Mohan Shans an v. The State of Karnataka

Judgment

1. a . C C ) C ) l C a 0 H C C C C C C C C C - ) ) C C a ) C . — ) C C C a ) C C C “ ’ ) C ) C . ) C _ a a j n i ) ) C . ) l ) l C C ) C C C C C C C ) C . : C C C H - ) ) C C C C C ( ) C — C ) C ) l C ) C a C C ) ) C C l C C ) C ) 9 ) C ) l C C C l - ) — 9 I C a C C C a C — ) C — ‘ C C D I ) C ) I ( ) ) C C C C / , ) ) C C ) C C C ) C n r C C ) l C C C $ 9 C C H C C ) C C C C ) C ) C - a C C ) C — ) l C ) C a a ) C C C C C — C C “ ) C ) l C a - J — C ) C ( — a ) 9 C C D L C C ) C C C ) 9 i C C ) l C a C C ) C a 9 ) C 1 C C ) ) C C C C C C C ) C l C - C - ) 9 H ) 9 ) C C C ) C 9 ) l C “ - a i C C C C — ) C C C ) ) C C D C C - C C C ) C ) l C o - ) C C C C C ) C C C C C I < . C C ‘ ) c C ) C C C ) C C , , ) C ) - C C C ) C ) C C — C D C C C - ) C C C ) C C C ) C C C C C a D C C < ) C C ) C ) l C ) C a ) C C C C , ) C ) C C C C ) C ) l C ) C C C ) C C C C C C C ) C C C ) C ) l C ) C ) C i C ) ) C C ) C C ) C — C C ) ) C C C C C C - - c ( . ) C C - C C C i C C ç C : • i C ) 9 - C C o ) C ) C — C C ) ) ) C C C C C C C C C C C ) C a 9 I ) C C < - .

9 — C C C C ) C C C - a i C ) C C ’ C - C C ) C i C C C C C C C ) C ) C ) / C ) C C C ) C i 9 C ) C ) 9 ) C — C C C C - c — C C ) 9 ) C ) 9 ) aC C ) C C C a ‘ ) C C C ) ) C C — C C C C a C C C C ) ) C C C C + r C C ) C ) l C C C ) ) C C C ) C - C C ) C 9 : : C C ) C ’ C C ) i C ) C : C C ) C C C C C ) ) C C ) X C ) C F — i “ ) C ) ) C C I ( C “ — C C ‘ C C $ 9 ) 9 C C C C ) C C C 9 ) C — . i - C C C C C ) C ) l C r C C ) C C C . ) C ) ) l C C C ) f r ) C ) C I ( ) C C C / - r - $ ’ F 9 - ‘ ‘ H C C C C C C H a 9 - . ) C C C ) ) C C ) C C C ) C I C 9 C C C C ) C C C ) C ) C - C C ) C ) C C C ) ) C C ) l C 2 ) C a C C c : t C— - ( r C C ) C ) ) ) C C C C C ) l C l C ( ) C C I ( ) C r C C ) C ) H( 9 i - c ) C C C - C C l C C = : l C ) 9 C C ) C c C i C ) l C ) C C C ) C ) l C 2 : — .

I — - ) C C C ) 9 C i C C C ) C r ) C C C ) -C I ( “ ( •1 a c usc ci did not hec.d to the I quest of P ‘A ard rapc d P’A 1 P’A ciccil udi Onhcrinh i ri P’A ml PV ri’Icd to ftc. ‘C ol )fcrc. m1 tic icct Md ‘cnn” n t ftc in hc ho is In I c ire ii shilc the ac cu’ec1 h id told P W I that thc math in should not bc.. informed to mi bod’ othen ise lx ii iii not marti her On enqin P3k 4 mcI P ‘A mc. to knoti thout the incident Irom P %V 1 Hoi cit cr thc.s ilso kept ‘iuic t as thei i’ anted to conic tic m Panc hai ath )rdc t to sc e tint the ic tsed niric iwi rw cimc t i-h mi fnn Mosque lloie tr h rci’ i ‘ot mtd t ir V 1 ) As IC 1 V C rt 4 11 2008 lot tin’ olTen es punish al* undei Section 4 1 7 .“id 2,o ot rut ilk in tin IMi C cii!, Iiisprc tor P \ .IS Thu P,,I’cc .itlrr ij %t1.I.,fl,.ri 1411j lilt • h.irtyc’ h.i—r I. r tin’ t ‘lb ‘nec punishubie’ t inner St—elton “7.1 ul 11w 1 i-ft.

In artier to pru e its t aq, the Procreunon in at’ exarnint-ci 20 uttnesse% including the proserutrix. 11 exhibits nnd three imitenul ubjtrts were rntrkrd. L ‘pnn hearing. rue trial (‘ourr acciuitteci t:w 4cc usc-cl. 4

Sri \ \1 Bcinakai le trncd kdditional Stint’ Public Piostc utor. sui)rnits LI- it thc iiencc 01 the ptose titrix alo K s suutinwnt. n ct h t d Iic 1 c ,Il’\k tjy t I n Ic. t IP\% ‘Ic , nt Ft 11 r I’ “t ‘ .1 Ii1 .1 iii ‘ •1 • i ‘ 1 i. _1 • • . r ii ifti t ‘ (C •‘ ‘ C .1. • • I — — i , •‘:‘ l C 0 ) C l C D C D C C C t r i - : 9 ” i C D C l ) C D C ) C D C ) C . i C C 9 - l C 9 D C l C “ - ) C D C D C i C 0 ) C l l C : 9 C C l ) C l C D - C ) C l i o C : i C C C D ) ) C C C C C — D C i C C 9 1 0 ” i C D C C D C l C D C ) C D C ) C l l C C D C l C i i C D C l ) C C — C ) C ) ) C 1 “ — ” 9 — 9 “ “ — . . 2 : l C 3 1 D C ) C ) C D C — l C l C D C ” 9 ) C C C / 9 9 — D C D C - l C l 0 ) C : 9 D C D C l l C C H D C C ) l C l C D C i - D C D C • D C l C l 1 . D C ) C C o D C C D C - 2 C ) C C C l I C D C D C i C D C - -C D C Q i C - l C D C — 0 C D ) i C C l l C C - 0 l C D C l ) C H C — 9 r l r C D C D —C D C X D C 1 H r D C l C H ° i C — ) C r C D : — 9 C l 9 . . 9 I D C r 0 C C D D C 9 - H : 9 < CI ) D C C l D C i C C i C O I . C C D l C i - 9 ) o C i D ) C l C I ) o C : 9 1 - . l C 0 9 D C i C l C D C — ° C C C D C 2 l C l i C C D C — 2 l C — D C 1 : “ 9 - l C 2 ) C l l C C ) C D C l C l C l C ” i C D C < D C 9 — — : 9 ) C - D C D C 2 . : - 9 l C D C l C D C i C r * 9 1 C r . 9 ) C 9 D C D C C C C D C C D C ) C ” i C l C D C D C ) C ( i C l C l C l C “ C C ( l - C — a l C D C 2 ) C < 9 l ) C C i C H l . C — “ D C — ) C l D C C l C D C ) C C D C 9 l C i C ) C C C ) C l C . 9 - i C C i - ) C D C C i C C C C l l . C ) ) C C 9 . ) W ( D C i C ) C D C C C D C ) C . • - l C 9 D C C C C i C “ l C ) H C ) C C C t l C D C 9 l C ) ! ) - l i C C D C ) C l ) ! C C 9 9 l C • i i l C t r D C . H D C l C D C : 9 D C l — C ) ) - 9 i C l C l ) C ) C . 9 ) ( l C i C : 9 i ) C C C D C l D C l C . 9 — ) C - D C I ) 9 C i C 9 ( l C r . C C — D C D C 3 D C • D C C C C ) C 9 C D C D C i ) : ) C C C C D C l C I : C — l a C * l C l C l C D C j , . . c , . . D C 5 : 9 D C C l C . 9 l D C C : C l C D C D C ) C : 9 l C : 9 C ) C l C 2 2 2 D C l D C C . 9 : 9 C C C C o C C C % E C C o C 9 * o C C C o C C C C C C C r C C ) C — I C - C C C , 9 C— C o C C C — C c C C C C C C i - C C o C • C C - a . a C C C C C C C C o C . I C C C o C ) C C C C C i — h C C C C C C . C C C C 0 C C l f ) C C C 9 o C ) C C C C C . 9 . C C C C C C b t ’ r - C C - , . t — i 9 r h C C ) C — - o ) o o O C C C C C — - o C C C 9 i h ’ o C i •1h C C ’ r C C C C C C C C C o C a — O C . C C C C o C o C o C ) C C ) C C o C C C I ) C . 9 ) C - - o C ) C C C C C C C o C ’ r o C C C C C 9 — o C C C C C o C 9 o C C C C C C C i h . a 9 C C C C C C o C 2 o C o C ) C C C C C 4 C C o C o C C C i h C C C C C C . . . C C C C C ) C C C a o C C C o C C C . C C C C $ C C C C o C . a C C - 9 o C o C C C ) C C C i h ) C i ) 9 — o C ’ C C C C 2 C C C C C C * C C C . a C C 9 i h C C ) C 9 2 o C , — C C o C C C o C ) C C C C C C C C C ) C ) - C C — C C _ < o C ) C C C o C . a C C 9 a - C C o C . — : o C C C o C . . < ‘ o C ) C a - C C C . C C i h C C o C C C r o C - o C C C ) ) 9 . . C C i h o C C C C C C C C C C C o C - ) C C - C C o C ) , C C C C C C o C H 9 C C . , . C C C C ’ r o C C C C C “ C C r C C ‘ C — ‘ C C t ’ r o C C C ) C C C o C C C ) C * . C C 9 a $ , . . C C C C C C . a H C C C C C C o C : 9 o C ) C i h _ C C C C . o C C C o C i h C C C C i h C C i h o C o C . 9 C C ) C - — C C o C i h 9 C C C C C C o C i h C C C C C C o C C C i h J ‘ ) C C o C ) C C o C C C . . C C C C C - ) - C C C r C C ) C - ) C C ‘ ; i l o C C C o C 4 . . . , “ — 9 C C C C o 1 ) C o C I C o C ‘ . . C C ) C C ’ 9 C C _ C . C C i h o C - , 3 9 i i — C C C C - o C , C C ) C o C C C C C i h C C C — C C C C ‘ o C ) C C C — C C ) C o C o C C C C C C C C C C C “ ) C ) C $ C C 2 o C ) . . L C C o C o C C C o C H , C C C C ’ i h C C ) ) C o C o C C C C C o C C. C , ) C a H . C C o C o C C C o 2 . C C C C . 1 — . . . i o C ) i C * r o C C C o C C C $ i . h o C C C C C C C r . + r , i h C C C C C C C C C flu important iiutnesses rn the matit r arc P.W. 1 proe( utrix and the Dix wi P V.1 A sh ecanhint ci the pros cii’ ri P i 4 ..rnd ‘ to cc’ tan’ nte”t ‘ire relnant S. According in thc proset uUon the incident has occurred on 2001 .2008 at about 0100 p.m. The accused on that day during the said time entered the house of P.1k .1 and committed rapt on her T’.V. I started crting. P.W. 4 and S who were neat the place came inside the house of P W. I and sa’i’ the accused runTiint it’ a) from the cctnc of offence ft is the sprcific ase of the pns’ c titian that the ccusCJ had thre itcrl( 4 p W 1 ft-cm Ii uk,in,’ the inf.,rmotiOT tc third p it-ti on c pIotWC tha’ hi ‘inul.1 m irrt her in -. St the ntidtt.t . ti4 n.i3ael to

1. I nc” Iflyit P,’. iht’ - ‘ 4atil’ it indael- B’it ite*flt l P.W. , lit n t iii ip tc i st j • Utt’ I n,.tl’ r o’ I 9. at. I.%t A i ([ I’ ‘ It 1 ( ( ‘“Is 4 t’s, S iftei tin ‘tic idc iii. I hcrc is no reason as to P W I Ii 1 ‘ t cuat itI out tnt it’ i c st thc in )tt tIn. u mi PW it” uml’ I is rcpo Cl ‘P(IC contidcncc ii P W. 4 md ilK sit jnocrs th in hcr o’n nicahc.t Thc ‘.cn conauct of P W I in into ming PW I and , about the in idc ut s ould shoi that she t is bold enou to tell to the third parties that shc as rapt d In such an ient it is q’ tiet unn itural on her part f r kc eping thc rncidcnt of rapc sc crc t b’ not nforming U Ni n th r 1bc natural condu t of P . i Md haic bccr fl info Ft n ii Cr Iirst t i )f the p a U mu ftc i Ii pc a C 0 t IV i r I i Ft C - 4 - C C t r C C C C C C — C 3 — T C C C . 5 C — T C ( s - - _ C • - 4 e i C C C — s u - C T C C C C — C - 9 C C C S . C C t r C C C 9 5 C C C C C C C C T C C r 5 2 C C 2 C 9 C C - - C C C - C , . C - - C - C C - C C - C C - C - C C — C - C C - C C C C s t - C - — 4 - - C C C - C 2 9 C - - C C C 9 - C R - C : ) 5 C C ’ e C - C - C i C — C C 9 C C C T C C 9 C - C C 9 C H i C a C C 9 C C C - - C C - C C C C C C C T C : < — n C T C — c - - C 5 5 C - 4 C C C j - C - s - s C C C C - C C C C C 5 C C - C C 0 . . . - ) ) C 5 o 0 C C t r - C C 5 C C C t r - C C t r 9 — - C T C 5 C 9 C C t - C C C T C C t r — C - - C C ) C S E 2 - C T C C C C . - C 5 C - C 9 C C C C - — < < ) C 4 - s C C C S E C - C 9 t r o - C C - C - - C , 5 - C C C - - C C 9 C t r t r 2 — - t C S H ) ) 5 9 T C C t - - C - C C 5 ; ; C - C - C - C C C T C - C - C - — — - C - 4 _ _ - C - 9 c C S E C C C 9 — C C C — C t . . C C — - C C C 0 o C 9 C — C : C - C C t - “ C t r C 5 - C C C j r 9 • - C - 9 C t - C - C T C - c - C — C C — C - C 9 - C - - C C C r C - C . — ) 5 C - C 9 C C C — - C C C C — C C t S T C C - - C C - C C 5 5 — C C e < C 9 C H C C t r — C C 9 - 9 C — 9 9 C - C t C C C C C 9 C 2 — 2 C • C 9 4 . C - - C C r C C C C C C 9 C - 9 C C - C - - - 4 - C S C - ) 5 C - C i - - C C ) C 0 C — C — I ‘ . - . C H - C - C C - C C - o i - C C 0 C - C 5 C C C C C T C - - ) C C ) C C S 4 - - H ) C ( C C ( C ( H C ( - a — - ) C ) C C ( C ( 2 C ( c * - a — C ( ) C ’ 2 C ( — , , . , c ) C ) C P C ( r H C ( r ) C . . . a . C ( C C C C ( ) C - a C ( C C ( ( ) C C C C C C ( ( ( ( ( - C r ( C ( C ( ) ) - . ) C C ( C ( — a C ( C C ( ( E H H C ( ) C C ( + - C ( 1 2 - C ( C C ( ( — . I C C ( L C C ( H — C ( C C C ( C ( = C C ( ( a C ( C ( C —( C C C ‘ C ( a a C ( L C C ( H - a H C ( ) a C ) C C ( C ( C C ( ( - 0 - a _ C ( C ( - a C ( D L C . . L C - a - a L C C C ( ( - C ( C C ( ( C C C ) C a H C C ( ( H C ( ) C C ( a C C ( ( ( C C D ( L — 2 - a a C ( ) C ( C ( ‘ ) C C C ( ( C C ( ( r ) C . ) C a C ( H ‘ ) C c - 0 C ( ) HC C ( E E - H C ( - a ) - ) C - a C ( . L — C C H D C C ( * H H D C - C ( - C ( H C ( H ) C l C _ . ( C C ( ( r a C C ( ( - a a * H D C I ( - r H D C C -( C ( H 2 C ( . 2 D C — C ( H a a C ( ) C — ) C r ) C H C ( _ f C C ( ) C a - D C C C C ( ( ( r - - a ) C C - C ( l C ( C C C ( ( ( C C ( ( C 2 i - — C ( ) C a a C ( — C ( H ) C C ( r j C ( + - ) C C C ( H C C ( ( 2 a ) C C ( • < a . ) C ) C C C ( ( a r C ( C C C ( ( ( C C ( ( . _ 1 : C C C ( ( C ( L C , f ) C C ( ) - C C ( a ) C C ( C ( H C C ( — C C f a ) C - a a o C C ( ( C ( ) - 2 C C ( ) C - H C ( C ( C ( ) C a C ( - o - _ C ( C ( C C ( ( C ( ) C C ( c 2 C ( a ) CC ( C c C C C ( ( ( ) C C ( C E E a H ) C C ( C ( ‘ C ( _ Q C L . C ( C ( L C ) C C C ( ) - o C C ( C . C ( C C ( P C( C C ( r H C ( H — . — C ( C H ( C C ( ( C ( ) C — L C ( 2 CC ( ) C C C C ( ( ( ( C C ( ( C C ( ( ) C C ( • a C ( ) C H C ( ) C C ( C C C C ( ( ( ( f 5 E ) C H c C ( E C ) ) C ( - C — ( C ( C ( C ( ) ) C ( C L C ) ) ’ C C H C C ( ( C C ( H C ( ) C C - ( , . ) C C ( . C ( . C ( a C C C ( C C ( ( . C ( C C C C C ( ( ( ) C D C D C ) C ) C 1 ( < — C D 6 t i - D C D C C D 3 ( C D ; C D - D C C D D C < > C C 2 4 ( — 2 ( D C C D D C - D C C D ” 4 D C D C C D D i l ” ) C D C ) C j . ) C r D ( C D ) C C D . a 1 C — C D “ D C C ” D 4 . “ ) C C D 3 ( I ’ 3 ( ) C . ) ) C C ” 3 1 D C ) C ( C ) C C D D C “ “ D C C D ’ 3 ( : . ) C D C D C D ) C I 3 ( 4 D C L C C D r a D C — 2 ( D C 3 ( - C D . D C C D . ) C D C C ( L C ” ) C D C ” 4 a - — ‘ . a ) C ) C 1 , t r ( C D C ) C D , — ) C ” ) C D C 3 ( C D C D ) ) C C ) C C D ) ) C C C D L C D C . C D C D ” 4 “ 3 ( * i 3 ( C D D C C D ) C ” 4 ) C D C C D 2 ” D C D C C D ) C C D ” ) C D C D C 6 : : ) C — C D ” 3 ( D C r 2 D C 2 D C ) C — D C — D C ) C D C D C D C ) C ) C D C C D . 2 C D D C D C a 6 2 c C ) D C ) C C D D C C D D C - ) C - C D ) C D C C D D C C D ) C 2 E 2 D C ) C D ) C 2 * C D 2 ) i 2 L a C — ) C 1 C D D C D C ) C 3 ( 2 a D C D C C D “ P ) C D C I ( ( a C D C D ) C — C D D C C D 2 C D D C C D ) a C I ( ) C ’ 2 C D C D C D ” ) C D C ) C D C D C C D D C C D ” ) C D C ) C C D ) C C D $ 2 ( 2 ) C C D 2 ) C “ ” 4 L C — C D L C D C ) C - 3 . ( C D C D ) 3 ( ) C D C D C ) C — ) C r C 2 ( L C ) ) C C L “ D C C D C D “ ) C 3 ( ” 3 3 ( C D ) C D C ) C C D ” ) C D C C D C D 3 ( 3 ( C D D C 3 ( ) C L I ( 2 D C C D ) C 3 ( 2 ( . 2 ( ) C D I ( C D ” ) C . C ( ) C C D “ D . D C ? 2 3 ( 2 ) C 3 ( 3 ( ) C 2 ( ” 4 4 — C D — ) — D C D C — — ) ) C C D I ( C D ’ l C 3 ( D C C D C D ) C C D ” ) C D C ” ) C ) C C D 2 i - D C . 2 C D ) C C D 3 ( ) C ) C C ” 3 ( C D D C D C ) C C D D C a C D — L C ) C D C I C ( ( C D ” 4 2 ( - C D L C D C . — 3 ( D C D C ) C C D D L C 3 ( 4 C D 2 C D ) C ) C ) C D C C D ) C C D C D D C H ’ 3 ( ) C C D - ) ) C C ) C ) C ’ C D C D • Y D ) C D 2 ) ) C C a - D C q j ( ) C D C C D C ) C D C 6 C D C D D C L C ) C 2 , . ) C D C 2 2 3 ( D C C D ” D C ) C D C D — 2 C CC D L) r ’ r D I l C D — ) C ” ) C D C C I ) C 2 C D ” 4 — 3 ( L C ) ) C C ) D C C • C D ” ) C D C • C D ) C ) 3 ( C D C C D - ) C C D ” ) C ) C C D t I ( ) I ( D C 2 D C C D L C ) C j - C D C D I C C — C D ” ) C ” C D L C ) ) ) C C C ) C ) C ) C . ) C ) C ) C . ) ) — C C ) — C — ) C ) C ‘ ) C ) C ) ’ ) , . C C — ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C ) ( ) ) C C ) l C ) C : ) . ) p C C ) C ‘ C C ‘ ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C 5 ) ’ l ) C C C ) C ) C E ) l ) C C C — C ) C ) C ) C ) ) C C “ ‘ . ) C ) ’ ) C C ) ) C C ) - C ) C ) l C C ) — C < “ ? C C ) C H l C < C ) ) C C - ) C ) C ) ) C C S ‘ ) C ) C ) C . C C ) C - C C ) — C ) C ° ) C ‘ ) C ) C ) “ C ) C ) C ) C - ‘ ) ‘ ) C C ) C ) C C C ) C ) C ) C ) ) C C — ) C ) ) ) C C C - ) C C C ) C ) C 6 ( ) ) C C _ H s ) C . ) C ) C ) ) C C ) C — C l ) C C - ) N C < ) ’ ) C C l C < ) ) C , J c ) C < < ) C ) ‘ ) ) C C C ( - ) C C C , , ) C ) C ) ) C C ) C ) C < D C ) ) ) C C C D C ) C ) i C ) C ) ) C C ) ) C C . ) C ) C C ) ) C C ) ) C - ) C — ) C — ) C ‘ ) C I ) ) ) C C C C ) ) ) C C C ) C ) ) ) C C C ) C ) I C — , ç - ) C C C ‘ ) C ) ) ) C C C ) ) C C ) / ) C C ) ) ) C C C u . H ) C C C ) ) C ) C C C “ ) C ) C H - ) ) C C ) C ) — C ) C ) ) C C ) C r ) ) C ) C ) C C ) C ) C , C . ‘ C ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C ( ) C ) ) C C C ’ ) C ) C ) C ) ) C ) C C ) C — ) C ) ) ) C C C ) C - ) ) C C ) C C ) ) C C H H ) C - C _ . C — C l C ) ’ ) C ) C , , , . . ) ) C H ) C . C - ) ) C C ” ) C C — C ) ) C C ) C ( l f ) ) C . ) C C ’ ) C ) C ) C H ) ) C C 6 ( ) C ) C ) ) C C ) ) C C ) C — H ) ) C C ) ) ) C C C . S ) — C H H < ) C ) C ) C ) C — ) C ) C ) C - ) C _ ( ) C ’ ) C ) C ) C ) ) C C C ) C - - ) C “ — C ) C . “ ) ) C C C C C ) — C ) — C ) ) C C . ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C ) ) C - 5 C ) ) ) C C C — ) C ) C ) C ) C — C C . ) ) C C C C ) C ) C . l C i P ) C ) C l C . — ) ) C ( C ) C l C . . . . ) C C ) C C : , ) C ) C - ) C . ‘ ) C ) C H ° C — . ) ( C v - C C ) C ) C ) C - ) ) ) ) C C C C , ( ) C ) C ‘ N ( ) ) C C C C ) C - - - 6 ( — N l C C C C ) C ) C ) C - ) C ) ) C C 4 C o ) C H ) C )HC C ) ) ) C C D C : ) C ) N C ) CC ( ) C C ) C ) ) ) ) C C C C ) ) ) ) C C C C ) C ) C — . H HC C ) C ) C ) ) C C : ) C . ) C ) C ) C ) C ) C C C l C H ) C ) C — ) C C C ) C ) C - D ( ) C : H ) ) C C 6 ( s S - ) C \ 1 d S ) C ) C ) ) l C C C C . ) . ) C ) C ; 6 ) - C ) C ) ) C C C C C ) ) ) ) < ) C C ) C ) C ) C ) C ) ) ) ) C C C C - . ) C H - ) C ) ) C C ) C r D PUo — C I - VL a - t ) C4 - U stV —a - c- V U P - : 2 4 4 - ¶ ; U v ’ - — S i 5 £ — c 4 - o L a r - 2 - - I £+ - C - Ub - r • L - — — r a S — I — I _ C U U t a S 4 - U 4 - E D C - — L a L U U C -S- 4 4 H - C r C U C r 2 c r a sU U U 2— C ) — C C - V L U - CC C 1 a S a s — C b E U - - 2I - C U — U 4 4 C U I 4 - - U — ( N U - £ 4 4 — — 4 1 C — C o £ 4 S U p 2 2 a s C O X S — C — 4 - — — I C 0 4 U s o C C H a U C — 2 - , H P - c t— 5 4 - O f L U - C 2 ) — V 2C — C — V U C4 C r F - V - C 5 t — 4 - $ C ) C U — 4 - 4 1 U - - HU C 4 L U U 4 ) 0 4 - A t V a S a 4 - - C - c a S 4 - C ) C U U S C r P a A 14: Court cannot be said to be erroneous in the facts and circumstances of the case. It is by now settled that the High Court would not normally interfere with the order of acquittal, if two views are possible from the material on record and if the trial Court has taken one of such two views. We find that the view taken by the trial Court a possible view, under facts and circumstances of the case. In view of the same and in light of shaky evidence on record, no interference is called for. Appeal fails and accordingly the same stands dismissed. Sd/a JUDGE Sd/- JUDGE 1) I