Madras High Court · 2025

C.S.No.576 of 2019as per order dated 10.07.2024 on memo dated 10.07.2024 in C.S.No.576 of 2019D13 & D14 brought on record as legal heirs of the deceased 1st defendant as per order dated 09.09.2024 in A.No.3332 of 2024 and time extended to carryout amendment as per order dated 12.11.2024 in A.No.5603 of 2024.Prayer : Civil Suit filed under Order VII Rule 1 of CPC 1908 Order IV Rule 1 of Original Side Rules for the following reliefs:-(a) for Specific performance by directing the defendants 1 to 12 to execute and register the undivided share held by them and their nominees by way of Sale Deed for 43000 UDS out of the total undivided share of 2,00,000 UDS in the Schedule property in favour of the plaintiffs or their nominees pursuant to the consideration already paid by the plaintiff to the defendants 1 to 12 and upon failure to direct the Court officer to execute the Sale Deed in favour of the Plaintiff.(b) for a permanent injunction restraining the defendants, their men, agents, servants, representatives or any one acting on their behalf from in any manner alienating, encumbering or disposing the suit schedule mentioned property to any third parties.c) to direct the defendant to pass the costs of the suit.d) to grant such other or other relief as this Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case 2/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019For Plaintiffs : Mr.P.R.Raman Sr., Counsel forM/s.Abitha Banu For defendants : Set exparte for D1, D3 to D7, D9 to D14 and D2 an D8 striking out since deceasedJ U D G M E N T The present Suit had been instituted seeking for a relief of Specific Performance as against the defendants 1 to 12 in respect of 43000 undivided shares out of the total undivided share of 2,00,000 in the Suit Mentioned property inter alia seeking for permanent injunction restraining the defendants from in any manner alienating, encumbering or disposing of the suit schedule mentioned property to any third parties.2. The brief facts of the plaintiffs case are that the second defendant had owned a Plot No.2 along with various others, which jointly forms the Schedule Mentioned Property. The owners of the plot were all closely related and they had decided to sell the Schedule Mentioned property and had entered into a Memorandum of Understandings with the said M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt., Ltd. on 10.08.1987 and 15.10.1987. Pursuant thereto, various sale deeds 3/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019were also executed by the respective parties either in their individual capacity or through their power of attorneys. For convenience, the land was divided into 200000 undivided shares of which the first plaintiff being the nominee of the said M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt., Ltd., became owner of 157000 shares and remaining 21.5% of undivided shares were transferred in the name of the defendants. The defendants 3 to 10 are the children of the first and second defendants. 3. It is the further case of the plaintiffs that such transfer of 21.5% undivided share in property and the built-up area was for the reason that the sale consideration in respect of the property remained to be paid in part. He would submit that it was an understanding that had been arrived at by the plaintiffs and the first defendant, who acted as power agent of the second defendant, one of the owner of the property, is that on payment of the said balance sale consideration, the respective owners of the 21.5% share would reconvey the property. It is their further case that such was only an oral understanding between the parties. However, he would submit that by further conduct of the defendants 5 & 10, who are the children of the first defendant (now deceased) have executed sale deeds in favour of plaintiffs subsequently, 4/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019would susbstantiate the oral understanding entered between the parties.4. On the side of the plaintiff, Ms.T.S.Shanti, Authorised Signatory of the first plaintiff has been examined as PW1 and marked Ex.P1 to Ex.P99. The defendants 1, 3 to 7 and 9 to 12 were set exparte on 22.08.2022 and defendants 13 and 14 were set exparte on 13.03.2025 and the defendants 2 and 8 struck out on 15.07.2020.5. Mr.P.R.Raman, learned Senior counsel appearing for the plaintiffs would submit that the defendants 1 & 2 are the husband and wife, the defendants 3 to 10 are their children. The 11th defendant is the father of the 12th defendant. He would further claim that the defendants are closely related. He would submit that under Exs.P.3 to Exs.P.14, the second defendant along with the other owners of the land had entered into a Memorandum of Agreement with one M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt., Ltd., which is the sister concern of the plaintiffs. The schedule mentioned property was originally owned by 12 lands owners including the 2nd defendant. He would further submit that the first defendant had mortgaged plot No.1, which is comprised in Suit Schedule Property and it was the plaintiffs, who had 5/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019redeemed the said mortgage. He would further submit that under Exs.P.15 to Ex.P.94, various sale deeds were executed by the Power of Attorneys in favour of nominees of M/s.Pioneer Housing including the first plaintiff in respect of 78.5% undivided shares amounting to 1,57,000 UDS and the remaining 21.5% amounting to 43000 UDS were transferred in the name of defendants 2 to 10, on oral understanding, it would be transferred to the plaintiffs. He would submit that the transactions in favour of defendants were all made in 1995 on the strength of such oral understanding. By referring to Ex.P.96, he would claim that under 230 payment vouchers/receipts and cheques which form part of Ex.P.96 series, the payments to the defendants have been made after 1995, which would only support the claim of the plaintiffs of the oral understanding that had been reached between the parties. He would submit that the defendants were all set exparte. He would submit that the 5th and 10th defendants were particularly set exparte on 22.08.2022. He would draw attention of this Court that the 5th and 10th defendants under Ex.P.98 and Ex.P.99 had executed two independent sale deeds in favour of the plaintiffs. He would submit that the recitals in the said Exhibits would clearly substantiate the claim of the plaintiffs with regard to the oral understanding, he requests this Court would also take note of the dates of Ex.P.98 and Ex.P.99, 6/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019which are after they were set exparte in the instant Suit.6. Referring to the said Exhibits, he would submit that the 5th and 10th defendants had in categorical terms indicated that the plaintiffs have honoured their commitment of oral understanding and it is the turn of the defendants to execute the sale deeds in favour of the plaintiffs in respect of the shares that were transferred to them. Hence, he prays this Court to grant relief as prayed for.7. I have heard the learned Senior counsel appearing for the plaintiffs and perused the materials placed on record. 8. The Suit for Specific Performance is based upon an oral understanding that had been reached between the plaintiffs and the defendants. From the Exs.P2 to Ex.P14, it could be seen that there has been a Memorandum of Understanding entered between one M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt., Ltd., and the defendants 1, 2 and other land owners, with respect to the Schedule mentioned property, which had been subjected to a development. The plaintiffs have been nominated by the agreement holder 7/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019namely, M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt., Ltd. The power of attorneys on behalf of the said land owners had executed various documents which have been exhibited under Ex.P15 to Ex.P94. A portion of the property had been sold to in favour of defendants D2 to D10. The claim of the plaintiffs is that there has been an oral understanding between the plaintiffs and the defendants for reconveyance of the property in favour of the first plaintiff as and when the balance sale consideration payable by the said M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt., Ltd., is paid by the first plaintiff. The sale deeds executed in favour of the defendants did not reflect any such contingency, but however, under Ex.P.98 and Ex.P.99, the 5th and 10th defendants had executed a sale deeds conveying the shares that were sold to them by the first plaintiff.9. A perusal of Ex.P.98 and Ex.P.99 would explicitly spell out an oral understanding that had been arrived between the plaintiffs and the defendants. The said Exhibits exemplifies such oral understanding. 10. It is further to be noted that the defendants were represented earlier and as they had not filed a written statement, the matter was directed to be listed under the caption “undefended board”. Since, the defendants had not 8/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019filed their written statement, the defendants 1, 3 to 7 and 9 & 12 were all set exparte by orders of this Court. It is also to be noted that the name of the defendants 2 & 8 had been struck off as they had died even before the institution of the Suit. 13th and 14th defendants who were brought on record as the legal heirs of the deceased first defendant by order dated 09.09.2024, had not chosen to enter appearance and they were also set exparte by this Court in its order dated 13.03.2025. Therefore, it is not the case that the defendants were not aware of the proceedings pending before this Court, and they have for the reason best known to them had opted to not continue to prosecute their case.11. In fine, the Suit for Specific Performance is decreed as prayed for as against the defendants 3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 11, 12 & 14 . As regards to the 5th & 10th defendants in view of the execution of Ex.P.98 & Ex.P.99, the prayer as sought for against them has become infructuous. The defendants are directed to execute the necessary sale deeds within a period of 12 weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment, In the event of failure, the Registrar of this Court shall execute the sale deeds in favour of the plaintiffs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous application is closed.9/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019.06.2025Index : Yes / NoInternet:Yes / NoPbn 10/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019List of witnesses examined on the side of the plaintiffs:PW1- Ms.T.S.Santhi (PW.1)List of documents marked on the side of the plaintiffs:ExP1Original Board Resolution dated 26.03.2025ExP2Original Power of Attorney dated 29.03.2025ExP3Original Memorandum of Understanding between Peer Mohammed and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt., Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP4Original Memorandum of Understanding between Khaja Mohideen and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP5Original Memorandum of Understanding between Raja Peer Mohammed and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt., Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP6Original Memorandum of Understanding between 1st defendant and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP7Original Memorandum of Understanding between Mumtaz and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP8Original Memorandum of Understanding between Sayem Anbu Beevi and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP9Original Memorandum of Understanding between Dowlat Koyammal and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP10Original Memorandum of Understanding between Asia Meeran and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP11Original Memorandum of Understanding between Syed Abdul Rahman and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP12Original Memorandum of Understanding between Shamshudeen and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 10.08.198711/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019ExP13Original Memorandum of Understanding between S.M.Syed Abbas and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 10.08.1987ExP14Original Memorandum of Understanding between 2nd defendant and M/s.Pioneer Building Syndicate Pvt Ltd., dated 15.10.1987ExP15Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of K.Shantha in Doc.No.609/1995, dated 23.01.1995.ExP16Certified copy of the Sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of Jayanth Bhoopal in Doc.No.613/1995, dated 15.12.1994ExP17Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.614/1995, dated 15.12.1994.ExP18Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 2nd Defendant in Doc.No.2931/1995, dated 15.12.1994.Ex.P19Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 1st Defendant in Doc.No.2932/1995, dated 15.12.1994.Ex.P20Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 1st Defendant in Doc.No.3428/1995, dated 23.03.1995.Ex.P21Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3429/1995, dated 23.03.1995.Ex.P22Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of Dr.N.Bhagavandas in Doc.No.3430/1995, dated 23.03.1995.Ex.P23Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendants and others in favour of 5th Defendants in Doc.No.3431/1995, dated 23.03.1995.Ex.P24Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of Dr.N.Bhagavandas in Doc.No.3432/1995, 12/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019dated 23.03.1995.Ex.P25Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3435/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P26Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3436/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P27Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 3rd Defendant in Doc.No.3437/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P28Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3438/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P29Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3439/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P30Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 3rd Defendant in Doc.No.3440/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P31Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 5th Defendant in Doc.No.3441/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P32Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 2nd Defendant in Doc.No.3442/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P33Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 1st defendant in Doc.No.3443/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P34Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3444/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P35Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 1st Defendant in Doc.No.3445/1995, dated 24.03.1995.13/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019Ex.P36Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 3rd defendant in Doc.No.3446/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P37Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3452/1995, dated 25.04.1995.Ex.P38Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 4th defendant in Doc.No.3801/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P39Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 6th Defendant in Doc.No.3802/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P40Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 4th defendant in Doc.No.3803/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P41Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 3rd defendant in Doc.No.3804/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P42Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 4th defendant in Doc.No.3805/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P43Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 4th defendant in Doc.No.3806/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P44Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 6th defendant in Doc.No.3807/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P45Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 7th defendant in Doc.No.3808/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P46Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 4th defendant in Doc.No.3809/1995.Ex.P47Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of Nisha Prita Kakumanu in Doc.No.3810/1995.14/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019Ex.P48Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of Tara Keerthi Kakumanu in Doc.No.3811/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P49Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of Tara Keerthi Kakumanu in Doc.No.3812/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P50Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of Nisha Prita Kakumanu in Doc.No.3813/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P51Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3814/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P52Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3815/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P53Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3816/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P54Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3841/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P55Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3857/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P56Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3858/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P57Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 2nd Defendant in Doc.No.3859/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P58Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 2nd Defendant in Doc.No.3860/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P59Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others 15/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019in favour of 6th Defendant in Doc.No.3861/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P60Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 2nd Defendant in Doc.No.3862/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P61Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 1st Defendant in Doc.No.3863/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P62Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 8th Defendant in Doc.No.3864/1995, dated 25.04.1995.Ex.P63Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 6th Defendant in Doc.No.3865/1995, dated 25.04.1995.Ex.P64Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 9th Defendant in Doc.No.3866/1995, dated 25.04.1995.Ex.P65Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd defendant and others in favour of 10th Defendant in Doc.No.3867/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P66Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 6th Defendant in Doc.No.3868/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P67Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 6th Defendant in Doc.No.3869/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P68Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Plaintiff and others in favour of 1st Defendant in Doc.No.3870/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P69Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3872/1995, dated 24.03.1995.Ex.P70Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3954/1995, dated 16/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 201924.03.1995.Ex.P71Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3955/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P72Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3956/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P73Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3957/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P74Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3958/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P75Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3959/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P76Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of Miakhan in Doc.No.3960/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P77Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3961/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P78Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3962/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P79Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3963/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P80Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3964/1995, dated 03.05.1995.Ex.P81Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 2nd Plaintiff in Doc.No.3965/1995, dated 10.05.1995.17/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019Ex.P82Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3966/1995, dated 25.04.1995.Ex.P83Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3967/1995, dated 25.04.1995.Ex.P84Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3968/1995, dated 25.04.1995.Ex.P85Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3969/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P86Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3970/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P87Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3971/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P88Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3972/1995, dated 31.03.1995.Ex.P89Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3973/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P90Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3974/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P91Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3975/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P92Certified copy of the sale deed executed by 2nd Defendant and others in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.3976/1995, dated 10.05.1995.Ex.P93Certified copy of the sale deed executed by K.Shantha and 18/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019K.Ramagopal in favour of Plaintiffs in Doc.No.4456/2006, dated 16.11.2006.Ex.P94Certified copy of the sale deed executed by C Jayanth Bhoopal in favour of 1st Plaintiff in Doc.No.4743/2006, dated 04.12.2006.Ex.P95Photocopy of the Rough SketchEx.P96 Series) (230 Nos)Original Payment Voucher/Receipts/Cheques paid by the Plaintiff between periods 1987 to 2003 Ex.P97Printout of the judgment in O.S.No.12594 of 2010 dated 29.03.2019(Certificate under Section 65B of Indian evidence Act dated 01.04.2025 filed for Ex.P97Ex.P98Certified copy of the sale deed dated 15.05.2023 registered as Doc.No.2117/2023 executed by the 5th defendant in favour of the plaintiff.Ex.P99Certified copy of the sale deed dated 19.10.2022 registered as Doc.No.4572 of 2022 executed by the 10th defendant in favour of the 1st plaintiff.List of witnesses examined on the side of the defendant:NILList of documents marked on the side of the defendant:NIL23.06.2025Pbn 19/20 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis C.S.No.576 of 2019K.KUMARESH BABU.J.,Pbn Pre-Delivery Judgment inC.S.No.576 of 2019& O.A.No.893 of 201923.06.202520/20