High Court · 2011

Judgment

1. ‘p e._ ..i:,:. •: ;!fli •“. •—• r4.: .j;, s”l

7.. (j’’c i’;. LaI4- I, (‘U (I. ILL ifl s “. kiT tilt ci N.i at ,iIi i’inij ii). • %t •1 i ii”t; i( hie liii. liii ‘)i 1t•-. 1 11121 (1 ici u .1 ‘0 fl’( iii WI In ii a I’ll’.. i •i’&i •r1i (1%’)’ ‘Si’ i_c nb’ ‘Iar ‘ze ii’.: alàt (cattY .tC at i& d 1 id , •i jit in! 1 ul kci tn (lit. ii. hit. itirti ii’ lilt hr .c TI I 1 ‘jJll(33.{ti I cdl (ohM to i.i Ii iii C’ .i1&V4’tt,ii iit I ‘4:’ t, a tor 1 lu b4 1w t’ 1 his r id&.c a. ‘her ilic’ )I% ta1 Ill a3V .il%(’ tctfli in his hr U t’ h a, 1

11. 1 5 TI ! h pure ha%f’cI 1)11: ul mini the iinp II nfl. lliiu.ni_ir’rlrl’ Hc %i S 5b F n Ii d •..,ui•..i ik’ did ‘•i u. n Im It (in tilt •_t ‘b. l ‘I—rn i I j Ia 1— 1 ..ri,I(1%n,. ‘s..cV .ei \: I’n’a (It) t til ih.. s •, i .11’ C IjK n. a 1 • rI I II ‘1.0 1 il SI .t• “II 11*1 Pie €: • ‘ —. .. I—.’ ‘S_Ill ‘ ii t’% L ‘a • I • ).) ,l i t :i’ ‘. ii, P ‘.—, • a — ‘4 C tfl S. • •. I’ lit) ,. Ta . .1

1. — 1 l.a a I I tl%11 J ) h) ILl LUC j)( 1 ) III!” ILI!’!!LILLIII.laqiPtIIti[.’i)fLI’AL4jJj)—UllUup.t’I’I.sJ3t1: i ) I .t i’t—11I’:) ;t/’lJ”tT: ‘tIL ‘iI’”.1 v‘ ).fl S I I 1 ! 1’”1sifl i1’qi‘t’I1‘flI.flflb’LI)jII1!ILII.”‘TlI”%l.)t)a LII ) IJ.)UTt.Hl inavjaqialrI%•‘. ‘4 .upprml) ‘qPut’ I Iifl 4SIt ‘St flt)tJt $1 J)J jutadn IL’1fl)UUTd$%11 PS Jtfl b fIL ILIspLTPIttit’ ‘-‘L’41311 oja’lOqr, •Ii i—.L’I.))Jj ..•41 ) Fl I I 1( ‘LI U1I4 %) ‘Al U’ %c Ad LI ‘ ‘t)% 1j 1 I• L.i%l1 ,.JiTT;

1.111115.1%!T.%Iit’ .I:I‘. T”. .1’L4! .kt I •.l 1 •!1.ttI;.•P!.’.’ I _, SI_I 1%I.,i 41 ‘I VI I 1’ Il LI ‘‘ I —II I. 1 :1. i1.fltIBill ‘I•1LI’i ).341.)ijiii’iiçaIIaqiuc, ILLJI)i,ul11 ‘.11! lIlara1t...L?jIl!I(•ULlii •‘j’t’fl’)v11’P.01. •rj ‘p.s lilLi1 ‘tJIjL’l)’ITl ‘IX! I )( V.) IL’ I JI:•)

1. !PI •LI ‘ ‘i ‘) I CiI FL J’ ) • 11’TilTiiI liT1I ,j_T• ...?..Mj 14 .)iJciiiU)J•M.11 ‘Mijla.’jt..1kall1fl4IUi4.iCa‘o: alA!j%afl%sill%.nhICqJ?lI LIto ‘..s,uqhap.staItil.jOtpT3p)fl.tviiJlI’Ll)‘LIT11.u I • CpT•CjftJJ(4I ;.,i0.\ih3p•.n‘l’T14’..bT1•i?•PLJqIlj_BUØt. .‘%Ia’ ;.‘l, ‘1’;”. U; •%4q)n.)a tL’iI • )rikit •4. JIi fT•P’•_’ •ut! : I ‘Cj“P1 •‘.‘J .1 ‘iI • •1L1L’•dl1.’, .LI)1 6) ‘1! 1 %1Ji) I II T 1’ I tIIf i’ttl( . I • •Jt . ) ••—ft •1 •. I, att( a I% L • 1 • JT..i• :. •t •1..•• .7 ..

7. J , J j( , ‘7 ) • I I I I C ‘4L Ii a Vc S

14. Ii IC t I n Ii LI 114’ ‘.4 IT) d r • ii “d dim nil I p 1 Shizbli.i; alt ‘tel’. ‘It.l(I avcI ,,ie’j’,k’ i,.i.ii tt% %‘dlrr ‘it Irnn ‘ I I I ‘I ‘ C 4 C ‘ ttii’it LV L” 4 tiiii”td t •ic ‘iiJ ne J)Ier.iu Lit: t xanjnatinfl. ‘.bc’ ‘._n’ s ii at ihen -4 ‘jiju ‘cii 1itiirc. ‘al i i K • Ii i )C d t .. ckr’.ed the door and tt ent auic. The distance I.e1’u—n bet ,or ant i nv. CI 1% ‘ S t Ii ‘c b.) 30 S’n -ridd b ‘ u is I’ ‘pt ni her slit t ii tb’ ‘si ‘creani. Sb. deities tht su2eninr that n’t it’ r in law I I t ‘1 C I £ I I I ‘ii icI3% c’i” ‘,“fl—’ii ‘at’ ‘;‘)iit’. lioti 1 •-ji, 1 •‘ • •t. on,. “1 . hi ‘n’’’a ‘—1 titsi.”: • 1 (it •.( S ‘%t ‘1 ihitLi ‘ • d iSI’(1 10 11 C ( CC 1 d—’ ‘a.’, eel ‘;tl ‘‘‘ if calL lit I’iI. (1 Ui ‘I • N ‘‘ I hi i1’ FL’ ‘I ,. I i ‘i ‘j, ) C. . Ig.ej •‘ t ‘ I 4’ I’ I i 0 13 )1.11(11iJI‘I I I tIlC 1 1’) THi.) —.Ib’Ita; I IsflJ1)11 •\.f ‘tj1“ Ik.I’U’l•,aij!jfli j(’ .1111 p)i I’ t”4b‘‘•L’LT’ebji. ItnsI%Ufl1’_V_.trRT itt•I

0. %l%%flLT)T1.’p1TdmCI’Tjluç,,urn.1SXCI £IAicT jITT1 ctIfldIII.A‘liiapuad.i1titAl’.St ‘II’””iI’1i111Li‘I.kJLJj J.JlaOjU)SCidJO)Iaqi(‘1 -, U’%Jt’Ot01j ‘t¼LIII )1 2 IT (‘ISd ‘

1.)J()fP.)4)nu.;Ifl 1)11.11 [).‘L.’flj.IIO.’ IL’fl•1uP3maI(flI 3 i.)uCppqj I ) ) j I ‘‘tLp1’ aJItjOj ‘-‘TLfl:’TI Ij..t!1

31.1L1i4 ‘ N. tmI i.tflny .11tI:ud)•UP’ntfl.11:).‘TJI1IiU”Iflpti’SUifli ;—.orlP4 I(’ L°’)lI J111 1JtI)1 )Ii S I ‘ , — ‘t t , ,çn 1T’) ‘‘. .hhI.t.’.IL,.(T !‘ ‘ IC fl’T1’jP)‘‘—J J7LI’ I1; II,,t’’I 31 ‘ I ‘ Li ,u1)iI1Lil(j Ifl1sq•I1t)IjPLPiUPt) II:LII i)iJIOi1LtitlijYt )IUV[JLi! LI)%T‘LI))11b1111.a44%TI j.i3IJjiij1%4)dqi.i i;.’—tilln 11 •%j6Wtf 4 illfr’ifi’1Q’’‘)II.%’1I’i •T UO,L1)(lii1 )NIGd JC) Jiji ‘ )Liu) TSjsaq’ )IPJJ%it3i’1patu

1.isd 1 A1fl‘tjl1flT4S tU.IL.I C’G) 1PMI ‘up .t t’)l’is)ijI. 0J.fl)I) 1’P°” I )r ..Iti4..PLPI,t • ) .•tjra))t •-!I • • •5T7’Ii%I I.. •11I ‘‘(‘IIF!; r ••I ! S‘•I • :1‘•l*’t •‘ iTi1LI.); ‘ 1T.i: :‘ •t.vt.; ‘‘s’Lt...)II :‘ — .11 “‘—: • —•.•:. .‘ I...;• ‘ 1 I; )ti II ifl% at. It %(i (1 ii i rA I hE bilfll% r% irE i; I. i”irl hi. ti’.’) 14)—.rIViiI 111:11 lii t idvi’i — •4• 1 1 1’ Ii %lrl)t ivI.. tic:’ a%ec’ in rc:olr wln’r’ in’ idcnt F • r • L • I r and and iii’ .aiar. iltn I. re’.porsihlt i)r i1i Hi’ kitni. I”i . 1. i I t Ll C •C C I C •i. ,, ilitir videnc’e. fl.V:3 has ‘pea ifleall> Mated that on C d r u c ‘av mokt’ ciiitiini I, cnn lilt rnoifl anti thc door ‘V.i cli “.ed I - I r z I i ‘ 5 .inn ‘ h I— r%141111%lVEl l’c% ‘ifl Tt.i%tiiIiiblP entilit ‘ha ‘ I d p e st. i ,r ‘i a 4 • 1 ii:’ : •n•. i ‘— —‘1’ ‘he .isl11i.t r. ‘ ‘ ht. i I’d’; ,n11j ri.. .‘ h c J ‘ a’..i’Iiz.. n’ It •‘ c%’.”.iI .n 4 iN ‘ —. i ii I i 1 *1 ‘ rI . I •t I ti .i.;i C . I ‘ — 1 ,,i. . i’ :t I ,, iii) id ‘“ ii ‘ 1 ‘1, It • I •‘ I’I .hIJIILIl;)1la)f) apOjI!PIi1PUIILIPII’’’1.’tt .flj 1I_?pja1-;•i\ ‘ tat;%,allfla%LLILLa_fl j)LIIp1 ;I{g1ilLp!Jti(, Itaat!_3‘a)p )Ja)flfla:It1IB),1 ! )!.Lb[.it’.11111ILl%a_sLUI)jj a_,•j put:c.• 1114111lti’U!qIJI%•—.nlII’lJjIi.’it’.IL.ti- .ThL ‘11’ %l)’ 1l(a j’t1‘!lTT-‘15131’!I It IUII%IUII.’liI ‘aqgJoiIfl’•)l.Tlmumu t TOTUMIT f1M% ,I iiTVLP TittlOJjot )(1p1l),UL )I ) )O) ktT %JLj I 11331!Vlt’I pill.LTI1PIdu TICiSJa. TSA%JJt ‘aiaqai;ITUtY T’L’OS4 ‘if sa1Tip1t10111I)31tjagI t%pa:JjI‘UjJTtl f’ai aga11:1;i ‘zqn.g’ •Li9—. j91!q11 inD a1IUI aIa%.•Ta;TjjTt.-Jfl%L’’aIha!tat_alt )ITT!t’gc.TT ._;i0L.,112t_’jiiSaZ!:_T)l_ fljjIi )anT, I•1%! a ;L;. ‘[fl’. %aJ P‘••T•a .11.1,1j! ‘at..)fa’1•I’fl ;r. • ‘.“.1 • •- ‘j’‘I’)—. I•l3 U‘II. a a •• • • a .‘:.• a Iag•ii 4 LJiid°‘‘i’s I’)q(II J •f )S) .4.1 Jo •HJ•H•‘\..t. Lit. 14u11I%ItiC3 ).‘1 i.II1Ij;TL’—‘‘U..:i)4si%dttIqI” ililialn•. .L9T: Itli I%). ) 4 , ) 1 .. I “i ‘1P1TI I ‘ )T)S sl)lCj’ fl(i1”qi i•\_JInJ.LI3()jA) s )%0.’%TPc1.n:aIlL iU.?L1 JO )14 31 SI p‘ UTt’)JST L 3 ‘ )‘ 0%,p‘iT Ip.11 Tat)pITTs.T 2M.110LIT0.11lii .‘ TTiU)l, .1111 IL’..)I)I‘bTIt .1L(11.’kL,gll.’.W) IUOII1).3ptIo)3’LIPJ)l’tIl.P11’ C’) .J.I{ [31 1 ‘:1LI11h4. ..%t—!Ln 1’’.s“IOILLtLT1i1.( 4t,1.ltps.33.’ ‘:.uug‘j% I)1,_%•pI. ).“•‘i’‘‘I iiPLL’.‘I t flITid- .1 A? I I I ) 1 I 4ZrLqI’piDc’eL’I’ ‘41atilp.t; 1’) J.s L’ I .i I t1J.) I • (. I! ‘Ilii11 t%I•f’1.i ‘‘Ill. 1 I j JiH )l1)) Ij.t 41 1 ‘1P—““! i.\’g’—‘b ‘ ‘I;1iaT. !i. Jill,’Iii ‘Ii ‘ I’ a 4 4 ..•f• J I i 7 ‘ .. - ! ‘i ‘11I I . ‘ •.. — ‘ .1 itii’1i..JcIraqiicia’rIIl•.i-”,•iTtu.aIt1UOi.)T{l II.Ti’ .ltj) jliI_LI1.;L1I)p.vaai -.i)I.)IflS •.3Ul •)I4! .t’’ i.1LjT1i%.L1,bti.1%1d i’•11TIlt.,14tI)..iIa.’j !)T1l 111,j19I.I(11’I ‘fipilhiC’;fl• II’‘Ij.;I’%IatIi •,‘.‘c1L1h1:4“P•‘It‘-‘ILi fr-a, •s_l..i)%IIIT 13111 r.,%1)11v1;riu’v31L1Jflpn;nu’u•’3 IrtTlIlb{LIa‘.W\ iIt)TIIIX1’n)TLlflitDljJlI)flifls%1t43UN‘J’JI1j, I%%i - iI1C’t(1’ )1IEL”1’q31Ij.I1%.1111 •‘.)‘—•‘)U1!.II“1)ILUi 134&P‘$41painap•)•unj ‘LUCUIIWl.Ti:UTp.1(’“NTLl1‘13lJ 41 ‘SmIOUi41L)%IL).)P )P111L1L)JSl3J.I!1!%dP1 paQr.’—1 i -1Jflui%pajiputic flU. ‘.!tl•N1Gt9S)O%Tflp1—.ia•1’ w’. %_ITITPI{l’tItutlu‘ui’i.qiu.did iiin’çJ Cl.jIq.IaII’uJt_1’muiq?iaruqj’.;•,m1p.1..iI1,V14•)“t’.’ITICISTII 11ip.%‘qs I’1’a14? pupI°\ I1’j C1 •‘flilfls 1P133J1’tufl1o3UtI%IRuL1%31 %i% r.eIL1.’”’‘i iflICp’’[ip•)IgJ :d‘l!i1r.ic,—Ort.Ifl1a%1JI! ‘,TlM1?I41’)Jt.lIgl-fllflpfl •iV—ta• Viur‘‘iTjWVhIL 1111 -‘ .:1japa’T’•‘ I’:•j. ,gflH )‘.‘ i . ‘ • i — ‘“ ‘ % t_t I .J —. ;E’’’.’’ I• ; ‘• • 1 Iji • I - e[r)‘ •

11. s • •‘ I- ), I ( (1 d (3 c 7 uji.i 1 i C -t i Of’ ‘UN J U3 i n p lx bit IA) Lii 1 i 1% lii I i liii fli%LU C’ 111111% ‘i%i o i’ r I I I P1’ _Ilctflt th i “keen. ‘ rc’ jcijg. ii ht t Ptt I tl’ctt Lip* • t. Ii”C’1 V VqntI’k .1 n’nr’iej ntd tciercahLr nurut ihr dtad •och It po4 .inrten rptt of & c ccl Sit u a ) ;I j.,r i r t it do c iii exudn I)flL4ht rt’ ‘lo”d —- A at. s( n V ri s Ac i U SI 1JC II nc I 3 hr x”i i Lii )r’, i ‘wr’i”ric’i ill 1t i isa of tfl r.piil.rinv. ‘h’ “‘ii a”” U%ta1I’ ,ii.trk’aiv • ;‘eilt&itd %lI’Aiflt hetrniw I ILCI2IL’ pak lit’. •i’O (Lii •i A41..,.li I 1C,)I”L flt IC ‘ Ii ) lb vu’ iiIi 1’ . C’ ‘.5.1 j” 5 :L.fla%e. •J l.i:; ‘1,11.1 Ii..,.f • :, I. . t14,, i,i.f s a .,— __ •&h. I ii ‘, i1t’. ‘ 1 c u 1 ‘‘ — %(

1.1 I •,

5. • p I , I - It ‘C: — e w 1$ ‘.r n.u1 I LI ii’ dcc *a%C(j ihi rt a1cr P(h11flQ Ptttt 1 QJI h t a id ‘Ii It C line o cit :h IbOLI t7 I” 2i liLJt% P’°’ it’ C P’ at) iflc Ti (X11 1 ILII !2 ()t 1 1) l,1 ;1 - ,. . ,%ç)fl ‘‘ i’ the cspiu;niI it iniciti Ii ii1 Ii t t - I the pi’ ‘4( titi’ it W.iifl(%M C Mid ha £ o.nr n tie that Il-it aec u%.cI is guilt of ii t offenet (01 chisioi (wtilng-t zkI1Fa11Ior.sttdadrrp ii vitw f the thou... cuss LiS%iOil ‘C pass tat .nJlo I’ bat uerl

ORDER Il’is C flilillirL akl)JsrcI’ Is dust ps%rd 7 —p • p p I-, KSRJ & CRKSJ: 25.01.2011 - 19- ORDER CRLA.No.263 1/2008 Mlsc.Crl.No. 16553/2005 sunrive consideration, the main matter dismissed. Accordingly, Misc.Crl.No. 16553/2005 is dismissed. Sd! JUDGE a AHB