High Court · 2025

Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly, one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus, declaring the action of the 2nd Respondent in interfering with manufacturing sale and distribution of bio-products/b io- stimulants of petitioner- Firm, viz., Kuber, Triumph-B, UPS Charger, Bio Therapy, Bangaram, Ethy-Grow- 69, Vita Grow-99, Gracia, Greeno Borro-20, Greeno Amino-20, Root Charger, Black Star, Margo, Kalaam, Rootmate, Humus-SP, Biogreen, Yeskon, Daikon, Explore, Killadi, Kickstar, Fructus, Raboth, Cardo Plus, Verde, Green Flower, Biocare, Winner, Greenmax, Gain Flow, Green-90, Protector, Sky Grow, Target, Graphy Sweet, Rooto Vam, Protector, Sux, Chodo, Neem Green 900, Smart, Root Charger, Super, Power, BTS, Greenmix, Grill, Kaya, Raide, Drop Down, Aarons, Adril, Bethany, Debarah, Abigail, Dani, Haggai and Micah, which contains Anti Transpirants F:,rt:l;.;mud, Chitine and Egg Shell and ilre i:lso not covered underthelnsecticide:;'\ct'lg68andnotincludedinSchedue-Voft'eFertilizers Control (Order) A':t 1985' by issuing Memo No PP ll(1)20e5/ 2005 Cated 21-0'1- 2006and Letter No l-'t'll\1)2085t2005' dated 21-01-2006'and in th: absence of notificationpresc'ibin;hestandardsinSchedule-Vl'asbeingillelal'arbitrary' u nconstitutiona r. ianrl r rect the 2nd respondent not to interfr:re vrithirr any manner in selling ,nO 0,.1';1-'Lrlion of bio-products/ bio- stimulants includ ng from the licensed premises rlf the dealers/stockists under the lnsecticides I ct' 1968 and the Fertilizers Control( I rder) Act' 1985' t.A.NO: 10F 2025 Petition Urrcler []'rctton 151 CPC praying that in the c rcurlsta rces stated in the affidavit fileo in sL'pport of the petition' the High Court rray lre pleased to direct the 2ndrespon'1:nt not to interfere with manufacturing' sale a td distribution of bio-products/bic-r,t rrulants of petitioner-Firm' viz-' Kuber' Tri rmph-B' UPS Charger, Bio Therapy. Bangaram' Ethy-Grow-69' Vita Grcrw-99' Gracia' Greeno Borro-20, Greenc A,rnino-20, Root Charger' Black Star' tvlargo' Kalaam' Rootmate, Humu-q-Sil) Biogreen' Yeskon' Daikon' Exp ore' Kil adi' Kickstar' Fructus. Raboth C a,-rl I Plus' Verde, Green Flower' Biocare' VVinn':r' Greenmax' Gain Flow, Green 9I Protector' Sky Grow' Target' Graphy Sweel Rooto Vam' Protector, Sux, ChoCc Neem Green 900, Smart, Root Chargter Super' Power' ,(aya, Raide, Drop Down, Aarons, A'Jril' Betl any' Debarah' BTS, Greenmix, Gril rr & Micah, which contains Anti Transpirarts' Pressmud' Abigail, Danr, [1agc z I and are also not covered under the Insr:ctic ides Act' '1 968 Chitine and Eggr .c h': Schedule-Viof the Fertilizers Control (Ord :0 Act' 1985' and not included 1 including f rom tl-re I censed premises of the dealers' stockis ts' under the lnsecticides Act 11)il3 and the Fertrlizers Control (order) Act' 1985' pending disposal of the i:bove writ petition' Counsel for the Petin:ioner : M/s B'V'APARNA LAKSHMI Counsel for the Re:;oondents : GP FOR AGRICULTURE The Court made thr: following ORDER THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T,MADHAVI DEVT WRIT PETIT IONNo . 1804aoF 2o2s ORDER: This Writ petition is filed for the following relief:_ "...to issue a writ order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the 2,,a respondent in interfering with manufacturing sale ald distribution of bio- products/bio-stimulants of petitioner_Firm, viz., Kuber, Triumph-B, UpS Charger, Bio Therapy, Bangaram, Ethy_ Grow-69, Vita Grow_99, Gracia, Greeno Borro_20, Greeno Amino-20, Root Charger, Black Star, Margo, Kalaam, Rootmate, Humus_Sp, Biogreen, yeskon, Daikon, Explore, Killadi, Kickstar, Fructus, Raboth, Cardo plus, Verde, Green Flower, Biocare, Winner, Greenmax, Gain l.llow, Green-9O, protector, S\z Grow, Target, Graphy Sweet, Rooto Vam, protector, Sux, Chodo, Neem Green 9OO, Smart, Root Charger, Super power, BTS, Greenmix, Griit Kaya, Raide, Drop Dovm, Aarons, Adril,. Bethany, Debarah, Abigail, Dani, Haggai arrd Micah, which contains Anti Transpirants, pressmud, Chitine and Egg Shell and are also not covered under the Insecticides Act, 196g and not included in ScheduleVl of the Fertilizers Control (Order) Act, 1985, by issuing Memo No. pp.II(tl2OBS / 2005, dated 21-0|-2006 ajld Letter No.pp.II(1)208S /2OOS, dated, 21_ 07-2006 ald in the absence of notifrcation prescribing the standards in Schedule_Vl, as being illegal, arbitrary, unconstitutional, and direct the 2"a respondent not to interfere within any manner in selling and distribution of i' 2 l bio- lr'{rcr( ts /bio-stimulants including from t}re licensed prerliser' of the dealers/ stockists under the lnset:ticires Act, 1!)6,3 rnd the Fertilizers Control (Order) Ac1, 19i35'"

2. Hezrrcl lr:,,rned counsei for the petitionel' ald 1t arned GovernmerLt I) eader for Agriculture appearinll or: be lalf of the respc,nrlr: II.s. Perused the material available o.1 record' It is surbmitted by the learned counseL fr'r the 3. petitioner tl'zLr the subject matter of this writ lletiion is squarel]r c,.)\r€Ied by the common order of this Ct>urt dated lO.O7.2AI::; i:r W'P.No.25293 of 2Ol4 ard rat(h' as modiheri b:, the Division Bench of this CorLrt in W.A.Nos 1 l,1,l1l and 1136 of 2016, dated 0l]'11 '2016' Further, t.}ri,; .lourt, while disposing of W'P'I'lo/8 o:2027 and bat<:tr ',ice common order dated 07 '09'''2021, t eld as under: " 1 1. I r ;iew thereof, the Writ Petitions are lisprlsed of, grantrnil liberty to the petitioners to make applicationr in forrplit,i , e rviih the requirement of Clause 5 of *Le or der of the ( ;rlernment of India, bearing No'S'O'882 (E), de ted 23.O:?''.ilci 1, within two (02) weeks from the date ol rec:ipt of <:o;ry r,1 this order. If such applications are :nadr: wil hin the tinre stipulated above, the competent aullority s ra11 prccess the same and if satisfred, to issue provisir na1 -Certillc,r,c of Registration in Form G-3, within tour (4) wer:ks; r h ereafter. 12,. l r s made clear that the competent autt oriQ is entitlccl t,r collect samples in compliance of Fart-(l of the 3 ,*.irt"- *oi-.'oi,i". order dated 23.02.2021 t:.:gt"i"-."i;;;;;;il1:","J,r;"TTfl1:j,yJ"'#: nut.ents, before sranting the provisionJ'CJi,ii."," o, Registration. It is in the pubtic interesil;;";; ** pro.duct to be producea ana ma.t eieJ-"" J'u.#ir,r"r, " witJl the object of helDi cerrulose ;i-;;#;";X'i1"9-" r1T" to deverop high ""o^"I:: il*:flil,: ffir["*: pararnerers ro quari_s, shall.co-operate in arawing th. ";;;.;", ,#.'Il-,"" 1l.,jireoea above, is completed, i"U;.o .o Tl":i..." -submitting applicarions IiJ, urn" strpulated above and in compliance of requirei"ents of c-tays9.s of the order a"t"azs.oiioir of India, pelitioners are entifleal to manufacture a,,d "i.ir]-c1#ll-".,, 1i"!1uy* as contemptatea uy ctausel ,i,rr.'Lali'a",.a .2021 . Howevei, it is always open to the competent 23.02. authority..to verify wherher tt," p.iJ""iI i, ""'""i# r."o an^d distributed by the petitior"."-rr? r, ."-o"riiill, ** the. statutory requirements arrd take ""ti."-"!li#L,.a a. winra bv law,, In terms of the aforestated orders and for the reasons mentioned therein, this Writ petition is also disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.

4. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand ciosed. //TRUE COPY// D/-A.V.S. PRASAD D PUTY REGISTRAR SECTION OFFICER L p The Princi al Secretary, Agriculture and Co_o pera Dept., Secretariat, State of Telangana at Hyderabad The Commissroner and Director of Agriculture State of Telangana, Opp Two CCs to Gp FOR AGRI CULTURE High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad tourl One CC to lvl/s B.V.APARNA LAKSHMt, Advocate [OpUC] Two CD Copies Stadium, Basheerba gh Hyderabad, Telangana State To 1 3 4 R SA BS 5 4,Tn; t' .1 ES 14 C) [ ] jr 2025 Sf in,- -: * ,:HED HIGH COURT DATED:26106t2025 ORDER WP.No.18048 of 2025 DISPOSING (]F THE W.P WITHOUT COSTS. @rd { \