✦ High Court of India · 20 Jan 2025

High Court · 2025

Case Details High Court of India · 20 Jan 2025
Court
High Court of India
Decided
20 Jan 2025
Bench
CORAMTHE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE
Length
1,062 words

CMP NO. 29291 of 2024 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS DATED: 20-01-2025CORAMTHE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE J.SATHYA NARAYANA PRASADCMP NO. 29291 of 2024ANDSA NO. 9 OF 2008 NAGARAJANS/o. R.Manickam, No. 21, Annadhanapatti, Trichy Road, Salem 636 002 and 3 Others Appellant(s) VsSANTHAMMAL(since Deceased) and 26 Others Respondent(s) SA NO. 9 of 2008NAGARAJANS/o R.Manickam At 21 Annadhanapatti Trichy Road, Salem 636 002 and 3 Others Appellant(s) VsSANTHAMMAL(died)S/o R.Manickam At 21 Annadhanapatti Trichy Road, Salem 636 002 and 26 Others Respondent(s) CMP NO. 29291 of 2024For Appellant(s): M/s.D.ShivakumaranS.MayilnathanFor Respondent(s): SA NO. 9 of 2008For Appellant(s): D. ShivakumaranV.SekarR.Ezhilarasan For Appellant https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis M/s I.Abrar Md AbdulahB. Viveka VananS. SaravankumarC. Gunasekaran For Rr5 To R7M/s.S.Dorai SamyV.Elangovan For Rr9 To 17R-2 Kamalam , R-3 Jothy, R-4 RajeswariR-3 Jothy W/o S.Jayavel P&t Quarters Mettur 636 401R-4 Rajeswari W/o Sadasivam 55 Ambedkar Nagar, Maniyanur Post, Salem-10R-8 K.Ilangovan @ Rajan, R-9 SundarambalR-18 A.Kumar S/o Late Iyyavu 120-a Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar Mettur-1R-19 B. Gnanasekar S/o. Late. Balaiya, No.16-g, Behind Medical College Perundhurai (kundrathur Road) Kunnathur, Tiruppur 638 103.Rr1 & 23 - Died ( Steps Taken )Rr21, 22, 24 & 26 - LeftR20 - No Such AddressR25 - Address Cannot Be LocatedR27 - Minor Rep By R26Pvt. NoticeRr1 & 23 - Died, Vide In EbAos Filed Reg Rr5 To 7 - ServedRr19 To 22 - LeftRr24 To 27 - LeftR2 To R4, R8 & R18 - Aos Not FiledFor Respondent(s): -------ORDERLearned counsel for the appellant submitted that the first respondent died and the LRs of the deceased has to be brought on record. Notice was ordered by this Court on the LRs of the deceased and the said notice was returned with the endorsement as left.C.M.P.No.29291 of 2024 is filed to order substituted service of notice for the respondents 20 to 22 and 24 to 27 through paper publication in one issue to Tamil Daily News Paper having Circulation at Salem District.Heard both sides.Being satisfied with the reasons stated in the affidavit filed in support of this petition, the Civil Miscellaneous Petition is ordered as prayed for. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis The appellant is directed to effect paper publication for service of notice for R20 to R22 & R24 to R27 in Tamil daily viz “Thina Thanthi” having circulation at Salem District by mentioning the hearing date as 14.02.2025.List the main Second Appeal on 14.02.2025.20-01-2025pamCMP NO. 29291 of 2024To1. SANTHAMMAL(since Deceased)2. KAMALAMW/o.K.Natesan, No.1/502-13, Uthirappan Nagar, Maniyanur Post, Salem-103. JOTHIW/o.S.Jayavel, P And T Quarters Mettur- 636 401.4. RAJESWARIW/o.Sadasivam, No.55, Ambedkar Nagar, Maniyanur Post, Salem-105. S. RajeswariW/o.Ponnusami, Residing At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-2.6. P.MurugananthamS/o.Late Ponnusami, Residing At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-27. NAGALAKSHMID/o.Late Ponnusami, Residing At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-28. K.Ilangovan @ RajanS/o.Kalimuthu, C/o.Kanikondi Anjamma O Line, 8th Cross Nallaseuva, Indira Nagar Guntur, Andhra Predesh.9. SUNDARAMBALW/o.Late Iyyavu Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

10. A. RaniW/o.Rajan No.4, Allied House Meyvazhisalai Opposite Airport Road, P.T.C.Post Perankudi, Madurai.11. TAMIZHARASID/o.Ayyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.12. A. KalaivananS/o.Iyyavur, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.13. A. KalaiselviW/o.Ramu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.14. A. JohnsilaW/o.Singaram Residing At Manicka Vaithiar Compound (near Karuvattu Mandy) Annadhanapatty, Salem- 636 002.15. A. ThenmozhiD/o.Late Iyyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.16. A. AnnaduraiS/o.Late Iyyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.17. A. SundarajanS/o.Late Iyyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.18. A. KumarS/o.Late Iyyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.19. B. GnanasekarS/o.Late Balaiya, No.16-g, Behind Medical College, Perundhurai (kundrathur Road) Kunnathur Thiruppur- 638 10320. B. Ramu @ SelvarajS/o.Late Balaiya Esan Complex, Behind Jothy Theatre Ponnamapettai Salem- 636 00121. B. RajanS/o.Late Balaiya, No.177, Rajarajan Nagar, Hasthampatti Salem- 636 007.22. B. VijayakumarS/o.Late Balaiya, Rajarajan Nagar No.82, Alagapuram, Periyapudhur, Hasthampatti Salem- 636 016. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

23. B. Sankar(deceased)24. B. Veni @ KrishnaveniW/o.Philip, D/o. Late Balaiya No.177, Rajarajan Nagar, Hasthampatti Salem- 636 007.25. S. Devika @ DeviW/o. Sundar, D/o Late Balaiya 311, M-block Allikuttai Colony, Annadhanapatti Salem- 636 002.26. S. RajithaW/o.Late B.Sankar Residing At No.315, Rajaraja Nagar, Hasthampatti, Alagapuram Pudhur Salem- 636 016.27. Minor S. SahanaD/o.Late B.Sankar Rep. By Mother, Guardian And Next Friend, Residing At No.315, Rajaraja Nagar, Hasthampatti, Alagapuram Pudhur Salem- 636 016.SA NO. 9 of 20081. SANTHAMMAL(died)S/o R.Manickam At 21 Annadhanapatti Trichy Road, Salem 636 0022. KAMALAMW/o K.Natesan 1/502-13 Uthirappan Nagar Maniyannur Post, Salem -103. JOTHYW/o S.Jayavel P&t Quarters Mettur 636 4014. RAJESWARIW/o Sadasivam 55 Ambedkar Nagar, Maniyanur Post, Salem-105. S.RajeswariW/o Ponnusami At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-26. P.MurugananthamS/o Late Ponnusami At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-27. NAGALAKSHMID/o Late Ponnusami At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-28. K.Ilangovan @ RajanS/o Kalimuthu C/o Kani Kondi Anjamma O Line, 8th Cross Nalla Seuva, Indira Nagar Guntur, Andhra Pradesh9. SUNDARAMBALW/o Late Iyyavu 120-a Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar Mettur 636 40110. A.Rani W/o Rajan https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis No.4 Allied House Meyvazhisalai Opposite Airport Road, P.T.C.Post Perankudi Madurai11. TAMIZHARASID/o Ayyavu12. A.KalaiselviS/o Iyyavur13. A.KalaiselviW/o Ramu14. A.JohnsilaW/o Singaram At Manicika Vaithiar Compoundnear Karuvttu Mandy Annadhanapatty Salem 636 00215. A.ThenmozhiD/o Late Iyyavu16. A.AnnaduraiS/o Late Iyyavu17. A.SundararajanS/o Late Iyyavu 120-a Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur 636 40118. A.KumarS/o Late Iyyavu 120-a Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar Mettur-119. B. GnanasekarS/o. Late. Balaiya, No.16-g, Behind Medical College Perundhurai (kundrathur Road) Kunnathur, Tiruppur 638 103.20. B. Ramu @ SelvarajS/o. Late. Balaiya, Esan Complex, Behind Jothy Theatre, Ponnamapettai, Salem 636 001.21. B. RajanS/o. Late. Balaiya, No.177, Rajarajan Nagar, Hasthampatti, Salem 636 00722. B. VijayakumarS/o. Late. Balaiya, No.82, Rajarajan Nagar, Alagapuram, Periyapudhur, Hasthampatti, Salem 636 016.23. B. SANKAR(died)S/o. Late. Balaiya, No.82, Rajarajan Nagar, Alagapuram, Periyapudhur, Hasthampatti, Salem 636 016.24. B. Veni @ Krishnaveni https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis W/o. Philip, D/o. Late. Balaiya, No.177, Rajarajan Nagar, Hasthampatti, Salem 636 007.25. S. Devika @ DeviW/o. Sundar, D/o. Late. Balaiya, 311, M-block, Allikuttai Colony, Annahanapatti, Salem 636 002.26. S. RejithaW/o.Late B.Sankar Residing At No.315, Rajaraja Nagar, Hasthampatti, Alagapuram Pudhur Salem-636 016.27. Minor S.SahanaD/O.LATE B.SANKAR REP.BY MOTHER, GUARDIAN AND NEXT FRIEND, RESIDING AT NO.315, RAJARAJA NAGAR, HASTHAMPATTI, ALAGAPURAM PUDHUR SALEM-636 016. r1 died, rr19 to 25 are brought on record as lrs of the deceased r1 and r23 died, rr26 andd 27 are brought on record as lrs of the deceased r23, r26 is appointed as guardian and nextfriend of r27 vide court order dated 14/02/2024 made in cmp nos 8277 of 2021 and 31 and 36 of 2022 in sa no 9 of 2008(GAMJ)

CMP NO. 29291 of 2024 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS DATED: 20-01-2025CORAMTHE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE J.SATHYA NARAYANA PRASADCMP NO. 29291 of 2024ANDSA NO. 9 OF 2008 NAGARAJANS/o. R.Manickam, No. 21, Annadhanapatti, Trichy Road, Salem 636 002 and 3 Others Appellant(s) VsSANTHAMMAL(since Deceased) and 26 Others Respondent(s) SA NO. 9 of 2008NAGARAJANS/o R.Manickam At 21 Annadhanapatti Trichy Road, Salem 636 002 and 3 Others Appellant(s) VsSANTHAMMAL(died)S/o R.Manickam At 21 Annadhanapatti Trichy Road, Salem 636 002 and 26 Others Respondent(s) CMP NO. 29291 of 2024For Appellant(s): M/s.D.ShivakumaranS.MayilnathanFor Respondent(s): SA NO. 9 of 2008For Appellant(s): D. ShivakumaranV.SekarR.Ezhilarasan For Appellant https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis M/s I.Abrar Md AbdulahB. Viveka VananS. SaravankumarC. Gunasekaran For Rr5 To R7M/s.S.Dorai SamyV.Elangovan For Rr9 To 17R-2 Kamalam , R-3 Jothy, R-4 RajeswariR-3 Jothy W/o S.Jayavel P&t Quarters Mettur 636 401R-4 Rajeswari W/o Sadasivam 55 Ambedkar Nagar, Maniyanur Post, Salem-10R-8 K.Ilangovan @ Rajan, R-9 SundarambalR-18 A.Kumar S/o Late Iyyavu 120-a Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar Mettur-1R-19 B. Gnanasekar S/o. Late. Balaiya, No.16-g, Behind Medical College Perundhurai (kundrathur Road) Kunnathur, Tiruppur 638 103.Rr1 & 23 - Died ( Steps Taken )Rr21, 22, 24 & 26 - LeftR20 - No Such AddressR25 - Address Cannot Be LocatedR27 - Minor Rep By R26Pvt. NoticeRr1 & 23 - Died, Vide In EbAos Filed Reg Rr5 To 7 - ServedRr19 To 22 - LeftRr24 To 27 - LeftR2 To R4, R8 & R18 - Aos Not FiledFor Respondent(s): -------ORDERLearned counsel for the appellant submitted that the first respondent died and the LRs of the deceased has to be brought on record. Notice was ordered by this Court on the LRs of the deceased and the said notice was returned with the endorsement as left.C.M.P.No.29291 of 2024 is filed to order substituted service of notice for the respondents 20 to 22 and 24 to 27 through paper publication in one issue to Tamil Daily News Paper having Circulation at Salem District.Heard both sides.Being satisfied with the reasons stated in the affidavit filed in support of this petition, the Civil Miscellaneous Petition is ordered as prayed for. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis The appellant is directed to effect paper publication for service of notice for R20 to R22 & R24 to R27 in Tamil daily viz “Thina Thanthi” having circulation at Salem District by mentioning the hearing date as 14.02.2025.List the main Second Appeal on 14.02.2025.20-01-2025pamCMP NO. 29291 of 2024To1. SANTHAMMAL(since Deceased)2. KAMALAMW/o.K.Natesan, No.1/502-13, Uthirappan Nagar, Maniyanur Post, Salem-103. JOTHIW/o.S.Jayavel, P And T Quarters Mettur- 636 401.4. RAJESWARIW/o.Sadasivam, No.55, Ambedkar Nagar, Maniyanur Post, Salem-105. S. RajeswariW/o.Ponnusami, Residing At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-2.6. P.MurugananthamS/o.Late Ponnusami, Residing At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-27. NAGALAKSHMID/o.Late Ponnusami, Residing At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-28. K.Ilangovan @ RajanS/o.Kalimuthu, C/o.Kanikondi Anjamma O Line, 8th Cross Nallaseuva, Indira Nagar Guntur, Andhra Predesh.9. SUNDARAMBALW/o.Late Iyyavu Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

10. A. RaniW/o.Rajan No.4, Allied House Meyvazhisalai Opposite Airport Road, P.T.C.Post Perankudi, Madurai.11. TAMIZHARASID/o.Ayyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.12. A. KalaivananS/o.Iyyavur, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.13. A. KalaiselviW/o.Ramu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.14. A. JohnsilaW/o.Singaram Residing At Manicka Vaithiar Compound (near Karuvattu Mandy) Annadhanapatty, Salem- 636 002.15. A. ThenmozhiD/o.Late Iyyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.16. A. AnnaduraiS/o.Late Iyyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.17. A. SundarajanS/o.Late Iyyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.18. A. KumarS/o.Late Iyyavu, Residing At No.120-a, Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur- 636 401.19. B. GnanasekarS/o.Late Balaiya, No.16-g, Behind Medical College, Perundhurai (kundrathur Road) Kunnathur Thiruppur- 638 10320. B. Ramu @ SelvarajS/o.Late Balaiya Esan Complex, Behind Jothy Theatre Ponnamapettai Salem- 636 00121. B. RajanS/o.Late Balaiya, No.177, Rajarajan Nagar, Hasthampatti Salem- 636 007.22. B. VijayakumarS/o.Late Balaiya, Rajarajan Nagar No.82, Alagapuram, Periyapudhur, Hasthampatti Salem- 636 016. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

23. B. Sankar(deceased)24. B. Veni @ KrishnaveniW/o.Philip, D/o. Late Balaiya No.177, Rajarajan Nagar, Hasthampatti Salem- 636 007.25. S. Devika @ DeviW/o. Sundar, D/o Late Balaiya 311, M-block Allikuttai Colony, Annadhanapatti Salem- 636 002.26. S. RajithaW/o.Late B.Sankar Residing At No.315, Rajaraja Nagar, Hasthampatti, Alagapuram Pudhur Salem- 636 016.27. Minor S. SahanaD/o.Late B.Sankar Rep. By Mother, Guardian And Next Friend, Residing At No.315, Rajaraja Nagar, Hasthampatti, Alagapuram Pudhur Salem- 636 016.SA NO. 9 of 20081. SANTHAMMAL(died)S/o R.Manickam At 21 Annadhanapatti Trichy Road, Salem 636 0022. KAMALAMW/o K.Natesan 1/502-13 Uthirappan Nagar Maniyannur Post, Salem -103. JOTHYW/o S.Jayavel P&t Quarters Mettur 636 4014. RAJESWARIW/o Sadasivam 55 Ambedkar Nagar, Maniyanur Post, Salem-105. S.RajeswariW/o Ponnusami At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-26. P.MurugananthamS/o Late Ponnusami At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-27. NAGALAKSHMID/o Late Ponnusami At Annadhanapatty Line Cross Road, Salem-28. K.Ilangovan @ RajanS/o Kalimuthu C/o Kani Kondi Anjamma O Line, 8th Cross Nalla Seuva, Indira Nagar Guntur, Andhra Pradesh9. SUNDARAMBALW/o Late Iyyavu 120-a Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar Mettur 636 40110. A.Rani W/o Rajan https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis No.4 Allied House Meyvazhisalai Opposite Airport Road, P.T.C.Post Perankudi Madurai11. TAMIZHARASID/o Ayyavu12. A.KalaiselviS/o Iyyavur13. A.KalaiselviW/o Ramu14. A.JohnsilaW/o Singaram At Manicika Vaithiar Compoundnear Karuvttu Mandy Annadhanapatty Salem 636 00215. A.ThenmozhiD/o Late Iyyavu16. A.AnnaduraiS/o Late Iyyavu17. A.SundararajanS/o Late Iyyavu 120-a Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar, Mettur 636 40118. A.KumarS/o Late Iyyavu 120-a Near Ldc Quarters Kaveri Nagar Mettur-119. B. GnanasekarS/o. Late. Balaiya, No.16-g, Behind Medical College Perundhurai (kundrathur Road) Kunnathur, Tiruppur 638 103.20. B. Ramu @ SelvarajS/o. Late. Balaiya, Esan Complex, Behind Jothy Theatre, Ponnamapettai, Salem 636 001.21. B. RajanS/o. Late. Balaiya, No.177, Rajarajan Nagar, Hasthampatti, Salem 636 00722. B. VijayakumarS/o. Late. Balaiya, No.82, Rajarajan Nagar, Alagapuram, Periyapudhur, Hasthampatti, Salem 636 016.23. B. SANKAR(died)S/o. Late. Balaiya, No.82, Rajarajan Nagar, Alagapuram, Periyapudhur, Hasthampatti, Salem 636 016.24. B. Veni @ Krishnaveni https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis W/o. Philip, D/o. Late. Balaiya, No.177, Rajarajan Nagar, Hasthampatti, Salem 636 007.25. S. Devika @ DeviW/o. Sundar, D/o. Late. Balaiya, 311, M-block, Allikuttai Colony, Annahanapatti, Salem 636 002.26. S. RejithaW/o.Late B.Sankar Residing At No.315, Rajaraja Nagar, Hasthampatti, Alagapuram Pudhur Salem-636 016.27. Minor S.SahanaD/O.LATE B.SANKAR REP.BY MOTHER, GUARDIAN AND NEXT FRIEND, RESIDING AT NO.315, RAJARAJA NAGAR, HASTHAMPATTI, ALAGAPURAM PUDHUR SALEM-636 016. r1 died, rr19 to 25 are brought on record as lrs of the deceased r1 and r23 died, rr26 andd 27 are brought on record as lrs of the deceased r23, r26 is appointed as guardian and nextfriend of r27 vide court order dated 14/02/2024 made in cmp nos 8277 of 2021 and 31 and 36 of 2022 in sa no 9 of 2008(GAMJ)

Find similar cases Start drafting free
This is the original judgment text as indexed from the source corpus. Always verify against the official court record before relying on it in a filing — you can do so on eCourts or the Supreme Court of India website. ← Search more judgments