Kaj alSharm a v. The Panj abUniversit yand ot hers

herfirst and secondsem est ersand secured351 and 336 out of500 m arks in flrstandsecond in Novem ber 1 0 0 I C I Z C I 08 OO 7 Z Qm nm e 2008 and April2009 Duringt hird sem est er sought t o t he Universit yI st it ut ion of LegalSt udies t he hereinaft er referred t o as t he UI LS Panj abUniversit y No t he and t he pet it ionerwas adm it t edat t he I nst it ut eof LegalSt udies on 08092009 of form alit ies depositof t he et cI t is st at edt hat t he nam e of t he pet it ionerwas placedon t he not iceboard on 23112009 short ageof 27 lect ures NoA const it ut eda t hree Mem bers Com m it t ee t o considert he short agecases The beforet he Com m it t eeand on t he recom m endat ionof t he Com m it t ee of 27 lect ureswas condoned t he pet it ioner roll num ber for t hird sem est er exam inat ionwhich was scheduledt o com m ence on 27112009 I t is fult her allegedt hat when t he pet it ionerwen t o appear for t he exam inat ion on 27 1 2009 she was from t akingexam inat ion011 of wit hdrawal of t he roll Rawat Seem a 2014.04.15 14: 14 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh t his act ion oft he ber The pet it ionerhas Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 92 CWPNol9368 of2009 3 MrGaurav learned counsel for t he hasraised t he followingcont ent ionsl 0 t hatt he was never t heshort ageof lect uresexcept27 lect uresat any t im et o enablet he t o m akeup t he deficiency i t hat t he havingbeen issued t he roll on t he couldnot of t he Com m it t eet he have been wit hdrawn wit hout any andt hat t oo wit hout affordingany sam e reason ofbeingheardt o her 15 of Panj abUniversit yCalendar Vol I I I a priornot icewast o be givent o t he t he of lect ures Videint erim order dat ed16122009 t he t o appear111t het hird sem est erexam inat ion was t o be held on 17122009and 2612009 The in it s disclaim er t o t he not only adm it t ed t he of t he from t he PURC t o UI LS but also t he issue of Roll Num ber o t he t he of 27 lect ures on t he Com m it t ee I t however t hat t he pet it ionerhad 1 C 0 0 I Cao I Z I Ol a7 Z Ll e at t ended only 52 per cent of t ot al Rawat Seem a 2014.04.15 14: 14 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh of 75 per cent lect ures as againstt he Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document t o t he Universit yt here is 9 93 0 19 1 0 0 I C5 4 Z I C45 14 7 Z t l n CWPN19368 of2009 4 of 61 lect ures whereas only 40 lect ures could be condonedundert he rules I t is furt her st at edt hat t he hadshort ageof 34 lect uresat PURC which inform at ionwas not byt he t o t he and it was only on 26112009 at 430 pm when t he inform at ion was receivedfrom t he PURC t he short ageof t heselect ures I t t he st and of t he t hat t he COndOnat iOn Com m it t ee condoned 27 lect ures in UI LS due t o rush of st udent swit houtknowingt he fact of of lect ures111 PURC The Panj ab has fram ed rules for adm ission and t o BA LLB ionsl Five Years lt egrat edCourse t o 10 sem est ers decision dat ed 2412004 I t emNoCm 39and for condoningt hedeficiencyin lect ures Therelevantext ract oft he rulesis not iced hereunder 4r4A candidat eadm it t edt o t he course shall be eligible t o appear lI l a Sem est er if he has at t endedat I east75I o t he lect uresl lect uresl t ut orialsl t o Court or ot her inst it ut ions et c as m ay be delivered or during t he sem est er Providedt hat t he deficiencyin t his m ay be condoned as folloWSl a1Upt o30 lect uresin a papers9in t ot al t o Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Rawat Seem a 2014.04.15 14: 14 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh 94 0 11 CWPNo9368 of2009 5 1 f 0 C I 9 I Ct Z L I 08 QO 17 Z Qm t he best oft he st udent and upt o 10 lect ures in various speciallect uresl m oot slvisit s t o Court s or ot herinst it ut ions byt he b The ViceChancellor in t he cases on t he m ay upt o10 lect uresin a t o t he t he st udent beyondt he condonaUondone byt he Headl Chairm anl 13 These rules TlY Providefor m inim um 75I o of t he lect ures includingspeciallect ures t ut orials m oot s duringsem est er The deficiency111 t he lect ures is upt o30 lect uresin a paperslin t ot al and upt o100I oin vanous lect ures m oot s and visit s t o Court s by t he and in cases upt o 1 0 by t he ViceChancellor on t he t he Thus 111 all 40010of t he deficientlect urescan be condoned I t is t he st andoft he also The pet it ionerhas short ageof 61 lect ures XV oft he sam e furt herdeal wit h t he rules forcondoningde8ciencyin lect ures The relevantext ract Of t herule is as under Rawat Seem a 2014.04.15 14: 14 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh e I f at t he t it neof subm issionof adm ission Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 95 0 CWPNo9368 of2009 6 forrn a has not lect ures et c t he nam e m ay be sent up for t he exam inat ion of Dept t The sha1115 days before t he dat e of of exam inat ion int im at e t o t heRegist rarif t he st udenthas m adeup t he hasnot beencondoned11 lect ures or t he This rule t hat where at t he t im e of t he subm ission of t he adm ission form for an exam inat ion if any st udenthas not t he percent ageof lect ures hislher nam e m ay be sent up for exam inat ion t hat PrincipallI ad t he I t int im at e t o t he 15 days before t he dat e of com m encem ent of t he exam inat ionwhet hert he st udenthas m ade if t he deficiencyhas not of lect uresor upt he From t he readingof t he aforesaidrule it appears t hatt he of lect uresm ust be exam inedwhen t he fonn of a st udent for exam inat ionis t o be forwarded by t he concerned t o t he bodyand if it is found at t hat st aget hat t here is oflect ures t he form is t o be sent I t furt herrequirest hat 15 daysbefore t he dat e of com m encem ent 1 r 0 CA0 I C5 I Z 2 Q I 08 Z e oft he t he Regist rarof t he Exam iningBodyist o be Rawat Seem a 2014.04.15 14: 14 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh by t he t he Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document whet her t he 96 9 CWP No9368 of2009 7 st udenthas m adeup t he deficiencyof lect uresor if t he has not been condonedby t he aut horit ies From t he t he aforesaidlule it appears t hat before an form is forwardedt o t he body it upon t he of t he t o exam lne t he of lect uresof a st udentand if it is foundso hislher formis t o be forwarded The nat ural corollaryoft his t his st age is t hat a st udentm ust be putt o not ice at t he lect urest o enablehim t o up t he deficiencySuchexerciseis t o be 15 days t he com m encem entof t he exam inat iont o flnd out whet her t he st udent has up t he deflciencyand if not whet hert he deficiencyis t o be condonedor not and int im at ion has t o be forwardedt o t he of t heExam iningBody as t he case m ay be ie 111bot ht he where deflciencyhas been m adeout and where it is not so whet hert he deflciencyis condonedor not This provisionseem s t o havebeenenact edwit h an obviousobj ect 1 r 0 0 I 49 I Z f I 08 00 WA7 Z Llm and purportt o t o t he default ingst udentt o Gne and m ake up t he deficiencyupt o 15 days beforet hecom m encem ent oft he exam inat ion I n t he presentcase t he form of t he pet it ionerwas forwardedt o t he wit hout any reservat ion There is Rawat Seem a 2014.04.15 14: 14 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh in t he replywhich m ay even t hat t he exam inat ion Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 97 0 CWPNo19368of2009 formoft he 8 t o t heUniversit ybYt heUI LS l t he deficiencyof lect ures I t appears t hatat t he t im e of sendingt he form no exercise was conduct edbyt he UI LS deficiencyof lect uresl of t he st udent s I t was for t he first t im e on 232009 four daysbeforet hedat e of com m encem entOf t h t hat t he short ageof andt he sam e was puton t henot iceboard The was not iced nam e t he not ice board short ageof only27 The Com m it t ee for condonat ionof short age of lect uresexam inedt he case oft he wit h t he short ageof at t endanceon 2512009and t he issuedt he roll num ber Even at t hatst aget he was notinform edabout t he putt he of I ect uresbeyond27 The Universit yhas blam e upon t he of fact s andhas accusedher of learnedcounsel arguedt hat it was t he dut yof t he 1 0 0 C3 C5 Z C I 08 00 4 W Z 0 wm W pet it ionert o have about t he short ageof lect ures at PURCbut she did not revealanyt hing To t hecont raryit is on behalfoft he pet it ioner t hat t he havingbeen Universit yit was t he Rawat Seem a 2014.04.15 14: 14 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh dut yof t he under t he orders of t he Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document t o have 98 0 r 1 0 0 0 I 0 I 1 Z C 0 I 08 00 4 V2 Z Om C Vn CWPN19368 of2009 9 t he short agefrom t he PURC To m y m indbot hie t he andt he are t o be for t his fiasco Pet it ioner who had st udiedat PURCshouldhave known if not t he exact at least deficiencyoflect ures She chose not t o reveal At t he sam e t im e at t he t im e of or at least whenexam inat ionform of t he forwardedt o t he UI LSt o have boundendut yof t he body it was t he t he deflciencyof from PURC and 111any case when t he m at t er was before t he Com m it t eeThe shouldhavesought form PURC Bot h have fault edat t heir levelsand now it is a blam e gam e t o eachot her I ft he hasnotdisclosedaboutt he lect urest he has also not it s t he short ageof 27 lect ures and alsoissued roll num berst o t he exam inat ionHowever one t hing1S veryclear t hat m andat eof in t he rule 2 of Chapt erXV has not been carried out by t he whichint erlia t he exam inat ionof deficiencyatt he st ageof sendingt he exam inat ionform or at I east 15 daysbefore t hedat e of com m encem entof t he exam inat ionTo t hecont raryt he for t he flrst t im e placedt he nam es of Rawat Seem a 2014.04.15 14: 14 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh t he wit h deficient at t endanceon t he not ice board only Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 99 m C 0 0 I 0 I Z r 08 CO 7 Z t l CWPNo19368of2009 10 before t he exam inat ionSufficeit t o say at t his st age a st udenthad no occasion t o m akeup t he deficiencyoflect ures even want s t o im proveand had t he desired t o m ake up t he Under t hesecircum st ances t he cannot be offrom in t he exam inat ionwhen t he it selfhasissuedt heroll num berst o t hepet it ioner I n view of t he above m ent ionedst at ut oryprovlSlOllS cont ained t he calendar t he cont ent ion of leam ed counsel t he Uiversit ycannot be For t he reasons above t he presentwrit is allowed The hasalready ln som e oft he papers undert he orders of t his Court The t o appearlll t heexam inat ion 1S The is direct edt o declaret he result of t he papersfor which t he I n t he t he shall be t o fourt h selnest er ifot herwise eligibleNt oCOS C boALe4 09042010 BLS 46 PERMOD KOHl JUDGE Whet hert o be referredt o t he l YESI Ne 5 t Rawat Seem a 2014.04.15 14: 14 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh 16P 1 Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document