West-Tripura- 799210

503. Pradip Debbarma S/O-Bhubanjoy Debbarma, Vill-Dainmara Para, PO-Dighalia, PS-Sidhai, Pin- 799211

504. Prativa Rani Debnath W/O-Haralal Debnath, Vill & PO- Algapur, Dharmanagar, North Tripura-799250

505. Purnima Dey Sen W/O-Amal Kanti Sen, Hospital Road, Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura-799131

506. Rabimala Debbarma W/O- Sanjoy Debbarma, R/O-Asrai para, Chachu Bazar, Sidhai Mohanpur, West- Tripura, Pin-799211

507. Rabindra Debbarma S/O –Umesh Debbarma, R/O- Joy Ram modi para Lembucharra, Lefunga, West- Tripura-799210

508. Rajendra Kumar Tripura S/O-Bishi Kr. Tripura, R/O-East Takka Tulshi, Manu Bazar, South Tripura-799143

509. Rajesh Sinha S/O-Babulal Sinha, R/O-Dhaleswar, Kalyani, West Tripura-799211

510. Rakesh Debbarma S/O-Durjoy Debbarma, RO-Ujan Hezamara, Baikunthapur, Sidhai Mohanpur, West Tripura Pin-799211

511. Rakhi Debbarma D/O- Lt. Ramesh Debbarma, R/O-Rajghat para, Kamalghat, Sidai, West Tripura- 799210

512. Rakhi Dey (Deb) W/O-Prabin Kr. Deb, R/O-Chari Para, Agartala, West Tripura-799003

513. Rakhi Mallik D/O-Gourmohan Mallik, Vill-Barbari, Panisagar, Dharmanagar, North Tripura- 799260

514. Rakhi Sarkar (Mallik) W/O- Rajkumar Mallik, R/O-Town Pratapgarh, West Tripura-799045

515. Ram Sabdakar S/O-Lt Jagadish Sabdakar, R/O-Chulubari, Kamalpur, Dhalai-799286

516. Ramabali Reang D/O-Jaminrai Reang, R/O-Kathalcherra, Nepaltila, Dhalai-799275

517. Ramani Paul S/O-Rupesh Paul, R/O-Ambassa, Dhalai, Tripura-799289

518. Ramkrishna Sarkar S/O-Nirmal Ch. Sarkar Harish Ch. Kalai Para, Khasiamangal Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura, 799205

519. Ranjan Biswas S/O-Lt. Satish Biswas, North Krishnapur, M.T Para Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, 799184

520. Ranjit Tripura S/O-Joyram Tripura, R/O-Kaladhepa, Manu Bazar, South Tripura-799143

521. Ranjit Datta S/O-Sadhan Ch Datta, R/O-Rupaichari, Sabrum, South Tripura-799145

522. Ranjit Sarkar S/O-Lt. Jogendra Ch. Sarkar, R/O-Golaghati, Takarjala, Tripura-799102

523. Ranjit Sarkar S/O-Manuranjan Sarkar, R/O-Singichara, Khowai-799201

524. Ratan Chandra Das S/O-Lt. Satish Ch. Das, R/O-Kaiya Depa, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala-799102

525. Ratan Datta S/O-Sunil Datta, R/O-Khash Noagoan, Bhati Jaynagar, West Tripura-799007

526. Ratan Sarkar S/O-Haradhan Sarkar, R/O-Echarbil, Karailong, Teliamura, Khowai-799205

527. Rathindra Debbarma S/O-Rabindra Debbarma, R/O-Chandranath Thakur Para, Chebri, Khowai-799207

528. Ratna Deb D/O- Rabindra Ch. Deb, R/O- Tebaria, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala-799102

529. Ratna Roy (Deb) W/O-Mrinal Kanti Deb, R/O-Kamalacherra, Ambassa, Dhalai Tripura-799289

530. Rekha Paul W/O-Lt Subal Paul, R/O-Naithong Cherra, Karamcherra, Manu, Dhalai Tripura- 799266

531. Rina Biswas S/O-Surya Kanta Biswas, R/O-Ranjit Nagar, Ramnagar, West Tripura-799002

532. Rinku Sarkar S/O-Rabindra Lal Sarkar, R/O- Maynarma, Chailengta, LTV, Dhalai-799275

533. Rita Deb (Roy) W/O-Sankar Roy, R/O-Kali Tilla, Teliamura, Khowai-799205

534. Rita Debbarma S/O-Alendra Debbarma, R/O-Balurban Sidai Mohanpur, West-Tripura

535. Rupen Baishya S/O-Sunirmal Baishya, R/O-Rajnagar, Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura-799205

536. Sabakar Sabar S/O-Lt Jagobandhu Sabar, R/O-Champu Basti, Chama Hour, Khowai-799201

537. Sabitri Chetri S/O-Raju Das, R/O-Nepali Basti, Nandannagar, West-Tripura- 7992006

538. Saikat Bhowmik S/O-Makhan Bhowmik, R/O- Sonaichari, Sabrum, South Tripura-799145

539. Sajal Saha S/O-Lt Pran Ballav Saha, R/O-South Dhaleswar, Kalyani, West Tripura-799004

540. Samir Debnath S/O- Jogesh Chandra Debnath, R/O- Unakoti, Tripura-799264

541. Samir Kumar Datta S/O-Lt Shishir Ranjan Datta, R/O-Gourangatila, Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura- 799205

542. Samir Nama S/O-Rabi Nam, R/O-Sukanta Palli, Manu Bazar, South Tripura-799143

543. Samit Dey Chowdhury S/O-Samarendra Chowdhury Chebri, Khowai Tripura, 799207

544. Sananda Pandey D/O- Dayal Pandey, R/O-West Halahali, Kamalpur Dhalai-799286

545. Sanjib Reang S/O-Jitendra Reang, R/O-Gunadhar Para, Kanchanpur North Tripura-799270

546. Sanjit Debbarma S/O-Bishu Debbarma, R/O-Kaman mura Para, Jirania, West Tripura-799045

547. Sanjit Debbarma S/O-Rabi Charan Debbarma, R/O-Bhagaban Thakur Para, Bodhjungnagar, Lefunga

548. Sanjit Debbarma S/O-Karnel Debbarma, R/O-Brindaban master para, Khowai Tripura-799203

549. Sanjita Debnath W/O- Ajit Debnath, R/O-Jubarajnagar, Dharmanagar, North Tripura-799254

550. Sanjoy Das S/O- Sudhir Ch Das, R/O-Rupaichari, Sabrum South Tripura-799145

551. Sanjoy Debbarma S/O- Chitra Mohan Debbarma, R/O-Joy Krishna Kobra Para, Sachindra Nagar West Tripura-799045

552. Sanjoy Debnath S/O-Manindra Debnath, R/O- Santinagar, Teliamura Khowai, Tripura-799205

553. Sanjoy Sharma S/O-Lt Prafulla Sharma, R/O-Dhaleswar Extension, Azad Hind Road, Agartala West Tripura-799007

554. Sankar Sen S/O-Lt. Ananta Kr. Sen, R/O-Guachand, Manubazar, Sabroom, South Tripura- 799143

555. Santa Chakraborty Choudhury W/O- Haradhan Choudhury, R/O-Tamsabari, Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura- 799131

556. Santana Chakma D/O-Lt. Biresh Mani Chakma, R/O-Manughat, Dhalai-799275

557. Sarmin Begam D/O-Lt. Kanu Mian, R/O-Durganagar, K.K. Nagar, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala-799102

558. Sharmistha Dey W/O- Amar Das, R/O- Mekhlipara, Ranirbazar, West Tripura-799035

559. Sarthaki Choudhuri W/O- Lt Biswajit Chakraborty, R/O-UjanAbhoynagar, West Tripura-799005

560. Satyajit Debbarma S/O-Lt Tarun Kumar Debbarma, R/O-Kaimaicherra, Kamalpur Dhalai-799287

561. Satyajit Debbarma S/O-Mohan Chandra Debbarma, R/O-Nalkata (Gowala Basti), Manu, LTV Dhalai Tripura

562. Satyajit Paul S/O-Subhash Ch. Paul, R/O- Town Pratapgarh, West Tripura-799001

563. Shakti Telenga S/O-Lt ChinibabuTelenga, R/O- Asharambari, Chama Hour Khowai-799201

564. Shila Rani Das D/O-Lt Abani Mohan Das, R/O-Kali Tila, Teliamura Khowai-799205

565. Shipra Rani Saha W/O- Natun Banik, R/O-Sonamura Math Para Sepahijala, Tripura-799131

566. Shyamal Ghosh S/O- Lt. Santi Mohan Ghosh, R/O- Jirania, West Tripura-799045

567. Sima Rani Sinha D/O-Lt Samarendra Sinha, R/O-Moth Chowmahani, West Tripura-799004

568. Sital Bhattacharya S/O-Lt. Manoranjan Bhattacharya, R/O-Golaghati, Takarjala, Sepahijala Tripura- 799102

569. Soma Chakraborti W/O-Sumen Bhattacharjee, R/O-Kalyani, Dhaleswar Agartala-799004

570. Soma Mog W/O-Abhijit Samanta, R/O-Mog Bari, Chakmaghat, Teliamura, Khowai-799205

571. Subal Chandra Namasudra S/O-Lt Sudhir Ch. Namasudra, R/O-Banbazar, Chama Hour Khowai-799201

572. Subash Debnath S/O-Lt Sudhir Debnath, R/O- Ambassa (K.Colony) Dhalai Tripura-799289

573. Subrata Chakraborty S/O-Swapan Chakraborty, R/O-Manughat, LTV Dhalai-799275

574. Subrata Shil S/O- Gopal Shil, R/O- Matabari, Udaipur Gomati Tripura-799013

575. Sudhan Biswas S/O-Lt. Rajani Biswas, BaluCharra, M.TPara Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, 799184

576. Sujata Sarkar W/O- Ranjit Sarkar, R/O-Machmarra, Pecharthal, Unakoti Tripura-799263

577. Sujit Debbarma S/O-Lt. Sambhu Debbarma, R/O-Rajghat para, Kamalghat, Lefunga, West Tripura- 799210

578. Sujit Mani Das S/O- Haripada Mani Das, R/O-Borobil, Singicherra, Khowai -799201

579. Sujit Paul S/O-Rabindra Ch. Paul,R/O-Brajanagar, Ranirbazar Tripura-799035

580. Sukanta Chakma S/O-Bijoysing Chakma, R/O-Nabincherra, Pecharthal Unakoti Tripura-799263

581. Sukla Das D/O-Lt Amulya Das, R/O-Agartala, College Tila West-Tripura-7992004

582. Sukumar Debnath S/O-Jitendra Debnath SamruCharra, Chebri Khowai Tripura, 799207

583. Suman Barman S/O- Babul Barman, R/O-Rajghat, Melaghar Sonamura-799115

584. Suman Chandra Das S/O-Dilip Kr Das, R/O-Taibong, Sabroom South Tripura-799145

585. Suman Das S/O- Lt. Amar Krishna Das, R/O- Bhattapukur Durga pally, AD. Nagar, West Tripura- 799003

586. Suman Nath Bhowmik S/O-Khagendra Nath Bhowmik, Gouranga Tilla, Teliamura Khowai Tripura, 799205

587. Sumanta Chakma S/O- Nilmani Chakma, R/O-Subalpara, Karaicherra Tripura-799263

588. Sumen Debbarma S/O-Purnachandra Debbarma, R/O-Lefunga Para, Mohanpur West Tripura, Pin- 799210

589. Supriya Marak D/O-Narendra Debbarma, R/O-Kamalghat, Lefunga West Tripura-799210

590. Suraj Debbarma S/O-Prabhat Deb Barma, R/O- South Herma, Rang mala, Bishramganj, Sepahijala- 799102

591. Swapan Das S/O- Harekrishna Das, R/O-Purba Chandighar, Melaghar, Sonamura-799115

592. Swapan Deb S/O-Lt Nilmani Deb, R/O-Durgapur, Kalyanpur Khowai-799203

593. Swapan Debbarma S/O-Lt. Sukramani Debbarma, R/O-Lefunga West Tripura -799210

594. Swapan Debbarma S/O-Chaitra Debbarma, R/O-Rabi Charan Para, Dighalia, Lefunga, West Tripura- 799211

595. Swapan Debbarma S/O- Madhusudhan Debbarma, R/O-Chelekhata, Gazaria, Bishalgarh Sephahijala, Tripura-799102

596. Swapan Kumar Sen S/O- Lt. Kanta Mani Sen, R/O-Gornagar, Samatal Padmabil, Khowi-799201

597. Swapan Sen S/O-Ranjit Sen, R/O-Chandighar, Melaghar, Sonamura, Tripura-799115

598. Swapna Debi Debbarma Noatia W/O- Biswa Lila Noatia, R/O-Chundul ADC, Melaghar, Sepahijala, Tripura- 799115

599. Tapan Debbarma S/O-Birmani Debbarma, R/O-Bar Kathal, Sidai, West Tripura-799211

600. Tapan Debbarma S/O-Manindra Debbarma, R/O-Bakiram Para, Uttar Dash Goria, Sidhai, Tripura - 799212

601. Tapas Chandra Das S/O- Shiba Pada Das, R/O-Aralia, Sepahijala, Tripura-799131

602. Tarit Debbarma S/O-Lt. Nitai Debbarma, R/O-Biswader Sadhupara, Sidai-799211

603. Tinku Bhowmik S/O-Lt Jaggeswar Bhowmik, R/O-Radhanagar, Purba Noyagoan, Ranirbazar, Agartala-799035

604. Tinku Majumder S/O-Bishnu Majumder, R/O-Jowali Khamar, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura-799013

605. Titan Goswami S/O- Sunil Chandra Goswami, R/O-Basanta Nagar, Kakraban, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura-799105

606. Usha Rani Debbarma D/O- Budhi Chnadra Debbarma, R/O-Kutni Bari, Chachu Bazar, Sidai Mohanpur, West Tripura-799211

607. Usha Rani Debbarma D/O-Ranjit Debbarma, R/O-Maikhar Para, Lefunga, West Tripura-799210

608. Usha Ranjan Debbarma S/O-Lt- Kashiram Deb Barma, R/O-Daodharani para, Darogamura, Sidhai, West- Tripura-799212

609. Swarna Debbarma S/O-Suraj Debbarma, Kairai Para, Mandai, West Tripura, Pin-799045

610. Washim Akram S/O- Alamgir Hossain, R/O-Durgapur, Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura-79911

611. Sandhya Kumar Jamatia S/O- Kanta Hari Jamatia, R/O-Maharani Colony, P.O- North Maharani, Gomati Tripura, 799013

612. Puranjoy Reang S/O- Partha RaM Reang, R/O-Shila Roy Para, P.O- Korbook, Gomati Tripura, 799013

613. Sipra Das D/O- Late Sushen Chandra Das, R/O-Champlai, P.O- M. T. Para, Khowai Tripura, 799703

614. Supriti Ghosh (Baidya) W/O- Bipul Baidya, R/O-Matai, P.Ο- Matai, South Tripura

615. Bipalab Kumar Murasing S/O-Laxman Kumar Murasing, R/O- North Tailbandai, P.O-Melaghar Sepahijala Tripura, 799105

616. Michil Miah S/O- Harich Miah, R/O-Sonampur, Rabindranagar, P.O- Rabindranagar, Sepahijala Tripura, 799131

617. Nandita Debbarma W/O- Chandra Debbarma, R/O- Debapur, Kalacharra, P.O- Kalacharra, West Tripura, 799211

618. Ajit Debbarma S/O- Sukrani Debbarma, R/O- Bhati Fatik Charra, P.O- Kamalghat, West Tripura, 799210

619. Sabita Debbarma W/O-Shyam Charan Debbarma, R/O- Haricharan Para, P.O- Ishanpur, West Tripura, 799212

620. Ajit Debbarma S/O- Mankurui Debbarma, R/O- Daldali Simna, P.O- Simna West Tripura, 799212

621. Jyotsna Debbarma W/O-Prafulla Debbarma, R/O-Murabari, West Tripura, 799211

622. Aparna Debbarma W/O-Swapan Debbarma, R/O- Chandrapur Colony, Kalacharra, West Tripura, 799211

623. Ajit Debbarma S/O-Jadu Lal Debbarma, R/O- Sambhu Chandra Para, West Tripura, 799210

624. Bikash Debbarma S/O- Pulin Debbarma, R/O- Joyram Modi Para, West Tripura, 799210

625. Sachindra Debbarma S/O-Shib Charan Debbarma, R/O- Basu Ram Para, West Tripura, 799211

626. Arun Debbarma S/O-Mangal Debbarma, R/O- Bania Para, West Tripura, 799211

627. Ashit Debbarma S/O- Subendra Debbarma, R/O- Subal Garh Para, West Tripura, 799211

628. Pariel Debbarma S/O-Kamal Krishna Debbarma, R/O- Debra Para, West Tripura, 799211

629. Sajal Debbarma S/O- Hari Ranjan Debbarma, R/O- Debtabari, West Tripura, 799210

630. Kartik Chandra Gope S/O- Nikhil Chandra Gope, R/O- East Nalchar, Sepahijala Tripura, 799115

631. Jayanti Das Sarkar W/O-Dulal Kanti Das, R/O-Madhuban Sonamura, Sepahijala Tripura, 799131

632. Saha Jalal S/O-Ayub Ali, R/O- Srimanta Pur, Rabindra Nagar, Sepahijala Tripura, 799131

633. Santi Mohan Molsom S/O-Gonahari Molsom, R/O- Temtai Bari, Gomati Tripura, 799114

634. Madhab Karmakar S/O- Late Mintu Karmakar, R/O- Rangamura, South Tripura, 799153

635. Sentu Datta S/O-Haradhan Datta, R/O- West Khupilong, Gomati Tripura, 799114

636. Amar Bir Jamatia S/O- Biswa Narayn Jamatia, R/O- Najila Dumbur, Gomati Tripura, 799114

637. Kallol Chakma S/O-Kiran Ch. Chakma Vill-Boxmani K/P PO+PS- Manik Pur Pin- 799273

638. Pankaj Barua S/O-Subhasish Baruas, VILL+PO+PS:- Chawmanu PIN-799273

639. Ram Debbarma S/O- Suku Debbarma Vill+PO-Dem Cherra PS Nepaltila Pin- 799275

640. Saawan Kr. Marak S/O- Khanna Marak, Vill-Jamircherra PO- Manu PS- Dhumacherra Pin-799275

641. Karnadhan Kalai S/O- Jumia Kalai, Vill-Jamircherra PO- Manu, PS- Dhumacherra Pin- 799275

642. Matakanya Kalai W/O - Binodh Kalai, Vill- Jamircherra PO- Manu, PS- Dhumacherra Pin-799275

643. Gunendra Chakma S/O- Nikunja Chakma, Vill+PO+PS-Chawmanu Pin- 799273

644. Prantosh Chanda S/O- Swadesh Chanda, VILL+PO+PS-Dhumacherra Pin- 799275

645. Saptami Debbarma D/O Jamini Debbarma, Vill-Morabari, P/O-Champahour Khowai

646. Rajesh Banik S/O Rathindra Banik, Vill Char Ganki P.O. Khowai Court P/S, Khowai, Tripura Pin 799202

647. Lata Joy Reang S/O- Sidhirai Reang, R/O-Ananda Bazar Kanchanpur, North Tripura

648. Nitai Das S/O-Sarada Chandra Das, R/O- S.B.C. Nagar, Belonia, South Tripura

649. Mirulal Debbarma S/O Bisongroy Debbarma, Vill+P/O Shantirbazar, Kumarghat, Unakoti 799290

650. Rajesh Deb S/O-Laxman Deb, Vill+ P/O R.K. Nagar, Khas Noagaon, West Tripura, Pin-799008

651. Subrata Bhowmik S/O-Santosh Bhowmik, Vill + P/O - Uttar Majlishpur, West Tripura, Pin- 799035

652. Niren Singha S/O Nirode Baran Singha, Vill + P/O - South Dhaleswar, West Tripura, Pin-799004

653. Chaitanya Hrishi Das S/O-Haripada Hrishidas, Vill+ P/O - Madhuban, Ranikhamar, West Tripura, Pin- 799102

654. Smt. Rupa das D/O-Sushil Chandra Das, Vill + P/O -Surya Road, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799001

655. Sri Jay Kumar Sarkar S/O-Nagendra Sarkar, Vill + P/O - R.K. Nagar, West Tripura, Pin-799008

656. Tinku Chowdhury Kar S/O-Rakesh Kar, Vill + P/O -Ratannagar, Ranirbazar, West Tripura, Pin 799035

657. Hiranmoy Reang S/O.-Milanjoy Reang, R/O- Village – Raimani Para, Po-Kalapani Ps-Anandabazar, North Tripura-799270

658. Pallab Chowdhury S/O.-Lt. Kanti Bhushan Choudhury, R/O- Kadamtala, Dharmanagar North Tripura, 799261

659. Nidhuban Das S/O. Manik Das, R/O-Village Karamcherra, District Dhalai, Tripura, Pin-799266

660. Siuli Chowdhury (Rakshit) W/O. Sajal Rakshit, R/O-Village– RabindraPalli, R.K. Pur, Udaipur, District - Gomati Tripura, Pin-799120

661. Narayani Bhowmik C/O. Shiba Prasad Bhowmik, R/O-Village – Shalgara, Udaipur, District-Gomati Tripura, Pin-799114

662. Nurul Amin S/O-Mumtaj Miah, R/O-Noapara, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala Tripura, 799102

663. Nani Gopal Debnath S/O- Anil Chandra Debnath, R/O- Arabinda Nagar, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala Tripura, 799102

664. Santi Das S/O- Ayudha Das, R/O-East Laxmi Bill, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala Tripura, 799102

665. Mahendr Das S/O- Mohan Lal Das, R/O- Madhya Laxmibill, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala Tripura, 799102

666. Mahendr Das S/O-Mohan Lal Das, R/O- Madhya Laxmibill, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala 799102 Tripura,

667. Shyamsu Miah S/O- Abdul Latif, R/O- North Charilam, Aralia, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala Tripura, 799103

668. Hrishikesh Debbarma S/o-Ashuk Kumar Debbarma, Vill-Paija bari Khowai Tripura 799201

669. Sentu Debbarma S/o-Rabindra Debbarma, Vill-Mudibari, Khowai Tripura 799201

670. Sentu Debbarma S/o-Rabindra Debbarma, Vill-Mudibari, Khowai Tripura 799201

671. Ranjit Debbarma S/o-Jogesh Debbarma, Vill-Athaibari, Khowai Tripura 799207

672. Monoj Kumar Debbarma S/o-Nirmal Debbarma, Vill-Ghilatoli, Khowai Tripura 799203

673. Sujit Biswas S/O Subhash Biswas, Village – South Taranagar, Trish Ghar, P.O – Mohanpur, P.S – Sidhai, Dist – West Tripura, PIN – 799211

674. Sujit Shil S/O – Dhirendra Shil, Village – Noagaon, P.O-Kalibazar, P.S – Lefunga, Dist – West Tripura PIN – 799210

675. Rabi Mala Debbarma W/o-Sanjoy Debbarma, Vill-Asrai Para, Sidhai Mohanpur, West 799211 Tripura, Pin-

676. Kishore Kumar Reang S/O: Lt. Ganga ram Reang, Village: Gobinda bari, P/O: Nabincherra, Unakoti, Tripura

677. Debajit Bhattacharjee S/O- Biswajit Bhattacharjee, Village & P.O – Ishanpur, P.S – Sidhai, Dist – West Tripura, PIN-799212

678. Bina Debbarma S/o Late Brajakumar Debbarma, Vill-Kishong Para, PO-R.C. Nagar Ranirbazar West Tripura

679. Suman Sarkar C/o Bipad bhanjan Sarkar, Vill+PO+PS-Kakraban, Dist – Gomati Tripura, Pin - 799105

680. Smt. Bina Datta (Bhadra) W/O-Lt. Khokan Bhadra, Village & P/O- Khilpara, Udaipur, Tripura

681. Fulmala Debbarma (UGT) S/o-Shatrugna Debbarma, Vill- Ishan Chowdhury Para, P/O- Simna Colony, P/S: Sidhai, Dist- West Tripura Pin No-799212

682. Biplab Kumar Murasing S/o-Laxman Kumar Murasing, Vill-North Taibandal, Melaghar, Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799105

683. Aparna Saha Das W/o-Nepal Ch. Das, Vill-Jumer dhepa, Melaghar, Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

684. Lipika Ghosh D/o-Bishu Das, Vill-Telkajka, Melaghar, Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

685. Tapan Debbarma (UGT) S/o-Birmani Debbarma,Vill+P/O-Barkathal, Tripura(w), Pin-799211

686. Pradip Ch. Das P/S-Sidhai mohanpur, Dist- S/O Kumudranjan Das, Vill Rajnagar, P.O Samarendragoanj P.S – Manubazar, Dist- South Tripura, Pin-799156

687. Bishnu pada Karmakar S/o Lt Nepal Ch karmakar, Vill-Jamir Ghat. P.S-Lefunga, PO- Kamal Dist-West Tripura, Pin-799210 Ghat,

688. Napur Pal S/o Mantu Pal, Vill+PO-Debipur, P.S Belonia, Dist. South Tripura, Pin 799155

689. Nitai Paul S/o Tulshipaul, Vill-Gopal Nagar, PO- Kalkali, PS-Sidhai, Pin-799211, Dist-West- Tripura

690. Ashish Ghosh S/o-Narayan Ghosh, Vill-Santi Para, PO Kamalghat, PS-Lefunga, Dist- West- Tripura, Pin-799210

691. Jahangir Miah S/O-Lt-Samsu Miah, Vill-Noyapara, PO-Rayermura PS Amtali, Dist-West Tripura Pin-799130

692. Md Maharam Ali S/o-Abdul Hamid, Vill-Laltila kakraban, Udaipur Silghati Gumati Tripura, 799105

693. Ramu Jamatia S/o-Shib bakta Jamatia, Vill-Gamariabari, P/O-South Maharani, Udaipur, Gumati Tripura, 799013

694. Shymal Ch Saha S/o-Mrinal Kanti Saha, Vill-West Dhajanagar, Udaipur, Gumati, Pin-799114

695. Malati Jamatia W/O-Mongal Jamatia, Vill-Hatichara, P.O-South Moharani, P.S: R.K Pur, Dist- Gomoti Tripura, Pin-799013

696. Palash Chandra Majumder S/o Late Bimal Majumder, Vill+P.O – Rajnagar P. S – R.K. Pur, Pin code-799114

697. Ishak Jamatia S/o- Deb Sadhan Jamatia, Village- Sing Long Bari, PO- Laxmipati PS- R.K. Pur, Dist- Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799013

698. Lokesh Debbarma S/O-Rajendra Debbarma, Vill-Mudibari, Khowai Tripura 799201

699. Rima Debbarma D/O-Khagendra Debbarma, Vill-Dhupchara, Khowai Tripura, 799207

700. Md.Khalilur Rahaman S/o-Nur Jalal, Vill-Kalagangerpar, P/O-Kadamtala, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, 799261

701. Pinky Suklabaidya W/O-Manindra Suklabaidya, Manughat, Dhalai, Tripura-799275

702. Fulan Rani Dey (Das) W/O- Sujit Lal Das, R/O-Ambassa, Dhalai, Tripura-799289

703. Ranjita Debnath W/O-Rajesh Ranjan Debnath, R/O-North Narayanpur, Dharmanagar, North Tripura ...........Petitioner(s) Versus

1. State of Tripura Represented by the Commissioner/Secretary to the Government of Tripura Having His Office at New Secretariat, Agartala, P.O. New Secretariat, P.S. NCC West Tripura, Tripura

2. The Additional Secretary Government of Tripura, Department of Education, Having his Office at New Secretariat, Agartala, New Secretariat, P.S. NCC, District – West Tripura, Pin Code 799010

3. The Director of Elementary Education Government of Tripura, Directorate of Elementary Education, Shiksha Bhavan, Office Lane, Agartala, Tripura, Pin Code 799001 ...........Respondent(s) For Petitioner(s) For Respondent(s) : : Mr. AL Saha, Advocate. Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A. WP(C) No.57 of 2025

1. Sri Santanu Bhattacharjee S/O- Sudhir Chandra Bhattacharjee, Vill- West Joynagar, Road No-7, P.S- West Agartala, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799001

2. Md. Najrul Islam S/O- Lt. Nur Ahmed Vill- Barnarayan, P.O and P.S- Jatrapur, Dist- Tripura, Pin-799132 Sepahijala

5. Sri Arjun Shil S/O- Lt. Mahendra Shil Vill- Machima, P.O and P.S-Jatrapur, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799132 Sri Tapas Debnath S/O- Late. Raiharan Debnath Vill- Dhanpur, P.O - Dhanpur, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131 Sri Parimal Chandra Bhowmik S/O- Paresh Chandra Bhowmik Vill- Madhya Santinagar, P.O- Dhanpur, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

6. Tajul Islam S/O- Late Idrish Miah Vill- Balardhepa, P.O Dhanpur, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

7. Sri Babul Debbarma S/O- Late Nidan Debbarma Vill- Sovapur, P.O - Rabindranagar, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

8. Taj Mahamed S/O- Alakash Miah Vill- Srimantapur, P.O Rabindranagar, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

9. Md. Habibur Rahaman S/O- Late Julfu Miah Vill- Durgapur, P.O - Durgapur, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

10. Debabrata Sarkar S/O- Late Ananda Mohan Sarkar Vill- Gururband, P.O - Urmai, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799135

11. Manik Shil S/O- Late Rakhal Chandra Shil Vill- Purba Chandigarh, P.O - Purba Chandigarh, P.S-Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

12. Jatileswar Bhowmik S/O- Gour Prasad Bhowmik Vill- Machima, P.O - Jatrapur, P.S- Jatrapur, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799132

13. Jahangir Hossain S/O- Abdul Khalek Vill- Khedabari, P.O - Khedabari, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

14. Sanjit Paul S/O- Late Chitta Ranjan Paul Vill- Dhaliai, P.O- Sonamura, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

15. Nirmal Das S/O- Nikunja Behari Das Vill- Battali, P.O - Battali, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

16. Md. Mustafa Alam S/O- Babul Miah Vill- Sonapur, P.O - Rabindranagar, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

17. Bijoy Manik Tripura S/O- Prem Kumar Tripura Vill- Rampada para, P.O - Taksapara, P.S-Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799103

18. Anupama Mukherjee D/O- Ajit Kr. Mukherjee Vill- Purba Chandigarh, P.O - Purba Chandigarh, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

19. Rinku Das W/O- Santosh Ch. Das Vill- Rangamatia, P.O - Khedabari, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

20. Bhajan Chandra Ghosh S/O- Late Gopal Chandra Ghosh, Vill- Chandul (Kalapania), P.O -Mohan Bhog, P.S-Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

21. Habil Miah S/O- Rajjab Ali Vill- Durgapur, P.O- Durgapur. P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

22. Bhanulal Kar S/O- Sudhir Chandra Kar Vill- Mohanbhog, P.O - Mohanbhog, P.S-Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799105

23. Md. Habil Miah S/O- Md. Ali Hossain Vill- Paharpur, P.O - Jatrapur, P.S-Jatrapur, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799132

24. Sukanta Sarkar S/O- Late Himangshu Bikash Sarkar Vill- Rabigopal Para, P.O - Taksapara, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799103.

25. Tarasankar Das S/O- Lalit Mohan Das Vill- Chandanmura, P.O - Battali, P.S-Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

26. Abhijit Das S/O- Late Dinesh Das Vill- Chandigarh, P.O - Melaghar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

27. Amrita Chakraborty S/O- Late Satish Chakraborty Vill- Chandigarh, P.O - Melaghar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

28. Eunus Miah S/O- Late Michil Miah Vill- Bejimara, P.O -Bejimara, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

29. Intikab Alab S/O- Late Siddiqur Rahaman Vill- Tamsabari, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

30. Maran Chandra Das S/O- Ramani Mohan Das Vill- Laxmandhepa, P.O - Laxmandhepa, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

31. Ranjit Mandal S/O- Manoranjan Mandal Vill- Rabindranagar, P.O - Rabindranagar, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

32. Kaji Muslem S/O- Kaji Mustafa Vill- Tamsabari, North para, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

33. Sahajan Mia Choudhuri S/O- Abdul Rezzak Choudhuri Vill- Sonamura, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

34. Rafiqul Islam S/O- Late Md. Sona Mia Vill- Indiranagar, P.O - Melaghar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

35. Rajesh Ch. Saha S/O- Late Sunil Ch. Saha Vill- Rabindranagar, P.O - Rabindranagar, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

36. Md. Abdul Khalek S/O- Md. Rahamat Ali Vill- Bardowal, P.O - Bardowal, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

37. Krishnadhan Sarkar S/O- Haridas Sarkar Vill- Sonamura Hospital Road, P.O- Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

38. Delowar Hossen S/O- Abul Hassem Vill- Paschim Durlavnarayan, P.O - Durlavnarayan, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

39. Jalal Uddin Bhuiya S/O- Late Jahir Uddin Bhuiya Vill- Sonamura, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

40. Raju Dey S/O- Late Bidya Dhar Dey Vill- Sonamura Hospital Road, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

41. Alamgir Hossain Khandakar S/O- Salim Mia Khandakar Vill- Durgapur, P.O - Durgapur, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

42. Samir Pal S/O- Late Manoranjan Pal Vill- Uttarsantinagar, P.O - Dhanpur, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

43. Sureya Akter W/O-Aman Ulla, Vill- Tetaiyamura, P.O- Jatrapur, P.S- Jatrapur, Dist- Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin - 799132

44. Md. Abu Taher S/O- Md. Usman Ali Vill- Tetaiyamura, P.O - Jatrapur, P.S- Jatrapur, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799132

45. Lakshman Chakraborty S/O- Late Upendra Chakraborty Vill- Machima, P.O - Jatrapur, P.S- Jatrapur, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799132

46. Nimai Debnath S/O- Late Surendra Debnath Vill- Khedabari, P.O - Khedabari, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

47. Baharu Necha W/O- Litan Miah Vill- Aralia, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

48. Jahangir Hussain S/O- Late Abdur Rahman. Vill- Bordowal, P.O - Bordowal, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

49. Najama Begam W/O- Ruhul Amin, Vill- Sonamura Hospital Road, P.O Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

50. Dilip Kar Sil S/O- Rakhal Ch. Sil. Vill- Dhaliai, P.O Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

51. Kaberi Dey W/O- Dilip Das Vill- Poangbari, P.O - Poangbari, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

52. Mrinal Kanti Debnath (PH) S/O- Late Brajendra Ch. Debnath Vill- Chowmuhani, P.O - Chowmuhani, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

53. Dhruba Chandra Debnath S/O- Late Prahalad Chandra Debnath Vill- Chowmuhani, P.O - Chowmuhani, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

54. Jagadish Banik S/O- Subhash Banik Vill- Kamrangatali, P.O - Kamrangatali, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

55. Sanjoy Debnath S/O- Arjun Debnath Vill- Talkajla, P.O - Telkajla, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

56. Rabi Bashi Debbarma S/O- Late Gurucharan Debbarma Vill- Barpathar, P.O - Telkajla, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

57. Sipra Paul Majumder W/O- Jagadish Majumder Vill- Thakurmura, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

58. Faruque Hossain S/O- Farid Miah Vill- Mainama, P.O - Kulubari, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

59. Ashish Ch. Dey S/O- Atal Ch. Dey Vill- Paschim Durlavnarayan, P.O - Durlavnarayan, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

60. Partha Chakraborty S/O- Late Amarendra Chakraborty, Vill- Chanidagarh, P.O - Chanidagarh, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

61. Saha Alam S/O- Late Nurul Haque, Vill- N.C Nagar, P.O- Durgapur, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin - 799131

62. Billal Hossain Maishan S/O- Jalfu Mia Maishan. Vill- Paschim Durlavnarayan, P.O Purba Durlavnarayan, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

63. Babul Debnath S/O- Late Nagendra Debnath. Vill- West Nalchar, P.O - West Nalchar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

64. Bijoy Das S/O- Sachindra Ch. Das. Vill- West Nalchar, P.O - West Nalchar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

65. Ripana Begam W/O- Jahangir Hossain. Vill- South Maheshpur, P.O - Kathalia, P.S- Jatrapur, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799132

66. Sanchita Das W/O- Sukhen Barman. Vill- Rajghat, P.O - Melaghar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

67. Aktar Hossain S/O- Fajlul Haque, Vill- Sonamura, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

68. Abdul Mamin S/O- Manu Miah, Vill- Mayanama, P.O - Kulubari, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

69. Biswajit Majumder S/O- Late Upendra Kumar Majumder, Vill- Reshambagan, P.O - Reshambagan, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799008

70. Keshab Das S/O- Late Haradhan Das, Vill- East Nalchar, P.O - East Nalchar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

71. Uttam Kumar Laskar S/O- Late Phani Bhushan Sarkar. Vill- Kumariakucha, P.O - Bagmara, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799103

72. Abdul Hassem S/O- Tarab Ali, Vill- Aralia, P.O - Kulubari, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

73. Abdul Monaf S/O- Late Manu Miah Vill- Indiranagar, P.O- Melaghar, P.S- Melaghar Dist- Sepahijala,Tripura, Pin - 799115

74. Manik Majumder S/O- Manindra Ch.Majumder Vill- Masterpara, P.O - Rudijala, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

75. Ratna Sutradhar W/O- Pankaj Sutradhar. Vill- Bashpukur, P.O - Jatrapur, P.S- Jatrapur, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799132

76. Swapan Debnath S/O- Chitta Ranjan Debnath. Vill- Nalchar, P.O Nalchar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

77. Biplab Dey S/O- Late Haripada Dey. Vill- Bagabasa, P.O - Bagabasa, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

78. Sankar Ch. Das S/O- Late Santosh Ch. Das. Vill- Bagber Kalshimura, P.O - Kalamchowra, P.S- Kalamchowra, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799102

79. Sekhar Saha S/O- Late Somesh Saha. Vill- Tamsabari, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

80. Sanjit Das S/O- Manoranjan Das. Vill- South Nalchar, P.O - South Nalchar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

81. Mithun Das S/O- Bhulu Das. Vill- Telkajla, P.O - Telkajla, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

82. Md. Ali Siddiki S/O- Late Fazal Haque Vill- Rabigopal Para, P.O - Taxapara, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799103

83. Md. Nezam Uddin S/O- Late Abdul Latif. Vill- Balardhepa, P.O - Dhanpur, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

84. Sahid Ulla S/O- Late Leaquat Hossain. Vill- Rangamatia, P.O - Khedabari, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

85. Jashim Miah S/O- Abdul Jalil. Vill- Durgapur, P.O - Durgapur, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

86. Anich Miah S/O- Late Abdul Hakim. Vill- Aralia, P.O - Kulubari, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

87. Maman Chowdhury S/O- Late Ismail Chowdhury. Vill- Barnarayan, P.O - Bejimara, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

88. Mir Hossain Miah S/O- Late Akmat Ali Miah. Vill- Durlovpur, P.O - Bhabanipur, P.S- Jatrapur, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799132

89. Krishna Dhan Pal S/O- Late Chandra Mohan Pal. Vill- Palpara, P.O - Melaghar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

90. Milan Chandra Das S/O- Late Hari Bhusan Das. Vill- East Nalchar, P.O - East Nalchar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

91. Ranjit Debnath S/O- Anil Debnath. Vill- Purba Durlav Narayanpur, P.O - Purba Durlav Narayanpur, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

92. Mrinal Kanti Sen S/O- Pijush Kanti Sen. Vill- Jumerdhepa, P.O - Jumerdhepa, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

93. Satyaban Saha S/O- Late Ramesh Ch. Saha. Vill- Indiranagar, P.O - Melaghar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799115

94. Amlan Bhowmik S/O- Late Ashok Kumar Bhowmik. Vill- Madhuban, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

95. Abdul Halim S/O- Roshan Ali. Vill- Kulubari, P.O - Kulubari, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

96. Rakesh Mandal S/O- Madhusudhan Mandal. Vill- Sonamura, P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

97. Ratan Majumder S/O- Late Jitendra Chandra Majumder. Vill- Jumerdhepa, P.O - Melaghar, P.S- Melaghar, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

98. Abdul Malek S/O- Abdul Khalek. Vill- N.C. Nagar, P.O - Durgapur, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799131

99. Anamika Podder W/O- Ratan Baidya. Vill- Badharghat, P.O - Siddhiashram, P.S- Amtali, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799003

100. Dulal Ch. Das S/O- Late Anil Ch. Das. Vill- Chandinamura, P.O - Ramnagar, P.S- West Agartala, Dist- West Tripura, Pin- 799002

101. Smt. Krishna Chakraborty (B.A) W/O- Sri Bhaskar Bhattacharjee. Vill- Chandipara (Fishery Road), P.O - Amarpur, P.S- Birganj, Dist- Gomati Tripura, Pin-

102. Parimal Kanti Das S/O- Arun Chandra Das. Vill- Gourangatila, P.O - Teliamura, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

103. Sankar Chakraborty S/O- Late Bijoy Krishna Chakraborty. Vill- Chandipara Amarpur, P.S- Birganj, Dist- Gomati Tripura, Pin- (Fishery Road), P.O

104. Priya Ranjan Debbarma S/O- Late Santosh Ch. Debbarma. Vill- Hakimpara, P.O - Uttar Pulinpur, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

105. Ranjit Debbarma S/O- Late Manik Chandra Debbarma. Vill- Uttar Pulinpur, P.O - Uttar Pulinpur, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

106. Bibhuti Bhushan Debnath S/O- Late Joy Chandra Debnath. Vill- Icharbil, P.O Karailong, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

107. Aparna Das C/O- Shyamal Pal. Vill- Santi Nagar, P.O - Teliamura, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

108. Dipak Banik S/O- Late Kumode Ranjan Banik. Vill- Kalyanpur, P.O - Kalyanpur, Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin- 799203

109. Biswanath Goswami S/O- Late Binoy Bhushan Goswami. Vill- Kalyanpur, P.O -Kalyanpur, Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin- 799203 P.S- P.S-

110. Dhirendra Debbarma S/O- Shib Charan Debbarma. Vill- Yakhrai Para, P.O Kalyanpur, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

111. Goutam Biswas S/O- Late Sunil Biswas. Vill- Champlai, P.O - M.T.Para, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

112. Ratan Sharma S/O- Late Karuna Sagar Sharma. Vill- Paschim Ghilatali, P.O Ghilatali, Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203 P.S-

113. Kamal Ranjan Das S/O- Late Samarendra Das. Vill- Moharchara, P.O Moharchara, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

114. Gobinda Das S/O- Late Katuram Das Vill- Ghaniamara, P.O Totabari, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

115. Bhubanmay Shil S/O- Late Nikhil Kumar Shil Vill- Karailong, P.O - Karailong, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

116. Nilima Sutradhar W/O- Prabir Biswa Barman Vill- Karailong, P.O - Karailong, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

117. Pranab Das S/O- Rabi Lal Das. Vill- Gamaibari, P.O - Teliamura, P.S- Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205 Dist-

118. Shyamal Sarkar S/O- Late Debendra Ch. Sarkar. Vill- Brahma Chara, P.O Brahma Chara, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin- 799205

119. Simafue Mog W/O- Mogshathai Mog. Vill- Mogbari, P.O - Chakmaghat, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

120. Biresh Sarkar S/O- Chandra Kumar Sarkar Vill- Kalyanpur, P.O- Kalyanpur, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

121. Biswa Ranjan Giri S/O- Late Lalit Mohan Giri. Vill- Dakshin Durgapur, P.O - Ratia, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

122. Pandab Chanda S/O- Late Prabhat Chanda Vill- Gopal Nagar, P.O - Kalyanpur, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

123. Sumana Sinha W/O- Arun Sinha. Vill- Khash Kalyanpur, P.O - Ramdayalbari, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

124. Dhankanya Debbarma C/O- Kanu Sukla Das. Vill- Khash Kalyanpur, P.O - Ramdayalbari, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

125. Chandrani Debbarma D/O- Debendra Debbarma. Vill- Gumsingbari, P.O - West Laxmichara, Champahour, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203 P.S-

126. Goutam Laskar D/O- Nepal Ch. Laskar. Vill- Pakpai, P.O - M.T.Para, P.S- Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203 Dist-

127. Pijush Debbarma S/O- Nepal Ch. Laskar. Vill- Pakpai Bari, P.O - M.T.Para, P.S-Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203 Dist-

128. Haripada Das S/O- Late Nilmohan Das. Vill- Kamalnagar, P.O - Mohar Charra, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

129. Sujit Das S/O- Late Nepal Chandra Das. Vill- Chalitabari, P.O - Mohar Charra, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

130. Alendra Debbarma S/O- Late Moni Chandra Debbarma. Vill- Darpanarayan Para, Moharanipur, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205 P.O North

131. Kasmika Debbarma D/O-Promode Debbarma. Vill- Dinadayal Sardar Para, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203 P.O - Ghilatali Bazar,

132. Garan Jamatia S/O- Mukti Charan Jamatia. Vill- Chalitabari, P.O - Moharchara, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

133. Chandraketu Sarkar S/O- Krishnadhan Sarkar. Vill- Chalitabari, P.O Moharcharra, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

134. Achin Kumar Jamatia S/O- Gokulhari Jamatia Vill- Garjanmura, P.O Hadrai, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

135. Amar Jamatia S/O- Late Ananda Kumar Jamatia Vill- Khamarbari, P.O Hadrai, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

136. Manoj Debbarma S/O- Birbal Debbarma. Vill- Tablabari, P.O Sonatala, P.S- Khowai , Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799207

137. Subhash Debnath S/O- Late Upendra Chandra Debnath. Vill- Peknicharra, P.O - Chebri, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin- 799207

138. Biswajit Das S/O- Late Dinesh Ch. Das. Vill- Nayanpur, P.O M.T.Para, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

139. Sajal Kanti Das S/O- Satyendra Ch. Das. Vill- Pulinpur, P.O Howaibari, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

140. Ananda Chandra Barman S/O- Rabendra Chandra Barman. Vill- South Pramode Nagar, P.O D.P.LL. Colony, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

141. Ajit Debbarma S/O- Late Rahi Kumar Debbarma Vill- Mongkurai Para, P.O - N.K.R Para, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

142. Ajit Kumar Debbarma S/O- Birmani Debbarma. Vill- Debtabari, P.O - Yakharai Bazar, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

143. Sanjoy Debbarma S/O- Late Akhil Debbarma. Vill- Bharat Sardar Para, P.O Samatal Padmabhil, P.S- Khowai, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799201

144. Hiranmoy Datta S/O- Late Himangshu Ranjan Datta. Vill- South Durgapur, P.O-Ratia, Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203 P.S-

145. Priyatama Debbarma W/O- Prashanta Debbarma. Vill- Para Kalak, P.O Uttar Pulinpur, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

146. Kamal Debbarma S/O- Sukrai Debbarma. Vill- South Gokulnagar, P.O Khasiamangal, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

147. Shiba Hari Jamatia S/O- Late Tribhanga Hari Jamatia. Vill- Kunjamura, P.O Uttar Gakulnagar, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

148. Amrit Debbarma S/O- Biran Debbarma. Vill- North Maharanipur, P.O North Maharanipur, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

149. Biswa Mohan Debbarma S/O- Sumanta Debbarma. Vill- North Maharanipur, P.O - North Maharanipur, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

150. Sujit Banik S/O- Manindra Banik. Vill- Chebri, P.O Chebri, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799201

151. Manoranjan Debbarma S/O- Subhajoy Debbarma. Vill- North Maharanipur, P.O North Maharanipur, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

152. Arun Mandal S/O- Late Jogesh Mandal. Vill- Southghilatali, P.O Southghilatali, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

153. Biswajit Gope S/O- Late Ramdhan Gope. Vill- Moharcharra, P.O Moharcharra, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

154. Manuj Kumar Debbarma S/O- Hiran Debbarma. Vill- Godai Para, P.O Santinagar, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

155. Raghunath Roy S/O- Late Dipchan Roy. Vill- Paschim Ghilatali, P.O Ghilatali Bazar, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

156. Dipak Modak S/O- Bishnu Prasad Modak. Vill- Rajnagar, P.O Teliamura, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

157. Amalesh Saha S/O- Late Kshemesh Ch. Saha. Vill- Santinagar, P.O Teliamura, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

158. Sumandra Debbarma S/O- Late Devendra Debbarma. Vill- North Maharanipur, P.O North Maharanipur, P.S- Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

159. Rajib Roy S/O- Jagadish Ch. Roy. Vill- Manu, P.O - Manu, P.S- Manu, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

160. Chandan Roy S/O- Late Sudhir Roy. Vill- West Machli , P.O Machli Bazar, P.S- Manu,(LTV) Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

161. Sanjoy Debbarma S/O- Mangal Debbarma. Vill- Lal Cherra, P.O Chailengta, P.S- Chailengta, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

162. Prahelika Chakma S/O- Sharadindu Chakma. Vill- Lambabil, P.O Manu, P.S- Manu,Dist Tripura, Pin-799275 Dhalai

163. Abhijit Tripura S/O- Birbahu Tripura. Vill- North Dhumacherra, P.O Dhumacherra, P.S- Dhumacherra, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

164. Pradip Das S/O- Dukhai Das. Vill- Bhatkhadri, P.O Salema, P.S- Dhumacherra, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799278

165. Rakhi Bandhan Tripura W/O- Eti Ranjan Kalai, Vill- Dhumacherra, P.O- Dhumacherra, P.S- Dhumacherra, Dist- Dhalai, Tripura, Pin 799275

166. Ramprasad Choudhury S/O- Harish Chandra Choudhury. Vill- Chailengta, P.O - Chailengta, P.S- Chailengta, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin- 799273

167. Sukriti Sharma (Saha) W/O- Dipesh Saha. Vill- Durgapur, P.O - Gandacherra, P.S- Gandacherra, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799284

168. Swapna Paul D/O- Manik Lal Paul. Vill- Durgapur, P.O - Sharma, P.S- Gandacherra, Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799284 Dist-

169. Ujjal Saha S/O- Narayan Chandra Saha. Vill and P.O - Sonamura, P.S- Sonamura, Dist- Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799131

170. Mira Das D/O- Nabadwip Das. Vill- South Mirzapur, P.O - Belonia, P.S-Belonia, Dist- South Tripura, Pin-799155

171. Bakul Debbarma S/O- Birendra Debbarma. Vill- Nalkata, P.O - Nalkata, P.S- Manu, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799264

172. Sebika Datta (Das) W/O- Arup Das. Vill- Debpara West Masli, P.O - Masli Bazar, P.S- Manu, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

173. Nimai Singha C/O- Himangshu Debbarman. Vill- Old Guest House, P.O - P.S- West Agartala, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799001

174. Kartik Chandra Das S/O- Sachindra Das. Vill- Anandanagar, P.O - Anandanagar P.S- Srinagar, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799004

175. Supriya Singha D/O- Basanta Singha. Vill- Baidhyer Dighi, Laxmibil, P.S- Bishalgarh, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799006

176. Basanta Sarkar S/O- Late Bani Kanta Sarkar. Vill- Indranagar, P.S- N.C.C, Dist- West Tripura, Pin- 799004

177. Ajoy Dey S/O- Late Manoranjan Dey. Vill- Dhaleswar Water Supply Road, Agartala, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799004 P.S- East

178. Purabi Saha W/O- Sri Abhijit Ray Vill- Ramnagar Road No -9/10 P.S- West Agartala, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799002

179. Paritosh Shil S/O- Late. Promod Ch. Shil Vill- Amar colony, P.O- Kalyanpur P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

180. Amal Sarkar S/O- Kalidhan Sarkar. Vill- West Durgapur, P.O- I.C.Nagar P.S- Amtali, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799203

181. Jutan Debnath S/O- Paresh Debnath. Vill- Paschim Ghilatali, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799203

182. Subash Majumder S/O- Khokan Majumder. Vill- West Noabadi, P.S- Bodhjungnagar, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799130

183. Suk Lal Roy S/O- Laxmi Kanta Roy. Vill- Gabtali, P.O- Rayermura, P.S- Amtali, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799130

184. Dulal Das S/O- Late Jaharlal Das Vill- Ramkrishna Para, East Pratapgarh, P.S- East Agartala, Dist- West Tripura, Pin- 799004

185. Pancham Rudra Paul C/O- Late Kamini Rudra Paul. Vill- Indranagar, P.S- East Agartala, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799006

186. Jhumar Banik C/O- Litan Banik. Vill- Pratapgarh, P.S- East Agartala, Dist- West Tripura, Pin- 799004

187. Arup Kumar Das S/O- Late Ashutosh Das. Vill- Manu, P.S- Manu, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799275

188. Khajendra Tripura S/O- Late Ashutosh Das. Vill- Manu, P.S- Manu, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799275

189. Amiliya Chakma W/O- Ripan Chakma. Vill- Tilak Para, P.O-Mainama, P.S- Chailengta, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

190. Monsoon Chakma W/O- Junnyh Chakma. Vill- Tilak Para, P.O-Mainama, P.S- Chailengta, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

191. Anna Devi Chakma W/O- Surjya Lal Chakma. Vill- Chailengta, P.O- Chailengta, P.S- Chailengta, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

192. Talea Dewan D/O- Hirajiban Dewan. Vill- Madhab Master Para, P.O- Mainama, P.S- Chailengta, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799273

193. Sujit Das S/O- Manoranjan Das. Vill- Chailengta, P.O- Chailengta, P.S- Chailengta, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

194. Tutu Mog S/O- Are Mog. Vill- Kashim Cherra, P.O- Kalaibiyar, P.S- Ambassa, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799204

195. Shyamal Chandra Banik S/O- Late Chitta Ranjan Banik. Vill- Manughat, P.O- Manughat, P.S- Manughat, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

196. Manash Kanti Das S/O- Late Narayan Ch. Das. Vill- Manu, P.O- Manu, P.S- Manu, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275

197. Rajib Chakma S/O- Late Sukra Charjiya Chakma. Vill- Nakkata, P.O- Nakkata, P.S- Pecharthal, Dist- Unakoti Tripura

198. Krittikava Chakma S/O- Nilmani Chakma. Vill- Machmara, P.O- Machmara, P.S- Pecharthal, Dist- Unakoti Tripura, Pin-

199. Ananda Chakma S/O- Dhaniram Chakma. Vill- Dewanbari, P.O- Machmara, P.S- Pecharthal, Dist- Unakoti Tripura, Pin-799263

200. Bimal Chakma S/O- Santi Kumar Chakma. Vill- Nalkata, P.O- Nalkata, P.S- Pecharthal, Dist- Unakoti Tripura, Pin-799263

201. Rajendra Debbarma S/O- Sudharanjan Debbarma. Vill- Chelikhala, P.O- Gajaria, P.S- Bishalgarh, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin- 799102

202. Manashi Das D/O- Manoranjan Das. Vill- Officetilla, P.O- Bishalgarh, P.S- Bishalgarh, Dist- Sepahijala Tripura, Pin-799102

203. Sabita Karmakar C/O- Subir Roy, Vill- East Dukli ,P.O- East Pratapgarh P.S- East Agartala, Dist West Tripura, Pin- 799004

204. Mukta Lal Das S/O- Late Hriday Chand Das. Vill- Gourisankar Pur, P.O- Dasda Bazar, Dist- North Tripura, Pin-799271

205. Ashit Baran Nath S/O- Abani Mohan Nath Vill- Daincherra, P.O- Suknacherra, Dist- North Tripura, Pin - 799270

206. Sanjoy Nath S/O- Sukhamoy Nath. Vill- Subhashnagar, P.O- Kanchanpur, Dist- North Tripura, Pin-799270

207. Manindra Chanda S/O- Late Sudhangshu Chanda. Vill- Sanicharra, Dharmanagar, P.O- Dharmanagar, Dist- North Tripura, Pin-799270

208. Md. After Miah S/O-.Late Abdul Rashid Vill- Bishnupur, P.O- Rakhalganj, Dist- North Tripura, Pin-799261

209. Md Abdul Jaynal S/O- Abdul Matlib. Vill- Bishnupur, P.O- Rakhalganj, Dist- North Tripura, Pin- 799261

210. Dulal Debnath S/O- Late Haripada Debnath. Vill- Madhyapara, P.O- Khayerpur, Dist- West Tripura, Pin-

211. Md Abdul Fajal Choudhury S/O- Abdul Rahim Choudhury. Vill- Kadamtala, P.O- Kadamtala, Dist- West Tripura

212. Santosh Das S/O- Late Bipin Ch. Das. Vill- Rajnagar, P.O- Fatikroy, Dist- West Tripura, Pin- 799290

213. Dhruba Kanti Dey S/O- Dakshina Dey. Vill- Dharmanagar, P.O-Dharmanagar, Dist- North Tripura

214. Pratap Debbarma S/O - Sri Sumendra Debbarma Vill- North Ghilatali PO- Ghilatali Bazar, PS - Kalyanpur, District - Khowai, Tripura PIN -799203

215. Namita Rani Nath W/O- Mantu Chandra Nath Vill- Ichailalcherra, P.O- Ichailalcherra P.S- Dharmanagar,Dist- North Tripura,Pin- 799251

216. Bijay Debbarma S/O Late Manmohan Debbarma Vill- Sridampur ,P.O- Nagbangshi P.S- Kamal Pur, Dist- Dhalai,Tripura

217. Debasish Dutta S/O- Jagadish Ch. Dutta Vill- Dhaleswar, Kalyani, P.O- Agartala college Pin- 799004

218. Paramita Sarkar S/O- Sukumar Sarkar Vill- West Bhoubanban,P.O- Lankamura, Agartala, Dist- West Tripura, Pin- 799002 P.S-West

219. Shyamali Banik C/O- Jiban Banik Vill- Ranjit nagar, P.O- Ramnagar Dist- West Tripura, Pin - 799002

220. Rakesh Pal S/O- Hariprasad Paul Vill- Town Bordowali, C.R.U Rest house lane, Agartala, Dist- West Tripura,Pin-799001

221. Uttam Banik S/O- Late.Swapan Kr. Banik Vill-Santipara, South lane, Agartala, Dist-West Tripura, Pin-799001

222. Parindra Sarkar C/O- Harish Chandra Sarkar. Vill- Banzer, P.O- Banzer, Dist-Khowai,Pin 799201

223. Ratish Biswas S/O- Rama Ranjan Biswas Vill- Asharam Bari ,P.o- Asharam Khowai,Pin- 799201 Bari Dist-

224. Nerananda Telenga C/O- Shyamal Telenga Vill- Asharam Bari, P.O- Asharam Bari Dist-Khowai, Pin- 799201

225. Adhir Ranjan Gupta S/O- Late.Amulya Ranjan Gupta Vill- Maranipur ,P.O- Chakmaghat, Dist- Khowai,Tripura,Pin-799205

226. Ajit Kumar Debbarma S/O-Late. Mangal Debbarma. Vill-Asharam Sardar para, P.O-Uttarpulin pur. P.S- Teliamura, Dist-Khowai Tripura. Pin-799203

227. Dipak Sarkar S/O-Haribal Sarkar, Vill-Brahmacharra, P.O- Brahmacharra, P.S-Teliamura, Dist- Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205

228. Shipra Das D/O-Late.Sushen Ch. Das, Vill- Champlai,P.O- M.T.Para,P.S-Teliamura, Dist- Khowai,Tripura,Pin- 799205

229. Sri Nani Gopal Biswas S/O Late Rajani Kanta Biswas, Vill- Trisha Bari, P.O Mohar Cherra, PS. Teliamura, Khowai, PIN-799

230. Sipra Das D/O Sri Durga Mohan Das, Vill and PO Noabari, Jirania, West Tripura, 799045 PIN-

231. Jaba Bhattacharjee C/O-Late Kshirod Chandra Bhattacharjee, Vill-Teliamura, P.O Teliamura, P.S- Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, PIN-799205 ...........Petitioner(s) Versus

1. State of Tripura Represented by The Commissioner/Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Having His Office at New Secretariat, Agartala, P.O. - New Secretariat, P.S. NCC, PIN- 799010, Tripura.

2. The Additional Secretary, Government of Tripura Department of Education, Having his Office at New Secretariat, Agartala, New Secretariat, P.S. NCC-799010, Tripura, Pin Code 799010.

3. The Director of Elementary Education Government of Tripura, Directorate Of Elementary Education, Shiksha Bhavan, Office Lane, Agartala, Tripura, Pin Code- 799001 ...........Respondent(s) For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. Abheek Saha, Advocate. For the Respondent(s) Date of hearing Date of delivery of Judgment & order Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A. : : 18th August, 2025. : 31st October, 2025. Whether fit for reporting: NO YES √ HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA JUDGMENT & ORDER Common questions of facts and issues being involved in all the three writ petitions, same were heard simultaneously and are being disposed of by this common judgment. BACKGROUND FACTS [2] In the year 2002, the State of Tripura took initiative for recruiting under graduate teachers, graduate teachers and post graduate teachers for different schools established and functioning in Tripura. Accordingly, first advertisement was issued on 29.10.2002 for filling up 1000 posts of Graduate Teachers, 500 posts of Under Graduate Teachers and 100 posts of Kokborok Teachers. Several persons applied pursuant to that advertisement. On

05.04.2006 again another advertisement was issued for filling up 962 posts of Graduate Teachers, 389 post of Under Graduate Teachers and 100 post of Kokborok Teachers on fixed pay basis. [3] No recruitment was, however, made pursuant to above said two advertisements and again on 23.09.2009, another advertisement was issued wherein 4856 posts of graduate teachers, 4629 posts of Under Graduate Teachers and 99 posts of Kokborok Teachers were advertised. Regarding the filling up of posts of post graduate teachers, similar advertisements were also issued in 2002, 2006 and lastly on 23.09.2009. In the advertisement of the year 2009, it was also mentioned that the candidates who had applied in the year 2002 and 2006 pursuant to earlier advertisements noted above, were not required to apply again but they were supposed to appear before the interview board. Several candidates applied for jobs against those advertisements. [4] Prior to that, in the year 2003, the State Government framed an employment policy vide memorandum No.F.1(4)-GA(P&T)/99 dated

30.08.2003 giving guidelines regarding such recruitments in respect of various categories of posts under Government of Tripura. [5] The selection process in respect of the candidatures received in respect of above said advertisements was initiated by the State following above said employment policy and the successful candidates were appointed. [6] Challenging the said recruitment process, several writ petitions were filed before this Court (the then Gauhati High Court, Agartala Bench) and learned Writ Court without entering into the merit of the matter, disposed of a total of 61 writ petitions by a common judgment dated 16.11.2011 remanding the matter to the Government for thorough scrutiny and examination by constituting a committee of responsible officers. [7] The State challenged said judgment of the learned Writ Court and some of the petitioners also simultaneously filed an appeal being aggrieved by said decision. The Division Bench, in W.A. 54 of 2011 and other connected matters, allowed the writ appeals holding that matter should be decided by the Court. [8] Thereafter, in view of large numbers of petitions and considering the public interest involved in these matters, the Division Bench took up all the matters for hearing and one of such cases was Tanmoy Nath and others vs. State of Tripura and others [WP(C) No.51 of 2014]. All the writ petitions were disposed of by the Division Bench by a common judgment dated

07.05.2014 (hereinafter referred to as Tanmoy Nath’s case) quashing said revised employment policy and setting aside the entire selection process. It was also held that the selections were totally unfair and the policy was illegal and unconstitutional. The Division Bench, however, considering the fact that the education of children are not disturbed, directed that the teachers whose selection was set aside should continue to function in their present place of posting till 31.12.2014 and before said date, the State must complete a fresh process of selection of all teachers in all categories. [9] The State Government was further directed in the said judgment to frame a new employment policy within two months and to carry out the selection as per the fresh policy. In case the State did not frame any guidelines or fresh policy, then some guidelines were also issued by the Court asking the State to follow the same while making new selections. [10] At Para 127 of the said judgment, it was further clarified by the Court that the judgment shall be prospective in nature and shall not affect the appointments already made unless the said appointments were already under challenge before the Court on the ground that the employment policy is illegal. Said paragraph No.127 of the judgment of Tanmoy Nath’s case having significant relevancy in the present cases is extracted hereunder: “127. Since we have set aside the revised employment policy which applies to a large category of posts and not merely to teachers, we would like to make it clear that our judgment shall be prospective in nature and shall not affect the appointments already made unless the said appointments are already under challenge before the Court on the ground that the employment policy is illegal.” [11] The State preferred an appeal before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court against the said judgment in Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s).18993- 19049/2014 which was dismissed on 29.03.2017. However, the direction of the High Court given in paragraph No.123 of the judgment of Tanmoy Nath’s case containing direction to the State to complete a fresh process of selection of teachers by 31.12.2014 was modified to the following extent: “............ Since we do not find any ground to interfere with the impugned order, the directions in para 123 now required to be suitably modified. We, therefore, direct: (a) New Employment Policy should be framed by the State by 30th April, 2017 if not already framed and advertisements for filling up the vacancies may be issued latest by 31st May, 2017. (b) The fresh selection process be completed on or before 31st December, 2017 and till the fresh process is completed, the teachers already appointed shall continue. (c) The candidates who participated in the selection process pursuant to the advertisements in question, whether selected or not, will be allowed to participate in the fresh selection process by relaxing their age but subject to their having necessary qualifications. (d) The qualifications in the case of teachers governed by the provisions of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 shall be in conformity with the relevant statutory provisions of the said Act. (e) The qualifications of teachers employed for Classes IX and above shall be strictly in compliance with the relevant provisions concerning such appointments. Subject to the aforesaid modifications, the view taken by the High Court in the impugned order is affirmed and the special leave petitions are dismissed.” [12] According to the State, after the order was passed by Hon‟ble Supreme Court, the services of post graduate teachers, graduate teachers and under graduate teachers who were appointed in the year 2010 came to an end on 31.12.2017. Thereafter, those teachers were appointed again on 01.01.2018 for a period of 6(six) months on ad-hoc basis vide Memorandum dated

23.12.2017 and then in pursuance of the subsequent order of the Hon‟ble Apex Court, the tenure of the teachers re-appointed on ad-hoc basis was extended from time to time up to 31.03.2020 and thereafter, they were terminated from the service. Meanwhile, the Education (School Department), Government of Tripura formulated the Recruitment Rules of different categories of teachers following the guidelines of National Council for Teacher Education (in short „NCTE‟) and started recruiting teachers through selection processes conducted by Teachers‟ Recruitment Board, Tripura (in short „TRBT‟) since 2016. [13] Now, the present writ petitions are filed by some of the terminated teachers challenging their termination, which was on different grounds. WP(C) No.592 of 2024 is related to termination of some of the post graduate teachers; WP(C) No.57 of 2025 relates to termination of some of the graduate teachers and WP(C) No.699 of 2024 relates to termination of some of the under graduate teachers. The case bearing No. WP(C) 592 of 2024 (post graduate teachers) is being treated as the lead case. CHALLENGES MADE IN THE PRESENT WRIT PETITIONS [14] The basic challenges of all the writ petitioners in these petitions regarding their termination from the service, are on the following grounds: i) They were recruited following the Recruitment Rules of the State Government issued vide notification No.F.25(1)-E/70(EC) dated

26.01.1971 (Annexure 1) and not by any other rules or policy. ii) They were recruited vide State Government policy bearing No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)/05/Part-1 dated 16.10.2007 (Annexure 2) and not by the policy of 2003 as was set aside in Tanmoy Nath’s case. iii) They were not party to said Tanmoy Nath’s case and therefore, said decision was not binding on them. Though public notice was issued in Tanmoy Nath’s case as per the provision of Order I rule 8 CPC and was published in two newspapers having wide circulation in Tripura, the petitioners were not concerned with said notice inasmuch as they were recruited following a different Recruitment Policy. iv) The 2003 Recruitment Policy was not mentioned in the advertisement issued by the respondents or even in the appointment orders of the petitioners and therefore, the applicability of said policy in the cases of petitioners or even the existence of said policy itself is questionable. v) The services of the petitioner were protected in the contexts of paragraph No.127 of the judgment of Tanmoy Nath’s case as extracted earlier. vi) That such termination was illegal and unconstitutional being done in flagrant violation of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, as no notice to show cause before such termination was issued to them, and no proceeding was initiated against them. According to them, once a person is recruited and subsequently regularized in service, they hold a civil post, and the only way to terminate the service is to follow the procedure laid down in CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 and Article 311 of the Constitution and therefore, en-masse orders of termination from service were illegal. vii) In WP(C) No.592 of 2024, further defence was taken that after the judgment passed in Tanmoy Nath’s case by the High Court, the services of the petitioners were regularized vide Memorandum dated

05.11.2015 giving the benefit of a regular pay scale and other allowances to the petitioners of said case. Therefore, said fact suggests that the selection and appointments of the said petitioners were not under challenge in Tanmoy Nath’s case. ARGUMENTS PLACED ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS [15] Mr. R. Marar, learned senior counsel for the petitioners in WP(C) No.592 of 2024 addresses his argument that the petitioners were guided by the Recruitment Policy of 2001 and the policy of 2007 and not by the policy of 2003 and therefore, decision of Tanmoy Nath’s case has no impact on the services of the petitioners. According to learned senior counsel, no notice before termination of their service was issued to the petitioners and therefore, it was in gross violation of natural justice. Further, the services of the petitioners were also regularized in the year 2015. Learned senior counsel also submits that there has been no inordinate delay in filing the present petition, for they earlier preferred a writ petition before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the year 2024 and later on the same was withdrawn for availing remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution before the High Court. [16] Learned senior counsel also relies on a decision of the Single Bench of this Court in case of Abul Bashar Zia Uddin vs. the State of Tripura and others [WP(C) No.797 of 2020] (Annexure-13). In that case, some Assistant Teachers (Biology/Pure Science) challenged the show cause notice issued to them, alleging that they were covered by the decision of Tanmoy Nath’s case. They were appointed in response to an advertisement issued by the State on 25.08.2010 and were given appointments in the month of March,

2012. Learned Single Bench categorically observed in said judgment that the decision of Tanmoy Nath’s case was not applicable in the case of the petitioners of said case, as they were recruited pursuant to the advertisement dated 25.08.2010 which was never challenged in Tanmoy Nath’s case and therefore, said show cause notice was quashed. [17] Mr. T.K. Nayak, learned counsel in addition to the submissions as advanced by Mr. Marar, learned senior counsel, further argues that as per the dictionary meaning, the word “memorandum” means either a communication or an agreement pending finalization and therefore, by issuing such policy of 2003 through a memorandum, the services of petitioners could not be terminated, inasmuch as the contents of the memorandum are always subject to final approval by the different authorities of the executives. Therefore, such policy of 2003 issued by a memorandum was subject to finalization and that is the reason for which it was not published for general appraisal. Thus, said policy could not be applied in the case of the petitioners. [18] Learned counsel has also added that the policy of 2003 was only meant for the purpose of reservation and not for the selection process and moreover, it was at the draft stage. Learned counsel continues to argue that there was no denial in the counter affidavit submitted by the State against the assertions of the petitioners that 2003 policy was not binding on them. [19] Mr. Nayak, learned counsel also relies on a decision of Division Bench of this court in case of Sudip Kumar Debnath and others vs. the State of Tripura and others [WP (C) 119 of 2020] decided along with another writ petition bearing No. WP(C) No.620 of 2020 wherein the services of the petitioners of both the cases were terminated pursuant to the decision of Tanmoy Nath’s case. Those terminations were challenged in the Court and the Court ultimately dismissed said writ petitions. At the time of hearing, from the side of the petitioners, reference was made to the appointments of three respondents as science teachers pursuant to an advertisement issued in the year

2010. Said three respondents were also made party in another earlier writ petition bearing No. WP(C) 537 of 2012 which was decided simultaneously with Tanmoy Nath’s case. In this regard, the Court in Sudip Kumar Debnath’s case observed that one of the stray petition i.e. WP(C) No.537 of 2012 out of the entire group of large numbers of petitions, did involve a challenge to the science teachers who were also appointed on the basis of the same Recruitment Policy. However, in the entire judgment of the High Court in Tanmoy Nath’s case, the sole focus was on ten thousand plus appointments made to the Under Graduate, Graduate and Post Graduate teacHers pursuant to the advertisement dated 23.09.2009 and therefore, one could not be allowed to pick an isolated petition out of the context to hold that the entire selection and appointment of science teachers which were not part of said recruitment notification dated

23.09.2009 but were by way of termination of entirely different selection process, must also stand nullified. Mr. Nayak, learned counsel tries to impress the Court that the present case also stands on similar footing which was not the matter of controversy in Tanmoy Nath’s case. But this Court is not convinced with such submissions, as the present petitioners were not appointed as science teachers like said three respondents of Sudip Kumar Debnath’s case. [20] Mr. Nayak, learned counsel further relies on the following decisions: (i) Secretary, State of Karnataka and others vs. Umadevi (3) and another, (2006) 4 SCC 1- The Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in this case at paragraph No.47 observes that when a person enters a temporary employment or gets engagement as a contractual or casual worker and the engagement is not based on a proper selection as recognised by the relevant rules and procedure, he is aware of the consequences of the appointment being temporary, casual or contractual in nature. Such a person cannot invoke the theory of legitimate expectation for being confirmed in the post when an appointment to the post could be made only by following a proper procedure for selection and in cases concerned, in consultation with the Public Service Commission. In that case, however, as a one time measure, the services of irregularly appointed (not illegally appointed) persons, who have worked for ten years or more against duly sanctioned posts, were directed to be regularised by the Government. This judgment is pronounced in a completely different context. (ii) Gulf Goans Hotels Company Limited and another. vs. Union of India and others, (2014) 10 SCC 673- In this case, the appellants were the owners of Hotels, Beach Resorts and Beach Bungalows in Goa whose certain properties were ordered to be demolished by the State authorites on ecological grounds, and such orders were upheld by Bombay High Court and therefore the matters came before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court. Certain environmental guidelines of the Governments, in this regard, as a matter of policy were relied on and were examined by the Court. In that context, the Apex Court observes at paragraph No.19 that Article 77 of the Constitution provides the form in which the Executive must make and authenticate its orders and decisions and as per Clause (1) of Article 77 of the Constitution, all executive action of the Government must be expressed to be taken in the name of the President. At paragraph No.21, relying on another decision of the Supreme Court, it has been observed that in absence of due authentication and promulgation of the guidelines, the contents thereof cannot be treated as an order of the Government and would really represent an expression of opinion. A noting recorded in the file is merely a noting simpliciter and nothing more. It merely represents expression of opinion by the particular individual and it cannot be treated as a decision of the Government. At paragraph No.22, it is also observed that what is claimed to be law must be notified or made public in order to bind the citizen. (iii) The Management of Rain Row Dyeing Factory, Chinnamuthu Street, Shevapet, Salem and others vs. the Industrial Tribunal, High Court Buldings Madras-1 and another, AIR 1959 Mad 137- While dealing with the question as to whether 30 industrial establishments can be allowed to file joint writ petition where the Tribunal passed an award considering the questions unit by unit and the management of all the 30 concerns are affected by said order of the Tribunal, the High Court incidently observed as under: “Section 141, Civil Procedure Code, provides that the procedure laid down in the Code in regard to suits shall be followed, as far as it can be made applicable, in all proceedings in any Court of civil jurisdiction. On the strength of this rule it was suggested that the provisions of O.1, C.P.C., can be applied to writ proceedings. In respect of this suggestion it is sufficient to refer to Thakur Prasad v. Fakir Ullah (1) where when dealing with S.647 of the old Civil Procedure Code, which corresponds to S.141 of the present Code, the Privy Council observed: “Their Lordships think that the proceedings spoken of in S.647 include original matters in the nature of suits such as proceedings in probtes, guardianships, and so forth, and do not include executions.” So far we are aware, a writ proceeding has never been held to be in the nature of a suit….” As it appears, by referring to this decision, Mr. Nayek, learned counsel tries to show that the general notice issued under Order I rule 8 C.P.C. in Tanmoy Nath’s case was not permissible at Law and therefore, the same is not binding on the present petitioners. But any such question regarding validity of the notice, as was issued in that case, cannot be challenged or reopened in a parallel proceeding(s) like present writ petitions and moreover, the matter has already reached finality. (iv) Hochtief Gammon vs. State of Orissa and others, (1976) 1 SCR 667 at page 679- In the relevant paragraph, it is observed that the Executive has to reach their decisions by taking into account relevant considerations. They should not refuse to consider relevant matter, nor should they take into account wholly irrelevant or extraneous considerations. They should not misdirect themselves on a point of law. Only such a decision will be lawful. The courts have the power to see that the Executive acts lawfully. (v) Msr. Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of India and another, (1978) 1 SCC 248- In paragraph No.14, the relevant portion as referred by learned counsel discusses with the principle of audi alteram partem. It has been observed therein that the audi alteram partem rule is intended to inject justice into the law and it cannot be applied to defeat the ends of justice, or to make the law „lifeless, absurd, stultifying, self-defeating or plainly contrary to the common sense of the situation.‟ Since the life of the law is not logic but experience and every legal proposition must, in the ultimate analysis, be tested on the touchstone of pragmatic realism, the audi alteram partem rule would, by the experiential test, be excluded, if importing the right to be heard has the effect of paralysing the administrative process or the need for promptitude or the urgency of the situation so demands. But, at the same time, it must be remembered that this is a rule of vital importance in the field of administrative law and it must not be jettisoned save in very exceptional circumstances where compulsive necessity so demands. [21] Mr. Aditya Mishra, another learned counsel for the petitioners also referred to paragraph No.13 of Tanmoy Nath’s case. In that paragraph, basically the Court referred to a decision of the Apex Court rendered in State of Orissa and another vs. Mamata Mohanty, (2011) 3 SCC 436, wherein the Hon‟ble Supreme Court stressed upon the excellence of the teaching staff and that they should possess a good academic record/minimum qualification prescribed as eligibility. [22] Mr. Abheek Saha, learned counsel for the petitioners in WP(C) No.57 of 2025 submits that the judgment of Tanmoy Nath’s case was not in rem and therefore was not binding on the petitioners. He also refers to Section 35 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 which basically deals with the relevance of certain judgments of a competent Court or Tribunal in the exercise of probate, matrimonial, admiralty or insolvency jurisdiction. Therefore, that provision being rule of evidence cannot be applied in the present contexts. Mr. Saha, learned counsel also argues that petitioners were not made party in Tanmoy Nath’s case resorting to the provision of Order I rule 10 CPC and therefore, on that ground also said decision would not be binding on them. [23] Mr. Saha, learned counsel relies on the following decisions: (i) Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited vs. Ghanshyam Dass (2) and others, (2011) 4 SCC 374- In this case, it was observed that where only the affected parties approached the Court and relief was granted to those parties, the fence-sitters who did not approach the Court cannot claim that such relief should have been extended to them, thereby upsetting or interfering with the rights that had accrued to others. (ii) State of Uttar Pradesh and others vs. Arvind Kumar Srivastava and others, (2015) 1 SCC 347- At paragraph nos. 22.2 and 22.3, it is observed that those persons who challenge the wrongful action in their cases and acquiesced into the same and woke up after long delay only because of the reason that their counterparts who had approached the court earlier in time succeeded in thier efforts, then such employees cannot claim that the benefit of the judgment rendered in the case of similarly situated persons be extended to them. However, this exception may not apply in those cases where the judgment pronounced by the court was a judgment in rem with the intention to give benefit to all similarly situated persons, whether they approached the court or not. It is further observed that if the judgment of the Court is in personam holding that benefit of the said judgment shall accrue to the parties before the Court and such an intention is stated expressly in the judgment or it can be impliedly found out from the tenor and language of the judgment, those who want to get the benefit of the said judgment extended to them shall have to satisfy that their petition does not suffer from either laches and delays or acquiescence. Mr. Saha, learned counsel also submits that there must be some reasoned order of the authority before terminating the present petitioners from the service which was lacking in the impugned termination letter. (iii) Constitution Bench decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India and another vs. Tulsiram Patel, (1985) 3 SCC 398, as referred by Mr. Saha, it is held that the second condition necessary for the valid application of clause (b) of the second proviso of Article 311 of the Constitution is that the disciplinary authority should record in writing its reason for its satisfaction that it was not reasonably practicable to hold the inquiry contemplated by Article 311(2). (iv) Sukhdev Singh vs. Union of India and others, (2013) 9 SCC 566- In this case, reference was made to another decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Dev Dutt vs. Union of India, (2008) 8 SCC 725, wherein it was held that non-communication of entries in the Annual Confidential Report of a public servant would be arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. This citation appears to be totally misplaced by the petitioners. (v) Managing Director, ECIL, Hyderabad and others vs. B. Karunakar and others, (1993) 4 SCC 727- In the context of departmental proceedings and imposition of penalty, it was held that proceedings must be just, fair and reasonable and negation thereof would offend Articles 14 and 21 and that the principles of natural justice shall have to be followed. No decision prejudicial to a party should be taken without affording an opportunity or supplying the material which is the basis for the decision. It was also observed that the enquiry report constitutes fresh material which has great persuasive force or effect on the mind of the disciplinary authority. (vi) Bilaspur Raipur Kshetriya Gramin Bank and another vs. Madanlal Tandon, (2015) 8 SCC 461- In this case, the copy of list of witnesses and the list of documents were not supplied to the delinquent in the departmental proceeding and the High Court quashed the order of removal. The Division Bench thereafter observed that although the show cause notice was served along with seventeen charges, no document was supplied along with the show cause notice to the delinquent. The Apex Court in that context did not differ with the decision of the High Court. (vii) Deepak Ananda Patil vs. the State of Maharashtra and others, 2023 INSC 11- In this case, it is observed that an adjudicatory body cannot base its decision on any material unless the person against whom it is sought to be utilized has been apprised of it and given an opportunity to respond to it. (viii) Smt. Bijaya Bhattacharya vs. the State of Tripura and others [WP(C) No.172 of 2015 decided analogously with some other writ petitions on 26.02.2016 by this Court]- Said case was relating to a dispute regarding recruitment of Assistant Professor wherein it was observed that in case the State decided to reserve any post, then de-reservation and reservation should clearly be made subject-wise and while doing so State shall take into consideration the number of reserved category candidates in a particular subject and if the reserved categories are sufficiently represented, then there can be no reservation in that subject. Said judgment was also passed by the High Court completely in a different context. (ix) Mr. M. Manju Prasad vs. State of Karnataka, by its Chief Secretary and others, ILR 2023 KAR 3869- The relevant portion of the judgment of the Apex Court in Dilbagh Rai Jarry vs. Union of India and others, (1974) 3 SCC 554, as referred by Mr. Saha, observes that the State is not an ordinary party trying to win a case against one of its own citizens by hook or by crook; for the State‟s interest is to meet honest claims, vindicate a substantial defence and never to score a technical point or overreach a weaker party to avoid a just liability or secure an unfair advantage, simply because legal devices provide such an opportunity. (x) Sundeep Kumar Bafna vs. State of Maharashtra and another, (2014) 16 SCC 623- In relevant paragraph No.19 as relied on by Mr. Saha, learned counsel, it is observed by the Apex Court that a decision or judgment can be per incuriam any provision in a statute, rule or regulation, which was not brought to the notice of the Court and a decision or judgment can also be per incuriam if it is not possible to reconcile its ratio with that of a previously pronounced judgment of a co-equal or larger Bench; or if the decision of the High Court is not in consonance with the views of the Apex Court. Learned counsel relies on this judgment to buttress his submission that the issues raised in the present writ petition were not raised and discussed in the decision of Full Bench of this Court in case of Pranab Deb vs. the State of Tripura and others [WP(C) No.893 of 2022] and therefore, said judgment is not binding on this Court. [24] Finally, referring to a part of Lok Sabha debate of the year 2009 wherein one of the then MP from Tripura addressed the House on the need for establishment of a separate High Court in Tripura considering the geographical condition of the State that it was in the remote corner of North-East region and access to Guwahati was extremely difficult for common people. Mr. Saha, learned counsel submits that in such a remotest corner of the country, termination of poor employees from the service was too harsh. [25] Mr. A L Saha, learned counsel in WP(C) No.699 of 2024 mainly argues that service condition of the petitioners are governed by Articles 309, 310 and 311 of the Constitution and without following the procedure as laid down in the CCS (CCA) Rules, an employee cannot be terminated; otherwise, it would be violative of Article 21 of the Constitution. Mr. AL Saha, learned counsel also submits that conversion of the petitioners from regular employment to ad-hoc employment itself was a punishment and therefore, before doing so, Rule 11 of CCS (CCA) Rules ought to have been applied by the State. However, on query by the Court, learned counsel fairly submits that such plea was not taken in the writ petition. [26] Learned counsel also refers to the relevant part of the draft Constitution containing the debate portion wherein Sri Brajeshwar Prasad, during discussion, expresses that there should be some authority in the State to dismiss a public servant if a civil servant is found guilty and if the authority is convinced that he is a fifth columnist and that it is not desirable to keep him in service. But there should not be so many authorities vested with this power and the President alone should be empowered with this power. This reference does not show any relevancy with the present controversies in hand. [27] His next point of argument is that quasi-judicial authorities are required to follow the principles of natural justice and there should be a reasoned order passed by such authority. According to learned counsel, both in the case of lowering the petitioners to the status of ad-hoc employee and also at the time of final termination, no notice was issued to the petitioners and the provision of Article 311 was also not followed. Even the respondents have not furnished any information to the petitioners as to by which procedure and under what authority they were terminated from the service. [28] Learned counsel also relies on a decision of Constitution Bench in case of Collector of Monghyr and others etc. vs. Keshav Prasad Goenka and others etc., 1962 SCC OnLine SC 93. This case was basically relating to the construction of Section 5-A of the Bihar Private Irrigation Works Act, 1922. Sub-section (1) of Section 5-A provides that notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in the Act, whenever the Collector, for reasons to be recorded by him, is of opinion that the delay in the repair of any existing irrigation work which may be occasioned by proceedings commenced by a notice under Section 3 adversely affects or is likely to affect adversely lands which are dependent on such irrigation work for a supply of water, he may forthwith cause the repair of such irrigation work to be begun by any one or more of the persons mentioned in clause (ii) of Section 3 or by such agency as he thinks proper. In that context, the Apex Court observed that on the texture of the provision the recording of the reasons is a condition for the emergence of the power to make the order under sub-section (1). Said observation of the Apex Court is no doubt in view of the above said provision of sub-section (1) of Section 5-A of that Act. [29] Learned counsel also further relies on the following decisions: (i) Nazir Ahmad vs. King-Emperor, AIR 1936 PC 253 (2)- In this case, it was observed that where a power is given to do a certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all. (ii) State of Orissa vs. Dr. (Miss) Binapani Dei and others, 1967 SCC OnLine SC 15- In this case, it was observed that the State undoubtedly has the authority to compulsorily retire a public servant who is superannuated. But when that person disputes the claim he must be informed of the case of the State and the evidence in support thereof and he must have a fair opportunity of meeting that case before a decision adverse to him is taken. (iii) Basudev Dutta vs. the State of West Bengal and others, 2024 INSC 940- In this case at paragraph No.12.5 as relied on by learned counsel, reference was made to another decision of the Apex Court in the case of Aureliano Fernandes vs. State of Goa, (2024) 1 SCC 632, and in said case at paragraph No.73 it was observed that even when the rules are silent, principles of natural justice must be read into them. (iv) H.L. Trehan and others vs. Union of India (UOI) and others, (1989) 1 SCC 764- In this case, it has been held that post-decisional opportunity of hearing does not subserve the rules of natural justice. The authority who embarks upon a post-decisional hearing will naturally proceed with a closed mind and there is hardly any chance of getting a proper consideration of the representation at such a post-decisional opportunity. (v) Union of India and another vs. Tulsiram Patel, AIR 1985 SC 1416- The Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in this case observed that the pleasure doctrine embodied in Article 310(1), the protection afforded to civil servants by clauses (1) and (2) of Article 311 and the withdrawal of the protection under clause (2) of Article 311 by the second proviso thereto are all provided in the Constitution on the ground of public policy and in the public interest and are for public good. It was also observed that livelihood of an individual is a matter of great concern to him and his family but his livelihood is a matter of his private interest and where such livelihood is provided by the public exchequer and the taking away of such livelihood is in the public interest and for public good, the former must yield to the latter. These consequences follow not because the pleasure doctrine is a special prerogative of the British Crown which has been inherited by India and transposed into the Constitution but because public policy requires, public interest needs and public good demands that there should be such a doctrine. (vi) Msr. Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of India and another, AIR 1978 SC 597 (Para 56)- Mr. A. L . Saha also relies on this deicision again to the observations of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court that the principle of reasonableness which legally as well as philosophically is an essential element of equality or non-arbitrariness pervades Article 14 like a brooding omnipresence and the procedure contemplated by Article 21 must answer the test of reasonableness in order to be in conformity with Article 14. It must be "right and just and fair" and not arbitrary, fanciful or oppressive; otherwise, it would be no procedure at all and the requirement of Article 21 would not be satisfied. SUBMISSIONS FROM THE SIDE OF RESPONDENTS [30] Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. submits that despite advertisements issued on 29.10.2002 and 05.04.2006, no selection was held following those advertisements, rather the recruitment was made on the basis of advertisement issued on 23.09.2009 whereby the applications submitted in pursuance of the previous two advertisements of the year 2002 and 2006 were also taken up together. He argues that all the questions raised by the present petitioners in the above said three writ petitions are already discussed and decided in previous two judgments of the High Court and therefore, now these controversies cannot be re-opened again. Learned Addl. G.A. in this regard relies on a decision of the Division Bench of this Court rendered in Sri Bijoy Krishna Saha & others vs. the State of Tripura and others [WP(C) No.1040 of 2019 decided analogously with a bunch of other writ petitions on 03.10.2019] and the decision of the Full Bench of this High Court dated

26.09.2023 in the case of Sri Pranab Deb (Supra). [31] In reply to said argument, Mr. T.K. Nayak, learned counsel submits that the above said two decisions of this Court will not constitute res judicata as the petitioners earlier filed a petition under Article 32 before the Apex Court and as per liberty granted by the Apex Court, WP(C) No.592 of 2024 was filed and moreover, the parties of the present petitions were also not party in those cases and the issues raised are also not common. ANALYSIS & DECISION [32] In consideration of the submissions made by both sides and materials placed on records by the parties, the points of challenges as placed by the petitioners in these writ petitions and as indicated in paragraph No.11 above are being taken up one by one for discussions and decisions. [32.1] The point raised by the petitioners that they are not covered by the decision of Tanmoy Nath’s case is being examined first. It is their specific plea that they were recruited following the Recruitment Rules of the State Government issued vide notification No.F.25(1)-E/70(EC) dated

26.01.1971 and not as per Recruitment Policy framed by the State Government in the year 2003 and therefore, the decision of Tanmoy Nath’s case is not applicable in their cases. Said Recruitment Rules of 1971 are placed at Annexure 1 in the lead case which basically mentions the desired educational and other qualifications and age limit for direct recruitment for the posts of Assistant Teachers, Secondary Schools. Details of the manner of such recruitment are not enumerated therein. The revised employment policy framed by the State of Tripura (as reproduced in Tanmoy Nath’s case) demonstrates that certain general instructions were laid down therein by the State regarding the age limit, reservation policy for Scheduled Tribes and Scheduled Castes, Physically Handicapped Persons and Ex-servicemen Category including guidelines for the appointment of dependents of retired Government servant, defence personnel, retrenched employee, Other Backward Community, Minority etc. [32.2] In WP(C) No.592 of 2024, the petitioners have categorically stated that they applied for the post of Post Graduate Teacher under advertisement dated 23.09.2009 (Annexure 3 of the lead case). In WP(C) No.699 of 2024, it is also the assertion of the petitioners that they applied for the post of Under Graduate Teachers under said advertisement dated

23.09.2009 and in WP(C) No.57 of 2025 it is the claimed by the petitioners that pursuant to advertisements dated 29.10.2002, dated 05.04.2006 and lastly, dated 23.09.2009 published by the State Government, they applied for the posts of Graduate Teacher. They placed those advertisements at Annexure 2 of their writ petitions. It is also the case of the petitioners of all the present writ petitions that on being selected, they were issued with an offer of appointment and accordingly, they joined in the service. Now, on perusal of the judgment passed in said Tanmoy Nath’s case (Annexure 6 of the lead case), it appears that the selection of Under Graduate, Graduate and Post Graduate Teachers pursuant to advertisements issued on 29.10.2002,

05.04.2006 and 23.09.2009 was under challenge in the said bunch of writ petitions and after thorough examination of said Recruitment Policy of 2003 as well as the selection processes, High Court held that the selections were totally unfair and were not made in a transparent manner and most of the clauses of the policy of 2003 were illegal and unconstitutional and further, entire policy was held to be vague. [32.3] In said judgment of Tanmoy Nath’s case, the entire selection process in respect of said three advertisements was set aside and the State Government was directed to complete a fresh process of selection of teachers in all categories on or before 31.12.2014 by framing the new employment policy within two months therefrom, and in case the State did not frame any guidelines, then some guidelines were also issued by the High Court to be followed in the fresh selection. Therefore, the position is very clear that the selections made pursuant to the above said three advertisements whereby the petitioners appointed, were set aside and therefore, without the least hesitation, it can be said that the judgment passed in Tanmoy Nath’s case and as was affirmed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.18993-19049/2014 (Annexure 9 of the lead case) are applicable in the cases of present petitioners and therefore, the ground raised by the petitioners that they were not recruited by the policy of 2003 is also not acceptable. Hon‟ble Supreme Court in said Special Leave Petitions however, modified the directions of the High Court contained in paragraph No.123 of the judgment of Tanmoy Nath’s case in the terms as already extracted in paragraph No. 11 above with a direction to the State to complete the fresh selection process on or before 31st December, 2017 and meanwhile, the teachers already appointed were allowed to continue. [32.4] After said judgment passed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court on

29.03.2017 and subsequent order passed on 14.12.2017, the State Government issued a memorandum dated 23.12.2017 (Annexure 10 of the lead case) wherein it was stated that the tenure of the incumbents will come to an end on

31.12.2017 terminating the service of all the persons who were covered by the decision of Tanmoy Nath’s case, and accordingly their services including the services of the petitioners were terminated w.e.f. 31.12.2017. Thereafter, in terms of the order of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court dated 14.12.2017, they were again appointed on ad-hoc basis for a period of six months w.e.f. 01.01.2018 vide memorandum dated 23.12.2017. Thereafter, as permitted by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, their ad-hoc appointment services were allowed to be continued till 31.03.2020 and finally, their such ad-hoc services were also terminated vide memorandum dated 31.03.2020 (Annexure 11 of the lead case) in respect of Post Graduate Teachers, vide memorandum dated

31.03.2020 [Annexure 11 of WP(C) No.699 of 2024] in respect of Under Graduate Teachers and vide memorandum dated 31.03.2020 [Annexure 8 of WP(C) No.57 of 2025] in respect of Graduate Teachers. [32.5] Mr. T.K. Nayak, learned counsel, submitted that the post Graduate Teachers were appointed vide policy bearing No.F.10(2)- FIN(G)/05/Part-1 dated 16.10.2007 (Annexure 2 of the lead case) but said policy is not at all an employment policy. It was a policy decision of the State Government regarding recruitment of Group C and Group D employees on fixed pay basis by keeping in abeyance the regular pay scale posts as a matter of cost-cutting method. In said notification, it is indicated that those employees would be first placed on fixed pay for five years and thereafter regular pay scale would be provided to them and during their period of fixed pay, they would also be provided with certain benefits like leave, seniority, coverage under die-in-harness scheme etc. Said notification has no relation with Recruitment Policy of the State and therefore, such claim of the petitioners that they were recruited vide policy of the State Government dated

16.10.2007, is also not tenable. [32.6] On behalf of the petitioners, it was also argued that though public notice under Order I rule 8 CPC in two newspapers was published in Tanmoy Nath’s case but as the petitioners were recruited following a different Recruitment Policy, they were not concerned with said public notice but such a plea is also incomprehensible in view of the discussions made above. If, despite such public notice, they did not deem it necessary to contest said writ petitions, the decisions rendered therein are obviously binding on them now. [32.7] As to the claim of the petitioners, regarding the inapplicability of Recruitment Policy of 2003, it has also been argued that the Recruitment Policy of 2003 was not published in the advertisements issued by the State respondents and even in the appointment order of the petitioners also there was no mention of any such policy and therefore, said policy was not applicable in the cases of the present petitioners. Moreover, existence of said policy itself was questionable. It is also argued that said policy was issued under the nomenclature „memorandum‟ and therefore, it was a draft policy and not the final policy decision of the Government, and further that said policy was also not published by the Government for general information. Answer to the above said challenges, firstly, is that challenge to said Recruitment Policy of 2003 was the subject matter of Tanmoy Nath’s case wherein despite issuance of public notice, the petitioners did not appear and participate. Therefore, in a subsequent collateral proceedings they cannot challenge the same inasmuch as the decision of the High Court has reached the finality up to the Apex level. Secondly; that, while deciding Tanmoy Nath’s case, the Division Bench of the High Court had taken into consideration the fact that said policy was never published by the State for general information of the public and was an inter-departmental communication and finally, decided that petitioners of that cases had the right to challenge it. The relevant paragraph No.36 of Tanmoy Nath’s case is extracted hereunder: “36. As far as the policy is concerned, despite our specific questions, the State has failed to show that the employment policy was ever published in the gazette. The employment policy was not even referred to in any of the advertisements issued in the year 2002, 2006 and 2009. How can poor unemployed persons be aware of an employment policy which was never made public? It was only an inter- departmental communication. Therefore, the petitioners cannot be debarred from laying challenge to the revised employment policy.” The contention that the nomenclature was “memorandum” which does not include final decision of the State authority, is too technical to accept. The policy, by whichever name it is referred such as memorandum, notification, office order etc., in fact was implemented by the State while initiating the process of selection of the present petitioners and other similarly situated persons who were recruited following the advertisements issued in the years 2002, 2006 and 2009, therefore, embossing the name „memorandum‟ in the said policy will not make any difference. Moreover, present challenge regarding applicability of 2003 policy in the said selection processes on the ground of its non-publication cannot be reopended in the present writ petitions as the policy has already been declared ultra vires by judicial pronouncement and such pronouncement has already reached finality. [32.8] In Para 127 of Tanmoy Nath’s case, it was observed by the Division Bench that the revised employment policy applied to a large category of posts and not merely to the teachers, still all the appointments already made following said policy were saved except those which were under challenge in Tanmoy Nath’s case. It was also clarified that the judgment would be applicable prospectively. This way the Court protected the other selection processes of other Departments or even of Education Department unless those were under challenge in Tanmoy Nath’s case. It was already discussed earlier that the challenge was made before the High Court in said case only with respect to the selection of Under Graduate, Graduate and Post Graduate Teachers recruited following the advertisements of 2002, 2006 and 2009 and therefore, the appointments of present petitioners and other similarly situated persons were subject matter of challenge in Tanmoy Nath’s case. Thus, the claim of the present petitioners regarding protection under the umbrella of paragraph No.127 in Tanmoy Nath’s case is also not sustainable. Similarly, the petitioners, though raised the plea that as their services were regularized their selections and appointments were not under challenge in Tanmoy Nath’s case, is also not acceptable. [32.9] In paragraph No.121 of Tanmoy Nath’s case, it was clearly observed that the selections of those three categories of teachers were totally unfair and were not made in a transparent manner. Most of the clauses of the policy were illegal and unconstitutional and the entire policy was vague, as it did not provide any guideline and consequently the entire selection process was set aside. [32.10] In paragraph No.122 also, the Court concerning the education of small children directed that the teachers whose selections were set aside should continue to function in their present place of posting till 31.12.2014. In fact, this is the initial direction of the Court following which the State re- appointed the petitioners and other similarly situated persons again on ad-hoc basis. Hon‟ble Supreme Court also from time to time extended the said period of such ad-hoc employment till 31.03.2020 as already indicated above. But surprisingly, after termination of their regular services on 31.12.2017, the present petitioners never challenged the same earlier till the present writ petitions are filed by them after 6/7 years of their termination. Even, despite public notice issued in Tanmoy Nath’s case, none of them appeared there to contest the same. When thereafter the matter was pending before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court also, they did not try to intervene. Rather, they acquiesced to continue with their ad-hoc appointment without raising any grievance. Therefore the petitions are now hopelessly barred by the principle of delay and laches. Though some of them filed WP(s)(Civil) Nos. 177 of 2024 before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court same was also withdrawn by them on 19.03.2024. Said petition was also filed at a belated stage. [32.11] Now the challenges of the petitioners on the ground of violation of Article 311 of the Constitution by not following the procedure as provided under CCS (CCA) Rules are being examined. It has been strenuously argued by Mr. AL Saha and Mr. Abheek Saha, learned counsel that termination of the services of the petitioners was without following the provision of Article 311 of the Constitution and the provisions of CCS (CCA) Rules, and therefore, such terminations were illegal and ultra vires. It was also submitted by them that before their termination, no notice was issued to them giving them the opportunity to place their representation and to take proper defence in this regard. These points as raised are totally misconceived and moreover, these were already decided by this Court earlier, at least in two judgments passed by the Benches of higher strength. [32.12] In fact, the termination of the petitioners from service is nothing but compliance with directions of the High Court and the Hon‟ble Supreme Court. Their termination was not on the ground of any misconduct or any conviction in criminal case. Therefore, there is no applicability of Article 311 of the Constitution or the provisions of CCS (CCA) Rules in the present cases. There were no charges of any misconduct or of commission of any crime by any of them. Therefore, all the decisions as referred to by both Mr. AL Saha and Mr. Abheek Saha, learned counsel in relation to this point of challenge, have no application in the present cases. Article 311(2) specifically mentions the word “charges” and cast a duty on the disciplinary authority to inform the delinquent about the charge and to provide him reasonable opportunity of being heard in respect of those charges. As discussed above, the present cases are not related to any such charge(s) framed against the petitioners. [32.13] It has been held by judicial pronouncement in Tanmoy Nath’s case that the entire selection process itself was unfair and, therefore, such process was set aside. Earlier total 85 nos. of writ petitions were taken up by the Division Bench of this Court under the title “Sri Bijoy Krishna Saha and others vs. the State of Tripura and others, [WP(C) 1040 of 2019 decided analogously with 84 other cases on 03.10.2019]” wherein similarly situtated persons like present petitioners whose services were also terminated, challenged such termination, inter alia, on the ground that they were not party in Tanmoy Nath’s case; that their services were protected in view of the observation made in Para 127 of the said judgment; that notice published under Order I rule 8, CPC in Tanmoy Nath’s case was not binding on them; and that no notice was issued to them before their termination. The Division Bench of the Court dismissed said writ petitions as being devoid of merit. The relevant paragraphs No.16 to 20 containing discussions and findings of the Division Bench, are relevantly extracted hereunder: “16. The core issue which arises for consideration is as to whether the instant writ petitioner(s) can be allowed to reopen the issues decided by this Court in Tanmay Nath (supra), as affirmed by the Apex Court vide order dated 29.03.2017 on the ground that; (a) this termination is illegal on account of violation of principles of natural justice, inasmuch as no notice stood issued to them, nor were they impleaded as parties to such proceedings; (b) the services of the petitioners stand protected by and in terms of the directions contained in para-127 of the very judgment; (c) whether the impugned memorandum extending the period of services on ad-hoc basis and rejecting the representations should be quashed or not. In WP(C) No.51 of 2014, titled as Tanmoy Nath 17. (supra), the Court vide order dated 06.02.2014 had directed issuance of a public notice since large number of parties (4000) were likely to be affected. Pursuant thereto, notices dated 21.02.2014 were issued in two newspapers namely, Dainik Sambad and Daily Desher Katha respectively. During the pendency of the hearing, we had called for the record of WP(C) No.208 of 2010, titled as Shri Sudhan Majumder & others vs. The State of Tripura & others, also disposed of with Tanmoy Nath (supra), and noticed that public notice dated 08.12.2010 was issued in the daily newspaper namely “Syandan Patrika” informing the general public of the pendency of the petitions and the Court dealing with the matters with regard to the appointment of graduate teachers. Also there is an order dated 24.11.2010 in C.M. Appl. No.223/2010 in c/w WP(C) No.208 of 2010 to such an effect.

18. As such, at this stage, instant writ petitioners cannot be allowed to reopen the entire issue, purely on the ground of their non-impleadment as parties or non-issuance of notice to them. Who are the petitioners? Are they illiterate rustic villagers, hailing from the most deprived strata of the society having no access to justice, also not knowing its procedures? Most certainly not. They are educated Government employees posted at several places within the State. Can it be said that they were not aware of the proceedings laying challenge to the appointments made with regard to more than 10,000 posts of different categories of teachers appointed by the Government, pursuant to the advertisement issued in the year 2002, 2006 and 2009? The answer obviously lies in the negative and the reason is two- fold. The pendency of the original writ petitions was widely circulated, as we are informed, throughout the State, both in the print and electronic media. So also was its outcome made known. It sent ripples throughout the State. Not only that, prior to rendering of the judgment in Tanmay Nath (supra), this Court had directed issuance of notice to be published in the newspaper, which was also done. To contend that such directions or notice were confined only with respect to certain category of teachers and as such, cannot be construed to be a notice qua other categories is not acceptable. Teachers in Tripura are a close-knit fraternity. They also have a union who has been pursuing the matter at different levels. It is true that in a service matter, principles laid down under Order I Rule 8 of CPC may not apply, but then this Court was dealing with a case where as it stood observed, that the action of the Government was “a cruel joke on the people of Tripura”. The entire selection process was held to be absolutely arbitrary, capricious and whimsical. It smacked of nothing less than nepotism and favourism. Prudently, the writ Court thought it fit to issue a general notice and not implead all of the 10,323 selected candidates as party respondents, some of whom, in any case, were before this Court. In a representative capacity, the petitions were considered, argued and decided.

19. Significantly, none of the instant petitioners laid any challenge to the judgment rendered by this Court in Tanmay Nath (supra). Neither did they seek review, nor did they file any appeal. Why so? remains a shrouded secret. With the dismissal of the Special Leave Petition on 29.03.2017, and their appointment conclusively found to be illegal, they ought to have returned home, but for the extensions granted by the Apex Court vide orders dated 14.12.2017 and 01.11.2018 (reproduced supra) [paras-9 & 10]. Even at that point in time, they did not express their concern or raise any protest of violation of principles of natural justice; the issue of their non-impleadment or of the order passed behind their back. It is not that they were sitting in a penance or meditating in the Himalayas, totally cut off from the worldly affairs. Obviously they were waiting in the wings and only when they fell out favour of a lady fortune, inasmuch as time extended by the Apex Court is expiring, and otherwise not having qualified, they took steps, speculative in nature, of issue reopened by challenging the having the entire judgment of this Court in Tanmay Nath (supra). We find their such act and conduct to be absolutely despicable. By raising one false plea after the other, somehow they are just trying to cling to the post, to which they were illegally appointed and thereby scuttle the due process of fresh selection and appointment wrongfully depriving the eligible candidates. in the absence of the

20. Contention that instant petitioners impleaded as parties in the petitions subject matter of Tanmoy Nath (supra), this Court should direct continuance of their appointment, more so, in the light of ratio laid down in Udit Narain Singh Malpaharia (supra), A.M.S. Sushanth (supra), A. Arthur Jeen (supra), K.H. Siraj (supra), Rashmi Mishra (supra), Sadananda Halo (supra), Suresh (supra), Tridip Kumar Dingal (supra), Poonam (supra), Ranjan Kumar (supra), Vijay Kumar Kaul (supra), and Jal Mahal Resorts (supra), is absolutely fallacious. At this point in time, it is not open for the respondents to take such a plea, more so when everyone was made aware of the proceedings pending before this Court, by way of public notice. In the cited decisions, what weighed was interest of an individual and not general public interest, in formulating a policy which was held to be illegal so also appointments made thereunder.” [32.14] Among several writ petitions filed by many other such terminated teachers, in one writ petition bearing No. WP(C) 334 of 2021, a Coordinate Bench of this Court (Single Bench) set aside the memorandum issued by the State Govt. terminating the services of the petitioner(s) of said case on the ground that it was a non-speaking order, and therefore, Court directed the respondents to pass a reasoned and specific order in the subject matter relating to the petitioner. Subsequently, the State filed a review petition against the same in the Court and the said Bench disposed of the said review petition only by clarifying that Government had the liberty to issue a specific and reasoned order to the petitioners regarding their termination. Thereafter, another writ petition bearing No.WP(C) 893 of 2022 was filed similarly challenging the termination of petitioner(s) of that case and another Coordinate Bench (Single Bench) differed with the decision rendered in said WP(C) No.334 of 2021 and referred the matter for decision by the larger Bench. Accordingly, a Full Bench was constituted by Hon‟ble the Chief Justice and the matter was decided in Pranab Deb vs. the State of Tripura and others, WP(C) No.893 of 2022 on 26.09.2023. While deciding the matter, the Full Bench also observed that the services of the petitioners were not terminated on the charges of misconduct and, therefore, Article 311 had no application. The Full Bench further observed that when the Court had directed the State to frame a fresh employment policy and to conduct the fresh selection process after giving age relaxation to the appointees whose services were terminated, it could not be said that the termination orders were suffering from a violation of principles of natural justice. While concluding that there was no reason to interfere with such terminations, the Full Bench further observed the followings in paragraphs No.24 to 27: “[24] That apart, it is now well settled that “if the mischief played is so widespread and all pervasive, affecting the result so as to make it difficult to pick out the persons who have been unlawfully benefitted or wrongfully deprived of their selection, it will neither be possible nor necessary to issue individual show-cause notice to each selectee. The only way out would be to cancel the whole selection.” It is also settled “when the entire selection is stinking, conceived in fraud and delivered in deceit, individual innocence has no place and the entire selection has to be set aside.” [Ref: MP State Cooperative Bank Limited, Bhopal Vs. Nanuram Jadhav & Ors, (2007) 8 SCC 264]. is not a [25] Besides, principle of natural straightjacket formula. It depends upon various facets in the administration of justice and it is established that there is justice exception to rules of natural justice. The present case falls within such exception where rules of natural justice would not be applicable because of large scale corruption, favouritism, nepotism and arbitrariness found in the entire selection process. The entire selection process was vitiated by fraud and arbitrariness which has already been declared illegal and appointments of the persons so selected were terminated. [emphasis supplied] [26] The appointments of the petitioners and other teachers were vitiated from the very inception which resulted in the issuance of their termination orders and in that case, the principles of natural justice were not violated, if no opportunity was given to the employees concerned to have their say in the matter before their appointments were recalled and terminated. [27] As an upshot of the above discussions and the reasons recorded, we are of the unanimous view that no interference is called for in the impugned orders whereby the services of the petitioners have been terminated. The reference is answered accordingly. The instant writ petition is dismissed with a cost of Rs.25,000/- to be deposited in the Tripura State Legal Services Authority.” (Emphasis underscored) [32.15] As it appears, Mr. AL Saha, learned Counsel himself was the engaged advocate representing the petitioners in that case and these issues as raised in these present writ petitions, are also settled by the Full Bench. Thus, reopening these issues once more is not permissible. Though it is submitted from the side of the petitioners that the decision of the Full Bench has been challenged before the Apex Court, simultaneously, it is also submitted by learned counsel that no stay order has been passed in respect of said judgment. [32.16] It is also argued on behalf of the petitioners that decisions of Division Bench in Bijoy Krishna Saha (Supra) and of Full Bench in Pranab Deb (supra) do not form res judicata as the present petitioners were not party in those cases. Such submission is also totally unacceptable, for, it is not the principle of res judicata, rather the rule of precedent which is applicable in the present cases. When similar and identical issue(s) is/are decided by a Bench of higher strength, the same is binding on a Bench of lower strength as a matter of judicial discipline. [32.17] Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Bharat Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. vs. Mumbai Shramik Sangha and others, (2001) 4 SCC 448 observed that a decision of a Constitution Bench of said Court binds a Bench of two learned Judges of that Court and that judicial discipline obliges them to follow it, regardless of their doubts about its correctness. In Royal Orchid Hotels Limited and another vs. G. Jayarama Reddy and others, (2011) 10 SCC 608 also, it has been observed that a Single Bench is bound by the judgment of the Division Bench. Thereafter, in Official Liquidator vs. Dayanand and others, (2008) 10 SCC 1, as a matter of further caution, the following were observed by Hon‟ble Supreme Court: “90. We are distressed to note that despite several pronouncements on the subject, there is substantial increase in the number of cases involving violation of the basics of judicial discipline. The learned Single Judges and Benches of the High Courts refuse to follow and accept the verdict and law laid down by coordinate and even larger Benches by citing minor difference in the facts as the ground for doing so. Therefore, it has become necessary to reiterate that disrespect to the constitutional ethos and breach of discipline have grave impact on the credibility of judicial institution and encourages chance litigation. It must be remembered that predictability and certainty is an important hallmark of judicial jurisprudence developed in this country in the last six decades and increase in the frequency of conflicting judgments of the superior judiciary will do incalculable harm to the system inasmuch as the courts at the grass roots will not be able to decide as to which of the judgments lay down the correct law and which one should be followed.” Again in Shashikala and others vs. Gangalakshmamma and another, (2015) 9 SCC 150, the Apex Court referred to the decision of Bharat Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. (supra) to the effect that the rule of “judicial discipline and propriety” as well as the theory of precedents, permits only a Bench of the same quorum to question the correctness of the decision by another Bench of coordinate strength upon which the matter can be placed for consideration by a Bench of larger quorum and that a Bench of lesser quorum cannot thus express disagreement with, or question the correctness of, the view of a Bench of a larger quorum. Therefore, the plea that the petitioners were not a party in said two cases and therefore, the same did not form res judicata, is not at all sustainable. [33] In the light of discussions made in the foregoing paragraphs, it appears that after their termination from services, many of such terminated teachers, either in a group or singly have been trying to reopen the matter as test litigations which have already been decided in Tanmoy Nath’s case and affirmed by the Apex Court, on similar and identical grounds which are also later on decided by the Division Bench and Full Bench of this Court. Such attempts are nothing but abuse of process and wastage of valuable time of the Court. Therefore, the writ petitions are required to be dismissed with heavy costs. Anyway, only considering the facts that the petitioners have already lost their jobs and are under mental strain and suffering, minimal costs are being imposed on them. In the result, all three writ petitions are dismissed being devoid of any merit with costs of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) in each case. The petitioners shall deposit said amount of costs to the Tripura State Legal Services Authority (TSLSA). The TSLSA will expend these amounts only on the programmes relating to the welfare and protection of children and for the matters relating to the elimination of drug abuse. With such observations and decisions, the writ petitions are disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. JUDGE Rudradeep RUDRADEEP BANERJEE Digitally signed by RUDRADEEP BANERJEE

Find similar cases Start drafting free

This is the original judgment text as indexed from the source corpus. Always verify against the official court record before relying on it in a filing — you can do so on eCourts or the Supreme Court of India website. ← Search more judgments

More cases under A of the Bihar Private Irrigation Works Act 1922