V. Srinivas, S/o v. Kathalappa Aged about

...RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more particurarry one in the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondent Nos.1 to 3 in not implementing the provisions of rhe street Vendors (protection of Livelihood and Regulation of street Vending) Acl, 2o14 as arbitrary, illegal and in violation of the procedure laid down under the said Act and also contrary to the law laid down by the Hon'ble supreme court and consequenfly direct the Respondent Nos.1 to 3 to implement the provisions of the said Act and further direct the Respondent Nos.4 to 11 not to harass the petitioners by imposing fine, eviction, confiscation of goods elc. I.A. NO: 3 OF 2016(WPMP. NO: 9548 OF 2016) Petition under Section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct the Respondent Nos.4 to 11 not to harass the petitioners herein by imposing fine, eviction, confiscation of goods etc., in violation of Section 3(3) of "The Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of street vending) {ct,2014", pending disposal of the Writ Petition l.A. NO: 1 OF 2016(WVMP . NO: 1413 OF 2016) \ D U Li! CCIL ,t S:a Lc oI Tela:-.gar:a, Rep br its CIrie: ,!ccrc ran, Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad, Hvderabd

2. Srare of Telangana Rep b1. its Principal Secrelerrl,, Dcpartment of Hor.ne, Secre tariat oi Buildi11gs, Hvderabad 3 SLate oI Telangara. Rep. b]. irs IJrlncipal Secrer.rry, l-pdirn,.nr I l.l trrr, rpal AdminisLrdttun, & Urban Development Sccrerar ia: ot- Buildings, Hyderabad. The Grearer tlycler-abad i\,lunicipal Corporarion Rcp. by its Commissroner & Chairoerson Tor'.,n Yeltd:n{ C-.ll:tnrirre e. Lo*,er- Tank Bund, Htclerab: r

5. Commrssioner o1- Polrcc, I-lvderabad, Ifi,der-altad.

6. (lo u rrl issione r oi'polrce, Cvlterab:rd, Hvderab.rd. .\clclirional. Ccmnissioner of police, I-l_i,clc rabad and Nlerlber'l'own Vendirr!, Police Co n rrol Roonl, Hvderabad

8. Thc StaLion FIouse olficer, Saooornag,U l'r aiitc police Station Saroopnagar, C,.'berabad, Hyderabad 9 Thc Sta r iorr House otficer Lvt a- a Kpe i I r.rllt( polrce StaLin, \4alakpet, H),derabad. l0.The station House officer, Saroor nagar police Statiorl Saroornagar. Cl,berabad, Hyderabad I i. The Station House officer \lalakpei Police Statron, \'lalal<pe r, H1,clc rabad. .. Petirio I Respo:t r E.t I i l l. t t I j I l, l I I I 0 z-r, , xrt\l N 1 J. Shekar yadav S/o Rajaiah yadav Aged about 24 yrs, Occ: Srreet Vending. 2 S, Baiaji S/o Shankar Aged about 36 yrs, Occ; Street Vending. 3 Md Moinuddin, S/o Md. Mohammecl Aged about 30 yrs, Occ: Street Venciing 4 N,l Naganna S/o M. tr,Iallanna Aged abouL 36 yrs, Occ: Streer Vencirng 5 C. Nagisef] S/o Advappa Aged about 54 yrs, Occ: Street Venciing. 6 B.Sunil Laxman S/o B. La_xman Aged about 28 yrs, Occ: Streer Vendinq 7 Zaneer Ahmed Hondrrrg S/o llohan.,rnecl Ahn-rcrj Honcrrrq Aged about 43 yrs, OcciStreet Vending 8 V. Srisailam S/o late La,iman Aged about 40 yrs, Occ: Strcer Vending. 9 K.SujaLha W/o K. Sriniuas tl Aged about 38 yrs, Occ; Strecr Vending. I O V. Srinrvas S/o V. I{athalappa Aged about 45 yrs, Occ: Srreer Vendrng. I1 .{. Srir-ru s/o A.Venl<atiair .,\gecl ;ibout 45 yrs, Occ SLreet Vendrlg 12 A. Nagaraju s/o Venkatarah Aged about 40 yrs, Occ: Street Vending. 13 Abdul Naseer S/o Abdul Wahab . Aged about 28 yrs, Occ: Street Vending. l4 M.A. Mareen S/o M.A. Gani Aged about 27 yrs, Occ: Street Vending. 15 C.Raju S/o C. Nagiserq,/ Aged about 28 yrs, Occ: Street Vending. 16 C.Ashok S/o Adavappa Aged about 45 yrs, Occ: Street Vending. 17 G.Vryay Kumar S/o G. Maitaiah Aged qbout 25 yrs, Occ; Srreet Vending. 18 P. Mohan S/o p. Bisappa Aged about 34 yrs, Occ: Street Vending. i9 P.Krishna s/o Gundayaa Aged about 40 yrs. Occ Srreer Vending. 20 G.Kamakshi S/o G. Nageshwar Rao ,{gecl about 37 yrs, Occ: Streer Vending. 2l G.Nageshrvar Rao s7o Subbr.,vlrdu Agecl about 42 yrs, Occ: Srreec r,iendrr.ig I \0,/ J'(r 't I

1.. I f I i Ii -1 22 Bharatamma W/ o lr{al.laiah, Aged about 40 yrs. Occ: Street Vending 23 R,Srilatha W/o Nagender Aged about 22 1,p5, g." Street Vending 211 i\4 r f'asii Ali S,ro \liI Qaisar Ali -{gtrj abour 25 1.r s, Occ: Streer \/endrng 23 A.l.larLlthi s/o lJagalpa lgeci abouL .1o 1rs, Occ: Sr.eet \rencitng 25 P.i\ni] Kumar S,/o Lare Gandaiah. Age ci about 33 r.'rs, Occ: Street Vending 27 P Vtcrcsharn S1o Birappa Agcd abour 40 1'rs, Occ. Streer Vendrng 28 T.ii;riu S/o T. Pancu -.1-qr.i abour 2B I'rs. C)cc: SLreet Vending 29 G. Ran.ranj aneyulu sro Venkat Ramulu Agl:c about 22 )-rs. Occ. Street \rending 30 c. ir:ran Kumarr s7/o Chinnaiah Agecl about 24 },rs. Occ: Street Vending 31 L.Chenna Reddlr s1o Lare Papi Reddy Aged about 58 yrs. Occ: Street Vendrng 32 Pavan Kumar s1'o Papalal Jeshwal Age(l about 32 yrs, Occ: Street Vending 33 V. Laxman S/o V. Karhalappa Aged about 43 1,rs. Occ: Street Vending 34 \.'.Sr,tsva W/o V. L.L{l].tan Aged abour 33 1.rs, Occ: Street Vending 35 D. iiousalva W/o D. Sar Reddy Age.i aboltt 45 1'rs. Occ: Street Vending 36 Raj Kr,rmar Pandey s,.o Ashok Kumar pandey Agcrl about 22 1,rs, Occ. StreeI Vending J7 ts ....u.cr- Sr.-^r s/o S. id,,i?- Aged about 31 yrs, Occ: Street Vending 38 Md. Jahangeer S/o Abdul Subhan Aged a5ouL 28 1rs. Occ: Street Vending 39 Abdul Hameed S/o Abdul Wahab AgeC abour 29 1r's. Occ: Street Vending 40 l'1c Jaharlgeer Qureshi S/o Md. pasha eureshi Agcd about 35 yrs. Occ: Street Vending. 41 D Santhosh S/o Veeraaoa Agecl about 26 1,rs, Occ: Street Vending 42 L. Shekar S/o Late Lingappa Aged about 41 yrs, Occ: Street Vending II i.,,1:l t I I I I -, .i3 44 4 T.V1av I'iumar S/o T.Veerappa. Aged about 27 yrs, Occ: Street Vending G. Raghavulu s/o T. Veerappa Aged about 60 yrs, Occ: Street Vending 45 G.Venkatesh S/o G. Raghavulu Aged about 32 vrs, Occ: Strect \,'encling .i5 B \Iallesl'r s/o Sangaialr Aged about .+ 1 yrs, Occ: SLreer Vendir]g .+7 B.Veeranna S,/ o AnSanna Aged about 25 yrs, Occ: Streei Ver'rding 48 T. Naresh S/o T. Ramulu Aged abollt 25 yrs, Occ: Street Vending 49 lv1d. Shirajuddin s/o Md. Abdui Wahid Aged about 44 yrs, Occ: StreeI Vending 50 Shaik Ghouse S/o Shaik Hyder Sahab Aged about 25 yrs, Occ: Street Vending A11 are R/o C/o B.M.S, Ofhce, TRT-141, 9ft Street, Jawaher Nagar, Hyderabad - 500020 ..Peritioners,/ Respondents Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated the High Court may be Pleased o rs passed in W.P.M.P. No 1Z of in the affidavit filed in support of the petition vacate the interim order passed interim orde 2016 in W.P. No.7474 of 2016 dt 9-3-2016' \ |t I U =' LA. NO: 2 OF 2016(WVf[P. NO 1693 0F 2016) []et* cclr i. S(iltc of -lc illllr:t.t. I?clt ltt ts Citit,l scr.rct:rr,t, Sccrcral.r Ij r lr lclin q s. S,t,lr r.tii. llr ricrlLucl 2 SLatc of 'l'c lar,llal t it, liitll ll\ trs princrpnl SccrctatJ, De l)i,1- I ( lll ()l llon.re, Scc|e lrtr tLL buildrngs, Ilvdcrabad. il. Stilte oITcl:rllqan:r, Rr:p, br its pr-incipal S(]crctary, Depa.rr I\1ur-rJcipaL Arirnrrrrs{r-irIion & Urban Devc]opmen[, SecreLi.r i buildir-rgs, Il-\ d e rirba.l. (r-lr of 1

4. The Grater I{r'dclabaC Municipal Corporation Rep. by its Commissionel ancl Charir Person Tou,n Vcnding committ(,c. Ta nl<bu nd, Fi...dcr a bac1. -lr\'cr

5. Commissioner oi Policc, Hydera bad 6. Comnrissione:-ot Po Iicc, Cvberabad 7. Additional Comrnrssior.rer of Police, (Trattic), HycJerabad an l Nlcmber'l'ot,rr r,e ncling Police Control Room, Iiyderabad. 8 Thc Station I{or,Lst: oflicer, Saroornasar Traflic police. Sari,r.r f.agar', Cl bera bail, I lld c ratrad

9. The SLatron Housc ()fficcr, Ma]al{pet'fraffic police Statior:, M:rlakpct, Hvclr:r-a bad. lOThc Station llor.rsr O1'[rccr, Saroornagar police Station, Sa L r : tirqal, C vbcra btid 1 1.'l lrc Statii)r' Ili,Lr:Lt ()tlir:cr , \,1irl:rl<pct lbllcC staLion, Mal. I I I lvcle ra lt:t d .[)el t rcrs. lLe-,t l) ) L(lents ,? ''..k" r\nd -) 1o\ L \l .l Slrel<:rr Yaclar S,'o R:rlaiah, agr:cl .rUoLrt 1.1 \-r's. ()cc SlrccL \(itCllt{ I 2. S Balali, S/o Sharrkcr'. agcd abolrt.16 -\rs. Occ: Suect rcndng .l \lD \ioLrucldi|l S'o \1ol)alllrr( (i. ;rqcd ab,rut 30 r:s. (Jcr Sir((., \'cr)(lr:i:1 rl \l \"aqalrrr.1. S,to \tT;illarrna, agccl al)oLlt 3o,,,ts. Occ: Sucer r'cl<lrng :. C \^grsell\. S'o.\cherpPa, xqc(l allou.5-l \rs. ()c( Srrctr rcnclrnq o B Sunrl Laxrna,r, S/'o Laxmiur, agccl iibout 23 Irs, Occ: Str-cct rcndrD( 7. ZJticer AhrncLl Hon(lurg, S;'o \1oh;rmnrecl llorrdLlr'9, ilgc(l irl).,!lL ,13 \'rs. Occ: Strcct \:er1(liDg I V Srrsharlam, S/o Late l-a.rimaiah, agcd al)out 40 J rs, (lcc: SLrcet r'ctrdrng 9. K Sujalha, W/o Snnivas, aged about 38 1r-s, Occ: SLreel !'cnding I0.V Sr-ir-rir,:rs, S/o I(atha-lappa, agcd ;rbour.15 yrs, Occ: Strcct vcrtdrng I LA Srinu, S/o vcnl<ataiah, aged about 45 vrs. Occ. Street vendlng l2.A Nagara.ju, S/o Vcnkataiah, aged about 27 1.rs, Occ Strcct vendrng l3.Abdul Naseer, S/o Wahab, aged abouL 28 \'rs, Occ Slrcct len(ling I+.N{A N,lathccn, S/o Ghani, agcd about 27 yts, Occ: Street vcnding I5. C Raju, S/o Nagrsettr, agcd about 28 yrs, occ: Street \'cnding lrl.C Ashok, S/o A<lrvappa, aged about 45 yrs, Occ: Strcct vcndrng 17. G Vijay Kumar, S/o Mallaiah, aged abour 25 1'rs, Occ: Streel \cndirrg l8 P Ir{ohan, S/o Bisappa, aged about 34 vls, Occl Street vcnding tg P Krrshna, S/o (iundarah, agcd .rboul '10 ) rs, Occ: SLrect \,endrrlg 2O G l(amal<shi. \\'./o Nageshuar Rao, aeed alx)ut 37 yrs. O(r(: Slrcct vcodrng ll.(l \iigcsh\\'ar Rao. S/o Subba RaYtrtltt. agcd al)otlt '12 \'fs R ' srrt'il vendrn!l ll.BhlratharrLlla. \\,'o IT:rllatair, ag('d iibotll _'l Ll ,rls. Ocl: Sli(c: \Lll(l.r)!l l3 Il Srrlatha, W7o Nage rtclr:r. a!lc(l aboLLt 22 1r s, Oc<: SLrcct ''crrclrrril -l+.i\lir Farsa) Ali, S,ro \{rr Qaisar Ali, agcd al)oLrl 26 )'rs' Occ Strcrrr lencl'r.ig 25.A lvlarulhi, S/o NagaPpa,.lgcd about 46 yrs, Occ. SLrccl tcn(ling lb.P Anil I(umar, S/o l-ittc Garr(larah, agcd ab(iuL 33 )'rs. Oc( S(rccL r.,e n din g -17. P Vccrcsh.rm, S/o tsccrzrppa, agc.l aboul r10 vrs. Occ: Slrc'l \crlding 28.T ttalu, S/o Partclrt, agecl aboul 28 Irs, Occ SLIect vetldirlg 29.G R:rmanjzurel'r-rltr, S/r.: Velrl<aL RanllllLl, agcd allortt 22 lls, ('rt:r Srrcct verlding

30.C l(rran l(umar, S/o Chinnaiah, aged aboltt 24 yrs, C)ccl Street vendttrg 3 L L Chenna Reddv, S,/o Late Pal)i Rcdd1 , agccl aboLrt 58 yIS, Occ: SLreel ve nding

32. Paval Kumar, S/o Papalal Jasrval, aged about 32 yrs, Occ: Strcet ve ncling

33.V La-\man, S/o Kathalappa, age abouL'13 !'rs, C)cc: Slrccr vcncling 34.V Susya, W/o La-\rnarl, aged about 33 yrs Occ: Strect vending \' >' \l e- f

35. V I(ousalya, W/,r S:tr liedd\. agetl :rbout 45 y|s, Occ: Strecl vend I i () {shr)k LiL!rnar Pirrrdcr'. aged ztl)out 22 \'r s ) 36. Rajkumat Par rl"r . Strcct vc'trclr rl q 37 B (lhandr:i Sht l<a' S o iLrlrlappa. aq.(l al)r)Llt 31 vls. Occ: SLri' c r L'r r riing

38. \'l t) ,jahan gir. S, o .19. {bdul I l;rrnec tl S ' 40.1\'ll) Jahagrr Qrrrcshr, S,/o \1D Pirasha Quleshi' aged about 35 \ -1. ,,+, '. .,l/Jrrl f8 \rs \l'':. : .\ r' Jl, .',r i .,1, 't .'' rrs. Uc'' Occ: Strc€ SLre(t\ail'ri!i | Str'cc t r e ncll lrg 4l I) S.rnthosh. S ro vccrallp agecl ;rbour 26 Yrs, Occ: Street vcll( L 42 l- Shekar, S/o La'. l-rrlqapl)a, age d abouL '+ I J rs' Occ: Strcer ' r : 43.'1 Vi.jay Kumar. S.1o Vce I al)pu, :rgcd about 27 yrs' Occ: SLreet i'' t 4ul (l Rilqh:t\Lllll, i, o {nar'.h;ttah, zl(cd al)out_ 50 Irs' Occ: Strce t -15.(l \icnl<irtcsl), -i/") llitghit|rrlLl, agcd abotlt 32 yrs' Occ: Strect \! r 46.trl \lallcsh, S7o -s;rng:rrair,.rgccl about'1 l\rs, C)cc: Street vcnt-r 47 Ll \'ecranna. S' o \lll.tllllil. ilqc(l irl)oul 25 rr's' ()cc' Street verd l air()llLJ5 l r s' ()cc: Strcct!endLr'c 46.'l Naresll, S,/o llat)rLllLl. al!i( 'l ]](1.\lD Sir,rtllC(l)1.. -q L,'.lll.\lrri'rl \;rhrcl. ilqc(l irl)otlt 4{ \rs' O(:( ' I l cl:ll ! Occ clir-t g d ing vcnding 50 Slr:ril< Olrortsi . S, rr Slr.:rli llilrclar Siilral) aged about 25 lrs - SLI (' ri r cr.clutg All arc R/o C/o ll\lS ollr((,'i'R'l' l'1 l, ()r' qLrcct Jztlr'ahatr f'l:l H\ (lcrab.r(i. 5O( ),.) I -r I f , ,l-:i'I l, "" Petition under section 15'1 cpc praying that in thr: lircumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High C()r rt may be pleased to vacate the interim order passed inte.m orders passed in \ r'.p.M.p No. g54g of 2016 in W.P. No. t4t4 of 2016 dt. 9_3_2016. Counsel for the petitioners: SRl. MOGILI ANAVENI counsel forthe Respondent No.1: Gp FoR GENERAL Atr [NrsrRATroN Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 2,5to11: Gp FOR HOM: Counsel forthe Respondent No.3: cp FOR MCPL ADMN-L RBAN DEV Counsel for the Respondent No.4: SRI pASHAM KRISH \ REDDy, SC The Court made the following: ORDER -/ THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI WRIT PETITION No.7474 OF 2016 ORDER Aggrieved by the action of respondent Nos.1 to 3 in not implementing the provisions of The Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) 4ct,2014 (for short "the Act, 2014), the present writ petition is filed. A consequential prayer is sought to direct respondent Nos.1 to 3 to implement the provisions of the said Act and further to direct respondent Nos.4 to 11 not to harass the petitioners by imposing fine, eviction and confiscation of goods, etc.

2. Heard leamed counsel for the petitioners, leamed Standing Counsel for respondent No.4 and Mr. R.Laxmikanth Reddy, learned Assistant Government Pleader for Home appearing for respondent Nos.s to 11.

3. Learned Standing Counsel appeanng for respondent No. 4 submits that the provisions of the Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Acl,2014 ('the Act of 2014') are being duly implemented in letter and spirit. lt is further contended that the petitioners have failed to place on record any specific instance of violation or non-compliance with the statutory mandate. ln the absence of any material particulars substantiating the grievance, it is urged that the writ petition does not survive for adjudication. 2

4. Learned Assistant Government Pleader for Home, while endorsing the above submission, contends that the re,r )ondenvpolice have neither interfered with nor created any obs r tction in the implementation of the provisions of the Act of 201 4 lt is further emphasized that the role of the police is only anci lrry in nature, confined to rendering assistance for enforcement of tl r provisions of the Act strictly in accordance with the procedure estirl lished by law and in furtherance of the objectives sought to b,: achieved by Parliament in enacting the statute.

5. This Court has carefully perused the pleadingr; and materials available on record-

6. Having regard to the relief sought in the w-i petition, the submissions advanced on behalf of the respondents, ar i the admitted position that the statutory framework under the Act o 2014 is under implementation, this Court is of the considerec opinion that continuation of the present writ proceedings is rendered rnnecessary. 7 . The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Maharashtra t ikta Hawkers Union v. Municipal Corporation, Greater Mumbait,l-i s categorically recognized that the Act of 2014 is a complete code pror' Cing adequate safeguards for the protection of the rights and live i rood of street vendors while simultaneously ensuring regulation in ,ublic interest. Once the statutory machinery is in operation, interventit r by this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia is warre r ted only upon ./: 2014) 1 SCC 490 3 demonstration of specific illegality or arbitrariness, which, in the present case, has not been established by the petitioners.

8. Nonetheless, it is clarified that the dismissal of this writ petition shall not preclude the petitioners from instituting appropriate proceedings or availing any other remedies available to them in law in the event of any violation or infringement of their rights under the Act of

2014. Subject to the above liberty, the writ petition is disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any pending in this petition, shall stand closed. I //TRUE COPY// SD/. M. NAGAMANI ASSISTANT REGISTRAR G SECTION OFFICER I \ To, - -- Hyderabad Cyberabad, Hyderabad 'l . The Chief Secretary, Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad, Hyderabad 2. .l.he Principal Secretary, Departmen'[ of Home, secretariat Buirdings, 3. The Principal secretary, Department of l\rlunicipal Administration and Urban _ Development Secretariit Buiidings, Hyderabad ' 4. The Chairman and Chairpersoi Grater Hyderabad lrrlunicipal Corooration. _ Town Vending Committee, Lower Tank Bunci, HvderabrO 5. Commissioner of Police, Hvderabad. Hvderabad 6. Commissioner of Police, Cilberabad. Hvderabaci 7. Additional commissione-r 6f porice (Tiaffic), Hyderabad and Member Town ^ y9nd49 Police Control Room, Hyderbbad ' 8. The Station House officer, Saroornagar Traffic porice station saroornagar, 9. The station House officer, Marakpet rraffic police Station Marakpet, 10. The Station House officer saroornagar porice station, Saroornagar, Cyberabad, Hyderabad '1 1.The Station House Officer, 12.One CC to SRt. MOGtlt ANAVENI, Advocate IOPUCI 13.Two CCs to cP FOR IVUNtCtpAL ADM|N|STRAT|ON AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT ,High Court for the State of Telanoana, at Hvderabad foUft 14.rwo ccs to Gp FoR cENERAL ADMINtsiRAfioll, Higri C6r,t"6'. ti":Ei.id . _ of Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT] 1 5. Two CCs to GP FOR HOIvIE High Court for the State of Telangana, at 16.One CC to SRl. PASHAM KRISHNA REDDY, SC tOpUCl 17. Two CD Copies police Station [Vlalakpet, Hyderabad Hyderabad [OUT] Hyderabad -fylg.lglpgt BM P\/t c,)/ HIGH COURT DATED:1810912025 ORDER WP.No.7474 of 201G (tus o O 1 2 tl\q lq)i , -)r S z G)L, i DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS ,},ob o