SHAMURAILATPA v. The State
Case Details
Judgment
1. The State of Manipur through Commissioner/Secretary, (Education /S), Government of Manipur, Imphal Secretariat, P.O. Imphal-795001, Imphal West District.
2. The Director of Education(S), Government of Manipur, Lamphelpat, - 795004.
3. W. Sobita Devi
4. N. Achouba Singh
5. A. Joykumar
6. G. Thambalsana Kabui
7. M. Takheljao Singh
8. S.Bijaya Devi
9. M. Debendro Singh
10. N. Dijendra
11. H. Dhanajit Singh
12. R.K. Shyamchoron Singh
14. T. Indira Devi Th. Subashchandra Singh
15. K. Sunanda Devi
16. L. Norendro Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 14
17. M. W. Tharawon
18. N. Pramodini Devi
19. Th. Rajendra Kumar singh
20. K. S. Yaruingam
21. M. Kalachand Singh
22. Khol khoikim Vaiphei
23. M. Muhindro Singh
24. Mohnn Kumar Ivlishra
25. H. Anandi Devi
26. L. Triveni Devi
27. O. Geetarani Devi
28. M. Kiranmala Devi
29. Kh. lbomcha Singh
30. Ch. Robindro Singh
31. W. Rameshwor Singh
32. L. Rajendra Singh
33. N. jibanlata Devi
34. Th. Ralendro Singh
35. Ch. Medha Devi
36. I. Lily Devi
37. Urmila Kshetrimayum
38. Anupama Nepram
39. N. Goutam Singh
40. N. Borchandra Singh
41. P. Nimai Singh
42. M. Saya Devi
44. Shachikurmari Huidrombi S. Ibemnungshi Devi
45. H. Jeeten Singh
46. N. Premlata Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 15
48. T. Khomdon Singh Th. Helu Devi
49. R. K. Chaoba Singh
50. N. Sangita Devi
51. Th. Sachinanda Singh
52. Kh. Memtombi Devi
53. I. Usharani Devi
54. M. Kheroda Devi
55. Jeida Begum
56. Kh. Shangai Devi
57. N. Ratana Devi
58. P. Baroda Devi
59. R. K.Sanatombi
60. H. Padmini Devi
61. W. Mohindro Singh
62. Kh. Chandrakanta Singh
63. Kh. Kamalakanta Singh
64. Y. Radheshyam Singh.
65. Kh. Shyamkumar Singh
66. K. Rajani Devi
67. G. Geeta Devi
69. Sh. Jayanta Singh Saroj Kumar Sinha
70. O. Somila Devi
71. Ng. Kiranmala Devi
72. H. Ripupyari Devi
73. Kh. Bikramchandra Singh
74. S. Jugindro Singh
75. M. Tikendrajit Singh
76. Heltinmang Misao W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 16
77. M. Nimaichand Singh
78. N. Sumila Chanu
79. Kh. Nandini Devi
80. Th. Pratima Devi
81. Nirmala Koijam
84. L. Bor Singh S. Devikarani Devi I. Sujata Devi
85. K. Shantibala Devi
86. L. Bharati Devi
87. K. Bijaya Devi
88. Ksh. Ratna Devi
89. K. Shangkham Monsang
91. P. Nilakumari Devi L. Nandabir Singh
92. Ataullah Khan
93. Ng. Karmaljit Singh
96. Sunita Laisom T. Pusparani Devi L. Sangeeta Devi
97. O. Manmohini Devi
99. Th. Ranieeta Devi Prem Prasad Shivakoti
100. Vidya Mairembam
101. Th. Irika Devi
102. H. Sureshkumar Singh
103. P. Omita Devi
104. Th. Lite Devi
105. Kh. Brajeswori Devi
106. Kshetrimayum Kunjabihari Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 17
107. Y. Premila Devi
108. Thounaojam Bilasini Devi
109. Y.lboyaima Singh
110. Chabungbam Ranjit Singh
111. E. Noren Singh
112. Khundombam Indikumar Singh
113. O.. Rajendro Singh
114. Angonjabam Nalini Devi
115. Shantikuman Prasad
116. Chongtham Noyin Singh
117. Lhingneilam Haokip
118. Khuraijam Sunanda Devi
119. Ph. Tampakleima Devi
120. Taorem Jiibanlata Devi
121. Y. Babu Singh
122. Waikhom Ibeyaima Devi
123. R.K. Sarda Devi
124. Shamurailatpam Devani Devi
125. Y. Kumar Singh
126. Angoljabam Premila Devi
127. Ng. Tamphatombi Devi
128. Gurumayum Satyabati Devi
129. M. Subashini Devi
130. Oinam Sorodhoni Devi
131. Y. Khomdon Singh
132. Raikumari Khambisana Devi
133. H. Rejubala Devi
134. Nongmaithern Rasmon Singh
135. I. Usharanj Devi
136. Heisnam Mangijao Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 18
137. K. Lucybala Devi
138. R.K. Sanatomba Singh
139. I. Bipin Meetei
140. Thokchom Indira Devi
141. R.K. Sharatkumar Singh
142. Khuraijam Binodini Devi
143. Kh. Romola Devi
144. Konthoujam Bimolini Devi
145. H. Binodini Devi
146. Nongmaithem Sunita Devi
147. S.B. Pathak
148. Pukhrambam Sarju Singh
149. L. Muhindro Singh
150. Elangbam Dipali Devi
151. Dal Bahadur Bhattarai Chhetry
152. Moirangthem Opendro Singh
153. M.Sakhitombi Devi
154. Amakcham Naba Siingh
155. Punita Das
156. Nongthombam Femina Devi
157. Promila Ahanthembi
158. Naorem Lokendro Singh
159. M. Bidyapati Devi
160. Oinam Noyon Singh
161. Th. Anibolin Devi
162. Thongbam Bhogendro Singh
163. W. lbeyaima Devi
164. Nongthombam Lala Singh
165. A. Shashilata Devi
166. Laishram Nandakumari Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 19
167. 0. Sarjubala Devi
168. Loitongbam Dorendro Singh
169. Kh. Bimola Devi
170. Chandam Khomei Singh
171. A. Sarjubala Chanu
172. Khoisnam Sunita Devi
173. L. Jugelata Devi
174. Laishram Doren Singh
175. N. Amita Devi
176. Rajesh Kumar Kar
177. Parmanand Singh
178. Waikhom Sushilkumar Meitei
179. Irom Shyamkesho Singh
180. Irom Bedamani Devi
181. H. Meghachandra Singh
182. Md. Alauddin Shah
183. L. Jibanmala Devi
184. Yumnam Bihari Meetei
185. L. Ratnaprava Devi
186. Talkhellambam lbohal Singh
187. Th. Nandini Devi
188. Akham Domarendro Singh
189. L. Padmabati Devi
190. YunosKhan
191. O. Chanu Amita
192. Laishram Sanjtibkurmar Singh
193. R.K. Romoni Devi
194. Kangjam Jamuna Devi
195. W. Manojkumar
196. Mandingbam Roma Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 20
197. K. Geetika Devi
198. Laishram Sarojini Devi
199. G. Bala Devi
200. Nadira Begun
201. Nonibala Longjam 202. Kh. Kamkhohao Lungdei 203. H. Bhobashis Luwang
204. Nongmaithem Udoya Devi
205. Konsam Surendra
206. Thiyam Brajakeshwor Singh
207. N. Dhana Singh
208. Gururnayum Radharnani Devi
209. L. Joychandra Sharma
210. Keisham Jugeshwar Singh
211. Y. Romashini Devi
212. Rajkumar Dalimkumar Singh
213. K. Rebati Chanu
214. Md. Hatim Ali
215. W. Jayantakumar Singh
216. Laishrarn Khamba Singh
217. N. Jogendro Singh
218. Takhellambam Subarta Singh
219. Kh. Bimola Devi
220. Monohormayum Bebi Devi
221. W. Johny
222. Elangbam Rajen Singh
223. P. Nilamani Singh
224. Sanasam Bita Devi
225. S. Prabhatchandra Singh
226. Maibam Surjabal Khuman W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 21
227. Ranjeeta Laishram
228. Tongbram Tomba Singh
229. Md.Mirja Khan
230. Kshetrimayum Chitralekha Devi
231. Y. Binati Devi
232. Burhanuddin
233. Masan Ahamnd
234. Ahanthem Meghachandra Singh
235. N.Nandan Devi
236. Changamayum Binarani Devi
237. Arambam Sujata Devi
238. Khuraijam Indiprabha Devi 239. W. Gunananda Singh 240. Bareda Begum
241. Nganbam Bhobanta Singh
242. Wairokpam Ojitkumar Singh
243. O. Kunjo Singh
244. Kakchingtabam Pramodini Devi
245. Jeshmi Thokchom
246. Sikander Ali
247. P. Babu Singh
248. Md Liyakat Ali
249. Wahidur Rahaman
250. Moirangthem Sunita Devi
251. L.Ibomcha Singh
252. Bisnulatpam Profullo Sharma
253. Y . Badal Singh
254. N. Sanjib Kumar Singha
255. W. Priyadarshni Devi
256. Naoroibam Sashikanta Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 22
257. Charu Chandra Haomon
258. Kshetrimayum Mema Devi
259. T. Ibetombi Devi
260. Rajkumar Milan Singh
261. Ngangom Dilipkumar Singh
262. Lisam Jiteshwari Devi
263. L. Kanta Meitei
264. Md. Afzal Ali
265. Kiyam Sharat Singh
266. Mujibur Rahman
267. Chongtham Romita Devi
268. Thangjam Biren Singh
269. Nirmala Achom
270. Rajkumari Premoda Devi
271. L. Premchandra Singh
272. Wahengbam Dineshkumar Singh
273. Y. Nandakumar Singh
274. Ngangbam Tombi
275. Chandam Yaima Devi
276. Naoshekpam Aruna Devi
277. Gurumayum Meenakshi Sharma
278. Kangjam Ratankumar Singh
279. Leimapokpam Khogen Singh
280. Okram Imo Singh
281. Yumnam Jayanta Singh
282. Thingujam Heramot Singh
283. M. Raju Singh
284. Abdul Kalam
285. Rosekumar Ningthoujam
286. Shanglakpam Dhaneshwori Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 23
287. H. Dijen Singh
288. Nongthombam Jugeshwar Singh
289. Leimapokpam Jumen Singh
290. Thongam Sunita Devi
291. Nongmeikapam Nilakanta Singh
292. Huidrom Basantakumar Singh
293. K.Priyokumar Singh
294. Thokchom Janaranjan Singh
295. L. Premananda
296. Laishram Dhamendra Singh
297. Khangembam Romen Meetei
298. Leishangthem Kheroda Devi
299. T. Soniya
300. Longjam Roma Devi
301. Shahabuddin Khan
302. Mayengbam Bijoychandra
303. Ksh. Ibubgo Singh
304. Shandmbam Pishak Singh
305. Thokchom lmobi Singh
306. Konsham Mahila Devi
307. Huidrom Surchand Singh
308. Thoidingjam Sunil Khuman
309. Yumnam Tarunbala Devi
310. Ngashepam Shanti Singh
311. Yanglem Sanaton Singh
312. Kayarnuddin
313. L. Anilkumar
314. Yamkhopao Touthang
315. Salem Imocha Singh
316. Laishram Nando Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 24
317. S. Ratna Devi
318. Brahmacharimayum Gyaneshwari Devi
319. S. Holendro Singh
320. LairikyengbamToniya
321. A. Shyamchand Singh
322. Sultana Begum
323. Takhellambam Promosini Devi
324. Athokpam Umabati Devi
325. A. Jayadev Sharma
326. Soraisam Meghachandra Singh
327. S. Ripon Singh
328. Yengkhom Thoibi Devi
329. Salam Meghachandra Singh
330. Yumnam Vedajit Singh
331. W. Sobha Singh
332. Sanasam Premananda Singh
333. Basantarani Pukhrambam
334. Shyamashakhee Nongthombam
335. Rajita Thingbaijam
336. Thounaojam Chanu Romabala 33 337. R.K. Romila Devi
338. Samukcham Romola Devi
339. N. Biramani Singh
340. Yumnan Tampha Devi
341. O. Modhochandra Singh
342. Konsam Ibungo Singh
343. Soibam Pramochandra Singh
344. Potshangbam Sabitri Devi
345. Thounaojam Neetu Chanu
346. Loitongbam Dadu Chanu W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 25
347. Ayam Thoi Singh
348. Vijaya Kongbrailatpam
349. Ch. Bogeshor Singh
350. Konsam Sanajaoba Singh
351. K. Bijoy Singh
352. Ibomcha Irengbam
353. Wham Nodiyachand Singh
354. angita Soram
355. Ningthomam Lukhoi Memel
356. Ngangom Rejia Devi 357. L. Sanahal Devi 358. Y. Premananda Singh
359. Ahongshangbam Monita Devi
360. Gopimohon Khundrakpam
361. Th. Bharat Singh
362. Thoudam Premila Devi
363. Ngaineihkim Gangte
364. Moirangthem Jayantakumar Singh
365. Lungthailiu Panmei
366. G. Surajkumar Sharma
367. Esther
368. Oinam Nepoleon Singh
369. Mashangvaljek Tangkhul
370. Th. James Singh
371. S. Subon Singh
372. Md. lqbal Shah
373. Suchin Akoijam
374. Laishram Surjitkumar Singh
375. Gourika Devi Naosekpam
376. Yendrembam Nomita Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 26
377. Ak. Santaraj Singh
378. Namminkparn Sunita Devi
379. N. Inungnganbi
380. Ranita Angom
381. N. Robindro Singh
382. Brahmacharimayum Ramananda Sharma
383. Gurumayum Surlekha Sharma
384. Ngangom Nilamani Singh
385. Kh. Herojit Singh
386. Md. Iahuruddin Shah
387. Oinam Shyamprakash Singh
388. Najib Ali
389. Khundrakpam Chanuleima Devi
390. Thokchom Tamphaibema Devi
391. S. Ibetombi Devi
392. Elangbam Jamuna Devi
393. Sunita Ngashepam
394. Naorem Nabachandra Singh
395. Ak.Nongmainingthou
396. Radha Naorem
397. Rupachandra Lourembam
398. Keisham Surjalata Devi
399. Kumam Devachandra Singh
400. Khaidem Ashokumar Singh
401. N. Sarat Singh
402. Ningombam Upendro Singh
403. Punshi Khuraijam
404. Lairikyengbam Vidya Roy
405. Hidam Ramananda Singh
406. Khumallambam Inakhunbi Devi
407. Leimapokpam Komol Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 27
408. Lourembam Bimorani Chanu
409. Ak. Brojendro Singh
410. Thingbaijam Chanu Merryland
411. M. Ratna Devi
412. Sagolsemcha Pathou Mangang
413. R.K. Jien Singh
414. Moirangthem Baleshwor Singh
415. M. Amrita Devi
416. Mohd. Anjar Khan
417. Laishram Sharmila Devi
418. Abdul Quadir
419. Yumnam Brojeshwori Devi
420. Ngangbam Bandana Devi
421. L. Bhanumati Devi
422. Elangbam Anita Devi
423. Leimapokoam Sunilkumar Singh
424. Ningombam Samananda Singh
425. Th. Surjiit Singh
426. Naorem Dharmendra
427. Goswami Kebi
428. Chongtham Bidyaleima Devi
429. S.Sunderjeet Singh
430. Konsam Sodeshini
431. Oinam Dhaneshwori Devi
432. Nongthombam Ravichandra Singh
433. Rajkumar Somorjit Singh
434. Sagolsem Roma Devi
435. L.Chitaranjan Singh
436. Nongmaithem Budhibala Devi
437. M. Pahari Singh
438. Laishram Tanita Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 28
439. Sanasam Dorendra Singh
440. Khaidem Ratan Meitei
441. Takhellambam Jayanta Singh
442. Monoharmayum Tangkeswor Sharma
443. L. Roohan Singh
444. Yuhlung Budhichandra Chothe
445. A. Shyam Singh
446. Sanjrambam Sandhyarani Devi
447. Leimapokpam Pratap Singh
448. Thaja Irom
449. Soibam Umeshwari Devi
450. Thangjam Romita Devi
451. Akoijam Priyokumar Singh
452. Orlando Laishram
453. Kh. Lolindro Singh
454. Aongshangbam Ajitkumar Singh
455. Kh. Joykumar Singh
456. Takhenchangbam Sunderchand Sharma
457. R.K. Dhanabir Singh
458. Wahengbam Inaocha Singh
459. Laishram Jugindro Singh
460. Sanasam Deban Singh
461. Sophia Akoijam
462. Nongthombam Purnima Devi
463. Longjam Joychandra Singh
464. Khwairakpam Suleja Devi
465. H. Sangtesana Chanu
466. Naorem lbomcha Singh
467. Samom Johnkumar Singh
468. Ayekpam Nandarani Devi
469. Usham Ranita W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 29
470. Yendrembam Phalguni Devi
471. K. Gautam Singh
472. Heisnam NilakantaSingh
473. Flangbam Upendra Singh
474. Kshetrimayum Nirmala Devi
475. Karam Bimola Devi
476. Huirem Meghachandra Singh
477. A. Basanta Kumar Singh
478. Ningthoujam Kennedy Singh
479. Heisnam Sobita Devi
480. Leitanthem Raiesh Singh
481. Puyarn Robindro Singh
482. Oinam Sandhyarani Devi
483. Oinam Medha Devi
484. Wanglembam Mobi Singh
485. Kh. Kamala Devi
486. Ningthoujam lngotomba Singh
487. Surbala Abujam
489. Laishram Suchitra Devi
490. Elam Salini Devi
491. Okram Ranjana Devi
492. Puyam Raniit Singh
493. Md Shoukat Ali
494. Sanasam Ira Singh
495. Hemam Umabati Devi
496. Kh. Belinda Devi
497. Sharmila Wahengbam
498. Th.Geetarani Devi
499. Ningthoujam Deepashree Devi
500. M.Premkumar Siungh
501. Kangujam Shanta Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 30
502. Niroda Kongbrailatpam
503. Rajkumar Naba Singh
504. Yumlembam Priobarta Singh
505. Aribam Chanchalkumari Devi
506. Taiyemjam Meghachandra Singh
507. Haobijam Lokendro Singh
508. S.Sanjeeb Sharma
509. S. Mala Devi
510. Ngangom Sharjubala Devi
511. Angom Robinson Singh
512. L. Kamala Devi
513. Lamabam Anjuna Devi
514. W. Amujao Meitei
515. Sagolsem Cha Binit
516. Brahmacharimayum Seityabrata Sharma
517. Loitongbam Ojen Singh
518. K. lndira Devi
519. Hemam Jiitcn Singh
520. Ch. Runchi Devi
521. Yumnam Sulochana Devi
522. W. Nungshitombi Devi
523. Laimayum Surjakumar Sharma
524. Khundongbam Ranjit Singh
525. Ningthouiam Rajendra Singh
526. Naorem Dhanajit Singh
527. Soubam Sunitibala Devi
528. Romeo
529. Khuraijam Roshan Kumar Singh
530. Ph.Gokulchandra Sharma
531. Angom Chanu Renubala
532. S.Imo Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 31
533. Sorokhaibam Gojen Singh
534. N. Mangal Sana
535. Koijam Premala
536. Oinam Broieshwar Singh
537. Sharungbam Nganthoi Chanu
538. Kshetrimayum Goiendro Singh
539. Kangjam Sobha Devi
540. Oinam Arunkumari Devi
541. Moirangthem Ajitkumar Singh
542. L.. Robert Singh
543. Indira Devi Sorokhaibam
544. Wahengbam Debola Devi
545. Nongthombam Nalini Devi
546. Khwairakpam Surjit Singh
547. Khwairakpm Wangkhei Singh
548. Thingbaijam Zenita
549. Huirem Rajen Kumar Singh
550. Ziaur Rahman
551. S. Chhayalaxmi Devi
552. Yumkhaibam Bimol Singh
553. Laishram Manoikumar
554. L. Dhramendra Meitei
555. Md. Nasir Hussain Shah
556. Laikangbam Shalini
557. A. Nonima Singha
558. Rajkuman Shivani
559. Kangjam Geetarani Devi
560. Y. Sanatombi Devi
561. R. K. Krishnakumari Devi
562. Oinam Doren Singh
563. Waikhom Bimota Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 32
564. Th. Surpriya Devi
565. R.K. Haridutta Singh
566. H.Ranjan Meetei
567. Hidangmayum Bishwashanti Sharma
568. Maikam Sharat Singh
569. Elangbam Nonibala Devi
570. Memthoi Takhellambam
571. Konsam Nokul Singh
572. Thounaojam Kanta Singh
573. lrengbam Nandini Devi
574. Jina Thokchom
575. Nongthombam Brojen Mectei
576. Naorem lbomcha Singh
577. Thiyam Dwijenkumar Singh
578. Maibam Tilotama Devi
579. Naorem Jibol Singh
580. Maibam Surjen Singh
581. Yumnam Binasakhi Devi
582. K.Sureshkumar Singh
583. Anwar Hussain
584. M. Meghachandra
585. Thoudam Maichael Singh
586. H.Surjit Singh
587. Aheibam Radhetombi Devi
588. Ningthouiam Thoiba Singh
589. Sorokhaibam Dhanachandra Singh
590. A. Inaotombi Singh
591. Kongbrailatpam Romeo Sharma
592. Khilona Thokchom
593. Naorem Nimaichand Singh
594. Th. Bimola Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 33
595. Hemam Jinibala Devi
596. Md .Rashid Ali
597. M. Romeo Singha
598. Firoz Khan
599. Kshetrimayum Vivekananda Singh
600. Ningombam Romita Devi
601. Thingbaijam Gagarin Singh
602. Oinam Hemanta Meetei
603. Huirem Rakesh Singh
604. L. Dhanajit
605. S. Madhumati Devi
606. Khuraijam Phalguni Devi
607. Thangjam lnaobi Devi
608. L. Homen Meetei
609. Sagolsem Saraju Devi
610. Th. Ranijta Devi
611. Keisam Zenithta Devi
612. Mohd Noor-Ul Hasan Shah
613. K. Bidita Devi
614. S. Gurucharan Singh
615. Yengkokpam Ajitkumar Singh
616. M. Luhen Singh
617. Keisham Jiban Singh
618. Thingbaijam Dharamendra Singh
619. Thounaojam Shyamo Singh
620. A. Anita Devi
621. Ningthoujam Ramdas Singh
622. N. Bilash Singh
623. Thokchom Shurjitkumar Singh
624. Keisam Chinglenkhomba
625. Thokchom Nimai Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 34
626. T. Babita Devi
627. Leishangthem Amba Chanu
628. N. Kirankumar Singh
629. Laishram Chaoba Singh
630. Ninthemcha Tomba Meetei
631. Ningthoujam Manglem Singh
632. Konsam Santoshkumar
633. Maimom lngo Singh
634. Laishram Jugeshwar Singh
635. Waikhom Jotindro Singh
636. Ningombam Meghachandra Singh
637. Tourangbam Toto Singh
638. Yumnam Sangjta Devi
639. Thongam Chanu Chingkheileima
640. Aribam Sanajaobi Devi
641. L. Neheru Singh
642. Yumnam Shanta Singh
643. Shreemayum Premkumar Sharma
644. L. Broien Singh
645. Maibam Dijen Singh
646. Thiyam Devkiran Singh
647. Chandam Heramani Singh
648. Linthoingambi Wairokpam
649. Laishram Joykumar Singh
650. Ningombam Sarjubala Devi
651. Jiten Sharma
652. N. Premkumar Singh
653. Tongbram Rebarani Devi
654. Sunil Ahanthem
655. Mutum Manbi Devi
656. Hemam Bheigyachandra Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 35
657. Khundrakpam Asharani Devi 658 Kh. Dharmendra Singh
659. Khundongbam Ashokumar Singh
660. W. Khadrakpa Singh
661. Rikhi Philemon
662. L.Okendro Singh
663. K. Sow Stephen
664. Anne Chandam
665. Yengkhom Binapati Devi
666. L. Ashokumar Singh
667. Asem Nongyai Singh
668. Thokchom Premchand Singh
669. Lalboi Telien
670. Khwairakpam Jibon Singh
671. Raomai Thomas
672. Puyam James Singh
673. Akoiiam Sobita Devi
674. Wangkheimayum Phulindro Singh
675. Soram Jati Devi
676. L. Ranjanakumari Devi
677. Kshetrimayum Shamananda Singh
678. Nongmaithem Ronel Singh
679. Hoikhochong Lhungdim
680. Mongjam Anila Devi
681. Meithuan Pamei
682. Taorem Jeeban Khuman
683. Sanasam Mohendra Singh
684. Khundrakpam Punyabati Devi
685. Kimjaneng Koroung
686. Renuka Huidrom
687. Ch. Deborah Gangte W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 36
688. Mili Karam
689. Ningombam Surjit Singh
690. Md. Tamijur Rahaman
691. Salam Bimolchand Singh
692. Ningthoujam Premlata Devi
693. Jasha Cecilia Anal
694. Md. Arzad Ali
695. Sangita Sorokhaibam
696. Haobam Beejen Meitei
697. Thingujam Irabot Singh
698. Salam Sundip Singh
699. Heisnam Linthoingambi Devi
700. Ksh. Bhopender Singh
701. Okram Rajendro Singh
702. Ningthoujam Shivamkumar Singh
703. Naorem Mani Singh
704. M. Christamani
705. Shagolsem Anand Singh
706. Thoudam Rebika Chanu
707. K. S. V. Raamses Kahorthing
708. Sila Sinam
709. Ruivahnao Apem Shimray
710. Oinam Gitchandra Singh
711. Ameeta Huidrom
712. Amom Ronesh Singh
713. Langkoklakpam Melina Chanu
714. Indrani Akoiiam
715. Laishram Binasakhi Devi
716. Kongkham Loidang Devi
717. Maharabam Leibaklei Devi
718. Jaichand Oinam W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 37
719. Irengbam Ruhinikumar Singh
720. Chongtham Gilbert Singh
721. Khaidem Sunanda Devi
722. Soyam Nungshithoibi Devi
723. Tongbram Priyokumar Singh
724. S. Jotish Singh
725. Oinam Shyam Singh
726. Oinam Shyamo Singh
727. Md. Nurul Hussain
728. Premabati Leishangthem
729. Shemreingam Mungrei
730. M. Renubala Devi
731. Thiyam Jairam Singh
732. Hanjabam Shanta Devi
733. Sr. Tohring
734. N. Ranjita Devi
735. Adani Lokho
736. Th. Subhaschandra Singh
737. Haile Peter
738. Th.Motilal Singh
740. Ngamkhohou Baite
741. E. Khogen Singh
742. Khumanthem lngocha
743. R.K Dhaneshwari
744. Maharabam Neshwari Devi
745. Athokpam Sunanda
746. Adhikarimayum Brojenkumar Shanna
747. Khumallambam Nirmala Devi
748. Salam Premlata Devi
749. L. Ishwarjit Sharma
750. TakhellambamRobindro Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 38
751. Salam Naran Singh
752. Singmipam Khamrang
753. I.Dhani Devi
754. Chirom Jadumani Singh
755. Maisnam Premchand Singh
756. S. P. Philamaya
757. K Dineshchandra Singh
758. Reisang Iloram
759. Mamata Tayenjam
760. Simon Pukeho
761. Pukhrambam Shantikumar Singh
762. Ingudam Sanjoy Singh
763. Th. Somorjit Singh
764. Moirangthem Jiten Sinsth
765. Chongtham Chittaranjan Singh
766. Soibam Joymilan Singh
767. Ch. Indira Devi
768. N. Nityai Singh
769. N. Bembem Devi
770. Thounaojam Shyamashakhi Chanu
771. Bachaspatimayum Winchester Sharma
772. Yumnam Hemapati Chanu
773. Senjam Manju Devi
774. Jangkhothang Hoakip
775. Kh. Dhananjoy Singh
776. Naorem Surjit Singh
777. L. Ritendro Singh
778. Chongkhoncnit Chongloi
779. U. Ibohal Singh
780. Silas M ram
781. Ningthoujam Milankrishna W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 39
782. P. M Joy Charles
783. Keithelakpam Nandini Devi
784. Wahengbam Tuleshwori Devi
785. P. Jagatmani Singh
786. Nongmeikapam Omika Devi
787. Th.Venuchandra Singh
788. Nongmaithem Bikramjit Singh
789. Taorem Bhavini Devi
790. Debory Fimsangpui
791. Kh. Sanayaima Singh
792. Salam Rajeshwar Singh
793. Khaidem Sharat Singh
794. Samuel Shelly
795. Laishram Romita Devi
796. Sagolsem Linthoingambi Devi
797. Moirangthem.9aniit Singh
798. Aribam Shyammuhini Devi
799. Mayengbam Bhorot Singh
800. Thaigongam Dangmei
801. Takhellambam lbocha Singh
802. Kangababam Premchandra Singh
803. Ng. sanajaobi Devi
804. Aheibam Sanatomba Singh
805. Salam Janori Devi
806. M. Doukllomang Haokip
807. Sapam Jotindra Singh
808. K.S. Jehu Tangkhul
809. Kh.Premchand Singh
810. Sarita Laithangbam
811. Yumnam Sunil Singh
812. Samson Soro W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 40
813. Akoiiam lbochouba Singh
814. Wungreisun R. S.
815. L. Santa Devi
816. Akhuwan Kamei
817. Gotimayum Kennedy Sharma
818. John Ragui
819. Yumnam Sarajlakshrni Devi
820. Lalthuoikim Pangamte
821. Tongbram Jugin Singh
822. Konjengbam Chungkhonleima Chanu
823. Dinbuiyang
824. Khampi Pamei
825. S. Khamminthang Ngaihei
826. Ragailung Gonmei
827. V.S. Mashunthing
828. H. Lalthamuan
829. Yuimi Varam
830. Pantina Panmei
831. Esau Shaiza
832. Zeanut
833. Greenmila Rungsung
834. Patricia Neaihlun Thawmte
835. Thothor Muinao
836. Lalhminghlu
837. Patrina Ngaihlun Thawmte
838. Z. Pamreishang Shimray
839. S. Ngulzaching Negaihte
840. Lalthalur Infimate
841. Lalnghaklien Khobung
842. Dangmei Gaingamlong R Naga
843. Lamkhohen W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 41
844. H. Thangtungnung
845. Gangmei Surjit Kabui
846. Zamkholen Haokip
847. R.Muinao Tangkhul
848. Sochipem Keishing
849. Lalhmunsiama
850. Maibam Edula Devi
851. Ruijom Ruisosame Aimol
852. Jonathan Th
853. Sharon Gangte
854. Ruwndar Lastny Anal
855. Thangminlien Kilong
856. Sosochon Jajo
857. Keinamgong A. Riamei
858. Shylas Paoruw
859. Leivon Soneglerchung Kom
860. William Chanisii
861. Kamlunmang Kit>!!.cn
862. Salam Santosh Singh
863. Th. Ngailian Vaiphei
864. Yengkhom Jaken Singh
865. K. Siamkhanmuan Shamte
866. Leishangthem Manju//////////
867. Phelim Keishing Tangkhul
868. Khuraijam Rameshowri Devi
869. Namthiuwangbow Newmai
870. T. Kaikhanmuan
871. S.N. Bongshel Lamkang
872. Roel Margaret Moyon
873. Gaichui Malangmei
874. Jankholal Mate W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 42
875. Seikhomang Guite
876. Felly Hatneiting
877. Julia Golmei
878. Shornalu Phaomei
879. Nemjalam Doungel
880. Minhlung Anal
881. Lunkhothang Haokip
882. Letkholal
883. Sonminlian S. Haokip
884. Thoveini Peter
885. S. Chinhoikim
886. Awungshi Shimray N.
887. Shukrengzam Chiru
888. Phangamsung Ronra Shimray
889. T. Thuamkhanvung
890. Thienkhohao Touthang
891. Lankhollung Dangmei
892. Tungnung George Ginsuanlian Zou
893. Cecilia Zemei
894. Khopuneme Easter Arila
895. KL Warson Anal
896. Suantak Mercy Vaiphei
897. Phakholom Haokip
898. Sonkhosei Kilong
899. Thanglienlal C. Thangzom
900. S.R. Berilus
901. Arfina Haokip
902. Siambiakkim
903. Mayanglambam Brajabinodo Singh
904. Usham Anuradha
905. Shamjetshabam Thambou Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 43
906. A. Mary
907. Mayanglambam Cheiteinya Singh
908. Thiyam Surajkumar
909. N. Sumita Devi
910. P. Manikho
911. Ksh. Meghachandra Singh
912. Boisy Thangneivah
913. M. Maipak Singh
914. Heikrujam Sachikumar Singh
915. Maharabam Jamuna Devi
916. Elangbam Sunibala Devi
917. Ksh. Amarjit Singh
918. Nongmaithem Surjit Singh
919. Naorem Sangita Devi
920. Mayanglambam lndubala Devi
921. Y. Amujao Singh
922. Mayanglambam Praphullo Singh
923. Dineshchandra Haobijam
924. Thoudam Santa Singh
925. T. Lamkhoneng Haokip
926. Mayanglambam Chandrasekhar Singh
927. S. Lunjacob Vaiphei
928. Koningam Bungdon
929. Leivon. Damrenghui Kom
930. Amom Dilip Singh
931. G. Akimpou Kabui
932. Yumnam Sanjit Singh
933. Wahengbam Radhetombi Devi
934. Amom Raju Singh
935. Khundrakpam Devachandra Singh
936. Ruwndnr Nunsthnnit Anal W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 44
937. Mayanglambam Robin Singh
938. Mayanglilinbam Sapna Devi
939. Thingnam Ronita Devi
940. Khumukcham Ranibala Devi
941. Kshetrimavum Tampha Devi
942. Kshetrimayum Rani Devi
943. Yengkhom Sumita Devi
944. Oinam Chandrakumar Singh
945. Yumkhaibam lbomcha Meetei
946. L.Bono Singh
947. Chingakham Sujita Devi
948. Pukhrambam Chinglen Singh
949. Angom Manoi Kumar Singh
950. Meera Pheiroijam
951. Maibam Biiendra Singh
952. Warepam Sajuk Singh
953. Pheiroijam Shyamsunnder Singh
954. Shambanduram Daneel Singh
955. Pukhrambam Justice Singh
956. Kangabam Sunderchand Singh
957. A. Ratankumar Sharma
958. Rajkumar Bhupendra Singh
959. Laiphrakpam Zinco Singh
960. Chabungbam Somorjit Singh
961. Ahongsangbam Jayanta Singh
962. Ningthojam Dharamendra Singh
963. Hemam Bembem Devi
964. Khadrakpa Moirangthem
965. Ningthoujam Mahabir
966. Yurembam Jogen Singh
967. Philem Radharani Devi W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 45
968. Thokchom Sunil Meeti
969. Kakchingtabam Budhadev Sharma
970. Laithangbam Pushparani Devi
971. Langpoklakpam Hectorkumar
972. Amita Gurumayum
973. Longjam Lilashwori Devi
974. Aribam Utam Sharma
975. Thokchom Keat Singh
976. Konjengbam Minashwori
977. Ishwari Thiyam
978. Monica Yengkhom
979. Anuradha Khaidem
980. Laishram Jaysandeep Singh
981. Mutum Gopeshwor Singh
982. Sanatombi Chabungbam
983. Khundrakoam Gautam Singh
984. Yumkham Sarita Devi
985. Lairenlakpam Mirabati
986. Candela Takhellambam
987. Chirom Jolin Singh
988. Heikrujam Nevarani Devi
989. Laishram Nomita
990. Govind Oinam
991. Khangembam Nanao Devi
992. Khunjamayum SunitaDevi
993. Asem Priyoshakhi Devi
994. Amarwaljit Thounaojam
995. Shanglakpam Lakshmi Devi
996. Shahnaz Beguim
997. MoiranRthem Nawalkishore Singh
999. Bindia Laipubam W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 46
1000. Huidrom Sally
1001. Yengkhom Panche Chanu
1002. Khundrakpam Raman Singh 1003 Kshetrimayum Ibotombi Singh
1004. Khuraijam Dhananjoy Singh
1005. Pebam Sobharani Devi 1006 Lairellakpam Rita Devi
1007. Romesh Rajkumar
1008. Ngangom Prem Kumar Singh
1009. Mayengbam Meenakshi Devi
1010. Rajkumari Sanjita Devi
1011. Sanasam Renuka Devi
1012. Waikhom Robindro Sangh
1013. Nameirakpam Anuradha Devi
1014. Thounaojam Thabaleima
1015. Ningthoujam lndrajit Singh
1016. Chabungbam Shomita Devi
1017. Shamurailatpam Shantanu Sharma
1018. Ayekpam Angamba Meitei
1019. Rajkwrori Uttam Devi
1020. Konika Lourembam
1021. Oinam Geeta Devi
1022. Laishram Bijen Singh
1023. Chongtham Chandrakala Devi
1024. Md. Abdul Hashim
1025. Senjam Omala Devi
1026. Suchitra Taorem
1027. Naorem Ranjan Singh
1028. Yumnam Romamanjuri Devi
1029. Sinam Sanjib Singh
1030. Shamurailatpam Doren Sharma W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 47
1031. Thingnganing Awungshang
1032. Apem K. H.
1033. Huidrom Surrmla Devi
1034. Zanyo Varam
1035. Khaidem Mandakini Devi
1036. Alamjan Bibi
1037. Chingangbam Sujata Devi
1038. Thiyam Dharmendra Singh
1039. Laishram Nirmala Devi
1040. Vungzamoi
1041. Nongthombam Nandita Devi
1042. Orient Thansing R.S
1043. Joshua Kazingmei
1044. Soram Inaobi Singh
1045. Yumnam Nandita Devi
1046. Mongjam Ranjan Singh
1047. Naorem Romio Singh
1048. Themreichan Sharon S.
1049. Sudip Dhar
1050. Irom Ichal Devi
1051. Mayengbam Surak Singh
1052. S. kaminlun Vaiphei
1053. Naorem Yani Devi
1054. Tongbram Dham Singh
1055. Miranda Luithui
1056. Zcnmuanching
1057. Sonia Sanienbam
1058. Duidang Wonshimla
1059. Sally Niangngaihching Guite
1060. Konsam Nishikanta Singh
1061. Chanambam Bisheswor Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 48
1062. Jacob Laldomsang
1063. Lourembam Yaioharembi Devi
1064. Thiekzakhuo Buhril
1065. Haobam Rajashree Devi
1066. Ngaranmi Asara
1067. Nianlhianslam
1068. Ginkaolian
1069. Ashangbam Samani Devi
1070. Chingtham Babykiran Devi
1071. Cherry Kasom
1072. Manoharmayum Pushpanjali
1073. Nongmaithem Tilotama Devi
1074. Rajkumar Sanachaoba Singh
1075. Thuamneihmawii
1076. Sorokhaibam Supriva
1077. Chiinthianhoih
1078. Wungnaolui Luikham
1079. Yaothingwon Phawung
1080. Ninothoujam Nebedita Devi
1081. Soreiya Khongreiwo
1082. L. Chuimila
1083. C. Kam Thian Mang
1084. Mayonao Lungleng
1085. Lourembam Leenabai Devi
1086. Sonia Kongsong
1087. Wairokpam Pusoarani Devi
1088. Laishram Somobala Devi
1089. Rinsophy Ragui
1090. Pau Sonal Singson
1091. Jyotsana Lourembam
1092. Jasmine Hajarimayurn W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 49
1093. Leiphrakpam Sarnalata Devi
1094. Sagolsem Reedy Devi
1095. Laishram Kapil
1096. Takhellambam Manichandra Meitei
1097. Haobijam Shyamananda Singh
1098. Chongtham Apurba Singh
1099. Phuritsabam Yudhistrytatha Singh
1100. A. Vivekananda Singha
1101. Auegustine Anal
1102. Keisham Suresh Singh
1103. Sanasam Dijeshori
1104. Mangvungjamkhoneng Haokip
1105. T. Doukhoshon Haokip
1106. Db. Shantina Lamkang
1107. Sumpi Peter Anal
1108. Ashem Jamuna Devi
1109. Thangjam Nandashyam Singh
1110. Khwairakpam Tomcha Singh
1111. Wungminao Vashumwo
1112. Ngangom Manichandra Singh
1113. Amom Pushband Singh
1114. Nongmaithem Jugindro Singh
1115. Konjengbam Noyon Singh
1116. A. S. Boniface Phungyo
1117. Salam Apabi Singh
1118. Namthuilung Kamei
1119. Khundrakparn Bimol Singh
1120. R. S. Lucas
1121. Khangembam Bimol Singh
1122. P. Rammung
1123. Naorem Juegeshwar Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 50
1124. Lunkim Kaikhomang Khongsai
1125. Md. Muhammad Khan
1126. Lairenlakpam Bimol Singh
1127. Chongnu Kilong
1128. Wahengbam Bira Singh
1129. L. Thanmila
1130. Khugai Kamei
1131. Shapam Maipak Meitei
1132. P.S. John
1133. Huidrom Brojen Singh
1134. Mutum Lalmani Singh
1135. Haobijam Oken Singh
1136. R. A. Willington
1137. Irengbam Gandhajit Singh
1138. Ahongshabam Rajen Singh
1139. Ningthoujam Deben Singh
1140. Tonton Pheiray
1141. Nandalal Baral
1142. Shangngam Mayirnao
1143. A. S. Josiah
1144. Lalkai Chongloi
1145. Makujinang Philip
1146. Sanasam Prasanta Singh
1147. Mangshatabam Iboyairna Singh
1148. Pukhrambam Dayabati Devi
1149. Chongtham Hemanta Raj
1150. Salomie Panmei
1151. Rajkumari Bhanisana Devi
1152. Waikhom Umakanta Singh
1153. Jims Shadang
1154. Urikhimbam Baleshwor Singh W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 51
1155. Guitiang Panmei
1156. Ningthoukhongjam Ranjita Devi
1157. A. S. Redeemson
1158. Anoubam Devadutta Sharma
1159. Elizabeth Gangmei
1160. Howrei Panmea
1161. Shimeichan Rongray Shimray
1162. Athuma Panmei
1163. Huidrom Menaka Devi
1164. Shamurailatpam Nimaichand Sharma
1165. Salam Robiya Meitei
1166. Ngangbam Premlata Devi
1167. Moirangthem Gandhamani Singh
1168. Chanabam Shyamjit Singh
1169. Nongmaithem Vikram Singh
1170. Heisnam Gojen Meetei
1171. Thanjluliu Colme1
1172. Moirangthem Roshan Singh
1173. Kangabam Robikumar Singh
1174. Irom Bimol Singh
1175. Aribam Gyaneshwor Sharma
1176. Ok Somendro Singh
1177. Elangbam Homeshwari Devi
1178. Konthoujam Ranjita Devi
1179. Devikarani Khundrakpam
1180. Kshetrimayurn Mirabai Devi
1181. Yumnam Laksikanta Singh
1182. Maibam Somen Singh
1183. Nongmaithem Sanjiv Singh
1184. Mayanglambam Bebarani Devi
1185. Mayengbam Diana Chanu W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 52
1186. Khumukchrun Bebeshwori Devi
1187. Yumnam Binita Chanu
1188. Lhunthang Lunkim
1189. Laishram Vivekananda Singh
1190. T. Tongkholun Haokip
1191. Khuraijam Leibakleima Chanu
1192. S. Debananda Singh
1193. Dhiraj Sharma Sanglakpam
1194. Khaidem Jayananda Singh
1195. Joykumar Wahengbam
1196. Longjam Wilburd Singh
1197. Kongkham Babyshila Devi
1198. Phianringamang Panmei
1199. Md. Wahajuddin
1200. Mani Ibema Ksh
1201. Pheiroijam Singhajit Singh
1202. B. Harichoron Sharma
1203. Singam Leimatombi
1204. Ningmareo Shimray
1205. Gou Biak Ching
1206. S.R.Thotchuila … Respondents. HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN BEFORE For the Petitioners For the Respondents :: :: Mr. HS Paonam, Senior Advocate Mr. S. Nepolean, GA Date of Hearing and reserving Judgment & Order ::
17.06.2022 Date of Judgment & Order ::
13.07.2022 W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 53 JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV) Mr.S.Nepolean, learned Government Advocate, accepts notice on behalf of the respondents 1 and 2.
2. Heard Mr.HS Paonam, learned senior counsel for the petitioners and Mr.S.Nepolean, learned Advocate respondents 1 and 2. This writ petition has been heard and reserved at the admission stage itself.
3. This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners to quash the notification dated 20.04.2022 thereby publishing the tentative seniority list of Lecturers in Government Higher Secondary School and to direct the respondents to fix the seniority of the Lecturers in Government Higher Secondary School strictly in terms of the relevant provision of seniority rules of Government of Manipur and relevant rules and also settled principles of law.
4. Mr. H.S. Paonam, the learned senior counsel for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners are the direct recruits appointed in the year 2016 on the recommendation of the Manipur Public Service Commission. He would submit that the petitioners are aggrieved by the fixation of seniority among the direct recruits and promotion on the basis of Recruitment Rules, 2021 and not in W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 54 accordance with Recruitment Rules, 1997 where under the petitioners were appointed.
5. The learned senior counsel further submitted that the petitioner are also aggrieved by the placement of the regularized contract Lecturers above them since the direct recruits were selected earlier than the regularization of the contract Lecturers. Moreover, regularization is not a mode of appointment and the regularization having been done de hors the rules, the employees cannot be placed above the direct recruits appointed on the recommendation of the MPSC.
6. The learned senior counsel urged that in the impugned notification, it has been informed that any claims and objections to the tentative seniority list may be submitted on or before 12.5.2022. Aggrieved by the erroneous fixation of the seniority position of the direct recruits of 2016, some of the petitioners have filed their objections on 11.5.2022 claiming that the tentative seniority list is erroneous since the same has been fixed on the basis of Recruitment Rules of Lecturers of Government Higher Secondary Schools published in 2021, wherein the method of recruitment is 50% by direct recruitment and 50% by promotion. Further, in the said objection, it was also mentioned that the regularized contract W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 55 Lecturers of Government Higher Secondary Schools should be placed enbloc below the direct recruits appointed on recommendation of the MPSC. However, till date the said objection has not been considered by the competent authority. However, the petitioners are reliably learnt that based on the impugned tentative seniority list, process has been taken up for conferring the higher charge of Vice-Principal of Higher Secondary School. Thus, the learned senior counsel prayed for set aside the impugned tentative seniority list.
7. Per contra, Mr. S. Nepolean, the learned Government Advocate appearing for the official respondents submitted that there is no error in publishing the impugned tentative seniority list and the seniority list impugned has been prepared and published taking into consideration all the relevant Recruitment Rules and, therefore, there is no flaw in it. Apart from this, the official respodnents called the claims and objections to the tentative seniority list may be submitted on or before 12.05.2022 and accordingly, some of the petitioners have filed their objections on 11.05.2022 and the same is pending for consideration. If the petitioners are aggrieved on the orders passed by the respondents on the objections dated
11.05.2022 the petitioners are very well to challenge the same in W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 56 accordance with law. Therefore, ths writ petition is premature. Therefore, there is no ground to cause interference in the impugned tentative seniority list. Thus, the learned Government Advocate prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
8. This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the materials on record.
9. The grievance of the petitioners is that in the tentative seniority list, the seniority position of the petitioners has been fixed on the basis of the Recruitment Rules of Lecturers of Government Higher Secondary Schools published in 2021, wherein the method of recruitment is 50% by direct recruitment and 50% by promotion and promotees and direct recruits are placed one after another according to the rotation of vacancies as prescribed in the Recruitment Rules, 2021. Such fixation is erroneous because seniority has to be fixed on the basis of the rules in existence when one entered service and it cannot be fixed on the basis of subsequently amended rules. Therefore, the seniority position of the Lecturers of Government Higher Secondary Schools should be fixed on the basis of 1997 Recruitment Rules, wherein 66 -2/3% is provided for direct recruitment and 33 -1/3% is provided for promotion. According to the petitioners, the placement of contract W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 57 Lecturers of the Government Higher Secondary Schools who were regularized vide order dated 12.5.2016 is contrary to the rules and also against the notification issued by the Government of Manipur from time to time in regard to fixation of seniority.
10. The learned senior counsel for the petitioners urged that the direct recruits who were appointed on the basis of the recommendation of the Selection Committee after following due process shall be placed enblock above those regularized back door entrants who entered service without following the due selection process.
11. As could be seen from the records that the petitioners have applied to the post of Lecturers in the Government Higher Secondary Schools pursuant to the advertisement dated 8.11.2014 issued by the MPSC and the written examination for selection process was held on 22.2.2015 and the result of the same was declared on 13.8.2015. The petitioners were found qualified for the personality test for selection to the post of Lecturers and the personality test was held between 13.9.2015 and 18.9.2015 and a subject wise merit list was published on 18.9.2015.
12. According to the petitioners, even though the MPSC had furnished a copy of the recommendation to the Government for W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 58 appointment to the post of Lecturers of Higher Secondary Schools in School Education Department for taking necessary steps on
2.11.2015, the appointment order could not be issued in favour of the selected candidates because of the interim orders of this Court operating at the relevant time. Subsequently, those interim orders stand vacated thereby granting liberty to the respondent authorities to proceed with the recruitment process as far as the appointment under direct recruitment to the post of Lecturers in Higher Secondary Schools as per the recommendation of the MPSC is concerned. Pursuant thereof, the State Government was pleased to appoint 180 recommended candidates as Lecturers of Government Higher Secondary Schools on 31.8.2016, including the petitioners. Thereafter, by another order dated 18.11.2016, nine candidates were given appointment from waiting list. Therefore, the learned senior counsel for the petitioners contended that the petitioners are seniors to the private respondents and accordingly, they could be placed above the contract Lecturers.
13. There is no dispute that the appointment to the post of Lecturer of Higher Secondary Schools is governed by a recruitment called the Education (S) Department Manipur (Lecturer of Higher Secondary Schools) Recruitment Rules, 1997. Under the said W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 59 rules, as stated supra, the method of recruitment is 63 – 2/3% is by direct recruitment and 33 – 1/3% by promotion. The post of Lecturer of Higher Secondary Schools is classified as Class-I Gazetted by the said Recruitment Rules.
14. The Government of Manipur decided to regularize the services of 707 contract Lecturers in Government Higher Secondary Schools with immediate effect vide order dated
12.5.2016 and, accordingly, the services of the contract Lecturers have been regularized on 12.05.2016. Since the regularization of the contract Lecturers is prior to the appointment of the direct recruits, how the direct recruits can be placed above the contract Lecturers as sought for by them. Anyhow, the said aspect of the matter cannot be gone into in this writ petition.
15. Nothing has been placed on record to show that the private respondents are back door entrants and are entered into service without following the due selection process. That apart, the said factual aspects of the matter cannot be decided in the writ petition and nothing has been produced and/or established to show that the impugned notification is erroneous.
16. Further, the case of the petitioners is that the private respondents are surplus contract employees and in order to give a W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 60 solution to human problems, they are regularized in their respective services. Since regularization is not a recognized mode of recruitment under the Recruitment Rules, those regularized contract Lecturers from a different category and they ought to be placed below the direct recruits of the same recruitment year cannot be gone into, for the reason that whether the regularization of the private respondents is legal or illegal is not the subject-matter of an issue in this writ petition. If the petitioners are so aggrieved by the regularization of the contract Lecturers of the Government Higher Secondary Schools, they will have to question the same at the relevant point of time and the same cannot be questioned in the present writ petition.
17. At this juncture, the learned Government Advocate submitted that the determination of seniority of the employees working in the Government is regulated by the Office Memorandum of the Government of Manipur and after following the rules and the applicable Office Memorandum only, the impugned tentative seniority list has been prepared.
18. Though the petitioners, by relying upon various Office Memorandums of the Manipur submitted that the determination of inter-se seniority amongst the direct recruits and the promotee and W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 61 the regularized contract Lecturers ought to be placed below the direct recruits appointed on the recommendation of the MPSC, the said aspects of two issues cannot be gone into in the present writ petition.
19. It appears that pursuant to the impugned tentative seniority list, the petitioners 2 and 17 alone have submitted their objections. Nothing has been produced by the petitioners to show that the other petitioners have also submitted their objection to the impugned tentative seniority list. If an employee is so aggrieved by the tentative seniority list published by the department, it is the bounden duty of the employee to submit his/her objection within the time given in the notification publishing the tentative seniority list. By using and relying upon the said representations of the petitioners 2 and 17, the petitioners numbering 95 have filed the present writ petition questioning the impugned tentative seniority list.
20. The impugned tentative seniority list was published on
20.04.2022, thereby the Deputy Secretary (Education-S), Government of Manipur calling for claims and objections to the tentative seniority list of Lecturers by prescribing the time limit on or before 12.5.2022 with a condition that the claims and objections received after the last date shall not be entertained.The petitioners W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 62 2 and 17 have submitted their objections/claims to the impugned seniority list on 11.05.2022 and the writ petition was filed on
16.6.2022 without giving a reasonable time to the department to consider the objections/claims made by them. Thus, the writ petition appears to be premature. In the case on hand, the receipt of the objections/claims of the petitioners 2 and 17 dated 11.5.2022 has not been disputed by the official respondents.
21. Since the petitioners have raised an issue that the contract Lecturers of the Government Higher Secondary Schools should be placed enbloc below the direct recruits appointed on the recommendation of the MPSC, this Court is of the view that in order to give quietus to the matter, it would be appropriate to direct the official respondents to treat the objections/claims submitted by the petitioners 2 and 17 as common to all the petitioners and, accordingly, pass an order in accordance with law taking note of the same as common grievance of the petitioners.
22. Accordingly, a) the writ petition is dismissed as premature. b) respondents No. 1 and 2 are directed to consider the claims/objections dated 11.5.2022 submitted by the petitioners 2 to 17 to the impugned tentative W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 63 seniority list and pass orders in accordance with law taking note of the same as common grievance of the petitioners to give quietus to the issue. c) the petitioners are at liberty to challenge if they aggrieved the order to be passed by respondents No.1 and 2 based on claims/objections dated 11.05.2022. d) No cost. JUDGE FR/NFR Sushil W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022