State of Karnataka v. Rudrappa, Sb. Irappa Gooli

6. On committal, the trial Court framed the following two charges for the offences punishable under Section 498A and 302 read with Section 34 of IPC: ‘1. That you accused No. I being the husband. you accused No.2 being the ‘nother-in-law and your accused No.3 being the sister-in-law of deceased Annapurna, in furtherance of your common intention, ever since her date of marriage, you all the accused, subjected the deceased Annapurna to cruelty by wilful conduct by torturing her physically and mentally at your residential house at Rayanal Village within the jurisdiction of Old Hubli P.S.. and caused grave injury to her lfr and therein you have corn milled an offence punishable under Section 498(A) nw Section 34 of IPC and within my cognizance.

2. That, on 1 0.5.2005 at about 5 O’clock in the morning at your residential house at Rayana.l village. you accused No.2 poured kerosene oil on the person of deceased and you accused No. 1 lii her on fire and did commit her murder by intentionally causing the death of deceased and thereby committed an ojjènce ) C t ) C D C j - D C L C D C ) C L C L C ) C C o D C C ) 4 L C L N E ( L E N D C C N D C L E . ) C D C D C L C c r : D C D C ) C D C r ) ) ) C C D C D C D C D C ) c C : C C D C D C ) C : D C L C Q D C ) C D C D C ) C D C L C N E C - — D C ) C ) i - C : D C • t C ) C . . D C — D C L C D C t i ) ) C C L C l * : D C D C C < E D C ) C D C D C L C I L C ) C D C < N — ) C D C H L C — ) C D C D C D C N C ) l E 0 ) N ) C D C L C D C L C ) ) C C D C D C D C L C ) C D N c C ‘ - ) i C L C ) C - L C D C D C D C N ( ) D C L C D C L r E L C D C D C L C D C D C D C L C D C D C D C . S . L C D C N ( ) ) C C t r L C ) C C D C 0 * . . C D C D C D C D C D C . C D D C D C D C D C L C D C ) N ) ) C N E D C D C ) C D C D C D C D C D C ) N C D C L C D C D C . N C ) C H L C o ) C ) ) ) C C C D C ) ) C C D C D C N E L C - - C ) C D C D C O ) C D C D C L D C ) C D C ) C ) C ) C D L C D C D C ) C D C c D C t - r 0 ) ) C c ) C C D D C D C c L C D C . D C ) C L C ; - D C c D C L C — L C D C L C D C D C D C . ) C ) C D ) C C - ) 4 . o c ) ) C C L C ° - ) C L C L C ) C C D C i c D C ) ( ( ) L C D . C L E ) ) C C t i D C L C D C ) N . . i c ( n L C D C . - N 4 - L C . ) C o c D C L C D C - D C “ — • D C D C D C r ) 4 L E ) C j — _ D _ C m C N — E ) D C C D C D C ) C . N ( I D C ) D C C D C D C D C D . ) C C — : D C ) C D C D — C D C C C ) C D C ) C — ) C H E - - : L E O D \ l f : L C ) o N C C ) N ) N ) ) C ) N ) ) C C L C m c ) N D C L C C c — D C ) ) ) C D D C C C C ) i N ( L C N r ) C D C D C ) ) C : L E : D C ) D C ) N ) C . ) C L C ) c C ) C - ” C D C — t C D C L E L E ) C C C D C ) : E C L C . N D C D C D I ) C - D C 1 D C ) C D C D C L C t i D C L ) C D C t r L C D C D C ) C ) D C D C C N D C ) C t r D C D C m N c L E . D C i - ) C D C ( 9 O D E C I D C L C D C L C t i ) ) C C . L E ) C O D ) N 0 N N N ) C D C t 4 3 2 2 : 2 : 2 2 7 : + — 9 4 - 2 2 : - 2 : — - 4 j j ‘— ( 2 Y 3 C 3 2 l C 2 : 2 : 2 2 : 2 7: ) 1 7 3 2 j - i - - CN - - 2 : — ; 2 : 2 l C 2 : C l C l C ) - C / C E z — l C — 1 1 2 2 3 ( - - C - — - t - 3 - - ) - 2 2 3 2 2 2 7 2 2 : , . ’ D 2 C D C l E l l E D C E . I C D C — D C - D C D C — . 4 C 9 1 4 ” e l D C 9 E i C a D C D C l E C . D C D C . . 9 . 4 r — D C D C D C i C l D C E i C l E ( l E D C D C i C D C l E 5 l E l E D C D C . — D C , _ “ . i C m C D - C m c — 5 D C . 4 — - D C D C i “ D C C H H l E D C — D C D C 4 D C 4 4 l E D C i C C4 : C D C l D C E i C 4 D C 4 i D C — D C — D C D C ” r - I C - D C D C D C 4 C ‘ . a - D C 1 4 i C D C 9 5 c C C C i C D C . . : D C D C ” D C D C . D C ‘ — D C — : D C l E D C D C D C D C — — ‘ “ D C l E r r e 9 . — D C a D C D C : D C D C D C a D C D C D C D C D C a D C i C : m c a D C 4 l ‘ E C C — D C D C D C t D C D C C C 9 l E 4 D 1C 4 m c l 7 E — D C D C D C i C ; — . — ‘ 9 ‘ D C 4 9 D C D C D r C ‘ C C C D C l E D C ’ D C 5 9 D C 9 D C 2 4 D C m c 1 - a ; — l D C D C E D C ” C ) : C C D C — D C . D C ) D C D C l E “ ‘ D — C i C a a D C D C l E D C . i C ; — t . 5 , J ) D C . D C : C D C D C 4 m e — 0 — * — t i i i C C . D C - D C ‘ L : D C D C D C D C ’ 9 D C D C . 5 . Z ’ 2 D C I C C D C D C D C D C ) r C m c D C l 9 E D C C C C D C 9 1 4 D C - a l E D C — D C D C D C D C i C l D C E D C 5 t — T C D C - ; — t i a D C “ 4 D C ‘ . D C ‘ l P E 5 D C a D C D C l E D C l E l E D C D C ’ D C D C S D C - D C D C . ) C “ i C a ’ D C D C D C D C 1 4 D C i C l l E E m c D C D C m c l m c E D C a i C D C 5 D C 5 ) 4 C i i 2 C : 4 - l E C - ‘ C C C 1 4 D C — D C - . i - C C C D C i C D C D C r — D C l E C C l D C E D C — ’ D C D C D C a ‘ i — C i — D C D C — H — — ‘ m D c C , , I i C ‘ D C D C l E . ” C C D C i C D C r i C l D C E — . H ‘ D C l E D C D C i C , m i C C C ) 4 C N ( i C D C D C “ D C C D C ’ ” C i C ’ r C U C D C D C D C 2 5 a ” D C i l C m c l E : D C l E i C 1 4 a D C 1 4 D C D C m e C C C S l E D C — D C - D C ’ D C D C 4 9 : D C l E ’ D C D 2 C - 9 D C D C l — E D C l D C E 5 - I D C D C l E , , “ D C ‘ 1 4 0 — ) 4 i C l E l E D C D C ’ D C D C — D C i C l D C E H ) 4 l E D C 4 9 - — l E D C D C . D C 2 m e r l E i . — D C i i z D C C ” i D C - o D C < D C . 1 4 l E ‘ D • C — D C D C D C L i i i C D C . — D C D C D C ‘ l : D C E C C 5 D - C 4 C J - m C ; C l N E ’ I l D C E D C N D ’ D C 5 9 a D C D C D C D C D C < > l E , C 4 9 I : - D C D C 4 ” 9 p D C r l E r4 r e m e r l E ’ ; 2 D C . l E D C l E D C . D C D C C C C C . — D C C C D C r S ) C C l l E E “ D C ’ D C D C ’ C C m - r — D C D C - D C 4 1 4 D C l E l E a 9 l E D C : C C D C . D C D C 7 7 * - i - D C ) f I D C 9 l E D C i i C i C i D C • D C “ . 4 9 D C : D C D C ’ D C D C ) D C C D C m c C C D C — H { . c / - - L j - * r ) j - 1 — J ) _ - — — — D J D / J : I , - t a j I L c L j _ j Z c - — J I C - j I I - C 2 1 - IC )I C I CC C - - C * 2 . I - - C C 1 2 - C C L t 2 D j 2 - 4 - C . l c t - C - C — - jL * * 3 3 : r I - 5 : , 5 — * 3 — - 3 : - — - 2 ( : ( 0 3 : 3 : 5 * 3 , 3 : 0 * 3 3 I : - , 5 S . o m c m c * 3 I 3 : - * 3 — * 3 I - - 3 : - * 3 3 : - Q — * S 2 / 3 : 3 : D 2 / 2 / 3 : D C - 2 D C r D C D C t F t F D C ) F — D C D - D C D C t r D C a . . ‘ D C D C D C Q ‘ : D D C C t ‘ F ‘ “ U D C 2 ) F t F D C . , D C ’ 9 D C D C . a t F D C — U - ‘ D C D C • ‘ D C D C 9 D C D C a . . U D C D D C • • t F D C — D C ) i ) . D C D C “ — N - D C ) ) F t F ’ D C D C D C D D C 2 . D C D C D C D C D C t F D C D C D C ‘ 9 “ ) D C - D C t r D C . ) . L D C D C a ’ t . a D C 2 D C D C — D C . D C D C F a t F D C Ft D C - D C ) — r — D C t F D C ’ ) F D C D C D C D C — ’ . E — D C . — D C D C — t ’ r U D C D C . 9 r D C D C D C D C D C - . . . D — C t F U — ) F D C — D C ’ 2 + - D C D C 9 . z - . D C D C D C ) F i - D C r t i - - D C D C 2 1 - — D C D C t F D C t F — — . - D C D C 1 D C 9 - ’ D C — D C D C D C D C D C ) F - t F 2 . D C D ) t r D C D C D C a t F D C , a D C D C D C D C D C — D C . . - — . t l a a I —