THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER DEPARTMENT SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT PARANDA v. GORAKH SUBRAO SURYAWANSHI
Case Details
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD 917 FIRST APPEAL NO.2941 OF 2023 WITH CA/4167/2023 IN FA/2941/2023 WITH FA/2943/2023 WITH CA/4173/2023 IN FA/2943/2023 WITH FA/2388/2023 WITH CA/4171/2023 IN FA/2388/2023 WITH FA/2942/2023 WITH CA/4169/2023 IN FA/2942/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER DEPARTMENT SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT PARANDA VERSUS GORAKH SUBRAO SURYAWANSHI ... Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mr. K. N. Lokhande ... AND 979 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3028 OF 2023 IN FAST/7280/2023 WITH CA/3029/2023 IN FAST/7280/2023 WITH CA/3030/2023 IN FAST/7287/2023 WITH CA/3031/2023 IN FAST/7287/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SINA KOLEGAON PROJECT DIVISIONPARANDA VERSUS VISHWANATH SHANKAR KARPURE ... Advocate for Applicants : Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mr. K. B. Jadhavar … AND 980 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3032 OF 2023 IN FAST/7263/2023 WITH CA/3033/2023 IN FAST/7263/2023 WITH CA/3034/2023 IN FAST/7269/2023 WITH CA/3036/2023 IN FAST/7269/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS JAGANNATH BABU KOLI (DIED) ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mrs. R. P. Gour 2 917 FA 2941-2023 ... AND 982 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3038 OF 2023 IN FAST/7255/2023 WITH CA/3039/2023 IN FAST/7255/2023
Legal Reasoning
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER DEPARTMENT OF SINA KOLEGAON PROJECT PARANDA VERSUS APPA LIMBAJI PATIL ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mr. K. B. Jadhavar ... AND 984 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4182 OF 2023 IN FAST/10198/2023 WITH CA/4181/2023 IN FAST/10198/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SINA KOLEGAON PROJECT DIVISIONPARANDA VERSUS KONDABAI VITTHAL THAVARE (DIED) ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr.Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mr. N. T. Bhagat ... AND 985 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4200 OF 2023 IN FAST/10148/2023 WITH CA/4202/2023 IN FAST/10148/2023 WITH CA/4212/2023 IN FAST/10161/2023 WITH CA/4214/2023 IN FAST/10161/2023 WITH CA/4209/2023 IN FAST/10164/2023 WITH CA/ 4211/2023 IN FAST/10164/2023 WITH CA/4204/2023 IN FAST/10167/2023 WITH CA/4206/2023 IN FAST/10167/2023 WITH CA/ 4207/2023 IN FAST/10170/2023 WITH CA/4208/2023 IN FAST/10170/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS DEVIDAS JIVALAGA SURYAWANSHI (KASAB), ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State: Mr. K. B. Jadhavar ... 3 917 FA 2941-2023 AND 986 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4216 OF 2023 IN FAST/10359/2023 WITH CA/4217/2023 IN FAST/10359/2023 WITH CA/4220/2023 IN FAST/10365/2023 WITH CA/4221/2023 IN FAST/10365/2023 WITH CA/4218/2023 IN FAST/10376/2023 WITH CA/ 4219/2023 IN FAST/10376/2023 WITH CA/4223/2023 IN FAST/10380/2023 WITH CA/4224/2023 IN FAST/10380/2023 WITH CA/ 4226/2023 IN FAST/10384/2023 WITH CA/4227/2023 IN FAST/10384/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SINA KOLEGAON PROJECT DIVISIONPARANDA VERSUS ASHOK LAXMANRAO PADULE ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr.Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mrs. R. P. Gour … AND 988 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4235 OF 2023 IN FAST/10422/2023 WITH CA/4238/2023 IN FAST/10422/2023 WITH CA/4240/2023 IN FAST/10425/2023 WITH CA/4243/2023 IN FAST/10425/2023 WITH CA/4245/2023 IN FAST/10429/2023 WITH CA/ 4248/2023 IN FAST/10429/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SINA KOLEGAON PROJECT DIVISIONPARANDA VERSUS ARUN SANDIPAN PADULE ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mr. K. B. Jadhavar ... AND 989 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4241 OF 2023 IN FAST/10279/2023 WITH CA/4237/2023 IN FAST/10275/2023 WITH CA/4239/2023 IN FAST/10275/2023 WITH CA/4242/2023 IN FAST/10279/2023 WITH CA/4244/2023 IN FAST/10283/2023 WITH CA/ 4246/2023 IN FAST/10283/2023 WITH CA/4247/2023 IN FAST/10288/2023 WITH CA/4249/2023 IN FAST/10288/2023 WITH CA/ 4250/2023 IN FAST/10295/2023 WITH CA/4252/2023 IN FAST/10295/2023 WITH CA/4253/2023 IN FAST/10300/2023 WITH CA/ 4254/2023 IN FAST/10300/2023 4 917 FA 2941-2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SEENA KOLEGAON PARANDA VERSUS BABULAL MUSSA FAKIRAND OTHERS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr.Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mrs. R. P. Gour … AND 990 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4258 OF 2023 IN FAST/10392/2023 WITH CA/4257/2023 IN FAST/10392/2023 WITH CA/4261/2023 IN FAST/10396/2023 WITH CA/4262/2023 IN FAST/10396/2023 WITH CA/4259/2023 IN FAST/10399/2023 WITH CA/ 4260/2023 IN FAST/10399/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SEENA KOLEGAON PARANDA VERSUS BALWANT BHAIRU PATIL OTHERS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr.Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mr. N. T. Bhagat … AND 991 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4267 OF 2023 IN FAST/10518/2023 WITH CA/4266/2023 IN FAST/10518/2023 WITH CA/4268/2023 IN FAST/10531/2023 WITH CA/4269/2023 IN FAST/10531/2023 WITH CA/4270/2023 IN FAST/10539/2023 WITH CA/ 4271/2023 IN FAST/10539/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER DEPARTMENT OF SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT PARANDA VERSUS VISHVNATH SOUDAGAR GHOGARE AND OTHERS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mr.K. B. Jadhavar ... AND 992 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4284 OF 2023 IN FAST/10480/2023 WITH CA/4274/2023 IN FAST/10449/2023 WITH CA/4275/2023 IN FAST/10449/2023 WITH CA/4277/2023 IN FAST/10452/2023 WITH CA/4278/2023 IN FAST/10452/2023 WITH CA/ 4282/2023 IN FAST/10455/2023 WITH CA/4285/2023 IN 5 917 FA 2941-2023 FAST/10455/2023 WITH CA/4288/2023 IN FAST/10461/2023 WITH CA/ 4290/2023 IN FAST/10461/2023 WITH CA/4293/2023 IN FAST/10465/2023 WITH CA/4296/2023 IN FAST/10465/2023 WITH CA/ 4279/2023 IN FAST/10468/2023 WITH CA/4280/2023 IN FAST/10468/2023 WITH CA/4281/2023 IN FAST/10473/2023 WITH CA/ 4283/2023 IN FAST/10473/2023 WITH CA/4286/2023 IN FAST/10480/2023 WITH CA/4287/2023 IN FAST/10486/2023 WITH CA/ 4289/2023 IN FAST/10486/2023 WITH CA/4291/2023 IN FAST/10489/2023 WITH CA/4292/2023 IN FAST/10489/2023 WITH CA/ 4294/2023 IN FAST/10497/2023 WITH CA/4295/2023 IN FAST/10497/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SINA KOLEGAON PROJECT DIVISIONPARANDA VERSUS UTTRESHWAR GYANBA PATIL (DIED) THR LRS GAJENDRA PATILAND ORS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr.Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mrs. R. P. Gour ... AND 993 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.6582 OF 2023 IN FAST/15622/2023 WITH CA/6583/2023 IN FAST/15622/2023 WITH CA/6584/2023 IN FAST/15625/2023 WITH CA/6585/2023 IN FAST/15625/2023 WITH CA/6586/2023 IN FAST/15629/2023 WITH CA/ 6587/2023 IN FAST/15629/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT - KRISHNA KHORE - M I AND PT DIVISION VERSUS DADASAHEB VITTHAL SALUNKE AND OTHERS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr.Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mr. N. T. Bhagat ... AND 994 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.6593 OF 2023 IN FAST/15637/2023 WITH CA/6596/2023 IN FAST/15637/2023 WITH CA/6597/2023 IN FAST/15641/2023 WITH CA/6598/2023 IN FAST/15641/2023 WITH CA/6600/2023 IN FAST/15644/2023 WITH CA/ 6601/2023 IN FAST/15644/2023 WITH CA/6602/2023 IN 6 917 FA 2941-2023 FAST/15647/2023 WITH CA/6603/2023 IN FAST/15647/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, PARANDAEXECUTIVE ENGINEER VERSUS SANTOSH DASA GANGAVITTHAL AND OHTERS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mr. K. B. Jadhavar ... AND 996 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.6614 OF 2023 IN FAST/15656/2023 WITH CA/6613/2023 IN FAST/15656/2023 WITH CA/6615/2023 IN FAST/15659/2023 WITH CA/6616/2023 IN FAST/15659/2023 WITH CA/6619/2023 IN FAST/15662/2023 WITH CA/ 6620/2023 IN FAST/15662/2023 WITH CA/6617/2023 IN FAST/15665/2023 WITH CA/6618/2023 IN FAST/15665/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, DIVSION PARANDA VERSUS SHRIMANT LIMBA SURVASE AND OHTERS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr.Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mrs. R. P. Gour ... AND 997 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.6795 OF 2023 IN FAST/15602/2023 WITH CA/6796/2023 IN FAST/15602/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, PARANDA VERSUS GAJENDRA SHIVAJI CHAVAN DIED, THROUGH HIS L.R. BALU GAJENDRA CHAVAN AND OHTERS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr.Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State: Mr. K. B. Jadhavar ... AND 998 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.6801 OF 2023 IN FAST/15605/2023 WITH CA/6802/2023 IN FAST/15605/2023 WITH CA/6811/2023 IN FAST/15608/2023 WITH CA/6812/2023 IN FAST/15608/2023 WITH CA/6809/2023 IN FAST/15611/2023 WITH CA/ 7 917 FA 2941-2023 6810/2023 IN FAST/15611/2023 WITH CA/6805/2023 IN FAST/15615/2023 WITH CA/6806/2023 IN FAST/15615/2023 WITH CA/ 6803/2023 IN FAST/15620/2023 WITH CA/6804/2023 IN FAST/15620/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER SEENA KOLEGAON MEDUM PROJECT OSMANABAD VERSUS PRAMOD RAMCHANDRA BHALERAO AND OTHERS ... Advocate for Applicant : Mr.Jethliya Dhiraj R. AGP for Respondents-State : Mrs. R. P. Gour … PER COURT : CORAM : ARUN R. PEDNEKER, J. DATE : 08/11/2023 1. The learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the Acquiring Body has placed on record order passed by this Court dated 19/10/2023 in FAST/10903 of 2023 and other connected matters and submits that the same order would be applicable in the instant case. 2. In all applications filed for delay condonation, the claimants though served, none have caused appearance in the matter. 3. Except CA No.3028 of 2023 in FAST/7280/2023, in all other applications filed for condonation of delay, for the reasons stated in the applications, particularly the administrative reasons, the applications for delay condonation are allowed and disposed of accordingly. 8 917 FA 2941-2023 4. In CA No.3028 of 2023 in FAST/7280/2023, reissue notice to respondent No.3, returnable on 05/01/2024. 5. In all applications filed for stay, the learned Advocate for the applicants submits that the amount has been deposited in this Court as per the directions of this Court. In view of the same, the Stay order passed by this Court dated 29/03/2023, in the applications for stay, is confirmed. The applications filed for Stay stand disposed of. 6. The learned Advocate for the appellants to take steps in respect of deceased respondents as well as in respect of unserved respondents in respective matters. The learned Advocate for the appellants to remove office objections, if any, before the next date. 7. 8. All the appeals are Admitted. After admission, the learned AGP waives service of notice on behalf of respondents-State. 9. Paper book is dispensed with. ( ARUN R. PEDNEKER, J. ) vj gawade/-.