State of Karnataka by Sadalaga Police Station, Belgaum v. Snu. Kamalanayaku More

Judgment

1. TTiis appeal i.s fi.led by the S tate agai.nst judgment a.nd order of acquittal pa.ssed. by the Past Track Court-lb. Belgau.m No, I hS.2OO6, E3. impugned ucigment r’esntmcieni’ accused s acquItted of the offences punishable under Secntm -CC- A and 304-B of the Indian Penal Code and Section 0 of the Dowry Prevention Act.

2. The accused is the mother-in-lan of the deccasd Roopah. Ti ie marriage of Roopali wuli the son of the accused La ara] nertormed 1 10 1 00(5 According to the pro.secut on at the time of the m.arriagc the parents of Roopali had given her o ustom.ar’y ornamen.ts and certai.n. new c.lothes. Aft.er - N C) . r p ii Ont. Cii a a The deceaseci. couRt riot ri Serate the. iii- t eatm nt r.n iCed. to h..er by the accused anyrn.ore. Thus, o 5 200 6 C), 10 m t í’5r ii . . i’) nC’n IcC) 10 cnci her ‘ilc pourc d kerosc nc lit rst If and set Nr on hrc. Ctuse-qa lent up’n hit! Slit sLS Iii tid i \t t%t I t1 iii rJ’ineS ii ciii. ( — 11 t tile 1A I (Jr t •:ir icr strc tins 1 ci husbu ci un i—u md sit whb iir persons Lmr Jill eNtingmnshed ilu’ tire and shilted her t the indira Gandhi \lemorial Hospital h hahkaninji IM iharastra St nej treatnitni Pohcc Shivajin€muacr Point Station 1)1 kIlLiIai;.Irjiijl ‘ kite.:! the— hospital and iecorcird the statc tm—nt •‘t ‘ wtnn During the intcnening midnight bcttci 01 3- ?OOt an I 0. 0 )OU( ilit- Tim s si’ ifted u ( P.K Ilusj’it€.d a kUIh.IPUI mr ii’tt’er tir.itmri’t \i .sb’eist tSp tn .03)Obn inrni • sni thc It L’s.c itis’iac s It “u 1 ‘i\ia. ‘!‘t I O.a C ti : 1a’ . :€ Li. . ‘ •1 l•i 1 j.’ t’ •‘:t •..i. )\

1. • C q . is _.:. j . •_. $ L , 1 • •r • t.• •: . t ‘. a $ I I .• — . . . iI• • IS I 5 4 tas c ons to is and oru nit d to time plac c and pt rsons Xn end ,rscinnt u-nc ic ix issucd to th sai I cfltct b tF. suc’ D tn PW I n t’ Id tu r iecor’ic d in PW 19 On the nct in 0-i it i’ n 03 0a 2006 another statement 01 the dt.c eased cami to be rec orded b the Polic e as p i Ex p. i in thc presence of another Doctor In namc Dr 1thnd Di Milind has certified tint the path nt as conscious md oncnted and shc can gne her statemcnt Ex.P 19 bears thc endorsement of thc Doctor b name Dr Milind Based on tnt said sntemeiit 01 tU m Ex p 1 Q d ited 030) 200b m omplun camc c I.e rc’stri tainst thi. re >por dci t f r fft nc c punishahlc t. hr tic r 4984 of thc IP( n Cnn-it \ 11 006 cf iidtai C U 1 : m c ’ L C c c c i L ) C ’ m C c m c m c i L m c , ; C C m c i H ; C m c : ) C m c m c m m c c ) a a A — m c ) C — a . — a — i H i H ) ) ; a a ) C c m c a A a ) C a C . — L C a “ a c c - ; ) C i — H a c c m c ‘ > m c ) I - C ’ Et i H a m m c c — ) 7 ( i H ‘ c - t — - a m c ( > ” C L C f i C D — m c : c ) f ) C L C > , ) C ) C h T i H - m c ; i — L . a a A i ) C > ’ i L ’ a a L C ’ c C a ‘ i m — H — > a t f a ) C > A . . : . i $ < t i ’ a ; ” C c c - m c a i - . C J , m c m c . ) - a C . A r E ) C — - ; a . a a C ) C — H 2 m - . ) m C c m c m c 7 ( L C : - ) C ‘ ’ i L ) ) C C ) C m - c c C A r i i H L t m m c ) C c t i c m c — . ‘ a m c a H A i H L C a , ’ C L C , , m m - c 2 L C ) ) C C C - : ’ m c , ” , . ’ C , , A a : a ) C L • m c C c : H L C L C a i a H . 2 C . ) . a m c m c - L C m c m c ) > C “ ) i ) a C L L C - i - L C m c m m c c ‘ a , ) C a a m c ” C “ m c ’ a — o - H t ” r m ) C c ) C L C ’ t i H ‘ - c c — , a a a — c ) ‘ ) : a — - : a . m c ) ) C C L C : m c - — A A a a . r C m c i L ‘ i ) H C m c i L ) C ) / ) ) C i H a ) C — i L m c E - ’ C ‘ m c m H c A i c c c - i - ; c c - i H ’ A C - i L ) C C m c r E a a m c L C i > H L C c C i H — . — ) / ( C m c — L C i L ’ ) C • m c a m c m c C - C . l i i L H ’ i H . c c m c m — c ) C , . — - t f ( a i i H L L C i L A m c ) aC m c m c . C - m c C c c a a . — — - L C ; a m c i C - , L m C c C . L C i L ’ a — L C i L a — Q C ) i L : ç C i L a ’ ) C C l f i - ; c c . i ; H L m c i H ‘ , ; • Va H i H A ) ) f m c C a m c — ) r Cc o m m c a C d c : a ; a c . ; ‘ ) “ C L C : m c m c m c : c c c m c . 4 m — c A m c ’ ) C m c C A c — a - ’ 2 ’ h C T m ) , c ) m c m c a ‘ - a . ‘ c c - a a H ) C ; ; m c : ; c . ’ a c - > i H ‘ “ , ’ A ‘ ‘ ’ a a , m c — : ) C ) C c — ’ i H C ) C “ ; L C - m c i H a m - 7 ( C c m L , i m c ’ m c 7 ( 7 : L C c , , , ‘ i - Ct m c L C . c c ) 7 L C c m . ; A 7 : 2 ’ D — C ‘ — L D D C “ 4 7 D C D C , ) . , , N ’ 4 7 ” D C D C 2 2 ( — ) N ’ C C C ( H H D C ‘ D C ) ) N H D C N ’ D C D C D C D C D C D C H — ’ D C ) N D C D C ‘ — D C p D C D C t - P “ < ) N D C ( — 2 ¶ D C ‘ L C H ” H ) N ) H - P “ < ) C H < - C H ‘ ’ D C D C — 5 i , , ’ D C H ) ) C : ) N 4 7 D C ” ‘ 3 — 7 D C , D H C ‘ H ‘ 1 2 — D C . D C “ 9 - < ) N ’ 7 , — H u 7 H ‘ ‘ H 1 “ ’ H D C ) - N ‘ “ D C D C D C D C D C H D : ( H L C D C ‘ < “ < D C ’ — D C D C L C ) H N ) D C N ’ D C D C — H ‘ D C H ) N D C D C D C ’ H D C D C . m r — ’ D C ” D C D C 3 : ( H D C ’ 9 H ‘ “ ‘ < D C , C D C ‘ — ) N D C “ r . — D C H D C ; 7 ) ) C , D C — D C H ( ‘ r r D C D C ” i — C r D C ‘ 3 - 7 ) C 4 7 D C D C ) N H ’ r ‘ ) ) Q D C N N D C H ( ’ D C ‘ < < ) N “ ‘ 2 ¶ — “ ‘ . ” C D D C C < > ’ H D C D C H D C H D C N D C — H D C ’ D C “ < D C 2 ¶ t — 9 “ < ‘ D C ) N D C ) ’ H D C . D C H D C ’ D C D — C D C H 2 ¶ D C ) D C N ’ 5 < 7 < — D C , < < D C , ) N D C D C ) N ) N “ D C H D C - ) D C L C P ‘ H I I < N D C D — C ’ D C ’ r P ‘ H ’ ) N D C D C H D D / D C ) ” 3 — D C ‘ 4 D C _ < “ ” 3 D C ’ 9 C D H < ) D C H D C D C N H ’ r i C H H D C 1 ‘ D C D C D C . p ‘ < < D C H D C 4 7 — D C o D C D C ) N D C ’ D C H , 2 ¶ ) ) ) N 2 ¶ N N D C $ ) N D C D C < D C ” 9 ’ r ‘ , C < — D C t > — < H p ‘ - ‘ D 2 C ¶ 2 ¶ — H : H D C H — , — D C > ) C C I < o ) ’ 3 ’ t r D C H — D C H — — ‘ - ’ 5 r c : , — — D C D C — p p C - - H P H p ‘ < 2 D C p P ’ D C ) N 7 “ D C 9 7 p p — ’ ) N t L C $ ) D C N D C H ( ) C H ) N m C ‘ H H — — D C ’ ) D C N D C H ; 5 D C D C D C H 2 ¶ C ’ z 3 — C D D C . D C I D C - “ H ‘ , ‘ < < H , ‘ H ’ r — ) N D C - D C < > ‘ ’ D C ) t r N D C ’ r r — 4 7 D C D 5 7 < C C , c ) H p < N ) > N — D C H ‘ “ - j ) C D 7 7 p D C H H ) D I < . ) N D C D C < ‘ < D C D C 9 H < D C ) N ‘ , , . , ) ) C D - ’ H D C H - ’ H D C ) N ” D C ‘ — H — , ‘ D C - < 3 ) 4 P P ) N D C D C C D H < , D C ) ) , C D C 7 3 7 H - H D C ‘ ‘ — $ D C D C ‘ ’ — D 1C C : ’ D C H D C . D C ‘ < ‘ ’ 6 ) C ‘ < , — ) ) N N ’ D D C ‘ ’ < r ) N ’ H ’ D C : D C 2 ¶ - n ’ r H H ’ ) — N “ “ ‘ - S H ’ H ” ’ ) C ’ ’ r D C ) N r r 7 7 H D C D C D C D C H ; P 5 “ ’ ” C C ‘ H , 9 7 7 ) N D C 5 < p p ’ ) C H ’ D C ; ’ 5 ” C ‘ ) N P P ’ D C 1 L D — C “ ) N H ) N — D C ‘ ‘ — D C D C H D C H o — g ) ’ 2 D C ; o r N ) N ’ ) N ” D C ’ ) D C N D C - 2 ¶ ’ H - - ) D C N 9 ; 5 ) N 4 7 ; 5 4 7 ’ r — ; 5 ” C C ) C D H L D , _ H L * — “ — - ; H 5 D C ) ’ H D C L D D C ) N 2 ¶ : H D C D C H D C 2 ¶ 9 ) ) C N D C D C p ‘ < ‘ 2 ¶ 2 ¶ ’ D C 1 7 ) D C ” j ‘ D C ( D C ) N — ‘ — 4 7 D C D C . : — H - . v r ) 9 7 N D P D C ) N 4 7 s - 5 3 9 ) C D C 7 3 3 D C ‘ “ 9 2 ¶ 9 L l . 9 . H D H ) N D C “ H ) ‘ C . D . 9 7 P P H ; 5 ’ 5 : 3 ” C D “ P — 2 ¶ 2 ¶ 9 D - C “ - 5 ” 3 2 ¶ ; 5 D C i ; 5 D C . ] 9 - D C D C 7 - 5 : D C D C : l D D C , ’ r P N . D C 3 ) 5 . D C 2 ¶ < D C J N ’ 5 : ) o N o N ) - : 2 ¶ ’ 9 9 4 7 SI) ) I i’li9)I’i II ()t !lw IIL’L.%flI II. ‘‘tErn. t• A C ,i’.Iin ‘j lit ii ‘ tint I d ‘ii de.l II 11(0 b P La h 5’.’ ( I I ‘1t ‘“ijI ,‘ 1 i I • t • I. ‘. ci Sli ill I t I hr ‘It ‘ t 1%U. ) ‘‘ !i!t!’’ 1% tI-it I).’. t’’i “ 11. tss cci in c naorsc mc in tha’ (“InSCiOUS .111(1 nnt’nied t.. 2fl r !xr %tL.ft’mciit. Is n’ ‘1 rXjflhiflrtI bet’,rc the C curt I lie in ol r:s rt ‘‘—.11 tl.at ‘h.. idetti ot ‘UIl’ •l.tS Ut till rt tI .tt I C) 0(1 p.ir 1n cii •t ?(n .tt Man ikpui ilIactt C hikkodi 1 ii ik Inc n ihut, \htharastr.: St..’. • At tfiat J)J)1t •t t;fli. ‘lb I,ti%l,jnr I 7ht ItL i ‘ t ii. I ,‘ 1 ‘. imc I Ic’ f’t’ u Iri I •‘•‘ ‘ri • ‘‘‘ir’aiS.r’’ Ir l’s. •1 t• I ‘I C ‘ S S • • • I • .1 • ‘ ‘? %.:s ;r • • • • • • • I I • • • • 1 I’i• it’ “ :.. . • —, • • i •a ‘ • I • • s II I • • • •—• I • •., • I I I 2 a . 3 a a u a 1 7 7 ) 3 a - 3 - a 3 - 0 3 a - 3 — 2 3 — - 3 a ) 3 E a 3 4 a 7 — - - a 7 7 0 a 7 a . . . D C — i — a - 3 3 l E . a . — 1 1 a . . a — a E 7 0 a . . — c c ) C a I a t — i c — 7 ) 3 a 7 i - 7 l r — a t r o * o ) 3 a — E . a a - ) C : H 7 7 ) C ) — 3 ) C a ) 3 ) a 3 3 a O J 2 — o — 7 a — 4 a H ) 3 a 7 7 a a a . — r 0 I a 2 0 3 ) 3 a — . , a * ) 3 ) a 3 * 3 l E l E a ) C a 7 a — ) - 3 a - 7 — ) 3 7 a * a - ) 3 a . a 7 3 l E - . — a 3 a — L 3 — a 7 - 3 a J - . a 3 4 . 3 a 7 - a 2 3 ) 3 3 a — 3 — 3 ) 3 3 - 7 a 4 3 — ) 4 3 D C — — t C 7 — 3 — . 3 — 3 a 7 ) 3 a 7 3 — 0 — a a 3 C a 7 — a 2 3 D C ) 3 0 7 - - ) 3 a — D C ) 3 6 — a ) C a — a — 7 a t C a L 3 7 - 2 0 ) 3 r a h T f — a I — 7 . ) 3 3 a 0 - a a ) ) 3 3 — - a ) C — i c a . a 3 — a — . . , , , — a a 3 7 a - 3 4 2 3 a a — - — ) C — a . - j a — , 7 — 3 h T - 7 a a 3 1 a . . 7 ( : 7 a 7 7 7 a E O E E a E I E a 7 • I, examination dearly admits Police Shivajinagar Police Station have recorded the statement of the victim even prior to the victim is admitted to the hospital. It is not in dispute that I.G.M. Hospital within the jurisdiction of Shivajinagar Police Station. The then Deputy Superintendent of Police (P.W. 16j his deposition has admitted that the victim had given her statement in l.G.M. Hospital at lchalakaranji and such a dying declaration of the victim is recorded during her treatment in I.G.M. Hospital was in the file relating to investigation. According to him the entire file including the dying declaration recorded at

the first instance was handed over to the Police Inspector Mr.S.Prakash of COD. Division. which means. victim’s first dying declaration was recorded during her treatment the Hospital Ichalakaranji

01.05.2006 and such a dying declaration was found in the investigation records. The same is the evidence of the Police lnspector-P.W. 1 7. He has also admitted tht the Police of Shivajinagar Police Station who recorded I t I r 5I J — 2 / — I r C — I H ” C — a * ” ” 0 a — - H — a a ) 7 z H C - — C r o K ( a — C * — H — ‘ ( H a ) 0 K ( - a a O J — 4 c - H 7 $ - $ a o J ) 0 ) C * a a ) 1 ( ) 0 H C ” 0 * 0 ” 7 ( — ) 0 r J ) C C - a — — a a 0 ( H — C o J H C c I ( H ” 4 ) 0 K a K ( H - ( C a a - a / K a C H ” a 4 ” 0 C H H ) 0 a “ - ” 0 K ( ” a a H • K ” C ) - o • C ) C r o a H - C r J . . . H a r o ) C K ( a ” 0 a ) C ) 0 a a K ( K ( a H ” 0 4 r o H C H H 2 r o K a C _ “ ” a r o . . r o 2 K ( C 7 ( r o ) C ” a ” 0 ” 0 7 ( c C c C H a H H a ) 0 C K ( ( * r o a K ( ” 0 r o ” 0 r o K ( - ” 0 r o r J r o r o — 2 ” C 0 ( a a H K F — ” 4 ” 0 0 K ( a ( ” 0 ) C 0 2 r o ” 0 0 ( 4 ” C ” 0 ” 0 - r o r o a a a • H ) 0 r o a - r J “ 0 ( r o H — — 4 0 K ( H a ) 0 r o ” 4 a . — ” a K ( H 0 ( r o - — ) C K ( a ” 0 r J 4 H ” 0 r J a 0 ( — — r o ” 0 C r o ) C ° — — a a — r o C 4 H — a a 2 r o a a - £ a H a ” 0 — ” 0 ” C r o c r c 4 - ” 0 ’ 0 2 H ” 0 0 ( 0 ( C a K ( o i - H H 2 E — ) 0 K ( “ a a 7 a ) 7 a - r o 1 “ ’ 0 r o a K ( H H ” 0 ) 0 ) 7 ” 4 . . a C ” a ” ” 0 0 ( ” 0 r o — ‘ 0 2 ” 0 a K ( a ” 0 ” 0 O C - 1 K ( K — — 4 0 ( H ” 2 r o - a 0 ” 0 K ( a K ( ) 7 H ’ 0 7 ( o r * o — H ” ) C r o a C a H a H ” 0 a ) 0 a “ K ( H C H c r J K K ( “ : - H 2 - ” 0 — K ( ” 4 ) 7 7 ” C ” 0 7 $ r o r J 0 ( — — a K ( ) 7 a H — * a a H z 7 ( ” 7 a ( ” 0 0 2 ( C r - / D I 1 r I 2 r — — — - C t - — C I - i — I C I - V - - - - I - C t — — — C t 4 F_.P I) iS .1 :“‘t Lii) (In’ r.t u ii the Polin’ Ii t’it Is !u’tl.zti’ bJ: t4:c: , %I 1 ‘)t ‘l.:!i’1 .t, •.!::iI” in t P P 11. 2.’ ti 14aI ‘1 ,. 1 .. , • r. It .r:t t’ ‘‘: ‘flit F_’ rI • ‘‘1 )) _H If )i te ‘is .j1 • ‘ppt)rtiflht I’’! the’ Peilice ti, ct such stflrifle nt ru nrclr’I InhtHittli tf11’ Taft ika kxn un; r \I1tgisti ate- B’ IT str)riLtUI mdi P’T1ttt11! ‘)fjiCt’) . tiit ‘F. uItiIt.t Exec. Lltk t 1.insinite. is IilIOflhltb(! ht1r ii • ‘;rel’n E . P F’ Tin’ Pnltrr tlwmsd Cs C rn (,rdrd tli statement E.x P. 10 In the absem of the endem of thc 1)ou. w who gavt eflGOrqefliflit flfl E’ P 0 th I ii ii C jyt 1 jtittti-d ‘n tO 1 1 in ‘n C ti t I CL ] t h. I ) h’ 1 ‘cIIiUC IC. c I 1

11.1,) 1 lIsa ( iJ’’ I r’ ‘ ‘‘ i.n I ,•t • S .4 •.I ‘ I tIl .1 I ••• . I I . i .1 € a m e m 3 3 e — 3 3 - — m e m m 0 0 — 9 m e * — . a m m 0 0 0 m e 3 0 m e ( 3 0 ) 3 : * m e 3 3 3 3 - 1 3 0 0 ’ 0 0 C 3 ( — 3 ) 1 ) l C m m c o C 0 0 . m e C 4 C X C m e 0 0 — m e * C 3 0 m e - — 0 0 0 0 ) 1 3 a m m m e - . — : 2 ( 1 1 3 m e m e 3 3 m e * o C ) C - m m 0 0 m C ” 0 3 0 1 3 2 ( . 1 3 . 0 3 ( 3 3 m m ) 1 3 m e - m e m e . 2 9 - 0 0 m m - ) 1 3 a 3 O C — m e 2 ( . 0 0 0 0 ) ) ) 1 m m i - m m m m - - — a o o 0 0 3 3 — m e 3 3 m m 1 3 0 . 0 * - ‘ 3 3 m e N ( 2 ( 0 0 3 3 1 0 . o 3 0 o m m 0 0 3 ( 3 0 m e m m m e * m e 0 0 3 ( m m 2 ( ( 2 ( 2 ( m m m e 3 3 * ) / C 2 ( 0 0 0 0 m e — Q T C 3 ( 3 0 3 0 Q r c C m ( m m m m 3 ( * - - — 0 0 ‘ • — - m e — 0 0 C 1 3 a m e 2 ( C 0 — 0 a 3 3 m e 3 0 m e 0 0 0 0 o m e - 3 ( 2 ( m m 9 j m m — m e m e m e ‘ 9 . 0 0 m e a ( 2 ( 1 3 ( 0 0 ) 3 ( m e m m 0 0 m m ‘ 3 : — 3 3 C 0 0 ‘ ) 1 3 1 3 3 3 - * — 0 0 3 0 m e 3 0 3 ( ) C 9 a e m m 0 0 m m 1 3 3 * m e ) C 3 : ) 1 3 m e 0 0 m e m e ) 2 ( m m - 3 0 a m a m 3 3 — i c 0 0 . 3 0 ‘ _ ç m e m e m m ) ) 1 9 m e 9 , 3 m m 2 3 0 . 3 3 - — m e 3 3 m e 0 0 - m e 3 3 0 0 ) 3 0 , 3 2 3 0 m m 0 0 m e ‘ . 3 0 , 0 1 3 3 3 3 0 3 0 ) f 3 - m m m m m e 3 ( - m e ) 1 3 0 0 . 3 ( m m 0 0 ) C 3 ( 2 ( 0 0 ) 2 ( 3 3 a 0 0 a . 3 3 0 0 - , - - — — 0 0 m e ‘ - . m m , 3 3 3 ( m e m m 9 3 0 m e ) l C m m m e 2 m ‘ e , 3 0 0 a 0 0 m e N ‘ m e - 3 0 3 ( i — ) 1 “ ’ o m e 3 3 , m e m e a m m ” f m e 0 . 3 : — “ 1 ( — m m m m ‘ ‘ ’ m e 3 ( 0 0 — O C i - ‘ m — e 0 0 — ) C / c 3 3 2 3 : — ‘ - — 1 3 a r 3 ( ( 3 3 — ) C 3 0 1 3 3 3 ) C . 0 — 0 m m 3 - ( ) C / c m m C . 0 0 m e 1 3 ( 0 0 3 ( O C Z . 3 3 0 0 m e ) C 0 0 - ) C m e ) C C ) C 0 0 m m 1 ‘ 0 0 - ‘ - , — 0 0 C — a 3 0 . C m e ‘ m , - 3 3 1 3 m e . - ) 1 3 . 1 3 ( . m e 3 ( ) C 3 ( ) C 3 0 3 ( 3 3 3 3 3 0 C . 0 3 3 . 3 : ) / C m e m e 3 < 3 3 ) 1 3 m m 0 0 m e a ) 1 ‘ m e . ‘ m e f c - - ) . 2 3 : * 1 - ) 0 j ‘ 3 1 3 m e ‘ o ” 0 . 0 ) ) 1 3 ( . C C C a . ) C a ) ) C C ) C E . a C ( ) C h T ( ) C ) C C ) C ’ ) C ’ a C ( ) C ( ) C ) C . ) C • 1 ( C ( ) ) C C , ) C ) C ‘ . C ( c C C ( ) C a C 1 ‘ , ’ ) C , ) C ) C ) C ) C ) , 7 a 1 ‘ a l “ ) C ’ C , ) , 7 — , ’ ) C ( ) C C ) C ” C ) C a a ) C . * a ” ) C ’ . C C ” C , ) - ” C - ) C ’ ; C ) C - , . ) C ” c C ) C ) C , , , ) C C ) C C ( ) C , , 7 ) C ) ) C C C ‘ _ . ‘ ‘ : ) C ) ) C C ) C C ( C C ) , a C , “ ’ ) C L C . a ’ ) C , ) , , . ) C C ) C ) , ) , e ) , ‘ 7 ) a a ) ) C C C , . ( m C “ . a - a ) C C , C C ) C : ) C , H ” ) C a ' “ , C C C C , : ) C ) C , ’ ] ) ) C C C “ ’ ) C a , 7 ; C C C C ’ a C ‘ C C “ C ( ‘ ’ C C C ) C ) c , — “ - : ) C ) C ) C - C“ ) a C ‘ L C ) ) , 7 , 7 7 ‘ < ) C ” p - ) . ‘ C C ) , 7 C ( ’ a ’ ) ) C C , , C C C : ) C ‘ C C ” ) C ” ) C ’ ) C C ‘ : C C C J ” ) C ’ ) , 7 L C ; , 7 , — a ) ) C ) ) . 1 ” a a ” — a a . C ) C C ( ) : ) C C ] ) C ’ ) ) C C ) C ) C ‘ , ) a ” ) C ‘ ) , 7 * ’ C ) C ’ a C ( ) C ) a ) C — - ) C ) C C a ( ;C ) C ( , C C C ’ ) C ’ ) C ’ C C C ) C * ; C C , ) C ” ) C C C C ( C ( ) C ) C C a ‘ . ) , . 7 a ‘ , ) C ) a : 9 ) C - 7 C C C “ ) C , C 7 C C C C . ) ) C C , C C C a ’ ” ) C C ( ) C C C ) ) C C ) C C C ) C ” ) C ) C C C a ) CC ‘ ” ) ) C ) ) C C ) ) C C ) C ‘ ) C ‘ C ( ’ ) C , I C ) , ) C ( C1 C C C ) C “ ) ) C C C ” ) C ) C ” C C H ” C ‘ ‘ “ , , , ) C . ) C ) ‘ ) C C ) C ) a ‘ “ ) C “ ) C ’ 7 7 ) ) C C , ) C ‘ 9 a ) , C , , , ) C C C . ’ ) C ? ‘ ’ C ( _ 1 ) ’ C C , ) _ ) C ” 7 ” 7 C C — ) , , 7 ) C “ ” ) C C ( ) a , ] C , ) C ’ ) C ” ) C ) ’ C ‘ H : ) C ‘ ) , , 7 C C C . ) C C C ( ) C C ) C ) C ) 7 7 H ) a C ) C ’ ) a ) C C C ( ( ) C , C C . a ) aC C C ) t C ) C ) C . C ( a ) C ) ) C C ; ) C . ) C a ) C ) C ‘ ) ) , ) - . C ) C ” c C C ( C C ) C C ( ’ C ( ) C 4 ” ) C C ( ) C C ( 1 T ’ c C H ) C a ) C ) C ( ) C , , ) C ; C C ) C C ) C a : ) C — — — a C ( j , - a ” ) C ) a ) C C C , , , , , C ‘ ) C ’ C C C . ) C ‘ ) C a : ) C ’ C ( , . ) C E ) ) C C ) C . a ” C ) a C ‘ “ ) C , ) C Z . ) C . C ( ) C — — ) C ) C a . , t f ‘ ) ’ a , 7 ( ) C ) C ) 17: record, no interference is called for. Appeal fails and accordingly the same stands dismissed. Sd! JUDGE Sd! 3UDGE