Balj itKaur v. St at eofPunj aband ot hers

passedin t he first counselingand who had not passedPunj abit ill 22009 and also t he candidat eswho had not deposit ed t he fee and a0e willingt o a l4 depositt he fee were furt her called for counselingon 1982009 The pet it ionershave challengedt he publicnot icedat ed 2372009 whereby t 172009 t he condit ion of 500I o and450I om arks for General and Reserved Cat egoriesrespect ively was int roducedas eligibilit yfor adm ission t o ETT course The cont ent ion of t he 1S t hat by 1SSUlng publicnot ices t he originaladvert isem entnot ice 1S soughtt o be am endedwhich is lI l law The St at ehas flled a det ailed reply I t is st at ed t hat t he originalpublicnot ices dat ed 1672008 and 2312009 were in fact not t he advert isem entnot ices These not ices were issued onlyfor collect ion of inform at iont o ident ifyeligiblecandidat es from EGS volunt eers I t is furt herst at ed t hat t he publicnot ices dat ed 2372009 and 1782009 t houghissued by way of but in f2ict t he publicnot ices laid down t he for adm ission for Teacher Training Furt her st and of t he St at e is t hat t he eligibilit ycondit ions have been laid down by t he NCTE t he apex body which regulat est he im part ingof ETT and ot her Teacher TrainingCourses 111t he count ryThe St at ehas also placedon record Annexure Rwhich Appendix2 of t he norm s st andards for Teacher issued by t he NCTE Under 32 of t he said not iflcat iont he for adm issiont o BEd Course are Um a 2014.04.03 16: 17 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh The condit ion reads as under Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:25 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 66 0 1 t r 0 Cm o 0 2 e t 2 O Ct e Z Clm CWP Nos3531 12289 and 14702 of2009 17355 12463 12525 13717 13801 14704 7 1 32 Eligibilit y 32 Candidat e wit h at least 50I o m arks in t he seniorit ysecondary 32 The reservat ion for SCI STI OBC and ot her shall be as per t he rules of t he Cent ral Govem m ent lSt at e Governm ent whichever 1S applicableThere shall be relaxat ion of 5I o m arks fvour of SCI STI OBC and ot her cat egoriesof candidat es 53 Thought he St at e relied upon t he norm s prescribedby t he NCTE however t he NCTE was not a part yt o t he pet it ionVide int erlocut ory order dat ed 2002009 passedln som e of t he writ pet it ionsincluding CWPN012463 of 2009 NCTE was im pleadedas part y askedt o file it s replyNCTE has also filed it s replysupport ingt he st and of t he St at eas regardt he eligibilit y for adm ission t o t he course I t is st at ed t hat under 2005 Regulat ionand norm s and st andardfor Teacher t he eligibilit y was at least450I om arksin t he Srecondary or it s equivalentexam inat ion However t hese subst it ut edby 2007 wherein t he m inim um m arks were at least 500I oin t he Sr Exam inat ion wit h relaxat ion of 50I om arks ln case of Reserved Cat egoriesI n view of t he above st and of t he NCTE t he eligibilit yprescribedby t he St at e vide it s not ificat ions dat ed2372009 and 1782009 cannot be sid t o be illegalI t 1S also relevant t o not ice t hat t he flrst t wo publicnot ices dat ed 1672008 and 232009 Um a 2014.04.03 16: 17 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh specificallym ent ion about t he inform at ion t o ident ifyt he Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:25 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document eligiblecandidat es Paragraph2 of t he aforesaid publicnot ice reads as 67 Z7 m Q 0 0 C Z 2 C 4 03t CQ m 1 Z Om em d r L 8 N0Se1353117355 12463 1252513717 13801 14704 12289 and 14702 of2009 The eligibilit yand ident it yfor eligiblecandidat esfor adm ission t o ETT Cours I t is evident t hat public not ice dat ed 2372009 prescribest he m lnim um percent agefOr General and ReservedCat egoriesLearned counsel t he pet it ionershas relied upon t wo of t his Court I n t he of Subhash Chandra VSe The I nst it ut e Educat ion and Research Chandigarhand anot her 1997 of Medical RSJ 346 it been held t hat t he adm issionbrochurecannot be perm it t edt o be am endedor alt ered at t he st ageA sim ilar view hasbeenheld 111 t he case of Munish Khanduj aVSe Guru Jam bheshwarUniversit yHisar and ot hers 200231RSJ 463 I n t he presentcase t he quest ionisoft he eligibilit yThe first t wo publicnot ices relied upon byt he pet it ioneare lI l fact not t he com plet ebrochurefor adm issionThe e condit ionin t heaforesaidnot ices is regardingt he inform at ionin respect of t he eligibilit y oft he EGS Volunt eersThese not ices were followedby t wo publicnot ices layingdown t he eligibilit yas per t he norm s laid down byt he NCTE I t 1S also pert inentt o not e t hat as per t he replyflled by t he NCTE t hese eligibilit ycondit ions have been laid down by t he st at ut ory fram ed by t he NCTE The st at ut orycondit ion laid down cannot be 0 wit h These condit ionshave t o be followed beingessent ial eligibilit yfor adm issiont o t he course These pet it ionswere flled for adm issiont o t he Course duringt he sesslon 20092010 I t is m ore t han one year Ot herwisealso at t hisbelat ed st ageno relief can be grant edt o t he pet it ionersI n CWP Nosl2525 and Um a 2014.04.03 16: 17 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh 13713 of 2009 t he pet it ionershave also placedOO record a publicnot ice Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:25 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Cr 1 CJL CWP N0se13531 17355 12463 12525 13717 1380114704 12289 and 14702of2009 9 dat ed 2622010 wherein t he EGS volunt eers have been given special chance t o im prove t he percent ageI t is cont ended Oll behalf of t he pet it ionerst hat t he pet it ionersare ent it led t o im provet heir percent ageand t heym ay be perm it t edt o do SO Sufflce it t o say t hat if t he pet it ionersare ent it led t o im provet heir percent ageln t erm s of t he aforem ent ionedpublic not ice t heyare at libert yt o do SO On t heir percent age t heywill ot herwisebecom e eligiblet o applyand seek adm issiont o t he Course However t his is possibleonlyfor t ure adm issions The Current Academ ic Session com m enced m ore t han one year back and t hus t he pet it lonersare not ent it led t o seek any benefit of t his publicnot ice at t his st age I n view of t he above I no m erlt lI l t hese writ pet it ions Dism issed No order as t o cost s Copyoft his order be placedon record on each concernedfile JJVv PERMOD KOHL JUDGE 1 1 C 0 0 C Z Q 021 00 m vm o 2 CL 30 62010 I VI FK Not elWhet hert o be referredt o report eror not YESI NO t a I JO ol 784v I o Um a 2014.04.03 16: 17 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:25 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document I P