THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANA v. GANDHARBAI W
Case Details
1 CA 1380/23 & Ors. IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD 947 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1380 OF 2023 IN FAST/3624/2023 WITH CA/1378/2023 IN FAST/3624/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANA VERSUS GANDHARBAI W/O DNYANDEO MATE ...DIED SINCE THROUGH HER LRS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. K.N. Lokhande ... 948 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1435 OF 2023 IN FAST/3729/2023 WITH CA/1434/2023 IN FAST/3729/2023 WITH CA/1440/2023 IN FAST/3732/2023 WITH CA/1441/2023 IN FAST/3732/2023 WITH CA/1438/2023 IN FAST/3735/2023 WITH CA/1439/2023 IN FAST/3735/2023 WITH CA/1436/2023 IN FAST/3738/2023 WITH CA/1437/2023 IN FAST/3738/2023
Legal Reasoning
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, AT PARANDA, TALUKA PARANDA, DISTRICT OSMANABAD VERSUS SADHU ANANTA KASAB..DIED THROUGH LRS BHAUSAHEB SADHUKASAB AND OTHERS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. K.B. Jadhavar ... 949 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1443 OF 2023 IN FAST/3665/2023 WITH CA/1442/2023 IN FAST/3665/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS CHANDRAKANT SHRIPATI PINGALE ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr.B. V. Virdhe ... 950 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1519 OF 2023 IN FAST/4017/2023 WITH CA/1518/2023 IN FAST/4017/2023 WITH CA/1529/2023 IN FAST/4020/2023 WITH CA/1530/2023 IN FAST/4020/2023 WITH CA/1526/2023 IN FAST/4034/2023 WITH CA/1527/2023 IN FAST/4034/2023 WITH CA/1524/2023 IN FAST/4038/2023 WITH CA/1525/2023 IN FAST/4038/2023 WITH CA/1522/2023 IN FAST/4043/2023 WITH CA/1523/2023 IN FAST/4043/2023 WITH CA/1520/2023 IN FAST/4046/2023 WITH CA/1521/2023 IN FAST/4046/2023 2 CA 1380/23 & Ors. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS DATTATRAYA UDDHAV KASAB ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. N.T. Bhagat ... 952 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1569 OF 2023 IN FAST/4231/2023 WITH CA/1568/2023 IN FAST/4231/2023 WITH CA/1570/2023 IN FAST/4235/2023 WITH CA/1572/2023 IN FAST/4235/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS NASHIKRAO DHONDIRAM JADHAV ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. K.N. Lokhande ... 953 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1576 OF 2023 IN FAST/4201/2023 WITH CA/1577/2023 IN FAST/4192/2023 WITH CA/1578/2023 IN FAST/4192/2023 WITH CA/1579/2023 IN FAST/4195/2023 WITH CA/1580/2023 IN FAST/4195/2023 WITH CA/1581/2023 IN FAST/4198/2023 WITH CA/1582/2023 IN FAST/4198/2023 WITH CA/1575/2023 IN FAST/4201/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS BABU SHRIPATI GHOGARE (DIED) ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. K.B. Jadhavar ... 954 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1584 OF 2023 IN FAST/3677/2023 WITH CA/1583/2023 IN FAST/3677/2023 WITH CA/1585/2023 IN FAST/3687/2023 WITH CA/1586/2023 IN FAST/3687/2023 WITH CA/1587/2023 IN FAST/3697/2023 WITH CA/1588/2023 IN FAST/3697/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS DNYANDEO MARUTI GADHAVE ... 3 CA 1380/23 & Ors. Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. B.V. Virdhe ... 956 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1599 OF 2023 IN FAST/3772/2023 WITH CA/1598/2023 IN FAST/3772/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS BABRUWAN DADARAO SURYAWANSHI ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mrs. R.P. Gaur ... 958 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1603 OF 2023 IN FAST/4011/2023 WITH CA/1602/2023 IN FAST/4011/2023 WITH CA/1604/2023 IN FAST/4014/2023 WITH CA/1605/2023 IN FAST/4014/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS SHRIRANG PIRAJI SHINDE (DIED) THROUGH LRS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. K.B. Jadhavar ... 959 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1608 OF 2023 IN FAST/3899/2023 WITH CA/1607/2023 IN FAST/3899/2023 WITH CA/1609/2023 IN FAST/3902/2023 WITH CA/1610/2023 IN FAST/3902/2023 WITH CA/1611/2023 IN FAST/3905/2023 WITH CA/1612/2023 IN FAST/3905/2023 WITH CA/1613/2023 IN FAST/3908/2023 WITH CA/1614/2023 IN FAST/3908/2023 WITH CA/1615/2023 IN FAST/3911/2023 WITH CA/1616/2023 IN FAST/3911/2023 WITH CA/1617/2023 IN FAST/3914/2023 WITH CA/1618/2023 IN FAST/3914/2023 WITH CA/1620/2023 IN FAST/3917/2023 WITH CA/1619/2023 IN FAST/3917/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS VITTHAL RANGNATH KASAB (DIED THROUGH LRS ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. B.V. Virdhe ... 961 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1638 OF 2023 4 CA 1380/23 & Ors. IN FAST/4291/2023 WITH CA/1637/2023 IN FAST/4291/2023 WITH CA/1641/2023 IN FAST/4294/2023 WITH CA/1642/2023 IN FAST/4294/2023 WITH CA/1639/2023 IN FAST/4297/2023 WITH CA/1640/2023 IN FAST/4297/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS GAHININATH BHAGWAN GHOGARE ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mrs. R.P. Gaur ... 962 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1644 OF 2023 IN FAST/4310/2023 WITH CA/1645/2023 IN FAST/4301/2023 WITH CA/1646/2023 IN FAST/4301/2023 WITH CA/1647/2023 IN FAST/4304/2023 WITH CA/1648/2023 IN FAST/4304/2023 WITH CA/1651/2023 IN FAST/4307/2023 WITH CA/1652/2023 IN FAST/4307/2023 WITH CA/1643/2023 IN FAST/4310/2023 WITH CA/1649/2023 IN FAST/4313/2023 WITH CA/1650/2023 IN FAST/4313/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS JOTIRAM GAJENDRA GHOGARE ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. K.N. Lokhande ... 964 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1664 OF 2023 IN FAST/4119/2023 WITH CA/1663/2023 IN FAST/4119/2023 WITH CA/1665/2023 IN FAST/4122/2023 WITH CA/1666/2023 IN FAST/4122/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS ARJUN UDDHAV KASAB (SURYAWANSHI) ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. B.V. Virdhe ... 966 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1690 OF 2023 IN FAST/4148/2023 WITH CA/1679/2023 IN FAST/4133/2023 WITH CA/1680/2023 IN FAST/4133/2023 WITH CA/1681/2023 IN FAST/4136/2023 WITH CA/1682/2023 IN FAST/4136/2023 WITH CA/1683/2023 IN FAST/4139/2023 WITH CA/1684/2023 IN 5 CA 1380/23 & Ors. FAST/4139/2023 WITH CA/1685/2023 IN FAST/4142/2023 WITH CA/1686/2023 IN FAST/4142/2023 WITH CA/1687/2023 IN FAST/4145/2023 WITH CA/1688/2023 IN FAST/4145/2023 WITH CA/1689/2023 IN FAST/4148/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS UTTAM MANIK KASAB (DIED) ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mrs. R.P. Gaur ... 967 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2114 OF 2023 IN FAST/5223/2023 WITH CA/2115/2023 IN FAST/5223/2023 WITH CA/2119/2023 IN FAST/5226/2023 WITH CA/2120/2023 IN FAST/5226/2023 WITH CA/2117/2023 IN FAST/5231/2023 WITH CA/2118/2023 IN FAST/5231/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, DEPARTMENT SEENA KOLEGAON PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS RAMCHANDARA UTTAM GHOGARE ...... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. K.N. Lokhande ... 968 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2147 OF 2023 IN FAST/5349/2023 WITH CA/2148/2023 IN FAST/5349/2023 WITH CA/2152/2023 IN FAST/5353/2023 WITH CA/2154/2023 IN FAST/5353/2023 WITH CA/2149/2023 IN FAST/5357/2023 WITH CA/2151/2023 IN FAST/5357/2023 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, SEENA KOLEGAON MEDIUM PROJECT, PARANDA, OSMANABAD VERSUS SHASHIKANT CHANDRAKANT PATIL ... Advocate for Applicants : Mr. Kulkarni Mukul S. AGP for Respondents State/SLAO : Mr. K.B. Jadhavar ... CORAM : ARUN R. PEDNEKER, J. DATED : 12/10/2023 PER COURT : 1. Appeals are filed by the Acquiring Body. 6 CA 1380/23 & Ors. 2. 3. None appears for the original claimants. In the Civil applications filed for condonation of delay, there is delay of more than 1000 days caused in filing appeals. For the reasons stated in the applications, particularly, the administrative reasons, delay caused in filing the appeal is condoned. Delay applications are allowed and disposed of. 4. The learned counsel for the appellants submits that the entire amount as directed by the Reference Court has been deposited except the
Decision
interest component. In view of the above submission, the ad-interim stay granted earlier is confirmed. Stay applications are also disposed of. 5. 6. Appeals are admitted. In appeals, issue notice to the respondents for final disposal, returnable on 9.11.2023. The respective AGPs waives service of notice for respondents State and SLAO in respective matters. ssc/ [ARUN R. PEDNEKER J.]