High Court · 2025

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stited in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue any appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus. a. declaring the action of Respondent No. 1 in not ratifying the admissions undertaken by the Petitioner No. 2 institution for B.B.A and B. Com courses for the Academic Year 2024-25 as arbitrary, illegal, and unconstitutional apart from the said action beinr; beyond the jurisdiction of Respondent No. 1 and in vioration of the orderof this r{onorabre High court and,"t b' consequently, direct Respondent No. 1 to ratify the admissions of students enrolled in Petition,er institution from Academic year 2oz4-2s and ail future "ril" *.i u"i,ol,'" "'''"'' academic years. IA NO: 10F 2024 Petition under liection 151 CPc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit fired in support or tne peiition, in" Hign court may be preased to direct the Respondent No. 1 universitv to pur.it the students of the petitioner No.2 institution in B.B.A and B. Com "orr."" for Academic year 2O24_25 Io attend and write the examinations schedured to commence on 26.11.2024 incruding by ratifying the admissions of the students for the Academ icyear 2024_ 25 pending disposal of the writ petition. Counsel for the petitioners: SRt TARUN G.REDDY Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI T.VENKAT REDDY, SC FOR KU Counset for the Respondent No.2: SMT C.VANI REDDY, SC FOR TSCHE Counsel for the Respondent No.3: SRI VAMSHI KIRAN YADAV, GP FOR HIGHER EDUCATIdN WRIT PETITIONNO : 34665 oF 2024 Between:

1. Avinash Brahmadevarz '$;;9*ft,"?ifr.rufl i"?i".i,a,*|hif ,B#B,,iH3B:,fJiid h}:i,TS"f

2. Avinash College of Commerce, H.No. .l _g_621 (N 621, Balasamudram r-r""i,-"i^;;";,:;"-3:.1 U-\ew./, H.r\o. 1-u-620 (P), 'l- Budda ranumakonda Dist. Rep..J;yli B,["c,J;h?:r.lihJ; ' 3:[",:oX,'ifr'#r;il%,f,*ylfi:i[x'":,:i/.qf,S,#,1.,'li,ll]zr(rishna B,ock, ...PETITIONERS AND ' [3l3t'i{f,",oYllX,T,.lllIa,,,i"i;"ntJ",']io$%n;strar NH-s63, vidvaranvapuri, ' Ifl 3 lnfi : f, "::x,:il?ilB J: ilX,i'#;.5,.Jff ifi,M1s5b +l,if H?:.;E ;yd, " 3 The State of Telangana, Rep. by.its Principle Secretary Higher Education Department Secretariat Buildings' HyoeraDao ...RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstancesstatedintheaffidavitfiledtherewith'theHighCourtmaybe pleased to issue any appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of 'Mandamus'' a. deilaring the action of Respondent No' 1 in not granting affiliation to the Petitioner No. 2 institution for Academic Year 2024-25 on the ground that the students were admitted through non-DOST medium as arbitrary' illegal' and unconstitutionalapartfromthesaidactionbeingbeyondthejurisdictionof Respondent No. 1 and in violation of the Order of this Hon'ble High Court and set aside such action b.consequently,directRespondentNo.ltograntaffiliationtoPetitionerNo.2 institution for Academic Year 2024'25 and all future academic years' IA NO :1OF 2O24 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition' the High Court may be 1l1a.yd directtheRespondentNo.luniversitytotreatthePetitionerNo.2institutionas validly affiliated to it for Academic Year 2024-25' including by treating the studentsadmittedtothePetitionerNo.2institutionasvalidlyratifiedpending disposal of the writ Petition. Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI TARUN G'REDDY Counsel for the Respondent No'1: SRI T'VENKAT REDDY' SC FOR KU Counsel for the Respondent No'2: SMT C'VANI REDDY' SC FOR TSCHE Counsel for the Respondent No'3: SRI VAMSHI KIRAN YADAV' GP FOR HIGHER EDUCATION The Court made the following: ORDER HONOf'RABLE SRI JUSTICE B. VIJAYSEN REDDY WRITPETTTI ONN os.32424 AND 34665 0F 2024 COMMON OR DER: (oRAL) Heard Mr. Tarun G Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioners in both the writ petitions; Mr. T. Venkat Reddy, learned Standing Counsel for Kakatiya University; and Mr. Vamshi Kiran yadav, leamed Governntent pleader for Higher Education for rr:spondent No.3; and peruse<I the material on record.

2. Mr. !'enkat Reddy, learned Standing Counsel for Kakatiya University, furrrished minutes of the meeting held by the Crtmmittee constituted to enquire into the issue regarding shifting of the college, change of manallement and name of the college for the academic year 2024-25 of Bhaclruka Degree College for Commerce & BM, on 20.02.2025, pursuant to the orders passed.by this Court, wherein the following recomrnendations have been made: "D To ac,;ord permission to issue orders to (i) change of management r'ii) shifting of college from one leased building to another leased building and (iii) change of the name of the college Ibr thc academic year 2024-25 by mentioning all aborie deficiencies and putting a conditions to fulfil the same before applying lor grant of alfiliation lor the academi c year 2025_26. wP Nos-J2424 & 3{665 oF 202r ii) To grant temporary affiliation to the college for the academic year 2024-25 and accordingly ratiry the admissions of students by mentioning all above deficiencies and putting a conditions to fulfil the same before applying for grant of affiliation for the academic year 2025-26 ' iii) While granting above permissions and affrliations, the orders should mention the fact that said permissions and affiliation is temporary and conltnes to academic year 2024-25 only and is subject to outcome of judgement in W'P' No'32424 of 2024- W.P. No.l34l2 of 2023 and W'P' No'17037 of 2017 and batch."

3. Mr. Tarun G Reddy, leamed counsel for the petitioners' submitted that in view of the above recommendations of the Committee, the writ petition may be disposed of in terms thereof' and the same is not opposed by the leamed Standing Counsel for Kakatiya University and the learned Govemment Pleader for Higher Education'

4.Therefore,recordingtheaforesaidsubmissionsofthelearned counsel, both the writ petitions are disposed of in terms of the recommendations made by the Enquiry Committee in its meeting dated

20.02.2025. A photostat copy of the said recommendations / minutes of the meeting shall be annexed to this order' No order as to costs' Y 8!?J \l? Nos.l2{21& 3:1655 OF 20+ As a sequol thereto, miscellaneous applications, if an1., pending in the writ petition stand closed. To, //TRUE COPYII {i SD/- A.V.S.PRASAD ASSISTANT REGISTRAR ,\ / SEcTIoNBfF!cER 1 . The Registrar, Kakatiy_a_ -U_niversity, Warangal, Telangana -506009 NH-563, Vidyaranyapuri, Hanamkonda, 2 lfq Secretary, Telangana State Council for Higher Education, .lst Floor, e. Ihq Principle llecretary Higher Education Department Secret;rriat Buildings, Mahaveer Marg, Opp. Mahaveer Hospital, Masab Tank, Hyderabab Hyderabad, State of Telang-ana.

4. One CC to SRI TARUN G.REDDY, Advocate tOpUCl 5. One CC to SRI VENKAT REDDY THtppARTHt, SC FOR KU [OpuC] 6. One CC to SMT C.VAN| REDDY, SC FOR TSCHE tOpUCI 7. Two CCs to cP FOR |il_GI1ER EDUCATTON, High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad [OUT]

8. Two CD Copies; c. BSR t 1 t \ .,;' i i HIGH COURT DATED: 20103t2025 CC TODAY COMMON ORDER WP.Nos.32424 and 34665 ot 2024 Js \ 1HE S t,(1 6 ) ) ,J 21 flAtl 216 * D :.gElr.i ( ii d 6(' z -c) DISPOSING OF BOTH THE WRIT PETTTIONS, WTHOUT COSTS $ ! i MEETING oF TIrE colrrlrrrrr-E coNsuTUTED To EIT.IJIRE INT. rIrE IssLrE REGARDIN. SITTFTING oF TrrE cor trRoM oxi r*nsm iunnnc roiANorIrER LEA'ED BUILDING' CEANGE OFMANAGEME*iAiO CffiiE OFNAME OFTIIE COI-I TGE FOR rm A.ADEMTc 202+2s_or as.o.Dn-u; i"C*Jrrcorr-ecE FoR coMMERcE & BM OO2OIO?.T2A5 Et II:fit IN OFFICE OFTTIE Ni*, C-OiirCE DEVE.LOP.,,IENT COI.,NCIT. KU (KU.Orders. No. I 3gt A2/KV nO2+Z02St COlrINt-423,Dated.14.022025) 'EAR 'JGE IHembers Present: !. Prof.P. Varalaxmi Dean, College Development Council

2. Prof.C. Hanumanthu Dean, Acedemic Audit KU

3. Prof.T. Manohar Dean, Faculty ofSocial Sciences & Principal Univ. College. KU {. Prof.K. R_ajender Controller of Examinations, KU

5. Prof.M. Srinivas Director, lrgal Cell, KU Chairperson Member Member Mernber Member The Committee after thorough verification of the records and the discussions found the following facts: Formerly avinash Co ege of Commerce (ACC) was Bhadflrka Collqge. It was took_over bv Avinastr Coltege of Commercc in the year zozl. si"d*f ;["c" ;;;iffi'ffiildil colony, Hanumakonda to Baras.m_ud*m, Iranumakona^ er"* La".i" year 2n,4-25and na; was oflicially changed as Avinash College of Commerce ! On 25-09-2024 Telangana State Council for Higher Educarion (TGCHE) vide Go. Rt. No. for change of Mana gement & Campus and Name. I6E DOn 1 I-2023 Universiry inspecred rhe Avinash cbllege and;seirt reporr io TGCHE on w- t -2023 Universiry imposed penalq and Avinash College of Commerce paid it. ') ) High Court already liven 2017 and batch. Bascd on above W P "common interim order,,.irn 1,7.07-201 7 in W.p. No. 17037 of the above Order, High Cou( has given same m

2. Again by W.P. No. 13251 of 2021 vqrr:-67q?iGTtiTFm2 Avinash Academ ic 4 rhe Hi the Covemment & University to allow non-DO ST process for Aedemi Yar 2024-25. u College of Commerce challenged DOST for gh Court again issqed same Orders i.e., directed z t2. b ("4rr .i.O 5 , I Accordrnglr,. Univeruity admi[ed I 27 studenls of BBA & B.Com. lrr_,iffNrli",,"r. applied for affitiation for rhe Academic year ZOZ4.Zsby paying fees on ACC requested the Universitv studen*. _._.-, on 06{g_2024 and 04.09-2024 ro rati} the above t f,1'l#.if..,"?,;ff,1Tffffi:,*:snto the Universiv on 2.1_0e.202.1. r0_0e_2024 and *ul*,fi{n:f coomerce issued Lee,] Notic€ r,o the universrty ro implernent rhe ,' iil\i:l:#,:{i::'"ffi.:'".",rf;#":'fl!:'J,iL:.,1':1h Co,,e*e orCommerce on 0,,*,Ji,ili,lLffir::J."];^,;Xri;:.r,:;1;,:; ffiinincthe studens to,"rir. "*.n,rnui1,"!, ^ i:.)"lJlJi;.':i'^t",ufifl? Yre Higrr Coun has rrrrt'ed rh€ un,vers,r-y ro consider exams scheaurea from ; fi ,r;',f-#l?l:tfr #itr., ; r r: z .n ai,L, ;";H: On,28-l l-:1024 High Court issued express order direcrine the illliii ;1ffi,3'J;il;;'"*u ;"ilh 6.il;';''-.H::J:: #,:, Tffi; [: lffi$lfl; l1 ffrsityfras issued halr_rickets wirhout menrioning the cotrege name and f#Ti,"Jlffi;l[;Uffi.:' t.t-tz-2024 nred cc No. 265t or2021 in tr.p. No. 12121or pending for heering on 2r-02-m2fl ratifoing the Een-R$6ilr6rrl7-srfi6Ei.c",i,"roii'"'rl 1{ W.P. No. 34665 of ?024 was filed by the Avinash College of C 2O24 befqrc High (burt. t )ommerce (F,CC)on Dec.ember, 4 5 F Argument b1. the ACC is that, despire orCers oi Hic\ Cour universiry' ha-s taken "J.*ri"g i,",ii;:;d;fl ;:,:iJ ir.lii;i,"i ) Issued tjall_Iickets to the studenb withour meodoning the college nam,:. O H;r#.* loss of ;epuurion to Avinash College of Comm.... urd *,lturion among rhe D Another contention is tl*, univenity is refusing to extend affiliation for the Ac:demic Yeat 202+25,rn the ground tf,il, ,.ri"rl "* "i,i,L".li..r*n non_DoST process. r2421 or 2024 'Ihe This amounti to violation of High Court order in Wp. No. )Z4Z of 2 024, Q fu-** j E- )1 4+, .-- -.. '-* -' -.: -1!ti.:-: _ --. I t " i[f9Ji,,T'S rtl[::,:.jfflr':*',,!':'.";o'r,;.€rant amriation rodhe Academic year

6. On verification of the r_ruo-o+0Acai.a,j,lr.ffir,lTffi,oL.d:rr*.*TT,:li^_T terms of the KU ffi#tr""fr8Tt"#l;fl,"if$.trrjl*y;#."l;ll;,*,ffixffiit Unlversftv and the same amr Ttl!:. ils t1' i;; *:,"..1ff ^ ili;. [T j:'|t'il i,-":,H ]ji;*-" 1,_{il': :T""ij* ;Ti::?Jff ffi :ff f,"#*,*:-lH:U1,i[l#f *.q*^.iffi t:sHi j*T necessary order for (i) shifting ot co ege, (ii) Change of Manar,S^OlT ?021'.!.: r"qr"rt"d to irrr. (iii) chanee ornan:e or :::,:$:ffi*:}Xili;::;l"l*' r'sobo'o,. i".-"-;, ;'.",'J:'"'*'and Proc€ssin8' Fee rorshiftincor IJ-.:r ;6i@:n;;;'-ii;;;"1,'J,:*:;il;li;;:":il;:"ro 037?6t99861 t, (ii) Rs.50.00( l:I:.;trs*?r11,i3li:ffi,ffi ii"rft.iff h!#*;:,,r:*dffi ilr,li . Tbe Committee after findinc cerrn;r ^^^,l:.:^__ -,- r" * J ty'ii.i,*"",,r'1,Tf, ;'ffi m'[:H'r:ffi ,'ffi;:l*b; L he i ns pccr ion com m i nees i 7 (i) (ii) (iiD The Office ofthe college, principal Roorn, and comr lntermediate courses running on 46 floor as leamt from discussions. [t is observed that the facurry shown during the insp€ction and lntermediate courses, no sep€rar" ,""t i"e ;";L tor Degree Courses- for degree and r","*ji"" *,',[, ffi ;$:Hr.[[nff .*' ro be common that no separale class rooms were a! lotted to the degrec & Intermediate It is notic€d courses, whenever re4uired bottr coltege stuae;;;';;g"; r1*e class rooms. No play ground is available for the college is meant both for Depree Puking area is very small and insulqEcient Library roonr size is not sufTicienr according to\hc no.ms, book not suf'cient for 7 courses as pmposed Ladies *aiting hall not available Computer labs and number of systems nor sumcient for the giv.en coirrses Cash Book, Stock Registers, Attendauce Registers wa5 not shorwr Ouring inspcction English Language [^ab is nor available nor holding reg,rlFr ph.D Degree, and her honorary doctorate from ]}tel,y:i*, ,is organlsation, but there is a orefix of *D.. Lfore on f,." iu-r. board. This is objecrionable. Therc is one person working rvith Dean Designation the University framework. n +4tfury Z This is nor admissible as Per u 7a 5- (iv) (") (vi) (vii) (viii) (ix) (x) (xi) (xii) (x ii i) yo L, ,p 8 I::!-, commrEe€ has resolved to recommcnd: in r ieq, o;,1," wrir ne11o1s and conrcmpr case pending be.l.ore the high coun. thf i) i0 iii) To acr:ord permission to issue orders to.(i) change of mana{enrenl (ii) shiRing of coilege from one leased building to _ott r.r.j tuifji"g";o (iii) change of the name of the college for rhe.ic-demic- y*, 20;4Ji ;; 'r"nt,oning ", all above deficiencies and puiing a conditions ro r"inl tf," r*rni-U""rJol'"pptying for graar of atlrli&rion for the academic y ear 2025-26. To gpnt temporao/ affiriation to the colrege for rhe acader.ric year 2024-25 and accord ingly rati& t,e admissions. of sruaenf, uy *"r,i"n,"*'",, above deficiencies and putting a conditions to tulfir the ;; b"f; iliil i;l |anr oraffiliarion ror dre academic year 2025-26. while granting above permissions arrd affiriations, the orders shourd mention rhe fact that :vrid permissions and aft,itiation i, ,.*p.*.y"*l;;;ll:. ro acadernrc year 2074-25 oaly and is subiect to ofluag"m*i ln w p.No.lZaZo of ZOZ+, W.P.\r:.t3412 of 2023 and W.p.No.t70i7 -outcome_ ' "rlol?-*JL"n.' Siigumrt of tle Mernbers : l. Prof.P. Varalaxm i Dean. Colleg: Development Counci!. Kt-r Chairpersorr

2. Prof G. HannLanthu DearU Academic Audit, KU

3. Prof.T. Manohar Dean, Faculry of Sociaj Sciences & Prilcipa.l Univ. College, KU

4. ProfX. Rajender Controller of li>:aminations. KU

5. Prof.M. Sriniva; Dircctor, Legal Cell, KU Member Member Member Mem be r

7., , ^^.>t 1*-#;,,, >aJrja I.-\-_1 1b\'_lk