Original v. Mukesh Madhukar Mahale and Others
Case Details
(1) speaking-arb-119-2020 & ors. IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD (1) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 119 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1055 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8496 OF 2020 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Mukesh Madhukar Mahale and Others /Original Claimants ...Respondents ... WITH (2) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 2 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 443 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8451 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Arun Vitthal Naik ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (3) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 3 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 444 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8436 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha Original Respondent ...Appellant/ Versus Ravindra Wamanrao Patil ...Original Claimant /Respondent ... WITH (4) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 7 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 449 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8437 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ (2) speaking-arb-119-2020 & ors. Versus Original Respondent Ravindra Ramchandra Chaudhari ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (5) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 8 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 450 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8438 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Vijay Sudam Patil ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (6) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 9 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 451 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8439 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Rajendra Ambadas Rane ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (7) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 10 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 452 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8455 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha .Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Nilesh Murlidhar Karande /Respondent ...Original Claimant … WITH (8) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 11 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 453 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8452 OF 2022 (3) speaking-arb-119-2020 & ors. National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha Original Respondent ...Appellant/ Versus Vasant Baliram Talele and Anr. ...Original Claimants /Respondents … WITH (9) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 12 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 454 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8448 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Ninu Ramkrishsna Badhe ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (10) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 13 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 455 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8425 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Pundalik Shankar Patil ...Original Claimant /Respondent ... WITH (11) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 14 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 456 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8422 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Eknathrao Ganpatrao Khadase ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (12) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 30 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 694 OF 2020 (4) speaking-arb-119-2020 & ors. WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8457 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Bhaskar Govind Zope and Ors. ...Original Claimants /Respondents … WITH (13) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 39 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 732 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8460 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha Original Respondent .Appellant/ Versus Prabhakar Sopan Zope ...Original Claimant /Respondent ... WITH (14) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO.40 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 734 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8434 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ...Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Jyoti Chandrashekhar Badhe ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (15) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 41 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 735 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8424 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ...Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Sandip Ramesh Khachane ...Original Claimant /Respondent (5) speaking-arb-119-2020 & ors. ... WITH (16 ) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO.42 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 736 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8450 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha Original Respondent Versus .Appellant/ Nalini Vasudeo Badhe ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (17) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO.43 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 737 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8432 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ...Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Vasudeo Shankar Kolhe and Anr. ...Original Claimants /Respondents … WITH (18) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 46 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 741 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8441 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Vijay Gagdish Patil ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (19) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 47 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 742 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8497 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus (6) speaking-arb-119-2020 & ors. Kundabai Arun Mali ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (20) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO.51 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 758 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8514 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ....Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Vasudev Rama Bhangale ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (21) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 52 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 761 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8515 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Avinash Ramchandra Sarode ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (22) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 53 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 763 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8516 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Mandakini Eknathrao Khadase ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (23) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 63 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 789 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8517 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, (7) speaking-arb-119-2020 & ors. Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Shailesh Kalidas Patil and Anr. ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (24) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 75 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 823 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8518 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha Original Respondent .Appellant/ Versus Mangala Vasudev Badhe ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (25) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO.76 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 824 OF 2020 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Madhukar Mahadhu Khachane and Anr. ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (26) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 79 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 842 OF 2020 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Gajanan Balkrishna Patil ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (27) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 80 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 843 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8493 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, (8) speaking-arb-119-2020 & ors. Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Hari Narayan Zope ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (28) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 81 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 844 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8498 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha .Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Gopal Narayan Khachane ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (29) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 83 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 847 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8494 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Namdev Trambak Badhe and Anr. ...Original Claimants /Respondents … WITH (30) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 84 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 848 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8495 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha .Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Pradip Barsu Badhe and Anr. ...Original Claimants /Respondents (9) speaking-arb-119-2020 & ors. … WITH (31) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 97 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 921 OF 2020 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Vasudeo Raghunath Patil ...Original Claimant /Respondent … WITH (32) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 103 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 928 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8513 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Murlidhar Vishvanath Patil and Ors. ...Original Claimants /Respondents … (33) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 104 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 929 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 9649 OF 2022 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Vasudeo Raghunath Patil and Ors. ...Original Claimants /Respondents … WITH (34) ARBITRATION APPEAL NO. 112 OF 2020 WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1047 OF 2020 National Highways Authority of India, Project Implementation Unit, Jalgaon, Through its: Project Director Chandrakant M. Sinha ….Appellant/ Original Respondent Versus Vasant Sopan Patil and Ors. ...Original Claimants /Respondents … (10) 2020 & ors. speaking-arb-119-
Legal Reasoning
Mr. Deepak S. Manorkar, Advocate instructed by Mr. M.V. Kini and Company for Petitioner, in all matters; Mr. Vinod Patil, Advocate for Respondent Nos.1 to 3, in all matters CORAM : SANDEEP V. MARNE, J. DATED : 22nd DECEMBER, 2022. PER COURT:- 1. Motion is made for speaking to the minutes in respect of order dated 19.12.2022. 2. In paragraph no.12 of the order the words ‘in this Court’ shall be replaced with words ‘Competent Authority, Land Acquisition, Jalgaon’. 3. 4. The corrected copy of the order be issued.
Decision
Motion is disposed of. (SANDEEP V. MARNE) JUDGE Devendra/December-2022