THE MANAGING DIRECTOR, NWICRT. C, CENTRAL OFFICE, GOIKUL ROAD. HUFLI, RERBY ITS CHIEF LAW OFFICER v. SMTMANG.ALA \V.’OPARAPPA NUCHH1

Judgment

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT B EN C H AT D HARWAD DATE..DD. THIS THE.. 19TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2011 BEFORE. THE HON’BLE MR SJLJSTICE BALNAOARATHNA MQia32OO7flV APPELLANT BETWEEN: THE MANAGING DIRECTOR, NWICRT. C, CENTRAL OFFICE, GOIKUL ROAD. HUFLI, RERBY ITS CHIEF LAW OFFICER, (B... UT WRONGLY SHOWN AS REP. BY THE DIVISIONA.L CONTROLLER, NWiCRTC. BELGAUM IN THE CAUSE TITLE.; BEFORE MACTI (BY SRi F. S. DABA Li, ADVOCATE) AND: 1,, 2,

3., 4 SMTMANG.ALA \V.’OPARAPPA NUCHH1, i\QP. 4(3 YEARS. 0CC: HOUSEHOLD WORK, K UMARI NANDA D/OPARAPPA NUCHHI, AGE 14 YEARS, 0CC: STUDENT, KUMAR GANAPATHI S/O. PARAPPA NUCCHI, AGE 1.2 YEARS. 0CC: STUDENT, KU MAR BASAVARAL 5/0, SARA PPA NLICL1Hi, AGE 10 YEARS, 0CC: STUDENT, THE RESPONDETN NOS,2 TO 4 ARE MINORS B mT4Er NAT’ RAL 4)THE5 ‘‘‘‘ ‘N — p?:LSPtDJ’JDE.NT No.1 A.LL THE RESPOt DENTS ARE P./O. LAXMI NAGAR, BANAHATFI, TALUR. JAMARHANDI, DIST.:BACALKOT. Ci5’YSKi.HiVI31iSi—{ Th,WIAJ.’.JUT AL2U. P2)I2 K?KSIPOAJDEN1T5 IHIS MPA IS FiLED I. NDER SECTION 1 73t11 J M\ NcT AGAINST fOE •JCLXMENT ND N\V\RL) DATED 03H2 200 NSSF D IN M\ C NO 1 3 LII I OF MEMBI R MAC F F. ()MPENM1TO\ (E Es NJTJON TIlL )FP()i ON THI ‘FMAKII\NDI. AWR1)ING N ‘5( \\iih INTl h1ESi F L?( iE. 00 THIS \PPE\L COMING ON FOR ADMISSION TillS DAF. THE cUtRf DELIVERED TIlL FOLLOWING JUDGMENT Phis ippeil s filed by th N.W K ETC ssaihng the judgmnnt and a\\ald dated 03 02 p002, passd in M\ C No 156, 2005 b the M’\CT at Jarnakhancli. lEe icictant fac s f the case dC that C LA 01 2005 Ofl Mtllcipp w hi ‘t as proceeding r w aids bo tnd canteen at Banah:itt, Jinag tvfth his sonLn Ian to oat e h21strariun Nc4 k-F 23 21 rnIn }yr djr5) :10 ; t 0 0 •gI dO5 C a 1 01’l I (C i I o:- nn N Earn rn Nan nk1rte 01n C f 1 1 i ‘ C4 p . it N I 1 a A D C * - D C r ) ) C C D C ) ) C i c c i c - ) C c D C - i C 2 D C I t - f C 3 1 I - C • l i c _ I - C - ) * ) C i i D C i c D C ,I C * r D C - - c c i c c l C r C D C - ì a * D C * - D C I _ r 3 0 0 D C - D C - D C c c D C 3 ( c c * - i c * 1 i c D C + - D C c c c 31c r C I D D C I D ) C i c c 3 - N c c r o i c I D D C r C ) C ) C t - c c * o i c c c * I D r C c c c i c D C i* c g r f D C 3 1 ) C c 3 r 1 - 1 c c Q - D C D C C D C I I D D D C ) i c i c D 3 C D C 2 ) i D C 3 i *c D C 3 I /D D C c c c 3 * c i ) i c 3 i c D C D C I 3 D C + I D * 3 i c C ( c C0c i 1c i c - 3 ( )1c c c i i 2c 1 ( 2 1 2 “ i c iIC c D 0 r t 2 I 1 ( 2 / ( i I 2 1 i c t C ‘ S ( — I 1I‘ S t 2 ‘ 3 ( r I I ‘ I — t S ’ 1 L C 2 ‘ i c * 2 ‘ ) 1 ) i c 2 1 1 ‘ D C 0 I * C i c i c i c 2 1 2 ‘ ( 2 / ( c c 0 2 1 I 2 1 1 : i c D C j r C 0 2 1 c I I 2 / ( i c 1 ‘ D 3 ( - 3 i c c ‘ t S 2 — e i c 0 i i c 0 i c i i c C _ J c 2 1 ( i - i c i i i c 3 ( i i c * 2I ( 2 1 i c i c — i i c i c 3 ( — ) i c f 2 ( i i c , C - 2 ( 2 ‘ ( 0 i c 2 / ( i c 2 : i c c i c 2 1 2 1 - 3 2 1 2 ( 2 1 )— 2 1 ( j ; ( ( t S ‘ ) I - 2 ‘ t S - i c ) I r 2 ‘ o 2 z i I 2 ‘ i c I - - ; I — i c ; J J N 2 1 I 2 ‘ I i c * i c 2 1 ) i c r I ‘ - 2 1 2 ‘ - 3 3‘ 2 ’ 1 2 ‘ 2 ‘ c c 2 ‘ i c D C D C ) C I ‘ ( . a . z C 5 : 3 0 3 C D i c p 4 - D C r o i i I ( I ( i k D0 C 1 1 ( 3 0 k O 3 0 . 3 0 3 0 - 3 3 1 1 1 1 D C D 0 C ) i c 4 - C i Cc S i c 0 0 3 0 5 3 0 i c 3 0 0 0 3 0 i c - ’ i c . a 3 3 D C 5 : 2 / 1 )2 i c 0 3 3 5 : D C ) l . a I ‘ ( c c . D C 5 3 0 D C 3 3 D C j - 4 - 3 3 0 3 0 ( 1 i c ) C I I I ) 1 ) i c 1 D C . a 4 - 0 3 3 g - ) i c i c CC 4 - 3 P 0 5 : 5 : 0 5 : 5 o D C c j J ) 1 3 : . — a 0 * r o 0 c 0 0 ) i Dc C f I D C D C 0 ( - D C 3 1 ) 0 + r o k 1 4 0 ) i c ) 1 ( — 0 i c - 3 — 4 j t D C D C 3 0 3 D C 5 0 4 5 - : - s 0 k j z o i c C i c ( 1 : ÷ - 2 / 1 ) i c D C i k ) 5C 0 5 : J - D r o D C 3 0 ; 3 0 I + i c * r o 0 : 3 P D C 3 - J ; i 0c 0 0 , 0 , 9 0 0 0I 0 t 0 c 0 0 0 a a .C 3 1 r 0 B 0 9 D C ) b 0 . I I a v s mC - 0 c r t • r P g - a a , a c S t - a 0 0 . 2 9 ’ A W ‘ 0 d — , a a 3 i o W