High Court · 2011

Judgment

1. • • •. S I ‘ • • 4 It • . • .1 ‘114 •; ••• • VO$48H’fJT 4.. t It 4 “ C [ H L i I ( D C 4 2 ) ) 9 D C 3 ( C C C 4 ( . 0 . 4 ( , i L L D D C i L 3 H ( D C I 0 O00C D ) ’ i L J - ) 9 - . 3 D C D — C . C C D C i 4 L - — 4 4 4 ’ 4 _ 4 D C ( ) l C 4 i L ’ D C — 3 ( i — L L C 0 - c — 9 0 ( . C — N C ( 4 . i L 2 , i — L . 3 m c - . 3 ( i L , D C D C . — i L 3 ( 4 - a - t 0 C ‘ — i L D C L 4_ I ( — 4 ’ - 4 D C i 3 ( L C ( t C — D C . — 4 4 / D C ) 4 ‘ 9 - 4 D C o D C i L 4 . C ’ . D 4 ‘ — i L 2 ( ( t C D C L C . — 0 L C ( “ i L D C t C 2 ( 2 ( ( . . . — 4 2 j 2 ( ( 4 ( i L . _ 4 2 ’ ( 2 ( ‘ : C c C i — L P 4 ‘ - ( i L — ‘ — - 2 ( ( ) C t C . ’ . D C D C r — 9 i L - — . D C i L ) 1 ( 3 ( D C i — L . . C ( D C ) 3 D C i L t C C I ( % 2 D C 4 c C C 3 ( ( i — L t C C C a ( C - - ) 9 i L i L DC D 3 1 ( .

D C i L t C i L L — C 4 D C 4 3 ( . D C 4 C . D C D C 0 D C . D C . . D C ) 2 ( 0 D 3 ( D C C C . i C L i L D C D C — ) ( r * — 3 ( i L - ‘ • C ( D C — - 9 9 9 , ‘ - - - ‘ D C “ • : i L D C i L i L ‘ 0 — - t C 2 ( ( ( ‘ t C i L — ’ C C C C ( ) 3 ( i L a - 3 ( ( 1 4 4 D C D C i L 2 ( D C i L D C i L D C i L D C . D C D C , 2 L i 3 ( : D C D C i L i L ‘ . ’ t C . C ) 2 ( i L D C D C — — — . D C . L C - . 4 ( 4 ( D C . i 0 L ‘ . i L m a c D C ( 0 D C D C 2 9 — ’ D C D C — 0 4 2 2 ( ( t C D C 1 ( — - C ( D C D C E “ . D C i L D C t C . ’ C D C ( 4 2 — ‘ ’ 3 ( D C D C 4 2 ; 2 ) 3 - i L D C ) 4 - 9 D C i 2 L ’ P C t C D C t C . ‘ — i L C ( ( D C 3 ( i L D C ) l - - r ’ C C D C t C ; 2 4 4 — L i t C D C i L — ) C i t L C D C .

4 ’ 9 - o 3 ( ( ( , 9 - D C - C ( 4 - : - O D o o C - D • C : i — L D C ‘ — . * ) l C i L D C D C C D ( D C ( t C 4 ( , 0 E 9 t C — i L C ( ‘ C C D C L 4 ( 4 ( — 2 ( i L D C i L D C a i L j 0 L ; 2 0 i L 0 ‘ — : “ 0 . — i i i L L L 3 ( j a ‘ • . ’ C C 3 ( I ( C C D C : i L ( . ( C C . ’ 1 C C D 9 * i — L 4 C 4 ‘ - — D C C C i 3 ( L - 3 ( r D C — ‘ 3 ( Q o 3 ‘ “ , ‘ i C L ‘ 9 - _ _ N ? 4 N — — L C N - N N — — N N 5 3 3 ? 4 N - N N — N N - ? 4 N N N N N N e ? 4 N 5 N N — 5 - N N N N e N - 5 ” N N - • N N N N r N N 5 - 1 : ? 4 N ? 4 ? 4 ? 4 . N - N N L C N N - ? 4 N ? 4 ) N N ( • - — N - N N N - N N — N N N . N ç ? 4 N N N N N N N N ; C y N : r N N N N N N N N N S • N S N N ? 4 N N ) N N 2 2 - . s N , r r H — N N .

N N — - N N N — N ? 4 — N N N N N N - N — , N . J N N ? 4 N N N ? 4 ? 4 - N e ? 4 N 5 N o — 2 — 5 N N N N N N - N N 3 3 N . — - N N N N S N - - N N c N - N . . ) L C — N ‘ N N N N e - N N , ? 4 . N N N - N N - N N N C N C N N O C j N O 2 5 N 5 N N N ? 4 N N N â — N 5 N c N — < N r 3 5 N N N N : — s N 3 3 - - N N , N . • — N J N I N N N — 4 ? — 4 ? 4 N _ — 9 - 3 3 3 3 - N — N . r J N N N [ : N S N N N o N . N N - . ? 4 O N C ? 4 2 5 N N N N ç N N 9 3 N — N N e ? 4 ’ N N I N N N J r N . N ? 4 5 ? 4 ? 4 . — 5 ? 4 N 5 u ? 4 N N ? 4 ° - N N r o ? 4 N e N N N — — N N N 5 3 N 3 N ? 4 N N ? 4 N N - N — N N N N ? 4 — N 5 9 N s N - N 3 3 N N N N N N N N O N ? 4 5 5 N h T — - N N N 5 5 N N N N 5 5 N N N N - N I N ? 4 — N N ? 4 N ?

4 N r J - N N 5 N N N — N ? 4 - N N N N - N - N ? 4 N N N N N ? C S N N ? 4 5 S C - ? 4 ? 4 N — N L - N — N N e t N ? 4 C N N ? 4 S N - J N N N 5 S C N N N N N e - N N 5 N N ? N 7 3 3 N N N N ) - N N N - — C N 5 N N ? 4 — N N H . N e ? 4 - ? 4 N + z N N r _ N 5 N S N t t N N N N N — N N N ? 4 — — - H N e — — N O N ? 4 N N N e - N N e C * - ? 4 N - ? e 4 - - N N N N N N ? 4 N N . — — — N : N — — e - . U - 4 - . 3 “ — I - - V - 4 . , I - 4 — ‘ — I ‘ 1 3 . a t I I V e C I ) ‘ V d — I ‘ 2 N)I t Iu I:) 1H r. ( 1( r i11 NI Ahethor oalr flffc jrn ur.)r)r st [1Iappa a ier iar Jiod or 2 C2 I9o a Do 2o’ u,’ae Fiaia2pa after oa+h f dcs s r aou’riop3s at iao r or d as rnanagc of tao faa 2 JJhro,rtt Jrr H ‘ r do n 21 !tHr 1rr s ro that I I 3 j I - I 3 11— 1C’4 - C r ‘ ‘ 3 N t cC’ t.

I :i: of suit property?

(vi) Whether defendant proves, she is the Wife of deceased Hanumappa and suit properties were separate properties of Hanumappa? vii) Whether plaintiffs are entitled for partition and separate possession of their 3I4 share properties. in the alternative? viii) What relief parties are entitled? ix) What decree or order?

5. The plaintiffs examined PW- I (plaintiff No.31 and got marked documents Exs.P- I to 12. On behalf of the defendant. she examined herself as DW- 1 and she also examined DW-2 in support of her claim and got marked Ex.D- 1—certified passed RTS.AP.No.77/ 1995-96.

6. The trial court after considering the contentions of the learned counsel for the parties and appreciating the ; 4 C C . 1 ( o a - i o C C— c 2 C S ) C L D C . ) C a L - • i E 9 - C C r l C ) ) ) C i C ) C C ( i “ o ) 0 C C 9 C C C C ’ 2 L C C C r c a C - 9 2 2 d . — C C 0 H C . C C C C C D C z 9 — C C ) C ) D C L C C D ) C C C C C C ) T C z ) . 9 N C C C C . C D C z 0 ) C C C C C , — ‘ — : D C ) l C L C < . D C D C D C ) C C L C ’ c ‘ C C w , C . C , C C C C C D C z 9 s $ C C - ) C C D C D C ) ) C C L C w ’ C ‘ C C C C ) C D C z 9 ) D C C C C C C C D C z 9 ) 0 ) U C C C C D C z 0 • ) C 4 - C C C C ‘ — . — D C . L C D C ‘ “ D C ) C C C D C 0 9 n r L C 3 5 9 ’ E C o C ( ) C C + - C C ) C D C — ; 4 D C L C C T C C C C D i “ D C — D C C C C L C ’ ) . C C C 0 D C C ‘ ) 2 0 C C 0 c : 9 — 9 ’ C C . C : a - C S ; 4 . ’ C C C C 0 C C 4 ‘ C D C C ) ) C C C C 9 ) C . ; 4 D C 9 D C o J - - o : C S ; 4 a - H — r C ) C 9 9 a $ C C ; 4 t C . ’ D C C C E t . : . D C 9 9 ; 4 ) C c f r ) C C D C ; 4 9 i c ’— C C ) D c C C D C . t i S ) C . ; 4 - ; 4 0 9 9 C C C C C C C a C C S ) ) C 2 ’ t r C C ) C C C D C L DC C C C ) c C C C a L C C C “ C C 2 C C . . r ) C C ’ H C — 0 D C C C i ’ C C D C D D I ” C S - ‘ C C r D C C C ” C C C C C ) C L C C C C C a C I 9C L C C C ( C C ( t r C 0 C C 9 l E ‘ C C — i D C D C N + 7 4 C C - ( D C a C . ’ c c c c ( c * E L E , E D C — , , . I S i i — C D 2D ( D C S i C I — i C D C a D C i c C < D — C • : * D C C C . — ; - D C D C 0 . _ V D C D D I c c c D C — - D C . , D C D C c N + 7V7 + . l C D C i — C i C a H a ’ 4 - a L a - 2 SC D D C ’ m c C D C L E E C D C I - C 2 ‘ - 9 - : 7 i ( L — D C C C i i i D C ) 1 C D D C / c - c l D ( D C : i - D C O D ) C “ D C ) I L C D C . S ) C C C I ( - 2 2 0 : D C D C ; N I - H 7 1 0 C D : i i - c c O zc D D C c - D C l C + 7 a D C C I D C 0 c D ( . D C ’4 C D D C c N C 0 “ ) C C V — D C i i D a - C D L E E . — t r 6 ’ N D C = 2 ( i — 2 L . i L D C — D — C H D C D C O D D C * D C D C . C C L E O D D C — ‘ . D C c c ( • S . i L D +C 7 . — . - C c C D D . D D C L : . — D C D C E z _ + — - C D . t F 2 ( O - j DN C ’ c c , a C O D D C — l C C C l C L E t V 4 - C C ‘ ( S E E C D C D C ( . 7 D C D C L D C C O D ’ r D C I L C 2 ( a C ( t r D C V a D C i L D - - C - J - a D C L E E C1. a - D C V N ( 9 9 — . i0 C C D t r 9 0 D C o c ! ‘ 9 — D C — j - D C • N O D C 4 — D C D C 2 L E D C ( L E V — : a 4 6 “ - 2 0 E E D C — ; D C — D C L E V t 2 2 L2 0 — ‘ 2 • E E o D C % C ) — C ‘ . - 2 7 m c C D O C L E C C ‘ r f L E c c a C . 2 — C D C I ‘ & - i D D C N O D C D C D C : ‘ , , “ — C D 2 7 D C . i C D C D C — . ( D C . L E — D C t . 3 — • * D C — a 9 N i m c V L E E L E D C ‘ V i D - 2 r D C — - C D D C ’ — D C S ’ m c c 4 — ( ) C C c ; 4 ) C - ’ I D C C C D C D C D C O 0 C 9 L E : 4 - 4 - 4 7 C D “ D C D C L E E c C c N “ D C 1 “ c c — ) 7 D C C D D C I S : 9 C D 4 7 a - N “ ( - 4 C D t a thc. c i i’t C i i . t ‘1—:? •1 ‘:t:,’• •‘•.?• •‘. n t •n. . I. I • •1 lIt.t ft•t1r • •‘T.t ‘: • ‘.. ;9 t’:’ • ¶..‘ •. ( t’ 1 1 H i ‘1’’ It j. ‘ ‘‘. 11c •)I’t s_aCt ( 1;t,a1 •. ; niiits !‘.at •.ii — t’,r .tI! ilisdit C a’’. ..rg WheAt i the tind ngs ot thc tiial court thi’ ‘t. 311 ff d flCt t. t’It I de aao’i c i aganst Vi deft dar.t is .rIJurIc4Ir ‘ustitieY? •Vh ‘I tht. Ir s ,f ‘re al tct Ii af. e ‘ :LStt12’ . Hit I•t • •I• • 1 t a 3 _ •‘• • .-.S%I — — .. Sc— .9 t ii: T .- calls fot interterence ‘n this dppear’ C’nethet the •;‘hrnc’t an’i ,Jnrgz passer1 •fl1 • : rnL ‘+ “a” ‘ ‘cc i i Pon No I & The findings of tit r l ot rt i juctified P r’ No 3 ntncjs t th tr,3 Th c.o.i’t ‘table to b rnoaf’ed Dv nolaing t’at the plaintiffs are entitled sna’e and the tn 1 8 defedan share ir ent.t’ed ‘c 1 suIt scheH.1 e Me r”• ites 4 tinIl ; oe RU ‘4 P01 lNos.1T04 • a a a. • i — C 2 2 c C S 2 # ( — i c - j N C - 4 C . - H C C S E - 4 ) 0 • ) N 2 2 ) • t i - 2 t i C C C t i c S ) - 2 0 ) N i c i C — C ) N C ) r C 2 H “ ’ - H C ) C N C t i o C ) 2 0 C N — H . i c 2 # ( h T 4 5 2 2 5 - 4 C C ’ 4 C - - H ) N C ) N C C t , - C - H - - H S - 4 C C - — C C - C C H - 2 C - a ) N ) N I 2 . t i 0 — t ) N : C C t i C C C S C s — — C C 5 2 - 2 2 — j - - C H C C C ) C a 2 ) i C t i 5 - - ) N — 5 S 2 ‘ ‘ - 4 ’ I ( C ( ) - ) N 2 # ( C ) N - 2 ) N ’ - — 4 E E C C ) _ , 2 0 C - - 2 - ’ C ) N ) N i c C 5 . — 2 r E C C C C ‘ — - 4 — C . — 2 o C — ’ 2 4 ( C 5 9 C - - 2 C C C C . - H 4 ) N C t i C . t F t i c C i ) a N C ) - C - 2 ) N C j ) — . 2 t r C 2 F0 — ) N o ç ’ H 2 # ( C C t ‘ ) H - r N C C ‘ — . - H - H ‘ ) N ’ C 2 C ) - H - 2 5 C 9 C - C H - 4 - , C ‘ - C ( C C ) N 4 C c - H 2 C ) N . 2 C t t i 2 0 — - H 2 1 ( C . , , C C - 4 - H ‘ 9 2 C C . t i - 4 C C — 2 0 2 2 # ( C . ° r — C _ C = “ ‘ 2 ; — - 2 9 5 ) N t i C C t i ’ 2 H 0 ‘ - C — C ) C C C N 9 C ) i ( ( ) a N f - - - 4 C . C t t i C - o C ) N 2 - 4 t i ) N - 2 C % ) N - 4 - t i ) N C H ‘ — 5 2 t ’ , 4 ) N C r - ‘ i ( ) N 5 / 4 - 4 4 4 , 9 / ( C : C ( ( ) N - 2 S C o C C ) a N C 4 # ( ) N C t i C C H t i — % 2 - 2 C C - 2 - 2 a C I ‘in’d It I I1

11.1 ‘itU I t t ii t1 It t I I d ) 1 I )( ‘ • .;1 IlL C li.4 •*1? p1 • Ut I ‘ I’ ‘I I. j.j1 r’jt’1 •; •h i. • I. , ‘I 1 ‘a I ‘‘a’ I )Ij! % tlltit’t(I t ) ti C ‘ “l• I • [ I • C C. ‘)r”p rrt’, I,\ flitti ‘ U V ‘‘CI’ It t t ‘ •91 ‘iv’’ “tfl 4 ‘ a i’t ‘ I) r: •, I •lt •1 — Q ), 1.i. ‘ilti Ha’ •‘• ‘ II 1 ii t11t spec tilt ‘ if’ I’C.’ ts •u It- ‘ i’ 1w j 1 1’ P I I 1,..s l(..!I (‘ C 1 I • • Ii ‘I VI I I C ‘ IT I, CCI 3 I Nb €1 1 1 n e. ,• I C I. t 1

1. 3 ,‘ Iii •1 S • • I. 1 I I I 1’ I I’ I - 1 1 ” ” ” 1 2 9 — D C 3 $ : N - - — 9 5 C D C D C D C D 2 0 2 — ” N 1 $ D C I L 4 9 D C C D ” 1 : I L D 3 % - D C 2 C “ It L I L t C C D D C ; 2 4 2 ” C D C D D C t C ” D C D C ; 2 3 $ 9 4 D C I L 1 1 I L 7 $ D C 5 ” $ c ” 3 $ ” ” C D ” C ‘ ; 2 l D ( ” 5 t C . , D ( C D * C D 9 C 4 “ ” 3 $ H ; 2 3 $ . C D C D ” I L i I C D t C t C D C I L I * * “ “ ” I L C D L C 4 1 2 D C 5 1 ” D C ) 3 $ t 1C 3 y I L I L C D — C D D 3 C D C D 9 C D 9 1 L C D C D C D C C D D C D C D C C D . 1 2 I _ < C I I L C D ” D C : D C C D C D t C ” 3 $ D C D C D 1 D I L 2 ) 1 ( 9 4 $ 4 D C . 1 $ 1 2 C D ” t C 9 2 4 J - D I t C t C C D . . ” 1 , 0 9 $ “ “ D C - 0 t C ” 3 $ 0 $ D C ” I L . C D C D . D C 1 3 9 4 C D D C 9 C C D I t . 1 2 < C 1 2 D C ” t r I L 1 9 * 2 — 1 2 D C C D I L C “ 1 2 C D - t C D C D C ” t C 1 2 3 $ t C < — 3 / I L “ C D 1 9 D I * 9 9 4 1 $ t D C C D C t C C “ t C ” D C D C 5 4 D C I L ; 2 2 D C 1 2 1 9 1 ( 9 4 1 2 . O D 9 4 O D i J C D C D C D C I L . ( . * 1 2 4 * C D 0 0 2 4 $ ( ” 3 $ . L . * p ; 2 — ; 2 o C D — C D C D C 0 2 $ 1 C D D C — 2 0 2 0 1 9 “ “ “ 2 0 0 2 • t l ” D I D C 1 2 D C D C C D . - D C ” I L D C I L I L ” 5 t D C C ” 3 3 I L C D t C ” D C r D C 9 4 - 3 ( ; . 2 - 1 2 9 $ C D ; ; 2 1 2 D C 1 1 ” 0 2 C D t r ” 0 2 D C I L I L D C C D ” D I . 1 1 . ; 2 ( D C C D j < $ 3 ; 2 1 ( ; 2 C D D C < C D ” D C D C 1 ( D $ C D ” 0 2 D C ” t r 9 4 4 9 1 2 0 ; * 2 “ 1 ; 2 9 4 9 4 2 3 $ . — C D D C C D t C ” 0 2 D I t o ” 0 2 D C D I C D 3 2 3 ” 2 4 1 * C D D C 0 $ 9 4 : . c 9 4 9 4 D C 1 2 ” I L ; 2 “ - $ ” t C ” 3 $ D C L D C . - 4 0 — “ “ “ ” D C D C 1 2 2 2 0 1 2 D C ; 2 ( 0 2 , 3 7 “ 9 ) 2 0 . 3 D $ _ D C * , - 1 2 ; 2 O D D C ; 2 0 2 x I L ; I 2 L ; 2 ” 9 C D ” 1 1 D C ” D C 0 $ D C D C L ; 2 D C n — 1 2 ” D D C C D ” D 5 3 7 ( C D C D < 2 : 9 ‘ , , “ “ — 1 $ j - 9 4 4 9 D C C D 2 t C 9 4 O 1 2 C D t C D C C D I L ; 2 D C : 9 1 9t9 D I C D < 1 “ 0 $ 1 1 t C 1 2 D C I D D C 4 - D C 1 2 r t C 4 t C D C O D C D ” ” C ” 4 9 . o D C ” ” ” z D C 1 2 t C D C 1 9 D C ” 0 2 C D t C 1 2 D C 9 4 ; 2 — D c 1 2 9 C . ; 2 1 $ 1 1 i t • D C C 9 * t C C . r < D C D C — C D < D 3 C D 9 4 C D D C 1 2 O ; 2 D C C D 3 2 $ D C C D I L 9 1 9 1 2 1 9 4 D C C D L C D D C I L 1 1 2 4 C D ” ” C ; 2 . 1 * D C C D H C D D C I L 2 0 ; 2 * 4 * D C D C ’ l 3 - “ ” H C D H ” H H , m c ” H ( f i L H ‘ ( “ “ ” “ H N ’ l — E H H H . l E H H H L C : C D — N ‘ ” H l E H H : H ‘ H H L C ” H H , ’ r ” H H l l H E ‘ E E E H ‘ — H H m N H ‘ — H ’t m - , “ ‘ — : H “ ( H ? _ H ’ H l .H E H ; H H ( ’ I — l E H ’ ’HN H ( l E H ” H ‘ H - - m c ’ N H H : l E H ‘ ( H H ’ N ’ C D < 3 ” H ’ N H f i ‘ ( . ’ l E H H “ ’ < 3 H ( N H ) — ‘ H H H H H H H H — : N ‘ H > H • H ; l E H H l E . ; , , 0 H ( 0 0 C c ) i H H ’ H H ” H H , H H H l E 3 H , 3 ( H “ ’ N ' N ” H ‘ ’ H ( D 3 “ “ l E H H H ” f i : l E ’ N ’ H H , , 4 H . H ’ H ‘ — H - - , ’ l E “ H A “ ’ H H ‘ D 3 H ‘ H H H H H ’ H H D 3 ” H “ H H H ( < H f i “ A “ ’ H ; ’ ’ H V m c ‘ - , . ’ 3 ( ‘ N D 3 l ’ E H ’ i C H H H H H ’ D 3 ’ N — H m c H ( : ’ f i ( H ’ H , H ( ’ H H — < 3 : H ( H H ” H H H H H H . H H H H - j j H ( o H H : H ” H H N ‘ ’ 0 ‘ ) H H H ‘ H N H H ” N ’ l E H ‘ ’ H H ” H D 3 D 3 H H l E H “ “ “ “ “ H ‘ ‘ — . H ’ N H H H H ‘ H H H H H ‘ N ’ ( ( ’ H H H ‘ ’ N H ’ H H , - N L ( H H H l E H “ H H H H ’ N ’ ” s H H H H ’ N - H “ l E 3 ( H H “ 3 ( H H “ ( H m ‘ c , H - . “ “ “ “ H H H ( ‘ 0 ( , - , H - ’ H H H ‘ 0 ‘ H H H ( H ’ t r H ’ ” m H c , 3 m ( c ‘ - H H H H i < H l E a “ ' H H ’ - ’ N H ” H l E ° “ — l H EtE H ’ H H N H H H “ ( “ ' . . H ’ H H m c H ’ ( ” , 3 N “ ' H ‘ ( f i “ 3 6 H D 3 ’ l E H H ’ H H N - “ ” H . H H ‘ “ , . H ‘ H ” ’ H , ’ r . , 3 ( H ’ H H ’ < 3 — H Q ‘ ) - N ( ‘ ' “ “ . — ” H H ” 0 H H “ < ‘ — = H H H ( ” H ‘ ' “ ‘ H - ‘ H ( H < 3 H ( m c l ’ E H m c 3 , ” I , ‘ r “ “ - H H H ’ N ’ N ” H H ‘ - H H ’ N H o ” H ’ H L D H H t H H Z H H H ’ N f i H H l E H ( H ” l E H l l E “ E H H H 3 ‘ $ “ H ( — H ( C N : H H C D ) H H H H H H , l E l E ’ H ‘ ” N H l E — H ” z H ‘ H . ’ l E ’ 1 ‘ NH 3 3 ± ‘ H - - ’ N “ H — “ l E H E H t - . H l E 3 - - H H l E H - H , H I D 3 E E H H ‘ H l E H H o H H “ . HH N “ H H HH H — o l HE H L D ,HE H l H H - H ’ H H ( H A ’ 1 : . l E A N 3 L C H ” 3 H “ : H ( , ’ f i - H 3 — N H H D ’ i ( , : - “ - H H H l E 3 - H E ’ l — m e H t mU e e m H a m e 0H 5a 2 . a 5 . 0 H ’ m e m c — r e H j . m e a - H N m e ‘ m e t I . : H aH H a m e ‘ H H m a H m e — a — . 2 H H 2 2 H m e H - 2 2 $ . H H 5 2 5 5 m 2 e m e . H 5 5 — 5 2 5 2 - m e H H : ‘ : - 0 H H 5 5 . I I H . a m e ’ H m e H — H a — - : : a ) 1 - H e m m e H H 5H c % U — m e o m e ’ m H H e m a H ’ m T m e i a : t . ’ H H H a . a a H a H e O l f t m e U H t — H ‘4e o m e ) U e m r E H a m H t H H m e H . H N e — H a H . - H a a ’ m H — H e m ) / 2 a m e - H H ’ H . e — m — H a m e a H — H a m e H H U ’ H H > H H a H H m e e e m — : H t I — H H m e m e : 2 H C T E i c 0- a : 2 H ( a H e m m e j - t r : 2 H H H H E c I ‘ 2 a a e m a e m H e m — H H 2 a H r E H a H m e m e - m e H o e m 5 E H H : H H H ) U H - ‘ a U H H a a H o e m e m H a m e a H — r r e mHH e a H 0 H e m N r E 5 . _ 2 m H IH ç c c > a o a o — a e m m e H H H - C H m e H H H . 2 H 5 5 * 2 H H : 2 a ’ 2 J e T r E e m a ‘ aH a . a H ’ i c H m e m e — m e ‘ . 2 a a e m H — m e H H H m e H m e H m e e m 5 2 a I ( e ‘ m e H H a m e H e m e m 5 “ 5 5 5 5 2 ‘ H H a 2 , t a H a H a H c c 2 H e - o H - 5 m 5 e . ‘ N ‘ . - e — m a H - H m e H m e a 1 1 . 5 2 H m e H a H H a 5 5 5 5 2 H — m e ) U * ‘ 2 H a H . 5 5 ’ m e a H H a m e H a 2 t I H m e H H H a m e a H L E E . H H H . H H H e m He e m a H H o e m H H H m e 0 H 5 2 I L ’ 2 L E H a r H H H m e * 5 m 5 e e m 0 H m e H ‘ ‘ H H a 5 2 H m e m e H a m — e m e H : H — 5 5 5 5 m e H H ’ H - H — H H H a H H m e H H m e e m * H m e a a H H : . H — m e H e m a H o . H t I : a H ( H H e m - H H - m e - — m e H m e < 5 2 a H L E E . e m H a . H ’ ) l H m ( - H a J I -II 4 C ‘ ) 9 L C ) C < L C L C ) ) C C i C L C — — L C ) C ) C . r E r E — — ) 9 ) 9 — ) — C — C ‘ 3 — — ) C r E L C L C ) C ) C , — ) C : ) C ) ) ) C C C ) C L C - ) — C % 4 ) C 3 ’ 2 N ( L C — ) C - 2 ) 9 ) C : r — E L C C < ) C ) ) C r ) E C . — - r E - ) C — ) ) C - C . . ) C L C , r L C r — E ) C ) C r E ‘ ) L C r E . 2 C C . ) C . ) C ) C ‘ ) C e - ) 9 ) ) C C r ) C ) : ) C C ) C 2 ) 9 C . ) ) C ) C L C , — ) C : . . 2 L C , ) - C < L C ) C ) 9 ) — C , r E ) C ) C L C ) C . < r E — ) C ) C L C ) ) C ) - C ) C r , ) C _ r E ’ — C L C L C J - L C r E N ( ‘ < L C r E C ) ) C L C ) C ) C L C L C < . ) C ) ) C C ) 9 t N N ( c L C ) C L C : 4 — ) C ) C ) C r E ) 9 ) — C , ) C ) C L C ) C ) C 4 d . L C ) C “ - L C - 2 ) C 3 L C ) C ) C - , L - C ) — C ) ) C C ) C ) C ) C L C ) C r E 2 — ) C r E E C ’ ) C L C ) 9 L C ) C r E L C ) C t 9 - J N — _ — - ) C ) C 4 ) C L C ) C r N E ) 2 C ) r C ( J _ . 3 — — ) C ) 9 L C L C ’ C ) C ) ) C C ) C ) C L C t r - 2 r E r E ) C - ) C 2 r E L C ) C I — - ) C ) 9 2 C ) C L C - L C — ) C ) 9 C N ( — - 2 ) C , C E — ) C ) ) C C < r E - ) r E C ) C ‘ < L C ) ) C C L C ) 9 L C 5 - 2 ) — C - ) C 9 3 r E ) C : ) — C ) j C L C C C L C r E . < ) C - ) C ) C ) C ) r 2 . ) “ C - ) C ) C C ) C ) C J N ) 9 L - — C L C ) C < ‘ C — - ) ) C C . . . L C ) C ) C H ) 9 ) C ‘ L C L C N ’ ) C - — ) C ) C ) C L C < ‘ C ) C . ) C L C a ) C r E ) C L C . ) C . : ) C ’ ) C — ) C ) C - C L C ) C ) C ) C r E C ) ) C C C - 2 — - r E ) ) C C r E L C 7 C 1 4 ) C ) C ) C ) 9 ) C C ‘ ) - C ) C L C ) C L C 3 ) ) C C ) C ( ) ) C C ) - C ‘ ) C N . . . , , 4 - C $ - ) C t ) 9 . . i c 9 2 9 C ‘ — ) ) C — — N N C 2 ) ) C C : ) - C 9 9 L C ) L C C o — ) C c f i S O L C — ) . ) 9 ) 9 C ‘ N - ) C L C C — ) C , C ) ) C C L C ) 9 — r — E - ) C “ - r E ) C r E C N . < ‘ ) C — ) C r I C - 2 ) C ‘ - ) ) C C ) — C ) C / ‘ ) C ) C Hanumappa and plaintiffs 2 & 3 along with their mother Gouravva—wife of Halappa, are entitled to 1/4th share.

24. The material on record would show that it is also admitted in the written statement that 1-lan umappa died on 22.09.1991 and therefore, his share will devolve upon the Class-I heirs in Schedule-I to the Hind u Succession Act which includes his mother. who died during the pendency of the suit and therefore, 1/4th share of Hanumappa would devolve equally upon his wife—the defendant and mother—original plaintiff No.1 as Classi heirs. Therefore, the defendant is entitled to 1 /8th share in the properties of Han umappa in the suit schedule properties and other share would devolve upon Plaintiff No. 1—mother and after her death during the pendency of the suit. upon her children. As the daughter-in-lav is not one of the heir who succeed to the properties of mother-in- law as per Section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act and the children would succeed to the properties of the mother . 9 L C ) C , 9 . 9 C j — L C i C C L L C ) C D C 9 ( D C i L 9 ‘ C N ( ) C L C L C D C - C l E L C D C L C l E - - , 5 : ’ C C L C — C C ’ C L C l E N ( L C ) C ) ) C C ‘ — - I I ’ ) C C L C ) C : , - ‘ ‘ ) C L C - D C ) ) C C ’ l E L C D C H ‘ L C N ( — D C L C . 9 C C E 4 1 2 . . ‘ ’ C L ) C ) C C C : 9 L I ’ L I ’ C C ) ’ C C c t C C “ ) - C C ‘ I L C D C ) C 9 4 1 $ 1 . 9 C ) L C L C t C C ) C D ’ ) ’ p ) ’ r L C L C ) C 5 5 : 9 4 ‘ — . N ( . C C L C t C C ‘ ( L C , , 5 E - C : 5 5 ) C t C 0 L C i l t ’ C D C i L E C T C ) C 4 ‘ C L C t , , ) C t C ” C 5 5 ’ i L C ) ) C C t C L C t C D C . H L C 9 D C E 4 1 . ‘ i L , ’ ) ’ C - 9 r i L . L C . L C D C L C t C ) 5 C C . 9 , , . - 9 C 4 ) ” 5 C D C , , 9 l C C “ “ , , l E . 9 ‘ C — “ - C ) ) C C D C ) 9 C C C ’ C ‘ C C L C D C C C L C D C 9 ” q E C D C . i L 9 X L C i L 9 L I . C C 9 ) 5 L C L I L C C ) ’ 9 L C ) C L C ’ ) ) 5 , 9 , - C D C 0 i L L C J - C — C N L C t C - C t , C 9 ) C l E , L C , L C C C . L C D C ” p L 4 , t C ‘ L C C ‘ ( , ) Q C 5 : i L 9 4 — C ‘ ( ; L C i L L C 9 — L C L C C ‘ ( L C S C ‘ C ‘ ) C r . i L L C - , , , C D 9 l E - 4 L l E 9 L C — t — C ’ i L C C S “ z L C “ ‘ ) C ) C L C ‘ ) C L C i L C C “ ) C c L C C C ’ D C l E L C , , C C ‘ ( i ) L C t o C l E C ‘ C S L C . C C . i L l E , , , , ) C ) C ) ‘ . 9 C “ L I i L ) , ‘ L C D C L C L I i L L C C C C C : : . l E - C z ) C C ) C 9 ) C L C L C ’ C C “ , ) L D - C ‘ C C 5 5 , ) 9 C C — ) 5 i L L C l E L C - C - C D C x N ( ” ) ) S C C L C t C ’ D C ’ 1 1 L C 9 ( l E ’ C )— C L C L C 4 ‘ 4 ‘ D C ) C ) C D C C ‘ E ( C L E I C ) C • ) C D C ) ) C C . ) C C L C l E D - - i L L C C ( — C L C t C ) C C C ) C L C e - c 2 C ‘ ( ) C L I . — C— t e : i L t C S - i L _ . . D C H J - D C ) L C C L C C C L C D L C L . ) C C ’ C C L C C ( C C L l E . 2 9 t C L C D C ” - C i L C C 4 5 ‘ ) 4 ‘ C t C 4 1 L C N ( D C . , N ( . ) C D C i L L C t C : 4 L C L C ‘ , ‘ L C C ‘ ( L C i L C C C ‘ L C L C ) C l E , 4 ‘ i L C C : — L I D C 0 C ‘ “ - ) C , — 4 5 ) K E C L C C N C ‘ ( C C L C . r ) C ) C t ” C L C D C L C L C ) C L C C C , C ( ORDER fli.. dL’Iea •s ai;o,.n_d I’! I’a t r ‘‘ iynri 3r’ 1&’’-e : cce-4 1” tht tra’ S N• 1’’t’ t hc iding U at th plaintiffs are entitled ‘ 4 hait. , bt.’ JbCJC die t )rdered that the plaintiffs are entitk. d to 7’R share and itt a 4endar, entitled to ‘8 har” ‘n the o. sthcduie GtOpe.4’C ‘i•i’ The p’3rties are arititleci possession & ‘he ‘ets and bcu’nt tr sparat jropertie h, TI’e juigm . “se eass • I r I