I NTHE HI GH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDI GARH v. Financiai Com m issloner Haryanaand ot hers

of t he above infirm it ies I n t he absence of any such infirm it yan appellat e or revisionalaut horit yshall not int et ferewit h t he choice of t he Coliect or A perusalof t he order passedby t he Com m issioner reveals t hat t he Com m issoner proceededt o weighm erit sof candidat es and t hereaft er im posedhis percept ionof t he bet t er candidat e wit hout recordingany findingt hat t he choice of t he Collect or is in any m anner perverse arbit rary illegal The Financial Com m issioner right lyrect ified t his error of j urisiict ionand rest ored t he choice of t he Collect or The regist rat ionof a crim inal case againstrespondentno 4 duringpendencyof proceedings cannot be a groundt o set aside his select ion as he has neher been charged nor convict ed I t would be necessary t o point out t hat t he pet it ionerhas however been chargedin a crim inal case as not iced byt he Financial Com m issioner As t he im pugnedorders do not suHer from any error of j urisdict ionor of I aw t he writ pet it ionis dism issed wit h no order as t o cosls 1 4 C I Z I 08 Z 0 RAJI VE BHALLAI JUDGE I l CJU Bat ra Am it 2014.04.23 10: 25 TRUE SCANNED COPY OF ORI GNAL PHHC CHANDI GARH Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document