THE MANAGING DIRECTOR. IVKRTC, GOKUL .ROA.D, CENTRAL OFFICE, HUBLU58003 v. I.1’bLLANT
Case Details
Summary
A structured summary for this judgment hasn’t been prepared yet. The full text is below.
Precedent status
No treatment data yet for this judgment in the Courts & Cases corpus.
Absence of data is not a statement about the judgment’s standing — the corpus covers only judgments we index and link with cited evidence.
Original judgment text
Judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD DATED THIS THE 14th DAY OF OCTOBER 2011 THE HON’BLE MR JUSTICE K N KESHAVANARAYANA BEFORE MF.A. No, 20009j2011jMVC) AJW MISiCVL. NOs. 100015&100016J2011 AND LW 1OOO18 2011 BETWEEN: THE MANAGING DIRECTOR. IVKRTC, GOKUL .ROA.D, CENTRAL OFFICE, HUBLU58003O. RER.BY CHIEF LAW OFF[CER, IiT GOK L ROAD, HU BLI-580030. HF S R \ \[N[N TI 0 HA ND F. !-i N N U AND: I.1’bLLANT \••1 [N I [N([NT OH ALA [[N .) ry I D F . I K L [N IARI .KAFITA [) .1’ [N, (;.T• H ES1T1 PITt IT RI •IK I N: IT H N (1.1, i[N[: C R\ U TIOTI I RI I[ N ([N [N V N L.) P. C) CC: : A (.1 F1 I C U If F fr ) I•[I• I S S FL EN IC) v ! 2 INMFA No. 20010/2011 SMT. GOPIKA. W/O. ARJUN GAVADE. AGE: 61 YEARS.
0CC: AGRICULTURIST. BAMANE. JOIDA TALUR, (RESPONDENT IS SERVED) M.F.A. No.20009/2011 IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF THE M.V.ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 27.07.2010. PASSED IN MVC NO. 76/2009. ON THE FILE OF THE MEMBER, ADDL. MACT, YELLAPUR AWARDING AT COMPENSATION OF RS.12,688/- ALONG WITH INTEREST AT THE RATE OF 6”h P.A. FROM THE DATE OF PETITION TILL DEPOSIT IN THE COURT. HALIYAL, SITTING MISC.CVL.NO.100015/2011 UNDER SECTION 5 OF THE LIMITATION ACT FOR CONDONATION OF DELAY IN FILING THE APPEAL FILED IS M1SC.CVL.NO.100016/2011 UNDER ORDER 41 5 OF Cit FOR STAY THE OPERATION,EXECUTION OR IMPLIMENTATION OF THE SAID JUDGMENT AND AWARD. FILED RULE IS M.F.A. No.20010/2011 IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF THE M.V.ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 27.07.2010, PASSED IN MVC NO.
78/2009, ON THE FILE OF THE MEMBER, ADDL. MACT, YELLAPUR AT AWARDING COMPENSATiON OF RS.10,465/- ALONG WITH INTEREST AT THE RATE OF 6% P.A. FROM THE DATE OF PETITION TILL DEPOSIT IN THE COURT. HALIYAL, SI’fl’LNG MISC.CVL.NO.100017/2011 UNDER SECTION 5 OF THE LIMITATION ACT FOR CONDONATION OP 50 DAYS DELAY IN FILING THE APPEAL. PILED IS 1: I’.‘r’l1\ It N’ICIN() I%OIIc 1t 4ciO Ii’g)tilf(iiS IuucL i’ 1d 10 \“1flI 110 tcI,1(I\I Lii)” Id) 11%Tdll T NOl VI C)SQl ci liii I I ‘IL ‘. itlOC)1SO t)00 r)flT ( ‘L((V 0 111 1 ) ) 10Oio(rO IKNCNOIfl‘flIAO)1L(wIC)810001 ‘)\IO1IOI1111(YINflU1(1iNiOJThI (C)’L‘0%111))S’IIII%\‘%fl’ LNawDunr JO‘)fl)1%IVjP)CIdPunat T1(1U110I i’I)U inc1eu&iywAiMnqpas’ci “s.M\UI 0) 600(8pu t1’flqSF4)flL{I 11))1 J( S10 SIP)cidP)S)LflAuqij ci )UCU 1 ) .‘I )i..iddi 1 ‘10IPX Icia’X(,J’lJSt ) ) I < 0 C C C a C ) C : 9 - — C 1 0 ( ) C C 0 ( C ) C ) C C - < 0 — ) C C ’ a ) C ) c C ’ a — a 9 ) N ) C — a C < 0 h T - - ) C 9 * ) C - 0 ( C 9 - ) C — < 0 ‘ ) H C C 1 ( 0 ( C 9 ) C < 0 C ) 0 C < 0 C C — 0 0 : 9 0 ( ) C ) < 0 C 9 . r c ) C 0 ) C C : 9 C H ) C C C < 0 < 0 ‘ — — - - 9 < 0 O C — < 0 a . ’ a - ( ) 0 ‘ C C : 9 C - : 9 ) ) C C C ) C — 9 < 0 < 0 < 0 1 0 a 0 a 9 ) C ) ) C C ) C ) < 0 ) ) C C - C ) C C > - C C 0 ( 1 - ) C 9 — J - < 0 C C 9 < 0 - < 0 ) C C ) C < 0 o C ) C < C < 0 9 C - 9 C : 9 ) C ) - ) 0 ) 9 H C ) C j - C ’ 9 ) 0 ) C 0 ( - ) C 9 : 9 - C ) C 9 < 0 1 ) C : 9 < 0 a ) C ) C ‘ - ‘ C t r 0 ( ) < 0 C - • — ) - a - ) 0 C < 0 < 0 < 0 “ 9 - 9 C - — ) C ) C ) < 0 C < 0 9 ) < 0 C ) C C < 0 < 0 - C “ C < 0 C C ) C ) C ) C C - : ’ C 9 a ) C ‘ — .
9 1 ) 0 1 Q C o - — 9 9 r < 0 9 — ’ ) C “ . ) 0 ) C ) 9 C ) C < 0 C C < 0 C C - C 9 ) C a ) C • ) C ) C 9 C C ) C < 0 < 0 C C ) H ) C ç . a < 0 C - . C ” i ‘ . : 9 : a 9 r < 0 ) C C . • : 9 — C ) C ’ a a < 0 ) C ‘ - o 9 . C - C a ) C - 9C ) C ) C ‘ - a 9 ’ a < 0 C - 0 ‘ a C C ) C - a C . ) 0 j ) 0 9 a a - ) C ) : 9 9 0 : < 0 ) C C ) C < 0 . ) C — a — C < 0 ‘ C . < 0 C < 0 C - C < 0 ) 0 < 0 < 0 < 0 ) )9 99a C C C a a - z 9 : 9 ) C \ . . D C C D D C D C D C D C ) ) ) D C D C 5 1 - D C D C D C — i L D C D C * 9 — D C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C 9 D C ) 9 D C ) C D C D C D C r D C D C , ) 9 D C D C * ) 9 C C C D C m D C - D C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C ) 9 9 . — D C . — . . . C D C D C D C i - D C — — X C D C < D C : C C D C D C D C o D C — D C . , D C .
D C 9 D C D C . D C D C C C D C D C D C U D C D C a i L . D C C C C C C D C D C D C D C a — . i L D C D a C D C i L D C — — D C . . D C D C . D C — D C 9 D C D C D C ) 9 D C - — D C ) C D C D C D C — D C — C . . a D C D C D C D C . - D C D C D C D C — 9 a D C D C D C D C . . D C D C - D C g D C D C D C D C . D C a D C D C ) 9 . D C D C D C D C D C * D C D C D C D C 5 1 D C a D C D C D C D C D C D C a D C D C C X C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C * . D C D C D C a — — i i D L C — D C * D C D C D C D C D C . o E D C D C D C — D C r D C C — D C D C C C C D C D C D C D C 9 — D C D C ) 9 D C D C D C D C C C D C D C U — D C D C x . r — D C D C ) 9 D C D C D C C C i L D C D C 5 1 D C ) 9 D C D C D C U D C D C C C D C C ) C D C D C D C .
( 9 D C D C i C D C D C D C — a - D C D C : H D C D C D C D — C D C D C i L D C D C a D C a D C 9 ) 9 C i ) 9 . . ) X C O C D C D C D C D C i c . D C D C L • . a D C D C D C D C D C ) 9 ‘ l C ( s . D C D C D C . D C < . i ( C ) C ‘ , 0 C C C D . C . D C D C D C i L D C D C D C 1 a C C C D C . D C < D C D C b o )o D C 0 D C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C C C C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C i D L C D C . C C C C C D C C C C . D C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C D C i c • D C D C D C D C D C D C ) C C 6 H ° ) C r H H H H ) H D C : H H H H H H 2 H HC D H H . H H H a : 6 HH ) I L - t r H H H : 6 1 H H 2H H H ? C H H D C 6 H H H H - H H ) ) C C C H . H H ) I L D C H 6 H D C H H H HH D C 3 H H H D C - r - 9 ) I L H H H H H H H H HC D H H H H - H H H 2 3 z .6 6 - — .
D C H H - H H ) C f - r D C H ) C H H D C H r C ) C 1 H : - 6 D C H H D C j D C H H - — — ) C H 2 H : 6 — H H H H 4 H D C H H H H ( - H 2 3 H ; H -C D ) C H H H : 6 H . H ) I L H2 H — H H D C — H H H 9 — j - ) C - H H H H _ ’ . ? C H . — : 6 H H H D C 6 H ) I L . H a C ) C H H 2 H . _ H H — H ‘ H H — — — - 1 H H D C ) I L f r : 6 H ) C H — a H H H H D C H H C H — H H H H D C D C ‘ D C H — H H ; H H C j - H H C D H H H H D C a ‘ ? C : 6 : 6 ) C H H C f - r H D C H ) I L H H H H H — H H ) I L H C D H . H H ? C ) C H i - H D C — C C D H ? C H . H HH - H D C H ; H H H D C H H - HH H H I - DHH C C ’ f — C H D C ’ H H H H ) I L HCC )H6 2i i - , H D C HH DHC C ) H 6 ) H . C— H H CH rHC D ) 4 a — ) I L . L r H C H H .
D C H : 6 • H D2 C . q c H ) C r — 2 9 - 3 . 1H H H H t 6 HH H — D C H ) C % E HH ) I L H H H H 9 H H — H H H : 6 H H C H ) C ) H • H C r H D C H D C 9 2 0 • — ) C H H a : 9 H - : — 6 H r D H t = D C r D t r r D t C t U t U D C r D D C D C C D t r . 2 4 : I r D H 2 4 t r g t r D C D : H r D D C - r r D D H D C “ • H ) - D C C D D C r D C D D C o - ) - t r 2 C D ’ C D - o 7 D C C D 4 , . , o C D * — 4 H C D r D H ’ D C C D D C r D C D r D D C H r D C D r D 2 t U H - 9 i - — r D — 2 H D C . H C — D H D C H r D . . ’ C 4 D C ( rt H D C L E < D C C D C D — o H 4 H 7 t r D C - . H D C C D r D z 6 t r D C r D r r D D H 4 D C - - D C 2 H H 9 D C 4 i - D C t ’ r H ” C . 2 C D — “ — r D C D r D H , 4 n C D o 0 - D C r D n A , , ‘ ) r D ’ D C ’ 2 H D C D C r D , 2 4 — A , c r D H D C t i 4 C 4 t r .
H D C C D D C — D C r D 4 A t H t i C ‘ ) & C D r 5 H D C ’ H — L C r D r D t i C . r o D H o r r D D H D C D C 0 L E r D H 9 4 ’ t r H D C . — - . — D C — ) - H r D o 2 . H r r D D j r D H D C n ’ C — D C C D r r D D - o — H O 7 , , r r D D ’ c r 4 4 4 H 9 ( 5 0 . 4 t C 9 H 4 H D C D C r D D C C D 5 0 , C 4 D H r D 4 2 . 4 r D r D - H C D D C H H . r D , 9 - 5 r r D D 4 r D 0 ‘ D C ’ i r H D C — r D ‘ — D C r D . 2 0 r D C D o r D 0 H D C C D r D H D C r D C D D C D C 4 C r D D C D C D C o D C C D C D ‘ — . 9 ( D C H C D . r D C D D C i C H H H ’ r 4 r D — , 4 4 D C t U 9 C D H 7 H - r D D C ’ l r H D C D C r D : H D C r D C D r H o r D H r C D 4 , D C r D , — r D D C ° D C r D C D ’ 4 D C r D ’ C D , — 0 r D — H D C r D C D 9 r r D D H D C D D C t ’ r H t U D C r D u H 0 r D D C — r r D D H H r D 0 r D D C D R ± ’ r H D C D C S t r C D 0 D C ’ C 5 7 . r D C r D . + 4 C D H H D ( C D r D r D C D C D H D C C D ‘ C D r D o - t U H H H m C . r D C D 4 c r D r D ( — D C 0 r D ’ 9 C D C D r D r D 4 C D - 9 C D r D ‘ C t ( U H i “ H o 4 H C D r D - 9 D C H r D , C , D , C D ’ 2 C ( ( “ n ’ C “ D C .
6 H D C - - ‘ H r D 0 P r D : r D H t r D r D C C r H s D C C D D C C D 2 H H C D D C 9 : 4 r D r D ( H D C r D H , 2 4 - r D C D D C 4 , — ’ C r r D D C D C D 9 4 9 n D C ‘ D r r 9 D r r D 8 Amount if any, in deposit. is ordered to be transmitted to the Tribunal concerned. In view of the dismissal of these appeals, the applications- Misc.Cvl. Nos.100016 & 100018/2011 do not survive for consideration. Accordingly. the said