Jiwan Dass v. Naresh Gupta & Anr.

Smt. Kamal Kanta and others

34. R.F.A No. 595 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Madan Lal and another

35. R.F.A No. 596 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Mohan Lal and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (6)

36. R.F.A No. 597 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Pritam Singh and another

37. R.F.A No. 598 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Raj Kumar and others

38. R.F.A No. 599 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ram Bhaj and another

39. R.F.A No.600 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Dhoop Singh and another

40. R.F.A No. 601 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Raj Kumar and another

41. R.F.A No. 602 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Mani Ram and another

42. R.F.A No. 603 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Mohan Singh and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (7)

43. R.F.A No. 604 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Naresh Kumar

44. R.F.A No. 605 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Manoj Kumar and others

45. R.F.A No. 606 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Pushpa Rani and others

46. R.F.A No. 616 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Pawan Kumar and another

47. R.F.A No. 617 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Hawa Singh and another

48. R.F.A No. 618 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kitab Singh and another

49. R.F.A No. 619 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Charan Dass and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants .....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (8)

50. R.F.A No. 620 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Santosh Rani and others

51. R.F.A No. 621 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Roop Lal Passi and another

52. R.F.A No. 622 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Saroj and another

53. R.F.A No. 623 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Naveen Kumar and another

54. R.F.A No. 624 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Om Pati and another

55. R.F.A No. 625 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Karam Singh and others

56. R.F.A No. 626 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Randhir Singh and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (9)

57. R.F.A No. 627 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Om Parkash and another

58. R.F.A No. 628 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Satnam Singh and another

59. R.F.A No. 629 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ramesh Kumar

60. R.F.A No. 630 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Asha Rani and another

61. R.F.A No. 631 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ramesh Kumar and another

62. R.F.A No. 632 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ram Kumar and another

63. R.F.A No. 633 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Jiwan Mal and others Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (10)

64. R.F.A No. 634 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sh. Avtar Singh

65. R.F.A No. 635 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Mohan Lal and another

66. R.F.A No. 636 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Bilas Kumar and another

67. R.F.A No. 637 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Sewa Singh and others

68. R.F.A No. 638 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Jagdev and another

69. R.F.A No. 639 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Mohinder Paul Kaushik and another

70. R.F.A No. 640 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Anoop Singh and another Vs. .....Appellants .....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (11)

71. R.F.A No. 641 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Madan Lal and others

72. R.F.A No. 642 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Dalipa and another

73. R.F.A No. 643 of 2007(O&M) Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents State of Haryana and another .....Appellants Vs. Ramesh Chand and another ....Respondents

74. R.F.A No. 644 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Krishan Lal and another

75. R.F.A No. 645 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Veena and another

76. R.F.A No. 646 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Rajesh Kumar and another

77. R.F.A No. 647 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vijay Singh

78. R.F.A No. 648 of 2007(O&M) Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondent State of Haryana and another .....Appellants Vs. Kuldeep Singh and another ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (12)

79. R.F.A No. 649 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Usha Rani and another

80. R.F.A No. 650 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kabaj Ram

81. R.F.A No. 651 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Chander Pati and others

82. R.F.A No. 652 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vinod Kumar and another

83. R.F.A No. 653 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Krishana Devi and others

84. R.F.A No. 654 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Ganpati Devi and another

85. R.F.A No. 655 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Prem Chand and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (13)

86. R.F.A No. 656 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Parveen Kumari and another

87. R.F.A No. 657 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Nirmala Devi and another

88. R.F.A No. 658 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Veena Rani and another

89. R.F.A No. 659 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Naresh Kumar and another

90. R.F.A No. 660 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ram Kumar and others

91. R.F.A No. 661 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Smt. Radha Rani and others

92. R.F.A No. 662 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ish Kumar Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondent R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (14)

93. R.F.A No. 663 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Bedo and another

94. R.F.A No. 664 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Siri Chand and others

95. R.F.A No. 665 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vasdev and another

96. R.F.A No. 666 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Sunita Rani and another

97. R.F.A No. 667 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Smt Sukhwinder Kaur and another

98. R.F.A No. 668 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Raghubir Sain and another

99. R.F.A No. 669 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Mohinder Kaur and another Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (15)

100. R.F.A No. 670 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Khazan Singh and others

101. R.F.A No. 671 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Lal Chand and another

102. R.F.A No. 672 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ved Parkash and another

103. R.F.A No. 673 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Jagdish Chand and others

104. R.F.A No. 676 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ram Kumar and another

105. R.F.A No. 677 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sh. Inder Kumar

106. R.F.A No. 678 of 2007(O&M) Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondent State of Haryana and another .....Appellants Vs. Sudhir and others ....Respondents

107. R.F.A No. 679 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another .....Appellants Vs. Sarvesh Kumar Seth and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (16)

108. R.F.A No. 680 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Nafe Singh and others

109. R.F.A No. 681 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Anand Singh and another

110. R.F.A No. 683 of 2007(O&M) Pawan Kumar Seth State of Haryana and others

111. R.F.A No. 850 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sushil Kumar and another

112. R.F.A No. 851 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Manohar Lal and another

113. R.F.A No. 852 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sonu Ram and others

114. R.F.A No. 853 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sanjeev Kumar and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (17)

115. R.F.A No. 854 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ramesh Chand and another

116. R.F.A No. 855 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Santosh Sharma and another

117. R.F.A No. 856 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kulbhushan and another

118. R.F.A No. 857 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Urmila Gupta and another

119. R.F.A No. 858 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Haryana State Electricity Board Employees Co-operative House Building Society and another

120. R.F.A No. 859 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Amit Singhal and another

121. R.F.A No. 860 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Pawan Kumar and another Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (18)

122. R.F.A No. 861 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Suraj Parkash and another

123. R.F.A No. 862 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Parveen Kumar and another

124. R.F.A No. 863 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kamal Kumar and another

125. R.F.A No. 864 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ram Bahadur and another

126. R.F.A No. 865 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Siri Niwas and another

127. R.F.A No. 866 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Naveen Kumar and another

128. R.F.A No. 867 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Gian Chand and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (19)

129. R.F.A No. 868 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Bhim Singh and others

130. R.F.A No. 869 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Hoshiar Singh and others

131. R.F.A No. 870 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Pankaj Kumar and another

132. R.F.A No. 871 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Anil Kumar and another 133 R.F.A No. 872 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Subhash Chand and another 134 R.F.A No. 873 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Parmod Kumar and another 135 R.F.A No. 874 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kamla Devi and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (20) 136 R.F.A No. 875 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Suraj Parkash and another

137. R.F.A No. 876 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Darshan Kumar and another

138. R.F.A No. 877 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Arun Gupta 139 R.F.A No. 878 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Satish Kumar and another

140. R.F.A No. 879 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Aman Kumar and another 141 R.F.A No. 880 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ishwar Chand and others 142 R.F.A No. 881 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kapoor Chand and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (21)

143. R.F.A No. 882 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ashish Chaudhary and another

144. R.F.A No. 883 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Anil Kumar and another

145. R.F.A No. 884 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kuldeep Seth and others

146. R.F.A No. 885 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ajay Kumar and another

147. R.F.A No. 886 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Tarsem Kumar and another

148. R.F.A No. 887 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Siri Krishan and another

149. R.F.A No. 888 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kuldeep Kumar and others Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (22) 150 R.F.A No. 889 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Pawan Kumar and another

151. R.F.A No. 890 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Suresh Kumar and another

152. R.F.A No. 891 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Parkash Chand and another 153 R.F.A No. 892 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Mohinder Paul Kaishik and another 154 R.F.A No. 893 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Babu Ram and another 155 R.F.A No. 894 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kharaiti Lal and another 156 R.F.A No. 895 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Roshani Devi and another Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (23) 157 R.F.A No. 896 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kavita Devi and another 158 R.F.A No. 897 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Suresh Kumar and another 159 R.F.A No. 898 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ramesh Chand and another 160 R.F.A No. 899 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Uma Rani and others

161. R.F.A No. 900 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vijay Prakash and another

162. R.F.A No. 901 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vijay Kumar

163. R.F.A No. 902 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Kamlesh Rani and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (24)

164. R.F.A No. 903 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Krishan Kumar and another

165. R.F.A No. 904 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sajal Seth and others

166. R.F.A No. 905 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Jiwan Dass

167. R.F.A No. 906 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Narender Kumar

168. R.F.A No. 907 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sunita Kumari and others

169. R.F.A No. 908 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Saroop Chand and others

170. R.F.A No. 909 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sham Bahadur and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondent .....Appellants .....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (25)

171. R.F.A No. 910 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Subhash Chander

172. R.F.A No. 911 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Brij Mohan and another

173. R.F.A No. 912 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kamal Gupta and another

174. R.F.A No. 913 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Raj Kumar and another

175. R.F.A No. 914 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Balihar Singh and another

176. R.F.A No. 915 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Raj Bahadur and another

177. R.F.A No. 916 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Tarsem and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants .....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (26)

178. R.F.A No. 917 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Mangal Sain and another

179. R.F.A No. 918 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Sumitra Devi and another

180. R.F.A No. 919 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vishal Gupta and another

181. R.F.A No. 920 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Jiwna Ram and other

182. R.F.A No. 921 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ghansham Bahadur and another

183. R.F.A No. 922 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Satish Kumar and another

184. R.F.A No. 923 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Hukam Chand and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (27)

185. R.F.A No. 924 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Surinder Kumar and another

186. R.F.A No. 925 of 2007(O&M) Ilam Singh State of Haryana and other

187. R.F.A No. 926 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Prem Chand

188. R.F.A No. 927 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ashok Kumar and another

189. R.F.A No. 928 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vinod Kumar and another

190. R.F.A No. 929 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Onkar Lal and another

191. R.F.A No. 930 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Roop Chand and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellant .....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants .....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (28) 192 R.F.A No. 931 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sudesh Rani and another 193 R.F.A No. 932 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Raj Kumar and another 194 R.F.A No. 933 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Virender Kumar and another 195 R.F.A No. 934 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Saurabh and others 196 R.F.A No. 935 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ram Gopal and others 197 R.F.A No. 936 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Madan Lal and another 198 R.F.A No. 937 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Jitender Kumar and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants .....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (29) 199 R.F.A No. 938 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sham Lal Chopra and another 200 R.F.A No. 939 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Narsi Mal and another 201 R.F.A No. 940 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Dalip Chand and another 202 R.F.A No. 941 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ishwar and another 203 R.F.A No. 942 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Rajesh Kumar and another 204 R.F.A No. 943 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Gian Chand and another 205 R.F.A No. 944 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Mulak Raj and others Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (30) 206 R.F.A No. 945 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kamlesh Kumar and another 207 R.F.A No. 946 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kamal Gupta and another 208 R.F.A No. 947 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ram Kumar and another 209 R.F.A No. 948 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Makhan Lal and another 210 R.F.A No. 949 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sat Parkash Gupta and another 211 R.F.A No. 950 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Gori Shankar and another 212 R.F.A No. 951 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Rakesh Jindal and others Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (31) 213 R.F.A No. 952 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Giyatri Kansal and another 214 R.F.A No. 953 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Balkishan @ Krishan Lal 215 R.F.A No. 954 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Radha Kishan Gaba and another 216 R.F.A No. 955 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Sunehara Singh and another 217 R.F.A No. 956 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Jiva Nand and another 218 R.F.A No. 957 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Dharam Pal 219 R.F.A No. 958 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ramesh Rani Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondent .....Appellants ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (32) 220 R.F.A No. 959 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Mohan Lal and another 221 R.F.A No. 960 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Surender Kumar and another

222. R.F.A No. 961 of 2007 State of Haryana and another Smt. Gayatri Devi and another

223. R.F.A No. 962 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Jiwna Ram and another

224. R.F.A No. 963 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Gurcharan Dass

225. R.F.A No. 964 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Navneet Goel and another

226. R.F.A No. 965 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Hoshiar Singh and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants .....Respondent ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (33)

227. R.F.A No. 966 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Mayawati and another

228. R.F.A No. 967 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vs. Vs. Satish Kumar Chaudhary and others

229. R.F.A No. 968 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Champa Khurana and others

230. R.F.A No. 976 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Kashmiri Lal and another

231. R.F.A No. 977 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Mangli Devi and another

232. R.F.A No. 978 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Prem Chand and another

233. R.F.A No. 979 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Smt. Sushma Bindlish and another ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (34)

234. R.F.A No. 980 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Chanda Singh and others

235. R.F.A No. 981 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Ilam Singh and another

236. R.F.A No. 982 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Sarjan Singh and others

237. R.F.A No. 1055 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Raghbir Singh and another 238 R.F.A No. 1056 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Sunehri Devi and others

239. R.F.A No. 1057 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Subhash Chand and another

240. R.F.A No. 1091 of 2007(O&M) Guruji and others State of Haryana and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents. ....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents. R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (35)

241. R.F.A No. 1095 of 2007(O&M) Sarvesh Kumar Seth State of Haryana and others

242. R.F.A No. 1102 of 2007(O&M) Shakuntla Devi State of Haryana and others

243. R.F.A No. 1103 of 2007(O&M) Pushpa Rani and others State of Haryana and others

244. R.F.A No. 1157 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana Dinesh Kumar and another

245. R.F.A No. 1164 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Giyatari Kansal State of Haryana and others

246. R.F.A No. 1165 of 2007(O&M) Naresh Kumar Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and another ....Respondents

247. R.F.A No. 1168 of 2007(O&M) Naresh Kumar State of Haryana and others

248. R.F.A No. 1169 of 2007(O&M) Rajesh Kumar Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (36)

249. R.F.A No. 1184 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Smt. Nirmal Batra and others 250 R.F.A No. 1185 of 2007(O&M) State of Haryana and another Daler Singh and others 251 R.F.A No. 1747 of 2007(O&M) Narender Kumar Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 252 R.F.A No. 1748 of 2007(O&M) Haryana State Electricity Board Employees Co-operative House Building Society ....Appellants State of Haryana and another 253 R.F.A No. 1749 of 2007(O&M) Prem Chand State of Haryana and another 254 R.F.A No. 1750 of 2007(O&M) Vijay Kumar State of Haryana and another 255 R.F.A No. 1751 of 2007(O&M) Arun Gupta Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ... Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 256 R.F.A No. 1770 of 2007(O&M) Mohinder Kaur ....Appellant Vs. State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (37) 257 R.F.A No. 1779 of 2007(O&M) Bijender Singh State of Haryana and others 258 R.F.A No. 1780 of 2007(O&M) Satnam Singh State of Haryana and others 259 R.F.A No. 1781 of 2007(O&M) Bilas Kumar State of Haryana and others 260 R.F.A No. 1782 of 2007(O&M) Ramesh Kumar State of Haryana and others 261 R.F.A No. 1783 of 2007(O&M) Ram Kumar State of Haryana and others 262 R.F.A No. 1784 of 2007(O&M) Satnam Singh State of Haryana and others 263 R.F.A No. 1785 of 2007(O&M) Buta Singh State of Haryana and others 264 R.F.A No. 1786 of 2007(O&M) Rakesh Jindal and another Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellants State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (38) 265 R.F.A No. 1787 of 2007(O&M) Sushil Kumar State of Haryana and others 266 R.F.A No. 1788 of 2007(O&M) Madan Lal and others State of Haryana and others 267 R.F.A No. 2076 of 2007(O&M) Hoshiar Singh and another State of Haryana and others Vs. Vs. Vs. 268 R.F.A No. 2077 of 2007(O&M) Satish Kumar Chaudhary and another State of Haryana and others 269 R.F.A No. 2078 of 2007(O&M) Kuldeep Kumar and another State of Haryana and others 270 R.F.A No. 2079 of 2007(O&M) Hoshiar Singh and another State of Haryana and others 271 R.F.A No. 2080 of 2007(O&M) Babu Ram State of Haryana and others Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (39) 272 R.F.A No. 2129 of 2007(O&M) Mohan Singh State of Haryana and others 273 R.F.A No. 2130 of 2007(O&M) Radha Kishan Gaba State of Haryana and others 274 R.F.A No. 2131 of 2007(O&M) Hazara Singh State of Haryana and others 275 R.F.A No. 2132 of 2007(O&M) Ram Kumar State of Haryana and others 276 R.F.A No. 2229 of 2007(O&M) Vinod Kumar State of Haryana and others 277 R.F.A No. 2230 of 2007(O&M) Roop Chand State of Haryana and others 278 R.F.A No. 2231 of 2007(O&M) Suresh Kumar State of Haryana and others Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (40) 279 R.F.A No. 2232 of 2007(O&M) Tarsem Kumar State of Haryana and others 280 R.F.A No. 2233 of 2007(O&M) Brij Mohan State of Haryana and others 281 R.F.A No. 2234 of 2007(O&M) Ashok Kumar State of Haryana and others 282 R.F.A No. 2235 of 2007(O&M) Ishwar Chand State of Haryana and others 283 R.F.A No. 2236 of 2007(O&M) Kamal Gupta State of Haryana and others 284 R.F.A No. 2237 of 2007(O&M) Ramesh Chand State of Haryana and others 285 R.F.A No. 2238 of 2007(O&M) Mohan Lal State of Haryana and others Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (41) 286 R.F.A No. 2239 of 2007(O&M) Subhash Chand State of Haryana and others 287 R.F.A No. 2240 of 2007(O&M) Darshan Kumar State of Haryana and others 288 R.F.A No. 2241 of 2007(O&M) Surinder Kumar State of Haryana and others 289 R.F.A No. 2242 of 2007(O&M) Pawan Kumar State of Haryana and others 290 R.F.A No. 2243 of 2007(O&M) Parkash Chand State of Haryana and others 291 R.F.A No. 2244 of 2007(O&M) Suraj Parkash State of Haryana and others 292 R.F.A No. 2245 of 2007(O&M) Jitendar Kumar State of Haryana and others Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (42) 293 R.F.A No. 2246 of 2007(O&M) Gori Shankar State of Haryana and others 294 R.F.A No. 2289 of 2007(O&M) Vasdev State of Haryana and others 295 R.F.A No. 2290 of 2007(O&M) Madan Lal State of Haryana and others 296 R.F.A No. 2291 of 2007(O&M) Mohinder Paul Kaushik Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents 297 R.F.A No. 2292 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Saroj State of Haryana and others ....Respondents .....Appellant Vs. 298 R.F.A No. 2293 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Mangli Devi State of Haryana and others 299 R.F.A No. 2338 of 2007(O&M) Siri Chand and others State of Haryana and others 300 R.F.A No. 2345 of 2007(O&M) Lajpat Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (43) 301 R.F.A No. 2362 of 2007(O&M) Laxmi Parsad (deceased) through LRs. .....Appellant State of Haryana and others 302 R.F.A No. 2372 of 2007(O&M) Sewa Singh Vs. Vs. ....Respondents .....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents 303 R.F.A No. 2580 of 2007(O&M) Sajal Seth and another State of Haryana and others 304 R.F.A No. 2581 of 2007(O&M) Kuldeep Seth and another State of Haryana and others 305 R.F.A No. 2582 of 2007(O&M) Raj Kumar and others State of Haryana and others 306 R.F.A No. 2583 of 2007(O&M) Mohan Lal State of Haryana and others 307 R.F.A No. 2584 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Gayatri Devi State of Haryana and others 308 R.F.A No. 2585 of 2007(O&M) Raj Kumar Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellants ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (44) 309 R.F.A No. 2586 of 2007(O&M) Raj Kumar State of Haryana and others 310 R.F.A No. 2587 of 2007(O&M) Randhir Singh State of Haryana and others 311 R.F.A No. 2588 of 2007(O&M) Ghansham Bahadur State of Haryana and others 312 R.F.A No. 2589 of 2007(O&M) Gian Chand State of Haryana and others 313 R.F.A No. 2590 of 2007(O&M) Dalip Chand State of Haryana and others 314 R.F.A No. 2591 of 2007(O&M) Sham Lal Chopra State of Haryana and others 315 R.F.A No. 2592 of 2007(O&M) Tarsem State of Haryana and others 316 R.F.A No. 2593 of 2007(O&M) Roop Lal Passi Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (45) 317 R.F.A No. 2594 of 2007(O&M) Ramesh Chand State of Haryana and others 318 R.F.A No. 2595 of 2007(O&M) Amit Singhal State of Haryana and others 319 R.F.A No. 2596 of 2007(O&M) Ram Bahadur State of Haryana and others 320 R.F.A No. 2597 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Sushma Bindlish State of Haryana and others 321 R.F.A No. 2598 of 2007(O&M) Manohar Lal Seth State of Haryana and others 322 R.F.A No. 2599 of 2007(O&M) Urmila Gupta State of Haryana and others 323 R.F.A No. 2600 of 2007(O&M) Mohan Lal State of Haryana and others 324 R.F.A No. 2601 of 2007(O&M) Raj Bahadur Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (46) 325 R.F.A No. 2602 of 2007(O&M) Sat Prakash Gupta State of Haryana and others 326 R.F.A No. 2620 of 2007(O&M) Vijay Parkash State of Haryana and others 327 R.F.A No. 2752 of 2007(O&M) Kharaiti Lal State of Haryana and others 328 R.F.A No. 2753 of 2007(O&M) Kitab Singh State of Haryana and others 329 R.F.A No. 2754 of 2007(O&M) Mayawati State of Haryana and others 330 R.F.A No. 2796 of 2007(O&M) Ram Gopal and others State of Haryana and others 331 R.F.A No. 2797 of 2007(O&M) Sushil Kumar State of Haryana and others 332 R.F.A No. 2822 of 2007(O&M) Chander Pati Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (47) 333 R.F.A No. 2852 of 2007(O&M) Sunehara Singh State of Haryana and others 334 R.F.A No. 2871 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Ganpati Devi State of Haryana and others 335 R.F.A No. 2881 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Sunehri Devi and another State of Haryana and others 336 R.F.A No. 3011 of 2007(O&M) Ramesh Kumar State of Haryana and others 337 R.F.A No. 3012 of 2007(O&M) Lekh Raj Chawla State of Haryana and others 338 R.F.A No. 3013 of 2007(O&M) Krishan Lal State of Haryana and others 339 R.F.A No. 3014 of 2007(O&M) Babu Ram State of Haryana and others 340 R.F.A No. 3015 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Om Pati Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. .....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (48) 341 R.F.A No. 3016 of 2007(O&M) Ran Singh State of Haryana and another 342 R.F.A No. 3044 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Bedo State of Haryana and others

343. R.F.A No. 3045 of 2007(O&M) Kuldeep Singh State of Haryana and others 344 R.F.A No. 3065 of 2007(O&M) Satpal State of Haryana and others 345 R.F.A No. 3094 of 2007(O&M) Prem Chand State of Haryana and others 346 R.F.A No. 3095 of 2007(O&M) Onkar Lal State of Haryana and others 347 R.F.A No. 3191 of 2007(O&M) Nafe Singh State of Haryana and others 348 R.F.A No. 3192 of 2007(O&M) Smt. Kamlesh Rani State of Haryana and others Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (49) 349 R.F.A No. 3709 of 2007(O&M) Satish Kumar State of Haryana and others 350 R.F.A No. 3870 of 2007(O&M) Sonu Ram and others State of Haryana and others 351 R.F.A No. 4137 of 2007(O&M) Hukam Chand State of Haryana and others 352 R.F.A No. 4138 of 2007(O&M) Dalip Singh Vs. Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellants ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents 353 R.F.A No. 4139 of 2007(O&M) Arvind Kumar State of Haryana and others 354 R.F.A No. 4140 of 2007(O&M) Randhir Singh State of Haryana and others Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents 355 R.F.A No. 4141 of 2007(O&M) (sr. no. 355 deleted vide order dated 24.12.2008) Khazanchi Lal State of Haryana and others 356 R.F.A No. 4486 of 2007(O&M) Khazanchi Lal Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (50) 357 R.F.A No. 258 of 2008(O&M) Kamlesh Kumar State of Haryana and another 358 R.F.A No. 259 of 2008(O&M) Vijay Singh Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 359 R.F.A No. 260 of 2008(O&M) Ved Parkash and another ....Appellants Vs. State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 360 R.F.A No. 261 of 2008(O&M) Atma Ram ....Appellant Vs. State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 361 R.F.A No. 262 of 2008(O&M) Mahesh Gupta and another ....Appellants Vs. State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 362 R.F.A No. 291 of 2008(O&M) Asha Devi State of Haryana and others 363 R.F.A No. 368 of 2008(O&M) Smt. Sarla Devi State of Haryana and others 364 R.F.A No. 371 of 2008(O&M) Pooja Vs. Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents 365 R.F.A No. 401 of 2008(O&M) Smt. Sunita Kumari and another ....Appellants Vs. State of Haryana and others ....Respondents R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (51) 366 R.F.A No. 414 of 2008(O&M) Shiksha Aggarwal ....Appellant Vs. State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 367 R.F.A No. 431 of 2008(O&M) Smt. Shiksha Aggarwal ....Appellant Vs. State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 368 R.F.A No. 717 of 2008(O&M) Shakuntla Nagpal State of Haryana and others

369. R.F.A No. 862 of 2008(O&M) Smt. Lata Jain Vs. Vs. ....Appellant ....Respondents .....Appellant State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 370 R.F.A No. 959 of 2008(O&M) Kanchan Seth ....Appellant Vs. State of Haryana and others ....Respondents 371 R.F.A No.1002 of 2008(O&M) Shamsher Singh and another ....Appellants Vs. State of Haryana and another ....Respondents 372 R.F.A No.1817 of 2008(O&M) Smt. Mahindro Devi and others ....Appellants State of Haryana and others 373 R.F.A No.1959 of 2008(O&M) Smt. Usha Rani Vs. Vs. ....Respondents ....Appellant State of Haryana and others ....Respondents Coram: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal Present: Mr. Rakesh Nagpal, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. Nos. 1102, 1103, 1164, 1165, 1747 to 1751, 1770, 2362, 4486 of 2007, 258 to 262, 414, 431, 1002 of 2008. R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (52) Mr. Randeep Singh, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. Nos. 2129 to 2132 of 2007. Mr. A. P. Bhandari, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. No. 1959 of 2008. Mr. C. B. Goel, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. No. 1091 of 2008 Mr. Rajinder Goyal, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. Nos. 2076 to 2080, and 3709 of 2007 and 717 of 2008. Mr. Arvind Bansal, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. Nos. 2752 to 2754 of 2007. Mr. G. S. Dhaliwal, Advocate for Mr. M. L. Sharma, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. No. 1095 of 2007. Mr. Harsh Garg, Advocate for Mr. Rakesh Gupta, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. Nos. 361 to 363, 683 of 2007 and 959 of 2008. Mr. Ankit Aggarwal, Advocate for Mr. J. K. Goel, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. Nos. 3011 to 3016 of 2007 and 291 of 2008. Mr. Gaurav Singla, Advocate for Mr. Sanjiv Gupta, Advocate, for the landowners in R. F. A. Nos. 1168, 1169 of 2007. Mr. H. S. Hooda, Advocate General, Haryana with Mr. Lokesh Sinhal, Additional Advocate General, Haryana, for the State. Rajesh Bindal J. This order shall dispose of Regular First Appeal Nos. 361 to 363, 683, 1091, 1095, 1102, 1103, 1164, 1165, 1168, 1169, 1747 to 1751, 1770, 1779 to 1788, 925, 2076 to 2080, 2129 to 2132, 2229 to 2246, 2289 to 2293, 2338, 2345, 2362, 2372, 2580 to 2602, 2620, 2752 to 2754, 2796, 2797, 2822, 2852, 2871, 2881, 3011 to 3016, 3044, 3045, 3065, 3094, 3095, 3191, 3192, 3709, 3870, 4137 to 4140, 4486 of 2007, 258 to 262, 291, 368, 371, 401, 414, 431, 717, 862, 959, 1002, 1817 and 1959 of 2008, filed by the landowners seeking further enhancement of compensation and R. F. A. Nos. 564 to 590, 592 to 606, 616 to 673, 676 to 681, 850 to 924, 926 to 968, 976 to 982, 1055 to 1057, 1157, 1184 and 1185 of 2007 filed by the State R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (53) seeking reduction in the compensation for the acquisition of land, as the same arise out of the same acquisition. However, the facts have been extracted from R. F. A. No. 361 of 2007. Briefly, the facts are that vide notification dated 9.8.2002, issued under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short, 'the Act'), the State of Haryana acquired 277.36 acres of land situated within the revenue estate of Village Patti Kaisth Seth Kaithal, Tehsil and District Kaithal, for public purpose of development and utilisation of the land as residential, commercial and institutional Sector-21 Kaithal. The Land Acquisition Collector (for short, “the Collector”) vide his award dated

5.8.2005 assessed the market value of the land at Rs. 5 lacs per acre. Dissatisfied with the award of the Collector, the landowners/claimants filed objections. On reference under Section 18 of the Act, the learned court below vide award dated 30.11.2006, determined fair value of the acquired land at Rs. 350/- per square yard. Learned counsel for the landowners/claimants submitted that the acquired land had a very strategic location being situated on Ambala- Hissar National Highway on the one side and road leading to Guhla-Cheeka. It was further submitted that Colony of the Electricity Board Employees namely Vidyut Vihar Colony, is part of the acquired land. The land in question was acquired for development and utilisation of Sector-21 and this sector consists of Vidyut Vihar Colony, Radha Swami Colony, D. A. V. Colony, Radha Swami Satsang Bhawan, Central Public School and adjoining D. C. Colony. It was further submitted that Sector-20 which is just across the Ambala-Hissar road on the other side had already been developed after the land therefor was acquired in the year 1989 where this court had assessed the value of the acquired land at Rs. 2,90,000/- per acre. The acquisition in the present case was 13 years later in the year 2002. The land was situated within the municipal limits. The value as assessed by the learned court below merely relying upon the Collector's rates called for further increase for the reason that in the year 1991 more than 10 acres of land was purchased by the employees of the Erstwhile Haryana State Electricity Board for the purpose of construction of houses by forming a society namely Vidyut Vihar Colony. It was @ Rs. 190/- per square yard. An increase of 15% per annum can be granted thereon considering R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (54) judgment of this court in Smt. Lille Madanjit vs Land Acquisition Collector, for Punjab State Electricity Board, Patiala 2008 (3) R. C. R. (Civil) 452 and the value of the acquired land would require further increase by this court. Even other sale transactions namely Ex. P-3 and P-4 showing the value of the acquired land have not been considered at all. Keeping in view the fact that the land falls within the municipal limits where the plots are always sold in square yard and about 100 houses were already build on the acquired land, a residential colony in the name of Radha Swami Colony had already been developed, itself shows that the land had great future potential and was already in the process of being urbanised. The pressure for expansion of the city was on this side. On the other hand, learned Advocate General appearing for the State submitted that the learned court below has totally gone wrong in placing reliance on the Collector's rates fixed for registration of sale-deeds which is not a good piece of evidence to be relied upon for the purpose of determination of fair value of the acquired land as has been held by Hon'ble the Supreme Court in Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti Sahaswan District Badaun through its Secretary vs Bipin Kumar and another 2004 (1) S. C. C. 283. He further submitted that what to talk of increase the amount as has already been granted to the landowners in the present case deserves decrease as there is practically no evidence except the Collector's rates. Other sale-transactions Ex. P-3 to P-5, which are in the form of small plots, could not have been relied upon as such for the purpose of determination of fair value of the acquired land which is a big chunk of 277.36 acres of land. As far as the location of the land is concerned, the same could not be disputed. He further submitted that reliance on the transactions which took place in the year 1991 whereby 10 acres of land was purchased by the employees of Electricity Board for carving out a colony for its employees is totally misplaced for the purpose of determination of fair value of the land acquired in the year 2002. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. A perusal of para 39 of the impugned award shows that after referring to the evidence led by the parties, the reference court merely relied upon the document Ex. P-162 which is a Collector's rates for the purpose of registration of sale-deeds in the area. R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (55) Hon'ble the Supreme Court in Bipin Kumar's case (supra), while relying upon its earlier judgment in Jawajee Nagatham vs Revenue Divisional Officer, Adilabad, A. P. and others, 1994 (4) SCC 595 opined that the reliance by the reference court on the value fixed by the District Magistrate for payment of stamp duty for registration of sale-deed is clearly erroneous. The judgment part is extracted below:- “It has been held by this court in the case of Jawajee Nagatham vs Revenue Divisional Officer, Adilabad, A. P. and others, 1994 (4) SCC 595 that market value under Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 cannot be fixed on the basis of a basic valuation register maintained by the registering authority for collection of stamp duty. Therefore, the reliance by the Reference Court on the value of land fixed by the District Magistrate for stamp duty purposes is clearly erroneous. For the purpose of Land Acquisition Act the market value must be determined on the basis of sale deeds of comparable lands.” Considering the fact that the learned reference court has merely relied upon the Collector's rates fixed for payment of stamp duty for registration of sale-deeds which as such could not be made the basis of determination of fair value of the acquired land and other evidence having not been considered, in my opinion, it would be appropriate to set aside the impugned award and remit the case back to the reference court for re- determination of the value of the acquired land on the basis of other relevant evidence on record. The parties through their counsels are directed to appear before the learned District Judge, Kaithal, on 30.1.2009. The learned District Judge may either keep the references with himself or may entrust the same to any other Additional District Judge for fresh consideration on the basis of material on record. It is further made clear that the amount of compensation if already paid to the landowners shall not be recovered from them during the R. F. A No. 361 of 2007 (56) pendency of the proceedings before the learned reference court and the same shall abide by any final decision therein. The appeals are disposed of in the above terms.

05.12.2008 vs. ( Rajesh Bindal) Judge