Civil Application No. 3044 of 2003 · At High Court · 2024
Case Details
( 1 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.IN THE NATIONAL LOK ADALAT PRESIDED OVER BY HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE KISHORE C. SANT,HELD ON 30th NOVEMBER 2024,AT HIGH COURT LEGAL SERVICES SUB-COMMITTEEAT AURANGABAD55 FIRST APPEAL NO. 344 OF 2003Executive Engineer Civil Construction BeedVERSUSShivaji Baburao Munde And Ors. WITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3044 OF 2003 IN FA/344/2003AND56 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1148 OF 2004Executive Engineer M S E B Parali VaijnathVERSUSSarubai Limbaji Munde Died LrsWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6926 OF 2004 IN FA/1148/2004AND57 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1149 OF 2004Executive Engineer Civil M S E BVERSUSSambhaji Dagdu Munde And OrsWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6925 OF 2004 IN FA/1149/2004AND58 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1150 OF 2004Executive Engineer Civil M S E BVERSUS
Legal Reasoning
( 2 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.Rambhau Kundlik Shep And AnrAND59 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1227 OF 2004Executive Engineer M S E BVERSUSDigambar Narayanrao Mundhe And OthersAND60 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1228 OF 2004Executive Engineer M S E BVERSUSRama Limbaji Phad And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1814 OF 2005 IN FA/1228/2004WITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1815 OF 2005 IN CA/1814/2005AND61 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1638 OF 2004The Executive Engineer BeedVERSUSDnyanoba Nivrutti Munde And Anr.WITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1925 OF 2005 IN FA/1638/2004WITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1808 OF 2005 IN FA/1635/2004WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 1635 OF 2004The Ex Engineer M S E BVERSUSMithu Kundalik Shinde And Ors.AND ( 3 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.FIRST APPEAL NO. 987 OF 2004Executive Engineer Civil Construction DivisionVERSUSGangaram Tatya Munde And OrsWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 5344 OF 2004 IN FA/987/2004WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 989 OF 2004WITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 5346 OF 2004 IN FA/989/2004WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 986 OF 2004WITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 5343 OF 2004 IN FA/986/2004WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 984 OF 2004WITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 5341 OF 2004 IN FA/984/2004WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 992 OF 2004WITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 5349 OF 2004 IN FA/992/2004WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 985 OF 2004The Executive Engineer Civil Construction M S E BVERSUSBalasaheb Deorao Munde And Two OthersWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 5342 OF 2004 IN FA/985/2004 ( 4 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 988 OF 2004The Executive Engineer Civil Construction M S E BVERSUSGanpati Daulata Munde Deceased Lrs And Five Others WITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 5345 OF 2004 IN FA/988/2004WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 991 OF 2004Executive Engineer Civil ConstructionVERSUSSopan Maruti Munde And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 5348 OF 2004 IN FA/991/2004WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 835 OF 2004Executive Engineer Civil Construction Divi MsebVERSUSDr Anant Awadhutrao Deshpande And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4352 OF 2004 IN FA/835/2004WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 836 OF 2004Executive Engineer Civil MsebVERSUSKishoribai Madhavrao Deshpande Deceased Lrs And OrsWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4355 OF 2004 IN FA/836/2004AND ( 5 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.63 FIRST APPEAL NO. 612 OF 2006The Ex Eng. M S E B BeedVERSUSGondiba Appaji Kachale And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3797 OF 2006 IN FA/612/2006AND 64 FIRST APPEAL NO. 616 OF 2006The Ex Eng. M S E B BeedVERSUSEknath Sopan MundeWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3808 OF 2006 IN FA/616/2006AND65 FIRST APPEAL NO. 618 OF 2006The Ex Engineer, Civil Construction Division No. 4VERSUSVasant Sopan Munde And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3799 OF 2006 IN FA/618/2006AND 66 FIRST APPEAL NO. 619 OF 2006The Ex Eng. M S E B BeedVERSUSBabu Dhondiba Kachale L.rs. Laximibai Babu Kachale And OrsWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3800 OF 2006 IN FA/619/2006AND67 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1558 OF 2008 ( 6 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.The Executive Engineer, Thermal Power Station, ParliVERSUSGuru Revansidhyaa Swami Trust Thr PresidentAND68 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1002 OF 2010The M.s.e.b Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSSumanbai Pralhad Mundhe And AnrWITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 706 OF 2010The The M S E B Throu The Executive EngineerVERSUSVaijinath Bhimrao MundeWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3637 OF 2009 IN FA/706/2010The The M S E B Throu The Executive EngineerVERSUSVaijinath Bhimrao MundeWITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 708 OF 2010The The M S E B Throu The Executive EngineerVERSUSKisan Vithoba Aaghav Throu Lrs Manik Kisan Aaghav Died L RsPrayagbai Manik Aaghav And OrsWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3641 OF 2009 IN FA/708/2010The The M S E B Throu The Executive EngineerVERSUSKisan Vithoba Aaghav Throu Lrs Manik Kisan Aaghav Died L Rs ( 7 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.Prayagbai Manik Aaghav And OrsWITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 709 OF 2010The Maharashtra State Electricity BoardVERSUSPrabhau Tatya Mundhe And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3639 OF 2009 IN FA/709/2010The Maharashtra State Electricity BoardVERSUSPrabhau Tatya Mundhe And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4418 OF 2009 IN FA/1002/2010The M.s.e.b Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSSumanbai Pralhad Mundhe And AnrWITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 1003 OF 2010The M.s.e.b. The Executive EngineerVERSUSKondiram Govinda Mundhe And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4416 OF 2009 IN FA/1003/2010The M.s.e.b. The Executive EngineerVERSUSKondiram Govinda Mundhe And AnrWITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 1005 OF 2010 ( 8 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.The M.s.e.b. Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSVaijinath Mahadeo Aghav And OrsWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4428 OF 2009 IN FA/1005/2010The M.s.e.b. Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSVaijinath Mahadeo Aghav And OrsWITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 1006 OF 2010The M.s.e.b. Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSShrirang Manaji MundheWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4426 OF 2009 IN FA/1006/2010WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 1000 OF 2010The M.s.e.b. Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSVenkat Namdeo Aghav And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4422 OF 2009 IN FA/1000/2010WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 1001 OF 2010The M.s.e.b. Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSMadhav Manikrao Mundhe And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4420 OF 2009 IN FA/1001/2010WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 1004 OF 2010 ( 9 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.The M.s.e.b. Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSShriram Munjaji MundeWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4430 OF 2009 IN FA/1004/2010AND69 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1532 OF 2010The M.s.e.b. Throught The Executive EngineerVERSUSBhima Dhenu Rathod And AnrWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4625 OF 2009 IN FA/1532/2010AND70 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1533 OF 2010The Mseb Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSManik Narayan Mundhe And OrsWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4623 OF 2009 IN FA/1533/2010AND71 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1534 OF 2010The M.s.e.b. Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSSambhaji Namdeo Aghav And OrsWITHCIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4621 OF 2009 IN FA/1534/2010AND 72 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1535 OF 2010The M.s.e.b. Through The Executive EngineerVERSUSMehboob Umarkhan And AnrAND ( 10 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.73 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3403 OF 2011The Maharashtra Power Generation Co.,ltd Previously Mseb ThroughThe Ex. Engineer,parali VaijnathVERSUSGyanoba S/o. Manaji Munde Deceasedthrough His L.rs. Udhav S/o.Gyanoba Munde And Ors.WITHFIRST APPEAL NO. 3404 OF 2011The Maharashtra Power Generation Co.,ltd Previously Mseb ThroughThe Ex. Engineer,parali VaijnathVERSUSDamodhar S/o. Tukaram Aghav Deceased Through His Lrs. RambhabaiW/o. Damodhar Aghav And Ors.ANDFIRST APPEAL NO. 613 OF 2006...Mr.V. V. Tarde h/f Mr. Rahul A. Tambe Advocate for Appellant.Mr. A. V. Thombre h/f Mr. S. S. Thombre for Respondents-claimants. Mr. Akash S. Hire h/f Mr. Parag V. Borde for Respondent in FA/9/2005. The authorised officer is present. O R D E R(30th NOVEMBER 2024)1.These Appeals are placed before us in today’s Lok Adalat.2.Mr. V. V. Tarde h/f Mr. R. A. Tambe, Advocate for Appellant-Acquiring Body, Mr. A. V. Thombre h/f Mr.S. S. Thombre, Advocate forthe Respondent-claimant are present. 3.The authorized officer is present in the Court. He produces onrecord a authority letter. On the basis of written instructions, theAppellant-Acquiring Body is seeking permission to withdraw the
Decision
( 11 ) 55 to 73This order is corrected pursuant to speaking to minutes order dt.20.02.2025.appeals.4.Permission granted.5.The acquiring body-appellant to deposit the entire amount ofcompensation, if not deposited, alongwith accrued interest as per awardpassed by the Reference Court within a period of six months from thedate of receipt of this order.6.The claimants/respondents are entitled to withdraw the saidamount on filing necessary application before the Reference Court.7.In view of the same, the matters stand disposed off after theamount is deposited and is withdrawn by the claimants.8. Court fees refund certificate be issued as per the provisions underthe Maharashtra Court Fees Act, 1959.9.Civil Application/s, if any, stand/s disposed off. [A. B. KADETHANKAR]AdvocateMember[S. G. SHETE]DJ (Retd.)Member [KISHORE C. SANT, J.]Head of PanelEthape