Manqali Chandrappa v. The State of Telangana

petition under Articte 226 of the Collstitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to lssue an Appropriate writ, order pr Direction in the nature of a writ of Nlandamus under Article 226 of lhe Con$titution declaring the action of the Respondents herein more particularly Respo[dents No.4 herein in not registering the Sale Deeds in Dharani Portal / Bhu lBharati Portal in pursuance to the Application No. 2500058488 in respect of lendee / Mangi Venkata Swamy and another Application No. 2500058653 in respect of Vendee / Khader Pasha, in respect of Sy. No. 277tAtA, to an extent of Ac O-24 gts. (Ac.0-'l 5 gts plus Ac 0- 09 gts. ) situated at Koilkonda village, Koilk$nda Mandal, Mahabubnagar District, ------Y is illegal, arbitrary, unfair, discriminatory and in violation of Article 14,21 and 300- A of constitution of lndia and also contrary to the provisions of Act, 9 of 2020 and Act, I of 2025 and consequenfly direct the Respondents more particularly Respondents No. 4 herein , to register the sale Deeds in Dharani portal / Bhu Bharati Portal in pursuance to the Application No. 250005g4g8 in respect of Vendee / Ivlangr Venkata swamy and another Application No. 250005g653 in respect of Vendee / Khader Pasha, in respect of sy. No. 277lAlA, to an extent of Ac. o-24 gts. (Ac 0- 1 5 gts prus Ac. 0-09 gts. ) situated at Koirkonda Viilage, Koilkonda ltilandal, [,4a habubnaga r District. lA NO: 1 OF 2025 Petition under Section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated tn the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct the Respondents more particularly Respondents No. 4 herein to register the Sale Deeds in Dharani Portal / Bhu Bharati portal in pursuance to the Application No. 2500058488 in respect of Vendee / Mangi venkata Swamy and another Application No. 2500058653 in respect of Vendee / Khader pasha, in respect of Sy. No. 277lAlA, to an extent of Ac. O-24 gts. (Ac. 0-1 5 gts plus Ac. 0_09 gts ) situated at Koilkonda Village, Koitkonda Mandal, Mahabubnagar District, pending disposal of the Writ Petition. counser ror the Petition"' ' ,t"Ti,1Ai*3XJi3i,_r, vAMSHT KRT'HNA counsel for the Respondents No.1to4: SRr L.RAVTNDER, AGp FoR REVENUE W.P.No.22356 OF 2025 Between: l\4glSrti Srrnu, S/o. Batakistajah. Aged about 48 years, Occ Agriculture, H.No.2-43. Parpalty Village. KoitkondiMandal, Mahablbnagar Districi R/o AND

1. The State of Telangana, Represented by its principal Secrerary, Revenue "R Ambedtar reranga;a S"iiJi5i"iranr. r,ir"a noaJ,- Department, Dr B Hyderabad. 2 The District collector and I\4agistrate, IVlahabubnagar, [\,4ahabubnagar District ..PETITIONER ---iz J The Revenue Divisional Offi District. The Tahsitdar and Joint Sub_Registral, Koilkonda Mandal, Mahabubnagar cer, Mahfbubnagar Division, Mahabubnagar ...RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of the C{nstitution of lndia praying that in the crrcumstances stated in the affidavit fired th(rewith, the High court may be preased to lssue an Appropriate writ, order or pirection in the nature of a writ of Mandamus under Articre 226 0t rhe corfstitution decraring the action of the Respondents herein more particurarry Resp$ndents No.4 herein in not registering the Sale Deeds in Dhar App caton No zsooosssll:":1r:.:T ffi:: :"Jil:[:ffii"i:; another Apprication No. 250005g774 in respect of Vendee / Khader pasha, in respect of Sy No 277rArAA, to an extent of Ac. o-24 gts. (Ac. 0-.15 gts prus Ac. o- 09 gts. ) situated at Koirkonda virage, Koirkonda Mandar, Mahabubnagar District, is illegal, arbitrary, unfair, discriminatory and in fiotrtion of Articre 14, 21 and300-A of Constitution of lndia and alr : : fj:;: "J: :' ;":.ffi' :: J::::,: of 2o2 5 a nd c o n se q u e n,,, ::,::i,rJ: j No 4 herein to register the sare Deeds in Dharani portar / Bhu Bharati portar in pursuance to the Apprication No. 250oo5g$g4 in respect of Vendee / Sarman Shareef IVd. and another Application No 500058774 in respect of Vendee / Khader Pasha, in respect of Sy. No.277tN , to an extent of Ac. O-24 gts. (Ac. 0_ 15 gts plus Ac. 0-09 gts.) situated at llkonda Village, Koilkonda Mandal, Mahabubnagar District. K lA NO: 1 oF 2025 Petition under section 'r 51 cpc prayinp that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit fired in support of the petition, the High court may be preased to direct the Respondents more particurarry Responderfrts No. 4 herein to register the sare Deeds in Dharani po,.ar tBhu Bharati portar in pursuance to the Apprication No. 2500058594 in respect of Vendee / sarman $hareef Md. and another Apprication No. 2500058774 in respect of Vendee / Khlder pasha, in respect of Sy. No. 277lAlAA, to an extent of Ac. 0-24 gts. (Ac. g_15 Sts + Ac. 0_09 gts.) situated at Koilkonda Village, Koilkonda f\4andar, IVlahabubnagar District, pending disposal of the Writ Petition Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI KONDA|PALLY VAMSHI KRISHNA counsel for the Respondents No.1to4: sRr L.RAVTNDER, AGp FoR REVENUE The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER HON'BLE SRT JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN wRt't PETI TION Nos.22 16 AND 2 2356 oF 2025 ORAL o RDER lleard Mr. Ii. Arlun Rao, I eqmed counsel rcpresenting Mr. K r the pctitioncr in both the urit Vulrrshi Krishrrir. leumcd eounscl lip pctitions and Mr. I . Ravindar. Iearne{ Assistant Gor,emment plcadcr fbr llcr r. n u,.. appcaring on hchalf ol'thc rcf pondents.

2. Per it ion cr in W.p No 22316 ol' 202-5. Mr. Mangali ('handrappa. is clainring that hc is thq absolutc owncr and posscssor of thc Iand a<imcasurin-e z\cs. I.37 gu]ntas in Surve.v No.27 T terec r>l Koilkonda \zillagc and Mandal. Mahfbubnagar District. rvhcreas. thc pctitiorrcr in W'.1,. No.22356 of 2025, VIr. Mangali Srinu, is claiminp righl ovcr thc land [() an extent of.Acs. I .37 guntas in Survey. No.277iotcs ol' rhc r cn sanre r illu.-qc. Both ol.thcnl har.e sold an cxtent ol.Acs.l. li guntas cach and balarrce land is Ac.0.2[ guntas. ln respect of the said Ac.0.l-l guntas ol' lund. rheir nanles u'ere also ntutatcd in revenuc rcc.rds and iatcst patradar passbook-c ur.ir-titre dceds *ore arso issucd in thcir lavour. In proof of thc samc. tlrcy have filcd copics of larcst pattadar passbook_cunr _tit le deecis. - \\, t, \os t:lt6 & l:li6ot lo:i 3. Thc pcritioners har c soltl thc said lancl to N4r. Mangi Vcnkata KI.J Swami'. Mr. Khadcr l)asha. It4r'. Mlr. Salrran Srrarccr'a,d Khacrer Pasha. rcspcctivell .l'he r har.c arso hrxrkcri sr.t a,d on completion or- thc said . rcgistration- rcsp.nclcnt No.-l is ,.t rcturnins thc salc rleeds_ I'hcrc{brc. challcnging thc said action ol'rcspondcnr No.4. thc pctirioncrs filt:d the prescnt rvrit pctil.ions.

4. Whcrcas. Mr. L. Ilar inclcr. learlcd Assistant Govcntment Plcader lor Rc'enuc. .n i:rst.uctirrs. rr ould suhrnit th.t though land in Sun,e1 No.277,'A,1,{ is har int rrr ctrcnt .l Acs.l.J_l gll,tas stood in the name ol farhcr o{ thc petitioncr.s. i\4r. tjalu Kistaiah. he is in actual possession ol' an cxlcnt ol' Acs.l.l6 _cunrus. AIicr his demisc. the pctitioners succccdccl t0 thc saitl c\tcnt of' Acs.2.l(r guntas. .l.he pctitioners har e soltl rhc said Iurrrl to \4r. I)antiu li.anqaiah. Mt.. Maneali Narayana and Mr. Mangali She kcr. I hcrctorc. lhe peririoners do not have an1, land in thc said sun cr rrrrnthcr. Mr. [tagh a i,crrrlc:r S/o Mangali Shckar has subrlitrcd an obiccrion l)ctirion l() rcsp()n(icnt No.4 stating that thc petitioncrs rlo nol har c arrr land in Survcr No.277lA/A. On rcccipt ol thc said oh jcctions. rcsJrt,ndcnt N,r..1 souqhr a report liom VRA...$ ho in turrr subrrrittecl a rcport stating tltat thc petitioners havc no .,) KLJ U P No\ 2l il6 & llljar oi:arlj land at alI and thev are nol in possessio of thc land in the afbrcsaid two n sun,cy numbcrs

5. As discussccl above. to sho I i I that the petitioners hcrein are or.vners and posscssors of the land admpasuring Acs. 1.37 guntas each in Survey No.277,'errel and Sun cr No.277,ftrlu. resPcctivety. thcy have liled i copies olold pattaclar passbooks. 'l-he1 I lhave sold the land to an cxtent of I Acs.1.l3 guntas cach and. thcrcforc. ba{ance land is Ac.0.24 guntas each. ln respcct of'thc said r\c.0.2'l eullms o land. their names were mutated. latest pattadar passbooks-cum- title dcc{s rvere also issued.

6. As discusscd supra, Mr L. Ravinder. learned Assistant Govemment Plcader firr Rcr cnuc s rnitted that one Mr. Mangali Raghavendcr has submitted oblcction p tition to respondent No-4 stating i P that th.e petitioncrs d{) not havc an1' lan in thc afbresaid survev numbcrs Iq I 'l herefore- he sought lirr report liom th q VRO

7. Rule - 58 of thc .l'elangana i + I ulcs under the Registration Act, 1908, deals n'ith 'enquir-r' bclirrc regist tion' Thc same is rclevant and extractcd as undcr ''58. It ltrrrns no parl of'a Reg I f stering Officcr's duty to locument brought to him enquire into the valiclity of a d fbr rcgistration or to attcnd t any rvrittcn or verbal p I 4 \\' Kl .l \or :llla,d:llli6ol 102) - protest against thc rcgistration ol- a doculller)t bascd on thc lround tlrar the crccritinlL panr had no rie,ht to execute the docuurcnl: but hc is bound to consider objections raiscd on anv of the gr,.runds stirted bclotr,: a. that thc parlics appcaring or ahotrt k) irppcar bctbre him are not thc lleisons thc\ profcs: ur be: b. that the documenl is lbrged: c. lhal lhc pcrson appcarirt! Js a rcnr(:!r)tirli\e. assign or agcnt. has no rieht to appeal in that capaciry-i d. that the erecutinI j]art]' is irot reallr tlcarl as alleged by the parti rroplling lbr regislration: or e. thai the executing partv is r rninor or an iriiot or a lunatic.'' Therelbre. if objcction submiucd bi Mr. Mangali ltauhe',.ender talls in any of the afbresaid fivc categolies, respondent No-4 can conduct inquiry. seek a report fiorn the VI{i rvith regartl to thc ground position. lf the objection submitted bv Mr. IViangali [{aghavcnclcr docs not lall in any of the albresaid five categorics. responclcnt No.J ctrrrr.tot. conduct any lnqulry

8. ln the light ol the afirrcsaid discrrssion. thi. rvrit pctition is disposed ol dirccting rcspondent No.,l to e orrsidcf tlle d().ul'nents liled by both the petitioners uirle Application Nos.2500058188. 2500058653, 2500058594 and 2500058774. respcctively' and the objcctions submittcd b1, Mr. l'4angali Raghavcnder. Rule - .i ti ot'the [-elanuana Iiegistration Rules, l90tt and also thc report ot- VRL If the ob.jecrilns subrnitted by KI. J $ l' )(,\ llllo& ::ii6 ol:0:i the said Mangali Raghavcnder arc fallifig in anv of thc atbresaid five (05) categories, rcspondent No..l can cofrduct cnquiry, othcnvise. he has to entertain the albresaid salc dccds presented by thc petitioners, if the samc are othenvise in orclcr. hc hus to 1cl.'ase thc same. If respondent No.4 is not inclincd to accepl thc rcquesf nradc b1'the pctitioners. he has to pass a reasoned ordcr hr assigning r$asons and communicatc a cop) of the said order to the pctitioners hcrein. Ilorrevcr. hc shall complete the cntire exercise u'ithin tso ((.)2) rteeks tiom the date of receipt of copy of this ordcr. In thc circumstanc s o1'the case. therc shall bc no I order as to costs As a sequel thcreto. trtiscellanco!i pctlttons. I I' any. pending in both the writ pctitions shall starrd closcel. SD/. A.H.S. GOWRI SHANKAR ASSISTANT REGISTRAR //TRUE CO qYlt SECTI OFFICER To, 1 2 4 The Principal Secretary, Revenue Deparlment, Dr. B.R.Ambedkar Telangana Secretariat, State of Ttilangana, Tank'UuhO ncjaa, ffyderabad. The District collector and [\rragistrate, Mai'rabubnagar, Mahabubnagar District |[ir[i"""r" Divisionat Officer, Mahabuf nagar Division, Mahabubnagar The Tahsildar and Joint Sub-Registrar, Kpitkonda tMandal, Mahabubnagar District

5. One CC to SRI KONDAIPALLY VAI\,,ISHI 6 T_wo CCs to GP FOR REVENUE, High C [nrSnrvn, Advocate. tOpUC] for the State of Telangana $urt

7. Two CD Copies. BSK PVL (n' HIGH COURT DATED:2610812025 CC TODAY --i---:-:'.-=,. 'i liE li i '1rI ,.:>... /j"'.' .: 2 i[P 2025 z. -Pi (j O .12 u a COMMON ORDER WP.Nos.2231G & 22356 of 2O2S DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS 01, rl ff q (X 1\ t).\