Judgment · High Court · 2011

q 0 3 . . C I e £ t f - n c • . — - ’ C a e a m 1 f 4J a s a s a , - ) J D C ) C o 4 . 0 ) a I l s t ‘ i C . 0 o D C J T • ) 0 * 1 t - 3 P r : I W W — D C i — a , 9 — I a - . a I i S - 1 . 1 0 ) . P I - & a — — 0 — t I ) P . . I t — i v ) ‘ 3 . . P 5 1 1 0 I L 5 0- a - — 3 1 3 1 3 : L I — a 3 5— : t — - p - p - a D a 0 ( 1 5 1 3 3 : 1 I L i I p 3 : ) X C : - : - 3 : p — 1 0 1 0 ç 3 * a i - 3 : I L 3 - 5 : 3 5 - 3 5 3 1 a 0 - 3 ( lC f / 5 I L 5 : 1 0 L I 1 3 - a a * 5 1 3 : ) 3 ( - 1 0 3 : a 3 ( 0 ( S C I L 3 : 5 : 3 1 5 L I * ) 3 : ) 3 : : 3 ( L I — 5 : a 5 : I L 3 ( - 5 3 : ) C - ) I L ) 3 ( 3 : ) 3 : 5 - a - - L I L I 5 : L I 3 : ( 3 : - I c i c : 3 : - L I I L I 3 : ( I L 1 0 3 : 3 : ) C E S C 1 0 ( L I 1 ( * X I ) i c J - 1 0 3 ( 1 3 E ; L I 5 : 1 E I ( D - 3 : 5 : 3 : 3 : 5 3 : i c P E I L L I 1 - ) 3 : a j S 3 I 3 : ) 1 ) 3 : 1 0 5 : 0 ( 3 : ) 3 : 3 L I L I I 3 : ‘ - 3 : I 3 : 3 : 3 : 3 : 5 3 : ) 3 : 5 : 3 : 3 a 3 ( L I 1 — / — J S - : t 3j : 3 ( t - 3 : * 1 ( 1 9 3 ( 3 ( 3 : 0 - 3 : 3 : 3 : 3 : ( - t 3— ( v ) : 3 : - D I 3 ( - - I ’ 1 3 : 3 : 3 : 3 : — D 1 C 9 0 0 3 : S 3 : C 9 C 3 : 9 3 ( t - 3 ( 9 3 ( ( 3 I i c - r 0j t - 3 ( 3 C 3 ( 3 ( 1 9 3 : 3 b . c - 3 ( t - 3 : 9 - C 3 : ( - 3 : t _ 3 $ 1 ( 3 : - 3 3 : - 3 ( - 0 1 5 3 : 3 : 3 $ / 3 : 3 ( 3 $ C 1 ( ) 3 : 0 3 : I i c — ) C / : C ) C 1 L L C 3 E I ) C i c - — ) C )j 3 C - — ÷ - . I - ) C - — — C C V ) C * I — - I : - C - a — — ) C C c ) C - I7 — i c ) C - - ) C — E - — 1 — j - C — - — - C ) C _ - 7 : : — C C7 C C ) C ( ) C - C- * C 7 C ) C — h C T - , ) JC - - I C - - l f ) C C C ) C ) C ) C ) C C a ) C ) C 7 - ) C ) C - 7 - — L I — - ) C 7 - E -I i’rI ‘L\o. II m,.201,c t: t’ “ ‘%t’ Th’ 2fl0 Ur C W..1 nu oti!’i have çinn ‘S murlc-r and thereb ‘onimittc i an offence p inishabk ‘indet (f’ 1K r 4 11% ic’ 1 r a. gni ante of this Corn. Second1. that ‘)U ,,crused no’,.

the above s;nd date. time and plan’ in turtlwrtnc c I and 2 ‘ni Of VuUI cnnimon intention oluntanh caused hurt to the complainint b3 (Ufl5 of thr’itiu acid on his lice and ned lurh is ned as ;capon of oUt ncc tht ret) c )mmitted offer e punihab1c under Section ‘ ‘ Sec 4 ‘if IPC and aithin the C flEfliZciflt(’ iii tlj’, to’ iii . Thirdh. that ‘.ou at . us’ a rnj5 I an1 2 on the ‘,oe said d.-v. time and p’arr. ‘n fiiitherance cowrno 1 tition ‘as d i t tiic C I’ a’li f C ‘Ii Af’ i’ce r tni’t . rsc C • •• ‘1 • ‘ j ‘-flaria: v.4 j am • ,‘ c tn f•jVt “tee. t.t g— .;‘t’ .9’i In ....,i :‘i .ii:’ ‘(37 •

•‘ •. ,j-n ‘t •;r r’’ — / r — aaCL I I L ( i T C C i L i L L q D ) I L i L — ) I L i L I L C a I IC L _ I L ( I D C CC 1 f a I a L I I L — 2 a — 2 I L c - I L * j C — I L J a - * I L a I L a - - i a — a 9 C 9 a I L ( 9 C a r 9 I - ( - 9 — a * D C i L a i L i C L 9 9 a ) / ( a i L — 2 C j a I L j D a I L D 5 I L C - - - - + - C C j a L Q I — C a i a L 9 C D C a 2 i L ) L I a Z I a j a C C i L I L 3 i — C a C ) I L C C I L a ) - C 2 - i a L z ) C f ( I ( )a I L L L I Q J C - r S - — DCS D ) C - C r D D C 1 D C — 5 I D C : C S C DC C C D C I C j C ) C 5 ) 1 - ) C C D 3 C , D C — C D C C D C r D C — C C r D 1 D — 4 4 A O C ) S C I : C - C - C I D C 5 : C - C C - C ) - C - C C C O C C j : C - - 3 5 - r D — 3 ( I ) I C C * D C C D C - ) C C - - - C - r — D D C j ) C - C C D C - C - C f C - C C C D - Q D C C - C - C C D - C D C C ) - C 9 : C S i C C C - C - 3 C c C I C ) - C - C C C D r D ) 5 D C - C : C r D — H D C S - C — 5 - C - - C C O C - C C - C D C 1 C C t — o ) r D : C 1 ¶ - C : C - C - C i C C - C - C r D C C C 5 r C D - - C C CC D C D C C c C - r D : C + + f C D C C - 1 C S - - 2 . I 5 ) C a Y 1 . t - ‘ ) 0 I - t - ) 0 ç 1 c - I 4 3 . 1 t d $ 3 , - : a 0 - ; “ • D ‘ L ‘ o - 3 . 0 — 3 1 0 1 ( _ a ‘ ) ’ . i r t - D4 0 e a , a I 2 ‘ ; D C B . n - ’ I : C t 0 , . S — : j ; 3 r ‘ ; 4 3 m a 0 1 ’ 4 2 . B t C ? r C ) ’ C C b 0 t - . C , 5 4 b C t m - ‘ ’ 0 3 m a D C t I t - i ‘ . - I ; 0 - 4 - . - 4 ‘ - 5 ) 0 ) , . , C , 5 p a - D C - r i v s a - ‘ a g ‘ . , a , ; g - . 0 / . a t m p _ f B D C o , C ) 0 ’ 0 ) I 0 . S ‘ - I ‘ 7 I 4 i p - ‘ ‘ t 4 t I 4 ‘ a , a q ) 0 C , — . 0 ) C t t 0 ’ z R u , Dg C — — : : ; ! 3 “ r , V D C 0 D C t o j - - ’ 0 * a t I L 8 ‘ - ‘ , C D ‘ - 4 _ a 0 ‘ C y * ‘ ) , C t - 1 ‘ t 1c b • r . a - 3 t - . q o ) 0 0 ‘ 0 ; i - , D C 1 - J I W I • 4 I - : - a p I a a _ 0 % - 0 — 0 ) F ’ r 1 0• ‘ . C ( D C D C 3 . . , , a t - . * t ‘ . Q “ J ‘ . 0 n D ç t D ‘ - a e C t a e Z S t - a i D C ‘ ’ Z “ ‘ — V t , I - 6 a 4 - t I , Z D C 3 - - ü 2 . 0 - - V ) C £ I 3 3 $ F t S a • D C q4 s ! ’ 0 ) 0 ‘ U — a U e C 4 . S ‘ V ) a a C D I c I Ia C V D I I a1 l C a V D - C ) I D L a I I t L a C - - D C D I D ç I I I f I D I i L i L C a - - T I C 1 C I I C L IC 1I D i L f I D I t I . z — D I a V I D C V - V V V ) D I C f I r C V L L I ( c ? V a V D I D I i - ) a V f I D D I I f I r r 1 D1 I i L f i a a - ) a D I C D a C I I ) I a I 1 a Vi D I C I + - - D - I a a - ) - I D I D C i L ( L L I ( t Q - 1 VI D D I ) L V CC i V1 L I D -D I ) I i a C L I ( D I r V C i L f I DI I C I I I L V — i L f C y I C 11 Cr14%oIro’OQ,cw C I k% 1 also prc’ied as P3 1 has stated that the ..c.uscd no 1used tu cnrn to hostel and hc had san him lhc prosecution has titlist U tPW tad lacidbin ijurcsots both duc to splashina of acid In 4cc used no Prosec hon hq dc.n t1iat mjur’cs arc gneous in 8 Nou the question is as to whether the use of acid and splashing or thc. faa of P W as 3ith an intention U murder P W 1 ithcthcr it *ttracts thc prosisions of Section .30/of 9 Fr m th vidcn e kid by hc lrosccutio particula ‘, r refcrcncc thc omplar IxP w nd as c.corlcd t b t Oon r I 3 2(0) P n r t tfr a

4.csc r i I c t ( — i _ I r C , O 4 ? : c c O C i c a < 1 a O C a i c S - D I i c ( i i c a i c C ) ) C R ) C + , 4 i - c i c c c i c - I a 0 i c i c i i c I - i c c C i c 4 i c C / i c / C i c ’ 4 i c i r C - ) C ) C i c - i c i c l C i c C i c i c 0 i D i c D - O C O C i c ( a i D ) i D - i c O C i c c a i c 3 C 0 - i c a C a i — c i c - i9 c - 1 i c r C i D ( i c C i c — , 4 p ) C a ) C C - i c i c ) C r C i c c i c i c i c i D * i c i D i c - i c C O C 3 i D a c a a i c D 1 , 4 i D i a D ( i c i c c r C i c a i c o i c , 4 i c r C i c , 4 / 4 0 4 C i c i c j i c a , 4 i c r C 1 < ) i D a i c c i c i c i D r C i c i c ( , 4 C ) I . i c ’ 4 i D i c i c i D t t— — T C T C 1 T C ) I C t ‘ T C T C CI C - - T C I C I T C T C T C C — T C T C T1 C T C T i C T C T C Z c T T C ) - - T C T C T C T C T C ’ I 1 T C C T C C c t - — J - • I C - - C . I ; C j r T C I ( T C t - - C c C c T C - C C C C 3 C T C T C T C o T C T C o — T C T C T C T C Q c T C T C T C T C T C C c T C T C C L T C T C — — r T C C ) C T — C — jç T j T C — - T C T C T C T C C C H C o: 1 T C T C j T C j L ‘ C - T C C . T - C - C C j Y C f ) ) I C C , C 3 3 1 D C H — DI C D C 3 3 3 3 3 D 3 D 3 D 3 f C D C , 3 D r H — D C D 3 D C D C 3 3 C D 3 ) ) H — 4 — D 3 , 3 - D C 4 ) U CI 3 : - D 3 D C D 3 ) 1 H C f C I H — C ‘ C C 3 3 3 D C D 3 . o D 3 3 3 C I D C 4 - , D C C H D C ) 4 C 4 H 3 3 4 D 3 4 3 3 r - D 3 D C ) C D 3 C 3 3 D C C 3 3 ) H ; 3 3 H 3 D C ) C 3 3 ’ i ( D C , C c l C D 3 3 3 3 D I L D C ) C C D C D 3 4 - - 4 3 3 3 3 D 3 D 3 - D 3 3 3 , 3 - H 3 3 — Q D C ; 3 3 3 3 D C D I D D C * - C 4 D 3 3 I t ’ i - D C D C Q T C 2 1 jC - D C ) C , 3 D 3 D 3 j J ) 1 3 3 D C - 3 D ) C J D C 4 - , 3 D C 4 - D 3 3 3 Q J D 3 3 ç D D C D 3 D 3 D C , 3 . C D 3 j I C D I D C D C I ( d D C D 3 D . 3 3 — D C — 3 , 3 D ) , 3 ) ) 1 3 D C 3 3 ‘ ( j ; : : ’ 3 3 - - C — ) D C ) 3 ) 3 ) 3 D C 3C 3 ) 3 4 r C ) C D C 3 3 - D 4 C — C L C ) C 3 DC3 C f C D C ) 3 - D C D C ) C 1 ( j C C3 3C L I D I1C D C I ( D C - 9 - I 4 D 3 ‘ I( 3 ‘ D C 1 IC 3 ) f C C - 4 3 : I D C D C c ) C D i C 1 5C 9 * - c 1 - - 3 3 ) 3 9 - - C - D C I * I 3 — D C I 9 I ’ f L DC C D C - 4 D C D C D1 C 1 3 - 4 - 4 )- 3 D C 3 3 D C D C - j — ‘ ( - 4 ) C D C D C L C D C - D C I D C ) 3 3 ) C D L C 9 f C D C 3 3 DIC D C DI C D C D C IC D — D C - I D C D C D C D C - 4 D C 1 - D C I I j ) 3 3 3 3 ‘ ( 9 D C 1 D C - 4 I - I D C ) ( r I 3 - 4 - 4 I _ ) C L C 9 J D C 3 3 0 C ) D C C ) 3 3 D C C D C D C D C D C D C D C I 9 — * - 4 D - C D C ) 3 3 D C 3 3 9 D C ) 3 D C D C I - 4 D C 1 9 C - - 9 - ) 3 D C D C L — - 4 ) - I 1 J 4 I ’ C 4 3 = rC 3 c a - s a 4 d W U S ‘ - - V S c b . 4 ) 4 - 4 t C ) ‘ S P l f D C 0 ’ 4 : , I - a 1 1 . - - 4 . D C t t - 0 1 ‘ 0 0 ‘ I I - - . - 0 t - , D C b a D C ) 1 ’ a ’ ! 5 a V D C . 0 ‘ • ) C 1 S P S P a D C ’ 1 S aP I — S P a D C - ‘ I . . ’ T I t I 4 i 1 • D C I L ‘ — D ‘ t - . e C • t f 19 CrLA.No. 1170.2005 c/w CrI.A.No.702.2005 ?1O,000/-. We do not find any reason to interfere with the award of sentence. JUDGE 3UGE