BANGALORE-560 091 v. SMT. SUMANA NAGANAND, ADVCOATE FOR R3 [VC])

SRIDHARA MURTHY B S/O LATE NARASIMHAIAH H B AGED 73 YEARS 4215, 4TH MAIN SRI SAI KRUPA AMARAVATHI LAYOUT BANGARPET-563 162. SHESHADRI REDDY R S (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

SMT. GIRIJA W/O SHESHADRI REDDY R S AGED 59 YEARS BURUJANA ROPPA VILL. EIMANGALA HOBLI,HIRIYUR TALUK CHITHRADURGA DISTRICT-577598.

VITTAL JAYASHETTY S/O APPANNA JAYASHETTY AGED 71 YEARS GDA 2437, 4TH CROSS KOTANOOR, RING ROAD GULBARGA-585 102. ABRAHAM Y (SINCE DEAD, BY LR) 25

MRS. MANIMEGALAI A W/O LATE ABRAHAM Y AGED 65 YEARS 184, VIJAYANAGAR BEML NAGAR POST, K G F-563 115.

NARAYANA REDDY D G S/O GANGAPPA P AGED 68 YEARS 152, 1ST FLOOR 5TH CROSS KCHS LAYOUT 2ND STAGED BHUVANESHWARI NAGAR BANGALORE-560 056.

BEERAPPA C S/O CHINAPPA AGED 73 YEARS YELAVARA VIL., KAMADHENU HALLI KOLAR TALUK-563115.

SATHYANARAYANA SETTY P S/O VENKAT SWAMY SETTY AGED 75 YEARS 4110, 1ST MAIN KUPPUSWAMY NAGAR BANGARPET-563 114.

RANGA RAO U S/O JAGANNATH RAO U AGED 73 YEARS 4195 “PRASANNA” VIVEKANANDA NAGAR BANGARPET-563 114.

RAMAPPA M S/O CHANNAPPA AGED 73 YEARS RENUKA NILAYA 4TH MAIN 5TH CROSS AMARAVATHY, BANGARPET-563114. 26

ANTHONY CRUZE L S/O LOURDHUNATHAN AGED 73 YEARS 838, 5TH CROSS 2ND STAGED GOWTHAM NAGAR ROBERTSONPET K G F-563 122.

SRINIVASA K S/O KADIRAPPA AGED 72 YEARS BELAGANAHALLI , HUTTUR POST KOLAR-563 101. SHANKAR BABU T R (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. GIRIJAMMA W/O LATE SHANKAR BABU T R AGED 60 YEARS OPP. VENUGOPAL SWAMY TEMPLE KATARI PALYA, KOLAR-563 115.

RAMAKRISHNA B N S/O NARASIMHAIAH B L AGED 74 YEARS 1810/11, SRI NARASIMHA NILAYA BEHIND BET SCHOOL CHIKKABANAVARA, BANGALORE-560 090.

PERUMAL M S/O LATE MANICKAM V AGED 72 YEARS 866 SRIRAM NAGAR OORGAUMPET POST, K G F-563 121.

PUTTANNA S/O RAMA RAO V AGED 72 YEARS 783 NEAR VENUGOPALASWAMY TEMPLE KATARI PALYA, KOLAR-563 101. 27 149 . PURUSHOTHAMA SRIRAMULU S S/O LATE CHINNA SWAMY S AGED 73 YEARS 57, VIJAYA NAGAR, 5TH CROSS BEML NAGAR POST, K G F -563 115. SWAMINATHAN (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

ALBERT S S/O LATE SWAMINATHAN AGED 72 YEARS 4/248, GANDHI ROAD PONNAI VILLAGED AND POST VELLORE-632514.

GOPALA GOWDA B R S/O RAMAIAH B G AGED 72 YEARS 26/6, AKKALAPPA LAYOUT IMMADI HALLI WHITEFIELD BANGALORE-560 066.

REDDAPPA T N S/O LATE NARAYANAPPA AGED 73 YEARS BTM-1326 1ST CROSS VIJAYANAGAR, BANGARPET-563 114.

NARAYANASWAMY R S/O RAMAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 4775, 2ND MAIN 7TH CROSS AMARAVATHY NAGAR BANGARPET-563 114.

RAVINDRA A S/O LATE VENKOBA RAO A AGED 72 YEARS 214, 9TH CROSS VIJAYANAGAR BEML NAGAR, K G F-563 115. 28 155 . SREENIVASAN P S/O PACHAPPAN AGED 74 YEARS 111 NEW MODEL HOUSE E T BLOCK OORGAUM, K G F.

MRS. MANIKYA JOSEPH D/o LATE JOSEPH AGED 73 YEARS 2409, JOSEPH COTTAGED 2ND MAIN 3RD CROSS VIVEKANANDA NAGAR BANGARPET-563162.

LOGANATHAN R S/O RAMALINGAM AGED 74 YEARS 220, ST BLOCK COROMANDEL POST, K G F-563 118.

RAJAKUMAR S N S/O NARAYANA S C AGED 72 YEARS 305 DASARAHOSAHALLI EXTN. DESIHALLI POST BANGARPET TALUK- 563 162.

PRABHAKARA K S/O KRISHNAMURTHY M S AGED 72 YEARS 4-A, 19TH D MAIN ROAD 1ST BLOCK RAJAJINAGAR BANGALORE-560 010.

ABDUL ALEEM S S/O LATE SHAIK IMAM AGED 71 YEARS BEHIND GOVT. URDU SCHOOL AAYESHA MANZIL OORGAUMPET K G F-563112. 29 161 . SRINIVASA R S/O RAMAIAH AGED 72 YEARS KODI RAMASANDRA VILLAGED TAMAKA POST KOLAR-563 101. 162 . VINCENT C S/O CHINNA DURAI AGED 72 YEARS 1162, 6TH CROSS, PIPE LINE ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563 122. SIDDAPPA (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

LAKSHMAIAH S S/O LATE SIDDAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 532 MADHURA NAGAR, 3RD STAGED VARTHUR, BANGALORE-560 087.

AROCKIA DOSS R S S/O SAVARINATHAN R AGED 73 YEARS 1647 2ND STAGED, 3RD CROSS GOUTHAM NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

BASKARAN N S/O NARAYANAN AGED 72 YEARS 87, 3RD CROSS SWARNA NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

NATARAJAN M S/O MUNISWAMY AGED 72 YEARS L41, NEW ELECTRIC QUARTERS OORGAUM, K G F-563115. 30 167 . SUNDER RAJ S S/O SUBRAMANY AGED 72 YEARS 209, VIJAYANAGAR BEML NAGAR, KGF-563 115. 168 . ANTHONY CRUZE S S/O SAVARIYAPPAN AGED 72 YEARS 5/180, 1ST CROSS SHAMANNA COMPOUND, BEHIND TIN FACTORY SHAKTHI NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 016 ARASHAPPA T (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MUNIVENKATAPPA K A S/O LATE ARASHAPPA T AGED 73 YEARS A 66, BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST, K G F-563 115. NATESAN J (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SUGUNA D W/O LATE NATESAN J AGED 61 YEARS 36, 1ST MAIN 1ST CROSS SWATHANTRA NAGAR AYYAPPA NAGAR VIRGO NAGAR POST BANGALORE-560 036.

NAGARAJAN K M S/O LATE MALLAIAH K V AGED 74 YEARS 154/1, CHAND LINE BANGARPET-563 114. 31

SRINIVASA M S/O MUNISWAMAPPA B AGED 73 YEARS 2189, SARITHA NILAYA CAMPING GROUND BANGARPET-563 114.

THULASIRAMAN T S/O THIRUVENGADAM AGED 73 YEARS 78/1 BGML HOSPITAL COMPOUND CHAMPION REEFS, K G F-563 117. EKANATH BABU E (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SARASWATHI BAI E W/O LATE EKANATH BABU E 31, MADHURI NILAYAM, DK HALLI POST DASARAHOSAHALLI POST, K G F DOT 27/05/2009.

GOPALAKRISHNA K V S/O VENKATARAMANAPPA AGED 74 YEARS 439, 2ND CROSS, GOWRIPET KOLAR-563 101.

RAJENDRAN G S/O LATE GOVINDAN C AGED 72 YEARS 880, 8TH CROSS, GOWTHAM NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F - 563 122.

DEVA PRASATHAM R S/O LATE RAJENDRAN I AGED 72 YEARS 156 6TH CROSS, RAJAPPA COTTAGED ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122. 32

RAMANATHA K R S/O RATHNAIAH SETTY K M AGED 71 YEARS RATHNAIAH SETTY BLOCK, GEETHA RD., ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563 122.

SATTU V S/O VELAYUTHAM AGED 73 YEARS B 212, 3RD MAIN BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

ANTHONI SWAMY S S/O SAVARIMUTHU V AGED 73 YEARS 157 KATHIHALLI B E M L NAGAR POST, K G F-563 115.

GOPALAKRISHNA S V S/O BISHWESWARAIAH B S AGED 74 YEARS A 47 ADVAITHYA, BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

KALIDASAN K S/O KOTHANDAPANI A 37, 2ND MAIN 2ND CROSS BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR PO KOLAR GOLD FIELDS-563 115. JOSEPH KANICKARAJ S (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. ELIZABETH MARY W/O LATE JOSEPH KANICKARAJ S AGED 70 YEARS B 43, BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST, K G F -563 115. SAMPATH RAJ T (SINCE DEAD, BY LR) 33

MRS. MALATHI S W/O LATE SAMPATH RAJ T AGED 61 YEARS 102, 3RD CROSS SRINIVASA KRUPA SHIRIDI SAI BEML LAYOUT MEDA HALLI, BANGALORE-560 049.

ALLISAB S. YARAGUPPI S/O SANN HUSSAIN SAB AGED 72 YEARS 2281, 5TH MAIN, VIVEKANANDA NAGAR BANGARPET-563 114.

SIMON F S/O FRANCIS AGED 73 YEARS 1652/1, 9TH CROSS GOWTHAM NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563 122.

NAGARAJU B S/O BYSAPPA AGED 72 YEARS A 18, 2ND CROSS, BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST, K G F-563 115.

SRINIVASAN I S/O IRUCHAN AGED 73 YEARS 70, GOWTHAM NAGAR 1ST CROSS, 2ND STAGED ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

SETHUMADHAVAN S S/O LATE SIVARAMAN NAIR AGED 73 YEARS 65, 7TH MAIN 2ND CROSS DASARAHOSA HALLI EXTN. DASARAHOSA HALLI BANGARPET TALUK-563115. 34 SRINIVASAIAH M (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. LAKSHMAMMA W/O LATE SRINIVASAIAH M AGED 65 YEARS KESARNAHALLI, SG KOTE BANGARPET-563 162.

NAGAN A S/O LATE ARJUNAN AGED 71 YEARS MEL KRISHNAPURAM OORGAUMPET POST, K G F-563122.

KUMAR S I S/O IRUCHAN AGED 72 YEARS 648, 9TH CROSS, GOWTHAM NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

THARANATHA K S/O LATE VENKATARAMANA ACHARYA AGED 73 YEARS 7-35/11, SHREYAS B-7TH CROSS ALAGUDDA KODIKAL MANGALORE-574 227.

VENKAPPA S/O LATE MUNDAPPA SHETTIGAR AGED 73 YEARS 2-89/1(6), AMMA NAGAKANNIKA TEMPLE ROAD KOCHADY, MANGALORE-575 008.

PADMANABHA ACHARYA S S/O LATE DOOMAPPA ACHARYA AGED 73 YEARS 7-211/F, “SWARNA DEEPA” BETKERI, NEAR HP GAS GODOWN MOODABIDRI-574 227. 35 196 . SRINIVASAN R S/O LATE RAMACHANDRA RAO E S AGED 73 YEARS 115, 5TH CROSS 1ST MAIN NRUPATHUNGA EXTN. RT NAGAR BANGALORE-560 032. THIRAJ K (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

SMT. CHANDRASAGARI C W/O LATE ETHIRAJ K AGED 67 YEARS B 3, BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR, K G F-63 115.

DEVAIAH M A S/O AIYAPPA M M AGED 72 YEARS SHIRDI SAI RATHAN LAYOUT DR. SHIVARAMA KARANTH NAGAR BANGALORE-560 077. CHIDANANDA S (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SHAILAJA SOGI W/O LATE CHIDANANDA S AGED 59 YEARS 168, SHAKUNTALA NILAYA KATHI HALLI, BEML NAGAR POST K G F-563115.

MAHESHWARAPPA K B S/O BASAPPA K AGED 72 YEARS LIG-46, E AND F BLOCK RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR MYSORE-570 022. 36 SOMASHEKAR (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

SMT. VANI SHEKAR S C (LEGAL HEIR ) W/O LATE SOMASHEKAR 1354, SURABHI, 1ST MAIN ROAD KRISHNAMURTHY PURAM MYSORE-570 004. SRINIVASA RAGHAVAN G (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

SMT. VASANTHA S W/O LATE SRINIVASA RAGHAVAN G AGED 65 YEARS 19/1 BLOCK 6 SRIRAMAPURAM 2ND STAGED, MADHUVANA LAYOUT MYSORE-570 023.

SHANKARAIAH K P S/O PARADESHAIAH AGED 72 YEARS LIG-44, 3RD MAIN ROAD E AND F BLOCK RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR MYSORE-570 022.

RACHE GOWDA C K S/O LATE KARI GOWDA AGED 72 YEARS 73, 3RD CROSS “I “ BLOCK KUVEMPU NAGAR, MYSORE-570 023.

JAYASIMHA R S/O LATE RAGHAVENDRA RAO B AGED 72 YEARS 5687, PAVAMANA, VIJAYANAGARA 4TH STAGED, 2ND PHASE, MYSORE.

RAMANANDA S/O LATE P R A MUDALIAR 37 AGED 73 YEARS 8, 19TH BLOCK SRI RAMAPURA 2ND STAGED BEML LAYOUT, MYSORE-570 023.

DASARATHA T K S/O LATE KEMPE GOWDA AGED 73 YEARS 2847/11, 3RD MAIN, 8TH CROSS JAYANAGAR, MYSORE-570 014.

ISIYAS J S/O LATE JOHN JOSEPH AGED 72 YEARS 4770/1, 4TH CROSS N R MOHALLA, MYSORE-570 007.

BELLIAPPA A C S/O LATE CHENGAPPA K AGED 73 YEARS 1130, BEML LAYOUT, 2ND STAGED R R NAGAR, MYSORE-570 033.

KRISHNE GOWDA M S/O THIRUMALE GOWDA AGED 73 YEARS 3592 MIG, 19TH MAIN, 1ST CROSS VIJAYANAGAR 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 017.

SRIDHARA S/O SUBBARAMAIAH B K AGED 72 YEARS 6, BLOCK 11/C, BEML NAGAR SRIRAM PURAM 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 023.

RAGHAVA ACHAR S/O LATE NAGAAPPA ACHAR AGED 73 YEARS 5559 MIG, 14TH MAIN, 4TH CROSS 38 VIJAYANAGAR 1ST STAGED MYSORE-570 017.

KRISHNAPPA A S/O AVALAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 1963 15TH MAIN, VIJAYANAGAR 2ND STAGED, MYSORE-570 017.

VENKATA RAJU S/O SIDDAIAH AGED 73 YEARS LIG 53, 3/A MAIN ROAD “I” BLOCK RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR, MYSORE 570 022.

PARAPPA S/O LATE RAMACHANDRAPPA PATTAR AGED 73 YEARS 23/4, SRIRAMAPURAM 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 023.

SREEKANTA SWAMY G S/O GURUNANJAPPA K R AGED 74 YEARS LIG 48, 3/A MAIN ROAD I BLOCK, RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR MYSORE-570 022.

GURUMALLESH T M S/O LATE MALLAPPAIAH AGED 73 YEARS 730/S, 24TH CROSS HEBBAL 2ND STAGED, MYSORE-570 017.

DAYANANDA A S/O LATE ANGARA A AGED 72 YEARS 681, S R S COLONY BELAVADI POST, MYSORE-570 018. 39

CHANDRASHEKAR C S/O LATE CHAKRAPANI MUDALIAR N AGED 67 YEARS LIG 3730, 5TH CROSS, 20TH MAIN VIJAYANAGAR, 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 017.

VENKATESH MURTHY S/O LATE NARASIMHAIAH AGED 73 YEARS 5752, 23RD B MAIN, VIJAYANAGAR 2ND STAGED, MYSORE 570 017. GOPAL RAO (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. PARVATHI BAI W/O LATE GOPAL RAO HIG 5, 3RD STAGED BANNI MANTAPA OPP. MUNESHWARA TEMPLE MYSORE. SUDARSHANA (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. RADHALAKSHMI W/O LATE SUDARSHANA AGED 62 YEARS 33, NEAR FLOUR MILL MAHADESHWARA BADAVANE YELWALA, MYSORE-571 130.

RAJAKUMAR SINGH S/O LATE GOPAL SINGH AGED 73 YEARS 94, 9TH CROSS, S M V ROAD VIJAYA SRI PURA MYSORE-570 006.

SHIVANNA B M S/O LATE MUNIYAPPA B 40 AGED 74 YEARS 1057, 1ST MAIN, 3RD CROSS SRIRAMPURAM 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 023.

NAGARAJA RAO R S/O RANGANATHA RAO P AGED 72 YEARS 613, 14TH CROSS, 27TH MAIN JP NAGAR 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 031.

NAGARAJU K S/O LATE KRISHNAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 507, 30TH CROSS D BLOCK JP NAGAR, MYSORE.

PALALOCHANA M B S/O LATE BASAPPA M N AGED 75 YEARS 171, 10TH CROSS, 12TH MAIN SARASWATHIPURAM, MYSORE.

KESHAVA MURTHY H S S/O SRINIVASAIAH H N AGED 72 YEARS 2828, UPSTAIRS, 1ST CROSS CHAMUNDIPURAM,MYSORE-570 004.

VENKATESHA K N S/O LATE NANJE GOWDA AGED 73 YEARS 2160 C BLOCK, C N M LAYOUT MAHADEVA PURA, MYSORE-570 008.

INDIRESHAN S N S/O LATE NARAYANA RAO S L AGED 72 YEARS 26, 16A BLOCK, RANGA RAO COLONY RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR, MYSORE-570 022. 41 NANJE GOWDA B (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. JAYAMMA D V (LEGAL HEIR/WIFE) W/O LATE NANJE GOWDA B AGED 65 YEARS 1703, 30/8TH MAIN 2ND STAGED HEBBAL, VIJAYANAGAR POST MYSORE-570 017.

HONNE GOWDA S/O LATE VARADE GOWDA AGED 72 YEARS 721, E & F BLOCK, 4/5 CROSS RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR, 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 022.

RANGASWAMY R S/O LATE RANGA SETTY K V AGED 74 YEARS MIG 91, 2ND MAIN, 4TH CROSS I BLOCK, RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR MYSORE5-70 022.

ANANTHARAM N S/O LATE NARASIMHAIH N AGED 74 YEARS C/O SREEDHAR, 597, 2ND STAGED 2ND CROSS M BLOCK KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE-570 023.

THIMMAIAH M S/O LATE MUDALAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 97, 8TH MAIN 1ST STAGED HEBBAL, MYSORE-570 016. PUTTASWAMY GOWDA (SINCE DEAD, BY LR) 42

MRS. PREMA (LEGAL HEIR/WIFE) W/O LATE PUTTASWAMY GOWDA AGED 72 YEARS 334/C, NEAR TELE. EXCHANGE KRS MAIN ROAD, HULIKERE MANDYA-571 606.

MURALIDHARA R S/O LATE RAMANNA R AGED 72 YEARS 438, BEHIND NEHRU PARK UDAYAGIRI, MYSORE-570 019.

MANTRI K M S/O LATE MAHAMMED SAB AGED 72 YEARS 289, 3RD MAIN 8TH CROSS SUBHASH NAGAR, MYSORE-570 007.

SHIVARAJU S/O GOVINDE GOWDA D AGED 73 YEARS 3594, 20TH MAIN 1ST CROSS VIJAYANAGAR, 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 017.

PUTTASWAMY M S/O LATE KEMPAIAH AGED 73 YEARS 258, 1ST CROSS NIVEDITHA NAGAR MYSORE-570 022.

NATOLANDA A DEVAIAH S/O LATE APPAIAH N N AGED 73 YEARS 694, DEVI MAHAL, NEW STREET HINAKAL, MYSORE-570 017. THIMMAIAH B C (SINCE DEAD, BY LR) 43

MRS. DECHAMMA K P W/O LATE THIMMAIAH B C AGED 65 YEARS 553/2, 24TH CROSS HEBBAL 2ND STAGED, MYSORE-570 017.

YESU VANAJA C LATE CHANDRAKARAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 132 4TH CROSS E AND F BLOCK RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR MYSORE-570 022.

KRISHNA KUMAR D N S/O LATE IYENGAR D N AGED 72 YEARS MIG 102, 4TH CROSS, I BLOCK RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR MYSORE-570 022.

PENCHULAIAH S/O LATE VENKATAIAH AGED 73 YEARS NO. 16, BLOCK 21 BEML LAYOUT SRIRAMPURAM 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 023. ARAMANAD N Y (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. CHANNAMMA C W/O LATE ARAMANAD N Y AGED 62 YEARS 833, 4TH MAIN 4TH CROSS I BLOCK, RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR MYSORE-570 022.

KRISHNA S S/O LATE SRINIVASA BHATTA AGED 72 YEARS 44 3 BLOCK, 2 SRI NILAYA SRIRAMPURAM 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570023.

PRABHAKARA S/O LATE NEELAKANTA SETTY K S AGED 73 YEARS 1407, HT DOUBLE ROAD HEBBAL 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 017.

CHANDRAKANTH K S/O LATE KRISHNA RAO AGED 73 YEARS LIG 3740 20TH MAIN 5TH CROSS VIJAYANAGAR 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 017.

KRISHNA N S/O LATE NARASIMHE GOWDA AGED 73 YEARS MIG 300, E BLOCK, 26TH CROSS VIJAYANAGAR 3RD STAGED MYSORE-570 030.

ANNE GOWDA D S/O DEVE GOWDA AGED 72 YEARS 4641, 13TH MAIN, VIJAYANAGAR 2ND STAGED, MYSORE-570 017.

SUDHAKARA K R S/O LATE RAMASWAMY IYENGAR K AGED 72 YEARS NO.3, BLOCK 2, “SRI NILAYA” SRIRAM PURAM 2ND STAGED MYSORE-570 023. GUMASTE S S (SINCE DEAD, BY LR) 45

MRS. NIRMALA GUMASTE W/O LATE GUMASTE S S AGED 67 YEARS A 112/2 2ND MAIN ROAD BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST, K G F-563 115.

MOHAN VELU D S/O DASAN I AGED 74 YEARS 309, 3RD CROSS GOWTHAM NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

NAGARAJA K S/O LATE NAIDU N K AGED 72 YEARS 142, 2ND BLOCK NEW EXTENSION BETHAMANGALA-63 116.

NATARAJAN K S S/O LATE SADAYAN AGED 72 YEARS 100/7 E T BLOCK POOSWAMY COLONY OORGAUM,K G F -563 115.

JAYAPRAKASHAM P S/O PONNUSWAMY AGED 72 YEARS 549, MATHI ILLAL, SUBASH NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

JAYARAMAN P S/O PARASURAMAN AGED 72 YEARS 61, 2ND MAIN 2ND A CROSS VIJINAPURA, DOORAVANI NAGAR BANGALORE-560 016.

STEPHENSON M S/O MADULAI MUTHU AGED 72 YEARS 46 81, B BLOCK, CHAMPION REEFS K G F -563 117.

JAYARAMAIAH S/O VENKATAPPA 6, 2ND MAIN, 1ST CROSS OPP. RELIANCE MART MUTHURAYA SWAMY LAYOUT DODDABOMMASANDRA BANGALORE-560097.

MOHAMMED ZAHEERULLA S/O ABDUL SATTAR AGED 72 YEARS 6, 3RD MAIN ROAD KEMPAIAH BLOCK, JC NAGAR BANGALORE-560 006.

RUBAN S S/O SWAMY KANNU AGED 72 YEARS 176, KATHI HALLI, MARUTHI NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST, K G F-563 115.

PRATHAP N S/O LATE NARAYANA REDDY M AGED 73 YEARS 3975, NEAR LAKSHMI TEMPLE VIJAYA NAGAR, BANGARPET-563 114.

KALYANA SUNDARAM S S/O SELLAIAH YADAV K AGED 72 YEARS PLOT NO. 5 KTR ESTATE NEAR TRINITY SCHOOL GATE THIRUVARUR-610 001.

SUNDARA RAMANUJAM R S/O RENGASWAMY NAIDU S AGED 74 YEARS 55, SRI RAGAV NIVAS 47 4TH STREET, 2ND CROSS PANDIAN NAGAR, NARIMEDU MADURAI-2, TAMIL NADU.

NARAYANASWAMY N S/O NARASIMHAIAH A AGED 73 YEARS 13/8 OPP.GOVT. PRIMARY SCHOOL NANDI VILLAGED CHIKBALLAPUR TALUK AND DISTRICT-562 101.

MUTHAPPA B S S/O SONNAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 504, 1ST CROSS, JAYANAGAR KOLAR-563 101.

ELANGOVAN V S/O LATE VEERASWAMY M AGED 71 YEARS 48, VEERA KANNI ILLAM HANUMANTHA NAGAR, BEML NAGAR P O KOLAR GOLD FIELDS-563 115.

MOORTHY K S/O KANNAN AGED 72 YEARS 180, 9TH CROSS, VIJAYANAGAR BEML NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

SAM D S/O DHURAISWAMY AGED 74 YEARS A 101, BHARATH NAGAR BEM NAGAR POST, K G F-563 115.

MARIA DOSS M S/O MADHALI MUTHU N AGED 73 YEARS 1778/1, NEAR SUBHASHINI COLLEGE 48 CORONATION TOWN ROBERTSONPET, K G F- 563 122. SRINIVAS N (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. PADMA S W/O LATE SRINIVAS N AGED 64 YEARS 1463, MAHARAJA ROAD ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

JAGADEESH B S/O BASAPPA M AGED 73 YEARS 337, 3RD MAIN B CROSS SIR M V NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

REDDAPPA S/O VENKATARAMAIAH AGED 72 YEARS BTM 1322, 1ST CROSS VIJAYANAGAR, BANGARPET.

ANANDAN D S/O DHARMALINGAM AGED 72 YEARS 1158 PADMINI NEAR AYYAPPA TEMPLE VIVEK NAGAR, ROBERTSONPET K G F-563 122. GOPAL A (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. FATHIMA S W/O LATE GOPAL A AGED 63 YEARS 13, ONESAW MILL CHAMPION REEF, K G F-563 117. SAMPATH KUMAR (SINCE DEAD, BY LR) 49

POONGODHAI (LEGAL HEIR/WIFE) W/O LATE SAMPATH KUMAR 922, SREE RAM NAGAR OORGAUMPET, K G F-563 121. SUBRAMNONEY G (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. INDRANI S W/O LATE SUBRAMNONEY G AGED 65 YEARS 16, N T BLOCK, COROMANDEL K G F -563 118.

KARUNANITHI S S/O LATE SUBRAMANI AGED 71 YEARS 6TH CROSS J K COTTAGED ANGLO INDIAN COLONY ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

JANAKIRAMAN G S/O GURUNATHAN B AGED 73 YEARS 71A, VALAR NAGAR BAGAYAM THORAPAD PO, VELLORE-632 002.

SWAMINATHAN M S/O MUNISWAMY C AGED 74 YEARS 67, 4TH CROSS, PALAR NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST, K G F5-63 115. CHAND PASHA (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SUMMIYA W/O LATE CHAND PASHA AGED 26 YEARS 1212, 4TH CROSS, GOWTHAM NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F- 563 122. 50

MRS. RUKMANI (EMPLOYEE) W/O LATE SHANMUGAM G AGED 72 YEARS 98/B, MARUTHI NAGAR,KATHI HALLI BANGARPET TALUK- 563 115.

SHARAD PANDE S/O RAMPRASAD S PANDE AGED 74 YEARS 21, 2ND PHASE KAMMAVARI NAGAR M V EXTENSION HOSAKOTE-562 114. SRINIVASAN C (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SHANTHI W/O LATE SRINIVASAN C AGED 53 YEARS 588, MINNAL ILLAM BEHIND OM SHAKTHI TEMPLE PARANDA HALLI ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

KEMPANNA S S/O SONNAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 130, 6TH CROSS, VIJAYANAGAR B E M L NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

MALLIKARJUN DUNDAPPA R S/O LATE DUNDAPPA AGED 72 YEARS F/22, GANGA NILAYA PULIYENDRAN LAYOUT KUMVEMPUNAGAR BANGARPET TALUK-563 162.

MARIA LIGORIUS S/O ANTHONEY CRUZE R 51 AGED 72 YEARS 83, COSTON BLOCK CHAMPION REEFS, K G F-563 117.

SATHYAMOORTHY R S/O RATHINAM S A AGED 72 YEARS 283, PITCHAHALLI, K G F-563 121.

KRISHNAN C S/O CHINAPPAN AGED 72 YEARS 701, LAND HOUSE MUSKAM C BLOCK ANDERSONPET KOLAR GOLD FIELDS -563 115.

GOVINDASWAMY C S/O LATE CHINNAKOLANDAI AGED 72 YEARS 20, 2ND STAGED, 1ST CROSS GOWTHAM NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563122.

JACOB G S/O LATE GABRIEL T AGED 73 YEARS EMIMA ILLAM 2ND MAIN, 7TH CROSS AMARAVATHI NAGAR BANGARPET-563 114.

MANI A S/O ALAGEDSON R AGED 72 YEARS 72, E T BLOCK, OORGAUM K G F 5-63 121.

ANTHONY CRUZE S M S/O MADALAIMUTHU AGED 73 YEARS 85, B BLOCK, NEAR ST. MARYS SCHOOL CHAMPION REEFS, K G F - 563 117. 52

LAKSHMANA S/O NARASINGA RAO N AGED 74 YEARS 201 JEEVANADI GODAVARI APARTMENTS C V RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 093.

RAMESH K S/O KAVERAPPA M AGED 71 YEARS 5, SKYLITE VILLA SARJAPUR HOBLI, THINDLU BANGALORE-562 125.

MUNIVEKATA SWAMY D S/O LATE DEVAPPA AGED 72 YEARS ABHAYA ANJANEYASWAMY TEMPLE ST., KARANJI KATTE, KOLAR-563 101.

VENKATARAMANA S/O BASI REDDY AGED 71 YEARS 854, 4TH CROSS, SWARNA NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563122.

ALIAS D’SOUZA S/O JOSEPH DSOUZA AGED 74 YEARS 20, CHRISELLE COTTAGED TRINITY ENCLAVE 1ST MAIN, 6TH CROSS, HORAMAVU BANGALORE-560 043.

AMARANATHAN S S/O SEETHARAMAN AGED 72 YEARS 654, ITALIAN QUARTERS NEAR MYSORE HALL MARIKUPPAM, K G F-563 119. 53

JAYARAMAN P S/O NAMBIAR V R AGED 70 YEARS 10, SRI SAI KRISHNA DESI HALLI POST BANGARPET5-63 162.

SHEIK UBEDULLA P S/O LATE PYARU AGED 73 YEARS 1212, 4TH CROSS GOWTHAM NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

THOMAS A S/O ANTHAIAH P AGED 72 YEARS 211 CYCULLA COTTAGED 3RD MAIN, 2ND CROSS SIR M V NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

RAMAKRISHNAPPA D S/O VENKATAGIRIYAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 45, 3RD CROSS, SREE NILAYA BASAVANNAPURA MAIN ROAD KR PURAM, BANGALORE-560 036.

MOHAMMED ALAM S/O MOHAMMED YAQOOB AGED 72 YEARS 74, 1ST CROSS, SOMESHWARA BLOCK MANJUNATHA NAGAR OORGAUMPET POST, K G F-563 121.

CHANDRAMOULESHWARA Y N S/O NATESHWARA IYER AGED 71 YEARS 418 SHANDILYA F CROSS SIR M V NAGAR,K G F-563 115. 54

RAMAKRISHNA S/O VENKATRAMAIAH KYASAMBALLA ROAD AGED 74 YEARS HANUMANTH NAGAR BETHAMANGALA-563 116.

ANTHONY DOSS A S/O ANTHONY D AGED 72 YEARS 1893/2 B M ROAD CORONATION TOWN ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563 122.

KESAVAN B S/O LATE BALAKRISHNAN AGED 71 YEARS B E M L NAGAR POST KOLAR GOLD FIELDS-563 115.

PADMANABHAN ACHARY N S/O NARAYANAN ACHARY K AGED 72 YEARS 42, KRISHNA NIVAS, H P NAGAR B E M L NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

KUMARESAN D S/O DHAKSNA MANICKAM AGED 73 YEARS 441, 7TH CROSS SUBASH NAGAR EXTN. ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

NARAYANAN P S S/O SUBRAMANIYAM S AGED 73 YEARS 132/2 SASTHRI SALAI-5 SURAMPATTI VALASU ERODE-638 009.

PRABHAKARA B K S/O KRISHNA RAO B N 55 AGED 71 YEARS 35, SMV LAYOUT 1ST STAGED KENGERI, BANGALORE-560 060.

DURAIRAJ M S/O MUTHAN P AGED 72 YEARS B 132, KALAPRIYAN 3RD MAIN, 4TH CROSS BHARATH NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

KANNAPPA UDAYAR M S/O MURUGAPPA UDAYAR AGED 73 YEARS 60, 2ND FLOOR, 4TH MAIN 5TH CROSS, NAVODAYA NAGAR JP NAGAR 7 PHASE, BANGALORE-560 076.

VENKATARAMANAPPA M S/O LATE MUNISWAMY AGED 74 YEARS 2645, GANDHI NAGAR BANGARPET-563 114.

ANANTHAKRISHNA B K S/O LATE KRISHNAPPA AGED 74 YEARS 28 VENKATESHWARA NILAYA 1ST MAIN HAROHALLI BANGALORE-560 091.

KUMARAN P S/O CHEREYAMBU N AGED 74 YEARS 98, SHABALIMA HOUSE KAVERI NAGAR EXTN. BEML NAGAR, K G F-563 115. JAYAPALAN P (SINCE DEAD, BY LR) 56

MRS. KANTHA W/O LATE JAYAPALAN P AGED 71 YEARS 210, KUVEMPU NAGAR DASARAHOSA HALLI BANGARPET TALUK-563114.

SHANMUGAM M S/O LATE MUTHU AGED 72 YEARS 196 KAMMATHIAMMA PALLE GUDIPALA MANDAL CHITTOOR-517403.

NAGAPPA S/O SHARANAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 4026/4027, RAGHAVENDRA COLONY SHAKTHI NAGAR, RAICHUR-584 170.

RAMACHANDRAN R S/O RAJAKANNAN AGED 74 YEARS 27, SATHANIPET 2ND STREET MADUVINKARNI, GUINDY CHENNAI -600 032.

JANAKIRAMAN M S/O MUTHUKRISHNAN M AGED 74 YEARS 222/13-2, SEVANTHI POO STREET MEENAKSHI AMMAN NAGAR EAST SURYANAGAR MADURAI-625 014. MANICKAM K (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. JOTHI P W/O LATE MANICKAM K AGED 68 YEARS 1206/1B PJ NEHRU STREET 57 AMBURPET, VANIYAMBADI TAMIL NADU- 635751.

VENKATASWAMY S S/O GURAPPA AGED 74 YEARS 375, DASARAHOSAHALLI DK HALLI POST BANGARPET TALUK -563 112.

YESUDASS T V S/O VENUGOPAL T AGED 74 YEARS 18, MUNICIPAL QUARTERS ROBERTSONPET, KGF -563 112.

VENKATARAMAIAH M S/O MUNISWAMY AGED 74 YEARS 4766, AMARAVATHI NAGAR 11TH MAIN, BANGARPET-563 112.

CHANDRASEKAR M S/O LAKSHMINARAYANA SASTRY AGED 74 YEARS 301, 2ND FLOOR, 5TH MAIN SITI SHIVAGANGA ORCHIDS VALLABH NAGAR, UTHARAHALLI BANGALORE-560 061.

THANOJI RAO S S/O SHIVAJI RAO P AGED 74 YEARS TROPICAL KRISHNA PLATINUM 2ND CROSS, NAGASHETTY HALLI BANGALORE-560 059.

KRISHNAPPA A S/O ARASAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 1651, 4TH MAIN 5TH CROSS 58 JUDICIAL LAYOUT GKVK POST YELAHANKA, BANGALORE-5604 065. SHIROMANIE P (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. KAMALA W/O LATE SHIROMANIE P AGED 64 YEARS 35, 19TH CROSS 20TH MAIN SMS LAYOUT, JP NAGAR 5TH PHASE BANGALORE-560 078.

RAJA RATHINAM K S/O KOLANDAI VELU AGED 74 YEARS NO. 1, W.T. BLOCK, OORGAUM PO K G F -563 120.

GANGAPPA M S/O MUNIVENKATAPPA AGED 72 YEARS KALLANDUR VIL. BEGLIHOSAHALLI POST KOLAR-563 101.

MOHAN SHIVAYOGI SARAPURE S/O SHIVAYOGI SARAPURE AGED 73 YEARS 2346, SHIVAGANGA NILAYA VIVEKANANDA NAGAR BANGARPET-563 114.

THIMMAPPAIAH N K S/O NEKKERE KRISHNA BHAT AGED 73 YEARS C/O ARAVINDA KRISHNA NO.14 BANNURU, PUTTUR-574 203.

CHANDRE GOWDA A M S/O MUNIVENKATAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 59 1999, CAMPING GROUNDS BANGARPET-563 114.

PARAMASIVAM S S/O SIVARAM R AGED 71 YEARS SIVA NIVAS, GOPAL MENON COMPOUND 4TH BLOCK, ROBERTSONPET K G F-563 122.

NARASIMHAIAH R S/O RAMAIAH K AGED 73 YEARS 94, 1ST FLOOR, 1ST CROSS 5TH MAIN, REMCO LAYOUT VIJAYANAGAR, BANGALORE-560 040. SUNDER BABU G (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. JAGADESWARI W/O LATE SUNDER BABU G AGED 62 YEARS 1616, KVGM COMPOUND, 4TH CROSS ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563 122. SIVARAMAN (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. JAYANTHI S W/O SIVARAMAN AGED 70 YEARS 528, EDGAR QUARTERS MARIKUPPAM, K G F-563 119.

JAYARAMA REDDY S/O GANTLA REDDY 1025, 10TH CROSS,, SWARNA NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122. 60 VENKATESH PRASAD M N (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SAROJA W/O LATE VENKATESH PRASAD M N AGED 70 YEARS 404 ANKSHU RESIDENCY, 3RD FLOOR SATYA SAI LAYOUT, AYYAPPA NAGAR K R PURAM, BANGALORE-560 036.

OBULAPATHI B S/O CHEINNAOBAIAH AGED 73 YEARS 130, 2ND CROSS, SHIVANANDA NAGAR NEW THIPPASANDRA BANGALORE-560 075.

SANKARAN G S/O GOPALAN K AGED 74 YEARS 7, HARI NIVAS, 12TH MAIN NEW THIPPASANDRA POST BENGALURU-560 075.

RAMAN UNNI S/O LATE RAMAN KUTTY P AGED 73 YEARS 42 PALLATH, 10TH MAIN 3RD CROSS, MARUTHI NAGAR NEW THIPPASANDRA P O BANGALORE-560 075.

JOHN CHARLES S S/O SAMUEL AGED 73 YEARS 195/54 NETHRAVATHY STREET UDAYA NAGAR BENGALURU -560016.

JAIRAJ T S/O THAYAPPA 61 AGED 72 YEARS 8/1 2ND CROSS, JAI JAWAN NAGAR RS PALYA BANASWADI BANGALORE-560 033.

MUTHAPPA V S/O CHINNANNA AGED 73 YEARS 42 OPP. SRIRAMA TEMPLE SARAJAPURA BAGALUR ROAD BANGALORE-562 149.

JAYAPRABHU L S/O LOGAN T V AGED 72 YEARS SRI BALAJI HOMES 203 1ST MAIN GOPAL REDDY LAYOUT, BANGALORE-560 043.

PAVITHRAN P K S/O LATE GOPALAN P AGED 73 YEARS 17, 1ST FLOOR 2ND CROSS DEVAPPA LAYOUT RAMACHANDRAPURA JALAHALLI EAST, BANGALORE-560 013.

PAUL VINCENT S/O LATE ARUL DOSS AGED 73 YEARS 12, 12TH CROSS, CHINNAPPA GARDEN BENSON TOWN, BANGALORE-560 046.

VEERAKESAN M S/O MASILAMANI AGED 72 YEARS FLAT NO. 301, 1ST FLOOR KUBERA ENCLACE APARTMENTS KODIGEHALLI MAIN ROAD KR PURAM, BANGALORE-560 016. 62 SURESH C (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. TULASI W/O LATE SURESH C AGED 68 YEARS NO. 1 / 2 OMKARA NILAYA HANUMAN NAGAR, MAIN ROAD HAL 3RD STAGED NEW THIPPASANDRA BANGALORE-560 075.

SOMASUNDARAM R S/O LATE RAMASWAMY CHETTIAR AGED 71 YEARS 142 OLD UCO BANK ROAD 3RD CROSS RAMAMURTHY NAGAR BANGALORE-560 016.

SIVASANKARAN NAIR P S/O LATE PARAMESWARAN NAIR P K AGED 74 YEARS 33 “SARATHI” 10TH MAIN, 2ND CROSS MARUTHI NAGAR, THIPPASANDRA BANGALORE-560 075.

ANTHONY L S/O LOURDUSWAMY AGED 72 YEARS B 39-1511 BDA 3RD STAGED AUSTIN TOWN BANGALORE-560 047

RAMASWAMY E S S/O SUBRAMANYAM E K AGED 72 YEARS 130-B, 4TH BLOCK 4TH MAIN RAJAJI NAGAR BANGALORE-560 010.

RAMAPPA N S/O LATE NANJAPPA AGED 74 YEARS 2002, YELLAMMA TEMPLE ST. 63 NEW THIPPASANDRA BANGALORE-560 075.

LAKSHMAN JOGI S/O SHEENA PURUSHA AGED 72 YEARS 1/1 MANGALA LAYOUT OIL MILL ROAD, BANGALORE-560 084.

KESHAVA M S/O HARIYAPPA DEVADIGA AGED 72 YEARS 20, 15TH CROSS MANGALA LAYOUT OIL MILL ROAD, KAMMANAHALLI BANGALORE-560 084.

SIMON FRANCIS LASRADO S/O LATE MERCEL LASRADO AGED 74 YEARS 1347, 12TH MAIN 6TH CROSS HAL 3RD STAGED, BANGALORE-560 008.

NARASIMHA BHATRACHAR S/O SRIRANGARAJA BHATRACHARYA AGED 73 YEARS 1142 (185/1A) 1ST CROSS, 1ST BLOCK NEW THIPPASANDRA, HAL 3RD STAGED BANGALORE-560 075.

THAMA K S/O LATE KANNUSWAMY AGED 72 YEARS 104, 3RD E CROSS, KASTHURI NAGAR KALYAN NAGAR POST, BANGALORE-560 043.

VENKATARAMANAPPA A S S/O SEETHAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 174/A, AGARA SARAJAPURA ROAD BANGALORE-560 102. 64

MUNIKRISHNA RAO K G S/O LATE GOPALA RAO M AGED 73 YEARS 33 FIRST MAIN, FIRST CROSS PUTTAPPA LAYOUT, MAHADEVAPURA BANGALORE-560 048.

VENKATESH PRASAD S G S/O GURURAJACHAR S R AGED 72 YEARS 134, 3RD MAIN, 3RD CROSS NEAR JAIN TEMPLE, TR NAGAR BANGALORE-560 004.

VENKATARAMANAPPA N S/O NARAYANAPPA AGED 71 YEARS 32, KUGUR POST, VIA SARAJAPUR BANGALORE DISTRICT.

NARASINGAPPA S/O SOMANNA AGED 72 YEARS 924, 3RD B CROSS, 9TH B MAIN KALYAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 043.

RAJAMANOHARAN R S/O RATHNAM R AGED 65 YEARS 316, 1ST CROSS, 7TH MAIN NEW BAGALUR LAYOUT ST. THOMAS TOWN BANGALORE-560 084.

CHANDRAN O S/O KRISHNA PILLAI V AGED 72 YEARS 140, 1ST MAIN ANUGRAHA BEML SHIRDISAI LAYOUT MEDAHALLI, BANGALORE-560 049. 65

ABBAIAH S/O MOOGANNA AGED 71 YEARS 26, 12TH CROSS, BELLANDUR BANGALORE-560 103.

JOSEPH KLINE M S/O JOSEPH M L AGED 73 YEARS 603/1, 80 FEET ROAD HAL 3RD STAGED, KODIHALLI BANGALORE-560 008.

RAMAIAH G A S/O ANANTHASWAMY IYER G R AGED 72 YEARS FLAT NO. 412 A BLOCK MAY FLOWER BRIGADE MILLENIUM JP NAGAR 7TH PHASE, BANGALORE-560 078.

CHANNE GOWDA B H S/O HANUMAIAH AGED 73 YEARS 3/77, ST. THOMAS TOWN LINGARAJA PURAM BANGALORE-560 084.

MRS. SAROJA V W/O LATE VENKATARAMAN N AGED 71 YEARS 39, ARMSTRONG ROAD BHARATHI NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 001

VASUDEVAN V T S/O VARADARAJAN V T AGED 72 YEARS FLAT NO. 304, 1ST MAIN PALLANGERE, BANGALORE-560 098.

GUNASEKARAN S S/O SUBRAMANI 66 AGED 72 YEARS B 39-1511, BDA 3RD STAGED AUSTIN TOWN, BANGALORE-560 047.

RAJAMANIKYAM R S/O RUBAN AGED 74 YEARS 171, MOTTAPALYAM, 2ND STAGED INDIRA NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 038.

SALOMON S/O CHINNAPAYYAN AGED 72 YEARS 06, BETHAL COTTAGED JASMINE STREET KALLAPPA CIRCLE, KAMMANAHALLI BANGALORE-560 084.

CHANDRA KUMAR R S/O LATE RAJAGOPAL AGED 72 YEARS 17, 3RD CROSS, LBS LAYOUT INDIRA NAGAR 2ND STAGED 17 E CROSS, BANGALORE-560 038. ANGAPPAN T N (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS.RAJALAKSHMI W/O LATE ANGAPPAN T N AGED 65 YEARS 3/2, 12TH CROSS INDIRA NAGAR 1ST STAGED BANGALORE-560 038.

PAUL P R S/O RAPHAEL AGED 74 YEARS 92, ANUGRAHA 5TH MAIN, 5TH CROSS KODI HALLI, BANGALORE-560 008. 67

VISHNUGARAN K. S/O KANDHASAMY K AGED 74 YEARS 73, 5TH CROSS, NANJAPPA GARDEN KALYAN NAGAR PO, BANGALORE-560 043

JEROME REGO S/O LATE LAWRENCE REGO AGED 74 YEARS 16, 8TH MAIN, 4TH CROSS AURTHAR EXTN. VIVEK NAGAR BANGALORE-560 047.

DEENADAYALAN R S/O RAJAN T R AGED 73 YEARS 2088, 8TH CROSS, 14TH MAIN KODIHALLI, BANGALORE-560 008.

RAVANAN A S/O ANDI, 25, 4TH CROSS, MANJUNATHA NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 023.

DURAI RAJ B S/O BABU M AGED 72 YEARS 435/202, MUNISHAMAPPA LAYOUT KONENA AGRAHARA BANGALORE-560 017.

ANJANAPPA G S/O GUNTAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 36, 4TH MAIN, G M PALYA NEW THIPPASANDRA POST BANGALORE-560 075.

YESUDASAN A S/O AROCKIASWAMY 68 AGED 73 YEARS 23, 1ST MAIN 15TH STREET GOWTHAMPURAM, BANGALORE-560 008.

SIMON P S/O PITCHAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 463, 15TH CROSS, ANANDAPURAM NEW THIPPASANDRA POST BANGALORE-560 075. SUNDARESHAN V (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. LIDIYA KANTHIMATHI W/O LATE SUNDARESHAN V AGED 66 YEARS 53, 3RD STREET 1ST BLOCK PRAKRUTHI TOWNSHIP BANGALORE-560 043.

NARASIMHAN S/O ANNIYAPPAN AGED 74 YEARS 112, 3RD CROSS, BHASHYAM NAGAR SRI RAMAPURAM, BANGALORE-560 021.

MUKUNDA G P S/O LATE PERUMALACHAR AGED 72 YEARS 110/3, 6TH CROSS, TULASI ROAD K R PURAM, BANGALORE-560 036. JAIRAJ JADHAV (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SHOBA JADHAV W/O LATE JAIRAJ JADHAV AGED 63 YEARS 2ND MAIN 2ND CROSS 69 GANGAMMA DEVI, TEMPLE ROAD K R PURAM, BANGALORE-560 036.

KARUNAGARAN A S/O AYYASWAMY AGED 72 YEARS 15 1ST CROSS VIVEKANANDA NAGAR BANGALORE-560 033. RENUGOPAL (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS.KRISHNAVENI M W/O RENUGOPAL AGED 74 YEARS 169/B, 2ND CROSS BEML LAYOUT TC PALYA KR PURAM, BANGALORE-560 036.

PANDURANGAN R S/O RAJEE AGED 74 YEARS 124, GURAPPA LANE MOTHAPPA PALYA, INDIRA NAGAR BANGALORE-560 038. GOVINDARAJ E (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. CHANDRA G W/O LATE GOVINDARAJ E AGED 69 YEARS 607/4, 8TH CROSS PILLANNA GARDEN 1ST STAGED ST. THOMAS TOWN BANGALORE-560 084. SHANMUGAM T N (SINCE DEAD, BY LR) 70

MRS. DEVAKUMARI S W/O LATE SHANMUGAM T N AGED 64 YEARS 39, HANUMAN NAGAR 4TH MAIN NEW THIPPASANDRA POST BANGALORE-560 075.

GUNDAPPA N S/O NARAYANAPPA A AGED 70 YEARS 1289, 1ST CROSS, 1ST MAIN HAL 3RD STAGED, NEW THIPPASANDRA BANGALORE-560 075.

THYAGARAJAN T S/O THANGAVEL AGED 73 YEARS 50, 20TH CROSS, LAKSHMI PURAM HALASURU, BANGALORE-560 008.

ABDUL JABBAR S/O LATE ABDUL GAFFAR AGED 67 YEARS 2, ABBAIAH GARDEN VANNARPET, BANGALORE-560047.

MEGARAJ M S/O MUNISWAMY AGED 73 YEARS 8/1, 7TH CROSS LINGARAJA PURAM BANGALORE-560 084.

NARAYANA REDDY N V S/O VENKATARAMANA REDDY AGED 72 YEARS 1, 1ST FLOOR, ANKAPPA BLDG. 4TH CROSS, HAL POST BANGALORE-560 017. 71

LOGANATHAN S S/O SUBRAMANI AGED 74 YEARS 36, 20TH CROSS, LAKSHMYPURAM ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008.

THOMAS T M S/O LATE MATHEW K AGED 74 YEARS 2C 314, HRBR III BLOCK KAMMANAHALLI, ST. THOMAS TOWN BANGALORE-560 084.

SHELVA KUMAR T S/O LAKSHMINARAYANA RAO AGED 73 YEARS 5, BELLI MODA, 23RD MAIN 3A CROSS, BTM 3RD STAGED BANGALORE-560 076.

SELVARAJ S S/O SELVANATHAN M AGED 74 YEARS 95/2, VENKATASWAMY LAYOUT SUBBANNA PALYA MS NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 033.

SUNDER RAJ G S/O LATE GOPALA KRISHNAN N AGED 72 YEARS 71/6 R K MUTT ROAD ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008.

RADHAKRISHNAN T S/O THIRUTHANI V R AGED 73 YEARS 15/197, 2ND CROSS ROSE GARDEN COX T0WN BANGALORE-560 005. 72

ANBALAGAN J S/O JAYARAM AGED 72 YEARS 8/1, SHAKTHI NILAYAM, 5TH CROSS KUVEMPU ROAD, VIGNYAN NAGAR BANGALORE -560021.

MRS. SHANTHA KUMARI W/O RAMADASS NAIDU AGED 72 YEARS 16, 10TH CROSS G M PALYA NEW THIPPASANDRA POST BANGALORE-560 075.

RAJU A S S/O SETHURAMACHAR A AGED 73 YEARS FLAT NO. 103, 1ST FLOOR RHEA ORCHID 4TH MAIN OMBR LAYOUT, BANGALORE-560 043.

UDAYAKUMAR R D S/O DEVASAHAYAM R AGED 72 YEARS 65/23, 5TH MAIN, 6TH CROSS MUNISWAMYAPPA LAYOUT MURUGESH PALYA, BANGALORE-560 017.

JOSEPH C S/O CELENE JOSEPH AGED 74 YEARS 198, 2ND CROSS, JAKKASANDRA KORAMANGALA, BANGALORE-560 034.

ANANDAN T S/O LATE THANGAVELU AGED 72 YEARS 188, 2ND CROSS KARIYANNA PALYA LINGARAJAPUAM, BANGALORE-560 084. 73

JOEL D S/O LATE DORAISWAMY P AGED 72 YEARS 1843, 1ST CROSS, RR LAYOUT VIJANAPURA, BANGALORE-560 016.

VENKATESHAN K S/O KRISHNAPPA NAIDU AGED 72 YEARS 815/C, 3RD MAIN E BLOCK 2ND STAGED, RAJAJI NAGAR BANGALORE-560 010.

JOSEPH S S/O SELVANATHAN M AGED 74 YEARS 649, 3RD CROSS 3RD MAIN BEML LAYOUT 2ND PHASE RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

MARAIAH R S/O RAMAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 27 7TH CROSS 3RD MAIN BEML LAYOUT, 1ST STAGED BASAVESHWARANAGAR BANGALORE-560 079.

KANTHARAJA GUPTA K G S/O GOVINDA SETTY AGED 73 YEARS 407, 17TH CROSS 6TH MAIN BASAVESHWARA NAGAR BANGALORE-560 079.

PALANI G S/O GOPAL C AGED 74 YEARS 33, 1ST CROSS MARAGONDANAHALLI MAIN ROAD TC PALYA, BANGALORE-560 036. 74 NAGARAJU G.R. (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SHEELA RANI G S W/O NAGARAJU G R AGED 66 YEARS 245, 11TH CROSS, BASAVESHWAR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 079.

SADANANDA RAO G S/O GOPALAKRISHNAIAH M AGED 72 YEARS G-001, 899, ADITI RESIDENCY 9TH CROSS, 9TH MAIN, 4TH STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 078.

NAGEDSH K NAIK S/O KRISHNA N NAIK AGED 72 YEARS 48 3RD STAGED, BEML LAYOUT R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

SATYANARAYANA BHASKAR T R S/O LATE RAMASWAMY IYER T V AGED 75 YEARS 72, 1ST STAGED BEML LAYOUT 3RD MAIN, 6TH CROSS BANGALORE-560 079.

THYAGARAJU K S/O KRISHNAMURTHY R AGED 71 YEARS A/301, NIPUNA HERITAGED 3RD CROSS, MARUTHI LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 097.

JAYAPAL S S/O SANGIVEE R AGED 71 YEARS 75 22, 4TH CROSS, SIDDARTHA NAGAR BANGALORE-560 053.

SUBRAMANI A G S/O LATE GOVINDA SWAMY A AGED 73 YEARS 1315/A, 8TH MAIN 3RD STAGED RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

RAMU S S/O SEETHAPATHI AGED 74 YEARS 148/A, 5TH MAIN 4TH BLOCK RAJAJINAGAR BANGALORE-560010.

NAGARAJA POTHNIS S/O LATE POTHNIS S H AGED 74 YEARS 197, 4TH MAIN 1ST BLOCK GNANABHARATHI LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 059.

KRISHNA MURTHY K S/O LATE RAMACHANDRAPPA K AGED 73 YEARS 28/7, 20TH MAIN, MARENA HALLI BANGALORE-560 040.

NAGARAJA V M S/O LATE MUNIYAPPA V K AGED 72 YEARS 677, 2ND CROSS, 3RD MAIN RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098 GOPAL K (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. PRABHAVATHI W/O LATE GOPAL K 76 AGED 63 YEARS B65, SUSHRUTHI, BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

VISWANATHAN D S S/O SURAPPA D AGED 75 YEARS MF-4/3 D BLOCK NANDINI LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 096.

JAYARAJE URS H M S/O MUDDARAJ URS P AGED 74 YEARS 398, 7TH CROSS 8TH MAIN 6TH STAGED BEML LAYOUT WHITE FIELD, BANGALORE-560 066.

RAGHUNATH M S/O LATE MUNIRATHNAM REDDY K V AGED 72 YEARS 71, 4TH MAIN, 1ST CROSS SARVABHOWMA NAGAR SUBRAMANYAPURA POST BANGALORE-560 061.

DEVANESAN A S/O ANTHONY T S AGED 73 YEARS 193 C, 9TH CROSS 9TH MAIN 3RD STAGED RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

DEVARAJAN A S/O LATE ARUMUGAM AGED 74 YEARS A6 FFJ, NO. 124 BDA AUSTIN TOWN LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 047.

BASAPPA K S/O LATE UCHAPPA K 77 AGED 73 YEARS 633, “MANGALA” 3RD MAIN 4TH CROSS, 5TH STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

NOOR MOHAMMED G S/O ABDUL GAFFOOR G A AGED 73 YEARS 383, 15TH CROSS 1ST STAGED BANGALORE-560 079.

SATYANANDA G M S/O MAHABALA RAO G AGED 72 YEARS 110, 2ND MAIN, MKS LAYOUT 1ST STAGED, BANGALORE-560 062.

GOPAL K R S/O RAMANUJA IYENGAR K G AGED 73 YEARS 418, 8TH MAIN, AVALAHALLI BDA LAYOUT, BSK 3RD STAGED BANGALORE-560 085.

DAYALAN S L N S/O LATE SAMARAJ K P AGED 72 YEARS 10/4, 7TH A CROSS BANGALORE-560 033.

SRINIVASA K N S/O NARAYANASWAMY K N AGED 73 YEARS 778, 5TH CROSS, 4TH MAIN 3RD STAGED, BEML LAYOUT RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098. PRAKASH RAO D S (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. RAMAMANI S W/O LATE PRAKASH RAO D S 78 AGED 67 YEARS 698A, FLAT 405 SHUBODAYA RESIDENCY, IDEAL HOMES 23RD MAIN, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

KRISHNA MURTHY P S/O LATE NARASHIMLU CHETTY P V AGED 73 YEARS 420, 3RD MAIN, 6TH CROSS MYLASANDRA, BANGALORE-560068.

MUNIRAJA D S/O DASAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 1649, 5TH BLOCK SIR M V LAYOUT, ULLAL BANGALORE-560 110.

SYED JAFFERY S/O SYED YOUSUFF AGED 72 YEARS 9, 7TH CROSS, LAL BAGH FORT RD. KS LANE, BANGALORE-560 004. NAGARAJ N (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. KUMARI G W/O LATE NAGARAJ N AGED 70 YEARS 710, 17TH MAIN, 26TH CROSS JUDICIAL LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 065.

ABDUL RAHOOF S/O MOHAMMED ISMAIL AGED 72 YEARS 30, PUTTAYYANA PALYA 2ND CROSS 26 “B” MAIN 79 JAYANAGAR 9TH BLOCK BANGALORE-560 069.

JAYANTHA B S/O POOVAPPA B AGED 73 YEARS 333, 12TH MAIN, 2ND CROSS 6TH STAGED, BEML LAYOUT THUBARAHALLI, BANGALORE-560 066.

SHYAMA SUNDAR G GURKI S/O LATE GUNDU RAO G AGED 72 YEARS 161 “AASHRAYA” 5TH MAIN R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

KRISHNAMURTHY N S/O LATE NARAYANASWAMY IYER K R AGED 72 YEARS 210, 3RD AVENUE TEACHERS COLONY BANGALORE-560 034. RAMANNA G (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SARASWATHI G W/O LATE RAMANNA G AGED 63 YEARS 1071 11TH CROSS, SWARNA NAGAR K G F-563 122.

CANUTE D’SOUZA S/O LAWRENCE D’ SOUZA AGED 73 YEARS 1677, 5TH STAGED 4TH CROSS RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

SHANKARA RAO J S S/O LATE SRINIVASA MURTHY RAO J S AGED 73 YEARS 80 43, PADMA SHREE, 1ST MAIN TEACHERS LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 097.

SUBRAMANY J S/O JARAM NAIDU C AGED 72 YEARS GOTTIGERE, BANGALORE-560 083.

BHASKAR RAO N S/O LATE NARASIMHA MURTHY AGED 74 YEARS 16, SRINIDHI 4TH CROSS LAKE SHORE GARDEN, TINDLU BANGALORE-560 097.

ANKI REDDY C S/O THIMMA REDDY C AGED 72 YEARS 53, 7TH CROSS, 3RD MAIN A BLOCK AECS LAYOUT, BANGALORE-560 037. NARAYANASWAMY T (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

NAVEEN N S/O LATE NARAYANASWAMY T AGED 34 YEARS 25 1ST BLOCK 1ST MAIN KORAMANGALA, BANGALORE-560 034.

SRINATH D R S/O LATE RAMA IYER D AGED 73 YEARS 604, 21ST MAIN, 4TH T BLOCK JAYANAGAR, BANGALORE-560 011.

RAMA SWAMY D L S/O LAKSHMINARASIMHIAH D AGED 73 YEARS 81 51, 1ST MAIN 2ND CROSS BHUVANESHWARI NAGAR BANGALORE-560 093.

RAJARAMAPPA JADHAV S/O GUDDAPPA JADHAV AGED 73 YEARS 21, 1ST CROSS, 4TH STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

SRIDHARA H V S/O LATE VENKATASUBBAIAH H AGED 75 YEARS 904, 7TH MAIN 3RD STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

NATARAJA R S/O LATE RAMASWAMY AGED 72 YEARS 167, 6TH CROSS, VENKATADRI BASAVESHWARA LAYOUT RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

MARY PHILOMENA LOBO W/O LATE DAVID LOBO AGED 72 YEARS A 405, 24TH MAIN, 2ND SECTOR HSR LAYOUT,BANGALORE-560 107. MURALIDHARA M V (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. BHARGAVI H B W/O LATE MURALIDHARA M V AGED 67 YEARS 183, RAMA VILAS ROAD, KR MOHALLA MYSORE-570 024.

SRINIVASA M S/O LATE MADHAVA RAO 82 AGED 72 YEARS 1044, OM SRI SAI NIVASA 3RD CROSS, 2ND PHASE, RR NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

GOPALA KRISHNA S/O VENKATARAMAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 740, 4TH CROSS, 4TH MAIN RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

RAVINDRANATHAN T K S/O KOCHU KUNJU ACHARY G AGED 73 YEARS 1042, 7TH MAIN, 3RD STAGED RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

AUGUSTINE P FERNANDES S/O LATE PETER FERNANDES AGED 73 YEARS 22-35/6, OLINDA, JYOTHI NAGAR 1ST CROSS, KUDUPU POST MANGALORE-575 028.

NAGARAJU B C S/O CHANNAIAH AGED 70 YEARS 546, 6TH MAIN, 4TH STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

SEETHARAMA SHETTY S S/O LATE MUNDAPPA SHETTY AGED 72 YEARS 1280, 4TH MAIN 3RD STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098. DIWAN N G (SINCE DEAD, BY LR) 83 475 . MRS. SUNANDA DIWAN W/O LATE DIWAN N G AGED 67 YEARS 1693, 5TH STAGED, 6TH CROSS R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

NAGABHUSHANA H N S/O NANJUNDIAH H AGED 73 YEARS 1058, 1ST MAIN, 3RD CROSS R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

SOMA SHANKARA V S/O LATE VENKATASWAMAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 1326, 8TH MAIN, 8TH CROSS 3RD STAGED, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

VENKATAIAH H S/O LATE THIMMIAH AGED 75 YEARS 163, 9TH MAIN, 3RD STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

KRISHNA M S/O MARIYAPPA 503, C BLOCK CQAL LAYOUT SAHAKARA NAGAR BANGALORE-560 092.

BETTAIAH S/O LATE SINGRAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 19, RAJESHWARI NAGAR FRIENDS CIRCLE, LAGGERE BANGALORE-560 058.

NAGARAJ B S/O RAGHURAMA RAO B 84 AGED 72 YEARS 179, “SUDHANVA” 27TH CROSS KHB LAYOUT, KENGERI BANGALORE-560 060.

KRISHNA MURTHY A S/O RAMAVADHANULU A AGED 72 YEARS 1115, 1ST FLOOR, 9TH CROSS ASHOK NAGAR, BSK 1ST STAGED BANGALORE-560 050.

NARASAYYA K S/O LATE SUGARAYYA K AGED 72 YEARS 36, POST OFFICE ROAD VIDYARANYA PURA BANGALORE-560 097.

MOHAMMED HANEF S/O LATE FAKRODDIN AGED 74 YEARS 32/2, MASID MAIN ROAD BISMILLAH NAGAR BANGALORE-560 029.

RAMANJANEYULU E S/O CHINNAPEDDANNA E AGED 72 YEARS 601/A, 2ND CROSS, 3RD MAIN 3RD STAGED, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

SASIDHAR A S S/O SARVOTHAMA RAO A K AGED 72 YEARS 404, 4TH FLOOR SHREENIKETANA APARTMTS GUBBALALA MAIN ROAD BANGALORE-560 062. 85

JOTHI PRAKASH C S S/O SRINIVASAN C V AGED 75 YEARS 355, 1ST CROSS, VINAYAKA NAGAR KR PURAM, BANGALORE-560 036.

ANANTHA SWAMY R S/O LATE RAMA RAO G AGED 73 YEARS 1100, 3RD MAIN 4TH CROSS 5TH STAGED, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

KADAM S A S/O APPAJI IRAPPA KADAM AGED 73 YEARS 768, 4TH MAIN, 5TH CROSS RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098. SYED AHMED (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

SYED AYUB AHMED S/O LATE SYED AHMED AGED 44 YEARS 39, 4TH MAIN, 7TH CROSS NEW GURAPPANA PALYA BANNERGHATTA MAIN ROAD BANGALORE-560 029.

BYRE GOWDA P K S/O KEMPE GOWDA N AGED 71 YEARS 1323, GIRIBYRAVA 2ND CROSS, 4TH MAIN RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

KRISHNA MURTHY R V S/O VENKATACHAR R S AGED 72 YEARS 32, GURU KRUPA, BEML 7TH STAGED 86 MILASANDRA MAIN ROAD BANGALORE-560 059.

PRABHAKARA GUPTA T V S/O LATE VENKATAKRISHNA SHETTY T V AGED 73 YEARS 37, GF 001, SAI CASTLE, 8TH MAIN, RAMANJANEYA NAGAR BANGALORE-560 061.

VASUDEVAN IYER S/O VENKATESHWARA IYER R AGED 72 YEARS 1661, 3RD CROSS, 5TH STAGED 1ST PHASE, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

MALLARAPPA M S/O MAHALINGAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 1747, 7TH CROSS, 7TH MAIN OPP. BUS DEPOT, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

KRISHNARAO SHINDHE S/O BAJI RAO SHINDHE D AGED 73 YEARS 574, 3RD STAGED, BEML LAYOUT RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

NAGARAJAIAH B S/O LATE BASAVAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 481, 6TH PHASE, 1ST STAGED WCR, RAJAJI NAGAR BANGALORE-560 010.

CHANDRASHEKARAN A J S/O LATE JANAKI RAMAN AGED 75 YEARS 87 10 CLARKPET “C” STREET BANGALORE-560 001.

MOHAN RAO H S S/O SUBBA RAO H S AGED 73 YEARS 1070, 3RD CROSS, 6TH MAIN RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098. GOPINATH H V (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. RADHAMANI B K W/O LATE GOPINATH H V AGED 60 YEARS 496, 5TH CROSS, 5TH STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

CHIDAMBARAN N S/O NARAYANA IYER AGED 73 YEARS 58, 'A' BLOCK, 4TH CROSS, R.R. NAGAR BENGALURU - 560 059. SELVARAJ N (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SARASWATHI S W/O LATE SELVARAJ N AGED 60 YEARS 40, JYOTHI NAGAR, 1ST MAIN BANGALORE-560 017.

VENKATARAMANA SETTY S/O LATE JAVARAYA SETTY AGED 72 YEARS 690, 3RD CROSS, 3RD STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

SRINIVASA K S/O KRISHNAMURTHY 88 AGED 74 YEARS 38/1, 9TH CROSS KP AGRAHARA MAGADI ROAD BANGALORE-560 023.

MARIYAIAH S/O BORALINGAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 110, 6TH CROSS, 2ND MAIN JJR NAGAR BANGALORE-560 026.

NANJAPPA A U S/O LATE UTHAIAH A J AGED 72 YEARS 34, NANDA DEEPA LAYOUT R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098

SATHYANARAYANA P S/O PARTHASARATHY NAIDU R AGED 72 YEARS 756, 7TH MAIN 4TH STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

SURYAPRAKASH G R S/O RAMACHANDRAN G K AGED 72 YEARS G 14, C BLOCK, VENKAT WINGS ESTATE, JAKKUR ROAD YELAHANKA OLD TOWN BANGALORE-560 064.

SIDDAPPA K S/O BASETTAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 1676/202, SRI SADAN 1ST STAGED 4TH CROSS 1ST MAIN R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560098.

VIJAYKUMAR S/O VAMAN RAO 89 AGED 52 YEARS 902, CHARTERED BEVERLY HILLS GUBBALALA, SUBRAMANYA PURA BANGALORE-560 061.

SRINIVASA GUPTA D R S/O RAMIAH SETTY D AGED 72 YEARS 480, 10TH MAIN 6TH STAGED THUBARAHALLI BANGALORE-560 066.

PADMANABHA A V S/O LATE VENKATA RAO AGED 74 YEARS 700, 5TH STAGED 2ND PHASE 4TH MAIN, 1ST CROSS R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098. SRINIVAS IYENGAR N (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

BALAKRISHNA N S S/O LATE SRINIVAS IYENGAR N AGED 73 YEARS 449 D 1ST CROSS 1ST PHASE R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

PRATAP P R S/O RAJARAM P S AGED 72 YEARS 191C, 9TH MAIN 8TH CROSS BEML LAYOUT 3RD STAGED RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

VARADACHARYA B M S/O LATE MAYAPPACHAR AGED 72 YEARS 3, 3RD FLOOR, DURGA TEMPLE ROAD VIDYARANYAPURAM BANGALORE-560 097. 90

PRAKASH RAO K N S/O LATE NANJUNDA RAO K R AGED 72 YEARS 108, 1ST CROSS 4TH STAGED RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

VASUDEVA MURTHY K S S/O SUNDARA RAO K AGED 72 YEARS 54, 1ST MAIN 2ND CROSS SURABHI LAYOUT, YELAHANKA BANGALORE-560 064.

NAGARAJAIAH C S/O UDAYA REDDY V R AGED 72 YEARS 302, 1ST CROSS, 8TH MAIN ITPL MAIN ROAD, BANGALORE-560 066. HAROGERI N V (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. DHAKSHAYANI N H W/O LATE HAROGERI N V AGED 64 YEARS ALF 3/9, BDA APARTMENT NANDINI LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 096.

NARASIMHAN M S/O MARAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 481, 3RD CROSS 3RD STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

KRISHNA MURTHY K S/O KANTHARAJA SETTY R AGED 71 YEARS 1678, 4TH CROSS, 5TH STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098. 91

PRABHAKAR L BISURAHALLI S/O LATE LAKSHMANA RAO AGED 74 YEARS 78, 2ND MAIN BANGALORE-560 062.

RAJASEKHARAIAH S V S/O VEERANNA S AGED 73 YEARS 130, 8TH MAIN 3RD STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

VANAMALA RAO M S/O GURURAJA SHARMA M AGED 72 YEARS 5802, 5TH BLOCK 8TH FLOOR NANDI ENCLAVE BANASHANKARI 3RD STAGED BANGALORE-560 085.

SATHYANARAYANA IYER C N S/O NAGARAJA IYER C K AGED 72 YEARS 403, ROYAL HARMONY APARTMT IDEAL HOMES, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

KRISHNA SINGH R S/O LATE RAM SINGH K AGED 72 YEARS 10/30, RAJPUT NIVAS SERENITY LAYOUT SARJAPUR ROAD, BANGALORE-560 035 BABU VISHWANATH (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SHAMALA (LEGAL HEIR/WIFE) W/O LATE BABU VISHWANATH 92 AGED 62 YEARS 441, MANJUNATHA NILAYA 1ST MAIN 3RD CROSS 3RD STAGED RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

RUPAKANTH B P S/O PUTTA LINGAIAH B K AGED 72 YEARS 328, 5TH CROSS, 2ND MAIN 4TH STAGED BEML LAYOUT R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

RAMAN K S S/O SRINIVASAN K G AGED 73 YEARS 111, 1ST CROSS, 3RD MAIN 10TH STAGED, CHANNASANDRA R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

RAMACHANDRA M S/O PRAHLADA RAO M AGED 72 YEARS 994, PAVITRA, 3RD MAIN 7TH BLOCK BSK 3RD STAGED 2ND PHASE, BANGALORE-560 085.

THULASIDAS K S/O KUPPUSWAMY S AGED 74 YEARS 231, 5TH STAGED, 8TH MAIN R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

SUNDARAMURTHY T M S/O LATE MADHAVAN T S AGED 73 YEARS 174, BEML LAYOUT 1ST STAGED 93 8TH MAIN BASAVESHWARNAGAR BANGALORE-560 079.

KARIYAPPA H M S/O LATE MUDLAPPA AGED 73 YEARS 1, 2ND MAIN 4TH CROSS SUBBANNA GARDEN VIJAYA NAGAR BANGALORE-560 040.

PANCHAL M S S/O LATE SIDDAPPA AGED 69 YEARS 3, 2ND FLOOR, BLUE SAPHIRE 7TH CROSS, LBS NAGAR HAL, BANGALORE-560 017.

KRISHNA MURTHY N V S/O LATE VASUDEV RAO N AGED 72 YEARS 178, KRISHNAVENI, 1ST MAIN 4TH STAGED, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

BORAIAH B S/O BORAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 48, 4TH MAIN 10TH CROSS CITB LAYOUT, BAPUJI NAGAR BANGALORE-560 026. RAMACHANDRA T (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SHEELA R W/O LATE RAMACHANDRA T AGED 64 YEARS 18, 3RD STAGED, BEML LAYOUT R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098. 94

MANJUNATHA S S/O SASTRY YCS AGED 73 YEARS 381, 24 B CROSS, 9TH MAIN BSK 2ND STAGED BANGALORE-560 070.

SRINIVASAIAH C S/O CHANNAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 46, 2ND CROSS KUVEMPU EXTN. DEVASANDRA, K R PURAM BANGALORE-560 036.

SRINIVASA GUPTA P V S/O VENKATARATHNAM SETTY P AGED 72 YEARS 120, 7TH MAIN, R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

THIRUGNANA MURTHY N S/O LATE NATESAN V AGED 74 YEARS 592, 2ND CROSS, 2ND MAIN R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

VENKATACHALA REDDY S/O BYAIAHREDDY 112, 4TH MAIN, 4TH BLOCK THYAGARAJA NAGAR BANGALORE-560 028.

DODDE GOWDA S S/O SIDDAIAH AGED 73 YEARS 844, 9TH MAIN 4TH STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098. 95

MRS.MANOHARAMMA W/O NAGARAJ AGED 65 YEARS 491/302, 4TH CROSS, 3RD STAGED R.R. NAGAR BENGALURU-560 098.

HONNANNA S/O LAKSHMINARAYAN RAO P AGED 72 YEARS 884, 9TH CROSS, 3RD STAGED R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

ASWATHANARAYANA N R S/O LATE RAMASWAMIAH N AGED 72 YEARS 247, 7TH MAIN 3RD STAGED R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

JAGADISH PRASAD V S/O VEERAPPA H M AGED 71 YEARS 590, 1ST CROSS 3RD MAIN BEML 5TH STAGED, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

SHIVASHANKARAPPA R S/O RAJASHEKARAIAH S AGED 72 YEARS 27, 1ST CROSS, OLD KAVIKA LAYOUT MYSORE ROAD, BANGALORE-560 026.

SUBBANNA S S/O SESHAGIRI RAO H S AGED 72 YEARS 607/608, 4TH MAIN, 6TH CROSS R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098. 96 PARASHIVA MURTHY C (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. VIJAYAMBA C W/O LATE PARASHIVA MURTHY C AGED 62 YEARS 1063, 3RD CROSS, 6TH MAIN BEML 3RD STAGED, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

RAVINDRANATH S S/O SURAPPA D 856, 61ST CROSS KUMARASWAMY LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 111.

VENKATARAMANA SWAMY S/O NAGAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 834, 8TH MAIN 4TH STAGED RR NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

VITTAL RAO S/O LATE VENKOBA RAO P AGED 72 YEARS 22, SANJEEVAPPA LAYOUT IDGHA ROAD, VARTHUR BANGALORE-560 087. MARIYEE GOWDA (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. BHAGYA RATHNA C W/O LATE MARIYEE GOWDA AGED 64 YEARS 197, SAIRAM KRUPA, 4TH STAGED R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098. NAGARAJA N 97 (SINCE DEAD BY LRS MRS)

KASTHURIRAJ W/O LATE NAGARAJA N AGED 64 YEARS 1302, 5TH CROSS, 5TH MAIN R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

DHAPALAPUR S V S/O VEERABHADRAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 912, IST MAIN, 4TH CROSS 5TH STAGED, R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098.

CHIKKAMUNIAPPA S/O CHIKKANNA AGED 73 YEARS GANGAPURA VIL TAVAREKERE POST HOSAKOTE TALUK-562 130.

NANJEGOWDA H K S/O KEMPAIAH C AGED 72 YEARS OPP GOVT SCHOOL BELIJAJI ROAD, HESARAGHATTA BANGALORE-560 088. ELANGARAJ S (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. RAMANI R W/O LATE ELANGARAJ S AGED 49 YEARS 14, 2ND MAIN, SONENAHALLI VIVEK NAGAR BANGALORE-560 047. 98

SREEKANTACHAR Y V S/O LATE VEERABHADRACHAR 1539, IST CROSS, 5TH MAIN 5TH STAGED, BEML LAYOUT R R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 098.

GOVINDAPPA G S/O GOPALAPPA AGED 71 YEARS 78/1, 2ND FLOOR KORAMANGALA 6TH BLOCK BANGALORE-560 095.

RANGANATH GHATIKAR S/O GOVINDA RAO GHATIKAR AGED 72 YEARS 286, 12TH MAIN, 3RD STAGED R R NAGAR BANGALORE-560 098. SHAMBANNA S (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. PRABHAVATHI S W/O LATE SHAMBANNA S AGED 67 YEARS 1374, 2ND CROSS J C ROAD VIJAYANAGAR BANGARPET-563 114.

HANUMANTHE GOWDA B S/O BASAPPA AGED 71 YEARS 272, SREE RAMA TEMPLE ANDERSONPET K G F -563 113.

XAVIER A S/O ANTHONYSAMY AGED 71 YEARS 99 123A, CRAWFORD COLONY TIRUCHIRAPALLI-620 012.

VIJAYAN A S/O AYYAVOO THEVAR AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS A 19, BHARATH NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST K G F-563 115.

AIYAPPA K A S/O ACHAPPA K M AGED 73 YEARS 8, 2ND MAIN ROAD H P NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST KGF-563 115.

BELAPUR H S S/O BELAPUR S B AGED 72 YEARS 77/3, RENUKA NILAYA ASHRAM ROAD, PAREKH NAGAR VIJAYAPUR-586 105.

SAIBANNA S/O SHARANAPPA AGED 72 YEARS C/O ARALAGUNDAGI NILAYA OPP FCI GODOWN K H B COLONY KALIKERI ROAD SINDAGI VIJAYAPURA DISTRICT-586 128.

KUTTAPPAN M S/O MADHAVAN PILLA AGED 73 YEARS 50/7, FLATE NO.1, KARTHYAYANI HENNUR MAIN ROAD GUBBI CROSS, BANGALORE-560 077. 100

GOVINDAN C S/O LATE NAIR V S AGED 72 YEARS C/O PRAMODH G 28/S1-PANCHA TARA K V R HOUSING NAIDU LAYOUT JALAHALLI EAST BENGALURU-560 014.

HARI PRASAD K A S/O ANANTHARAMAIAH K S AGED 72 YEARS 608, 4TH MAIN, 4TH CROSS E AND F BLOCK RAMAKRISHNA NAGAR MYSORE-570 023.

RAMU D S/O LATE DORAI SWAMY AGED 72 YEARS NEW ESHWARA TEMPLE STREET OORGAUMPET K G F-563 121. SHAMBANNA S (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

UMESHWARA RAO S S/O LATE SRINIVASA RAO A AGED 46 YEARS 832, 2ND CROSS SWARNA NAGAR ROBERTSONPET K G F -563 122.

MOHANRAJ P S/O PACHAPPA P AGED 72 YEARS 544, ESHWAR KOVIL STREET SOMESHWARA BLOCK MANJUNATH NAGAR 101 OORGAUMPET POST KGF-563 121. SHAMBANNA S (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS SARASWATHI V W/O LATE VASUDEVAN M K AGED 68 YEARS 655, INDU ILLAM, SUBHASH NAGAR ROBERTSONPET K G F -563 122.

SUBBALAKSHMI G D/O VEERA KUMAR N AGED 72 YEARS 951, 7TH CROSS SWARNA NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

NAGARAJA RAO K R S/O LATE RAMACHANDRA RAO K AGED 73 YEARS C/O K S KISHORE NO.301 3RD FLOOR, SAIVARENYA PARK VIEW 9TH MAIN, 6TH CROSS, THURAHALLI BANGALORE-560 061.

SRINIVASA P V S/O VENKATASUBBAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 31, 2ND CROSS, SIMHADRI FCI LAYOUT DEEPANJALI NAGAR BANGALORE-560 026. SHAIK MOHIDEEN (SINCE DEAD BY LR) 102

MRS. SAIBUNNISA S W/O LATE SHAIK MOHIDEEN AGED 61 YEARS 41/16, SASTHIRAM BALUSAMY IYER STREET NAGAL NAGAR ADIYANUTHU DINDIGUL-624 008.

YESHVANTHA PAI T S/O SERVOTHAMA PAI T AGED 73 YEARS 15, NEHRU PARK ROBERTSONPET K G F-563 122.

SATHYANARAYANA IYER S S/O SREENIVASA IYER G N AGED 73 YEARS 780, KAREKALLAHALLI IDAGUR ROAD GOWRIBIDNUR-572 213.

KOPPAL R K S/O KRISHNA Y KOPPAL AGED 72 YEARS C-29/30, KRISHNA COLONY SAIFULROAD BIJAPUR ROAD SHOLAPUR-413 002.

SYED ABDUL QADEER S/O SYED ABDUL SALAM AGED 73 YEARS 406, BHAVARILAL PET ROBERTSONPET, KGF-563 122. ABDUL KHUDUS (SINCE DEAD BY LR )

MRS. RIYAZUNISA W/O LATE ABDUL KHUDUS 103 AGED 61 YEARS 203, CORNOATION ROAD BANGARPET-563 114.

ADINARAYANAN R S/O RAMASWAMY AGED 74 YEARS 93, B M ROAD, ASHOK NAGAR OORGAUM POST, K G F -563 120.

SAMPATH KUMAR S S/O SURYANARAYANA RAO V S AGED 74 YEARS 11, GROUND FLOOR ANJANADRI, 2ND BLOCK 4TH CROSS, WEST END PARK CHIKKALASANDRA BANGALORE-560 061.

ADINARAYANA S/O ADAIAH AGED 73 YEARS 87, LEELAVATHI NIVAS 6TH CROSS KUVEMPU NAGAR DASARAHOSA HALLI BANGARPET TALUK-563 114.

RAMU S S/O SUNDER RAJ AGED 72 YEARS 1041, 10TH CROSS, SWARNA NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F-563 122.

VENUGOPAL S S/O SWAMI KANNU AGED 74 YEARS 44, KANTHI NIVAS 3RD CROSS SUMATHINAGAR R PET, K G F-563 122. 104

RAJAN K AGED 73 YEWARS 1153/1, AKSHYA CHOVVA TEMPLE SOUTH GATE MELE CHOVVA CHOVVA POST KANNUR-670 007.

SHANKARANA NARAYANAN K N S/O CHINNAN NAIR P AGED 73 YEARS SOUGANDHIKA HOUSE VADAKKUMMURI IRUMBUZHI POST MALAPPURAM DISTRICT KERALA-676 305.

AMBAJI RAJOLKAR S/O HUSENI AGED 75 YEARS 10C, NEW GHATGE LAYOUT KALBURGI-585 103.

SUNNY M I S/O ITTIACHAN AGED 74 YEARS ALAPAT MECHERI HOUSE VALAPAD P O TRICHUR-680 567.

SHARBUDEEN A S/O ABDUL GANI AGED 73 YEARS 10/219, THARAKU THARU MUKAMDHU PATTAM PERAMBALUR-621 212.

GOPALAKRISHNAN C S/O NAMBIAR P K K AGED 74 YEARS C P V 933, SREEMAD 105 NEAR SHIVA TEMPLE VILAYANKODE KANNUR DT-670 504.

MAHIMAIDOSS T S/O THANGARAJ P S AGED 74 YEARS 638, AMRITHA HARSHINI 6TH CROSS, R PET KGF-563 122.

KESAVAN R S/O RAMANJI AGED 75 YEARS 3530, 3RD MAIN, AMARAVATHI NAGAR BANGARPET-563 112.

PANDURANGAPPA G S/O GOVINDAPPA K H AGED 73 YEARS 305, ATZ SPLENDOUR APARTMENTS THANISANDRA BANGALORE-560 064.

GURUSWAMY L S/O LOGANATHAN AGED 73 YEARS DK HALLI POST KUVEMPUNAGAR BANGARPET-563 162. SUBRAMONEY P (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS VAIJAYANTHI W/O LATE SUBRAMONEY P AGED 62 YEARS 161, 2ND BLOCK, ANDERSONPET K G F -563 113. SERALATHAN K (SINCE DEAD BY LR) 106

MRS. KIRUBAVATHY SUSEELA S W/O LATE SERALATHAN K AGED 71 YEARS 651/E19, SUSEELA ILLAM PULIYENDRAN LAYOUT DASARAHOSAHALLI BANGARPET TALUK.

GOVINDA RAJU R S/O RENGAIAH RAJU R M AGED 71 YEARS 970, 8TH CROSS, SWARNA NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563 122. KHANDEKAR G N (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. SHANTHA W/O LATE KHANDEKAR G N AGED 67 YEARS 751, 2ND STAGED BOGADI.

SYED HYDER S/O IBRAHIM M S AGED 71 YEARS 21, 2ND MAIN, 2ND CROSS NEAR KABIR COLLEGE MATADAHALLI, R T NAGAR POST BANGALORE. LOGANATHAN A (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. KALA A W/O LOGANATHAN A AGED 65 YEARS 103, 1ST CROSS GOWTHAM NAGAR K G F - 563 122. 107

CHIKRAPPA K S/O REVANASIDDAPPA AGED 74 YEARS 1857/32, 3RD MAIN SWAMI VIVEKANANDA EXTN. DAVANAGEDRE - 577 005. KEMPE GOWDA K (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. GOWRAMMA W/O LATE KEMPE GOWDA K AGED 69 YEARS 374, 7TH CROSS GANESHPURAM ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563 122. BADIGER S E (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. VIJAYALAKSHMI BADIGER W/O BADIGER S E AGED 61 YEARS C/O MOUNESH S BADIGER VIJAYALAKSHMI KRUPA HATTARAGEDRI ONI HAVERI-581 110.

HEMAVATHY D/O KRISHNAMURTHY AGED 69 YEARS 281, SOUDHAMINI NILAYA 12TH MAIN 2ND CROSS DASARAHOSAHALLI BANGARAPET-563 114.

GOVINDARAJ R S/O RAJAGOPAL A M AGED 73 YEARS 132/7, BEHIND KEB 108 DANDU ROAD BANGARPET - 563 114. LAWRENCE DYAS L.C. (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. MARY STELLA DYAS W/O LATE LAWRENCE DYAS L.C. AGED 73 YEARS 1115, 7TH CROSS, C BLOCK PIPE LINE ROAD, ROBERTSONPET KOLAR GOLD FIELDS -563 122.

ETHURAJAN D S/O DEVARAJ AGED 73 YEARS 9, OLD ORIENTAL LINE COROMANDEL POST K G F - 563 118.

SUSAINATHAN M S/O MANIKYAM AGED 74 YEARS 700, CHAMARAJA NAGAR MUSKAM ROAD ANDERSONPET, K G F -563 113.

MURUGEPPA S/O GUNDAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 365, SHIVA NILAYA 3RD MAIN AMARAVATHI BANGARPET - 563 114.

SHAIK AHMED S/O MOHAMED YOUSUF AGED 72 YEARS 57, MUNI GOWDA GARDEN NEELASANDRA, VIVEK NAGAR BANGALORE-560 047. 109

VENU NAIR K S/O CHANDU NAIR AGED 73 YEARS NANDANAM, ORAVINGAL THAZE ARIKKULAM KOILANDY KOZHIKODE DT., KERALA - 673 517.

RAJAGOPAL R S/O MUNIYAPPA R A AGED 72 YEARS DODDAVOLAGAMADI BANGARPET-563 120.

NATARAJA K R S/O RUDRAPPA K AGED 74 YEARS 35, GAYATHRI LAYOUT KARAHALLI VILLAGED BANGARPET - 563 114.

ELLAPPA G S/O GUNDAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 227, SRI RAMA NAGAR OORGAUMPET, K G F - 563 121.

RAMARAJ M S/O LATE MURUGIAH S AGED 73 YEARS CHARVI ILLAM 10TH MAIN 2ND CROSS DASARAHOSA HALLI DK HALLI POST, BANGARPET TK. PRASAD (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. NEELAMMA P W/O LATE PRASAD AGED 62 YEARS 110 124, KUVEMPU NAGAR DASARAHOSAHALLI, BANGARPET-563 112.

RAJAGOPAL C S/O CHINNAPPA AGED 72 YEARS I SANDRA MITTUR KAMMASANDRA POST VIA OORGAUMPET, KGF -563 121.

RAJNIKANTH B S/O LATE BOJI CHANDRAN T AGED 74 YEARS 24, HENRY’S ERODE LANE COROMANDEL, K G F - 563 118.

BHASKARAN G S/O GOPAL NAIDU M AGED 73 YEARS 2/719H2, ILLUPPAI KUDI MAIN ROAD ILLUPPAI KUDI EAST - 630 202.

ANANDAN K S/O KRISHNAN S 1885, BODHI NILAYAM CORONATION TOWN R PET KOLAR GOLD FIELDS - 563 122.

MARIAPPAN S S/O SUBBAREDDY S AGED 73 YEARS B 3-A-1, GOLDEN FORTUNE NOLAMBUR, MOGAPPAIR WEST CHENNAI - 600 107.

ABDUL RAHAMAN S/O ABOOBAKER AGED 73 YEARS 10 LOURD NAGAR ANDERSONPET, K G F - 563 113. 111

SEGARAN G S/O GOVINDARAJ AGED 74 YEARS 13, HENRY’S III M BLOCK COROMANDEL, K G F – 563 118.

ROBERT CLIVE P W S/O PETER WILLIAM AGED 74 YEARS 110, NEW NO.1393 ASHOK NAGAR OORGAUM POST, K G F - 563 121. SUBRAMANIAM R (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. ANJALI W/O LATE SUBRAMANIAM R AGED 62 YEARS 542, 2ND BLOCK, 9TH MAIN RAJAJINAGAR BENGALURU - 560 010. SUNDAR RAJAN K (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SELVI S W/O SUNDAR RAJAN K AGED 65 YEARS 39, M L BLOCK OORGAUM, K G F - 563 120.

LURDHU V S/O VIJAYARANGAM AGED 73 YEARS 4, 1ST CROSS, AISHWARYA LAYOUT MG HALLI MAIN ROAD BANGALORE - 560 036. 112 MOHANDAS A (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. VISHALAKSHI MOHANDAS W/O LATE MOHANDAS A AGED 65 YEARS 85, CHAITANYA PURAM DK HALLI ROAD BEML NAGAR, K G F - 563 115.

CHANDRASAGARAN D S/O DHANARAJ P AGED 72 YEARS 21, 3RD CROSS, KALKERE MAIN ROAD SIR M V NAGAR, RAMAMURTHY NAGAR BANGALORE-560 016. VIJAYANAND NAIK (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. PADMAVATI VIJAYANAND NAIK W/O LATE VIJAYANAND NAIK AGED 74 YEARS 15, 10TH MAIN, 14TH CROSS MARUTHI NAGAR NEW THIPPASANDRA BANGALORE - 560 075.

MUNIYANDI K S/O KUNCHI AGED 74 YEARS 65, LENIN STREET THILLAI NAGAR THANJAVUR, TAMIL NADU – 620 018.

MADHAVAN K S/O KUPPUSWAMY AGED 72 YEARS 7/86, ETTIYAMMAN KOIL STREET ETTIAPURAM VIL, 113 CHENNAI – 600 132.

ATHAULLA SHARIFF S/O AHAMEDULLA SHARIFF AGED 72 YEARS 15 MASJID-E-AZAM STREET JALEEL LAYOUT ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563 122.

VENKATESHA T S/O THIMMAIAH AGED 73 YEARS ELESANDRA VILLAGED AND PO BUDIKOTE HOBLI BANGARPET TALUK – 563 112.

MUNIYAPPA M R S/O LATE RAMAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 99, 2ND CROSS, BEHIND CANARA BANK VASANTH NAGAR, K G F-563 115.

CHINNADORAI R S/O RAJA GEMBEERAM I AGED 74 YEARS 243, 2ND MAIN 5TH CROSS AMARAVATHI LAYOUT BANGARPET - 563 114.

RAJAPPAN S S/O MADHAVAN V AGED 74 YEARS CMC-8/370A, CHERTALA-688 524.

VENKATARAVANAPPA K S/O KRISHNAIAH AGED 74 YEARS 295, 10TH MAIN, KUVEMPU NAGAR DK HALLI, BANGARPET - 563 162. 114

NARAYANAPPA A S/O APPAIAH AGED 72 YEARS 66, SRI MURALI NILAYA VASANTHA NAGAR B E M L NAGAR POST K G F - 563 115.

KIRUBAI NESAN Y S/O LATE YESU DOSS M AGED 72 YEARS NEAR L M CHOULTRY OORGAUMPET POST K G F - 563 121. PANKAJAKSHAN P V (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. ROHINI PANKAJAKSHAN W/O LATE PANKAJAKSHAN P V AGED 66 YEARS ROHINI VILLA, PANCHAYATH ROAD NEAR PALOTTU KAVU AZHIKODE – 670 009 KANNUR, KERALA.

ANANTHA PADMANABHA RAO L S/O LAKSHMINARAYANA RAO P S AGED 74 YEARS C/O SURESH P K 165/1, KRISHNA, VIJAYANAGAR BEML NAGAR, K G F - 563 115.

SOMAPPA M S/O RUDRAPPA AGED 74 YEARS FLAT NO. 7-B-206 GERANUM BLOCK 101, IVRC ROAD, BANGALORE - 560 064. 115 NANJUNDA B W (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. SEETHAMMA B N W/O LATE NANJUNDA B W AGED 61 YEARS 23, 7TH CROSS, 3RD BLOCK VISHWAPRIYA NAGAR BEGUR ROAD, BANGALORE-560 068.

CHANGAPPA K K S/O KALAPPA K D AGED 71 YEARS NELAJI VILLAGED AND POST KODAGU DISTRICT-571 235.

SUBRAMANYACHARY N V S/O VENKATARAMANACHARY AGED 72 YEARS PRASHANTHA NAGARA S G KOTE BANGARPET TALUK-563 114.

PAPPANNA C S/O CHINNA BIDDAPPA AGED 72 YEARS 28, MANJUNATH NAGAR OORGAUMPET, K G F - 563 120. DHAKSHINA MURTHY (SINCE DEAD, BY LR)

MRS. DHANALAKSHMI W/O LATE DHAKSHINA MURTHY AGED 59 YEARS 147, HENRY’S 2ND LINE COROMANDEL POST K G F - 563 118.

VIJAYAN PILLAI V K S/O KESAVA PILLAI 116 AGED 73 YEARS 865, VADAKKEPUTHAN VEEDU ANAYADI POST KOLLAM - 690 561.

BAPU SINNGH S/O BHAVANI SINGH AGED 71 YEARS 111, 6TH MAIN 3RD CROSS DASARAHOSAHALLI BANGARPET TK. - 563 112.

RAMDASS M S/O MUNISWAMY AGED 72 YEARS, 1074/1 11TH CROSS SAVIPRABHU NILAYA SWARNA NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, K G F -563 122. KRISHNAN P (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. RANI K W/O LATE KRISHNAN P AGED 69 YEARS 1033 RK NIVAS SWARNA NAGAR, K G F-563 122. REVANSIDDAPPA (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. PARVATHI W/O LATE REVANSIDDAPPA AGED 69 YEARS, 343, NEAR RAMAR TEMPLE OORGAUMPET, K G F - 563 120. 117 VENKAYYA K (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

GOVINDAMMA K W/O VENKAYYA K AGED 63 YEARS, 893, 5TH CROSS SWARNA NAGAR ROBERSONPET K G F – 563 122. ALWAR NAIDU G (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. KRISHNAVENI W/O LATE ALWAR NAIDU G AGED 62 YEARS, 12, 4TH CROSS, KHB COLONY PC EXTN., KOLAR-563 101. ALFRED D’SOUZA (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. VERONICA D’SOUZA W/O LATE ALFRED D‘SOUZA AGED 57 YEARS, 54, 2ND CROSS, 2ND MAIN BALAJI LAYOUT AGARA MAIN RD BANGALORE-560 043.

GURU PRASAD N G S/O NARASIMHA MURTHY J H AGED 72 YEARS, SUPRABHATHA, 2ND MAIN 7TH A CROSS AMARAVATHI NAGAR BANGARPET-563 114. SRINIVAS P (SINCE DEAD BY LR) 118

SMT. NARAYANAMMA M N W/O LATE SRINIVAS P AGED 69 YEARS, 128 6TH CROSS VIJAYA NAGAR BEML NAGAR K G F -563 115.

SRINIVASACHARY M AGED 72 YEARS, 16, SRI SAPTHAGIRI NIVAS 2ND CROSS VIJAYANAGAR BEML NAGAR POST KOLAR GOLD FIELDS -563 115.

MOHAMMED SIRAJUDDIN S/O MOHAMMED KHALEELUDDIN AGED 72 YEARS, 372, BOWRILALPET ROBERTSONPET K G F-563 122. VENKATARAMANAPPA M (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. VENKATAMMA W/O LATE VENKATARAMANAPPA M AGED 69 YEARS, MADAMUTHANAHALLI HUNUKUNDA POST BANGARPET TALUK-563 162. KURDIKERI B S (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. ANUSUYA B K W/O LATE KURDIKERI B S AGED 66 YEARS, 243, 1ST BLOCK 119 2ND STAGED BANGALORE -560 072. MUNIYANAKOPPA Y V (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. SHANTHA W/O LATE MUNIYANAKOPPA Y V AGED 60 YEARS, RENUKA NILAYA, 2ND MAIN 7TH A CROSS AMARAVATHI LAYOUT BANGARPET-563 114. SREERAMA N (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. VIJAYALAKSHMI N S W/O LATE SREERAMA N AGED 62 YEARS 27, K R NIVAS, SIR M V NAGAR BEML NAGAR, KGF-563 115.

NARASIMHAN M V S/O VENKATARAMANAIAH M AGED 75 YEARS, NO.269, WARD NO.22, 8TH CROSS SWARNA NAGAR, ROBERTSONPET KOLAR GOLD FIELDS -563 115.

SATYANARAYANA RAO B S/O LATE BHEEM RAO K AGED 75 YEARS F-112, NANDANA GREENS OMESWARA LAYOUTS BILEKAHALLI BENGALURU-570 076. 120

SATHYANARAYANA BH S/O HANUMANTHAIAH B V AGED 75 YEARS, #27, 3RD CROSS, 4TH “A” MAIN BASAVANAPURA MAIN ROAD K R PURAM, BENGALURU-560 036.

SURYAPRAKASH A S/O ANANTHAIAH B AGED 70 YEARS, #350, 8TH MAIN, 5TH STAGED BEML LAYOUT, RR NAGAR BENGALURU-560 098. SHIVAKUMAR (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. NAGARATHNA S W/O SHIVAKUMAR V AGED 67 YEARS, NO.2194, NEAR WATER TANK VIVEKANANDA NAGARA BANGARPET-563 114.

MRS. JAGATHEESAN M S/O MUNISWAMY K AGED 73 YEARS, IRUDAYAPURAM ROBERTSONPET KGF-563 122. BALAKRISHNAN C (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

KANCHANA P W/O LATE BALAKRISHNAN C AGED 66 YEARS, NO.35, 5TH CROSS HP NAGAR, 121 BEML NAGAR POST KGF-563 115. MADHAVAN P (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MRS. PUNGODHI W/O MADHAVAN P AGED 65 YEARS, NO.96 SRIRAM NAGAR OORGUAMPET EXTENSION KGF-563 121.

PRAGASAM G S/O GOVINDA SWAMY AGED 74 YEARS, NO.21, DHAWIN TRIRUSON COTTAGED NEAR DOUBLE CHURCH 10TH CROSS, A NARAYANAPURA BENGALURU-560 016.

JANET D S/O ABSOLOME C AGED 73 YEARS, NO.230, KRISHNAGIRI LINE MARIKUPPAM POST KOLAR GOLD FIELDS -563 119.

THIMMARAJU G R S/O RAMAIAH G AGED 65 YEARS, NO.51, 23 MAIN PIPELINE KURUBARAHALLI MAHALAKSHMIPURAM LAYOUT BENGALURU-560 096. RAMACHANDRA T (SINCE DEAD BY LR) 122

LAKSHMI R D/O LATE RAMACHANDRA T AGED 39 YEARS, NO.18, BEML LAYOUT 3RD STAGED, RR NAGAR BENGALURU-560 098. SATYA MOORTHY R (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

KANTHIAMMAL V W/O SATYA MOORTHY R AGED 68 YEARS, NO.1125, 11TH ‘B’ CROSS SWARNA NAGAR ROBERTSONPET, KGF-563 113.

HABIBULLA R S/O RAHMATHULLA AGED 73 YEARS, NO.2230, KATHIRAVAN NAGAR THIRUVALLUVAR AVENUE MANACHALANNUR TALUK NO.1 TOLGATE TRICHY TAMIL NADU-621 216.

MADHU M S/O SANGEEVIAH LATE AGED 74 YEARS, NO.216, 5TH MAIN 1ST CROSS 2ND STAGED KUMARASWAMY LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 078.

CHANDRAN M S/O MUNISWAMY AGED 74 YEARS, NO.27 VASANTHA NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST KGF-563 115. 123

PARATHASARATHY G S/O GOVINDASWAMY AGED 73 YEARS, 102, 1ST FLOOR ROYAL SPRING APARTMENT MOHAN NAGAR SOCIETY BANER PUNE MAHARASHTRA-411045.

HUTCHAPPA S/O MUNISWAMY AGED 74 YEARS, 252, 2TH CROSS DASARAHOSAHALLI DK HALLI POST, KGF 563 114. SIDDAPPA (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

MANJULA Y M W/O LATE SIDDAPPA AGED 59 YEARS 848, 9TH MAIN 4TH STAGED RR NAGAR BENGALURU - 560098 SYED NAYEEMULLASHA HUSSAINI (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

SYED SALEEM HUSSAINI S/O SYED NAYEEMULLASHA HUSSAINI AGED 33 YEARS, 4 1ST CROSS VIJAY NAGAR BEML NAGAR POST KGF-563 115. NARASIMHAN C (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

KASTURI BAI W/O NARASIMHAN C 124 AGED 73 YEARS, C N K BUILDING B M ROAD ROBERTSONPET KGF-563122. MD.LATEEFUDDIN (SINCE DEAD BY LR)

AMEERUNNISA BEGUM W/O. MD. LATEEFUDDIN AGED 60 YEARS, 36, 2ND CROSS SILVER SPRING ROAD RAGAVENDRA LAYOUT MARATHAHALLI BANGALORE-560 037.

ASWATHNARAYANA S/O AHOBALA SASTRY AGED 74 YEARS, NO.17/A, LAXMANAPPA GARDEN 4TH MAIN, 5TH CROSS BANASHANKARI 3RD STAGED BANGALORE - 560008

RAMACHANDRA MR S/O RANGAIAH AGED 73 YEARS, NO.190, 3RD CROSS KEMPEGOWDA NAGARA BYANDARAHALLI BANGALORE-560 091. ...PETITIONERS (BY SRI. S N MURTHY, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI. SOMASHEKAR, ADVOCATE ) AND: 1 . THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC ENTERPRISES 125 (MINISTRY OF FINANCE) PUBLIC ENTERPRISES BHAVAN BLOCK NO.14 ,CGO COMPLEX LODHI ROAD ,NEW DELHI-110 003. 2 . THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF DEFENCE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENCE PRODUCTION GOVERNMENT OF INDIA , ROOM NO.9A, SOUTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI-110 011. 3 . THE CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR BEML LIMITED BEML SOUDHA S R NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 027. (BY SRI SUSHAL TIWARI N, ADVCOATE FOR R1 & R2: SRI S S NAGANAND, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SMT. SUMANA NAGANAND, ADVCOATE FOR R3 [VC]) … RESPONDENTS THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT THE PETITIONERS ARE ENTITLED TO GRATUITY ON THE BASIS OF CEILING LIMIT OF RS.10,00,000/- AND FOR A DIRECTION TO THE RESPONDENT NO.3 TO CALCULATE THE GRATUITY PAYABLE TO THE PETITIONERS ON A CEILING OF RS.10,000/- AND PAY THE DIFFERENTIAL AMOUNT TO THE PETITIONERS ALONG WITH INTEREST AT 8.5 PERCENT INTEREST PER ANNUM FROM THE DATE GRATUITY WAS PAID TREATING RS.3,50,000/- AS CEILING, TILL DATE OF PAYMENT, ETC. THIS WRIT PETITION, HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR ORDERS ON 20.01.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT, THIS DAY, THE COURT, MADE THE FOLLOWING: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD 126 CAV JUDGMENT This writ petition is filed under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution of India, seeking the following relief:

A writ in the nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ or order declaring that the petitioners are entitled to gratuity on the basis of ceiling limit of Rs.10,00,000 and for a direction to the third respondent to calculate the gratuity payable to the petitioners on a ceiling of Rs.10,00,000 and pay the differential amount to the petitioners along with interest at 8.5% per annum from the date gratuity was paid treating Rs.3,50,000/- as ceiling, till date of payment.

The case of the petitioners is that, the first petitioner is an Association registered under the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960 and petitioner Nos. 2 to 694 are retired workmen of B.E.M.L., Bengaluru. They retired during the period from 01.01.2007 to 23.05.2010. The salary structure of these workmen was governed by settlements entered into between the Management and the workmen under the provisions of the Industrial 127 Disputes Act, 1947 (for short, the “ID Act”). At the time of retirement, the petitioners–workmen were paid gratuity up to a maximum amount of Rs.3,50,000/- in terms of the provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (for short, ‘1972 Act’).

On 26.11.2008, the Central Government issued an Office Memorandum directing that the ceiling on gratuity payable to Executives and non- unionized Supervisors of Central Public Sector Enterprises be enhanced to Rs.10.00 lakhs with effect from 01.01.2007. On the basis of the said Office Memorandum, notwithstanding the fact that the 1972 Act provides for a maximum gratuity of Rs.3,50,000/-, officers of HAL, which is a Public Sector Undertaking under the Ministry of Defence, were granted gratuity up to Rs.10.00 lakhs.

Since the officers - ex-employees of BEML were not extended the same benefit, they approached 128 this Court by filing W.P.Nos.36530–36708/2016 C/w.W.P.No.53708/2013. This Court, by order dated

11.01.2019, disposed of the writ petitions. Aggrieved by the said order of the learned Single Judge, the retired officers of BEML filed W.A.No.443/2019 C/w. W.P.No.23629/2019. A Division Bench of this Court disposed of the writ appeal on 05.03.2021, directing BEML to enhance the gratuity payable to the retired officers of BEML to the ceiling limit of Rs.10.00 lakhs. That order was challenged before the Apex Court in SLP(C) Nos.16004-16005/2021. The Apex Court confirmed the order passed by the Division Bench dated

05.03.2021. Thereafter, the benefit was extended to the officers of the BEML establishment. In meantime, the retired workmen of the BEML also submitted representations seeking enhancement of gratuity from Rs.3.5 lakhs to Rs.10.00 lakhs for the period from 01.01.2007 to 23.05.2010. However, the same benefit was not granted to the petitioners, and 129 their representations remain unconsidered. Hence, the petitioners are before this Court.

Sri S.N.Murthy, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners raised the following contentions: (i) Firstly, even though the 1972 Act has fixed the ceiling limit of Rs.3.5 lakhs in respect of officers, the Ministry of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises, Department of Public Enterprises issued certain guidelines regarding the salaries of officers and revision of pay scales with effect from 01.01.2007, and also issued guidelines enhancing the ceiling limit for payment of gratuity to Rs.10.00 lakhs with effect from 01.01.2007. Pursuant to the guidelines issued by the Ministry of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises, HAL enhanced the gratuity payable to its employees. On similar lines, the third respondent– establishment enhanced the gratuity payable to the 130 retired officers of the third respondent–Public Sector Limited, based on the directions issued by a Division Bench of this Court in W.A. No.443/2019.

449. (vii) Seventhly, while construing Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India, in the light of the Preamble and Article 39(d) of the Constitution of India, the 134 principle of “equal pay for equal work” is applicable to cases where different scales of pay are prescribed for identical work under the same employer. In support of this contention, reliance is placed on the judgment of the Apex Court in RANDHIR SINGH VS. UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS, reported in (1982) 1 SCC 618. Hence, the petitioner seeks for allowing of the writ petition.

Per contra, Sri S.S.Naganand, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents, raised the following contentions: (i) Firstly, petitioner Nos.2 to 694 retired during the period from 01.01.2007 to 23.05.2010. After a lapse of more than 11 years, they have filed the present writ petition. There is an inordinate delay in approaching this Court. In the pleadings, there is no explanation whatsoever for the delay in filing the writ petition. 135 (ii) Secondly, on 26.11.2008, the Government of India, Ministry of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises, Department of Public Enterprises issued an Office Memorandum enhancing the ceiling limit of gratuity for Executives and non-unionised Supervisors of Central Public Sector Enterprises (CPSEs) to Rs.10.00 lakhs with effect from 01.01.2007. The petitioners’ demand for enhancement of gratuity was denied pursuant to the Charter of Demands in the year 2009, which they accepted.

26.11.2008 issued by the Government of India, Ministry of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises, Department of Public Enterprises (Annexure A), is applicable only to Executives and non-unionised Supervisors of CPSEs. The petitioners are members of a recognised union and therefore cannot claim parity with Executives or non-unionized Supervisors of CPSCs. In respondent–Establishment, employees are classified into two categories, namely workmen and officers. Wage revision for workmen is arrived at through a tri-partite settlement between the recognised unions of all divisions and the Management under Section 12(3) read with Section 18(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Based on the Charter of Demands submitted by the recognised unions and prolonged negotiations spanning nearly ten years, a Memorandum of Settlement was executed containing 139 the terms and conditions of service before the competent authority. Therefore, the petitioners cannot claim equality with non-unionised employees. Consequently, enhancement of the gratuity ceiling for officers of respondent–Establishment pursuant to the directions of the Division Bench of this Court, and denial of the same relief to the petitioners, does not amount to discrimination. In support of this contention, reliance is placed on the judgments of the Apex Court in the case of STATE OF ORISSA vs. PYARIMOHAN SAMANTARAY AND OTHERS reported in (1977) 3 SCC 396 and in the case of K.V.RAJALAKSHMIAH SETTY AND ANOTHER vs. STATE OF MYSORE AND ANOTHER reported in 1966 SCC Online SC 77 and judgment of the Delhi High Court in the case of SAIL EX-EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION vs. STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA 140 AND ANOTHER reported in 2009 SC Online Del

By way of rejoinder, learned Senior Counsel appearing the petitioners submitted on contention of delay, that there is no delay in filing this writ petition. Even after their retirement, the petitioners have been continuously submitting representations to the Hon’ble Ministers, vide Annexure-J dated 31.10.2014 and Annexure-K dated 27.01.2016, and have been agitating their rights since then. The petitioners are retired employees respondent– Establishment. The Payment of Gratuity Act is a beneficial piece of legislation, and gratuity is not a bonus but a statutory payment in consideration of the services rendered by the employees. Therefore, the rights of the petitioners cannot be denied solely on the ground of delay. Further, it is contented that similar public sector undertakings like HAL, BEL and Bharat Dynamics 141 workmen were paid. Hence, he prayed for allowing the writ petition.

Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the writ petition papers.

The first petitioner is an Association of ex- employees of respondent–Company. Petitioner Nos. 2 to 694 are workmen who retired from the service of the third respondent during the period from 01.01.2007 to 23.05.2010 and they are the members of the first petitioner.

The principal grievance of the petitioners is that the benefit of enhanced gratuity of Rs.10.00 lakhs has not been extended to them even though same benefit has been extended to the officers of the third respondent – Company which is violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. 142

For the following reasons, the petitioners are not entitled to the benefit of enhanced gratuity of Rs.10.00 lakhs: A. The specific contention of the petitioners is that, pursuant to the Office Memorandum dated 26.11.2008, enhancement of the ceiling limit of gratuity should also apply to workmen who retired between 01.01.2007 and

23.05.2010, and that the definition of “employee” under the Gratuity Act includes both workmen and officers. The O.M. dated 26.11.2008 is not issued under the 1972 Act and also the said O.M. is not applicable to the unionized workmen. The petitioners case is considered under the 1972 Act, the ceiling limit of gratuity was Rs.3.5 lakhs up to

23.01.2010. By Notification dated 17.05.2010, published in the Gazette on 18.05.2010, the ceiling limit of gratuity was enhanced from Rs.3.5 lakhs to Rs.10.00 lakhs with effect from 24.05.2010. 143 Since the petitioners were retired prior to 24.05.2010, they are not entitled to the enhanced gratuity of Rs.10.00 lakhs under the provisions of the 1972 Act. B. The petitioners were members of recognised trade unions of respondent No.3. For the purpose of wage revision for unionised employees who were on the rolls of respondent No.3 as on 01.01.2007, the unions submitted their Charter of Demands relating to wages and allied matters. Negotiations were held pursuant thereto. One of the demands pertained to service gratuity. The relevant demand reads as follows:

Gratuity Act should be amended ensuring at least one month’s salary for each completed year of service and ceiling on maximum amount should be suitably increased to ensure higher amount (Rs.10.00 lakhs) with effect from 01.01.2007.

144 After negotiations and intervention of Conciliation Officers and the Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner, Bengaluru, the parties arrived at a settlement as per the Memorandum of Settlement dated 24.01.2011, duly signed by the representatives of the Management and the recognized unions of all divisions of the third respondent under Section 12(3) read with Section 18(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act,

1947. The settlement clearly records that the demand relating to enhancement of the ceiling limit of gratuity was rejected by the Management. Other benefits were extended and accepted by the unions. Accordingly, the retired employees of the third respondent were paid gratuity of Rs.3.5 lakhs, which was accepted by the petitioners. Pursuant to the settlement, a General Bulletin was issued on 24.01.2011. Since settlement was arrived at under Section 18(3) of the ID Act, it has statutory force. It is binding on both the 145 employer and employee. Therefore, the petitioners cannot seek enhancement of the gratuity amount contrary to the settlement. (i) It is well settled by a catena of decisions of the Apex Court that a settlement entered into between the employer and the recognised trade union is binding on the parties and carries statutory force. The Apex Court, in Barauni Refinery Pragatisheel Shramik Parishad v.

Indian Oil Corporation Limited, reported in (1991) 1 SCC 4, has categorically held settlements are enforceable in law and bind not only the parties to the settlement but also the workmen represented by the union. (ii) The said legal position has been reiterated in K.C.P. Limited v. Presiding Officer and Others, reported in (1996) 10 SCC 446, wherein the Apex Court observed that settlements arrived at in the 146 course of collective bargaining cannot be lightly ignored and are binding in nature. (iii) Once again, in Transmission Corporation of A.P. Ltd. and Others v. P. Ramachandra Rao and Another, reported in (2006) 9 SCC 623, the Apex Court affirmed that settlements entered into under the Industrial Disputes Act have statutory sanctity and are binding on all concerned, unless set aside in accordance with law. In view of the above judgments, it is very clear that settlement is binding on both the petitioner and the respondent No.3.

Therefore, petitioners cannot seek enhancement of ceiling of gratuity contrary to the settlement. C. The Government of India, Ministry of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises, Department of Public Enterprises issued an Office Memorandum dated 26.11.2008 regarding service benefits, enhancing the ceiling limit of gratuity from Rs.3.5 147 lakhs to Rs.10.00 lakhs with effect from 01.01.2007. This benefit was extended to Board-level and below Board-level Executives and non-unionised Supervisors in Central Public Sector Enterprises. It is not applicable to workmen, much less unionised workmen such as the petitioners. Therefore, the contention of the petitioners that the benefit under the Office Memorandum dated 26.11.2008 should also be extended to them is untenable. D. Workmen and executives stand on different footings insofar employment remuneration are concerned. The service conditions of workmen are governed by the Standing Orders framed under the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946, whereas executives are governed by the Service Rules of respondent.

The remuneration of workmen is determined through long- term settlements arrived at by negotiations with 148 registered and recognised unions in accordance with the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act. The tri- partite Memorandum of Settlement signed between the Management and the unions before the competent authority is binding on the parties. Therefore, the contention of the petitioners that workmen and officers of the third respondent stand on the same footing and that denial of enhanced gratuity to workmen amounts to violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India cannot be accepted. Workmen and officers constitute two distinct classes. The petitioners, being members of recognised unions, entered into a settlement with the Management and accepted gratuity of Rs.3.5 lakhs upon retirement. Hence, their claim for enhancement of the gratuity ceiling is unsustainable. In similar circumstances, High Court of Delhi in the case of SAIL EX-EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION (supra) held that employees who are 149 workmen constitute altogether different class from the Managers and Officers.

The relevant paragraphs are extracted below: “2. Another grievance of the Petitioner is that the ceiling on gratuity is applicable only to those employees who are in executive cadre and there is no ceiling in case of non-executive employees. The Petitioners have sought setting aside of the lower ceiling fixed by SAIL and have further sought removal of distinction between executives non-executive employees in the matter of gratuity. They have also sought payment of difference in gratuity amount along with interest at the rate of 24 per cent per annum.

3. The Petition has been contested by the Respondent-Steel Authority of India Limited. It has been stated in the Counter Affidavit that Respondent No. 1 is an independent Company having its own policy and rules for its employees and is not a department of Government of India and, therefore, the decisions of Government of India in respect of Government employees are not 150 applicable to it. It has been further alleged that as per Clause 3.2.1 of SAIL Gratuity Rules, the amount of gratuity in respect of employees governed by the Memorandum of Agreement, arrived at in the National Joint Committee for Steel Industry, is to be decided as per the terms of the agreement. Even the fixation of salary and other benefits in respect of the non- executives is based on the agreement arrived at National Joint Committee for Steel Industry. The Memorandum of Agreements signed at the National level are implemented by entering upon by-partite settlement at the plant/unit level with the local management and local Union representing the non-executives and the workmen. The Memorandum of Agreement of Joint Wage Negotiating Committee for Steel Industries which was signed in October, 1970, provided that there shall be no ceiling or limit on the amount of gratuity payable. In all subsequent NJCS Agreements, it has been provided that the benefits given under the previous Agreements will continue and, therefore, upper limit on payment of gratuity has become non-operative in case of non- executive employees. 151

4. It has also been alleged by the respondent Executives Officers/Managers at various levels are different and distinct class, compared to non- executives who constitute workmen. It has also been pleaded that since promotions from non-executives posts to executives post were accepted by the members of the Petitioner- Association, at the terms and conditions applicable to the executives, they are stopped from raising a grievance on this count. It has also been stated that Executive enjoys several benefits and allowances which are not available to non-executives and there cannot be any comparison since the two are distinct class categories. It has further been stated in Counter Affidavit that vide Government of India Ordinance dated 24.9.1997, under Payment of Gratuity Act, the amount of ceiling was increased from Rs. 1 lakh to Rs.2.5 lakh further vide Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 1998 dated 23.6.1998, the ceiling was raised to Rs.3.5 lakh. The Rules of the Company were amended accordingly so as the ceiling the date of amendments. 152

5. Let me first take up the grievance of the petitioners regarding distinction between executives and non-executives in the matter of payment of gratuity. Section 4(2) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 provides that for every completed year of service or part thereof in excess of six months, the employer shall pay gratuity to an employee at the rate of 15 days wages based on the rate of wages last drawn by the employee concerned. Sub- section (5) of Section 4 before its amendment with effect from 24.9.1997, provided that the amount of gratuity payable to an employee shall not exceed Rs. 1 lakh. It was increased first to Rs. 2.5 lakh and then to Rs. 3.5 lakh. The ceiling of Rs.3.5 lakh was prescribed by Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 1998, with effect from 24th September, 1997. Therefore, as far as Section 4(4) of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is concerned, the upper ceiling was Rs.1 lakh prior to 24th September, 1997, which was fixed at Rs.3.5 lakh with effect from 24.9.1997.

6. Section 4(5) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 reads as under: 153 “Nothing in this section shall affect the right of an employee to receive better terms of gratuity under any award or agreement or employer.” contract with

Thus, despite the upper ceiling prescribed by Sub-section (4), the employees are entitled to receive higher gratuity if it is so agreed under any award or an agreement or contract between the employer and employees.

As disclosed in the counter affidavit, the salary and other benefits of non-executive employees of Steel Industry were fixed under an agreement arrived at the level of National Joint Committee for Steel Industry, which was followed by by-partite agreement at plants/unit level between the local management and the local unions representing the workmen. The counter affidavit shows that a Memorandum of Agreement Joint Wage Negotiating Committee for steel industry signed in October, 1970 provided that there was to be no ceiling or limit on the amount of gratuity payable. It further shows that in all subsequent NJC's agreements, it was provided that the benefits provided under the previous agreement would 154 continue. Thus, in view of the agreement between the respondent and its workmen, there is no ceiling on the amount of gratuity payable to the non-executive employees and such an agreement is specifically permitted by Section 4(5) of the Payment of Gratuity Act,

9. It is true that differential treatment is being meted out by the respondent/SAIL to its employees forming part of the executive cadres and the employees who are non- executives/workmen. But, such a differential treatment is not without authority of law and is expressly permitted under Section 4(5) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The Constitutional validity of Section 4(5) of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 has not been challenged by the petitioners. They have also not challenged the agreement between the respondent and its non-executive employees. So long as there is a subsisting agreement between the respondents and its non-executive employees to the effect that there will be no ceiling on the gratuity payable to the workmen and such an agreement is permissible in law, no fault can be found with the respondent 155 treating its employees forming part of executive cadres differently employees who are workmen, in the matter of Payment of Gratuity.

10. Even otherwise, the employees who are workmen, constitute an altogether different class from the employees who are Managers and Officers, being members of various executive cadres of the respondent/Company. The pay structure, allowances and service conditions of employees forming part of managerial/officer cadres altogether different from the pay structure, allowances service conditions employees constituting non-executive cadres. Those who belong to executive cadres get not only higher salary but also better allowances, more perks and more favourable service conditions. In fact, executive cadres and non-executive cadres are altogether different classes and cannot be compared with each other. Differential treatment based on intelligible differentia is permissible under the Constitution so long as it has a reasonable nexus with the objective sought to be achieved in this behalf. Only those who are similarly situated are 156 entitled to equal treatment. Since employees forming part of managerial cadres belong altogether to a different class, they cannot claim, as a matter of right, the same treatment which is given to the non-executive employees on account of a binding agreement between them and the respondent company. Therefore, this is no violation of Article 14 of the Constitution in payment of gratuity to the executives as per their statutory entitlements while paying gratuity to the non-executives in terms of the agreement between them and the management.” (i) The Apex Court in the case of STATE OF UTTARAKHAND vs. SUDHIR BUDAKOTI AND OTHERS reported in (2022) 13 SCC 256 has held that a mere differential treatment on its own cannot be termed as an anathema to Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The relevant paragraphs are extracted below: “14. A mere differential treatment on its own cannot be termed as an “anathema to Article 157 14 of the Constitution”. When there is a reasonable basis for a classification adopted by taking note of the exigencies and diverse situations, the Court is not expected to insist on absolute equality by taking a rigid and pedantic view as against a pragmatic one.

Such a discrimination would not be termed as arbitrary as the object of the classification itself is meant for providing benefits to an identified group of persons who form a class of their own. When the differentiation is clearly distinguishable with adequate demarcation duly identified, the object of Article 14 gets satisfied. Social, revenue and economic considerations certainly permissible parameters in classifying a particular group. Thus, a valid classification is nothing but a valid discrimination. That being the position, there can never be an injury to the concept of equality enshrined under the Constitution, not being an inflexible doctrine.

A larger latitude in dealing with a challenge to the classification is mandated on the part of the Court when introduced either by the Legislature or the Executive as the case may 158 be. There is no way, courts could act like appellate authorities especially when a classification is introduced by way of a policy decision clearly identifying the group of beneficiaries by analysing relevant materials.

The question as to whether a classification is reasonable or not is to be answered on the touchstone of a reasonable, common man's approach, keeping in mind the avowed object behind it. If the right to equality is to be termed as a genus, a to non- discrimination becomes a specie. When two identified groups are not equal, certainly they cannot be treated as a homogeneous group. A reasonable classification thus certainly would not injure the equality enshrined under Article 14 when there exists an intelligible differentia between two groups having a rational relation to the object. Therefore, an interference would only be called for on the Court being convinced that the classification causes inequality among similarly placed persons. The role of the court being restrictive, generally, the task is best left the authorities concerned. When a classification is made on the recommendation 159 made by a body of experts constituted for the purpose, Courts will have to be more wary of entering into the said arena as its interference would amount to substituting its views, a process which is best avoided.

As long as the classification does not smack of inherent arbitrariness and conforms to justice and fair play, there may not be any reason to interfere with it. It is the wisdom of the other Wings which is required to be respected except when a classification bordering on arbitrariness, artificial difference and itself being discriminatory. A decision made sans the aforesaid situation cannot be tested with either a suspicious or a microscopic eye. Good faith and intention are to be presumed unless the contrary exists. One has to keep in mind that the role of the Court is on illegality involved as against governance.

For the aforesaid principle of law, we would like to quote the elucidations of this Court in the following judgments:

19.1.Transport & Dock Workers Union v. Mumbai Port Trust [Transport & Dock Workers 160 Union v. Mumbai Port Trust, (2011) 2 SCC 575 : (2011) 1 SCC (L&S) 566] : (SCC pp. 587-90, paras 36-37, 39-41, 43-44 & 48) “36. Differential treatment in our opinion does not per se amount to violation of Article 14 of the Constitution. It violates Article 14 only when there is no conceivable reasonable basis for the differentiation. In the present case, as pointed out above, there is a reasonable basis and hence in our opinion there is no violation of Article 14 of the Constitution.

In our opinion it is not prudent or insist on for the Court to pragmatic absolute equality when there are diverse situations and contingencies, as in the present case. In view of the inherent complexities involved in modern society, some free play must be given to the executive authorities in this connection. ***

In our opinion, there is often a misunderstanding about Article 14 of the Constitution, and often lawyers and Judges tend to construe it in a doctrinaire and absolute sense, which may be totally impractical and make the working of the executive authorities extremely difficult if not impossible.

As Lord Denning observed: ‘This power to overturn executive decision must be exercised very carefully, because you have got to remember that the executive and the local authorities have their very own responsibilities and they have the right to make decisions. The 161 courts should be very wary about interfering and only interfere in extreme cases, that is, cases where the court is sure they have gone wrong in law or they have been utterly unreasonable. Otherwise you would get a conflict between the courts and the Government and the authorities, which would be most undesirable. The courts must act very warily in this matter.’ [See Judging the World : Law and Politics in the World's Leading Courts by Garry Sturgess, Philip Chubb (Butterworths, 1988).]”

In our opinion Judges must maintain judicial self-restraint while exercising the powers of judicial review of administrative or legislative decisions. “In view of the complexities of modern society”, wrote Justice Frankfurter, while Professor of Law at Harvard University,

and the restricted scope of any man's experience, tolerance and humility in passing judgment on the worth of the experience and beliefs of others become crucial faculties in the disposition of cases. The successful exercise for rare of such judicial power calls intellectual in personal penetration, experience and imagination operate as the Constitution. These limitations of insights Mr Justice Holmes applied hundreds of cases and expressed memorable language : It is misfortune if a Judge reads his conscious or unconscious sympathy with one side or the other prematurely into the law, and forgets that what seem to him to be first principles are believed by half his fellow men to be wrong.

disinterestedness limitation *** 162 restraints

In our opinion adjudication must be done within the system of historically validated conscious minimisation of the Judges' preferences. The Court must not embarrass administrative authorities and must realise expertise in the field of administration while the Court does not. In the words of Chief Justice Neely, former Chief Justice of the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals: administrative authorities stockbroker ‘I have very few illusions about my own limitations as a Judge. I am not an accountant, electrical engineer, financer, banker, system management analyst. It is the height of folly to expect Judges intelligently to review a 5000 page intricacies of a public utility operation. It is not the function of a Judge to act as a super board, or with the zeal of a pedantic school master substituting its judgment for that of the administrator.’ record addressing

In administrative matters the Court should, therefore, ordinarily defer to the judgment of the administrators unless the decision is clearly violative of some statute connection, Frankfurter while Professor of Law at Harvard University wrote in The Public and its Government: shockingly arbitrary. Justice In ‘With the great men of the Supreme Court constitutional adjudication has always been statecraft. As a mere Judge, Marshall had his superiors among his colleagues. His supremacy lay in his recognition of the practical needs of the Government. The great Judges are those to whom the Constitution is not primarily a text for 163 interpretation but the means of ordering the life of a progressive people.’ ***