✦ High Court of India · 11 Jul 2025

Madrasdated High Court · 2025

Case Details High Court of India · 11 Jul 2025
Court
High Court of India
Decided
11 Jul 2025
Bench
Not available
Length
2,621 words

CMP No. 20004 of 2022Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3230. M.Murugan,S/o.M.Mani, 3, Arulayee Amman Pettai, Alandur Road, Chennai-32.31. V.Venkatesan,S/o. Venkatachalam, 41/1, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3232. G.Mani,S/o. D.Gopal, 109, Gandhi Nagar main Road, Ekkattuthangal, Chennai-3233. J.Mohanraj,S/o. J.S.Jabamani, 23B, First Street, Masoothi colony, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3234. S.Shanmugham,S/o. S.M.Sundaram, 3, Race Park, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3235. M.Srinivasan,S/o. T.Manickam, 56/36, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3236. R.Srinivasan,S/o. V.Radhakrishnan, 2, Ellaiamman Koil Street, Thiruninravur, Chennai- 602 024.37. A.Sekar, https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022S/o. P.Annamalai, 10, Manthoppu 2 nd street, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3238. N.Sekar,S/o. Nataraj, 41, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3239. G.K.Rajendran,S/o. G.Kannan, 19, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3240. S.Samuel,S/o.Chellan, 21, Dhandapani Street, Velanchery, Chennai-42.41. K.Thirunavukkarasu,S/o. V.Kannan, 7, Manthoppu 2 nd street, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai- 32.42. D.Loganathan,S/o. P.Duraikannan, 13/29, Dhandapani Street, Velanchery, Chennai- 42.43. M.Jesudoss,S/o. P.Munusamy, 2/17 B, European Line, St.Thomas Mount, Chennai -1644. V.Kotti,V.Kotti, S/o. Venu, 54, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3245. R.Selvam,S/o. Ramachandran, 14, 4 th street, https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022Kannan Colony, Alandur, Chennai- 16.46. M.Mani,S/o. Munusamy, 24, Dhandapani street, Velachery, Chennai- 42.47. D.Madhan,S/o.P.Durairaj, 18A, kogilam 3 rd cross street, Velachery, Chennai- 42.48. M.Murali Krishnan,S/o.Munivel, No.3, Race Park, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3249. M.Maridoss,S/o. Munusami, 24, Rajiv Gandhi Street, Pallikaranai, Chennai- 600 032.50. D.Suguna,W/o.M.Durai, Race view, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-3251. M.Krishnan,S/o.Mani, 16/33, Dhandapani Street, Velachery, Chennai-42.52. N.Rajan,S/o.Nagaiah, 18/63, Nasarethpuram, St.Thomos Mount, Chennai- 1653. S.Sivaprakasam,S/o.M.Sambantham, 11/9, Sowri Street, Alandur, Chennai-16.54. R.A.Arumugam https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022, S/o.Rajapalayam, 5/62, Nehru Nagar,Nanmangalam, Chennai-117.55. E.Manonmani,W/o.M.Elumalai, 1/21, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-32.56. E.VijayakumarS/o.Ettiappan, 3, 3 rd Street Moongile Lake, Pammal, Pallavaram,Chennai- 75.57. E.Jagannathan,S/o. Etiappan, 3, 3 rd Street Moongile Lake, Pammal, Pallavaram,Chennai- 75.58. E.Ganesan,S/o. Egambaram, 12/9, Parasuraman Street, Velachery, Chennai-42.59. M.Nagarajan,S/o.Manavalan, 22, M.G.R.Street, Bharathi Nagar, Guindy, Chennai-600 032.60. G.Vadivelu,S/o.Ganesan, 9, Masoothi Colony 1 st Street, Guindy, Chennai- 600 032.61. S.Jayaraj,S/o.Penchilaiah, 119, Rajapalayam Street, St.Thomos Mount, Chennai-116.62. E.Krishnan, https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022S/o.Elumalai, 13/5,Kamarajar Street, Velachery, Chennai- 42.63. B.P.Vengatesan,S/o.Pillaiah, 46, Ramar Koil Street, Nasarethpuram, St.Thomos Mount, Chennai- 116.64. G.Punniyakotty,S/o. Ganesan, 45, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai-32.65. G.Kala,W/o.Munusamy, 2/266, Lotus Colony, Sithalpakkam, Valluvar Nagar, Chennai-126.66. A.Noor Mohamed,S/o.A.Abupacker, 3/353, Panchachacharam Nagar, Chinnappanchery, Paraniputhur,Chennai- 122.67. S. S. ManiS/o. V.T. Sampanthamoorthi 24/30, Appavoo street, Alandur, Chennai 16.68. T. GovindarajS/o. M. Thamburan D. no. 9, 122, kambar street, Klambakkam, Urapakkam Po. Kanchipuram Dist 603 202.69. K. MuthuS/o. Kannappan 2/737, Chinna Kovilambakkam, Kolathur, main road, https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022Chennai 117.70. N. KanniappanS/o. Narayanaswamy S2, Sowri Street, Alandur, Chennai 16.71. M. Palani,S/o. Mokkaiah 42/8. 5 th Street, Gangai Nagar, Velachery, Chennai 42.72. B. Sivakumar1S/o. Balaram 5, Paulkat Natesan Street, Velachery, Chennai 42.73. N. K. Ashok Kumaran,S/o. Krishnamoorthi, 33A, 19 th East Cross Street, Vyasarpadi, MKB nagar, Chennai 39.74. V. PushpaW/o. K. vellai D. No. 2B, Kannapiran Kovil Street, Pallikaranai, Chennai 100.75. K.V. VenkatesanS/o. Vishwanathan No. 13, 3 rd street, Moongil Aeri, Pammal, Chennai 75.76. P. kothandaramanS/o. Ponnurangam 48, Five Furlong Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.77. B. DeenadayalanS/o. K.C. Balaram 92, Nasarethpuram, St. Thomas Mount, Chennai 16.78. R. SekarS/o. Raman 10, Kannan colony 3 rd https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022street, Chennai 16.79. P. SureshkumarS/o. Pachaiyappan C-1/5, Chettinad Quarters, R.A. Puram, Chennai 28.80. P.N. VenkatesanS/o. P.N. Naidu 8/43, Nasarethpuram, St. Thomas Mount, Chennai 16.81. P. RajiS/o. Periyasami C/2, Chettinad House, Staff Quarters, R.A. Puram, Chennai 28.82. C. KarunanidhiS/o. P.K. Chandrasekar No.1, Krishnasami Street, Chaman Nagar, Essar Pallavaram, Chennai 43.83. A. Asslam JohnS/o. Abdul Kadhar 43, Muktamji Street, Alandur, Chennai 16.84. G. SankarS/o. S.K. Govindasami No. 28/26, Sanyasi, Subendra Street, Alandur, Chennai 16.85. T. SrinivasanS/o. Tirupaul Kalkuli, Velachery Main Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.86. A. Marimuthu1S/o. D. Arumugam, No. 6, E.V.R Street, Kamarajapuram, Chennai 73. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 202287. M.D.K. NoorullahS/o. K.M. Mohamed Ali 3/29, Nathar Subaidar Street, Alandur, Chennai 15.88. N. Bagavan,S/o. C. Natesan 33, Thiruvalluvar St, Velachery, Chennai 42.89. A. AlbertS/o. Agustin 6/61A, Karayar Kovil Street, St. Thomas Mount, Chennai 92.90. S. KadirvelS/o. Subramani 387, Sheik Abdullah Nagar, Chelliamman Kovil Street, Arugambakkam, Chennai 92.91. V. Govindharaju,S/o. A. Venkatesan 432, Veerapandian Nagar, Nanmangalam, Chennai 117.92. S. John Peter,S/o. M. Selvaraj, 6/4, Karayarkoil Street, St. Thomas mount, Chennai 16.93. G. Selvam,S/o. Govindaraj 20/35, Thiruvalluvar Street, Velachery, Chennai 42.94. H. ParthibanS/o. C. Harikrishnan 110/112, Kannaigapuram 9 th Street, Velachery Main Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.95. K. RajanS/o. Kosinathan 35, Kannigapuram 2 nd https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022Street, Velachery Main Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.96. S. MahendranS/o. Subban No. 4, 10 th Street, CLC Line, Chrompet, Chennai 44.97. P. ChakarapaniS/o. Perumal No. 69, Swamiyar Thottam, Saidapet, Chennai 15.98. M. SivarajS/o, K. Mani 9/5, Puthiya kannigapuram 1 st street, Velachery Main Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.99. B. AnbuS/o. Balu No. 3, Race Park, Five Furlong Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.100. M. JaganathanS/o. Munusamy 46/71, Nemilichery High Road, Chrompet, Chennai 44.101. K. RamsinghS/o. Kamalsingh 11/24, Nathar Subaidar Street, Alandur, Chennai 16.102. M. Chinnadurai1S/o. Mallapuri No. 3, Race Park, Five Furlong Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.103. P. LoganathanS/o. Padavattan 61, Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, St. Thomas, Mount, Chennai 16.104. D. Subramani https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022S/o. Dharuman No. 3, Race Park, Five Furlong Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.105. C. GanesanS/o. Chinnaiah S-3, MRC Staff Quarters, Kannigapuram, Guindy, Chennai 32106. G. SairamS/o. Govindaraj, No. 63, Pillayar Kovil St, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai 32.107. M. DhandapaniS/o. T.M. Moorthi Race View, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai 32.108. D. LazarS/o. J.P. Doss No. 16 B, Sathani Pettai, 2 nd Cross Road, Velachery, Chennai 42.109. M. ManiS/o. Munusami 21/10, Annamali 1 st street, Mettupalayam, West Saidapet, Chennai 33.110. A. AmmavasaiS/o. P. Velan No. 3, D block, MRC Staff Quarters, Velachery Main Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.111. K. HemanathanS/o. M. Kannan 15/23, Kuntrakudi nagar, Neruppamedai, Adambakkam, Chennai 88. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022112. R.K SureshkumarS/o. R. Radhakrishnan 14/27, Mannadiamman Kovil 2 nd street, Adambakkam, Chennai 88.113. R. SampathS/o. C. Ranganathan 1536, 91 st Street, Adambakkam, Chennai 88.114. P. RavikumarS/o. Palanichami, No. 5E, Subash Chandra Bose Streert, Perungudi, Chennai 96.115. M. ShankarS/o. C.S. Munusamy 14/41, M.K.N Road, Subba Reddy Street, Alandur, Chennai 16.116. G. Nagaraj,S/o. S. Ganapathy 7/11 B, Janaki Residency, Madavaperumal south street, Alandur, Chennai 16.117. P. SathyakumarS/o. Ponnusami No. 4, Krishnamoorthi St, Bharathi nagar, Guindy, Chennai 32.118. A. AnthonyS/o. Antony Francies No. 9, Bharathi Street, Bharathi nagar, Guindy, Chennai 32.119. V. Prabhu https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022S/o. S.M. Vadivelu N0. 72. Venkatapuram, Saidapet, Chennai 15.120. A. JayachandranS/o. Ankaiah No. 132, 9 th street, Debor Nagar, Vyasarpadi, Chennai 39.121. K. GopinathS/o. K. Kanniappan No. 4, Thiruvalluvar 3 rd Street, Adambakkam, Chennai 88.122. E. SivakumarS/o. Elumalai No. 70, Thiruvalluvar Street, Manamai, Kalpakkam Road, Kanchipuram District.123. P. SaravananS/o. Panchatcharam No. 317, Palur, Chengleput, kanchipuram Dist.124. C. SathyakumarS/o. D. Chakrapani 12/34, Kaaji St, Alandur, Chennai 16.125. D. ChakarapaniS/o. M. Dhansing 34/B, 12/34, Kaaji St, Alandur, Chennai 16.126. A. VijayakumarS/o. V. Ammavasai No. 3, Kannigapuram, Velachery Main Road. Guindy, Chennai 32.127. P. MalcomS/o. A. Patrick D 3, New Quarters, https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022Race Course Interior Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.128. R. RubanS/o. Royappan No. 2, Adambakkam Kuntrakudi Nagar, Chennai 88.129. G. SivakumarS/o. K. Govindan 4/31, Mannadiamman 2 nd street, Adambakkam, Chennai 88.130. R. RajiS/o. Rangan 5, M.G.R. Street, Bharathi Nagar, Guindy, Chennai 32.131. X. FrancisS/o. Xavier No. 5, J Block, Raj Bhavan, Chennai 22.132. K. ElumalaiS/o. Kannan No.1/286, Indragandhi Street, Jaladeganpettai, Chennai.133. M. Leo CanveyS/o. P. Malcom D 3, New Quarters, race Course Interior, Guindy, Chennai 32.134. M. RameshS/o. N. Munusamy R1, MRC Staff Quarters Interior Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.135. M. VeluS/o. N. Munusamy 19B, Bakthawatchalam Street, Sakthi nagar, Lakshmipuram, Malayambakkam, https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022Kanchipuram District.136. K. SudhakarS/o. Kumar 19/44, Dhandapani street, Velachery, Chennai 42.137. B. RajiS/o. Balakrishnan No. 52, Five Furlong Road, Maduvinkarai, Guindy, Chennai 32.138. K. GovindasamyS/o. G. Kannan No. 37, Five Furlong Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.139. H. ArulS/o. P. D. Hentry No. 5, Perambanur, Maraimalai nagar, Kanchipuram district.140. K. SureshS/o. C. Kuttamani No. 3, Race Park, Five Furlong Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.141. M. SenthilS/o. Muthu No. 3, Race Park, Five Furlong Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.142. S. ChandranS/o. Somu 54, 4 th street, Annai Sathya nagar, Poothapedu, Ramvaram Chennai 89.143. Antony UdayakumarS/o. Shanmugam No. 3, Race Park, https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022Five Furlong Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.144. M. Sarom SahayamS/o. A. Michael No. 3, Race Park, Five Furlong Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.145. A. MayalaguS/o. Alagumalai No. 13, karthikeyapuram, 12 th street, Madipakkam, Chennai 91146. S. V. BaburajS/o. Vadivel No. 9, MRC Interior Staff Quarters, Guindy, Chennai 32.147. D. KarnanS/o. Duraikannu 19/44, Dhandapani street, Velachery, Chennai 42.148. K. SaravananS/o. M. kanniappan 2/58, B Dharmaraja kovil street Kovoor, Chennai 128.149. R. KandaswamyS/o. Radakrishnan 87, Sakthi nagar, 6 th street, Ponneri, Thiruvallur District.150. V. SaravananS/o. M. Varadhan 3/707, Amman Koil street, Gerugambakkam, Chennai 122.151. D. SeetharamanS/o. Duraikannu 35, Appavooru Street, Alandur, Chennai 16.152. G. R. Selvam https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022S/o. G. Ramu N0. 9, Bharathi Street, Gandi nagar, vijayanagar Extension, Chennai 42.153. M. GopinathS/o. Murugesan 5/11A, Dhandapani Street, Velachery, Chennai 42.154. R. Schellito Aninel GarfieldS/o. R.P. Schellito 29, Rajambal Street, Saidapet, Chennai 83.155. T. MathialaganS/o. Tulukanam 24/36, Dhandapani street, Velachery, Chennai 42.156. S. MoorthiS/o. Srinivasan 24/36, Dhandapani street, Velachery, Chennai 42.157. K. KumaresanS/o. E. Krishnan No. 44A/36, Bharathi nagar, Bharathi Street, Guindy, Chennai 32.158. M. SamuelS/o. Manashe No. 10, Bharathiyar street, Krishna nagar, Pammal, Chennai 75.159. S.Ramesh Pandi, S/o.K.Sekar, No.4B, Kalaivani Street, Venkateshwara Nagar, Ambatoor, Chennai.160. B. Santhosh Singh https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022S/o. Balaji 24, Natham Subbaidar street, Alandur, Chennai 16.161. J. SrinivasanS/o. G. Jayaraman No. 29, SRP Kovil street, Agaram, Chennai 82.162. D. YuvarajS/o. Duraisamy No. 1, D Block, MRC Staff Quarters Race course, Interior road, Guindy, Chennai 32.163. M.R. Pari ChelvanS/o. M.K. Ramadoss 10, Nethaji Street, Bharathi nagar, Guindy, Chennai 32.164. R. KumarS/o. Raman 10, 4 th street, kannan colony, Alandur, Chennai 16.Appellant(s)Vs1. The Madras Race ClubRep. By its Secretary, Post Box No.2639 Guindy, Chennai-600 032Respondent(s)OSA No. 178 of 20151. M.Victor2.N.Guru https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 20223.V.Sivan4.E.Rajini5.A.Elumalai6.V.Manoharan7.K.Veeran8.M.Pattu9.K.Shanmugam10.R.Kesavan11.E.Ravi12.M.Padma13.N.Selvam14.S.Santha15.K.Asai https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 202216.V.Mani17.R.Sudhar18.V.Jayaraman19.S.Venkatesh20.M.Chellappan21.R.Perumal22.D.Ravi23.M.Rajendran24.S.Rajapeter25.M.Jesudoss26.V.Gipsonraj27.S.Mahendran https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 202228.T.Punniakotti29.G.M.Murugan30.M.Murugan31.V.Venkatesan32.G.Mani33.J.Mohanraj34.S.Shanmugam35.M.Srinivasan36.R.Srinivasan37.A.Sekar38.N.Sekar39.G.K.Rajendran40.S.Samuel https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 202241.K.Thirunavukarasu42.D.Loganthan43.M.Jesudoss44.V.Kotti45.R.Selvam46.M.Mani47.D.Madhan48.M.Murali Krishnan49.M.Mariadoss50.D.Suguna51.M.Krishnan52.N.Rajan https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 202253.S.Sivaprakasam54.R.A.Arumugam55.E.Manonmani56.E.Vijayakumar57.E.Jagannathan58.E.Ganesan59.M.Nagarajan60.G.Vadivelu61.S.Jayaraj62.E.Krishnan63.B.P.Vengatesan64.G.Punniyakotty65.G.Kala https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 202266.A.Noor Mohamed67.S.S.Mani68.T.Govindaraj69.K.Muthu70.N.Kanniappan71.M.Palani72.B.Sivakumar73.N.K.Ashok Kumaran74.V.Pushpa75.K.V.Venkatesan76.P.Kothandaraman77.B.Deenadayalan https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 202278.R.Sekar79.P.Sureshkumar80.P.N.Venkatesan81.P.Raji82.C.Karunanidhi83.A.Asslam John84.G.Sankar85.T.Srinivasan86.A.Marimuthu87.M.D.K.Noorullah88.N.Bagavan89.A.Albert90.S.Kadirvel https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 202291.V.Govindharaju92.S.John Peter93.G.Selvam94.H.Parthiban95.K.Rajan96.S.Mahendran97.P.Chakarapani98.M.Sivaraj99.B.Anbu100.M.Jaganathan101.K.Ramsingh102.M.Chinnadurai https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022103.P.Loganathan104.D.Subramani105.C.Ganesan106.G.Sairam107.M.Dhandapani108.D.Lazar109.M.Mani110.A.Ammavasai111.K.Hemanathan112.R.K.Sureshkumar113.R.Sampath114.P.Ravikumar115.M.Shankar https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022116.G.Nagaraj117.P.Sathyakumar118.A.Anthony119.V.Prabhu120.A.Jayachandran121.K.Gopinath122.E.Sivakumar123.P.Saravanan124.C.Sathyakumar125.D.Chakarapani126.A.Vijayakumar127.P.Malcom https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022128.R.Ruban129.G.Sivakumar130.R.Raji131.X.Francis132.K.Elumalai133.M.Leo Canvey134.M.Ramesh135.M.Velu136.K.Sudhakar137.B.Raji138.K.Govindasamy139.H.Arul140.K.Suresh https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022141.M.Senthil142.S.Chandran143.Antony Udayakumar144.M.Sarom Sahayam145.A.Mayalagu146.S.V.Baburaj147.D.Karnan148.K.Saravanan149.R.Kandaswamy150.V.Saravanan151.D.Seetharaman152.G.R.Selvam https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022153.M.Gopinath154.R.Schellito Aninel Garfield155.T.Mathialagan156.S.Moorthi157.K.Kumaresan158.M.Samuel159.S.Ramesh Pandi160.B.Santhosh Singh161.J.Srinivasan162.D.Yuvaraj163.M.R.Pari Chelvan164.R.KumarAppellant(s) https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022Vs1. The Madras Race ClubRep.By Its Secretary, Post Box No.2639 Guindy, Chennai 32Respondent(s)CMP No. 20004 of 2022PRAYERTo allow this petition and issue clarification in the order of O.S.A.No.178 of 2015 and M.P.No.1 of 2015 dated 09.09.2015CMP No. 20004 of 2022For Appellant(s):Mr. V. Prakash, Senior Counsel For Mr. K.Sudalaikannu, For AppellantFor Respondent(s):Mr.L.Damodharan (caveator) For Respondent.ORDER(Order of the Court was made by Dr.Anita Sumanth,J.)The OSA to which the present Miscellaneous Petition relates has been disposed on 09.09.2015 in the following terms:'4. In the aforesaid contours of the dispute, it is agreed that the appeal may be disposed of in the following terms:a) Written statement having been filed, the replication may be filed within two weeks thereof.b) In view of the limited nature of evidence required, keeping in mind the already overburdened roster of the Master list, it is agreed that the evidence be recorded before a retired Judicial Officer, to expedite the final disposal of the suit. Normally in such a case, the costs would be borne in https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022equal shares, but given the unequal position of the two parties, the respondent has to bear the costs of recording the evidence which is quantified at Rs.50,000/- apart from out of packet expenses.c) We appoint Mr.C.Manickam, a retired Judicial Officer to record evidence.d) So far as preparing the suit for recording of evidence is concerned, the matter be listed before the learned single Judge for framing of issues on 30th September, 2015. e) The parties will file their respective documents within two weeks thereafter and the matter be listed before the Master on 14th October, 2015 for exhibiting the documents. Thereafter, the evidence will be recorded before the Commissioner. f) On recording of evidence being completed, the matter be listed for direction before the learned single Judge for giving a final quietus to the matter inview of the limited issues involved and also in line with the view of the learned single Judge that the relief in the nature of interlocutory stage is really a relief at the final stage.'2. Thereafter, it appears that the defendant in the suit, ie., the employer, Madras Race Club did not pay the sum of Rs.50,000/- to the retired Judicial Officer appointed for taking evidence and hence there was no progress on that front. While so, the suit was transferred to XXI Additional City Civil Court, Lilly Pond Complex, Chennai on account of the pecuniary jurisdiction of the High Court. 3. Hence the present petition has come to be filed by the https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022plaintiffs/petitioners seeking a clarification as to whether the Trial Court can record evidence. Though the name of Mr.L.Damodharan, learned counsel who is on caveat is printed for the Madras Race Club, there is no appearance on their behalf. 4. Since the suit is of the year 2012 and taking into account the nature of the relief sought, no further time should be lost in proceeding further with the matter. Hence a direction is to given to XXI Additional City Civil Judge, Lilly Pond Complex, Chennai to proceed with the matter, record evidence, complete the trial and dispose the same within a period of four (4) months from date of receipt of a copy of this order. 5. The Miscellaneous Petition stands allowed. No costs.[A.S.M.,J][N.S.,J] 11.07.2025slTo1.The Madras Race ClubRep. By its Secretary, Post Box No.2639 Guindy, Chennai-600 0322. XXI Additional City Civil Court, Lilly Pond Complex, Chennai https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 20004 of 2022ANITA SUMANTH J.ANDN.SENTHILKUMAR J.slCMP No. 20004 of 2022AND OSA NO. 178 OF 201511-07-2025

This is the original judgment text as indexed from the source corpus. Always verify against the official court record before relying on it in a filing — you can do so on eCourts or the Supreme Court of India website. ← Search more judgments