THE STATE OF MAHARSHTRA AND ORS v. SUBHADRABAI RATAN PATIL AND
Case Details
( 1 ) fa1382.15 IN THE NATIONAL LOK ADALAT PRESIDED OVER BY HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE KISHORE C. SANT, HELD ON 11.02.2023, AT HIGH COURT LEGAL SERVICES SUB-COMMITTEE AT AURANGABAD
Legal Reasoning
17 FIRST APPEAL NO.1382 OF 2015 WITH FA/1385/2015 WITH FA/1383/2015 WITH FA/1384/2015 THE STATE OF MAHARSHTRA AND ORS VERSUS SUBHADRABAI RATAN PATIL AND 18 FIRST APPEAL NO.2112 OF 2015 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS VERSUS JAISING LUMSING PARDESHI AND 19 FIRST APPEAL NO.3961 OF 2017 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER VERSUS SHRIDHAR ONKAR PATIL, L.RS. RUKHMABAI AND OTHERS AND 20 FIRST APPEAL NO.27 OF 2023 WITH FA/30/2023 WITH FA/31/2023 WITH FA/32/2023 WITH FA/29/2023 WITH FA/28/2023 THE COLLECTOR JALGAON AND ORS VERSUS CHIMANSING CHAWDAS PARDESI AND 21 FIRST APPEAL NO.270 OF 2023 WITH CA/4578/2012 IN FA/270/2023 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR VERSUS KADU DAGADU CHAUDHARI, DIED THR. L.RS. SWAPNIL AND ORS AND ( 2 ) fa1382.15 22 FIRST APPEAL NO.271 OF 2023 WITH CA/4554/2012 IN FA/271/2023 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR VERSUS BHILA HIRAMAN PATIL AND 23 FIRST APPEAL NO.292 OF 2023 WITH CA/4940/2012 IN FAST/8440/2012 WITH CA/4941/2012 IN FAST/8440/2012 WITH CA/4953/2012 IN FA/292/2023 WITH FA/293/2023 WITH CA/4951/2012 IN FA/293/2023 WITH FA/294/2023 WITH CA/4949/2012 IN FA/294/2023 WITH CA/4946/2012 IN FAST/8456/2012 WITH CA/4947/2012 IN FAST/8456/2012 WITH CA/4944/2012 IN FAST/8459/2012 WITH CA/4945/2012 IN FAST/8459/2012 WITH CA/4942/2012 IN FAST/8463/2012 WITH CA/4943/2012 IN FAST/8463/2012 THE SPL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER AND ANR VERSUS PRALHAD GURUMUKH CHAVAN AND 25 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.11360 OF 2011 IN FAST/17810/2011 WITH CA/11362/2011 IN FAST/17792/2011 WITH CA/11363/2011 IN FAST/17792/2011 WITH CA/11361/2011 IN FAST/17810/2011 THE STATE OF MAHARSHTRA AND ORS VERSUS PRATAP HIRAMAN PATIL AND 26 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3128 OF 2012 IN FAST/3237/2012 WITH CA/3132/2012 IN FAST/3225/2012 THE COLLECTOR JALGAON AND ORS VERSUS SUBHILABAI BHIMRAV KOLI AND 27 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4530 OF 2012 IN FAST/7177/2012 WITH CA/4531/2012 IN FAST/7177/2012 ( 3 ) fa1382.15 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR VERSUS GULAB BAJIRAO PATIL AND 28 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4551 OF 2012 IN FAST/6852/2012 WITH CA/4552/2012 IN FAST/6852/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ORS VERSUS LILABAI NARHAR KOLI AND 29 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4557 OF 2012 IN FAST/6865/2012 WITH CA/4558/2012 IN FAST/6865/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR VERSUS LOTAN KALU PATIL AND 30 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4583 OF 2012 IN FAST/6862/2012 WITH CA/4584/2012 IN FAST/6862/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ORS VERSUS KHANDERAO DAGDU KOLI, DIED THR. L.RS. EKNATH AND ORS AND 31 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4639 OF 2012 IN FAST/7164/2012 WITH CA/4640/2012 IN FAST/7164/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR VERSUS SUBHASH CHANDRABHAN MANTRI AND 32 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5021 OF 2012 IN FAST/7460/2012 WITH CA/5022/2012 IN FAST/7460/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR VERSUS MADHAV DAGDU PATIL, DIED THR. L.RS. MALTIBAI AND ORS AND ( 4 ) fa1382.15 33 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5025 OF 2012 IN FAST/7449/2012 WITH CA/5026/2012 IN FAST/7449/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR VERSUS PITAMBAR DAULAT PATIL AND 34 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5291 OF 2012 IN FAST/9181/2012 WITH CA/5292/2012 IN FAST/9181/2012 THE STATE OF MAH THR COLLECTOR AND ORS VERSUS RAMDAS TOTARAM PARDHI AND 35 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.6383 OF 2012 IN FAST/11620/2012 WITH CA/6384/2012 IN FAST/11620/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ANR VERSUS TULSHIRAM LOTU CHAVAN, DIED THR. L.RS. RAGHUNATH AND ORS AND 36 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10387 OF 2012 IN FAST/21445/2012 WITH CA/10388/2012 IN FAST/21445/2012 THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITIION OFFICER-1, JALGAON AND ANR VERSUS TULSHIRAM PANDHARINATH PAWAR AND ORS AND 37 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10389 OF 2012 IN FAST/21448/2012 WITH CA/10390/2012 IN FAST/21448/2012 THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITIION OFFICER-1, JALGAON AND ANR VERSUS SHANKAR GOBJI WAGH DIED THR LRS RAVSAHEB SHANKAR WAGHAND ORS ( 5 ) fa1382.15 AND 38 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10391 OF 2012 IN FAST/21442/2012 WITH CA/10392/2012 IN FAST/21442/2012 THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITIION OFFICER-1, JALGAON AND ANR VERSUS BABU RANGA MORE THR LRS ATMARAM BABURAO MORE AND ORS AND 39 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1842 OF 2013 IN FAST/30425/2012 THE SPECIAL LAND ACQ. OFFICER NO. 3, JALGAON AND ORS VERSUS NARAYAN HARI MAHAJAN AND ORS AND 40 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4113 OF 2013 IN FAST/33112/2012 WITH CA/4114/2013 IN FAST/33112/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ORS VERSUS PUNJAJI CHINDHA SABLE AND 41 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5619 OF 2013 IN FAST/4403/2013 WITH CA/5620/2013 IN FAST/4403/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER VERSUS ANYSAYABAI HIRAMAN PATIL AND 42 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.6306 OF 2013 IN FAST/7203/2012 WITH CA/6307/2013 IN FAST/7203/2012 THE STATE OF MAH AND ORS VERSUS CHIMANRAO DADAJI THAKARE, DIED THR. L.RS. PUSHPABAI AND ORS AND ( 6 ) fa1382.15 43 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.10768 OF 2013 IN FAST/23614/2013 WITH CA/10769/2013 IN FAST/23614/2013 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER VERSUS PARVATABAI CHATURBHUJ VED, DIED AND OTHERS AND 44 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3126 OF 2015 IN FAST/2621/2015 WITH CA/3127/2015 IN FAST/2621/2015 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER VERSUS RUPSING GORAKH PATIL AND 45 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5766 OF 2015 IN FAST/10786/2015 WITH CA/5767/2015 IN FAST/10786/2015 THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, M.I.W. DIST. JALGAON AND ANOTHER VERSUS BHASKAR BUDHO INGALE DECEASED THR LRS RAMBHABAI BHASKAR INGALE AND OTHERS AND 46 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5779 OF 2015 IN FAST/10804/2015 THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.3 UPPER TAPI PROJECT 3 JALGAON AND ANOTHER VERSUS BHIKANRAO BABURAO PATIL …
Legal Reasoning
Mr.A. B. Chate, AGP AND Mr. B.V. Virdhe, AGP for the appellants/State in respective matters Mr. Kiran A. Sawant Patil, Spl. Land Acquisition Officer, Collector Office, Jalgaon is present. ( 7 ) fa1382.15
Decision
O R D E R (11th FEBRUARY, 2023) Civil Applications for delay:- 1. Having regard to the reasons mentioned in the applications and as the parties have arrived at amicable settlement, it is desirable to condone the delay. The delay stands condoned. The civil applications for condonation of delay, if any stand allowed and disposed off. Office to register the appeals. First Appeals:- 1. These matters are placed before us in today’s National Lok- Adalat. Mr. Kiran A. Sawant Patil, Spl. Land Acquisition Officer, Collector Office, Jalgaon is present. Learned AGP submits that above numbered group of 2. appeals is squarely covered by Government Resolution No. Sankirna- 2014/pra.kra4/Bham-1/A-4 dated 03-11-2016 with Government Corrigendum dated 23-02-2017 and 13-08-2018 to the said Government Resolution. Hence, the group of appeals can be withdrawn as per the policy decision taken by the Government of Maharashtra. Accordingly, the State is withdrawing these appeals. The learned AGP states that entire amount in these appeals 3. has been deposited and later-on the said amount has been withdrawn by the original claimants by obtaining orders from this court. He submits that in these circumstances nothing survived in these appeals. 4. However, before disposing off the appeals, it is further ( 8 ) fa1382.15 clarified that in case the amount is not deposited as per the award, the State Government undertakes to deposit the said amount within a period of six months in the concerned Reference Court. If the amount is not deposited within six weeks, then it shall carry the interest in terms of Section 28 or 34 of the Act, as the case may be. If the amount is not withdrawn by the claimants/respondents, same is allowed to be withdrawn and office to allow withdrawal. If the said amount is not deposited, they are at liberty to withdraw the same after the amount is deposited. 5. 6. The first appeals stand disposed off as withdrawn. No order as to costs. 7. provisions under the of Maharashtra Court Fees Act, 1959. The court fee refund certificate be issued as per the 8. applications, if any stand disposed off. In view of withdrawal of these appeals, pending civil [A. R. BORULKAR] Advocate Member [S. G. SHETE] DJ (Retd.) Member [KISHORE C. SANT, J.] Head of Panel VishalK/fa1382.15