Karnataka Circuit Bench High Court · 2011
Judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE H.N.NAGAMOHAN DAS 13ETWEE: i. \. 2CC \1 \ S/o Ramagouda Pa tiP Age: 47 yea.rs, Oc. c S€..rvice, R1’o C hinchaiii, Tq: Chikodi-)Rd IdOl., Dist: Belgaum. I\ ge: 7l or•. 0cc t R/o Oh ika.rId.hana Road, Bija.pur. Dist: B.I.1apu.r-8b 1.
N; in e s s, f..., The Ef ranch Mana:er. idationni insurance L.ompanr L.r rJ ‘I’d is 0 PA is filed ui i u m yIif o 25/04/2003 psed in VIVA No.247 ..h ,/ 2001 on idn’ i Cii e Si Dii I iOu I n C I n n des Section 73(1) o I V Act , ] ] C C D ” D C ’ Z D C : ” ) K O C ( , : i L D C a i L a — 5 5 i L D C : C ( . D C ’ D C ’ ) K ’ H D C 5 5 5 5 O D D C D : ’ i L C D C i D C L ” r : I D D O D D C D C — C < D C i L i < L D C D C D C , , , 5 5 5 ) K O D C D C D . ’ t V i i D L L C 2 L ( i e c j : i L O D ” i L D C D C i L i L : , i L i L D J ‘ ’ D C D C , i L D C ‘ C C / O D i L _ , i L ] C , : ‘ ‘ . . . ’ o D C a ’ , C ) _ r “ — ‘ I E j ] r ] C ) K 1 : ) K : D C ’ C C D C D C ‘ i L “ D C D C “ O D ‘ a D C ’ ] C ’ i i L D C a i ( L 5 r ’ 5 C D O D ’ i L i L e C ’ D C ’ , , i L i i L L : ’ “ L ’ J • D C o D D C ) 0 ( D C 5 a 5 5 D C a i L ( C ’ i L i L 2 5 0 “ — t o t D C ( — 2 , D C ’ O D i L i ’ i L L ’ C C , . i L . - 0 / D C ; 2 D C ( ” ] C “ C . 2 _ P 5 N I D C . D C ‘ i L p 0 i L ‘ i L t ] T C o t ( i O D L e 5 : ’ c ( ‘ ‘ i , “ D C L ” I 5 : , D C ( Dt C i L i L ’ i L I - — ) D , C ‘ ‘ D C — _ < 5 ‘ “ / ’ “ O C i D C i L : ‘ ’ C O — i L ‘ ; _ ( 5 5 ’ . i L 2 ! ‘ ‘ 0 , 5 i L D C D C 5 5 ‘ ’ r i C L - i i L L D C “ ‘ i i S L ‘ ’ i L D C D C D C i L 5 5 D C ( ( i L , — D C i L ( ’ ; C C C . D C i L i L D C C ( i L D C D C ’ O D ( “ ) : C D C a ‘ 2 ( ] , , N D C “ O D ) K ’ ) K D C 5 5 D C 4 . ‘ D C ’ i ’ i L ” 5 L i i L D C a ’ 5 — D C C D D C ( ‘ ‘ ’ 5 O D 2 ( 2 ( i L D C ( a D C O ( a . 2 t i t - - , D C i L ’ i L ‘ D C ( D C : t i D L C , - D C i H L - i L D C . i L 5 : D C i L • ’ i L : i L a ” D C i L D C i L e i L ’ D C D C : O D E i L ‘ ’ D C D a C ’ O D ’ i L D C D C . r ‘ D C : i L ) D C D C C . 5 ) 0 ] C 1 ‘ ’ i L ) i C ’ D C D C , a L L i i ’ O D , 2 5 D C D C t S . 2 O D ’ i L i i L L r O C D D C 5 5 r H — < ‘ — D C D C ( ’ i D C — ’ D C i t - L ; D C ( — i L ) K ‘ 2 “ . D C : 5 5 . — — D C t r ‘ i i D C L L D C D C C i L : O D D C O D i i L L O D D C n 5 i L D C i D C L , D 1D C i i . 5 L 5 : C C < t D C O C t D C i L i L D C D C ’ 1 - D C c , D C i L D C D C D C D C D C D C D C c s - c - O D i 5 L ‘ i D C L L D O — i L D C — D c - C 5 D C O D L e 2 i ’ 5 : ) • ‘ i D C L ‘ i L c C . . i L ‘ i L D C . 5 i L ’ 0 . C C i L 2 ) t V , 5 - “ C D C i — L , o - i i L L O D . a D C : i L i L D C i i L L . i L . — D C 2 1 £ V D C 0 5 5 , D C , ( ] C i L ] C , i L ’ D C D C D C i L i L D C — C ( O — - ’ i L D C i L : i L 2 i L a D C D C - i L D C - O D D C i L ’ ] i C L D C D C D C D C C ’ , ’ n O t 5 5 t ’ c < ‘ : i L I ’ C J C O D ’ 5 L i : i L : , D C 2 / ( ) K . D C ‘ “ : . . t D C “ i L D C D C • D C D C c c ‘ D C D C 5 L i r , i L , i L 4 H H H H I L H H I L I L ( i i H H H I H ( H H H H H H ( H H ( H . 0 ( ( H I L H . 0 ( H H ’ 0 ( H _ 7 ( H 0 ( 0 ( o C o C H — I L H H H ( ( H ( I L H 0 ( - H H ( I L H H H ( I L H I L H H H o C . . H ( H ( H I H H ( ) ) C C . . . • i 0 ( . 0 ( H ( I L H I L I L — I L H H I H I L 3 I L — H 0 ( I L — I L H H H ( ) C H ( H 2 H H ( H H — H — 3 H o H ) H ( H ( H ( — i C H ( - I . . H 0 H ( — . , H I L : 0 ( . H 0 ( o C o C H H I L ( — H I L H H ( . 2 0 ( ) C H I L I L H I L I L I L * H 0 ( ( H H ( 0 ( H ( . . . H ( 1 , 0 . H ( H ( - 0 ( H ( H H H . H H 0 ( . H ( I L H — H I L — 1 - H I L H H ( H H ( * H H ( ‘ I L I L • , 3 0 ( H . H H . 0 ( H — H ( 0 ( H ( — 0 _ . — . H 0 0 H ( H H H H ( ( ( ( H 2 . H ( ( — H — - ) - I L H H I L 0 ( — H . h T H — — H - H I L H ( H , — ( : H 0 ( ( H ( I L 2 . H H H H I L 0 1 ( H H I L H ( H O C — H H a I L H ( I L H ( I L , H H ( H ( ) C C ( ( H - ) C H H ( ( H H ( ( . . I L H ( ) C H ( 7 ( H ( I — L — I L I L H H . I L ’ H ( H 2 H 7 ( H 0 ( H . — . H I 3 L IH L 0 ( H H H H ( H 2 0 0 ) C C H — H ( i H ( 0 0 H ( H ( . H ( i 2 H H : : I L H H H H— H I L ( H — I L • . I L • H i 2 H H - 3 H i H H H H I L _ I L H I L H H H ( I L —• i H • I L H 3 • H — — H ) 1 ( H H • I L • H o C 0 • I L I L
Precedent status how later indexed judgments have treated this case
No known negative treatment found in the Courts & Cases corpus.
This is a result about the indexed corpus, not a finding that the judgment remains good law. Coverage may be incomplete.