BELLARY v. DHARWAD

Judgment

1. THE STATE BY SUB iNSPECTOR OF POLiCE, KOVFUR POLICE STATION, BELLARY DISTRICT, REP. BY SPP. HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT BENCH DHARWAD. ... RESPONDENT (By Sri :V.M.BANAKAR,ASPP RECORDS THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.2790/ 2009 IS FILED UNDER SECTION 374(2)CR.P.C BY THE ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANTS SEEKING TO CALL FOR ENTIRE NO.64/2006 DTD.14/10/2009 ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSION JUDGE AT BELLARY & B) ALLOW THE APPEAL AND THE JUDOEMENT AND SENTENCE ACQUfl7ING THE APPELLANTS HEREIN FROM ALL THE CHARGES WITH WHICH THEY ARE CHARGED. SET ASIDE SC IN THESE CRIMINAL APPEALS COMING ON FOR HEARiNG THIS DAY, MOHAN SHANTANAGOUDAR J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: - JUDGMENT These appeals arise out of the Judgment and order dated 14-10-2009 passed by District & Sessions Judge, Beflary, in Sessions Case No.64/2006. The A :4: accused were tried for the offences punishable under Sections 447, 326, 307. 114 read with Section 34 IPC. The Trial Court convicted the accused for the olfences tinder Section 326 of IPC and sentenced them to undergo imprisonment for a period of 3 months and to pay fine of Rs.2,000/- each. with default clause. They are acquitted of other charges.

2. Criminal Appeal No.2869/2010 is filed by the State questioning the Judgment and order of acquittal passed by the Cqurt below acquitting the accused for the offence punishable under Section 307 read with Section 34 IPC, whereas, Criminal Appeal No.2790/ 2009 is convicted accused questioning the Judgment and order of conviction in respect of the offence punishable under Section 326 read with Section 34 of IPC.

3. The case of the prosecution in brief is that there was rivalry between the accused on one side and P.W.5 and his famil’ members on the other. in respect of a 1 9 N . ) N ) N N N H N . N ) N ) N N iN - N 2N - ) N N i - : ) N 0 - H H N O C : 2 2 N N $ i i 1 9 4 ) N ) N N N _ . H ) C ) ) N N N i N ) N H N 1 9 . N N H H N N 0 NNNNN N N N H N N ) N N N ) N 1 9 i i C i L N N N N N . 2 . 2 1 C 9 H r c N N N ) N ) N N — N . - — N N 9 N ) C ) N N . N < r 2 - . ) N 4 ) C N — ) N - N f _ . ‘ I C C 2 L a C ) N N N ) N N N N - N r N . N N ) N N N , * N N N 2 1 9 . 9 . N N N N H - N N , N N ’ 0 N - N - N 2N ) N — ) N N N ) C ) N , 4 ) N 2 H N N N N r — I C N ) o C ) N N 2 N . , , ) N N N N NN - H — 9 , . 1 9 C < ) N N N ) 9 N H < ) N . N E H N N 2 o N N H N N ) N N E ) N N 2N N - N - N N ) N 0 * 2 N ) N N ) N : N 9NN , : 9 N N ) N N - N * 2 - N ) N N N N ) N N— N N N N E H ) N N N 2 4 % 1 N ) C ) C < N ) : ) C ) N N H N ) - - - 2 2 . a N N N2N o H N N - N N ) - N N N ) N ) N o o N N N . 1 9 ) N N N * 2 N N ) N N N N ( N N • - 1 N N — ) N N 1 9 N N N N N N 9 ) N N 0 4 O C H —N H N N N - ) N N ) N o N N N N N N N N ) 2 : 2 ) N N NN ) N o N - • 4 N . ) N : 2 N H N o - ) N N N N r 2 9 $ Z . . . 0 N ) ) N N N N 2 . 2 2 4 N N N H N N N ) N N N . N N N 2 N - N ) N H : - N N N . 4 N N N N N N ) N N H N N N : : 9 2 2 . N N 4 4 2 2N N N - N N ) 9 N H N a N ) C N N — ) ) ) N H N N 9 N N N ) N N N N N N N N ) NN N N N N N — . ) ) H N 1 9 . o N . N a9 0 E . N 9 - N — ) N N ) N 1 9 t r h T N ) N N 9 - o • N — 2 N ) N N N N 0 t r N 2 f o • ) N ) N N — N * 2 4 2 N - ) N N N N N N N 1 - 9 f N N ( — ) N N 2 ) N ) N ) C 2 : o N f N_ 4 ) N 4 * 2 ) N N N — ; 2 N 2 N 4 r N * N ) ) N Q C I 2 N > . . Q N ) : ) N . H — H H 4 H H H * ( 4 H H r - 2 ‘ , H — H . H 4 . H ) H — — . H H H . H a H ( I ( . 4 H H H 4 ( ) H “ — H H — 4 ) H H H . 2 H — u H : 4 ( - 4 ( H H ( , H D C — ‘ , . — ’ H ( - . 4 3 H ( ’ H H ( H . H ) 3 H H H H N ( — H — H j I H - - . H . ) ‘ ( — H , H L H . H H H D C H . — H * . ‘ H H D E H H — H ’ o H ) H “ . — 4 H D C ) 3 3 ( . ) H C 4 : * — H : 4 ’ 4 ‘ ‘ “ H ’ H H 4 — C ‘ * H H ’ 4 H ( - 4 4 : . H ) C D C H • • ) C H H H ) C 3 ( ( ( . H ) C * ’ H ’ H . 4 * ’ H H 0 C I H H ) C H . . H H O J ( ’ 7 a ’ ) 3 ( H H . H I ( ‘ . H H H H ( — ) C H H H H . H H — 4 ( H . $ — H - - — H ’ H 4 . H H H ‘ 4 H H H H H H H . ) C H 0 . 4 ’ H E C H H — H H ‘ H — H H — ( H ( H H ( I ( . ’ 7 — , I ( ’ H H ) C . ) H H ) ) C . . H — ( H r — - D E H ) ) C E C ’ 4 — . . H 4 — l f 0 H . — H — . 4 : . ’ 4 H H ’ ) C - ) C ’ H H ’ , r , H Q — - . H H H H H , 2 H — H D C 4 1 H ’ 3 3 ‘ H . 4 H H H ) H H H . * H 4 . H 2 4 H . 4 — - • H 3 ‘ ) H H , 1 ( H 4 , ( H — H 4 . 0 H H “ H H H H O J ( 4 H H ( H — . H H “ ’ H $ 1 ‘ H H ) H . : H H * 4 H H ( ) 4 “ H ( — . , , . H 4 H F D I ( H a H H H H H H H H ’ 4 H ( . H H C H - . H H ) C , H H H . H I ( . H E H 4 4 . H ) C ( ( H H H H H H 4 ( H ( - H D E 4 H ( H l f * D 3 H ( H H H ’ . H H . • ) H H — ( . H ) C . . H 4 ’ 4 . H 3 : - . H E 3 H H 4 ( ) C H ) H H ( ) H H 2H ) C ) C . H C I ( . H H H H H F H H - — H H H ( H 4 . H - I : a ( . 4 ¶ H H z — H . H H . H 3 ( b . H . . H c N x c - c / c 2 N C < ; 7 * : 3 — N ) 2 N c c - . ; — N ’ a < — 2 ’ 2 x c N C < ) C ; 7 ) 2 ) C ) — ) 2 ’ : 3 N N c c c 2 ; 7 c c c ) x C a N N ; 7 N . 2 N - r c c c < r c — : 3 c c c 3 a - i c ) C : 3 N . c c ; 7 a N — I N c c c . N ) C — 3 : 3 : 3 N N ) 2 7 ) 2 ) I C C — N N ) C 3 2 ) x I N N ’ a < I ‘ ; 7 — x c C J - — N : 3 . ) N C ( c c 2 ) ) C C N ’ a N < i c N x c ) C C ) i < ; 7 ) ( N N x c N 7 a 3 2 x c I N : 3 D — N : 3 ‘ . N 0 < ) — 0 N N N ’ a ) C N C ( N C < • 3 N ) C • c c c N • . ) • x c N , . _ x c — N < N - 2 N • . C < ; 7 - — — ) C ) C C N N N N : 3 ( < ; 7 a C < ) c c N N i c . , ) C : 3 ) : 3 - 2 ) C N 0 ) 2 N x c N N * N ) C 2 * 2 . 3 : N N x c ; 7 . ; 7 N N ’ a ) C . 3 ) 2 N ’— a * N I N N o : 3 3 a 2 ’ a ) / ç N 2 N ) ( — , . — N i c N ) 2 ) C < c 2 N ) 2 ’ a < — 2 N a — ) C N . c c ’ I N ) N C N ; 7 N : 3 N — ’N a ; 7 N ’ N N : 3 — C < N N N - N N N ; 7 ’ a a N N N 3 2 ) 2 * : 3 ) 3 . N _ _ C < N . ’ a - C < 1 ( a - N ’ a < N < — a N a N N — c c c N 6 ; 7 N N ; 7 x c ; 7 N - N ‘ . a a N ) C N . c c a x c a C N N N < * ’ 0 < ) . I ’ N N — - < < N 7 - . “ . , , , , ) C a I — N NN \ - ’ N ) C c c c 3 : ) C ) 2 N : 3 ” a — N N N N ‘ N - ) C c - ’ 2 — ’ I N ) C N N ’ a ‘ N ‘ “ . ’ N 3 : 3 % 3 2 : 3 — - N 3 : : 3 N N - ) C . C < : 3 N ) 2 — ; 7 ) 2 . : 3 N — “ < 2 N 7 3 ’ a N C < — - N “ ’ 7 N N a < N c c : c c ; 7 ; 7 * N a x c % 3 : 3 ; ’ 7 a < j ; 7 N N 6 : 3 N N ) C * N . 2 ’ N c c N N ‘ . I * ’ N ’ l E ) 2 . H ’ a ‘ * — m C < ) C N N < . c c 6 1 ( N ) C : 3 N N N ; 7 c C ’ N N : 3 N ’ a r N : 3 N ’ a ) 2 C < ) C N N ) C ) C I 3 1 . ) C — ) C N ‘ < N c x N ) C C < N N . N : 3 2 . . ) ’ a C C N N N : 3 ’ a ‘ N a N N ) K c c N ; 7 N : 3 . ’ N c - 2 ” N N — 1 ) 2 ; 7 N < N 2 ) 2 C < I N ) 2 a ‘ ; 7 N N — a N a N . 2 ’ a ’ a N 7 ’ a : 3 ½ a 3 I 3 Ii I 41 C ) H 0 lspT 1 d flitC 33 I C U 4- j4 Lii ‘-I I I ) C C C — C H C — L C C — ) C C ( C C C c . C C C ( . - 3 - C ) L C . 2 C 1 ( C - — C — C C C * C ( C i c — C . ç < 3 C ( C C C ( . * 3 - 3 . < 3 - - 3 . C • C C ( i C D C D ( C a C C C a C C • — — C < 3 H C C L — C ( C C ( C 2 — C ( C C ( C C C C ( C C - C * C C a . — - H • C C ( t c C ( C C C . C C C C I ( C C C C C ( C C C - C ) C E C ( a — C C ( C C a C . - — D C E ) 1 a - C ( C C H b a C C C i - ( C ( . C ) C ( — , - . • C C - 3 < 3 C ; i C C C C ( C ( C C 1 ( C C C C - 3 C a C f f C C ) j C C ( C - < 3 C < 3 C < 3 1 ( C C 4 C C C 1 1 c C — 2 H C - C C C C C . m c < 3 C ( C — C — ) C C C - i C D C C ( C C C C ( C H H C C C L D ( D C C C ( H C D C ( C C — C C . C a H . . . . C — < 3 — — H — H C C ( C C ) ( C a C C ( C C ( N C ( H 2 CC C C C f • E r C H C H I J ( . 1 ( H CC ( : - . — — D C Ca 3 E E C CC H a . C C ( C ( : 3 — — c C 1 H H a - t ( — , _ CC ( ( h T _ ( , 1 : ) C — H ) ) C C 9 7 a 0 7 ) a C — 9 9 7 9 7 — ) C ) ) ’ C 1 ) C C H ) C ) 9 C g ) C ) 4 - C 9 ) C ) C - ) ) C C 9 ) C - C ) C - ) C 1 — 9 ) C ) 9 ) 0 - C ) C — T C . - C ) C - B - ) C - ) C a ) . C ) C C ) C — , ) ) C C a ) C ) — C t - a — — ) C C - C < 1 7 ) C C — 9 _ ) C ) C ) 1C - C a N ) C 9 7 ) C % J - ) C 9 ) C 7 9 ) C ‘ - 9 7 C - n ) C — C ) — C C C 9 7 ) ) C C a - C 1 - — — ) C ) C ) ; ) C C 1 ) C — 9 ‘ ) C ) C ‘ ( ) C . — 9 — - ) C - C ) C ) 9 ) 9 ) 9 0 . ’ C . 2 ) C ) 9 3 7 ) ) C C a ) C ) 9 r ) 0 - — — — - — ) C a a ) C - — - C ) C . - C - ) C ) C C C ) 0 9 ) C C ) C 9 : ) C ) C ) ) C C ÷ - a ) 9 ) C C 9 ) - C ) C ) 7 ) C ) C t r — ) ) C C ’ - C a 0 * r ) ) C C ) C ) C C — ) C - C ) C C ) C - ) B C C C > ) C t r ) C ) ) C C - 0 o , - ) C ) ) C C a a t r ) C ) ) C 1 C ) C C ) a C ) C ) 9 C ) C - ) 7 C 9 ) C . ) C ’ C _ 2 ) ) C C 2 C ) 7 ) ) ) C C C 2 ) ) C C ) 9 ) ) C C - ) ) C C - ) a C ) 7 - - C ) C ) C . . : - ) C ) 7 C 9 ) ) ) C C C ) a C ) ) C C ) 9 ) C 4 ) C ) ) ) C C C a 9 7 ) C ) C ) C l C t ) 0 7 p ) C - 9 ) C — t - - 9 ) ) C C — - ) C C C 9 7 ) C > r ) C ) C a ) ) 9 ) C a C C _ C 9 7 ) ) ) C C C — 9 — l ) C ) C C 1 ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C - — C a ) 9 1 7 _ 1 ) C C ) C C C C ) — C 7 7 — ) C ) C : 9 p - C C ) C 9 I ) C ) 0 a ) 4 C — ) - 9 ) C ) C 9 ) 7 C — . H 9 7 ) C ) ) ) C C C ) ) C C C ) C ) — 9 ) C — 7 Q J . . - a C — 2 a 9 a 9 - - 9 1 : — 1 C C — ) C - 9 C ) C — ) C ) C ) ‘ C ) C i ) C ) C 9 ) C 9 ) C - ) C - ) C a ) 9 a ) ) C C a ) ) C ) ) C C — - . ) ) ) ) C C C C ) 5 C C ) ) ) C C ) C ) C a ) 9 r ) 7 . 9 - C 9 7 9 : 9 7 ) . C ) C ) C a ) C 9 ) C C n r ) a C a — ) 0 2 . ) C 4 2 C ) C B ) C t ) C ) C ) C 9 C 4 ) ) C C 9 7 ) C ) C ) C 4 ) - 1 — ) C ) C ) ) C a - C 9 7 ) C ) ) C C t ) C — ) C — 9 ) 0 ) 9 . ) ) — 9 9 ) ) C C 1 ) C ) C ) 9 C — ) C ) C , B ) ) C C — ) C ) 0 : - C ) C - - 4 C ) - C ) ) C C — 9 7 - ) C r a a - ) C C C ) ) C ) C - - C ’ ) C - C ) C — ) C N 1 C ) - - ) C 9 - C ) ) C C ) : C ) C ) — a C ) C C - C 9 ) C ) ) C C ) C ) C - ) 9 9 7 . ) C C a ) C ) C 4 C . ) ) C C ) ) C C a ) C ) C : 9H ) C ) ) C C 9 C C ) ) C C )H C H H ) C 9 H ) C C —C ) ) C , ) C - - C C ) C C C — H u HC R C ) C ; — — ) C ) : C H ) ) C C H ) ) C C C2 C 9H C C ) C H a ) C ) C 9 C ) - ) C ) C 9 9HC ) ) C C C . ) C C C C o H - L C H C C C C ) C - C — ) C . a C C H H ) C - ) - U ) ) ) C C C 9 C 9 C C ) ) C C L ) C 9 ) C C C C ) ) C C H H . ) C ) C ) C — ) C H , , i U ‘ H H ) C H ) C . ) C ) C H ) C ) C C C C — C ) f C 9 w 9 . ) C H H - H H . ) C ) ) C C ) C ) ) C C C — ) C H ) i C C H ) C ) C — C C H H ) C H . . ) —C ’ 9 ) ) C C H ) ) C C ) C C C L C H — - ) c C ) C C C - ) C 9 ) C ) C 9 2 C ) - . - ) C — 9 ) C ) C # C C L C ) C ) ) C C ) C ) ) C C H C ) C C ) C ) * C ) C H C C L - C C C , 9 . 9 9 ) C L C . 9 ) C H 9 ) C 9 H ÷ - ) C ) C 9 9 H H ) C ) C — - - ) C L C H H H H - : C u c - 9 4 — )H C H . H ) C )9 C H HH ) C . ) C — ) C H u c H ) C H c 99 9 C ) F HC ) H H < R C — ) C — H ) C ) C ) ) C C C H ) C C C C C C 9 H HC ) C C H — o - ) C H H i U - o t r H ) C c ) C j C 9 : C - — a - C C 9 — ) : ) C C ) C - C ) C : ) C C H H H ) C ) 9 C ) C ) C H a - 9 ) ) ) C C C H a ) C H C C j ) C ) C H - ) C H ) C c - C H ) C ) C H ) C ) C 9 H ) C C C C ) - C H ) C - C H u C u C — C C H H ) C H ) C ) C : C 2 - ) ) C C C C ) C — . H ) C ) - C . 9 ) C C C — 9 ) C H H H ) ) C C ) a C ) C H H 9 H ) C - C C . - ) C ) C — H H ) C H . C C H m r H ) C H ) C C C C - — ) C ) : C C C C ) H . ) C a H . . < C C ) C i - ) C H H ) C C ) C ) C . . ) C 2 . 4 • — H ) C - C 4 ) C 9 ) C - ) C ) C C C ) ) ) C C C - - ) C ) C 9 L C ) C ) C — ) C H — C C ) C ) ) C C H ) C 2 9 9 ) 9 C . a ) C — ) / C ) C ) - C H ) C a — H . . — — ) C ) C H - — ) C c ) L ) ) C C 9 H ) C C C H — — a ) — . ( h T 9 H H — ) C H C C ) C C C . : . H ) - C C H — ) ) C C H — % Z a ) ) C u c — a ) - L H C ) ) C C ‘ . C C C C ) ) C r ) 9 C C ) H ) — C - C : ) C . — ) ) C C H H i 9 1 D C — D C a 4 - - a D C I H Da C D C D C D C C ) N ( D C D C ) C H 4 * I H D C D C S D C a < D C : t r . Da C t r — — D C D C — D C a D C D C I H D E D C D C I H t r D C D C t r D C D E t r D C D C D C a D C — I L - D C 5 j D C D C a D C 1 D C I H I H H ‘ H < a D C —< H D E C D C D C E D5- C I H D C D C D C D C D C D C I H D C D C L a - I H H . D C 9 a D C D C S E D C a - 3 D - C - i D C * a H ‘ D - C D C D C — — D C N 4 H < a D C . . D C C - I H I D C H I H D C — - I H D C a i ‘ L < D C l D C a D C a D C I H I H < < 5 4 2 a D - C 4 L ‘ * - - “ . a D - C D C o a D C ) C D C E E 5 I H H — I D C H a I H 5 D C I I H H D C D C D C D C I H I H D C D C I a H ‘ ) ) C D C I H D C D C I H D C D C a : H < ‘ - i - — a N < I H D C . - H < a D C I H D C a I H - D C S ) . C . ‘ < a I H D C — t r D C ) D C t r C H I H D C D C D C . a H H < < 1 a : 4 D C D E . n ’ C S . z D C : - I I H H n * r D C — q j D C D C — D C L C a D C 4 - I H a D C D C D C I H D C I H 5 ‘ ) D C D C I c - H S C C D C ‘ D C D C I H ) C - D C D C - D C D C D C ‘ - * < . R C * — I H D E ‘ — — S 3 I C 5 I H 4 I I H H . c - - > - D C . a I H — ) C C D C a D C D C C C H < H “ D C - H c I - H D C a D C D C a - i H H * . L C I H D C D C * — 9 - — < D C D C I H D C — I H D C I H D C L C H < * D C ‘ — D C D C D C H < a D C L C D C D C D C D C D C H < a H . . a I H I H L C I H D C H H 4 < D C C C D C a — I H - a H < H D - C . 1 C 4 D C a - D C * — a D C L C D C I H D C D C I H H - H — < ) C D C D C — 5 D E - — 3 3 L C a 3 - - D C a D C D C D C D C D C C - < L D C - N 9 H D C - D C H < - D C L < D C - D C I I H H . ) - D C D C - D C 5 4 5 . — 4 a D C - D C r . a C t D C I C C a L C ç - - 5 D C D C D C r - D C - a D C n H ‘ L C 4 ) x - . ) x c * D4 — — C I H D C D C I H . 4 a D C — D C ‘ D C - — — ) D C D C c c r D C H H H H H L C D - 5 H * r . ’ i 4 C H < - 5 D C - 5 - “ I H D C — 1 * 9 D C I H - 9 - 4 - : c - D E 4 D C - H - a I I H H a ) C — < ) D C D C D C D C D ’ I E I E C ’ D • 4 C - I - H ‘ D C L I C — L C L C — 4 - D E “ \ H H H . )Nt( i t’ 01 E P i t a ii nd Kb iNc I it% ot thr % l’fle . t’)r tr’.d Cr’ nt is 1.st:t,ec :i. rL !‘ t’’• tiJ”’!’ tItt uc’cn ci P’4 C rhoti,’t P \k tldu biothcr of ompi tin Un ih’ ‘is in atrcI heislilt. his it rsinn rrldtllig tø flu motic rc maine .1 ‘inq’testionecl tic ii is idmitted in Ins . idcncr that thurt was quc’rrt1 li1iii run t))g :jC Cl isni irid thc Iirrn1 rnen-bcrs of P W , iith icgaid to the ari’ ultura. land. fii.is the ctdenct’ c, \ 7 suppoits thc. c Sc f itt Ht sect 11)11 it Ic. st I I’ ‘fl t I t IPf)tL’r i(iT ‘ifl i’i%S1”l1 (‘I the WI’ i jN ..i ‘‘tIit H’ lSr. 1 Pc h t ‘ • 1 t - ra.cti,: hr, —.

1.tisii ii’. . f’t’kçi f :1) ,,j’i ,q:t!. ,,fl d t c’ U r l’’t •j. . I, • “ ‘ ‘‘. I Pt . ) L C 3 : 3 : a 2 — ) 1 ( - 4 C C - 3 3 ( C * ) a . a — ) a 3 ( O - 3 ( 4 C L C , 3 ( a 1 ‘ 4 . 3 C C 3 ( 3 ( ) 3 ( — 3 ( l C a , , a ‘ a 3 ( C C ( 4 3 ( L C — ) 1 a 1 ‘ ( 1 C C 2 a 3 ( a “ ) 3 ( ) a 3 ( 2 3 : 3 : L C L C Q C I 3 ( C ( ) 3 3 — ) 3 ( 3 ( — 3 ( — 4 3 3 ( 2 ) ) 3 3 ‘ ) 3 ( 3 ( a ‘ _ . . ‘ ) — L C . 3 ( 2 3 ( l C 4 3 : ‘ - - 3 ( a ‘ 3 ( t ( L C — 3 : 3 : 2 * L C 3 : 3 : 3 : C ( — 3 : L C a 3 : 3 : 4 a h T ( 3 ( C ( — 3 ( a 3 : 3 ( ) a 3 ( a ‘ a - ‘ — D 2 3 ( H a 0 1 ‘ — 3 3 ( 3 ( a 3 ( l C - . . 3 3 ( — 3 ( H 3 ( L C = ‘ — ‘ 3 : — C 3 ( C C C > C ( a — ) 3 ( ) 3 ( o 3 ( C ( ) 1 ( ) 3 ( 3 ( ) 3 ( 3 ( — C a ‘ ) a 3 ( - 3 : 3 ( ) a — L ( 3 : 3 ( 3 3 ( 3 : ( 0 ( a ‘ - a C C a ‘ 3 ( i C L C b a ‘ 3 3 ( ‘ ‘ C ( ( ) 1 ( 3 : H 2 — 3 ( 3 ( a ‘ - r C — C 3 ( ) a ) 3 3 3 3 3 ( ’ I 4 C ( L C 3 : 2 — 1 — L C - r C C a ‘ L C C ( 3 ( C ( 3 ( 3 ( a ) a — 4 n r — L C 3 3 ( ) C l C 3 ( 3 : 1 3 : a L C 3 3 ( 3 : a ‘ a ‘ ) a 3 ( C C 1 ( ) C — L C 6 L ) a C ) 3 ( 4 — - - 5 3 ( C ( 3 : 3 ( ) a t ( 1 , 3 ( ( H a ‘ ( C C - 3 3 ( 3 : o a ) ) C a — a l C - • 3 - ( i 3 ( C C ( ( ) C C C C r = 3 ( ) 3 ( — a L C 3 ( — 3 ( 2 , C ( ) 3 ( a 3 3 ( ) 3 ( C ( . * — L C 3 : l C 3 : “ ) — C — . ) J ( 3 : 3 ( ‘ 3 3 4 L C a ‘ ) a ) 3 ( w . 2 C C 3 : 5 ) 3 L C h T ; 3 : l C H a ‘ 3 ( a ‘ 2 4 3 ( ’ L 3 3 ( 3 : “ 3 3 ( 3 : 4 ) 3 ( , . . 3 : 3 C 3 ( L C 3 ( ‘ L C C ( L C l C — L C ) C C 3 ( a 3 ( — t - a ‘ 3 3 ( - a L C 2 , 3 : “ 3 ( l C C C C ) 3 ( — 3 — : . . C C - , . 3 ( 3 ( 1E . 1 ‘ 3 ( L C — a ‘ 3 ( 3 ( I a 3 ( a ‘ L C 4 ) 3 ( 3 ( 3 : 3 : _ ) C C C - ) C C ” 3 ( , 1 L C ) . 3 ( . + 2 - 0 ( a ) a ‘ . . 3 ( ( 4 3 ( a ‘ H 3 : 3 : 3 3 : 3 : 1 < 3 : 4 t r : • t - i un” 1 c c usc d uhc iif1i r it put ush,i 1c in ji’t section ‘“I ‘t% 9’Itt Ilk 9tt ‘cilirici ‘0t1 •It-’t ti ‘1 .1 tc. t iii Co Itt )i tF jh • fiat p in ‘Ii ii K a c1 Section 14?. 11 4, 3(ñ r Sec 31 ot tin. l1’( also necls to be conlir’ncd 1 ‘ W hue in wd Sr Hanani inth R’ d i’. 1 bjfl kthuvalt cLjflWu.flflg on behalf 01 tIle tc’custd on thc qunl’oui 1)1 St i’tc in c lie submits iii t lit I itid dl%put belt’ eti. U t a fles i’, L re tc’ tc)rnpIoIIilsc; I in4 ii ‘ girt’ 11W •I-fl Lc1)i’ • ) 1111 1 1% 1 ‘1 ‘t ha t I(,I’E’L)!tl. 1’c J ‘i r ‘ r’ 91 ‘ L,( .‘‘ ‘ ii t fiTj !c it. ‘ i ‘‘• ‘ CL [ti -I • lI.itl •.lir1 ; . V. . g_• , I — tT ‘S ‘ • ‘ 1( • ‘1 t • •• • .• .—. t.it ‘‘:7. •1 • I •t’ •.. • .3 • .1.1 l • 1 r. • ,I. • • I’ 1 pLt1iIbtictl)Jt titidrr %n tk’tl ))ti I ( cut u itli S’ I ut liii IP( H n” i ‘id s ihrr is’.iot .i .q sc’tl U d.f si’ I-’ 1 .. I In me rr&a d it’ ti w it ,tali i .,i tin facts .tnd nrc utnst in’ cs sm c thc pm-ut s Ii iw ‘nipn ‘i’cd ‘s (‘1 tiIt Lq)iIiI(Ifl tiLat the pt’ii(’(I ‘If Iifl9SOlflWflt airead uiickrwnie in ‘ ‘ md 3 ma ix sufficient punishment )f imprisonment ‘ceustd flu i ha not underwine Inipriwinrnt Ut .un ponl 01 119W t’’r the If fl” CS 11 jtIL%th)I ilL (clffl( t( ti I. ( I it ntd ‘ft 11’ 1< ancl .tsctu1i’cI tin 1r1:rr ;‘ rb the ‘lub ..‘ini ‘sit!’ ‘I— IC ‘Icy i. ) C. • t i.•—’ ‘, .•ist;c V ‘I.i;(i hc fl. .1 ‘ 1 • ••jg t c a ‘ i4 Li. I T•

1.iI ‘ ‘ii ,I 1 •1’ )rI •

1.1 I — I’. • I a t • if’ %l 1 •.i i., 1’ 1 .1 ( Is S..’, •• t. C :17:

ORDER (a) The judgment and order of acquittal passed by the trial Court acquitting the accused for the offences punishable under Section 427. 114. 307 read with Section 34 of l.P.C. stands confirmed. (b) The judgment and order of conviction passed by the trial Court for the offence punishable under Section 326 read with Section 34 of the l.P.C. stands confirmed. (c) Accused no. 2 and 3 are sentenced with the imprisonment for the period already undergone by them. (d) Accused no. I is sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of one month. Ce) All the three accused are sentenced to pay a fine of l 5,000/- each. Consciously we are not imposing default sentence with a view to compensate the victim. The fine shall be recovered from each of the accused, if not deposited, as arrears of land H O I ( 1(1 ( HI’ -H H ji’ I \8 ib \( r ‘Hi Ii- I 8 ( C ir III i r \ ) HH) U sI1I1(H I S 11HSc I ( ‘lflhllHI \ni cJ 8 4U j( ic 11 1 1 Ji’ I lIt a1 ‘‘ 1 Jo-