Jalna v. Vivek Vinayakrao Ghare, Age
Case Details
1 fa 2452-17 +11 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD FIRST APPEAL NO.2452 OF 2017 The Executive Engineer, L.M.I. Division Jalna, District : Jalna. .... APPELLANT (Ori. Respondent No.2) 1. 2. 3. VERSUS Sanjivanibai Subhashrao Salunke, Age : Major, Occu: H.H. & Agril. R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna The State of Maharashtra, Through the Collector, Jalna .... Respondent No.1 (Ori. Claimant) The Special Land Acquisition Offcer(Gaothan), Jalna, Tq. & Dist. Jalna ....(Respondent Nos.2 to 3) (Ori. Resp. No.1 & 3) ..... Advocate for Appellant : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondent No.1 Mr. D. M. Kakade AGP for Respondent Nos.2 & 3 : Mr. A. A. Jagatkar ..... AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2464 OF 2017 The Executive Engineer, L.M.I. Division Jalna, District : Jalna. VERSUS 1. 2. Murlidhar Dattatraya Ghare, Age : Major, Occu: Agril. Sandipan Dattatraya Ghare, Age : Major, Occu.: Agril., .... APPELLANT (Ori. Respondent No.2) 2 fa 2452-17 +11 3. 4. 1. 2. 3. R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna The State of Maharashtra, Through the Collector, Jalna .... Respondent No.1 & 2 (Ori. Claimants) The Special Land Acquisition Offcer(Gaothan), Jalna, Tq. & Dist. Jalna ....(Respondent Nos.3 to 4) (Ori. Resp. No.1 & 3)
Legal Reasoning
..... Advocate for Appellant : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondent Nos.1 & 2 Mr. D. M. Kakade AGP for Respondent Nos.3 & 4 : Mr. A. A. Jagatkar ..... AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2216 OF 2017 The Executive Engineer, L.M.I. Division Jalna, District : Jalna. VERSUS Vivek Vinayakrao Ghare, Age : Major, Occu: Agril. R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna The State of Maharashtra, Through the Collector, Jalna .... APPELLANT (Ori. Respondent No.2) .... Respondent No.1 (Ori. Claimant) The Special Land Acquisition Offcer(Gaothan), Jalna, Tq. & Dist. Jalna ....(Respondent Nos.2 to 3) (Ori. Resp. No.1 & 3)
Legal Reasoning
..... Advocate for Appellant : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondent No.1 Mr. D. M. Kakade AGP for Respondent Nos.2 & 3 : Mr. A. A. Jagatkar ..... 3 fa 2452-17 +11 AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2451 OF 2017 The Executive Engineer, L.M.I. Division Jalna, District : Jalna. VERSUS Vivekrao Prabhakar Ghare, Age : Major, Occu: Agril. R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna The State of Maharashtra, Through the Collector, Jalna .... APPELLANT (Ori. Respondent No.2) .... Respondent No.1 (Ori. Claimant) The Special Land Acquisition Offcer(Gaothan), Jalna, Tq. & Dist. Jalna ....(Respondent Nos.2 to 3) (Ori. Resp. No.1 & 3) ..... Advocate for Appellant : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondent No.1 Mr. D. M. Kakade AGP for Respondent Nos.2 & 3 : Mr. A. A. Jagatkar ..... AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2095 OF 2019 WITH CA/10023/2015 The Executive Engineer, Minor Irrigation Division No.1, Jalna. State of Maharashtra, Through Collector, Jalna The Special Land Acquisition Offcer (Gaothan), Jalna APPELLANTS .... (Ori. Respondents) 1. 2. 3. 1. 2. 3. 4 fa 2452-17 +11 VERSUS Yashwant Vywankatroa Ghare (died) Through his L.R's : Chhaya wd/o Yashwant Ghare, Age : 48 years, Occu.: Agril, Kalyan s/o Yashwant Ghare, Age : 44 years, Occu.: Agril., Kishor s/o Yashwant Ghare, Age : 42 years, Occu.: Agril., Umesh s/o Yashwant Ghare, Age : 25 years, Occu.: Agril, 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Madhavi Shrimantrao Chavan, 6. 7. 8. Age : 50 years, Occu.: Household, Savita Haribhau Uddange, Age : 48 years, Occu.: Household, Manisha Rajesh Sarkate, Age ; 46 years, Occu.: Household, Kanchan Pradip Patil, Age : 40 years, Occu.: Household, All R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna. .... RESPONDENTS (Ori. Claimants) ..... Advocate for Appellants : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondents : Mr. D. M. Kakade ..... AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2201 OF 2017 .... APPELLANT (Ori. Respondent No.2) The Executive Engineer, L.M.I. Division Jalna, District : Jalna. VERSUS 1. Yogesh Udhavrao Ghare, Age : Major, Occu: Agril. 2. Umesh Udhavrao Ghare, 5 fa 2452-17 +11 Age : Major, Occu.: Student, Both R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna .... The State of Maharashtra, Through the Collector, Jalna Respondent Nos.1 to 2 (Ori. Claimants) The Special Land Acquisition Offcer(Gaothan), Jalna, Tq. & Dist. Jalna ....(Respondent Nos.3 to 4) (Ori. Resp. No.1 & 3) ..... Advocate for Appellant : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondent Nos.1 & 2 Mr. D. M. Kakade AGP for Respondent Nos.3 & 4 : Mr. A. A. Jagatkar ..... AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2215 OF 2017 The Executive Engineer, L.M.I. Division Jalna, District : Jalna. .... APPELLANT (Ori. Respondent No.2) VERSUS Vishwasrao Rajaram Bagve, Age : Major, Occu: Agril. Prashantkumar Vishwasrao Bagve, Age : Major, Occu.: Agril, Preshkumar Vishwasrao Bagve, Age : Major, Occu.: Agril., Sachinkumar Vishwasrao Bagve, Age : Major, Occu.; Agril All R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna The State of Maharashtra, Through the Collector, Jalna .... Respondent Nos.1 to 4 (Ori. Claimants) 3. 4. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. The Special Land Acquisition Offcer 6 fa 2452-17 +11 (Gaothan), Jalna, Tq. & Dist. Jalna ....(Respondent Nos.5 to 6) (Ori. Resp. No.1 & 3) ..... Advocate for Appellant : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondent Nos.1 to 4 Mr. D. M. Kakade AGP for Respondent Nos.5 & 6 : Mr. A. A. Jagatkar .... AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2466 OF 2017 1. 2. 3. 1. 2. The Executive Engineer, Minor Irrigation Division No.1, Jalna. State of Maharashtra, Through Collector, Jalna The Special Land Acquisition Offcer, (Gaothan), Jalna .... APPELLANTS (Ori. Respondents) VERSUS Dnyanesh s/o Vinayakrao Ghare, Age : Major, Occu: Agril. R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna .... RESPONDENT (Ori. Claimant) ..... Advocate for Appellants : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondent No.1 Mr. D. M. Kakade ..... AND FIRST APPEAL NO.3501 OF 2015 The Executive Engineer, Minor Irrigation Division No.1, Jalna. State of Maharashtra, Through Collector, Jalna 7 fa 2452-17 +11 3. The Special Land Acquisition Offcer, (Gaothan), Jalna APPELLANTS .... (Ori. Respondents) VERSUS Arvind Ankushrao Ghare, Age : Major, Occu: Agril. R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna .... RESPONDENT (Ori. Claimant) ..... Advocate for Appellants : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondent : Mr. D. M. Kakade ..... AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2450 OF 2017 1. 2. 3. The Executive Engineer, L.M.I. Division Jalna, District : Jalna. VERSUS Sunetrabai Vishwasrao Bagve, Age : Major, Occu: H.H. & Agril. R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna The State of Maharashtra, Through the Collector, Jalna .... APPELLANT (Ori. Respondent No.2) .... Respondent No.1 (Ori. Claimant) The Special Land Acquisition Offcer (Gaothan), Jalna, Tq. & Dist. Jalna .... (Respondent No.2 to 3) (Ori. Resp. No.1 & 3) ..... Advocate for Appellant : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondent No.1 Mr. D. M. Kakade AGP for Respondent Nos.2 & 3 : Mr. A. A. Jagatkar ... 8 fa 2452-17 +11 AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2479 OF 2017 1. 2. 3. a) b) The Executive Engineer, Minor Irrigation Division No.1, Jalna. State of Maharashtra, Through Collector, Jalna The Special Land Acquisition Offcer, (Gaothan), Jalna APPELLANTS .... (Ori. Respondents) VERSUS Dilip Ankushrao Ghare (died) Through his legal heirs : Arvind Ankushrao Ghare, Age : 58 years, Occu.: Agril., Balasaheb Ankushrao Ghare, Age : 50 years, Occu.: Agril., Both R/o.: Kendhali, Tq. Mantha, District : Jalna .... RESPONDENTS (Ori. Claimants) ..... Advocate for Appellants : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondents : Mr. D. M. Kakade .... AND FIRST APPEAL NO.2465 OF 2017 1. 2. 3. The Executive Engineer, Minor Irrigation Division No.1, Jalna. State of Maharashtra, Through Collector, Jalna The Special Land Acquisition Offcer, (Gaothan), Jalna .... APPELLANTS (Ori. Respondents) 9 fa 2452-17 +11 VERSUS Sundarrao s/o Gopvindrao Ghare (died) Through his legal heirs : 1(a) Laxmibai w/o Sunderrao Ghare (died) 1(b) Bhaskar s/o Sunderrao Ghare, Age : 66 years, Occ.: Agriculture, 1(c) Pradeep s/o Sunderrao Ghare, Age : 48 years, Occu.: Agriculture, 1(d) Sumanbai w/o Sureshrao Bodke, Age : 60 years, Occu.: Househld, 1(e) Sushila w/o Vikas Salunke, Age : 38 years, Occu.: Household, R/o.: Green Field School, Plot No. 18, Smarthnagar, Aurangabad. .... RESPONDENTS (Ori. Claimants) ..... Advocate for Appellants : Mr. R. C. Patil Advocate for Respondents : Mr. D. M. Kakade .... CORAM DATE : 20/09/2022 : SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE, J. ORDER : 1. All these appeals are preferred by the appellant, who is original respondent No.2 in the respective LAR as mentioned in the chart reproduced herein below being dissatisfed by the impugned judgment and awards passed by 3rd Civil Judge (Junior Division), Jalna on the ground that exorbitant compensation has been granted. The chart is as under : Name of Parties Sr. No. First Appeal Number LAR No. Classifcation of land and rate given by Reference Court 1. Executive Engineer 2452/2017 584/2010 Dry land 10 fa 2452-17 +11 vs. Sanjivani Subhasrao Salunke 2. Executive Engineer MUrlidhar vs. Dattatray Ghare 3. Executive Engineer vs. Vivek Vinayak Ghare 2464/2017 863/2010 2216/2017 802/2010 (3750/- per R) Seasonal Irrigated (5625/- per R) Seasonal Irrigated (5625/- per R) 4. Executive Engineer vs. Vivek Prabhakar Ghare 2451/2017 1120/2010 Seasonal Irrigated (5625/- per R) 5. Executive Engineer Yashvant vs. Prabhakar Ghare 6. Executive Engineer Sanjivani vs. Subhasrao Salunke 7. Executive Engineer Vishwas vs. Rajaram Bagve 8. Executive Engineer Dnyanesh vs. Vinayakrao Ghare 9. Executive Engineer Arvind vs. Ankushrao Ghare 10. Executive Engineer Sunetrabai vs. Vishwasrao Bagve 11. Executive Engineer vs. Dilip Ankushrao Ghare 12. Executive Engineer Sunderrao vs. Govindrao Ghare 2095/2019 1032/2010 Dry land (3750/- per R) 2201/2017 556/2010 Dry land 2215/2017 112/2010 2466/2017 558/2010 (3750/- per R) Seasonal Irrigated (5625/- per R) Seasonal Irrigated (5625/- per R) 3501/2015 229/2010 Dry land 2450/2017 557/2010 (3750/- per R) Seasonal Irrigated (5625/- per R) 2479/2017 1033/2010 Dry land 2465/2017 331/2010 (3750/- per R) Seasonal Irrigated (5625/- per R) 11 fa 2452-17 +11 2. The lands involved in all these appeals of the respective respondents are situated at village Kendali, Tq. Mantha, District Jalna have been acquired by the appellant - original respondent No.2 for construction of Barbada Irrigation Project. 3. However, during pendency of these appeals, both the rival contesting counsel appearing for the respective parties submit that
Decision
these appeals can be disposed of in view of the decision given by this Court (Coram: R. G. Avachat, J.) in First Appeal No. 251 of 2016, whereby compensation of Rs.5,625/- per Are for semi- irrigated / seasonal irrigated land and Rs.3,750/- per Are in respect of dry land. Classifcation of the lands involved in the present appeals whether dry or seasonal irrigated is mentioned in the aforesaid chart, which has been provided by the learned counsel for respondents-claimants, which is already marked "X" for identifcation under the order of this Court dated 16/09/2022. The learned counsel for the respondents - claimants had also made it clear that he would not dispute the nature of land as decided by the learned Reference Court. 4. In view of the same and by considering the submissions of both the rival learned counsel and the fact that this court has confrmed the rate of Rs.5,625/- per Are for seasonal irrigated land and rate of Rs.3,750/- per Are for dry land as mentioned in the aforesaid chart. Since the aforesaid judgment and order has attained fnality, the following order is passed. 12 fa 2452-17 +11 O R D E R I) II) The appeals are hereby dismissed. The respondents - original claimants are permitted to withdraw the amount deposited by the appellant with accrued interest. III) No order as to costs. IV) In view of dismissal of First Appeal No. 2095 of 2019, pending Civil Application No.10023 of 2015 is accordingly disposed of. VS Maind/- (SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE, J.)