The High Court
Case Details
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI W.P.(S) No. 3143 of 2018 1 ------ 1.Raju Pandit 2.Surendra Das 3.Surendra Paswan 4.Md. Sabir 5.Rajo Choudhary 6.Sudarshan Mahto 7.Sita Ram 8.Kishun Das Kitto Prasad 9.Subodh Mahto 10.Dilip Kumar Mahto 11.Surendra Singh 12.Ram Bharosha Mahato 13.Raj Kumar Paswan 14.Krishnandan Rai 15.Bijay Kumar Rai 16.Ramesh Prasad Ray 17.Niraj 18.Raju Sahu 19.Dinesh Sao 20.Raj Kumar 21.Sone Lal Rai 22.Shrawan Sahni 23.Manoj Ram 24.Surendra Paswan 25.Mantun Sao 26.Lalan Kumar 27.Ram Bachan Thakur 28.Chhedi Ram Sao 29.Budharu Ram Sahu 30.Birmannu Ram 31.Ratnakar Swain 32.Motilal 33.Nathunirai Ramjanam 34.Prabhu Shaw 35.Sita Ram Yadav 36.Ram Pukar Rai 37.Hirin Prasad 38.Krishna Ram 39.Indrajeet Kumar 40.Krishna Paswan 41.Radhey Shyam Prasad 42.Binod Paswan 43.Sukhu Machua 44.Sanjay Kumar Sao 45.Poshu Ram Sah 46.Janardhan Rai 47.Jitendra Sahani 48.Shankar Singh 49.Binod Choudhary 50.Sanjay Ram 2 51.Ramchandra Das 52.Jagdish Sahani 53.Chhote Lal Ram 54.Ram Sao 55.Arun Kumar 56.Dilip Mahto 57.Siya Yadav 58.Bulak Rai 59.Sadhu Chouhan 60.Jogendra Jamadar 61.Kameshwar Rai 62.Sunil Kumar 63.Ganesh Behra 64.Bishram Lodhi 65.Kanhaiya Ram Sao 66.Ram Prasad 67.Shankar Pandit 68.Munna Kumar Pandit 69.Satyanarayan Sao 70.Kaleshwar Paswan 71.Sheo Shankar 72.Kashi Nath Prasad 73.Baleshwar Pandit 74.Bikash Shaw 75.Pramod Yadav 76.Bijendra Shaw 77.Karu Paswan 78.Okil Mahto Versus .... .... …. Petitioners 1.The Food Corporation of India through its Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Head Office 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1. 2.The Chairman cum Managing Director, Head Office 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 3.The Executive Director (East Zone), Food Corporation of India, Zonal Office, Kolkata. 4.The General Manager (Region), Food Corporation of India, New Collectorate Building, Kutchery Road, Ranchi. 5.The Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, New Collectorate Building, Kutchery Road, Ranchi .... .... .... Respondents W.P.(S) No. 705 of 2018 WITH 1.Bhanu Ram 2.Sudama Yadav 3.Brichh Yadav 4.Arvind Kumar 5.Nageshwar Paswan 6.Sanjay Kumar 7.Subhash Kumar Roy ... .... …. Petitioners 3 Versus 1.The Food Corporation of India through its Managing Director, Head Office 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1. 2.The Executive Director, Food Corporation of India, 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 3.The General Manager (IR-L), Food Corporation of India, 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 4. Assistant General Manager (IR-L), Food Corporation of India, Regional Office, New Collectorate Building, Kutchery Road, Ranchi 5.The Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, District Office, Ranchi, Lower Chutia, Samlong, Ranchi. 6. Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, District Office, Jagrity Nagar, Karnibad, Deoghar W.P.(S) No. 2936 of 2018 WITH
Legal Reasoning
1.Pawandev Mahato 2.Srikant Prasad 3.Parshuram Ram 4.Rajkumar Manjhi 5.Bhagwan Ram 6.Ramji Ram 7.Ajay Kumar Ram 8.Nathuni Paswan 9.Rakesh kumar singh 10.Santosh Kumar Manjhi 11.Ramawtar Prasad Chandrawanshi 12.Sukhlal Mahto 13.Binod Rai 14.Bisheshwar Prasad Chandrawanshi 15.Pramod kumar Rai 16.Ravindar Rai 17.Sanjit Kumar 18.Ramvilas pandit 19.Rameshwar Nonia 20.Manoj Kumar 21.Pintu Ram 22.Sanjay Yadav 23.Dwarika Yadav 24.Paras Ram 25.Suresh rai 26.Briju Manjhi 27.Shiv Kumar Ram 28.Dinesh Rai 29.Awedhesh Kumar 30.Ashok Rai 31.Rambabu Rai 32.Binod Rai 33.Sudama Rai 34.Nand Kumar Rai 35.Rudal Rai 36.Awadesh Kumar Mishra 4 37.Manjhi Mahto 38.Surendra Rai 39.Mangloo ram sahu 40.Birat kumar 41.Lachuman Mahto 42.Shankar Rai 43.Ramesar Sk Rai 44.Pappu Paswan 45.Madan Prasad 46.Ganesh Prasad 47.Budhu Mahto 48.Manoj Paswan 49.Nageshwar Yadav 50.Shyamli Yadav 51.Amarnath Prasad 52.Hiraman Prasad 53.Suman Kumar Paswan 54.Shankar Paswan 55.Dilip Kumar 56.Manohar Prasad Mandal 57.Mahendra Yadav 58.Ajay Paswan 59.Naresh Kumar 60.Manoj Rai 61.Shankar Prasad 62.Alok kumar 63.Ashok Paswan 64. Manoj kumar 65.Bajrangi Paswan 66.Dayanand Yadav 67.Ashim Kumar Dalai 68.Pushottam Mahto 69.Umesh Pandit 70.Ram Paswan 71.Madan Mahon Mahto 72.Ram Ratan Paswan 73.Shashi Bhusan Mahto 74.Pramod Kumar 75.Harshit Mahto 76.Binod Paswan 77.Kanhaiya Sao 78.Raj kumar rai 79.Ranjit Paswan 80.Jai Prakash Choudhary 81.Nawal Ram 82.Ramdas Tanti 83.Ajay Kumar Prasad 84.Bahuran Ram 85.Gunai Choudhary 86.Hira Mahto 87.Baijnath Pandit 88.Murari Lal 89.Rajkumar Pandit 5 90.Karu Pal 91.Subodh Pandit 92.Bhola Ram 93.Arjun Pandit 94.Sanju Pandit 95.Raghunandan Yadav 96.Paras Singh 97.Inardev Ram 98.Panchlal Das 99.Tuntun Paswan 100.Bhagwan Das 101.Sanjay Ram 102.Rajesh Roy 103.Birendra sk Shaw 104.Bharat Yadav 105.Prahalad Ram 106.Basant Kumar Sahu 107.Bhagwan Rai 108.Mahendra Yadav 109.Sant Ram Sao 110.Ram Eqbal Choudhary 111.Ajay kumar 112.Manohar Thakur 113.Anil Sao 114.Hazari Pd. Nishad 115.Jungi prasad 116.Binod Kumar 117.Jagarnath Pandit 118.Mahendra Rai 119.Vijay Chauhan 120.Ishwar Das 121.Ranjeev Mandal 122.Prasadi Mahto 123.Ramesh Rai 124.Ajay Kumar 125.Ranjit Sahani 126.Narayan Sahani 127.Sushil Poddar 128.Kailash Paswan 129.Md.Akram 130.Arvind Kumar Sahani 131.Sudam Mandal 132.Awadhesh Kumar 133.Shyam Sunder Mahato 134.Prabhat Rai 135.Surendra Mandal 136.Kalicharan Mandal 137.Panchu Mahto 138.Pintu Sarkar 139.Arjun Yadav 140.Jaidul Hussain 141.Ram Bhawan Singh 142.Dayanand Paswan 6 143.Upendra Rai 144.Arun Kumar Chaudhary 145.Santoshi Paswan 146.Indradev Yadav 147.Arjun singh 148.Jogendar Das 149.Badan Mahto 150.Jugal Singh 151.Jugeshwar Mahato 152.Naresh Bhokta 153.Ramashray Mahto 154.Yugal Mahto 155.Basant Thakur 156.Bijli Singh 157.Dinesh Bhokta 158.Rajendar Mahto 159.Jai Prakash Choudhary 160.Md.Idrish Ansari 161.Nankesar Sk Mahto 162.Nunmani Yadav 163.Ekadashi Mahto 164.Nilmani Nayak 165.Sonelal Paswan 166.Prakash Mandal 167.Doman Singh 168.Shishi Ranjan Dhara 169.Ganesh Mahto 170.Shatrudhan Prasad 171.Manoj Mahto 172.Ashok Mandal 173.Fekan Mandal 174.Basant Mahto 175.Shivcharan Lohar 176.Rajendra Yadav 177.Bajrangi Yadav 178.Ramnand Mahato 179.Tuntun Rai 180.Basudev Singh 181.Babulal singh 182.Shankar Yadav 183.Munni Baitha 184.Rajeshwar Singh 185.Durga Ravi 186.Sanjay kumar 187.Ashuni Kumar Shukla 188.Anil Mahto .... Versus .... …. Petitioners 1.The Food Corporation of India through its Managing Director, Head Office 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1. 2.The Executive Director, Food Corporation of India, 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 3.The Chief General Manager (IR-L), Food Corporation of India, 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 7 4. General Manager (IR-L), Food Corporation of India, 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 5. Assistant General Manager (IR-L), Food Corporation of India, Regional Office, New Collectorate Building, Ranchi. 6.The Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, District Office, Ranchi, Lower Chutia, Samlong, Ranchi. 7. Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, District Office, Jagrity Nagar, Karnibad, Deoghar. 8.Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, District Office, Dhanbad. 9.Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, District- Daltonganj. W.P.(S) No. 2953 of 2018 WITH 1.Indal Mandal 2.Vijay Kumar 3.Chandeswar Das 4.Mukesh Mandal 5.Upendra Ram 6.Umesh Das 7.Ashok Mandal 8.Kailash Manjhi 9.Ramekbal Manjhi 10.Mohan Yadav 11.Ashok Yadav 12.Surendra Kumar Ram 13.Bhagwat Yadav 14.Rajdev Yadav 15.Yugeshwar Yadav 16.Vijay Rajak 17.Narayan Singh 18.Md.Sahidul 19.Jang bahadur Mahato 20.Tapeshwar Yadav 21.Raja Ram Rai 22.Ghanshyam Mahto 23.Ramu Paswan 24.Bhojal prasad Yadav 25.Ravi Yadav 26.Sitaram Yadav 27.Dashrath Prasad Kushwaha 28.Ram Prabesh Paswan 29.Pawan Kumar Ram 30.Surendra sah 31.Munshi Yadav 32.Suresh Yadav 33.Narayan Yadav 34.Ramcharitra Yadav 35.Rajesh Yadav 36.Dinesh Yadav 37.Sikander Yadav 38.Upendra Yadav 8 39.Gulab Chand Yadav 40.Baleshwar Yadav 41.kishore Kumar Yadav 42.Rohit Choudhary 43.Bhola Mahato 44.Ramesh Sah 45.Dharmendra Raut 46.Ashok Yadav 47.Bhuneshwar Yadav 48.Ambika Nayak 49.Bideshi Yadav 50.Shibu Yadav 51.Dasai Rai 52.Sukhdeo Rajak 53.Jitendra Das 54.Nandu Yadav 55.Dayanand Mahato 56.Shyam Sundar Mahto 57.Ashok Ydav 58.Yogendra Paswan 59.Mahendra Yadav 60.Brahamdev Prasad Yadav 61.Niranjan ram 62.Prahlad Yadav 63.Ramu Mahto .... Versus .... …. Petitioners 1.The Food Corporation of India through its Managing Director, Head Office 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1. 2.The Executive Director, Food Corporation of India, 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 3.The General Manager (IR-L), Food Corporation of India, 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 4. Assistant General Manager (IR-L), Food Corporation of India, Regional Office, New Collectorate Building, Ranchi. 5. The Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, District Office, Ranchi, Lower Chutia, Samlong, Ranchi. 6. Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, District Office, Dhanbad, having its office at Dhanbad. W.P.(S) No. 3721 of 2018 WITH 1.Chandrika Modi 2.Sukdeo Mahto 3.Arvind Yadav 4.Bishnu Bhogta 5.Digambar Mahto 6.Sheo Kumar Das 7.Dulal Chand 8.Nawal Mahto 9.Gudar Mahto 10.Shiv Shankar Kumar Ydav 11.Dinesh Kumar 9 12.Tulsi Sah 13.Bhola Paswan 14.Rajendra Paswan 15.Krishnandan Mahto 16.Prayag Yadav 17.Rajendra Yadav 18.Rana Singh 19.Nagina Yadav 20.Dev Baran Prasad Yadav 21.Ashok Kumar Paswan 22.Ram Lakhan 23.Amar lal 24.Upendra Rai 25.Ramchandra Modi 26.Sri Ram Mahto 27.Rajesh Prasad Agrawal 28.Radheshyam Mandal 29.Swetambar Sahoo 30.Lorik Yadav 31.Surendra Kumar Das 32.Raj Kumar Paswan 33.Jichhu das 34.Ramashish Yadav 35.Mahendra Jadav 36.Vijay Paswan 37.Harihar Yadav 38.Yashvant Kr. Thakur 39.Amarjeet Paswan 40.Tapan Kumar Jena 41.Gour Mohan Manjhi 42.Shivji Mahto 43.Sukul Sahani 44.Wakil Kumar 45.Mithilesh Kumar Mahto 46.Surendra Oraon 47.Birendra Singh 48.Barmshankar Chaudhary 49.Munna Singh 50.Rohit Kumar Rai 51.Sita Ram 52.Manoj Oraon 53.Ganesh Paswan 54.Ram Saran Prasad 55.Munna Yadav 56.Baleshwar Mahto 57.Shankhnath Singh 58.Munna Prasad 59.Rajendra Prasad Versus .... .... …. Petitioners 1.The Food Corporation of India through its Chairman cum Managing Director, Head Office 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1. 2.The Chairman cum Managing Director, Food Corporation of India, Head Office,16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 10 3.The Executive Director, East Zone, Food Corporation of India, Zonal Office, Kolkata. 4. General Manager (Region), Food Corporation of India, New Collectorate Building, Ranchi. 5. The Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, Deo Mension, Deoghar. W.P.(S) No. 3722 of 2018 WITH 1.Ajay Kumar 2.Nagina Rai 3.Suresh Manjhi 4.Indra Bahadur Sonar 5.Darog Manjhi 6.Damodar Ram 7.Laxmi Manjhi 8.Umesh Mukhiya 9.Sidheshwar prasad 10.Rajendra Munda 11.Manoj Kumar Prasad 12.Balam Mahli 13.Umesh Manjhi 14.Sita Ram Mahto 15.Dinesh Manjhi 16.Ramawtar prasad chandrabanshi .... .... …. Petitioners Versus 1.The Food Corporation of India through its Managing Director, Head Office 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1. 2.The Chairman cum Managing Director, Head Office, 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 3.The Executive Director (East Zone), Food Corporation of India, Zonal Office, Kolkata. 4. General Manager (Region), Food Corporation of India, New Collectorate Building, Ranchi. 5. The Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, New Collectorate Building, Ranchi. W.P.(S) No. 3723 of 2018 WITH 1.Bishundeo Yadav 2.Manoj Kumar 3.Utpal Hazra 4.Suresh Yadav 5.Ramji Yadav 6.Ram Saran Yadav 7.Prabhu Yadav 8.Krishnadeo ram 9.Sugriv Yadav 10.Ram Bahadur Paswan 11.Sunil Paswan 12.Lalan Kumar rai 13.Umesh Mahato 14.Hari Yadav 11 15.Raghunandan Ram 16.Karu Ram 17.Jugal Kishore Yadav 18.Bijay Yadav 19.Nageshwar Yadav 20.Prabhu Yadav 21.Durga Yadav 22.Balram Yadav 23.Raj Kumar Yadav 24.Dhanu Yadav 25.Jagdish Yadav 26.Ram Bhaju Yadav 27.Muso Yadav 28.Satendra Yadav 29.Ramchandra Yadav 30.Batan Ram 31.Mahendra Ram 32.Naresh Yadav 33.Shambhu Ram 34.Jageshwar Kumar Nayak 35.Lalan Prasad Yadav 36.Md.Saidul 37.Arjun Yadav 38.Lakhan Ram 39.Suryadeo Yadav 40.Sukhdeo Yadav 41.Nago Yadav 42.Anandi Ram 43.LakhanYadav 44.Ashok Ram 45.Rajendra Ram 46. Subhash Mandal 47.Suresh Yadav 48.Indradeo Yadav 49.Bindo Yadav 50.Jaglal Manjhi 51.Anuj Singh 52.Dinesh Kumar Yadav 53.Suresh Yadav 54.Ramdeo Yadav 55.Dilip Kumar Yadav 56.Ratan Giri 57.Banaras Yadav .... .... …. Petitioners Versus 1.The Food Corporation of India through its Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Head Office 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1. 2.The Chairman cum Managing Director, Head Office 16-20 at Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-1 3.The Executive Director (East Zone), Food Corporation of India, Zonal Office, Kolkata. 4.The General Manager (Region), Food Corporation of India, New 12 Collectorate Building, Kutchery Road, Ranchi. 5.The Area Manager, Food Corporation of India, Usha Kunja, Dhanbad. .... .... Respondents .... CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE GAUTAM KUMAR CHOUDHARY For the Petitioners : Mr. Manoj Tandon, Ms. N. Bhardawaj, Mr. A. Kerketta & Mr. P. Kr. Roy, Advs. Mr. Ravi Prakash Mishra, Advv For the Respondents : Mr. Nipun Bakkshi, Advocate Mr. Subham Sinha, Advocate. ------ Order No.08 / Dated : 22.11.2023. In view of statement made in supplementary counter-affidavit filed on behalf of Respondents-FCI wherein it has been stated that the grievance of the petitioners/ employees has already been redressed as the deductions made have already been credited in their accounts. As such, the lis in between the parties does not survive. Counsels appearing on behalf of the Petitioners do not dispute
Decision
the averments made in the counter-affidavit. Accordingly, all these Writ Petitions are disposed of as infructuous. Sandeep/uploaded. (Gautam Kumar Choudhary, J.)