Writ Petition No. 8610 of 2024 · Bombaybench High Court
Case Details
2025:BHC-AUG:4329-DB WP.8610.24.TET.odt +IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYBENCH AT AURANGABADWRIT PETITION NO.8610 OF 2024 1.Vijay S/o. Vishwanath SanapAge: 26 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Yedud, Post Lakh,Tq. Audha Nagnath, Dist. Hingoli- 431702 2.Sandeep S/o. Nana BormaleAge: 30 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Vasai, Post Halda,Tq. Sillod, Dist, Aurangabad-4311123.Neha W/o Sumit BokadeAge: 32 years, Occ: EducationR/O. Plot No. 47-A, Ashwinnagar,Badade layout, Hinghna Road,Tq. Dist. Akola -4440014.Neha D/o. Shobhanath YadavAge: 30 years, Occ: EducationR/O. 302, Jiwan Prakash Building,Louieswadi, Opp. Union Bank LouieswadiTq. Dist. Thane-4006045.Shital D/o. Ashok DahifaleAge: 31 years, Occ: EducationR/O. Samarth Nagar, Near Shikshak Colony,Mali Babhulgaon, Pathardi, Tq. Pathardi,Dist. Ahmednagar - 4141026.Datta S/o. Madhav ChitteAge: 25 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Wahad, Post Kurula,Tq. Kandhar, Dist. Nanded-4317427.Mohan S/o. Balaji KendreAge: 32 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Post Haduli, Tq. KandharDist. Nanded… PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its SecretarySchool Education and Sports Department,Mantralaya, Mumbai.1/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +2.The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune.Having office at Annibesant Road,District Pune.3.The Chairman,Central Board of Secondary EducationShiksha Kendra-2 Community CenterPreet Vihar, Delhi. 4.National Council of Teachers EducationThrough ChairpersonOffice at G-7, Dwarka, Near Metro Station,New Delhi.… RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.2534 OF 20241.Ramdhan s/o Yogiraj Bade,Age : 32 Yrs., Occu. Nil,R/o. Gavdhar, Tq. DharurDistrict : Beed 2.Prashant s/o Anantrao Aaghav,Age : 34 Yrs., Occu. Nil.,R/o Paithan, Tq. Paithan,District Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar.3.Dhananjay Janardhan Cheke,Age : 32 Yrs., Occu. Nil,R/o post Aregaon, Tq. Mehkar,Distrct Buldhana.4.Shital Agatrao Gholave,Age 34 years, Occu. Education,R/o Malkapur, Tq. Kallamb,District Dharashiv.5.Swapnil Subhash Khedkar,Age 31 years, Occu. Education,R/o Tuljai Chowk Canal Road,Beed, District Beed.6.Chaya Achutrao Palwade,Age 33 years, Occu. Education,R/o Koregaon Road, Chumb,Tq. Barshi, Dist. Solapur2/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +7.Sandip S/o Vishnu Kedar,Age 34 years, Occu. Education,R/o Warni, Tq. Shrir Kasar,District Beed.8.Sudarshan Vijay Palaskar,Age 34 years, Occu. Education,R/o Kedarkheda, Tq. Bhokardhan,District Jalna.… PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its Principal Secretary,School Education & Sports Deptt.Mantralaya, Mumbai-400 0322.The Commissioner forSchool Education & Sports Deptt.,Government of Maharashtra,Pune.… RESPONDENTSWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 9692 OF 2024IN WRIT PETITION NO. 2534 OF 2024 Ramesh S/o Arjun Thorat & Others… APPLICANTS(Interveners)VERSUSRamdhan s/o Yogiraj Bade & Others… RESPONDENTSANDCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3738 OF 2024IN WRIT PETITION NO. 2534 OF 2024 Sachin s/o Haribhau Fand & Another… APPLICANTS(Interveners)VERSUSThe State of Maharashtra & Others… RESPONDENTSAND3/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3739 OF 2024IN WRIT PETITION NO. 2534 OF 2024 Yogiraj Vishnu Kedar… APPLICANTS(Interveners)VERSUSRamdhan s/o Yogiraj Bade & Ors.… RESPONDENTSANDCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8433 OF 2024IN WRIT PETITION NO. 2534 OF 2024 Lahanu Khandu Sadgir & Ors.… APPLICANTS(Interveners)VERSUSRamdhan s/o Yogiraj Bade & Ors.… RESPONDENTSANDCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8434 OF 2024IN WRIT PETITION NO. 2534 OF 2024 Kalyan S/o Prabhu Shep & Anr.… APPLICANTS(Interveners)VERSUSRamdhan s/o Yogiraj Bade & Ors.… RESPONDENTSANDCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11260 OF 2024IN WRIT PETITION NO. 2534 OF 2024 Sudhir s/o Dnyanadeo Bambarse… APPLICANTS(Interveners)VERSUSRamdhan s/o Yogiraj Bade & Ors.… RESPONDENTS…4/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +ANDWRIT PETITION NO.7938 OF 20241.Arjun S/o Mangilal RathodAge : 30 Year, Occ : EducationR/o, At Takali Rajerai, Tq Khultabad, Dist Aurangabad2.Dinesh S/o Santosh HalorAge : 34 years, Occ: EducationR/o, At Post Udane, Tq. & Dist. Dhule3.Anjali D/o Zulal PatilAge : 30 Years, Occ: EducationR/o, At Post Sakri Road, Shri Hari Colony,Tq. & Dist. Dhule4.Sandeep S/o Rangarao PatilAge : 37 Years, Occ: EducationR/o, At Panewadi, Post Savarde Patankar,Tq. Radhanagari, Dist. Kolhapur5.Umesh S/o Bhanudas PatheAge : 38, Occ : EducationR/o. At Post Khedale Kajali, Tq Newasa,Dist. Ahmednagar6.Rajkumar S/o Sahebrao IjgudeAge : 35 Years, Occ: EducationR/o, At Post Nimjgaon, Tq. Madha, Dist. Solapur7.Sainath S/o Vitthal KolteAge : 32 Years, Occ: EducationR/o, at Post Misalwadi, Tq. Chikhali, Dist. Buldhana8.Manisha d/o Ramdas Hyalij Age : 39 years, Occ: EducationR/o. At Post Snehagar, Dindori Road, Nashik9.Dipali d/o Bhikchand GhitreAge : 30 years, Occ: EducationR/o. Rajesambhaji Colony, Jadhavwadi, Aurangabad10.Sonam d/o Krishnat ManeAge : 31 years, Occu: EducationR/o. Chhatrapati Rajaram Colony, Kasba Bavda, Kolhapur.5/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +11.Shubhangi d/o. Sarjerao Khairnar Age : 35 years, Occu: EducationR/o. At post Malharwadi, Tq. Nandgaon, Dist. Nashik12.Sangita d/o Bhojalal GautamAge : 31 years, Occu: EducationR/o. At post Nawargaon Khu.,Tq. Dist. Gondiya..PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of Maharashtra through its SecretarySchool Education and Sports Department,Mantralaya, Mumbai.2.The Commissioner (Education) Maharashtra State, PuneHaving office at Annibesant Road,District Pune.3.Deputy Director of Education,Regional Office, Aurangabad4.National Council of Teachers Educationthrough ChairpersonOffice at G-7, Dwarka, Near Metro Station,New Delhi..RESPONDENTS...ANDWRIT PETITION NO.7956 OF 2024Dilbar Husain Mateen AhmadAge : 30 Year, Occ : Private JobR/o: At present Near Shivaji Chowk, Biloli Tq. Bilolik, Dist. Nanded.… PETITIONERVERSUS1.The State of Maharashtra through its SecretarySchool Education Department,Mantralaya, Mumbai - 322.The Commissioner of Education Maharashtra State, Central Building Pune… RESPONDENTS6/86
Legal Reasoning
WP.8610.24.TET.odt +passing percentage for reserved category students under the extantreservation policy. The NCTE itself by notification dated 29.07.2011provided the relaxation up to 5% in the qualifying marks for the reservedcategory candidates.6.The State of Maharashtra by Government Resolution dated13.02.2013 and pursuant to the provision of Section 23 of the RTE Actand the aforementioned NCTE guidelines made TET as a mandatoryqualification for teachers in the State. By another Government Resolutiondated 06.03.2013 it was directed that the TET qualification should beacquired by 31.03.2015, which was subsequently by GR dated20.08.2013, deleted.7.Government Resolution dated 23.08.2013 enabled acandidate to appear for the TET any number of time to improve his score.8.In accordance with the NCTE guidelines, the Government ofMaharashtra come out with resolution dated 07.02.2019 and grantedconcession of up to 55% in the qualifying marks in respect of reservedcategory candidates. Pursuant to the directions of this Court in PILNo.8/2015 the Government of Maharashtra passed GovernmentResolution on 23.06.2017 and made a provision of Pavitra Portal whichwas visible to all the candidates participating in the recruitment processof teachers. It also mandated Teachers Aptitude and Intelligence Test(TAIT) as the competitive examination further providing that the marksobtained in that test as a parameter for preparation of the merit list. It71/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +was also provided therein that the candidate will have five chances toimprove their score at the TAIT.9.The State Government issued GR on 07.02.2019 and soughtto undertake and operate the Pavitra Portal expressly declaring thatrecruitment to the post of Shikshan Sevak would be conducted on thebasis of the scores in TAIT. Private Educational Institutes were givenoption to follow the selection on the basis of merit in the TAIT plus theperformance at the interview. Though initially it enabled a candidate togive five attempts at the TAIT examination, the relevant clause 3.4 fromthis GR was modified by GR dated 10.11.2022 making it mandatory for acandidate to appear at a fresh TAIT every time and declaring that theprevious score at TAIT would not be considered.10.In the light of such NCTE guidelines and various GovernmentResolutions the respondent – Maharashtra State Council of Examination,Pune (MSCE) conducted TAIT examination for selection of teachers indifferent schools of Zilla Parishad, Municipal Corporation, Nagar Parishadand private managements, in the year 2023. A merit list was displayedon 25.02.2024 and on the next date i.e. 26.02.2024 it was displayed onthe portal that the candidates who had taken benefit of reservation inrespect of their scores at the TET or CTET will not be considered forunreserved category. All these petitions take exception to this merit listpublished on 25.02.2024 and some of them seek its correction and in72/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +some petitions even the subsequent notification put up on 26.02.2024 onthe website is challenged.11.The thrust of the submissions of all the learned advocates ofthe petitioners is to the effect that the score at the TET or CTET merelyprovides eligibility and the ultimate selection was declared to be purelyon the basis of the scores of the candidates at TAIT. Their stand is thatany concession extended to reserved candidates just to make themeligible cannot deprive them of migrating to unreserved category on thebasis of their merit at the selection examination TAIT. Once it is declaredthat the selection of the candidates was to be purely on the basis of theirscores at TAIT, ignoring their merit in TAIT would be contrary to the aimand object of Section 23 of the RTE Act, of maintaining standard ofeducation. If the selection criteria was only to be the scores at TAIT, itwould be illogical and illegal if meritorious candidates at TAIT who, inspite of merit are denied such migration merely because of havingdeservedly received some concession in the eligibility criteria. In order tosubstantiate their such submission they would rely upon the decisions inthe matter of Vikas Sankhala and Ors. Vs. Vikas Kumar Agarwal and Ors.;AIR 2016 SC 5265, Saurav Yadav and Ors. Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh andOrs.; 2021 AIR (SC) 233, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. and Ors. Vs.Sandeep Choudhary and Ors.; AIR 2022 SC 2975, Sadhana Singh Dangiand Ors. Vs. Pinki Asati and Ors.; (2022) 2 SCC 401. 12.They would also rely upon couple of decisions of this Court73/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +in the matter of Charushila Tukaram Chaudhari and Ors. Vs. The State ofMaharashtra and Anr.; 2019 (5) AIR Bom R 561 and Sayali Nitin InamkeVs. State of Maharashtra and Ors.; 2023 DGLS (Bom.) 3581.13.The other limb of the submission of the learned advocates forthe petitioners is based on the usual stand in such matters of changingthe rules of the game after it was played. They submitted that at no pointof time the candidates were notified that such of the reserved candidateswho would obtain some concession at the TET or CTET would not bepermitted to migrate to the unreserved category. However, the impugnedcommunication, by way of notification on the website on 26.02.2024,after publication of the merit list was received by them as a bolt from theblue. Had there been any such notification at the earlier point of time thereserved category candidates could have participated at the TAIT withoutclaiming any reservation. They, therefore, submitted that suchsubsequent change in the stance by way of notification, after publicationof the merit list is an after thought and is an attempt to salvage someground and justify the wrong. 14.The learned advocates of the petitioners would also citecertain instances, wherein, some candidates having scored less at theTAIT, either from the reserved category or unreserved category, find placein the merit lists in the unreserved category, and some candidatesclaiming reservation in spite of having scored more at the TET aremissing in the TAIT merit list and could have easily be placed in the74/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +unreserved category on the basis of their score at the TAIT. 15.The learned advocates for the petitioners would submit thatthe whole exercise of preparing such a merit list is contrary to thereservation policy and the trite principles of law, and prevents reservedcategory candidates to be placed in the unreserved category purely on thebasis of their merit in the selection examination.16.Per contra, the learned Advocate General would, at theoutset taken a stand that the issue being raised by the petitioners is nolonger res integra in the light of the decision of the Supreme Court in thematter of Govt. of NCT Delhi and Ors. Vs. Pradeep Kumar and Ors.; AIROnline 2019 SC 2024. He would advert our attention to paragraphNos.23 to 27. He would submit that since it is a matter of quality ofeducation to be maintained, the performance at the TET or CTET is alsoequally important. It was prescribed that the 60% score at the TET wasthe benchmark to maintain this quality. Every candidate was given anynumber of opportunities to better the score precisely for this reason. Thereserved category candidates who were otherwise not eligible couldbecome eligible for appearing at the TAIT by receiving 5% of concessionin the marks at the TET or CTET. It is only because of such concessionthat they were eligible to appear at the TAIT. He would submit thatprecisely for this reason, Pradeep Kumar (supra) expressly laid down thata reserve category candidate having obtained concession in respect ofscore at the qualifying examination of CTET, irrespective of their merit in75/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +the TAIT, cannot seek to migrate to the unreserved category. He wouldtherefore submit that Pradeep Kumar (supra) lays down the settledposition of law and in itself is sufficient to negate petitioners’ claims.17.The learned Advocate General would also quote before uscertain instances qua specific candidates. He would demonstrates thatthough the score of a reserved category candidate at the TAIT is morethan a general category candidate or even a reserved category candidatefrom the merit list from unreserved category, had scored more than himat the TET/CTET. He would, therefore, submits that merely by pointingout that an unreserved category candidate scoring less than the reservedcategory candidate at TAIT finding place in the merit list would bemisleading unless even the respective scores at the TET/CTET areconsidered. He would submit that in any case this principle has beenapplied uniformly and cannot be taken exception of. 18.The learned Advocate General would further submit that thePavitra Portal is a complex matter. The scores at TET, CTET and TAIT arenot the only relevant considerations. It is merely a platform so that thecandidates can see the vacancies and opt for particular institutions andthe posts. It is a common portal for all the educational institutions acrossthe State irrespective of whether it is a Zilla Parishad run school or schoolbeing run by local bodies but even the private institutions, aided orunaided. The lists are prepared on the basis of the options exercised bythe candidates and availability of the posts according to the merit.76/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +Therefore, merely by pointing out the individual merit without the otherrelevant considerations would not be sufficient to establish discriminationor arbitrariness in preparation of the merit list. 19.As regards the stand of the petitioners about the notificationhaving been put up on the portal after preparation of the merit list, thelearned Advocate General would submit that the stand is fallacious. Hewould submit that the office memorandum was issued by the Ministry ofPersonnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, of the Department ofPersonnel and Training, Government of India dated 01.07.1998 and04.04.2018. It was expressly notified that migration of a reservedcategory candidate to unreserved category would not be available to thecandidates of the reserved category who had secured relaxation inrespect of age, experience etc. He would submit that the notificationdated 26.02.2024 put up on the website was nothing but a reiteration ofthe extant policy which is being followed consistently. He would submitthat it is not a matter of justifying the merit list ex post facto. 20.Lastly, the learned Advocate General would submit that thedecisions cited on behalf of the petitioners are peculiar to the individualcases and do not address the exact issue in the factual scenario,particularly in the light of Pradeep Kumar (supra).21.The rival submissions now fall for our consideration. As canbe appreciated, the fate of these matters and the challenge put up to themerit list hinges on the issue which we have formulated herein above.77/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +22.Whether the TET – CTET merely provides for eligibility of acandidate or whether it is something more than that, touching the qualityof education to be imparted is the basic issue common to all thesepetitions. In our considered view, with respect, the issue has beensquarely covered by Pradeep Kumar (supra) and no different view ispossible. The observations in Pradeep Kumar (supra) from paragraphsNo.23 to 27 are relevant and read as under :“23. The other distinguishing aspect in Vikas Sankhala (supra) isthat the candidates who had applied under the reservedcategory belonged to Rajasthan. For the selection andaspirants from the same State i.e., Rajasthan, the Courtallowed such candidates to migrate to the unreservedcategory. In the present case, however, the candidates (i.e. therespondents) belong to States other than Delhi. Being OBC(outsiders), they could have been considered only under theunreserved category if they secure at least 60% marks in theCTET. The respondents admittedly did not secure 60% andthus were ineligible. Moreover, an OBC candidate notcertified in the State/Territory outside of Delhi cannot beeligible to avail of employment in reserved category postsearmarked for OBCs who are certified by the DelhiGovernment.24. It is important to keep in mind that the respondents arecompeting for general category vacancies. All others in thisgroup have obtained their CTET eligibility qualification,securing the normal pass marks without availing anyrelaxation of pass norms. On the other hand, the respondentsdespite their lesser marks in the CTET examination, couldqualify only because they availed the relaxation benefits asOBC category examinees. Their eligibility qualification issecured under relaxed norms meant for OBC category andtherefore we do not think it is proper to consider them to beeligible for the general category vacancies and contention tothe contrary is unacceptable.25. The respondents with their CTET qualification under relaxednorms would be eligible for OBC category posts provided78/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +their OBC status is certified and recognized by the Delhigovernment. But such not being the case, they are ineligiblefor the reserved category vacancies. To allow them to migrateand compete for the open category vacancies would not bepermissible simply because, they have secured the CTETqualification with relaxation of pass marks meant for thosebelonging to the OBC category. As the respondents have notsecured the normal pass marks for general category, theireligibility for the general category vacancies is not secured.Therefore, their performance in the selection examinationwould be of no relevance, in the present process.26. As earlier discussed, this case concerns qualifications obtainedwith concession in pass marks. Such concession would have adirect impact on standards of competence and merit in therecruitment of Special Education Teachers. The principles ofreservation under the Constitution of India are intended to beconfined to a specifically earmarked category and theunreserved category must be protected, to avoid dilution ofcompetence and merit. If Vikas Sankhala (supra) isinterpreted shorn of its peculiar facts, as has been suggestedby the respondents’ counsel, it would in our perception,considering that respondents secured the qualification underrelaxed norms, would lead to dilution of merit in theunreserved category. The arguments made to the contrary bythe respondents is therefore rejected.27. In view of the forgoing, the High Court and the Tribunal erredin granting relief to the respondents. The impugned judgmentof the High Court of Delhi in Writ Petition (C) No. 557 of2019 dated 21.1.2019 is set aside and this appeal is allowed.No order as to costs.”As can be noticed, the decision in the matter of VikasSankhala (supra) has also been incidentally distinguished by PradeepKumar (supra). The observations in paragraph No.26 even address theimpact on the standards of competence and merit in respect ofrecruitment of the teachers. It has been held that relaxation inqualification would lead to dilution of the standards of education. 79/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +23.True it is, as laid down in catena of decisions that whileundertaking preparation of any list in respect of a recruitment processesproviding for vertical reservation under Article 16(4) of the Constitutionof India or horizontal one, under Articles 15(3) and 16(1), invariably50% of the seats are to be allotted purely on merit at the qualifyingexamination irrespective the categories to which the candidates belong.It is thereafter that the respective reservations of different classes have tobe worked out. This is being consistently followed in the light of thecelebrated judgment in the matter of Indira Sawhney Vs. Union of Indiaand Ors.; 2000 (1) SCC 168.24.Saurav Yadav (supra), followed thereafter in many mattersincluding Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. (supra), which in turn also refers toSadhana Singh Dangi (supra), reiterated this principle. In our consideredview, the submission of the learned advocates for the petitioners referringto the decisions in the matter of Saurav Yadav, Bharat Sanchar NigamLtd. and Sadhana Singh Dangi (supra), and even referring to thedecisions of the division benches of this Court in the matter of CharushilaTukaram Chaudhari and Sayali Nitin Inamke (supra), is not relevant forthe determination of the issue before this Court in these matters which isas to if having become eligible by deriving the benefit of reservation andhaving scored less than 60% which is the benchmark provided for passingthe TET/CTET, the candidates of the reserved category can be allowed tomigrate to the unreserved category solely on the basis of their merit at80/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +the selection examination - TAIT. This is the precise issue considered anddecided in the matter of Pradeep Kumar (supra), in the processdistinguishing the other judgment relied upon by the petitioners, in thematter of Vikas Sankhala (supra).25.The dispute in Saurav Yadav (supra) was regardingadjustment of vertical reservation vis a vis horizontal reservation forwomen. This is not the issue before us. 26.Once having understood the peculiarity of the matters inhand in the light of Pradeep Kumar (supra), the performance at theTET/CTET also being a relevant consideration in light of Section 23 ofthe RTE Act, going to the root of quality and standard of the education tobe imparted and is not merely a screening or preliminary examination,the decisions in the matter of K. Manjusree Vs. State of A.P. and Ors.; AIR2008 SC 1470, Jitendra Kumar Singh and Anr. Vs. State of U.P. and Ors.;2010 (3) SCC 119, Ramnaresh @ Rinku Kushwah and Ors. Vs. State ofMadhya Pradesh and Ors.; 2024 DGLS (SC) 759, Deependra Yadav andOrs. Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors.; AIR 2024 SC 2147, wouldnot be applicable to the fact situation of the matters in hand. In all thesematters the issue was regarding the performance at the qualifyingexamination, wherein following the consistent line in the light of IndiraSawhney (supra), the reserved category candidates were allowed tomigrate to the unreserved category purely based on their merits at thequalifying examination. Precisely for this reason even the decisions in81/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +respect of relaxations obtained by a reserved category candidate inrespect of fees and age limit being not considered as operating againstthe claim of the reserved category candidates for migration to theunreserved category, would not be applicable to the matters in hand.27.As regards the stand of the petitioners that they were notmade known that they would not be entitled to migration and it is onlyafter publication of the merit list that the notification in question dated26.02.2024 was uploaded, as has been rightly submitted by the learnedAdvocate General, this was the extant policy as per the D.O.P.T.memoranda dated 01.07.1998 and 04.04.2018. Again, no such priorintimation in the form of a condition in the advertisement or notificationwould be necessary inasmuch as this is the law of the land which hasbeen declared by the Supreme Court. Since it is a matter of followingpolicy of reservation, as has been rightly put by the learned AdvocateGeneral, notification dated 26.02.2024 is nothing but reiteration of thepolicy. It is not a case of changing the rules of the game. Having derivedconcession to reach the benchmark, for appearing at TAIT, the petitionerscan be said to have knowledge about the consequences. Even withoutsuch notification dated 26.02.2024, the same principle would apply,preventing them from migrating to the unreserved category. Therefore,even this submission of the learned advocates for the petitioners is notlegally tenable.28.Their can be no debate as regards importance of TET/CTET,82/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +qua the standard of the education to be maintained, as interpreted andlaid down in Pradeep Kumar (supra). The challenge to the merit listwhich prevents the candidates who have become eligible to appear at theTAIT in spite of having scored less than the benchmark of 60% at theTET/CTET, to migrate to the unreserved category, is not legallysustainable.Writ Petition No.8610/202429.Additionally the challenge in this petition is to the merit listas being unconstitutional and contrary to the policy of reservation. Thesubmission of the learned advocate Mr. Rathod for the petitioners isfallacious. It needs to be emphasized that reserved category candidateswho have secured the benchmark of 60% at the TET/CTET and areeligible to appear at the TAIT can easily migrate to the unreservedcategory in light of the trite principle reiterated by the Supreme Courttime and again as discussed herein above. Since it is a matter of qualityand standard of education to be imparted by the teachers teaching tostandard I to VIII, they cannot be made to face the challenge by thereserved category candidates who were not eligible but for relaxation ofup to 5% of marks at the basic TET/CTET examination.30.The affidavit-in-reply filed in Mr. Rathod’s matter, detailstatistics has been provided to demonstrate that following the policy ofreservation, many reserved category candidates could easily migrate tothe unreserved category having not received any concession in their score83/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +at TET. It is pointed out that 2410 candidates belonging to reservedcategory who had not availed concession in marks form 68.85% of the listof 3500 candidates. It is also pointed out that over all percentage ofreserved category candidates is 90.17% (9995) in respect of total 11085posts under the merit list published on 25.02.2024. It has also beenpointed out that in the lists published on 25.06.2024 and 11.07.2024,69.12% (828) and 88.81% (2936) candidates respectively, could easilymigrate having not availed any concession in respect of the score at TET.It cannot be said, therefore, that the norm applied for preventingmigration of reserved candidates who were otherwise not even eligible toappear at the TAIT from migrating to unreserved category based solely ontheir merit at the TAIT, is not discriminatory or unconstitutional.WP No.7922/2024 and WP No.4827/202431.In these two writ petitions, apart from the issue involved inthe other writ petitions one additional issue has been raised. All thesepetitioners claim to have completed their education through Urdumedium. They are, therefore, aspiring to be appointed as assistantteachers in Urdu medium schools. Their stand is that due to non-availability of candidates from Urdu medium, about 1150 vacanciesremained in spite of the recruitment process having been undertaken.Though they have become eligible to appear at TAIT, having derivedconcession of 5% marks in the scoring at the TET/CTET, now that they84/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +have cleared TAIT and have reasonably fared well, it would beappropriate if they can be considered for filling these number of vacantseats. They are aggrieved that their such reasonable request is also notbeing considered by the respondent No.2 – Commissioner.32.In our considered view, if at all, all these petitioners havingbecome eligible to appear at TAIT by getting the concession to reach thebenchmark for becoming eligible to appear at TAIT, merely because theyhave some additional advantage having themselves completed educationthrough Urdu medium and could be of some aid to the Urdu mediumschools in imparting education and merely because there are seats goingvacant, they cannot be permitted to migrate to the general category, thecommon thread being prohibition to such migration to unreservedcategory once having derived the benefit of concession, to be eligible toappear at the qualifying examination – TAIT.33.It would be a matter of policy for the State Government toexplore as to how to come out of the situation when these number ofposts are going vacant in respect of teachers to be appointed in Urdumedium schools. This Court in exercise of the powers under Article 226of the Constitution of India would be loath in taking some view in thepolicy matters. Consequently, even both these petitions are liable to bedismissed.34.For the aforementioned reasons all the writ petitions aredismissed.85/86
Arguments
WP.8610.24.TET.odt +ANDWRIT PETITION NO.10709 OF 20241.Santosh Dharmaji PadmukhAge : 33 Year, Occ : NilAt – Wakhare, Tal – Jalna,Dist- Jalna - 4312032.Bhagyashree Mahadev Revdekar Age – 32, Occu: Nil,At – Kasal, House No.165B,Nawabazar Kasal, Tal. Kudal,Dist. Sindhudurg - 4166033.Pankaj Bhimrao Thakre Age : 33, Occ. Nil,At – Borgaon, Post – Kawlewada,Tal – Goregaon, Dist. Gondiya – 4416014.Ganesh Dnyaneshwar BorkarAge : 30, Occu : Nil, At – Tondgaon, Tal. Washim,Dist. Washim – 4445055.Bajrang Shamrao KokareAge : 35, Occu. Nil,At – Bandgarwadi, Post – Chopadi, Ta. Sangola, Dist. Solapur – 4133086.Swapnil Ramakant MahajanAge : 29, Occu: Nil,At – Rokade Galli Talai,Tal. Erandol, Dist. Jalgaon – 4251107.Urmila Mayuresh PardeshiAge : 30, Occ. Nil,At – Kharadi, Tal. Pune City,Sr. No.47, 5/A, Sainagari Chandannagar, Lane No.13, Pune – 4110148.Sonali Rajendra Bhalekar Age : 31, Occ. Nil,At – Vitthal Niwas, Shraddha Colony,Tal. Sangamner,Dist. Ahmednagar – 4226059.Madhuri Jitendra FundeAge : 35, Occ. Nil,Shriram Nagar, Tumsar, Tal. Tumsar,Dist. Bhandara – 441912 7/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +10.Rajat Omprakash ToleAge : 26, Occ. Nil,At – Near Hanuman Mandir, Murwadi, Thaware Nagar,Tal. Lakhani, Dist. Bhandara – 44180411.Shweta Babulal BhujaleAge : 31, Occ. NilAt Post Tirupati NagarDist. Hingoli - 43151312.Nitin Rameshwar KumbhalkarAge : 33 Occu: Nil,Tukdoji Square, Ward No.2,Tal. Deori, Dist. Gondiya – 44190213.Harishchandra Vasant NagapureAge : 36 Occu: Nil,At – Chekdarur, Ta. Gandpipri,Dist. Chandrapur – 44270214.Pankaj Bhikram ThakreAge : 28, Occu. Nil,at – Borgaon, Post Kawlewadi,Tal. Goregaon, Dist. Gondiya – 44160115.Rahul Arun Palwe Age : 28, Occu. Nil,At – Samrod, Tal. Jamner, Dist. Jalgaon –42420616.Shahaji Shantaram LendeAge : 34, Occ.Nil,At – Khambe, Post Warwandi,Tal. Sangamner, Dist. Ahmednagar – 41373817.Swati Sukhdeo NagargojeAge – 33, Occ. Nil,At – Flat No.1, DSK Tower, Yashwant Nagar,Tal. Paithan, Dist. Aurangabad – 43110718.Dipali Arunpant Boharupi Age – 33, Occ. Nil,At – Ward No.3, At Post Gadegaon,Tal. Warud, Dist. Amravati – 44490619.Onkar Gopal Khawale Age – 34, Occ. NilAt – Kathora, Post Bhota,Tal. Shegaon, Dist. Buldhana – 443404… PETITIONERS8/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +VERSUS1.The State of Maharashtra through the Secretary of Department of Education & Sports,Mantralaya, Mumbai - 400 0012.Commissioner (Education) Maharashtra State, Pune.Central Building, Pune – 013.Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State Exam Council,17 Dr. Ambedkar Marg, Near Lal Temple, Pune… RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.7922 OF 20241.Khatik Shaikh Imran Shaikh SaeedAge : 34 Year, Occ : NilR/o. Near Dilli Darwaja Azaad Chowk, Parola, Tq. & District Jalgaon2.Shaikh Irfan Shaikh Shabbir,Age: 33 years, Occu: Nil,R/o. Plot No.85, Mustufa Colony NearAusa Masjid ChopdaTq. Chopda, District Jalgaon… PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of Maharashtra through its Principal Secretary,School Education & Sports Deptt.Mantralaya, Mumbai - 400 0322.The Commissioner for School Education & Sports Deptt.,Government of Maharashtra Pune.… RESPONDENTSAND9/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +WRIT PETITION NO.11544 OF 2024 1.Deepali d/o Ramesh PawarAge: 37 Years, Occ: EducationR/O: RH-No.14, Vinayak ParkDeolai Parisar, Deolai,Chh. Sambhajinagar - 4310012.Madhuri d/o Madhukar AglaweAge: 35 Years, Occ: EducationR/o. Plot No.38, Sudhakar NagarSatara Parisar, Chh. Sambhajinagar – 4310033.Anup s/o Ramesh KatwalkarAge: 34 years, Occ: EducationR/o. Plot No. 47-A, Satpal Nagar,New Pahadsingpura,Chh. Sambhajinagar – 4310014.Nisha d/o. Dnyaneshwarrao KaleAge: 35 years, Occ: EducationR/o. Plot No.37, Raje Sambhaji Colony Jadhavwadi, Jalgaon Road,Chh. Sambhajinagar - 4310015.Vidhya D/o. Dhiwaruji Gedam Age : 37 Years, Occu: EducationalR/o. At Post Someshwar,Tq. & Dist. Nanded6.Ashok S/o. Dhondu Nibrad Age : 38 years, Occ: EducationR/o. Plot No.8, Adharsh Colony,Pahadsingpura, Chh. Sambhajinagar - 431001… PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its Principal SecretarySchool Education and Sports Department,Mantralaya, Mumbai2.The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune.Having office at Annibesant Road,District Pune.10/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +3.The Chairman,Central Board of Secondary EducationShiksha Kendra-2 Community CenterPreet Vihar, Delhi(Deleted as per court’s order dated 10.12.2024)4.National Council of Teachers EducationThrough ChairpersonOffice at G-7, Dwarka, Near Metro Station,New Delhi.(Deleted as per court’s order dated 10.12.2024)… RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.11521 OF 2024 1.Lukman s/o Hannan ShaikhAge: 35 Years, Occ: EducationR/o: House No.8/4, Behind TelephoneBhavan, Ajabnagar, Aurangabad2.Monika d/o Sushant NaikAge: 35 Years, Occ: EducationR/o. House No.5/12/1939,Kaman Wasti, Padampura, Aurangabad3.Haresh s/o. Govind AlbadAge: 33 years, Occ: EducationR/o. House No.1/2/1135, Sundarnagar,Padegaon, Behind Sai Mandir,Aurangabad.4.Pratibha d/o Sadashiv AntreAge: 40 years, Occ: EducationR/o. At Post Songaon, Tq. Rahuri, Dist. Ahmedngar – 4137115.Balaso s/o. Subhash KashidAge : 36 Years, Occu: EducationR/o. Indraprastha Colony, Balepir,Nagar Road, Beed6.Rupali d/o. Nanasaheb SomwanshiAge : 37 years, Occ: EducationR/o. Tirupati Residency, Building-A,Flat No.9, Cidco Mahanagar-1,Waluj, Aurangabad-43113611/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +7.Kavita d/o. Ramrao RathodAge : 35 years, Occu: EducationR/o. House No.36, Adarsh Colony,Guru Ganesh Nagar, Pahadsingpura,Aurangabad...PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its Principal SecretarySchool Education and Sports Department,Mantralaya, Mumbai2.The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune.Having office at Annibesant Road,District Pune.3.The Chairman,Central Board of Secondary EducationShiksha Kendra-2 Community CenterPreet Vihar, Delhi(Deleted as per court’s order dated 10.12.2024)4.National Council of Teachers EducationThrough ChairpersonOffice at G-7, Dwarka, Near Metro Station,New Delhi.(Deleted as per court’s order dated 10.12.2024)..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.10710 OF 2024 1.Vinayak Shripat KolageAge – 33, Occ – Nil,C/102, Swarali Apartment Co.Op. Hsg.Society,Waman Nagar, Manvel Pada Road, Virar (E),Dist – Palghar, 401305.2.Dinesh Barku BiradeAge 35, Occ. Nil,R/at Mahsa, Tal-Murbad, Dist-Thane - 4214013.Vishakha Vijay RanvirAge – 35, Occ. NilR/at Kurla, Ashok Nagar, Hall No. 3,Mumbai - 40007012/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +4.Swati Santosh MacchiAge 36, Occ. NilR/at Chikhle, Palghar, Dist-Palghar - 401605.Sameer Subhash DigheAge 30, Occ. NilR/at Raigad Naigaon, Dighe Wadi,Dist. Raigad – 410205.6.Sujit Satish SanapAge 32, Occ. NilR/at Kolad, Dist. Raigad – 402304.7.Vidhya Kanif DevkarAge 37, Occ. NilR/at Parande Vasti, Tal – Indapur,Dist. Pune – 413120.8.Aniket Jayant VadalAge 30 , Occ. NilR/at Chaul, Tal – Alibaug,Dist – Raigad - 4022039.Sheetal Vilas ChalisgaonkarAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Raghunathpur, Amravati,Dist. Amravati - 44471110.Gaitri Devidas IngaleAge 34, Occ. NilR/at pathrot, Tal – Achalpur,Dist. Amravati - 44480811.Mayuri Kamlakarao DholeAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Near Maruti Mandir, Khadkari,Amravati, Dist-Amravati 44460112.Neha Sharadrao GujarkarAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Rajmata Nagar, Morshi Road,Shivaji Nagar, Amravati,Dist. Amravati - 44460313.Sharda Charandas KoltekeAge 44, Occ. NilR/at Daryapur, Vasant Nagar, Amravati,Dist. Amravati – 444803.13/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +14.Dattatray Kisan SumbarAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Valuj, Tal – Gangnapur,Dist. - Aurangabad – 43113315.Ganesh Laxman TapkirAge 36, Occ. NilR/at Bidkeen behind grampanchyat,Aurangabad,Dist. Aurangabad – 431105.16.Santosh Shivling HingmireAge 29, Occ. NilR/at Kelgaon, Tal- Sillod, Aurangabad,Dist. Aurangabad - 42111217.Deshmukh Firdous Anjum Mohammed RafiqueAge 25, Occ. Nil,R/at Sillod, Dist – Aurangabad - 43111218.Rahul Karbhari TribhuvanAge 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Palkhed, Aurangabad,Dist. Aurangabad – 42370319.Priti Vikram PotdarAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Shradha Niwas, Plot No. 23,Shreeram Colony, Satara,Dist. Satara, 41500220.Mangesh Appa NerkarAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Dhaval, Tal – Phalatan,Dist. Satara, 41552321.Tejaswi Mohan DhavadeAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Near Toll Plaza, Pedgaon, Satara,Dist. Satara - 41552122.Neeta Balso KakdeAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Jinti, Satara, Dist. Satara, 41552223.Parmanand Udav KambleAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Wadwal Nagnath, Tal – Chakur,Dist. Latur – 413529.14/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +24.Mukund Govindrao GaikwadAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Awalkonda, Latur, Dist. Latur, 413517.25.Sheela Sahebrao KambleAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Kasarjavla, Latur,Dist. Latur – 46351126.Sachin Pandurang KawaleAge 36, Occ. NilR/at Tilaknagar, Latur,Dist. - Latur-413531. 27.Nagnath Panjabrao MhaskeAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Murtijapur Savangi, Hingoli,Dist. Hingoli, 43170528.Sheetal Prakashrao SonaleAge 29, Occ. NilR/at Akhada Balapur, Tal – Kalamnuri,Dist. Hingoli - 43170129.Kirankumar Prakashrao SonaleAge 34, Occ. Nil.R/at Akhada Balapur, Jetvan nagar,Hingoli, Dist. Hingoli, 43170130.Vinod Sakharam KhillareAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Gunda, Tal – Basmat,Dist – Hingoli, 43170531.Khushab Daulat BarsagadeAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Balapur Khurd, Maushi, Chandrapur,Dist – Chandrapur, 44120632.Chetan Prakash KaleAge 28, Occ. NilR/at Vihirgaon, Chandrapur,Dist – Chandrapur, 44121533.Gaurav Devidas MeshramAge 26, Occ. NilR/at Mahatma Phule Vidyalaya,Shindevahi, Chandrapur,Dist. Chandrapur, 441222.15/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +34.Vidya Vasantrao RajurkarAge 38, Occ. NilR/at Bhandarvati Chandrapur,Dist. Chandrapur, 44290235.Balaram Santosh KudkeAge 32, Occ. NilR/at Nagar Sul, Tal – Yevala,Dist. Nashik 42340336.Nitin Ramesh GunjalAge 39, Occ. NilR/at Patil Nagar, Cidco, NashikDist. Nashik, 42200837.Bhaskar Lahanu SanapAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Lohshingve, Bhalur, Nashik,Dist. Nashik – 42310638.Santoshi Ramesh KhedikarAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Sasra, Tal – Sakoli,Dist – Bhandara, 44180239.Ashwini Manohar BhuteAge 35, Occ. Nil,R/at Sakoli, Dist. Bhandara, 44180240.Ravishankar Tejram BaraskarAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Sakoli Sasra, Bhandara,Dist. - Bhandara, 44110241.Hemkant Nivruti KhoteleAge 28, Occ. NilR/at Sendurvafa, Tal-Sakoli, Bhandara,Dist. Bhandara, 44180242.Sanjay Dhanraj WaghayeAge 31, Occ. NilR/at Kesalvadi, Patil Ward, Bhandara,Dist. Bhandara, 44110443.Sujata Sachin GarudkarAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Kartewadi, Tergaon, Karjat,Dist. Ahmednagar, 41440116/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +44.Sunil Satappa ArdeAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Dattamandi, Boring Galli, Kudki,Tal-Radhanagari,Dist. Kolhapur, 41621245.Rajesh Prakash SatpureAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Tisangi, Kolhapur,Dist. Kolhapur, 416206.46.Rajaram Pandurang KhotAge 38, Occ. NilR/at Near Hanuman Mandir,Gargoti, Kolhapur,Dist. Kolhapur, 41620947.Dipak Ramchandra TamkarAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Ingle Wadi, Onancase, Ratnagiri,Dist. Ratnagiri – 41570648.Jayesh Ankush ShindeAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Dhangarwadi, Tal-Rajapur,Dist. Ratnagiri- 41371349.Savita Gopal RathodAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Raoltale, Chiplun, Tal-Chiplun,Dist. Ratnagiri – 41560550.Vrushali Raghunath Mundekar,Age 31, Occ. NilR/at Deulwadi, Bhatgaon, Tal. Bhatgaon,Dist. Ratnagiri – 415726.51.Rajesh Dilip IngaleAge 31, Occ. NilR/at Ananvase, Umbarghar Road,Ratnagiri, Dist. Ratnagiri, 41570652.Ram Sopan KareAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Baherewadi, Post, Jakhale,Dist. Kolhapur , 41611317/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +53.Neha Vinayak Koli,Age 35, Occ. NilR/at Koli Galli, Ghandhi Chowk,Tal – Miraj, dist. Sangali, 41642254.Sheetal Prashanta BhokareAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Hilwadi, Tal. Palus,Dist-Sangali, 41330355.Reshma Rajaram SarulkarAge 32, Occ. NilR/at Shivaji Nagar,Indira Colony Road No.1, Islampur,Tal – Islampur, dist. Sangali, 41150956.Rahul Pandurang KatreAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Vasandada Nagar, Bhilwadi, Sangali,Dist. Sangali, 41630357.Mahesh Dattatray NaikAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Naik Mala, Kaulapure, Sangali,Dist. Sangali, 43630658.Baliramdada PatoleAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Nagole, Sangali,Dist. Sangali, 41640559.Chetan Devidas KharbadeAge 28, Occ. NilR/at Dhalpa, Tal – Katol, Bori, Nagpur,Dist. Nagpur – 44130260.Akhilesh Ramesh BhrakheAge 26, Occ. NilR/at Umred, Nagpur, Dist. - Nagpur – 44120361.Komal Shriramji ThombareAge 36, Occ. NilR/at Ward No. 2, Tarasangva, Vardha,Dist. Vardha, 44220262.Pravin Babarao LondhekarAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Sindi Railway Near,Dist. Vardha, 44210518/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +63.Priti Nareshrao DhambareAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Near Budhvihar, Anje, Vardha,Dist. Vardha – 44200164.Switi Gajanan KuntiwarAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Yevli, Gadchiroli,Dist – Gadchiroli, 44260565.Kavita Mangesh ShelkeAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Babanrao Deshpande Near Ward No. 2, Motala, Buldhana, Dist. Buldhana, 443103.66.Moreshwar Dadaji UradeAge 37, Occ. Nil,R/at Chapahalwada, Tal- Chamarmoshi,Dist. Gadchiroli – 44260467.Sainath Sudhakar GedamAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Pardi, Tal – Gadchiroli,Dist – Gadchiroli, 442605.68.Alka Bhanudas WayzodeAge 32, Occ. NilR/at Yengaon, Wadshingi, Buldhana,Dist. Buldhana – 443402.69.Sandeep Samadhan PalveAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Sadargaon Dhagir, Shelgaon Bazar,Buldhana, Dist-Buldhana 443102.70.Mohini Nikhil ShahAge 32, Occ. NilR/at Khamgaon, Tal – Khamgaon,Dist. Buldhana- 44430371.Avinash Vishnu IngaleAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Somthana Peth, Buldhana,Dist. Buldhana, 44320119/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +72.Santosh Baburao KendreAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Malegaon Road, Near Hanuman Mandir,Nanded, Dist. Nanded, 43160573.Anil Sudam ChavanAge 37, Occ. NilR/at Ruplanaik, Tal – Mahur, Nanded,Dist. Nanded – 431721.74.Shubham Suresh BasalwarAge 29, Occ. NilR/at Dattanagar, Town Market, Shivaji Nagar,Nanded, Dist. Nanded, 43160275.Amar Uttreshwar TupareAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Borgaon, Itpur, Osmanabad,Dist. Osmanabad – 41350776.Vilas Narayan JadhavAge 42, Occ. NilR/at Kandlwadi Road, Baba Nagar, Kalam,Osmanabad,Dist. Osmanabad, 41350777.Dipali Mohan BhosaleAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Shikshak Colony, Malibahulgaon,Tal. Pathardi, Dist. Ahmednagar, 41410278.Pravina Sakharam JamdarAge 37, Occ. NilR/at Lokhande Galli, Tal. Nevasa,Dist. Ahmednagar – 41460279.Sanket Sudhir HarneAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Karne Ali, Tal-Kankavali, Sindhudurga,Dist. Sindhudurga, 41660280.Abdul Khadeer Altaf PatelAge 39, Occ. NilR/at Ausa, Lamsana, Tal – Ausa,Dist. Latur – 413516.20/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +81.Vaibhav Vinayak AndureAge 32, Occ. NilR/at Patardi, Ahmednagar,Dist. Ahmednagar, 41411382.Kirankumar Dipak TaskarAge 36, Occ. NilR/at Ganeshwar Nagar, Colony, Sangamner, Tal. Sangamner,Dist. Ahmednagar, 422605.83.Avinash Pralahad JawaleAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Vithalmandir Galli, Jamkhed,Ahmednagar, Dist. Ahmednagar-41320184.Pravin Dattatray LokhandeAge 32, Occ. NilR/at Bus Stand Samor, Taklibhan, Ahmednagar,Dist- Ahmednagar, 413725.85.Divyani Dattu AgaleAge 31, Occ. NilR/at Nevasa Khurd, Rural,Dist. Ahmednagar – 41330386.Pandurang Baburao BangarAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Nalewadi, Tal. Ambad,Dist. Jalana, 431205.87.Vinayak Shripat KolgeAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Room No. 2, Amdar Niwas,Servant Qurts.Maharshi Karve Road,Mantralaya, Mumbai – 400032.88.Pravin Bhaidas KokaniAge 31, Occ. NilR/at Dhekwad, Dist. Nandurbar, 42541289.Jayshree Baban YelveAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Grampanchayat Gaothan, Daithane Gunjal,Dist.-Ahmednagar, 414103.21/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +90.Rahul Babu BramhneAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Prakasha, Tal. Shadada, Dist. Ahmednagar – 42542291.Lata Vithoba DevaleAge 38, Occ. NilR/at Near Malwadi Zilha Parishad,Tal. - Sangola, Dist – Solapur, 41330792.Surekha Lalchand BhamreAge 42, Occ. NilR/at Saki Road, Jaybhairav Nagar,Dhule, Dist. Dhule-424001.93.Dinesh Arun Wagh,Age 35, Occ. NilR/at Saikrupa Colony, Rajendra Nagar,Wadavali, Dhule, Dist-Dhule, 424005.94.Vithal Vilas SherlekarAge 33, Occ. Nil,R/at Sherle, Nagdhuriwadi, Hose No. 886, Tal. Sawantwadi, Dist. Sindhudurga, 41651495.Girish Ganpat SherlekarAge 38, Occ. NilR/at Sawantwadi, Shetkarwadi,Sherle, Dist.-Sindhudurga, 416514.96.Arjun Vasudev JadhavAge 37, Occ. NilR/at Near Samaj Mandir, Kaleli,Sindhudurga, 416519.97.Komal Onkar KhajanwadkarAge 31, Occ. NilR/at Ingale Wadi, Kotakmate,Tal. Devgad,Dist. Sindhudurga, 416611.98.Prabhudas Laxman AajgaonkarAge 36, Occ. NilR/at Wayari, Kalavati Mandir, Malwan,Sindhudurga – 416606.99.Dinesh Shivdas MoryeAge 32, Occ. NilR/at Kankavali, Sindhudurga, 416602.22/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +100.Chetan Chandrakant PoojariAge 31, Occ. NilR/at Pural, Tal. Devgad,Dist. Sindhudurga. 416805.101.Rakhi Ravind MunjAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Ambrad, Tal – Kudal,Dist. Sindhudurga, 416628.102.Tejal Namdev TeliAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Kasaba Waghota, Tal. Devgad,Dist. Sindhudurga- 416804.103.Nilesh Prakash TirlotkarAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Gadewadi, Khurshi,Dist. Sindhudurga, 416805104.Shubhangi Manohar TagdeAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Deori, Tal. Deori, Sanjay Nagar,Gondiya, 441901105.Rajeshkumar Bidharam ChuteAge 34, Occ. NilR/at Naigaon Kalyan, Gondiya, 441601106.Nitin Rameshwar KumbhalkarAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Kurparr, Purada, Deori,Dist – Gondiya, 441902.107.Maheshwari Tilkachand TurkarAge 38, Occ. NilR/at Nilaj, Ward No. 1, Dasgaon Book,Gondiya – 441614.108.Govindprasad Ashok TembreAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Shastri Tiroda, Gajanan Mandir Jawal,Gondiya – 441911109.Gunjan Kishor BarneAge 23, Occ. NilR/at Titora, Gondiya, 441911 PUNE110.Anjali Dilip KhedkarAge 31, Occ. Nil23/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +R/at Pirangut, Tal. Mulshi. Dist. Pune, 412115111.Sonali Rajaram MokashiAge 32, Occ. NilR/at Katfal, Pune, Dist. Pune, 413133.112.Seema Pandurang ShindeAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Indapur, Dist. Pune, 413106113.Supriya Suresh JadhavAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Tal. Purandar, Saswad, Dist. Pune 412301114.Shital Vijaysing RatjputAge 37, Occ. NilR/at Ravet, Tal – Haveli,Dist.-Pune, 412101.115.Prashant Vasudev JoriAge 31, Occ. NilR/at Kambhut, Tal-Shirur,Dist.-Pune, 410504.116.Pradip Malikarjun Lohar,Age 33, Occ. NilR/at Aundh Camp, Pune,Dist. - Pune, 411027.117.Manisha Mahadev PansareAge 39, Occ. NilR/at Hadapsar, Flat No. B-401,Pune City, Pune, 411028118.Sumaya Imran MullaAge 35, Occ. NilR/at Bhosari, Chakrapani, Vasahat Road,Dist. Pune, 411039.119.Pratidnya Shashikant NalawadeAge 42, Occ. NilR/at Nirvangi, Pune,Dist. Pune, 413114.120.Suhasini Sagar DhapareAge 33, Occ. NilR/at Ambedkar Nagar, Tal – Karad,Dist. Satara-415124.24/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +121.Tejaswi Mohan DhawareAge 35, Occ. NilR/at padegaon, Tal-Khandala,Dist. Satara, 415004122.Pankaj Devram GedamAge 29, Occ. NilR/at Dongargaon, Tal-Kul,Dist. Chandrapur..PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of Maharashtra.Through the Secretary of Department ofEducation & Sports,Mantralaya, Mumbai – 400 001.2.Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune.Central Building, Pune-01.3.Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State Exam Council,17. Dr. Ambedkar Marg,Near Lal Temple, Pune..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.2585 OF 2024Ravindra s/o Babasaheb Khedkar,Age:- 32 years, Occ. Nil,R/o Chichpur Ijade, Tq. Pathardi,Dist. Ahmednagar..PETITIONERVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough Principal Secretary,Sports and Education DepartmentMantralaya, Mumbai-400032.2.The Commissioner,Maharashtra State Council of Examination,17, Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Road,Camp Pune-4110013.The Commissioner of Education (MS)Central Building Pune..RESPONDENTSAND25/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +WRIT PETITION NO.2869 OF 20241.Rameshwar Bhikchand GhitreAge:31 years, Occ:EducationR/o. Plot no.37 Raje sambahaji colonyJadhav wadi Jalgaon RoadChhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar(Aurangabad)2.Shubhangi Ramesh ChaudhariAge-34 years Occup-private jobR/o. C/o Ananad Ramesh pande.Kapidiya State near bus standHingoli Dist. Hingoli3.Aditay Purushottam PenoreAge- 30 year, Occup- EducationR/o- Antule nagara kola bypassHingoli Dist Hingoli4.Mahadev Amabads DhaknaeAge-31 years, Occup-EducationR/o – At Post SondevmalTal and District Jalna5.Dattatraya Kisan SumbarAge-33 years, Occup- EducationR/o- At Mandava Post SawkhedaTal Gangapur andDistrict Chhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar(Aurangabad)6.Suhas Gopinath BhoyarAge-39 years, Occup-housewifeR/o- Parvati Nagar Vidypith ParisarChhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar(Aurangabad)7.Amit Kailas KhandareAge-33 years, Occup-EducationR/o-Bhawshing PuraChhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar(Aurangabad)8.Anil Karbhari MalkarAge-34 years, Occup-EducationR/o- At post TadpimpalgaonTal Kannad,District Chhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar (Aurangabad)..PETITIONERSVERSUS26/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its SecretarySchool Education and Sports DepartmentMantralaya, Mumbai2.The Commissioner (Education),Maharashtra State, Pune,Having office at Annibesant Road,District Pune.3.The Pavatri PortalWorking under the The Commissioner (Education) PuneTal and District Pune4.Central Board Of Secondary EducationNew Delhi5.Maharashtra State Council Of Examination PuneTaluka And District Pune6.National Council of Teacher EducationThrough CharipersonOffice At-G-7 Dwarka Near Metro StationNew Delhi..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.3707 OF 2024 1.Shaikh Mazharuddin Shaikh FayazuddinAge: 33 years, Occu: NilR/o: Plot no.4, Jam Nagar,Jalgaon Tq. & Dist. Jalgaon2.Iram Kauser Mohammed AzamAge 29 years, Occu. Nil,R/o: Near Sadad Masjid,Azam Colony, Roshan Gate, Ch. SambhajinagarTq. & Dist. Ch. Sambhajinagar3.Shaikh Feroz Shaikh HashamAge 39 years, Occu. Nil,R/o At Nanja,Tq. Bhokardan District-Jalna.27/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +4.Shaikh Wazira Begum Shaikh Moin,Age 31 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Kumar GalliTq. & District- Jalna.5.Khan Naziya Tasneem Azhar Sarfaraz Khan,Age 39 years, Occu. Nil,R/o At Present BiloliTq. & Dist Nanded6.Mariya Imtiyaz AhmadAge 33 years, Occu. Nil,R/o At Present Motipura, Near BaidpuraTq & District Jalna.7.Rizwana Begum Rahmat KhanAge 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Gangkhed Road Parbhani,Tq. & Dist. Parbhani,8.Mohd Sharique Mohd RafiqueAge 35 years, Occu. Nil,R/o At Present Akbari Chauk Biyabani,Tq. & district Aurangabad,9.Gazala Murtuz Nadaf,Age 31 years, Occu. Nil,R/o At present Nilanga, Tq. NilangaDistrict Latur10.Sana Jilani Mujawar,Age 31 years, Occu. Nil,R/o. At Present Gajanan Nagar, DhuleTq. & District Dhule,11.Rabiya Sultana Mohammed Nazim,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o. At Present Mastar Colony Jalgaon,Tq & District Jalgaon,12.Mirza Faizan Baig Mirza Rahman Baig,Age 29 years, Occu. Nil,R/o At Present Opp Sara Aparment Sillod,Tq. Sillod & Dist. Aurangabad.13.Shahida Asifkhan Shaikh,Age 33 years, Occu, Nil,R/o At Present Chand Mahel, AhmednagarTq & District Ahmednagar.28/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +14.Khamsa Fatema Mohammad Anwar,Age 30 years, Occu. Nil,R/o At Present Mastar Colony JalgaonTq. & District Jalgaon.15.Mohammad Shakeeb Akhtar Mohammad Jalil,Age: 37 years, Occu. Nil,R/o At Present Saudagar Mohalla, WalujTq & District Aurangabad16.Sumayya Bano Riyaz AhAge 37 years, Occu. Nil,R/O 40 Feet Road, ChalisgaonTq. Chalisgaon Dist Jalgaon17.Sumayya Begum Mohammed Abdul SaleemAge 36 years, Occu. Nil,R/O Subhash Nagar DharmabadTq Dharmabad Dist Nanded18.Mohammad Wasif Mohammad GhaziAge 31 years, Occu. Nil,R/O At Present Sajjikha Pura Adgaon BkTq. Vaijapur Dist Aurangabad19.Shaikh Munna Shaikh ZameerAge 33 years, Occu. NilR/O At present, Near Noor Hospital, BhokardhanTq. Bhokardhan & Dist. Jalna20.Farhat Jabeen Abdul MajeedAge 36 years, Occu. NilR/O. At Present Ganim Pura Karbala Road NandedTq. & Dist Nanded21.Mansuri Shireen Bano Rafeeq AhmedAge 31 years, Occu. NilR/O. At present Maqsood Colony, Near Shahi Masjid, Jalna.Tq. & Dist. Jalna22.Shahid Ameen Anees Ahmad KhanAge 33 years, Occu. NilR/O. At present Peth MohallaParli V. TQ.Parli V. DIST Beed29/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +23.Qureshi Aijaz Khan Burhan KhanAge 30 years, Occu. NilR/O. Qureshi Mohalla BhokardanTq. Bhokardan Dist Jalna24.Saleha Jabeen Shahid Anwar QuraishiAge 28 years, Occu. NilR/o Near Quraishi Masjid ShivnaTq Sillod Dist Aurangabad25.Farheen Talat Mohammed AslamAge 29 years, Occu. NilR/O. At present Ansar GanjAgra Road, Dhule, Tq. & Dist. Dhule26.Nilofer Begum Mohammed RafeeqAge 32 years, Occu. NilR/O Umar Colony Degloor Naka ItwarTq. & Dist Nanded27.Aasim Ali syed Sharafat AliAge 22 years, Occu. NilR/O. At Present Khateeb Pura, GangakhedTq. Gangakhed Dist Parbhani28.Sayyad Moeen Ali Sayyad Mohsin AliAge 23 years, Occu. NilR/O. At present Khateeb Pura, GangakhedTq. Gangakhed Dist Parbhani29.Ali Rehan Syed Zameer AliAge 22 years, Occu. NilR/O. At Present Khateeb Pura, GangakhedTq. Gangakhed Dist Parbhani30.Sahoor Ahmad Masroor AhmadAge 32 years, Occu. NilR/o At Present Firdous Colony, Mehmoodpura,Partur Tq Partur Dist. Jalna31.Shaikh Ghufran Shaikh JafarAge 23 years, Occu. NilR/o At present Ballochpura BhusawalTq Bhusawal Dist Jalgaon32.Syed Khatija Begum Tajammul Hasan PeerzadaAge 31 years, Occu. NilR/o At Present Peerzad Lane VaijapurTq. Vaijapur Dist Aurangabad30/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +33.Saba Kauser Mohammad KhaleelAge 38 years, Occu. NilR/o Momin Mohalla AjantaTq Sillod Dist Aurangabad34.Shaikh Fatema Begum Abdul KareemAge 36 years, Occu. NilR/o Syed Chand Dargha Nideban Ves Udgir Tq. Udgir Dist Latur35.Nasreen Bano Mohammed NasirAge 41 years, Occu. NilR/o Aref Colony AurangabadTq & Dist Aurangabad36.Nilofar Mahibub So NadafAge 39 years, Occu. NilR/o At. Present Noorani Masjid Beed Road,Ambejogai Tq Ambejogai Dist Beed37.Nagma Shereen Shabbir AhmedAge 34 years, Occu. NilR/o. At present Abubakar Colony, ParbhaniTq. & Dist Parbhani38.Shaista Jabeen Shaikh NaseemAge 29 years, Occu. NilR/o At Present Rohila Galli, Latur,Tq. & Dist. Latur39.Rabiya Bano Mohammad Zahur AnsariAge 32 years, Occu. NilR/O Mohammadi Nagar DeopurTq. Dist Dhule40.Aaliya Tazeen Sajid BaigAge 27 years, Occu. NilR/o At Present Habib Nagar BhokardanTq Bhodardan Dist Jalna 41.Iram Gulfishan Mohammed JaveedAge 25 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Itwara,Tq. & District Nanded.42.Nehal Nisar ManiyarAge 28 years, occu. Nil,R/o Peth Mohalla,Tq. Parli District-Beed.31/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +43.Shaikh Aafrin Sultana Khwaja MainuddinAge 37 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Roshan pura belepir Nagar,Tq. District-Beed.44.Tashfeen Ahmad Abrar Ahmad,Age 27 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Slik Milk Colony, Ch. Sambahjinagar.Tq. & Dist. Ch. Sambhajinagar.45.Mohammad Baseet Abdul Naeem,Age 29 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Momin Pura, Ch. Sambahjinagar.Tq. & Dist. Ch. Sambahjinagar.46.Shabana Yasmeen Noor KhanAge 27 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Rahim nagar jalna,Tq & District Jalna.47.Farhana Bano Syed MushtaqueAge 40 years, Occu. Nil.R/o Khadkpura,Tq. & Dist. Nanded.48.Asma Farheen Mohd ShafiAge 31 years, occu. Nil,R/o Usmanpura, Ch. Sambahjinagar.,Tq. & District Ch. Sambhajinagar49.Naziya Akhtar Nazimuddin,Age 43 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Beed Bypass, Ch. Sambahjinagar.Tq. & District Chh. Sambhajinagar.50.Shaikh Adnan Jaleel Ahemad,Age 27 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Mirza Colony, Sillod Tq Sillod. District Ch. Sambhajinagar51.Ansari Muhammad Zubair Khalid Husain,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Momin Pura, Ch. Sambahjinagar.Tq & District Chh. Sambhajinagar52.Shaikh Intekhab Aalam Mohammad RafiqueAge 30 years, Occu. Nil,At Post Mehrun, JalgaonTq & District Jalgaon32/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +53.Aslam Khan Ahmed Khan,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Jubile park, Ch. Sambahjinagar.Tq & District Chattrapat Sambhajinagar.54.Aafreen Shafeeque Ahmad,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Dhar road,Tq. & District Parbhani55.Anam Shaikh Shakeel,Age 23 years, Occu, Nil,R/o Sahagaj, Ch. Sambahjinagar.Tq & District Chattrapat Sambhajinagar56.Shaikh Ashique Shaikh GaniAge 30 years, Occu, Nil,At Present, R/O. NashirabadTq. Bhusawal, Dist. Jalgaon57.Parvez Ali Zulfequar Ali SayyedAge 35 years, Occu. Nil,R/o At Present, Room no. 487 Hazar KholiDhule, Tq Dist Dhule58.Aafrin Bano Ahmed KhanAge 30 years, Occu. Nil,R/O Nashirabad Tq. Bhusawal Dist Jalgaon59.Ansari Faizan Ahmad Riyaz AhmadAge 31 years, Occu. Nil,R/O Mahada Plot Super Market DhuleTq & Dist Dhule60.Abdul Karim Abdul MunafAge 35 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Farhat Palace Pahur Galli JamnerTq Jamner Dist Jalgaon..PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough Secretary,School Education Department,Mantralaya Mumbai-322.The Commissioner of EducationMaharashtra State,Central Building, Pune..RESPONDENTSAND33/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +WRIT PETITION NO.3916 OF 20241.Nilesh Shivaji PatilAge-34 yrs, Occ-NilR/at-45, Akahay Colony, Walwadi,Shivar, Gondur road, Deopur,Dhule-4240022.Kavita Pitamber PatilAge-37 years, Occ-NilR/at-Amalner, Janave, Jalgaon-4254013.Himani Arvind GajbeAge-33 yrs, Occ-NilR/at-Ho-No-30, Shrey NiwasHiwarkheda Road, Javhar Colony, Kannad,Aurangabad-4311034.VijayKumar Bhikaji PundgeAge-40 yrs, Occ-NilR/at-Aundha (Nagnath), Dhegaj,Hingoli-4110275.Naresh Arjun KambleAge-35 Years, Occ-NilR/at- Mogara, Shoini TW, Lakhani,Bhandara-4418096.Arvind Sriram SangaleAge-35 Years, Occ-NilR/at-Jaulka, Dusarbid,Sindkhed Raja, Buldana - 443308..PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of Maharashtrathrough the SecretaryDepartment of Education and SportsMantralaya, Mumbai-4000012.Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune,Central Building, Pune-013.CommissionerMaharashtra State Exam Council,17, Dr. Ambedkar Marg,Near Lal temple, Pune..RESPONDENTSAND34/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +WRIT PETITION NO.4200 OF 20241.Vaishali Bhikchand GhitreAge: 25 Years Occ: EducationR/O, Plot No.37, Rajesambhaji Colony,Jadhavwadi, Aurangabad2.Anuradha Jaysing GhuleAge: 29 Years, Occ: EducationR/O, At Ghulewadi Post Sautada,Tq Patoda, Beed3.Barkabai Narayan GuldagadAge : 34 Years, Occ: EducationR/O, At Post Patewadi, Tq Karjat,Dist Ahmednagar4.Dattarao Apparao WawareAge: 34 Years, Occ: EducationR/O, At Post Tadkalas, Tq Purna,Dist Parbhani5.Trupti Kondiba TaleAge:30, Occ : EducationR/O Gajanan Mandir, Tirupati Nagar, Parbhani6.Swati Chandrabhan PabaleAge : 33 Years, Occ: EducationR/O, Amrutnagar, Ghulewadi, Sangamner,Ahmednagar.7.Sushma Shivaji KeleAge : 30 Years, Occ : EducationR/O, Kelewadi, Taluka Vashi,Dist Osmanabad8.Pranoti Purushottam RavekarAge: 30 Years, Occ : EducationR/O, Pundlik Nagar, Garkheda,Aurangabad9.Chitrasen Udelal GautamAge: 33 Years, Occ: EducationR/O, Pahadsingpura, University Campus, Aurangabad..PETITIONERSVERSUS35/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its SecretarySchool Education and Sports DepartmentMantralaya, Mumbai2.The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune,Having office at Annibesant Road,District Pune.3.The Pavitra PortalWorking under the Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune.4.National Council of Teachers EducationThrough ChairpersonOffice at G-7, Dwarka, Near Metro Station,New Delhi.5.Central Board of Secondary EducationNew Delhi.6.Maharashtra State Council of ExaminationPune.7.The Deputy Director of EducationRegional Office, Aurangabad..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.4827 OF 20241.Mohammed Masihuddin FarooqiMohammed Shamshuddin FarooquiAge 33 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Pension Pura, Hingoli,Tq. & District Hingoli.2.Mohammad Ubaidurrehman Abdul Razzaque,Age 32 years, occu. Nil,R/o Shanti Nagar,District Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.3.Samreen Zakir Patel,Age: 29 years, Occu. Nil,O/o Ajna Nagar, Khokadpura,Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.4.Lazampasha Shabbeerpasha Sahebwale,Age: 39 years, Occu. Nil,Near Aurangzeb Alamgir Madarsa,Kannad, Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.36/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +5.Nasreen Yasmeen Yusuf Khan,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Usman Pura, Chattrapati Sambahjinagar.6.Mohseen Ahmad Chote Saheb,Age 28 years, Occu. Nil,R/o City Chowk,District Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.7.Rana Tabassum Syed Waheed,Age 37 years, Occu. Nil,R/o in front Bus Stand,Sajja Road, Jalna,Tq. & Dist. Jalna8.Nazneen Sultana Syed Aarif,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Kangara Colony, Tq. Aurangabad,District Chattrapati Sambhajinagar9.Syed Waquar Syed Wasim,Age 34 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Beed Bypass,District Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.10.Shaikh Nasir Shaikh Mushtaque,Age 25 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Siddharat Nagar, Jalgaon.11.Mohammad Atique Khan Nasir Khan,Age 29 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Chikhali, Tq. Chopada,District Jalgaon12.Fatema Begum Khiyamoddin Khatib,Age 26 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Roshan Colony, Hingoli,Tq. & Dist. Hingoli 13.Mohammad Javed Mohammad Shabbir,Age 35 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Shivaji Nagar,District Chattrapat Sambhajinagar.14.Mariya Aiman Mohammed Samiyouddin,Age 26 years, Occu. Nil,R/O Subedar nagar,Tq. & District Parbhani37/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +15.Shaikh Sharique Shaikh Shakir,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Harsul – Harsul – Pisadevi Road,Chattrapat SambhajinagarDistrict Chattrapat Sambhajinagar.16.Farheen Begum Mirza Nayeem Baig,Age 29 years, Occu. Nil,R/O Bodhegaon, Tq. Shevgaon,District Ahmednagar.17.Naved Patel Yunus Patel,Age 30 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Shivajinagar Tq. Ambad,District Jalna.18.Yahaya Tabassum Basheer Ahemad Khan,Age 25 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Kali Peth Basmat,District Hingoli19.Reshma Parveen Ishaque Khan,Age 37 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Pension pura, Hingoli,Tq. & Dist. Hingoli.20.Nihal Mushtaque PatelAge 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Mahegaon, Tq. Rahuri,District Ahmednagar.21.Mohammad Aasim MakhdumMohammad Aziz Ulla,Age 28 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Masoom Colony, Parbhani.22.Mo. Faizan Shaikh Haroon,Age 27 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Shekta, Tq. Shevgaon,District Ahmednagar.23.Shaiban Iqbal Azimuddin,Age 25 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Khokadpura, Tq. & DistrictChattrapati Sambhajinagar.38/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +24.Wasim Ahmad Abdul Hameed,Age 36 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Noor shah mohalla bazar patta near dehli gate at post jafferabad,Tq. & Dist. Jalna.25.Yaqoob Husain Inayat Husain Wallampalli,Age 33 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Wahida Colony, Sillod, Tq. SillodDistrict Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.26.Salman Khan Ayaz Khan,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Pedgaon, Tq. & Dist. Parbhani.27.Shaikh Azeem Shaikh Manzoor,Age 33 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Shivna Tq. Shirur (K), District Beed.28.Qayyum Mirasaheb Hatti,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Jainpur, tq. Nevasa,District Ahmednagar.29.Noorussubha Ayyub Khan,Age 26 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Bhavsingpura, Tq. & Dist.Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.30.Mahamad Arif Mubarak Patel,Age 34 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Sahida Nagar, Jalgaon,District Jalgaon.31.Sanaullah Khan Habeeb Khan,Age 31 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Loni Galli, Tq. Karjat,District Ahmednagar.32.Mohd Aatif Faisal Mohd Aarif,Age 30 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Adharshi Corner,Shanti Nagar, Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.District Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.33.Lubna Firdous Syed Muzammil,Age 25 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Bhaginghar, Tq. Paithan,District Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.39/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +34.Mohsina Qasimsab Bagwan,Age 35 years, Occu. Nil,R/o R/o Shrigonda, Tq. Shrigonda,District Ahmednagar35.Mohd Irfan A SattarAge 34 years, occu. Nil,R/o Mominpura,District Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.36.Mohammad Saquib Mohammad Abulais,Age 29 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Saprewadi, Tq. Chalisgaon,Tq. Dhule.37.Shaikh Sagheer Shaikh Basheer,Age 29 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Kohinoor, Tq. Karjat,District Ahmednagar38.Shaikh Juned Shaikh Basheer,Age 28 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Kamgar Colony, Tq. &District Jalna.39.Nargis Anjum Gulsher Khan,Age 43 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Asara Apartment Manik Nagar,Chattrapati Sambhajinagar.40.Asma Parveen Mohammad Salim,Age 26 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Gulshan Nagar, Tq. Ambad,District Jalna.41.Mohammed Nazim Mohammed Saleem,Age 23 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Parijat Colony, Jatpura Road,Hanuman Nagar, Ahmednagar.42.Bagmaroo Qaiser Begum Habib Ahmed,Age 33 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Vivekanand Colony, Ausa Road,Latur, Tq. & Dist. Latur.43.Saba Tabassum Abdul Wase,Age 32 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Momin pura near cityHotel, Beed, Tq. & Dist. Beed.40/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +44.Syed Aamer Syed Zafar,Age 28 years, Occu. Nil,R/o Mayur Park, Aurangabad Road,Jalna, Tq. & Dist. Jalna...PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its Principal Secretary,School Education & Sports Deptt.Mantralaya, Mumbai-400 032.2.The Commissioner for School Education & Sports Deptt.,Government of Maharashtra,Pune...RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.5354 OF 20241.Swati Laxman Dhapate@ Swati Mangesh DhamalAge- 36 years, Occ- NilR/at – Kateri Peth, Asawali,Tal- Khandala, Dist- Satara- 4128022.Priti Pritam PotdarAge-35 Years, Occ- NilR/at – 8 Shivshankar Residency, Satara,Shanivar Peth 1059 1060 B,Near Kale Plaza, Satara- 4150023.Yogita Vishnu Mahimkar@Yogita Dilip YevaleAge-33 years, Occ-NilGirvi Tal- Indapur, Girvi,Pimpri Bk, Pune- 4131034.Durga Vishwanath MahaleAge- 32 yrs, Occ- NilR/at – Near Gajanan Maharaj Temple,Sant Gajanan Nagar, Nagar Tas Road,Teacher Colony, Tal-Malegaon,Washim-44450341/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +5.Rakesh Gopinath TurankarAge-34 years, Occ-NilR/at- Ward No.3, Usgaon, Cement nagar,Chandrapur-4425026.Dipti Tanaji Waghmode@ Dipti Valay PiseAge- 38 years, Occ- NilR/at – Kamal Kunj Vidya Nagar,Badar Road, Nilanga, Latur – 4135217.Komal Gopal UmaleAge-33 yrs, Occ-NilR/at – Uti Kh, Post – Jalgaon, Jamod,Dist – Buldhana - 4434028.Jyoti Arjunrao BachhavAge-37 yrs, Occ-NilR/at – Patel Colony, Near Radhakrishna Mandir, Yeola, Nashik - 4234019.Sandhyarani Mohan ManeAge-34 yrs, Occ – NilR/at – Mane Galli, Nandeshwar,Bhose, Mangalwedha, Solapur - 41332210.Jyoti Gorakhnath GaikwadAge-36 yrs, Occ-NilR/at – Gavhali Road, Sakore,Sakore, Nashik – 42310611.Shital Nilkant KendreAge-36 years, Occ-NilR/at – flat No. 303, Devbhumi ApartmentSatkar Sthal west Wada Road,Rajguru Nagar, Tal – Khed, Pune - 410505..PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its SecretaryDepartment of School Education And SportsMantralaya, Mumbai-4000012.The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune,Central Building, Pune-0142/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +3.Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State Exam Council,17, Dr Ambedkar Marg,Near Lal temple, Pune..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.5646 OF 20241.Hassana Khanam Wadood Ahmed KhanAge: 36 years, Occu: NilR/o: Nagar Naka Road, Hyder Baugh,Nanded Tq. & Dist. Nanded2.Mirza Uzma Fatema Mirza Shafeeque BaigAge 29 years, Occu. Nil,R/o: Near Sadad Masjid,Azam Colony, roshan Gate, Ch. SambhajinagarTq. & Dist. Ch. Sambhajinagar3.Asma Akhtar Bi A. Hakeem ShaikhAge: 32 years Occu: NilR/O. Ghat Road, Behind Chhajed Oil MillChalisgaon Tq. Chalisgaon Dist. Jalgaon...PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough Secretary,School Education Department,Mantralaya Mumbai-322.The Commissioner of EducationMaharashtra State,Central Building, Pune..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.6608 OF 20241.Madhuri Baburao PatharkarAge: 35 years, Occ: EducationR/o. Ashti At post KadaShiv Chhatripati ChowkDistrict Beed43/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +2.Deepak Baliram KekanAge-31 years Occup-NilR/o. At Chatgaon Post DindrudTal Dharur Dist Beed..PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its SecretarySchool Education and Sports DepartmentMantarlya Mumbai2.The Commissioner (Education),Maharashtra State PuneHaving office at Annibesant Road,District Pune3.The Pavatri PortalWorking under the The commissioner (Education) PuneTal and District Pune4.Central Board of Secondary EducationNew Delhi5.Maharashtra State Council of Examination Pune Taluka And District Pune6.National Council of Teacher EducationThrough ChairpersonOffice At- G-7 Dwarka Near Metro StationNew Delhi..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.7079 OF 2024 Shaikh Abdul Laeeque Sk Abdul LateefAge: 27 years, Occu: Private JobR/o: Galli No.5, Rahmaniya ColonyAurangabad, (Chh. Sambhajinagar)Dist. Aurangabad, (Chh. Sambhajinagar)..PETITIONER44/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +VERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough Secretary,School Education Department,Mantralaya Mumbai-322.The Commissioner of EducationMaharashtra State,Central Building, Pune..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.7128 OF 2024 1.Nitin S/o Virbhadra Swami,Age : 34 years, Occu: Education,R/o Near Shivaji College3266 Shobha NiwasRenapur, Tal. Renapur,District Latur.2.Ganesh S/o Ramchandra KhobareAge : 33 years, Occu: Education,R/o Narkhed, Taluka Mohal,District Solapur3.Arvindkumar S/o Prabhu Misal,Age : 26 years, Occu: Education,R/o Datta Nagar, Misal Nivas, Beed,Taluka and District Beed.4.Amol S/o Gajanan Raut,Age : 29 years, Occu: Education,R/o Indira Nagar, Shioni, Chircharalband,Gondiya, Taluka & Dist. Gondiya.5.Chetna D/o Laxmanrao Walokar,Age : 31 years, Occu: Education,R/o Plot No.49, Karodi Road,Near Hanuman Mandir, ZingabaiVTC Mankapur, Post. Mankapur,Tal. Mankapur, Dist. Nagpur6.Jaishri D/o Nagraj DesaleAge : 34 years, Occu: Nil,R/o Malich Gorane,Taluka Sindkhed, District Dhule...PETITIONERS45/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +VERSUS1.The State of Maharashtra,Through its Secretary,School Education and Sports Department,Mantralaya, Mumbai2.The Commissioner of Education,Maharashtra State, Pune,Having office at Annibesant Road,District Pune3.The Pavitra Portal,Working under the The Commissioner of Education, Pune./Taluka and District Pune.4.The Chairman,Central Board of Secondary Education,Shiksha Kendra, 2,Community Center, Preet Vihar,New Delhi.5.Maharashtra State Council of Examination,Pune through Chairperson,Office at – Balchitrawani,Shivajinagar, Pune-411004..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.7311 OF 2024Shaikh Naseem Begum Shaikh NizamoddinAge: 40 years, Occu: NilR/o: Bhuyee Galli,Parli-V, Tq. Parli-V. Dist. Beed..PETITIONERVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough Secretary,School Education DepartmentMantralaya Mumbai-322.The Commissioner of EducationMaharashtra State,Central Building, Pune..RESPONDENTSAND46/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +WRIT PETITION NO.8246 OF 2024 Nusrat bano Mohd Haneef SheikhAge : 41 years, Occu: Private JobAt present R/o : “Admission Carrier”,Aurangpura, Aurangabad (Ch. Sambhajinagar)Tq. & Dist. Aurangabad (Ch. Sambhajinagar)..PETITIONERVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough Secretary,School Education Department,Mantralaya Mumbai-322.The Commissioner of EducationMaharashtra State,Central Building, Pune..RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.8483 OF 20241.Arvind S/O Bhujanga PundgeAge: 36 Year, Occ: EducationR/O. Plot No. 338, Near Shankar TheatorPravin Nagar, Hingoli-4315132.Asawari D/O Ashok LoleAge: 43 years, Occ: EducationR/O. 5/39 Shahu corner, Narayan PethIchalkarnji Tq. Hatkangle,Dist. Kolhapur-4161153.Sharad S/o. Popat GharateAge: 41 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Post Kusumba Tq. Dist. Dhule4.Amol S/o. Suresh KambleAge: 37 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. Mhaisalves Panchshil Chowk,Miraj, Tq. Miraj, Dist. Sangli.5.Vishal S/o. Dattatray JadhavAge: 36 years, Occ: EducationR/O. Galli No.1, At Post Kusumba,Tq. Dist. Dhule-42430247/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +6.Jyotsana D/O Ramdas FullukeAge: 38 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Dighori, Post MurmadiTq. Lakhani Dist. Bhandara.7.Sonam D/O Balkrushna BaviskarAge: 33 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. Flat No. A/B 101, Kate ResidencyNear Dapoli, Tq. Dist. Pune-4110128.Sandip S/O Shamrao GondaneAge: 33 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Post Devri, Tq. Devri,Dist. Gondiya-4419019.Pavan S/O Gangadhar KoturwarAge: 31 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Dhanora Post Karkeli,Tq. Dharmabad, Dist. Nanded10.Ganesh S/O Dattatray ChaudhariAge: 31 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At post Kusumba Tq. Dist. Dhule-42430211.Rupesh S/O Devidas KatkarAge: 31 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. Dolamba Chikhalizara Tq. DigrasDist. Yawatmal-448520312.Siddharth S/O Mansing MoreAge: 33 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Post Dudhedadi, Tq. PhaltanDist. Satara-41552313.Sumita D/O Sopan AkhadeAge: 42 Years, Occ: EducationR/O. At Post Kombhali Tq. Karjat,Dist. Ahmednagar..PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough its SecretarySchool Education and Sports Department,Mantralaya, Mumbai2.The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune.Having office at Annibesant Road,District Pune.48/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +3.The Chairman,Central Board of Secondary EducationShiksha Kendra-2 Community CenterPreet Vihar, Delhi4.National Council of Teachers EducationThrough ChairpersonOffice at G-7, Dwarka, Near Metro Station,New Delhi...RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.8560 OF 20241.Vitthal Ramchandra SargarAge- 35, Occ – Nil,At – Udanwadi, Tal – Sangola,Dist – Solapur – 4133072.Bharati Basaweshwar GayaliAge-34, Occ:-Nil,R/at-Priyasarshani chowk, Javala,Tal-Sangola, Dist-Solapur- 413309.3.Mahesh Haridas DholeAge-31, OCC-Nil,R/at-Kamlapur,Tal-Sangola, Dist – Solapur - 413307.4.Girish Dilip SurawanshiAge-32, OCC-Nil,R/at-Akluj, Tal- Malshiras,Dist-Solapur- 4131015.Vidya Nagnath JadhavAge-32, OCC-Nil,R/at-Randivewadi, Solapur - 4132096.Ashok Rajendra SalampureAge-36, OCC-NilR/at-Sangam, Po-Niranashingpur,Tal-Malshiras, Dist – Solapur – 4132117.Prashant Uttam BurandeAge-32, OCC-NilR/at-Sangole, Tal-Sangola,Dist-Solapur, 4133078.Sukeshani Kamlakar BhaleraoAge-34, OCC-Nil49/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +R/at-Chare, Tal-Barshi,Dist-Solapur, 4134099.Huljute Mukund AsramAge-36, OCC-Nil,R/at-Kharwandi, Kasar,Dist-Ahmadnagar, 41411310.Andure Vaihav VinayakAge-32, OCC-Nil,R/at-Pathardi, Kharvandi,Dist-Ahmadnagar, 41411311.Pravin Vishwanath SaravadeAge-36, OCC-Nil,R/at-Ganesh Khadu, karkhana,Kedgavnagar, Dist-Ahmadnagar12.Khedkar Ashok SuryabhanAge-31, OCC-NilR/at-Munguswade,Dist-Ahmadnagar, 41411313.Ashwini Vishwanath GosewadeAge-35, OCC-NilR/at-Subhash ward Kardi, Mohadi,Bhandara, Dist-Bhandara-44190914.Saurabh Suresh KhobragadeAge-28, OCC-Nil,R/at-Bramhi, Konda Kosra, Bhandara,Dist-Bhandara – 44190815.Sunil Diliprao KandeAge-34, OCC-NilR/at-Wakadi, Bid, Dist-Beed, 43151916.Vishnu Sakharam MundeAge-34, OCC-NilR/at-Chikhalbeed, Tal-Wadwani, Dist-Beed,17.Nanasaheb Namdeo WadaneAge-34, OCC-Nil,r/at-Wadgaon Gunda, Po-Adgaon, Dist-Beed,18.Shilpa Angadrao KaleAge-34, OCC-Nil,R/at-Pancharatn Residency, Datta Nagar,Beed, Dist- Beed, 43112250/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +19.Vivek Dagadu BuvaAge-34, OCC-NilR/at Borgaonphata, Ghotavade, Dist-Kolhapur,20.Dipika Ashok KumbharAge-35, OCC-Nil,R/at-Nehru Road, Jaysinghpur, Dist-Kolhapur,21.Ujjwala Krushna GawadeAge-37, OCC-NilR/at-Samarth Nagar, SSC Board Kolhapur,Dist-Kolhapur - 41600822.Rupali Bharat SheteAge-43, OCC-Nil,R/at-Near Marathi School Kololi,Po-Kololi, Dist-Kolhapur - 41623023.Sandeep Baban KoliAge-33, OCC-Nil,R/at-Koli Galli, Tilvani, Kolhapur,Dist-Kolhapur, 41611624.Kavita Mangesh ShelakeAge-35, OCC-Nil,R/at-Ward No. 2 Motala, Buldhana,Dist – Buldhana - 44310325.Sandip Samadhan PalaveAge-34, OCC-Nil,R/at-Savargaon Jahagir, Buldhana,Dist-Buldhana, 44310226.Mohini Nikhil ShahaAge-32, OCC-NilR/at-Khamgaon, Tal-Khamgaon,Dist-Buldhana, 44430327.Jostna Shrimant ChouguleAge-35, OCC-NilR/at- Chabukswarvadi, Dist-Sangli, 41641828.Maya Suresh Narute@ Maya Shivaji BardganAge-36, OCC-Nil,R/at-Men Road Opp. Vitthal temple,Dhangar Galli, Soni, Sangli, Dist-Sangli,51/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +29.Priyanka Vishal SutarAge-33, OCC-NilR/at-Sutar galli Malegaon, Dist-Sangli, 41640730.Vishnu Sopan RautAge – 38, OCC-NIL,R/at- Urali Kanchan,Tal-haveli, Dist- Pune - 41220231.Jyoti Balaso BitakeAge – 34, OCC – Nil,R/at- Yede Wadi Navingar, Pune - 41221932.Omkar Suryakant TamsareAge-40, OCC-NilR/at-Naigaon, Dist-Nanded, 43170733.Archana Shyamrao BingewarAge-35, OCC-NilR/at-Cidco kautha, Dist-nanded - 43160334.Kranti devidas GawaleAge-26, OCC- NilR/at-1 15 803 Gandhi Nagar,Po-Taroda BK, Dist-Nanded35.Nitin Diliprao MurodiyeAge-32, OCC-NilR/at-Ward, 1, Jamgaon Khurd, Dist-Nagpur,36.Sharad Keshav BhuraseAge-33, OCC-Nil,R/at-Keroda, Tal-Saoli Jam Keroda Ryt,Dist-Chandrapur, 44122537.Bharati Budhaji Vishe@ Bharati Dattatray GholapAge-38, OCC-NilR/at-Waghivali Vishe, Murbad, Kishore,Dist-Thane – 42140138.Dipika Kunal Zore@ Dipika Deepak PendkalkarAge – 31, Occ – Nil,Retibandar Rasta, Dombivali,Kalyan (W), Thane – 421 202.52/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +39.Savita Gopal RathodAge-34, Occ-NilR/at-Ravtale, Chiplun, Dist-Ratnagiti,40.Sharvari Nitin Wadekar@ Vinati Vijay NivalkarAge – 34, Occ – Nil,Lanja, harche, Dist – Ratnagiri – 416 71241.Pratap Vinayak ShindeAge-31, OCC-NilR/at-Ausa, LamJana, Tal-Ausa,Dist-latur, 41351642.Avinash Madhukar WahulAge-34, OCC-Nil,R/at-Plot no-513, Milind Nagar,Osmanpura, Dist- Aurangabad, 43100143.Sanjay Madhukar TribhuwanAge-33, Occ-Nil,R/at-Palkhed, Dist-Aurangabad, 42370344.Sagar Vilasrao BondreAge-30, OCC-Nil,R/at-Sayatkharda, Tal-Ghatanji,Dist- Yavatmal, 44530145.Swati Shashikant MaskeAge-35, Occ-NilR/at-Shikshak Banke javal Khandala,Tal-Khandala, Dist – Satara, 41280946.Vinod Sakharam KhilareAge-33, Occ- NilR/at-Gunda, Gund, Dist-Hingoli, 43170547.Varsha Yogesh AhireAge-38, Occ-NilR/at-Mu Patne, Tal-Malegaon,Dist-Nashik, 42320348.Pravin Jagannath JadhavAge-33, Occ-NilR/at-11, Rajwada, Pimpalgaon, Dukara,Nashik, Dist-Nashik, 422502.49.Varsharani Khashaba KuchekarAge – 35, Occ – Nil,At/Post – Kuchekarwadi, Palaskhel,Tal – Atpadi, Dist – Sangli – 415 31553/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +50.Pratibha Shankar ShewaleAge- 36, Occ – Nil,Nashik, Dist – Nashik – 422 00351.Kiran Shivaji NagareAge – 41, Occ – Nil,Yevala, Dist – Nashik - 42340352.Sangharatna Changdev ShindeAge – 33, Occ – Nil,At – Kej, Tal – Kej, Dist – Beed - 43112353.Santoshi Satyapal KhedkarAge – 34, Occ – Nil,Sasra, Sakoli, Dist – Bhandara - 44110254.Suryakant Rajaram GaikwadAge – 35, Occ – Nil,Gaikwad Vasti, Pune55.Kirankumar Dipak SaskarAge – 36, Occ – Nil,Sangamner, Dist - Ahmadnagar..PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of Maharashtra.Through the Secretary of Department of Education & Sports,Mantralaya, Mumbai – 400 0012.Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune.Central Building, Pune – 01.3.Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State Exam Council,17. Dr. Ambedkar Marg,Near Lal Temple, Pune...RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.9939 OF 20241.Yogesh Narayan MoreAge – 31, Occ. Nil,At – 185K, Agave Morevadi,Tal – Lanja, Dist- Ratnagiri - 4156162.Sunil Suresh GotadAge – 32, Occ. Nil,54/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +At – 406, Kiran Bldg, Naren nagar,OP Mangesh Soc Cholegaon, Thakurli,Dombivali - 4156193.Krupali Jysing ShindeAge – 29, Occ. Nil,At – Nivali Varchi, Ravanangvadi,Tal – Dist – Ratnagiri - 4156394.Dipak Dattaram RevaleAge – 34, Occ. Nil,At – 796, Sahanechi Wadi,Sangameshwar,Tal – Sangameshwar - 4156115.Rohit Chandrakant KashalkarAge – 33, Occ. Nil, At – 57 B, Guravwadi, Beni Budruk,Tal – Lanja, Dist - Ratnagiri6.Prabhakar Yashwant DhopatAge – 35, Occ. Nil,At/Post – Watad, Dhopatwadi,Tal- Ratnagiri - 4156137.Sugandha Shantaram AmbekdarAge – 35, Occ. Nil,At/Post – Zarewadi, Kalambatewadi,Tal – Dist – Ratnagiri - 4156198.Bhalchandra Dilip DurgavaleAge – 33, Occ. Nil,At/Post – Vesvi, Tal – Mandangad,Dist- Ratnagiri - 4152089.Girdhar Ragho MasuleAge – 33, Occ. Nil,Gotane, Post – Chaugaon, Tal – Dhule.10.Renuka Chandrakant MirguleAge – 33, Occ. Nil,At/Post – Watad, Dhopatwadi,Tal- Ratnagiri – 415613.11.Shubhada Pramod KetkarAge – 33, Occ. Nil,At Post Nive BK,Tal – Sangameshwar - 41580412.Pranoti Rajendra RangankarAge – 36, Occ. Nil,55/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +93 B, Rangankarwadi, Ganeshgule,Tal – Dist – Ratnagiri - 41561613.Kundana Sadannad Kambale@Samruddhi Liladhar KudAge – 36, Occ. Nil,At – Dabhil Ambere, Tal. Ratnagiri - 41562614.Dinesh Chandrakant KambleAge – 34, Occ. Nil,At – 117 Bauddhawadu, Post-Choravane,Tal – Sangameshwar - 415803..PETITIONERSVERSUS1.The State of MaharashtraThrough the Secretary of Department of Education & Sports,Mantralaya, Mumbai – 400 001.2.Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, Pune.Central Building, Pune – 01.3.Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State Exam Council,17. Dr. Ambedkar Marg,Near Lal Temple, Pune...RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.10720 OF 2024 1)Arun Balu JadhavAge – 32, Occ – Nil,R/At – Devape, Tal – Murbad,Dist. - Thane – 421 4012)Madhuri Arjun JadhavAge – 37, Occ. Nil,R/at Jadhavwadi, Tal. Phaltan,Dist. Satara – 415 5213)Abhijeet Hansraj UradeAge – 38, Occ. Nil,R/at Wathar, Phaltan,Dist. Satara – 415 52156/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +4) Nilesh Shantaram KulayeAge – 38, Occ. Nil,R/at Room No. 3, Rateshwar Chawl,Rawate Compound No. 3, Ramnagar,Bhandup (West), Mumbai – 400 0785) Tanishk Tejas LokareAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Tarnadale Road, Gawadewadi,Dist. Sindhudurg – 416 7026)Arti Appasaheb PatilAge 42, Occ. Nil,R/at Lanja, Tal. Lanja, Dist. Ratnagiri – 416 7017) Rajesh Chandrakant PatilAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Gorhe, Tal. Wada,Dist. Thane – 421 3038) Sharda Shatrughna BhiseAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Shahapur, Village Wasind,Dist. Thane – 421 6019)Mohan Bharat Shelake,Age – 35, Occ. Nil,R/at Mhasa, Tal. Murbad,Dist. Thane – 421 40110)Sandip Shivaji BarhateAge – 30, Occ. Nil,R/at Shirur, Takali Haji,Dist. Pune – 412 21811)Radhika Ranjit PhalkeAge – 30, Occ. Nil,R/at Waifale, Tal. Tasgaon,Dist. Sangli – 416 31212)Rajeshwar Gopal JadhavAge – 33, Occ. Nil,R/at Jeur, Tal. Akkalkot,Dist. Solapur – 413 21913)Prashant Jalindar VasamaleAge – 34, Occu. Nil,R/at Mahadeo Galli, Wadgaon, Solapur – 413 30757/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +14)Santosh Shrirang SutarAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Hatid, Solapur,Dist. Solapur – 413 30715)Swapnil Dattatraya RautAge – 36, Occ. Nil,R/at Kurduwadi, Tal. Madha,Dist. Solapur – 413 20816)Ankush Bhimrao KunseAge - 35, Occ. Nil,R/at Shendola Khurd,Amravati – 444 90217)Sonali Ramrao ParbatAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Ward No. 2, Babulgaon,Yevatmal, Dist. Yevatmal – 445 10118)Tatesh Sevakram PeteAge – 36, Occ. Nil,R/at Karatwadi, Railway Post,Tal.Akot, Dist. Akola – 444 10119)Pooja Bhausaheb NagreAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Rajapur, Tal. Sangamner,Dist. Ahmednagar – 422 60520)Sujata Sachin GarudkarAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Tergaon, KarjatAhmednagar – 414 40121)Samir Sakharam KardileAge – 38, Occ. Nil,R/at Purnawadnagar, Tal. Shrirampur,Dist. Ahmednagar – 413 709 22)Sonali Narayan DawareAge – 35, Occ. Nil,R/at Rumbhodi, Tal. Akole,Dist. Ahmednagar – 222 60123)Sangram Balkrushna TarhalAge – 32, Occ. Nil,R/at Takalibhan, Tal. Shrirampur,Dist. Ahmednagar – 413 72524)Santosh Rajmal Telpure,58/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +Age – 33, Occ. Nil,R/at Undangaon, Dist. Aurangabad – 431 11225)Avinash Laxman MaghadeAge – 31, Occ. Nil,R/at Samta Nagar,Dist. Aurangabad – 431 10926)Priyanka Naresh NarawadeAge – 35, Occ. Nil,R/at Chalisgaon, Aurangabad,Dist. Aurangabad – 431 10527)Dnyaneshwar Madan SurosheAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Nivgha Bazar, Nanded – 431 74328)Bajrang Raghunathrao WagawadAge -36, Occ. Nil,R/at Halda, Dist. Nanded – 431 64629)Murlidhar Vishwanath ShindeAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Shiradhon, Tal. Khandar,Dist. Nanded 431 70730)Shital Nagorao DudhambeAge – 29, Occ. Nil,R/at Vithai Nagar, Mudkhed,Nanded – 431 10631)Anteshwar Sheshrao KagneAge 34, occ. Nil,R/at Raiwadi, Tal. Loha, Dist. Nanded-431 70832)Hanumant Tukaram ShirameAge – 35, Occ. Nil,R/at Hadoli, Tal. Loha,Dist. Nanded – 431 71433)Daregave Shriram Sheshrao,Age – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Muslim Galli, Hanuman Mandir,Narsee, Tal. Naigaon, Dist. Nanded -431 70934)Anand Baburao RathodAge – 33, Occ. Nil,R/at Sanmukh Wadi, Tal. Mukhed,Dist. Nanded – 431 71535)Laxman Punjaji Satalwadi59/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +Age – 36, Occ. Nil,R/at Himayat Nagar, Jalgaon – 431 80236)Sachin Sahebrao BhangeAge – 32, Occ. NilR/at New Nanded Vasarni,Nanded – 431 60337)Dnyaneshwar Madan SurosheAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Nivgha Bazar, Nanded – 431 74338)Sandip Vasantrao JadhavAge-40, Occ.Nil,R/at Subhan Wada, Bahiwadi,Kolhapur Farna Nagar,Kolhapur – 416 11339)Sushant Siddharth DarabareAge-32, Occ. Nil,R/at Udgaon, Tal. Shirol,Kolhapur – 416 10140)Varsharani Anandrao PatilAge – 38, Occ. Nil,R/at Malwadi, Tal. Panhala,Dist. Kolhapur – 416 23041)Sangita Dinkar ChoughuleAge – 36, Occ. Nil,R/at Karveer, Datta Nagar,Kolapur – 416 01042)Rahul Arun Palve,Age - 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Samod, Tal. Jamner,Dist. Jalgaon – 424 20643)Sunil Sardar VanjariAge – 36, Occ. Nil,R/at Rupnagar, Tal. Bhadgaon,Dist. Jalgaon- 424 10544)Vaishalee Gajanan NavareAge – 33, Occ. Nil,R/at NER, Tal. NER,Dist. Yevatmal – 445 10245)Nikhil Suresh BorkuteAge-33, Occ. Nil,R/at Akpuri, Tal Yavatmal, 60/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +Dist. Yavatmal – 445 30146)Prakash Vilas KongalwarAge – 31, Occ. Nil,R/at Telang Takali,Tal. Kelapur, Dist. Yavatmal – 445 30247)Shudhodhan Vitthalrao MhaskeAge – 37, Occ. Nil,R/at Masla, Tal. Gangakhed,Dist – Parbhani – 431 51448)Priyanka Achutrao JadhavAge – 30, Occ. Nil,R/at Sailu, Tal. Sailloo,Dist. Parbhani – 431 50349)Minakshi Mahadeo AdhaoAge – 34, Occ. Nil,R/at Post Palshi Supo, Tal. Jalgaon,Dist. Buldhana 443403 50)Shivaji Dnyaneshwar JadhavAge – 36, Occ. Nil,R/at Mera Khurd, Tal. Chiklhli,Dist. Buldhana – 443 20151)Avinash Dnyaneshwar SurosheAge – 33, Occ. Nil,R/at Duha, Tal. Buldhana,Dist. Buldhana – 443 10652)Nilesh Ishwar HalmareAge – 35, Occ. Nil,R/at Bhandara, Dist. Bhandara – 441 90453)Vilas Keshav MohutkarAge – 31, Occ. Nil,R/at Umri, Post Mangli,Tal. PAONI, Dist. Bhandara – 441 91054)Pramod Ramlal UniwarAge – 33, Occ. Nil,R/at Amgaon, Tal. Desaiganj,Dist. Gadchiroli – 441 20755)Ganesh Dnyaneshwar BorkarAge – 30, Occ. Nil,R/at Tondgaon, Washim,Dist. Washim – 444 50561/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +56)Sachin Dnyanoba WaghmareAge – 33, Occ. Nil,R/at Khudag, Tal. Sengaon,Dist. Hingoli – 431 54257)Sharad Ravindra BodadeAge – 40, Occ. Nil,R/at Kamothe, Tal. Panvel,Dist. Raigad – 410 20958)Prashant Shivaji GadadeAge – 28, Occ. NilR/at Anjansoda BK, Tal. Chaurk, Dist. Latur59)Minakshi Shivajirao ShingareAge – 40, Occ. Nil,R/at Partur, Tal. Partur,Dist. Jalna – 431 50160)Vilas Popat PatilAge- 35, Occ. Nil,R/at Nikumbhe, Tal. Dhule,Dist. Dhule – 424 00661)Nilima Madhukar SanapAge -31, Occ. Nil,R/at Someshwar Nagar,Barshi Road, Beed,Pin Code 431 12262)Kalpesh Kashinath Ghawali,Age – 34, Occ – Nil,Room No. 510, Ghavalwadi,Near ST Stand, Dorle,Ratnagiri – 415 6256...PETITIONERSVERSUS1)The State of MaharashtraThrough the Secretary of Department of Education & Sports,Mantralaya, Mumbai – 400 0012)The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, PuneCentral Building, Pune - 013)Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State Exam Council,17, Dr. Ambedkar Marg,Near Lal Temple, Pune...RESPONDENTS62/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +ANDWRIT PETITION NO.10721 OF 2024 1)Dipak Vasudeo DingankarAge – 33 Occu – NilAt – Bhatgaon, Tal – Guhagar, Dist – Ratnigiri2)Nitin Laxman SahareAge – 36, Occ. Nil,At – Mardi, Near Hanuman Mandir,Tal. Teosa, Dist. Amravati – 444 9043)Ramdas Pandurang WagadkarAge – 31, Occu. Nil,At – Plot No. 72, At Post Wakad,Tal. Bhokar, Dist. Nanded – 431 8014) Rajshree Manikrao LahaneAge – 34 , Occ. Nil,At – Pimpaldari, Tal. Gangakhed,Dist. Parbhani – 431 5145) Santosh Shivling HingmireAge – 29, Occ. Nil,At – Kelgaon, Tal. Sillod,Dist. Aurangabad – 431 1126)Madhuri Anandrao NaleAt – Saswad, Tal. Phaltan, Dist. Satara - 4155217) Sheetal Prashant BhokareAge – 35, Occ. Nil,At – Bhilwadi, Tal. Palus, Dist. Sangli – 4163038) Sujata Sitaram SonwalkarAge – 37 Occ. Nil,At – Songaon, Tal. Baramati,Dist. Pune – 412 1029)Praveen Shahaji ShendgeAge – 29, Occ. Nil,At – Kharatwadi, Post Pimpalegaon,Tal. Shrigonda, Dist. Ahmednagar – 413 70310)Kavita Prabhakar KhedkarAge – 34, Occ. Nil,At – Nimblak, Tal. Ahmednagar,Dist. Ahmednagar – 414 11163/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +11)Nagesh Sanjay PophaleAge – 33, Occ. Nil,At – Hirdav, Tal. Lonar,Dist. Buldhana – 443 30212)Rahul Balashaeb ShirsatAge – 33, Occu. Nil,At – Shirsatwadi, Mahadev Mandir,Near Mahadev Mandir, Tal. Pathardi,Dist. Ahmednagar – 414 10213)Maruti Pandurang BandgarAge – 34, Occ. Nil,At – Ankdhal Post Chinke,Tal. Sangola, Dist. Solapur – 413 30814)Rakshanda Dilip DeoreAge – 32, Occ. Nil,At – Plot No. 1, Bunglow No. 1,Chandrawel Phase – 2, Nakane Road,Walwadi Shiwar Deopur, Dhule – 424 00215)Lata Nathu PardhiAge – 39, Occu. Nil,At – Juni Wasti, Killa Ward,Tirora, Tal. Tirora, Dist. Gondiya – 441 91116)Priyanka Kailash NarwadeAge – 35, Occu. Nil,At – Chitegaon, Tal. Paithan,Dist. Aurangabad – 431 10517)Neha Shriram KutafaleAge – 33, Occ. Nil,At – Mauli Apt Godbole,Plot Dabki Road, Dist. Akola – 444 00218) Sanjay Baburao RathodAge – 37, Occ. Nil,At – Chakucha Tanda,Tal. Gevrai, Dist. Beed – 431 14319)Dipali Digambar HawaleAge – 33, Occu. Nil,At – Kolher Road, Sanjay Nagar,Georai, Dist. Beed – 431 127...PETITIONERSVERSUS1)The State of MaharashtraThrough the Secretary of 64/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +Department of Education & Sports,Mantralaya, Mumbai – 400 0012)The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, PuneCentral Building, Pune - 013)Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State Exam Council,17, Dr. Ambedkar Marg,Near Lal Temple, Pune...RESPONDENTS…ANDWRIT PETITION NO.8496 OF 20241)Syed Azizoddin Syed Gyasoddin Qauzi,Age 33 years, Occ. Nil,R/o. At present Nagar Naka Road, HyderBaugh, Nanded, Tq.& Dist. Nanded2)Sabiha Tabassum Ishaque Shah,Age 30 years, Occ. Nil,R/o. At present near Sadad MasjidAzam Colony, Roshan Gate, Ch. SambhajinagarTq. & Dist. Sambhajinagar.3)Munzreen Kausar Abdul Nasir,Age 32 years, occ. Nil.R/o. At present Ghat Road, Behind Chhajed OilMil, Chalisgaon, Tq. Chalisgaon, Dist. Jalgaon4)Mohammad Arifuddin Mohammad HakimuddinAge 38 years, Occ. Nil,R/o. At present Ghat Road, Behind Chhajed OilMill, Chalisgaon, Tq. Chalisgaon, Dist. Jalgaon.5)Arshiya Naaz Hamzakhan,Age 26 years, Occ. Nil,R/o. At present New Baijipura, Chalisgaon, Tq. Chalisgaon, Dist. Jalgaon...PETITIONERVERSUS65/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +1)The State of MaharashtraThrough Secretary, School EducationDepartment, Mantralaya, Mumbai-322)The Commissioner of EducationMaharashtra State, Central Building, Pune...RESPONDENTSANDWRIT PETITION NO.12566 OF 2024 Usha d/o Shankarrao KendheAge 45 years, Occ. Education,R/o C/o. Sudam More, Plot No. 13S No. 11,Gurukrupa Colony, Sudhakar Nagar Road,Near Ganga Godavari Lawns, Satara Parisar,Chh. Sambhajinagar-431003...PETITIONERVERSUS1)The State of MaharashtraThrough its Principal SecretarySchool Education and Sports Department,Mantralaya, Mumbai.2)The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, PuneHaving Office at Annibesant Road,District Pune3)The Chairman Central Board of SecondaryEducation, Shiksha Kendra-2 CommunityCentre at Preet Vihar, Delhi4)National Council of Teachers Education thr. Chairperson, Office at G-7, Dwarka NearMetro Station, New Delhi (Resp. Nos.3 and 4 deleted as per courts order dated10.12.2024)...RESPONDENTSAND66/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt + WRIT PETITION NO. 10354 OF 2024Shridhar Vilasrao Sawant,Age 41 years, Occ. Job,R/o. At post Gundge Patan,District Satara...PETITIONERVERSUS1)The State of MaharashtraThrough its SecretarySchool Education and Sports DepartmentMantralaya Mumbai.2)The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, PuneHaving Office at Annibesant Road,District Pune.3)The Pavatra Portal,Working Under the Commissioner (Education) PuneTq. & Dist. Pune4)Central Board of Secondary EducationNew Delhi5)Maharashtra State Council of ExaminationPune, Taluka and District Pune6)National Council of Teacher EducationThrough Chairperson,Office At G-7, Dwarka Near Metro StationNew Delhi...RESPONDENTSAND WRIT PETITION NO.13500 OF 20241)Santosh Bhikandas Nagargoje,Age 34 years, Occ. Education,R/o. At Wadgaon Gundha Post Adgaon,Tq. & Dist. Beed.2)Rahulkumar Dnyanoba Yedake,Age 30 years, Occ. Nil,R/o. Ghatnandur Post Ghatpimpri,Tq. Bhoom, Dist. Osmanabad.67/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +3)Vikram Ganesh Lavhate,Age 31 years, Occ. Education,R/o. At post Talegaon Bhokardan,Tq. & Dist. Jalna.4)Yogesh Bajarang Baravkar,Age 34 years, Occ. Nil,R/o. At post Dongerkinhi,Tq. Patoda, Dist. Beed.…PETITIONERSVERSUS1)The State of MaharashtraThrough its SecretarySchool Education and Sports DepartmentMantralaya Mumbai.2)The Commissioner (Education)Maharashtra State, PuneHaving Office at Annibesant Road,District Pune.3)The Pavatra Portal,Working Under the Commissioner (Education) PuneTq. & Dist. Pune4)Central Board of Secondary EducationNew Delhi5)Maharashtra State Council of ExaminationPune, Taluka and District Pune6)National Council of Teacher EducationThrough Chairperson,Office At G-7, Dwarka Near Metro StationNew Delhi...RESPONDENTS…Advocates for the Petitioners in respective matters : Mr. S.S. Thombre,Mr. R.S. Deshmukh Sr. advocate i/b. Mr. V. R. Gargade, Mr. KuthwadManoj Ramdas, Mr. M.R. Wagh, Mr. D.R.Shelke, a/w Mr. S.H. Rathod,Mr. Sanjeev Bapu Deore and Mr. A.R. Syed, Advocate for Respondents – State : Mr. Birendra Saraf Advocate Generala/w Mr. A.B. Girase Government Pleader, S.K. Tambe, Addl.G.P. andMs. Neha B. Kamble AGP in all Writ Petitions Advocate for Applicant (Intervenor) in CA/3738/2024: Mr. V.D. Sapkal,Senior Counsel i/b. Mr. S. R. Sapkal 68/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +Advocate for Respondent No.5 in WP/7128/2024 : Mr. Swapnil Joshi a/wMr. Chetan Chaudhari and Mr. Mahendra Swami i/b M/s. J.P. LegalAssociates Advocate for Respondents : Mr. S.S. Deve and Mr. Sachin V. Kuptekar forNational Council of Teachers Education in respective matters Advocate for Respondent : Mr. A.R. Nikam for Maharashtra State ExamCouncil in respective Writ Petitions ... CORAM : MANGESH S. PATIL & PRAFULLA S. KHUBALKAR, JJ.Reserved on : 14.12.2024Pronounced on : 14.02.2025JUDGMENT (MANGESH S. PATIL, J.) :Considering commonalty of the issues raised in all thesepetitions from different benches of the High Court, those have beenclubbed together, heard together and are being disposed of by thiscommon judgment.2.Rule. It is made returnable forthwith. Learned AdvocateGeneral Mr. Birendra Saraf, and the learned advocates for the respectiverespondents waive service. Considering the urgency and the ramificationsince challenges are put up to the entire merit list prepared by the Boardof Examination of the State of Maharashtra, the matters are heard finallyat the stage of admission.3.At the outset, it would be apt to cull down the common issueto be addressed in all these petitions :Whether candidates from the reserved category who have availedthe concession to become eligible to participate in the examinationto select the candidates for a post, can migrate to an69/86 WP.8610.24.TET.odt +open/unreserved category on the basis of their scores in theselection examination. 4.All these petitions put up a challenge to the merit listpublished on 25.02.2024 for recommending the candidate to individualestablishments for recruitment of teachers through an online portal viz.Pavitra Portal, evolved in the light of directions of this Court ofundertaking the process.5.In order to appreciate the issue in the proper perspective, itwould be apposite to peep into the history. In the light of the provision ofSection 23 of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory EducationAct, 2009 (RTE Act), the qualification for appointment and terms andconditions of the service of the teachers, are expected to be provided forensuring quality of education imparted to children. The CentralGovernment established National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE)on 23.08.2010 as an apex body to lay down the qualification forappointment of teachers. The NCTE laid down the qualification for aperson to be appointed as a teacher to teach Class I to VIII on23.08.2010. It prescribed clearance of Teachers Eligibility Test (TET) asan essential qualification for appointment of teachers. By issuingnotification on 11.02.2011 it also laid down methodology of the TETexamination. It was stated that the qualifying marks would be 60% ormore at the TET examination. It also enabled the Governments, localbodies and government aided and unaided institutions to relax this70/86
Decision
WP.8610.24.TET.odt +34.All pending civil applications are disposed of.35.Rule is discharged. [ PRAFULLA S. KHUBALKAR] [ MANGESH S. PATIL ] JUDGE JUDGEhabeeb86/86