High Court
Legal Reasoning
IN THE NATIONAL LOK ADALAT PRESIDED OVER BY HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE R. M. JOSHI,HELD ON 9th DECEMBER, 2023AT HIGH COURT LEGAL SERVICES SUB-COMMITTEEAT AURANGABAD1 FIRST APPEAL NO.3391 OF 2016WITH FA/3392/2016 WITH CA/13852/2011 IN FA/3392/2016 WITHCA/13858/2011 IN FA/3391/2016 WITH FA/3393/2016 WITHCA/13856/2011 IN FA/3393/2016 THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR BEED AND ANRVERSUSVITHAL SAYAJI JAYBHAYE AND ORSAND2 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10166 OF 2010IN FAST/17941/2010 WITH CA/2905/2012 IN FAST/17941/2010 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA VERSUSAAHELU SADHU MANE(DIED) LRS SUDAM SANTU MANE AND ORSAND3 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13853 OF 2011IN FAST/25567/2011 WITH CA/13854/2011 IN FAST/25567/2011 THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR BEED AND ANRVERSUSDULBA RAJARAM JAYBHAYE AND ANRAND4 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13909 OF 2011IN FAST/25028/2011 WITH CA/13910/2011 IN FAST/25028/2011 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA VERSUSBABURAO DADABA KEDAR ANDORS1 to 46.odt1 of 11 AND5 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1806 OF 2013IN FAST/21439/2012 WITH CA/1807/2013 IN FAST/21439/2012 THE STATE OF MAH THR COLLECTOR AND ANRVERSUSGANPATI RAGHU ANDHALE AND ORSAND6 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1997 OF 2013IN FAST/31132/2012 WITH CA/1998/2013 IN FAST/31132/2012 THE STATE OF MAH THR COLLECTOR AND ANRVERSUSVASUDEO NIVRUTTI RAKH AND7 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3762 OF 2013IN FAST/3436/2013 WITH CA/3763/2013 IN FAST/3436/2013 WITHCA/3765/2013 IN FAST/3475/2013 WITH CA/3764/2013 INFAST/3475/2013 WITH CA/3771/2013 IN FAST/3478/2013 WITHCA/3770/2013 IN FAST/3478/2013 WITH CA/3767/2013 INFAST/3481/2013 WITH CA/3766/2013 IN FAST/3481/2013 WITHCA/3769/2013 IN FAST/3484/2013 WITH CA/3768/2013 INFAST/3484/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHERVERSUSDATTU GANPAT ITHAPE AND8 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.8307 OF 2013IN FAST/16122/2013 WITH CA/8308/2013 IN FAST/16122/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHERVERSUSBABU MAROTI WAGH AND9 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.8311 OF 2013IN FAST/16116/2013 WITH CA/8312/2013 IN FAST/16116/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER1 to 46.odt2 of 11 VERSUSKAMALBAI HIMMATRAO PATANGE AND10 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10944 OF 2013IN FAST/19614/2013 WITH CA/10945/2013 IN FAST/19614/2013 WITH CA/10950/2013 IN FAST/19678/2013 WITH CA/10951/2013 INFAST/19678/2013 WITH CA/10948/2013 IN FAST/19681/2013 WITHCA/10949/2013 IN FAST/19681/2013 WITH CA/10946/2013 INFAST/19684/2013 WITH CA/10947/2013 IN FAST/19684/2013 WITHCA/10952/2013 IN FAST/19687/2013 WITH CA/10953/2013 INFAST/19687/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHERVERSUSRAMNATH SHANKAR DHAMNE AND11 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.11016 OF 2013IN FAST/19617/2013 WITH CA/11017/2013 IN CA/11016/2013 WITHCA/11018/2013 IN FAST/19666/2013 WITH CA/11019/2013 INFAST/19666/2013 WITH CA/11022/2013 IN FAST/19672/2013 WITHCA/11023/2013 IN FAST/19672/2013 WITH CA/11020/2013 INFAST/19675/2013 WITH CA/11021/2013 IN FAST/19675/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANRVERSUSPANDURANG SAHEBRAO SANAP AND ORSAND12 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.11028 OF 2013IN FAST/19645/2013 WITH CA/11029/2013 IN FAST/19645/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANRVERSUSBHAGWAN LAXIMAN HINGE AND13 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.11354 OF 2013IN FAST/22832/2013 WITH CA/11355/2013 IN FAST/22832/2013 WITH CA/11352/2013 IN FAST/22835/2013 WITH CA/11353/2013 INFAST/22835/2013 1 to 46.odt3 of 11 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHERVERSUSARJUN LAXMAN KAPSE AND OTHERSAND14 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.12949 OF 2013IN FAST/20456/2013 WITH CA/12950/2013 IN FAST/20456/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHERVERSUSKADAR DADUBHAI PATHAN DIED LRS SARDARBI KADAR PATHAN ANDOTHERSAND15 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1904 OF 2014IN FAST/35526/2013 WITH CA/1905/2014 IN FAST/35526/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA VERSUSTULSIRAM AMBAJI CHATE AND ANOTHERAND16 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.6563 OF 2014IN FAST/10421/2014 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHERVERSUSMACHINDRA PANDURANG UGALE AND OTHERSAND17 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10783 OF 2009IN FAST/20484/2009THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRAVERSUSMAHADEO DIGAMBAR DAMBAREAND18 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4166 OF 2010IN FAST/5645/2010 WITH CA/4167/2010 IN FAST/5645/2010 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR 1 to 46.odt4 of 11 VERSUSJADITRAO VENUNATH SUTAR AND ORSAND19 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.18058 OF 2010IN FAST/33395/2010 WITH CA/18059/2010 IN FAST/33395/2010 THE STATE OF MAH AND ORS VERSUSDATTATRAYA BABURAO PANCHAL AND ANRAND20 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2083 OF 2011IN FAST/2237/2011 WITH CA/2084/2011 IN FAST/2237/2011 WITHCA/2085/2011 IN FAST/2293/2011 WITH CA/2086/2011 INFAST/2293/2011 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA VERSUSARJUN BAPU UNDARE (DIED) LRS BABURAO ARJUN UNDARE ANDORSAND21 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3923 OF 2011IN FAST/6171/2011 THE STATE OF MAH, THR. COLLECTOR, OSMANABADVERSUSANANT GOVIND TAWARE AND ANRAND22 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5152 OF 2011IN FAST/5457/2011 WITH CA/5153/2011 IN FAST/5457/2011 WITHCA/5156/2011 IN FAST/5560/2011 WITH CA/5226/2011 INFAST/5560/2011 WITH CA/5154/2011 IN FAST/5564/2011 WITHCA/5155/2011 IN FAST/5564/2011 WITH CA/5157/2011 INFAST/5567/2011 WITH CA/5158/2011 IN FAST/5567/2011 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANRVERSUSNARHARI RAMRAO TAMBE AND23 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5159 OF 2011IN FAST/6762/2011 WITH CA/5160/2011 IN FAST/6762/2011 1 to 46.odt5 of 11
Legal Reasoning
THE STATE OF MAH, THR. COLLECTOR, OSMANABAD AND ANRVERSUSDEODATT ANANDRAO PATIL AND24 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5179 OF 2011IN FAST/8265/2011 WITH CA/5180/2011 IN FAST/8265/2011 WITHCA/5177/2011 IN FAST/8270/2011 WITH CA/5178/2011 INFAST/8270/2011 THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR OSMANABADVERSUSGOVIND LIMBAJI PAWAR, DIED THR. L.RS. BALIKA GOVIND PAWAR ANDORSAND25 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.9518 OF 2011IN FAST/13973/2011 THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR OSMANABAD AND ANRVERSUSRAMRAO BAPURAO JADHAV AND26 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2119 OF 2013IN FAST/30229/2012 WITH CA/2120/2013 IN FAST/30229/2012 THE STATE OF MAH VERSUSSHRIKANT SHRIDHARRAO RAJESHWARKAR, DIED THR. L.RS. SHRIPAD ANDORSAND27 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3681 OF 2013IN FAST/2449/2013 WITH CA/3682/2013 IN FAST/2449/2013 WITHCA/3683/2013 IN FAST/2466/2013 WITH CA/3684/2013 INFAST/2466/2013 THE STATE OF MAH VERSUSANGAD WAMANRAO NALWADE AND ORSAND1 to 46.odt6 of 11 29 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2289 OF 2016IN FAST/2329/2016 WITH CA/2294/2016 IN FAST/2343/2016 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND OTHERSVERSUSRAMESH PANDIT CHAVAN AND ANRAND30 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4508 OF 2016IN FAST/10026/2016 WITH CA/4509/2016 IN FAST/10026/2016 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANRVERSUSDEVIDASRAO NARAYANRAO KULKARNI SINCE DECEASED THRLRSVIJAYABAI DEVIDASRAO SANGVIKAR AND ORSAND31 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4534 OF 2016IN FAST/10592/2016 WITH CA/4535/2016 IN FAST/10592/2016 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANRVERSUSJAGANNATH DEVRAO KHANDEKAR AND ORSAND32 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5449 OF 2016IN FAST/36179/2015 WITH CA/5466/2016 IN FAST/36170/2015 WITHCA/5462/2016 IN FAST/36185/2015 WITH CA/5460/2016 INFAST/36189/2015 WITH CA/5472/2016 IN FAST/36197/2015 WITHCA/5470/2016 IN FAST/36218/2015 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND OTHERSVERSUSSAYYAD MANJUR AHMED KAZIAND38 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4926 OF 2012IN FAST/8859/2012 WITH CA/4927/2012 IN FAST/8859/2012 WITHCA/4929/2012 IN FAST/8864/2012 WITH CA/4928/2012 INFAST/8864/2012 THE STATE OF MAH VERSUSKISAN LAHANU DHAWLE AND ORS1 to 46.odt7 of 11 AND39 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10359 OF 2012IN FAST/20370/2012 WITH CA/10363/2012 IN FAST/20376/2012 WITH CA/10373/2012 IN FAST/20367/2012 WITH CA/10374/2012 INFAST/20367/2012 WITH CA/10360/2012 IN FAST/20370/2012 WITHCA/10361/2012 IN FAST/20373/2012 WITH CA/10362/2012 INFAST/20373/2012 WITH CA/10364/2012 IN FAST/20376/2012 WITHCA/10365/2012 IN FAST/20379/2012 WITH CA/10366/2012 INFAST/20379/2012 WITH CA/10367/2012 IN FAST/20382/2012 WITHCA/10368/2012 IN FAST/20382/2012 WITH CA/10371/2012 INFAST/20393/2012 WITH CA/10372/2012 IN FAST/20393/2012 WITHCA/10369/2012 IN FAST/20396/2012 WITH CA/10370/2012 INFAST/20396/2012 THE STATE OF MAH VERSUSNAMDEO SHRIRANG GHALME, DIED THR. L.RS. THHAKUBAI ANDORSAND40 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10621 OF 2012IN FAST/21576/2012 WITH CA/10623/2012 IN FAST/21576/2012 THE STATE OF MAH VERSUSRANJANABAI SAMBHAJI DHAVDE AND41 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10828 OF 2012IN FAST/16870/2012 WITH CA/10822/2012 IN FAST/16864/2012 WITH CA/10823/2012 IN FAST/16864/2012 WITH CA/10826/2012 INFAST/16867/2012 WITH CA/10827/2012 IN FAST/16867/2012 WITHCA/10829/2012 IN FAST/16870/2012 WITH CA/10824/2012 INFAST/16873/2012 WITH CA/10825/2012 IN FAST/16873/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR VERSUSGODARAM NAMDEV GADE AND ANRAND44 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10527 OF 2014IN FAST/22807/2014 WITH CA/10525/2014 IN FAST/22804/2014 WITH CA/10526/2014 IN FAST/22804/2014 WITH CA/10528/2014 INFAST/22807/2014 WITH CA/10518/2014 IN FAST/22810/2014 WITH1 to 46.odt8 of 11 CA/10519/2014 IN FAST/22810/2014 WITH CA/10522/2014 INFAST/22830/2014 WITH CA/10523/2014 IN FAST/22830/2014 WITHCA/10516/2014 IN FAST/22833/2014 WITH CA/10517/2014 INFAST/22833/2014 WITH CA/10520/2014 IN FAST/22836/2014 WITHCA/10521/2014 IN FAST/22836/2014 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHERVERSUSDAGADU ABA DOKE AND OTHERS AND46 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.7877 OF 2015IN FAST/22331/2014 WITH CA/7868/2015 IN FAST/22318/2014 WITHCA/7870/2015 IN FAST/22318/2014 WITH CA/7880/2015 INFAST/22326/2014 WITH CA/7879/2015 IN FAST/22326/2014 WITHCA/7878/2015 IN FAST/22331/2014 WITH CA/7866/2015 INFAST/22337/2014 WITH CA/7867/2015 IN FAST/22337/2014 WITHCA/7875/2015 IN FAST/22342/2014 WITH CA/7876/2015 INFAST/22342/2014 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA VERSUSRAMBHAU TRIMBAK TODMAL AND OTHERS...AGP for Appellant: Mr. A. R. Kale, Mr. V. M. Jaware Advocate :Mr. S. K. ShirseMr. Rajkumar Mahdev Mane, Deputy Collector, Medium Project No. 2,Osmanabad is present. Mr. Gangaram Mahadu Talpade, Deputy Collector is present.ORDER(9th December, 2023)1.These appeals are placed before the National Lok Adalat by theappellant-State.2.Learned AGP for the appellant/State submitted that the abovementioned appeals are squarely covered by the Government Resolutiondated 03/11/2016 with corrigendums dated 23/02/2017 and 13/08/20181 to 46.odt9 of 11
Decision
to the said Government Resolution. In turn, these appeals can bewithdrawn as per the policy decision taken by the Government ofMaharashtra. Accordingly, the State is withdrawing these appeals.3.The learned AGP for the state submits that in some of the appeals,the state has already deposited the compensation amount. He furthersubmits that if the amount of compensation is not deposited before thisCourt or before the Reference Court, then the same will be deposited inReference Court within a period of six months from the date of this order.If the amount is not deposited within six months from today, then it shallcarry the interest as per Section 28 or 34 of the Act as the case may be.After depositing said amount in the Reference Court, the claimants areentitled to withdraw the same. It is further clarifed that in case, anyamount is lying with this Court, then the same shall be transmitted to theReference Court. The Reference Court shall disburse said amount to theclaimants on their applications. The learned AGP further submits that inthese circumstances, nothing survives in these appeals. Therefore, theseappeals and application for condonation of delay can be disposed of aswithdrawn by the State.4.In view of the above, this group of appeals stand disposed of aswithdrawn. No order as to costs.1 to 46.odt10 of 11 5.Refund of Court fees be processed as per rules. 6.Pending Civil Applications, if any, stands disposed of. [A. B. Kadethankar]AdvocateMember[V. B. Mantri]DJ (Retd.)Member [R. M. JOSHI, J.]Head of Panel Malani1 to 46.odt11 of 11