High Court
Case Details
2025:BHC-AUG:24904 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated //
Legal Reasoning
P-1.odtIN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYBENCH AT AURANGABADWRIT PETITION NO. 13430 OF 2024Shaikh Babu Shaikh HasanVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through Secretary And OthersWITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13442 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13446 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13913 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13925 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13428 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13929 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13444 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13917 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13438 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13424 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13922 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13923 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13911 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13440 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13919 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13441 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 12226 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13426 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13445 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13425 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13439 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13908 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13924 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13928 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13927 OF 2024 WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13926 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 12228 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13427 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13915 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13918 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13910 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 12242 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13930 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13909 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13912 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13906 OF 2024UmeshPAGE 1 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated //
Legal Reasoning
P-1.odtWITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13914 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 12227 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13443 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13907 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13931 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13916 OF 2024WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 12235 OF 2024***• Mr. A. A. More, Advocate for the Petitioners***CORAM:R. M. JOSHI, JDATE:SEPTEMBER 25, 2025PER COURT : 1.This motion is moved for speaking to minutesof order dated 15.09.2025.2.It is submitted that in line 1 of paragraph 5inadvertently the word ‘not’ after word shall isremained to be incorporated.3.This being inadvertent error, the prayer forspeaking to minutes is allowed. After carrying outnecessary corrections, fresh order be uploaded. (R. M. JOSHI, J.) UmeshPAGE 2 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odt(This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dated 25.09.2025)IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYBENCH AT AURANGABADWRIT PETITION NO. 13430 OF 2024Shaikh Babu Shaikh HasanVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through Secretary And OthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13442 OF 2024Vilas Shrirang YadavVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13446 OF 2024Subhash Bhanudas YedleVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13913 OF 2024Anwar Divanshah SayyadVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13925 OF 2024Dadarao Tatyarao Samudre Died Thr Lrs Saraswati DadaraoSamudreVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHUmeshPAGE 3 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odtWRIT PETITION NO. 13428 OF 2024Damu Satvaji KordeVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13929 OF 2024Vasant Khandu TongaleVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13444 OF 2024Manchak Sadashiv KambleVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13917 OF 2024Najir Rasul Shaikh Died Through Lrs Ekabal Najir ShaikhVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13438 OF 2024Harishchandra Raghunath SonawaneVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthers WITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13424 OF 2024Vishwanath Jagdevappa Birajdar Died Through LrsGodavari Vishwanath Birajdar And OthersUmeshPAGE 4 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odtVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13922 OF 2024Laxman Gundaji SulVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13923 OF 2024Amir Dadamiya PathanVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13911 OF 2024Dayanand Gangaramappa BidveVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13440 OF 2024Riyajoddin Burhanoddin SayyadVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13919 OF 2024Kondiba Bapurao UjlambeVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthers UmeshPAGE 5 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odtWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13441 OF 2024Sudhakar Shankarrao GhembadVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 12226 OF 2024Shripati Govind SuryawanshiVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13426 OF 2024Yeshwant Devidasrao KulkarniVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthers WITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13445 OF 2024Nehru Gyanoba GhorpadeVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13425 OF 2024Annarao Vishwanath MahajanVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13439 OF 2024Laxman Ambadas BhartiUmeshPAGE 6 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odtVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13908 OF 2024Shardabai Manohar TingareVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13924 OF 2024Murlidhar Bapurao Jadhav Died Through Lrs SumanMurlidhar JadhavVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13928 OF 2024Usman Abdul ShaikhVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13927 OF 2024Gangadhar Prabhu Survase Died Through Lrs RukminbaiGangadhar Survase And OthersVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthers WITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13926 OF 2024Manikrao Laxman Jagtap Died Through Lrs IndubaiManikrao JagtapVERSUSUmeshPAGE 7 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odtThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 12228 OF 2024Venkat Premchand UdgirkarVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13427 OF 2024Tukaram Pundlik BarcheVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13915 OF 2024Ananda Gopal Shinde Died Thr Lrs Urmila Shriram ShindeVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13918 OF 2024Suman Vasant TongaleVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13910 OF 2024Shivaji Dnyanoba Survase Died Through Lrs Vimal ShivajiSurvase And OthersVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHUmeshPAGE 8 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odtWRIT PETITION NO. 12242 OF 2024Shrishailya Vithoba VairagkarVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13930 OF 2024Indrajit Laxman Musande Died Through Lrs VijayaIndrajit MusandeVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13909 OF 2024Raghunath Nagnath Ubale Died Through Lrs Saroj NagrajChatrabandVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13912 OF 2024Virbhadra Shankarappa Muchate Died Thr Lrs NilavatiVirbhadra Muchate And OthersVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13906 OF 2024Taimur Munnakha PathanVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through Its Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13914 OF 2024UmeshPAGE 9 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odtShripati Eknath Bhosale Died Through Lrs NajukabaiShripati BhosaleVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 12227 OF 2024Tamma Vithoba VairagkarVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13443 OF 2024Sheshrao Mahadeo ShindeVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13907 OF 2024Bhanudas Pandhari KambleVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13931 OF 2024Goroba Sambhaji Gandle Died Through Lrs Baburao GorobaGandleVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 13916 OF 2024Vishwanath Nagnath HarsudeVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndUmeshPAGE 10 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odtOthersWITHWRIT PETITION NO. 12235 OF 2024Manohar Vishwanath SwamiVERSUSThe State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary AndOthers...Mr. A. A. More, Advocate for the PetitionerMr. V. M. Chate, AGP for Respondent Nos. 1 and 2Mr. P. P. Shahane, Advocate for Respondent No. 3***CORAM:R. M. JOSHI, JDATE:SEPTEMBER 15, 2025PER COURT : 1.These Petitions are heard for some time.2.Learned Counsel for the Petitioners, oninstructions, makes statement that Petitioners wouldget their right determined from the CompetentAuthority/Court in accordance with law. If such rightis determined, liberty be granted to the Petitionersmove an application under Section 33(C-2) of theIndustrial Disputes Act, 1947.3.Learned Counsel for Respondent No. 3. opposesthe same.4.Prima facie perusal of the impugned orderUmeshPAGE 11 OF 12 This Order is Speaking to Minutes order of order dated // P-1.odtindicates that for want of pre determination of rightof the Petitioners, Applications under Section 33(C-2)of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, which is in thenature of execution proceedings, came to be rejected.The workmen are within their right to get the disputedissue adjudicated from competent Court and then to seekexecution thereof. Hence, Petitions stand dismissed aswithdrawn with liberty as prayed.5.Dismissal of the Petitions shall not come inway of the workmen to get their rights determined inaccordance with law. (R. M. JOSHI, J.) UmeshPAGE 12 OF 12