Judgment · High Court · 2011
Case at a glance
Provisions considered
Judgment
U I [iii I I-- -i I t I I C :tt. Li” til iCI h’ •ik’i’ and .t’.’suult 111% t it1... hex’ iii fl1L’tI:%’s ‘ :. !: ::. : ‘v.1 I.t. .A !t I: the tiecc .LseJ t’a’ .. :%9 *1)1.11 t’;’t’’ S _: r i’ tt tj’.1t i’rr h1.nhau1 USCLI t 1 i ht ii .1 t 1itC(1 ctLl I Ba’.’a J&’ a’ retuined t lc ii )l tIa 1iltI th dns he t C I I hi he trquirtd S.1 1.nJ (Jail th 14. t am ‘r . ‘a w 4, hi’ is iiicI .t the ‘ 1 . ‘‘se gI% u.ttd he •liitl k • t. l:i ‘ • r. I .•‘ i’’;: . - - - ...;- I.t !ia” it. ‘fC.fl,)t ‘1)1 “lit - 1’ ‘ ‘i.’ i’” I! — •._‘ U ‘ 1 I I-. % -. :tii •“ I ‘ • •t’i •I:•’ IIIIlj. ii i •I• _ • .1.:— • t •I !:. • •: . •- :;-:t t r • t:.r•.- :‘1I • I. :. •. •. I I L — • • - • I. . • — . 1 • I •• — — • - •• • - — L ii. 1’ ‘ P” 4) I’I .‘‘‘r’u’’iì,,ç‘pLk1 )di 11!111(1 ‘a,e1IUTP1:n.‘s1I’.:4 rt11.1%3 ‘lS i H ‘lL )s ‘1 511 )II1t”%i’put. ‘11.1 :‘I—; 11!Uj)!Jr)iJItdIUttj r‘H‘1011i!i .hunuin:s qçipai’ ‘U b 1%l’I_!?f“ ..t •‘ ‘.ji • pauniqi?
U I ‘t ‘C ‘p iIji1fl. F2h11I?I1 .fltj ii’ ! !%TLL’44 ‘1.’) ‘.IIII’%I•‘‘I •: j..• .•‘t; L’.i13)i ‘? .‘i31 ;(‘ nil. ‘I—! g;•: • .i’I • r“ ‘ •• .3 •Ii:Lt ‘,i.’T%. ‘-‘‘I ‘ii. r ) / C 3 - I P’’ 4 n. . . : .i’. .(‘‘‘ut .. a. •: L he ; r..pa’c I Lb a 1 ‘.li.!i”’ I ‘IL’ a Ltt’•’ p ‘ :‘i U I : !tI’ e a ‘‘ • tr’ C11t I i I t iI’Iic I It. ccclii J Ii 1 I ii I 1 1 1 1 k I riI• I! \t LI ‘ 11 lii I’ i cIcrcscl hi .1 I c it, ‘. nt.,d (Ut ft Tb t Lh t %f I’,jj. t1 ?3.flt ,._ I..’ i .utlt i It ‘C I’ t t I. Ii ‘Igfla 9 .1 tIc I .‘ C •I. ‘ ‘Li • -‘ e I , 1’ I ‘, 1 : ii I I _ I % I I I • I .)‘ II “I 10 lIt liii ‘ii ‘I ie’t’1..J ti .1 11)1’ t Li ot rift t. It r’ lu_a ‘d’ • ‘Ia 1 i a_wi an it . a it)LP I ) Ps I xl JllLi’IL I I ‘ ‘i’t isi hr pi I) :r t ?‘tS.t a IN das • P’ 4?(. \ 1 I i
fljt Ii PW.’ j.% l P’’1 ii’ 1 i’ fl)t aisised •t’ieI tid 1i\ ‘i’ :ts Ii t viten the eit to ni tiket. lit cane . kit ‘. Ia! i’ not Lnev n t I’) !1i’t .1’: u_ti He .10_s am %iibt 3L ‘U%t d ii is In L’ This ‘t li_u_s I ‘ii sti (a) Li’ a I I
L.’ t )Ii Iii ui Fit H s Its i ‘. .ir v is • )Ss 1:1 LI I i’u_. ‘r’ v I I ub..i.
P.si. .t ‘, I fl 1 hit. ‘S e1i ‘te I I I ti)’ Ill tit ••I’ _ “I j I a I’ I I t L i I •.•, • ‘ I• b11( K 10 Ii •h ‘0 ‘J%I%% ‘ ha di lIh n s ha I •ii•’il k.%t.1e t’• th iI: itt the r’ t’C” t ‘.‘. 1’ i12 1 el’’ 1tCL1 •I Is ii % t •anii; I i Ti 111 i;I’. !%t4., 111% • I, £ ) P% S Iit’ iCj)iI’CJ Ii’ it lie L’ov prn%ecutlln; ibiIILC¼’C% P\% !. 1 iP. !2. I :ntl I He tlef’L’StLi i’!) ‘b.” 26i1 ‘t n’lu \s ik.n lit s% ii, .it S.udaLI PW I I indu CaIflt a_nd t Id t i it tlsauh t iii ii t Fun it 1k Lb ) S.) It’ d a t d “ T I’ a1 i j; ‘ t 11 e ‘ JO t ) ‘ ‘1 icjd ‘pt uc ‘d lie e:’1i1 ‘i Sh . (.ini :cr ral Ir ti. Id ni, :k e%Ter.i nçht . 4 iI%I’(I ‘ td tflg Iii • IC I l’d%dflat I’’’ .i•i ;tt:i,” I .n t. ?•‘ : flit ,..t f;. .• 1% hi .51.) q ,_J I CI I ,I . I 1 I iI• £ U I I If k I ‘ i I I I ‘ii 1t :T:tu ! .b.t i: I I.: I I a II’ Li) if) Li IL I It) ‘1. t I I Nfl’ md alt IK ::rdei J lie ‘ ci (Ii meWi’ 1 ii tiw i’nipIaint. !h: ‘‘n’p!ai:’aIt: :( t I C’i h: ¼IJDLILIIr.
U. About I d ‘ ‘N ‘‘I I’. n:rk” ‘‘t I ‘‘aaI’ai .L%CI! ha LIITIIt LI ‘i ‘ i ! lit I I’ Ic CU%t’d C 1 )t heed sI has si Itt 11) tl’c j’i•I:c: I n tb I I “‘S - I’ La!) I. t Ci iidL I” • S, ii; • ‘. I ‘LI fl ‘Ii I I •‘I’’ •.‘i_ t I; i_I.: I.. ‘I • •—. (I 1 ‘I, 1 I — • II 1 ‘izn ttt’i ‘ •ll I :Il %>j,j lij’•t L’ e:’ :‘l itill hini Fiat i;. ha’ s t ith t. . t’W’i t’:t Faz ‘ :aIII’nci’ Ill dIe ‘ 1 t ‘1 .1 L. 1W ) a’ cit ia ci Ill,. e i’t Lu IA iii I’ 1 1 It ‘ I He doe’, Iwt kiu’ hn’ 1 u1 11,1% wiInes :ia% turned liustlic \c:j h!1:
4.. .ñ. .tcd I I iii’ CIOs .11 IC IL. LI F S I C %f 1’ j J C I bP 1° ‘bL. t, 4 .1 . _‘i t.I II’ ‘‘ 1t1.L 1tt. ‘ T aI. %.lhl ..i1.,!i, I : i1’. g. ii) • I) • ‘ . • ; •W I I ‘ I ‘‘ b lilt. • 1 •. •I t •‘ •h. ‘ 1 . • • t .• .i’.I \t — ! 4• ( L •1 c . ,_)c wIll • I . 0 si IL Sb 4 i: lii s at. a a s I:’ ‘d i’ n •lt l — fiei ‘d C:b.t tiLl... ‘I .1111
:I’c ‘ ‘ “ ‘I ‘ ‘ cx d. ii 4 h h ‘.1iL ‘C t i m ‘‘ r ‘ 1’ ig ‘ J ‘ ii) ‘h-’ liii’ and thct 1w a” aulxed hex h .1iea!1 )1 :iII p Duriri,i i ‘— ‘ amiliax iu” h ‘he L arx’V Jefent C t I % S U I P )1DL dl s Li ).S nut 1’ ‘v nh Uk x all h” ‘Jo girna and ;niors, wd I ‘i.C Ut t •i.:n’;ttcd ti tlic ho4.p ta! -,• ,‘, tP jj..,h’1 •1• • %ij5•_ T4(j pIi.% ‘ill’! tca •i a t 4, I. ! J’I •‘ I-.” lj I,j’ 3 1 1% I •• I, • I I.. •I C. ç ,. • ‘,ti’I ie’ - • :,. _ • ii. ‘.: • S It • ii’ .1 . :. .ue prrc.’i P i •h . ‘I; iIp . cm aitiu; id ti’e ¼LitciIctI Lr:l (Iii nL’r” I ‘. the iUtrc n er %caIp the w aiihj1 . • 9,. \ 4) 5 j,e it - tc’t Hk I’’L ‘e: t1 nt 2 C ontus (I ) en’. p’ei t C C t’ Iatei. \brisioi hecI In. Ii’. 5 ..r . — sent o ‘f i ‘ I!’ j$r “t I)’ ‘_T. ;l1 II —..‘ r ;• .-:• ,I:j !— h:,:. . :r .:..! •iI i_ 4 I. ;..!‘‘‘ i.,:, •Ii •‘ .f1¼., IT St. :. \([ ‘S 1% t. • ‘t’ ii t11L.hI t1’ C ) It • IL \ ( I ‘\ i “i “ $ a c. . 5 dis :1 U) ‘fijUt ‘ \a’ l is ‘$ j, I’iLa• I’a 10 \t$r nion O si,: ni - I c n st st i. n e.
Ji. I \ o’ tu’ I %j I — .•• “tCflt c Ibh 2IuteaI .t2.fl 1’. t. ‘it Is (9 • T tilt t .1 It F I —I ri• s i t n.r j’ \\ I) ha— 9 ft It’ an i at t ‘i, ‘m r,iia ‘e Itl)iN ‘‘t.. I al’iC’ i•”’i tbtI t ‘ tMI .& iii h.’ I I I I I € 1 •I’i •ç_ I t 1 $ I’ I r’iji ! .. ••1.t ;‘r_t. I” •‘ $ t i.’ I It i.I I’ ‘ t i . L ‘ I:.. ‘C -I’) $ 1k’ tu ICp0% at ‘ink leLib itt 12 t n’’ui p9t)i hi flicutni’ ‘‘..L1i.’;’t’1,’. lie t.’it!v. •k.pocd rbat on I — ‘W’— ‘1. 1 ,I:. ? t 1) I “I ‘ i •ni •ql I ..s’it 1 ‘C’ .011 ‘aai’l’t ‘ •1k’.lIl fl U\. 14” ha’ opined thaL ‘u.h i’tjur’cs in PIM a.vrtetu iep’rt can N It it i pc ,n 1— in i ted f’ r i:ik q a’ \c kiO’iU I nehne Dur’n S LV’S% t 11,1 i’ii’P ‘atIc t .1 ‘fl LX S )fl till’ a taiIjI ‘s Fiei’ tI’n • 1re 1’ i:c 1p !ll1 ‘Ut._Ifl 1i1za%;( 11 SE St at I CC (I ‘) S lii “1 ‘it strt1 •,t Jj% iC%fiI’!.. I’. P ‘ i_ ‘ I I I’ It, ‘ I I _,. I aI .. • • • •: 1. 4 C t I I L ilc’pfl%%.’d tli:it :LtI,%ctj ICd I:”:’ 5’ ln ia.U: tnd prt.tftttetl t lit axe tnd ib %:ntt ‘ a— ci ‘_.. I \ I-’ p a.katii•1sma. \du’swL’ .tI:’n’ ft.
1) ‘,J hI11... %t•i — •1.) -I •—: It” LX P Tht itattc i t:d to judi ial i.tsta itt cii I ‘ 2 PC\.II.32’ theiSt 1) Ortc’ ollecic the medic u’rnp’etion o ‘o(r he ... I i pm c d • 1 us... I — !3 S1p1c,i.1 ,i I u.ta’ S ‘i o. ‘ ot Ct P( ‘d ,.a: j . I • :,,—. :. •. — _i_ p ‘r a’.— — •;‘‘ !i: • h. 7’ !Ct,’C’’ ;‘‘.! fl,,)j I 5, I a ii 1’ , ‘ .r: ‘1’ 1. ‘,t. Is lit tzialCnu I li.is ‘l%tI._I ib.t ‘tc. iii.’ t P’ I tu t •i katie i du: ,•p nrh1 e •;e1 ii;”:’.i %h. ‘i.L dat IIIL’J. l1’i lç )t’ii 114 i’’li’ f’i’I ciii) it ‘I .1% t: it ci q1 Nt quai’ ‘ic’t ‘R’id hc n’uitipic itlit’ ‘ i:htItt ‘tI’i in c d1tib t II’S % nf’Ie LCLUitt ‘cli clii. lict1. c th” j4”’$flhl;t 0 ftc a ed h.illn’ Pt U k tL” I ‘ I L1 1 at P e tThkk.P4..c UI 2 i’u S t i jiI’,tt ii ti’ ‘it sat i C) I JIa%ah ii 1OIT’iflt1a1 ! Tb iiI( a I ‘t’m’rniü P44 1 ii) I’ i.cpI t,ti •‘tii Ioi : a Isi ‘Vi. I’ e s.. in tEe KLL! C. I s)e t I ‘ t itlits. . • i Ibflt .1 ilU i. P44b.I 114’. J%i$’ I •. I) I 1 U% 4.
4.. iilHt t, i a: • Ui• ‘ ‘•j fl..,_ S P’\ I i ‘. 14)J e ‘ ‘I •p ‘b ‘ : i i , 1
1.’ i. .‘i ‘ . . ri t •t( •!t. ,a•t. Jt’’i jilt! I I S . S I ‘I. ;4 i bet hi i’i oh Lt%Lt ‘%. at’l ‘ti :Ji tctuse a i It L .ui•c ta•k !.r ‘ur •,.. :, nt;’. ..‘ T;h.. .4 ‘ %Ci. ..it’t.fl. 11k. ‘a o: o I ‘lIiII tilt S •iJ 1)IL’t’ ‘ “i it t;i tuseil I t - r 1 hte t”’ I)rns:’II , br :‘i ‘: I I c I-t the nttelICj. ‘ha. crc’ The Co t’j •_it Iii though P%\ ‘tas tint %IPPL’ItcLl the t’trrt a%t 1jF I’J’ utwn • I) ; iii — I ii au he Ic. 1n La Ii’ 11% t!.Iur.t% .7n ‘ .:i: •:I t ;1 .fl, It* tflI C n.ri ...! .tI’ 1I’Ilti’ 1 p1’ 1’ it I P\ ‘C rn•’) 1 t t .1- 1 LI Ie . I hi I * — . . . . . I, . i:’.. — . : , . • :!. ;i. ;. I’) ‘. • it LI k ‘1. ‘.1 i,’t’ PLLt I I. I S I 4—.r’it da’ o,th’ •1. j ‘.i 1 . I..’ • ‘I tiLL%’ — liii’ I I rita: t 0 II IS ! I) depoed • hut Zfl1? tkt ea’t d flu Ic Lie.. I LI 1u;ion ndc.rc Iiersel... PV s 3 Pd aLit 1 ‘1k S d.i Still Li’stt hicut Ii i ti .auist l’rt i in Jb. 1f Sift ci lit iheir ii1age ‘ hcie bL as•’iiIted with •iI .flt i)ii ilel ie.’tI u.•! other •1 1’ ‘ PS ev: Jetiee iiflflhlit% tt•i: ,tfa),Ctijtj.)l) th a the teue ha ot ‘itted ‘e ‘ic %%i Vu ii.. iii (‘t’ti is il IuttF .(‘i t,r 41j1;’ it’ 1• ‘ . ;)“i ! tj :9 iI;e . ‘_ ‘ F’: ‘tP” .‘! :. Li..— er tl’e p S • I.. :‘ t I .. • :•..; ‘:•. .. ..•. ‘I • % !‘r. :.I .: 1 i AS • • .1 I. I’. I j_.t . ‘. . lI• • ‘I I. ‘ i’tI It I’ 1’’1:’t’ii1’!l)i1IILIij% 1’’ ‘)tj, “i!‘PP” ‘‘t1L(1U“fldlLa’ijCfl’( ‘1(‘jWd•k);.’i’p1%1t1b ‘)4‘q!” q’” p’arlUI?c’)l “‘ “ qi.‘U(’fln.‘flu.411 i‘i’d‘‘11ps ‘ i ‘‘ 1 P.;t ‘aru,%paj!n‘u .cpUn Put’ur; jouciuinc’“IIotext: c’S1.’fltlPtJ)3fltk’U11)l”!JI‘Pp31q.nqj‘qil?’Isaqpasrnn (U‘)VSSPIAii“•‘u‘i1ifl‘N!‘! Iipi ‘10)rat Ir’31311nj pi’atadq1j’j’j’L))LIDS‘)J1‘Cj” x1dr9ti si’arijaddrapin!““‘.‘p‘umsiqin.;)aua •.Iipxta.q,% Uq ‘ni iVt C it, ck.‘‘nft)!‘iiir’Jit.•.citr H’q a‘ 4111 I•j •afl ,) II ‘ •;• t1 1t,t,1’1i’i’33 . • •‘.—‘I’ •- I••: r—.• ‘ ! i 1,i I I • “‘If • t••t• • ‘ •‘ I ••• • I •. I 4 •• • • ‘I iiI’L1iiII.;flfli)S.11.1M!‘1114iI%I •na-‘‘t .11))iU!F’ ‘ira 11111 jp’ J’ ‘I!L i’i lS% Iii’ Lj A% I •, T’fl \II flJI p’s..X’, u“Tnquq’.i’qun.111L 4Jr:1aidnIL’]i.Ui’p’iir’.‘I; 1 ) 1 ‘ I I 1 4 ‘ ‘I ‘Ik?pI‘S1aiui.pa’‘Ilati %I%%3It)IwIatIj’jL’ 1’i’ a’llIi’jiiajt iii1ILL II’ ‘‘i’ ‘II’ IC)1tiC Id I I ‘S L1)flfl.%1)Td 1zi11 aqsii1,tk.n1apn’1•jI.tzraa”) l3Ld4pflep’undu 1LT1 )(i) ‘H ‘( 141 L%j’ ) itlijIPf’ I’ ‘St lii.
It 4(’j Ad .%fltj (In f) t’L;rN1” Si).\d •ij ‘ ii’i :!‘i 13•.q’’ I“‘Lii Ij’!!‘‘ LI , I I (IiI. ,.j;, ii’! Ii I• •“:1•(I:‘ .11)LPI% ‘:“ •• g1ij I II) ) ‘•1 1 .1 .i 1’ ‘ _I’ I-I. i — I .j., ‘ ‘I flU IS .4. ‘;:‘j :‘ she ‘‘ a cit” caiui1ft C r ‘I)’ ‘1’ I ‘ç •)I ii. — •lfl 3 t Cd ir ei in tI’c riaI PcvtI tji4 4.7 ‘ a...! ;i— I ;. •,— .•. I, . fl ! ‘‘4’iflH11’t i ‘ii P ‘ • ‘ Ia; A h ‘ ‘‘ 1’ • qIt’ii iii In e’ kitike ;k’t h.’ c,.’iii; ied ii. th a.t Ii. ‘Li’ _,:‘.! “;tjr’I .ii’c’ut ID injLirL 1iich i .il:c•at t.i i.nc Peci ate” bi : ‘.I’enp •“Iged r4tit .):!h.• i\.
T’ii. Li:;’ .1’,)” i ‘ii ‘•e’ttii :‘ ‘b..tht’ ihc !I ‘diii’ r I )qit ilk in, 1r ‘ei ii s C” 1 • . ‘t I I I”’. ‘_ . ‘I
h•l ‘‘41 I I. . . I “lid Is I , (j( .‘.(i ) ( •(aI1’ L1I0’I voC LI a” LII IIh’)I’t: ‘I‘“flRi IlIij%•i,) 1’ : :‘ ‘ Ti.J t_ •.‘I’• •‘a;i’‘J I.— 1 ‘ •‘,“;TjI.j.a, II 1— I” La“%i)(l%tI) ;“kI d“iPs’iaItI‘II’% ‘a j” L• ‘.L’ “4P” I‘i ‘1 ‘!.‘lJ“)L(3‘Rd‘)%Jl .‘t:a ‘P’”!1I1:%!t jIUi10J cI1flII! ‘I2’I.IUOIIfl ‘ • 1l”• •IL_ %?:ILI’.I lLfl%’JLJ‘rs1.11 I liii)Lii (LIL 3\I1’ ‘11C 03%l‘ 1k‘I.I’t’ i’Ll’ iiwq; ‘4.‘aq•.ttt \* •L_’‘P!.ta1;‘3••t4qiIij p?’It’I’q1i’aX.. \Vd aI! . ‘(“Ii i4P%” I1I\4:) •‘‘p•112ji•. :jl:.“ ‘i1 !aCt: I’‘ii” J.’i; JjlE4’(I, ‘‘j’:it ‘ a •..t i•‘fl•‘ ‘ ‘a • II ‘1 a. %a ILPii I).. Sq
1. 1• • I • ‘ I . • I s’.. 1’ 11) Ills )l P C I c .‘l Cc itt ii’ 1’ I tli L .s I’ I ‘ l-’.W Ii) I k vd in iail th I1IL des.id ill ‘P ti I IL ii ‘s I’j.,. i’?’; ‘L’t •‘ ‘he Jetai e I UI %t Lii Ii I ; t . o x a LI’ ii’ r’ i 4ç . •%. til? •1l ‘ I’ ‘ ii t” Jet’ ‘ P% Iii Iear1 ic’seak that de,.casc_d LaLc• I netu t- her that 1iei lw a aau d iii’. I ii kc. Iurng tic’s “ nm Lion I II I Ic a 3 fv LI’ C tile w usei I’rough’ his %9C Li thu tiI’ilc inI 1k’ ‘;js ieii tn%! .iicI trcatmeni .‘re €it u S - . t [ eu Ilt_iltioli ol — IC at ‘i ‘d )LIP L ibr t’ .‘ —‘f’fl31tIl’ that there 1 tic. a’. ‘. t, ‘ugi;t. i i,’ • .u. ut t..,d u:.: 1 tt. (k. I. I 1) j • It
1. I I I—i ‘ ‘ i i iir’ ha tc ‘_ j:• ‘ &z”, ‘ ‘r— ii .. ‘ ii .‘ • — ‘ i •‘‘; •. . .•‘ .:, . • •. • —C • .:_‘. ilTs’ a S.—, • S •I ; S :;‘. ¼ 1 .‘i ;•. •:. •; .. ..— i11t1 L1%i) aihe ‘ irit ihc jtIItIJ;.. ‘ct’’r 1 d b ir al (\‘uit tr ( I ‘I%I’t. 1’\ ‘tt I bi ‘1—ijt)G 5 Jr )I ‘ ii)’ I’ e s1 I ‘ ‘ 1’’ L1’h’S%Il” ‘S ci t Ot dcr Tite apt.u! I d1s! II%Lt S 1S si.
Questions this judgment answers
Which statutory provisions did this judgment involve?
Indian Penal Code, 1860.
Which court decided this case, and when?
Karnataka High Court, on 05 Jan 2011.
Precedent status how later indexed judgments have treated this case
No known negative treatment found in the Courts & Cases corpus.
This is a result about the indexed corpus, not a finding that the judgment remains good law. Coverage may be incomplete.