The High Court · 2025

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that n the circumstances stated in the affldavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the Respondents not to terminate the services of the Petitioners pending disposal of the above writ petition. lA NO: 5 OF 2018 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circL rnstances s,tated in the affidavit filed rn support of the petition, the High Court may be c eased to receive the additionial rlocLrments on behalf o{ the petitioners. lA NO: 1 OF 2021 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circr.mstances stated in the affidavit filed n support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the Respondr:nts to pay minimum pay scale of regular cmployees to the petitioner Nos.2 anl 3 in terms of the State of Punjab and (rthers Vs Jagjith Singh and others re:rorted n 2017 \1) SCC 148. Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI PRABHAKAR CHIKKUDU, REP FOR SRI T.KOTESWARA RAO Counsel for the Res;pondents: SRI G.VIDYA SAGAR, Sr. COUNTSEL, REP. FOR SRI CH.SAMSON BABU. SC FOI:I BHEt. The Court made the following: ORDER r '{ HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPANA WRIT PETITION No. 30491 OF 2017 ORDER Irc'ir I lr.,t rI i-s \\'cr( allpoiIia.(l :1S l('nl)oi-A1,. lrili-:i N,leclical St:rlT or rrl lioc l,.asis i;t Resportricll }io.1 - Oon.,pirr.r-r nli llr(' l'('iiliol(i:r iLr( liillr cliraiificrl t.) ttol(i l1tr. p,,-.1r :r,l.j.rl\l \\'1.rit'ir 'Lirci ,,r cii' scl,,'l:tr:(1 lrs pcr rircittiil-trt,nL l-rilcs. Tltt: ir111;Oinltitt'ttts ol tirC WIit f)Cilt]l)ittrt-s rVilit rli itLtis:tr(i.l:) tiiriiL.L : ,,1 i.: iir ! ll , ir ll!,;..i n .r r,r i,. i r) , / i\,leri c.r ie.. . n r l).fi" I I l,l , i:ri L,,ili.t nr \.1 l Ar.r..,"r ',.; l"l,ia:,,,' ",r..:,,. l N.r g, ), r t! r r.., , ri rl!r.p.). r\ M Sovrjr.ti llar I.Ip.r.r \!rsinal,l. r !1,rr i G M.ritu.r l.,rr!onr;v Dr.t i M!aiig r P.nluf.,.t..+ l,/lune.r Pandur.ngai r 'I emllo.a rv D es!a, tul 5ha rnl-ler:po -rn/ NLf ..,rtl O :nrnra.i.n Friiir.lrrr/ r .- .j lechn r rn K Syn.flll.r Dcvr Ie npor.rf D rq (:ii. r i' (.rnr.nnrnr., l . i rp,)r.r -! D e\ser I i\.1;nr ha fl.rr_.r Itirlp..ir! l,rrFl,.,::r /. Lr tr. r ,r 'r.. i-., ri.. rvl A r,trra,i. irrllltjaln, D, e.1. f r, l.itrr i inrr r 1., :. .r: / 3 9 i1 1) t1 1i ill _ -'r illr,t i.r(iri C.rr.pus se eci ol/.lpt) i(.r 1,.. 2_q c/.)005 De, n ln llyg.,. 5t ll i) rnr , rr I irL) .v.rts i F\r h,,,,: - r .r a-r arrau,l Apprentrce lr lerr;' C rcLri,r1j.x . r Ir ,,i)!, 1i 0E :005 l0 0 r.2cc / t -l 05 i 00n 16 04 I010 I r 03.2 009 1t 05 200.1 Dipicrxr; in o p h ilr;, rr. l5Jrsiir ls 0,!io x.r I Gener.r Nr rs;nil i .n! illclr'n l MLrlti Pr rpc5e Fealth,{/orker IrnpioVmen t Excharge 09 08 2012 ECG Te.lr n c an C.:.'puri ie1e, i . n/n rir ,r.t,.r )., .1) ,408 r1.ll! rY!'!€1 tJ. l]. d., Lr;.04 2!i! r e.r th \.Vori(ar Ii,ai .)ilt{l I cnith,,l'ci(aa lf l:l ,iJlil 1,.:ti : qil! ii_. it! i2.4l a'al :it ) U!r".i !-.k,r,r ieir;r. ,rr,, ,i ii li, i,f ir o!rnc.t E !r h..!,, {. l I echn Lrn , i, v SIr !i ll ,. l('froo'.r , rt.rrrd c rL Lr !r (l SL' o'rr n ll ri - , ,rrio , ! " r'r', rl ((l L,np.ynrerrt Err f:r rigc ill :r, ./. i 15 ll .)r i I lirdrogrrph. \!r! :rg A5r !.., 'l :;. t lc]tc !f tla Taahnra.rn ioLrr!" ), r l t? i (r .,' ).i.:L!] !,1,r.r.'i{'il]:': t. ra U rer, i ,a, ir I rr, 1 .. Car!r,. L Li i Piroa,e ilc;rllh,Ilork{'r \/ 13 I l-l 22 23 24 25 26 21 28 29 l"tir.ri,,n rr ,, il, lLr I rrr,, -r ,, 1,,, l ]Lr r ', Ll,i;tr i S.ricerir l::r,r! rrir'\, !,l :r, a 1.,K,)r i'. rl'i,.: , enrPor irav !r e',\: a l( S n,hn l( n'l-ri it !_ i) ir Jr raalsl tl 5w.ri _J Lrlfr.r cn_iiLrar,/ Pha rnEcist Chaltanya Ko urr lenrpor.]r! Ph, rr, a. Lst M a rgal Nl J il,l i.i it Tempor Jry Pharmac st Avunur Sowlanyn Tefipo :Iy Phar.na.isl S. Rajeswar Te|xporary Techni( aN Lab !.iir !ut ,rLeLL . rl.Pl, ,. I , Ailp,ent ce,/Aplr' Lat oi t.,.,r!,t s|i..t.. r,/rp r t, ) t,): ) ) 7l Lrl 2 (l:l ll:rl I i ala) i:,a rn tcrnr c rculat on Carnpus se ection/applrcation loternalCircular lnternal C rcu ar nternal Circular 17 1l . (ll)) 24 tr3 , (lllJ ,il.irrl . il l;) 26 i1 .. Lr 12

21.1.1 , U 12 24 :,7 . |t) Apprentice/Appllca ii!n

16.0,i arll Ll). ',1 L Dp 4 Opera. on lheJtre IechrrL)log./ fu]Lr 1l )l,r Polt Hedltr- lvorkri Bache or of Pir.r.n-Jcy Bac[)e or of B,rche or of Pharll- acy D.rche or of Phar[ a.y Bache or of !!"t19'v Dlp orr.r rn L rb T{rchnialln 30 03 rC09 Pharn-acy

1.1. r\il it:r' 1,'L ri,ilricrs iLre i'illl ttttrlir:lll sllr i r rrrci thril thcir- sen,i t:r's irre arsrstrl t iit l. Thc mocic of rcc i-Lli l t.ltcr-t t is L ltr',Lrsl't cnlltio', lti ri, r'r,- ltll!, i i;rici-t'tll1 circLtl:trsri L ltlltll'.t: ';r' r t . Lit itt],:l appli('riior:r. TliL sc'lr'ciioit \\as ll\ in'.r't,.ie rr. ' ittis. ii ltrLiiLi lr'crtlilirl('lIi \\'rilL(ll Lcsl r'; \\'( l ils rir iLirlt l1 'rgl I itor tt i. !,ltl ririirr'r ir:r i)( 1. 1-eciLLilttlclt! I lli('.r lt is I r liitlt ll 1tr mllkc iL lrr'lilloii lillri .r1:lrrrillltttcllt oi DrlLIt;L)l)l iii ()Ll / ' lttr. rrrtsis !_*. r \ias iirllr;ljl\ iiri ;r rr:r aj 1,.('p{,.1 .)' ..i- it,()rtilli otr r r ) 1 - ! 'i . I I I ( i , i I i (l i I r I I .. r r r r r r i r t t r r . ilr, rt.tlrr t. i)t liiit)ll('rs .rr( ,l I I illLllll3 to tl'tlrl'- i' ser.,i('( sr l;;- r'r',rr.; tr;qi llti'r. I?cspotld{ lll lJtl.I hr;rl irlrlr,i+-ri ill Llniilir Iiri)oLir 1)ti,( LtL.s ilr ittirrptitlg:1 l)L( illrilr lll('lll()cl oi-gir'ttlg an irrlrl-icial g:ll) ol a.rcek or so bet\\ccll lhe irller\':lls ol-six lrolrLlrs or al-l \ ('itr s(lillclirn( s and r('ilPll()int llctitiotlt:rs. 'l'Jlc sari.i .i('l ri- Rcsl;'rttrlclti No I is ilit'q:ri llrrrlcr Ir('rrl No l(r i'i Uni;rir l,itlrout- i)t rt, ticL's itttol-lloratccl irl tilr' Iiillll Scht'cltili tri' rl:l l|,lLtst-i:tl ilrsi)rr,, 1,t t. lq-!7. 11r, ,, :'l-rl),)illli-jlr'ill :tllrl r--olrtilrLliltg ll:r'ttt its rlrl /'rlt ttltl>io\'ees is '.tllt-t ;tsilllilllit. al-lltiiitl.\' 1111 lilr'.liii. i .1. Tir( i)irtiirtt( t( t-s ,iiid clou I.l l)\ rll(' Ilr:tl i;lt' '1 1lcr Crrilr il State o.f Kc.rncttaka u. (Jma Dcuij trt, lrl lr s;lrislicrl. Pc tlliOnt rs lr.r', trlt , ilit,i tllrrlLifi.t cnll:,lrlr l'li'lli (':i('lliilrqa- "i)llll)tl:i :;r')r'ctionf irt(,'irltl citt'ttlitr-s :llld srllisii(r(i Llr( Ifa]lSi)ilr'( r)t arilariil of li^ir' s( l('( ii(,1'i io rlrc posts rt it ii:ir ! C\. ,.i.'r,-' hoir litrg \'at1r's l()g('iltc r llrt', t't t'tt riqlrt oi lcgitinriltc e\])('('til I lotl t() gct penr]ir!rcr'lc\. itl l1l' trlsll()nciclll aomp::lll\.

1.3. ,Rcsllrllldt'lrl C(llllp.rl.l-\ ( ltlcl-i (l illt| a seltlcmcllt lilir qrctiLiortct-s or.t 0I-03 20lb uncler Sccr.io!r 12 (3i ol thc Ic)'17 ACL u lr,'rr'1r.. Rcsltot.irlcttts llttre agrccil '.(l colltillLl( perlliollur\ ot.. rrl ltoc ba:;i:r its p1 r lhc existilts l('rnl:l irir(l r-i ' r(iirllrl\, l-lo0a)l lS(C I I 't l lnriit:iiiittq lj tt; l:r i-,.' -, ,, iter-ii 10 f(til!illrli' iJtr.' ( liiill,i iil-r,l ol t)C-rl 11tiii ,r,.ii ) :,Ltr- i-! ; l i ) ll ( ) | I I 1 i I I : ' il( r:l .,ll .. iLlll rr( LlL irasis i-s . L -t ilirr.. l0 (-t3 :lir i:1 ill : Cu;.i'ii;:li;-r rtltl i tr If ()itLrS,' SLlr .rs ltct 'l'lrc ii( lLiemcllts (iill( (. (-) i ii l l(r l(., arlii rr l-l ijll \.,'(;rl1(1 rr t, ,.r iltiLi i.,',i,()Ii.i( IIi .i 1.o il.i\ iili sIrItLtloi.' i;L'iri lils o] r'.ill, ,lPI'. lriilr-L ir.lfnrs itrtcl lLlso ( r'iilir(i( (i ll1 ir.'li( iiL oi i'tc.r,.tsiirg iiCC () I it I tt( lal.l i i l(r ll l{) il,-'tit1oltei s. 'l hut l t'r'tr ilL:ir t)ro\ i(1cd u.iih trit'riiLri I ltr;i,r irrte.- :. r, r.. : I.rkl.... l:. , i '1.'r pciit.ioners ,.it-i: iitrltlct.t-tislrecl. :tt-icl it'i tr. L ri ( tls,.'. .ilr -\t)r)lor ofllccIl; (,f ticril)olt(1(tlil CItlllliint h:tl'ar tt:clrtllultrrl(li'( .liILIsi(]ll of their scrvices lront tirne to Limc canricl lrc ign -rrr cl lvhilc vicu'inq tlt(i rl.tiriiet- ilr tts (rl-I Iiret-\ 'l iris (lr,Lrri itt sirltrl:tt cir curl:;liurt r:s ilr Wrrt Pi:tilirtLL No. 19111-, ol-i0l ). grir n Le(1 in,.erin reii('1' to !-r(-rLlLi()rtcl tll( re In br orticlitlii llcslrr r (i,'nr:i 1ro L io rcnlo\ i ll( i ioi,!. :rs lht rt- is rtcc( l()r- t irrll:rlilt,1 rl( i si rr i,:t s. ) t; r i ir.- -r:irlrir-'r- l-iit:<l otr Lrclrtiil irl- t-i'slrLrir iir lL s. it is st,,lctl ilr': r: ':: l |ria'g1-lri('(i i),)\' i: l)j,l ll ''r Ii1,ttt,,'r,t iTl .i II i-: I , l ( . L i i -'i ,rri' o ilirqt',rl r llli li ' , rg ( r)Ir)i).i,rii:r ol ils l(ir](l il ln,iili, r,,,i1r, ,i rri r i.rsigLi. L'liqini('l-in9 rlii[l-iiri( ]LLr(. (:orrstru(lLi(lll. [(]silil!-l (Oil lrllsstorllllg arrtl s'-'r-r,til!, (tl :, \\ iric tirLtgtt iti'protlucts liLl(l s(f\i,,s lrr .rrtc scctor:i ,.)l il:i I ror.xrtt'.. \rz. Po\\'ei, 'l't-lrnsnllssirlll. iltclusirr'. T, l,iiisLrrr'irL rrl ifrlir,.rrlsrl iirl.lc\\ablr'Iirrir'!l , i)ii ,.i. (rri:,, \v'rrtt'l t 't I 'i K .iiral I)i li :ri l il:l i. rtl-L ..r icicsp;,-. iil rr('.'...'rrrk ,:,l il l\llrrLrIil(]'rLlr-i|! l)r\rsl(.i1 ,. 2 liirDair L.nii:,. -l iil,l,irltill ();jiir s. ii )| RCqionrrl Ir:1ar-ke ir;rg Ci'lrircs. i<csporrcicrt (onrl):lr\ l-iirs olti: r-,i tts ill . i l r L l i ir I i i r i L i .t. l,]]rl:r siLr.ttrtr,ri i]l i.l:r]ltll, iir , rrl. Hvcii:rarbaci. l'o r:ikr: i-,rcdical carrc of iLs e rnltic'. ce s anii rhcir cicpcrcicnL {irmil., nrcrrlr.-rr-s. jt h:rs e silirlisl'tcc1 i1 lJosiril ri rr ' its 1'or,, lr;hrp u"ircr.r ril il;:riicr.rt alnd oLit-llalicnl ir-cartntci.ris arc Drrr,..rclr,'ci. 'llrr: hosPiLri rs 150-bcddr:c1, ccluipperi ,"riLh mociern ircrljti, :: :rnil qi,;r[;l-icii rnc(iica] proit:isiol:rls. Horieli'l-. ',lte lo i ilL('i lr) ll)(l i :,p.rrrir:nL ( i)lttllaii\ . in rr,:ii't iiritrtiq!]-iri. r'ti ol ir,-r r n r c1i,-r i c nrctlir':ri r,i'r'rls oi Lirc c'tnp1c-,tl's \\r)rl{itig jrt tlt.i i'()nrililri l,rri Llr, ii (l( l)t rlal(llll I:rt-Liii-r' :lr,lil-:l;,. rli. i ('l1,1ir'l 'llt tli'-itl lrcrsolncl .rcll sorqlri io l)c clgargoci i)r'i 1('jl1)oiirr, irirsis iurd llti| is ltrtr.r [,r.riIIIIr.rII:, l-i:r.,,t, cOn-rr: ,1, jri,lligr, r,itg.,qcri :-,. li.t ill'si;onilL rri (,)iri)iiilr l,l Lllis i'i)ilr.ilxi, i:;,,ii :r l!i,,-ri i,li,'1, 1< (),: tcnrl).)rirr-\ i>:rsis tirl lixL-cl pcr-iocl,i s uith :rlrplic:tblc lt'i-rits :'incl irllrli l,rirs. i', iii:O11r'i:i r'if Il{r1 ;ltltt itsl. lllrli li].it s(, ,. . !1. lura.ic ()r"l rcgular- irrsis rrnd oquall\, rt is misconccivcd lira', rhc r-igh1s that .lc.ri-Lic L() a l:itizr:n unrlcr ,Ai-tit:ics f i, lij irlri li oj' tire CoL.rstiLrriion :rr-r' ',iolaLec-l. I{cncc, thr. scr\'rtrr-rs rcnrLercd b\ thc par:t irrcclrcal stal-l-:rrc noi 1i)r cote ttt:l.it'il.ii:s, herce, not r:ssenl.i:r1 ir r.ralrrrc'. [rr:lriioners \\'erc (]ngage(l ar Ciffcr:er-rt periods t, 1-n3ii3.:ll( r,1 )il:', ( i,lll.ii-(l illi'l'l i: ,l::l; ltr,i .rl r-(l('i |ls l ri,iiL oi llierl ii.il-r('il s rti-:l:

2.). l)r'iiijt,rti't s iii-rr i'l-rltlj3('al ()\', o(! itoi i)lrsi:r iii;,r Lt,ltt ttl lir e llLtt rt is rt!, 11c,.'tss.it'\' liLilL Lll(' Cotltllltrtr :;lttl riil ILL i rltt its our-i ii r-lF-r( hilrisln or sitt:r:iI-ii: procecltiic ttl lltr-,r ii'- ltrtr:lit:irl heirllh to Lh,: t' rl1o..'c,'s. i'r.:iiliOncr-s lLit.;irr,l. rrgli,-'t'ri Lr ,ir( ,rlllI:; and cor-tditir.';rs ri ii,r'it ttrt,..tt-t'. cartnot ito\\ iLlrl) i.lr()l iil .rll(l sal\ Ihat nr ane-.gclr'r.cr L has i ioiated 'rl.reii rigilts. 'l'ltc r:l; ll('ll1j()11 c!' Pc'titioner-r; lili,i :illl,ir' .11,-1. \\,-i( sulrl,.]r:i.t ri [(] ll( l-lri., .ri ,. (i-tr. oi scicciir,-r: o1- i)r)Lil i','i1t!cn titst as $llli i1:; '. i\it ;]l:c. thclr I Iri-liI!\'.Ili' :,lrr" ,i ilrL il,' rtt;t1r'(l lilrli i i , i)ill, r.r.i: ,! ulribLinri!r(l [tti ', rL' ,)irtl3t:l.ti1 ''\hiclr illr]\ lrit tt'li--1.iir ti, has no ltrlrril:q 1ri ,ir( )!-( si. tli lls. Ir|iiiiir:t.:' iriLl ril , . ()rlLi)ilr( '-i ,-rr rr .;.' l-'i, \1-,-s lltili lit( i rqir t \\'i )L I l( i r1 ( i.ir I li'i l l-,,.: lr1,l1>OirliCci ',r r'llillr l1 ll i).1'isl ol 1it,.:', l.1r 'tr i:-,'lLL,-ri lrr itilt" liLlt "ti;. t'IIII-'ItIr, r- r 'llrrr :lr'- :r p poin Lcii Lr!9;LrteIrng r)r (ilhcr Ser:tio;ls oi til(] i,,lrtrl:.ilt 2 ). -l lrr .L'tilt ll( lil clti.-l'L-C tti.loli \l ,r'.1i,-l iL.)l ,'|il(-ilil\ riqht ,;n I'r.iiionr fs liri q('liilrg rtpl;t,,lttLcti ()lt l-L qLllir llrlslr, illtc olj thc oLhLr- hanii. it \\arLtid colrfirm tlr:rt pctiltorrt:ts ):t'1. lt ir'llccc Ilt,-- ii-a.il-r ..l,ri ,.,.ttrll ;(,r)r t() 1)( r:OiiiirLtcr ()ri Lr'n-irr).:, r l)iLsi:, t Iturlhcr, lx r:oirlc-riirg iir:' bc-'rr:fiLs sucil tiri ilSl, If']F. .]tacta'i:r' rro ri;11t1 ii)a it!rrt:.r'rr'rll rl,ptlillirl.lcl:i it'irriiri :l'.:,':ii(r lo i)( iil'l)1-ri'rs T1rus. lireir colll(rllliolls elrc \\'hoil-\ Liltlallzlllli. lltlt.ii'ih lIt (it-rrirrtri i.,l, t I. t j-i., s,irLr, .rl)oril iltt r-tItitici.r ri,i ti si I i ,,tr , Il. tcc()r.nrl('rr{llililrls tli illt olliccrs lilr thcil c()ill.illLlilll()li. .{s :1ir ILiliirt\i'('. ',', Itclll, r:i] llrl i,,r| l,.rst. r)l- l), l-lr' r', ;;1. l]-i'r llllil Ltl \,oLl\ \\ iLhor-ti ltli'trtrsll :r ral caii,i:1ll'.. illI iiti:rs 11i- il'-'rr ' 'rl:' r,-orrirl irc qo,,t r tt,..i i)\ ill,-' ClirLlscs oi- '.ilc .l(ll.r-( Lli( i:r ilrilr lralr- ircr:n ,. r'rt-ere cl I)Lr1 iti)L i)n lllc ilasis of lhc Ioctlmll.le ilalaiialls oi' I irc st':rsr>ticcl oll-it L t s. In Groltn<l rrlo 9, Petirioners \\'ould t[' to compare

2.3. li'lt nrsclvt:s riitlt ['l'.ilirrllrlrs Ill Writ PeLi'.iott L\o ]cii'ltr ol ':Ol0 llLrl li.rr' lllt i:; oi lltl itt-( s('lli ( 11sc itnil tllrl lsst-tcs illvllllcrl are c'r-rtiICh ciii'il'rertt ritrci ir ilits no bearil-lg ()lr Ih(l 1i-s oi Iirr !)l-('5t|rL i\i t-ir Irr't it ior r. I{et:lt.tl St-l l)t atllhai<:rr C}-rikk'"lrl.r, lciit-ircd c:oirrrsi'l otl il. i;r'llrrli oi-Srt 'l- i.,rt,.:",itrir ]iirr), lcitrtlt'cl Ir,',lts''i i'rL- i' l'l "r r' irs q.1il ;rs -Sri tl. r.1;rlyti Sap,1r, lclriitt ll Sli'llol- L{riillsi-'l l.r'l)!-rsa]ltlitl S:-t t'l;. Sl:iirst--tl tJ;.1 llrt l'.'rtt'lli'cl Stitl:ilillll {loiiilscl on I reltir I j ri' rcst-.Lrr ttli'tr i l-:. '1. 'l ltt tr' lr- ll() alr.lilal cl tO ilrc ii)rlL illili i)trlitit'il't-s ;rtt- i e m llor:u-\' .t.l-h()a j)ar.llnediclai stali it't Rcspondent Crllllllatl\' itr l'.rcclt ,jrrlr 2Oi).r ;riril Nrtrrtmber 21..]1,.. 'i'll('iI ,llrllIlrltlrl( lrls i 't S \{'efc rnad( t lrro'"1'-tit er.nplo-t'meut ext'hartg'.r. iliicrrrit. r'irt L.tlilt s, Lrair ll Lis stcl( (' lr)l' rlr i I .\i,:rLilatior-is [c]lo,.r,:rl ir'. r'.tlr.ii' I L( sts irrICl t, intervieu,s. llcni--tl ilri'ir i;ririal rccrl.lttmcIlt ',i lrs i:lit I'rrl alt<1 ui accorclancc ': iLl-r Ihe 1)rcscribed pr-occrlr.tri' Rc'sirt)rrrii' :I ComprLnr itril iniiuilgi.ri iii rtrifair lairoLii r.:rrlcLiccs rrl'r(rt Nc. iO ol tlrL' i:iitit -'-t'l'icclLlie ol Lhc itr t. I'irt' i ttL I te rr-i ]I LLCLL cnqargcmct Ii oi r-,.l tiii0i:lrs .rs rld-hoc .mplor t ls 1i)r- :r( \ (- r-:ti \,Lalrs iI,r(]lltrlS.r) lrlrr::iti)t). ltsll, ( l:rl-' '.rl', I l ltll lli'i', pl:lccri ,-'rnplo'.: \.'| ct i r-,-'3. ur1:r rized i,illL:r-iitsi 1\\i) \('lt' I ttl' ()tl lrc( s(t..ilt1 . "i i -. i , li ii 11r"'; r.11 11 1i11.', i?...,,,,. I : i|r ' i:iliii)i ()ll iltr]r!;]i(']-Lt t,ir:r. lilsl;tltiritltlt ( oIlrl)il l\ r'tli(trt. ]i t,' sL'ill('1I( ril .',rll, t,,. iil rl',('l:l (rrl Ol 0.1 )Olrl rir,i,r ll, ' tl,,ir i.2ii-l u.'i,, .'r \, ,, , ;t, t,,tttltinit, ti..: aLd lLor I I ti.rit.r', t-rtr:ti1 Lt,t,fcf L \:i:rl '.1 li:llrs l-li:; t ltlrl-ll itlrLiclrlr r'-' rl ct"ltll-rr , rl lttcti lilt' 'rhr:ir si;-,, . r'r. l-r t,'lt' jrrsril\'l;lq tht'lli)rr:'iilii I'i I ')ll I p|rrrliin(tll lrtisi;. 'lile sctiLt'inenls (ii]1(il '-li ().' )(ri(; rtttci

10.03.2U lt, irtr<ltr Slt:tiort 12(3) u'o,-rlcl silr)\\ llrllL ir'':;ilcllcle'tt Cr.rtnpattt :ql-r'eti ltl ilro\i(ic:ltaaLllor\ bctl,-'ilts 3i..tr-1i i.r !l-ll. ili'}l' BonLrs,'.'llir Ir,i'l- IJlltrL Ilclrllls. ltlllt3 ',' 1' I ho''isillrl it|cl;,tl:1]!ll ri )r ,i-,.i rr|llic lti iit:;Ltrlilltt iiir llr l ,r, iti'- f, b,ntlits iif.t: i',ir:-,:: lh(i !'xlr';t(lr:tl t-iti,'rlit;rl ( i)\(r'it!r '\,'1.( Lo l)(j cr:lsrr-i'- ti li ::t i (] ;r., iil;. ,r'.i1. iirr'rti',i 1. l.'ilLrr! i i -.i sr ii. C". 9 (i€'niccl oi .joir secut itr :tncl rcgul:rr pay s(t.tics, highlighting alt attempt to exploit ihr:nt br, pay ing lorn'cr u'ages comparecl to pcrlrancnl c r l;lo r'r'c s.

5. 'lhrs Ci,ult. in orclcr Lo adju drc:l ic lhr' Prcsc n i 1is is r-clring L-tp,:rtr tlrc lits llrirl rlou'n br' l Iris CoitrL so ir iso il' thr: Hol irlc Aprrr L oiri l 'i'iris (-lorril rn Wi it Prriiirrrlr liir 1 1 ?, rl' ){ .t ).) lr( l(i iirirt i't'tilir,.rcrs. irlro atirniLLcclir srttisi\ il-rc Ir riai iii i:ri.l rlou it t;t Ijirr:r No..13 it: g*o Deri's t':r:la {sl;1lr:t) c.lll ll'i }le rlcplii r-rl r)i 1h( iiirl-LL I rl giillrzaiiot-i. iir:1". trrri l)oili(,rl {)i il-rc s:r iri ordcl il; r'x1 l lrr:I lr:l Ir,'I r'ittrc]ct ,. i.l Il' lhls is soil3ili -ri:i tt'rllr. r.|,lrli)\r.a.s i\ h{,]l llrr' ,rrl'r i(,1 rl'r,,,''Lr ri r'rijr)"ri\ \\'llai ilrrt l'ol'x llhll tnir is I ,: l:.slri tli il lt'il r',,ri il':i la) lhC sl;lt;' (il lt: lilsLi llrrl( illil ti,r.( ilLurr! ri:r','r'l rrr, tl,, , rrrPl,lr,' ollselre thctll llr I)(lrlLlilllcl'1 rlcl\l('e o1- to ;tllou lilcrll lo ( illllllltlc thr' rlri.islr(rri arrsrs r,.ltclher a nlalfltl,ritllLs crrLtld llr' tssr,t'::rl irl i()fr.\1 i). i)lor)i l lo ic(r 1o ll,: iir'oLrr ari sr,r'1r Pr rsr,Lr \l rllrs jLlilaiLll-(, il \ill itt Ral Sh -'r'tltliri dCr:isioir oi- tltc t ottsrtLllton Llt:tlch oi rhis (.)1lii -l lrat .'asc a r-ose Ral.radrrr (i)r) r (iolelning llodr oI t]re Naiancia Co11r:gc. olrr ()l_ lh. rIlfs;rl ro )r (.(i,i ille r-i'l)(itiLiotl arlrL lllr', ilIlricri thr'lrrlrrt'r .)al .l llrr (:oli.'gc \\ril slo ) titis + ii']r i rat ill (ll(lcr iliirt iralrd.lmlls tr','r r- s t' to corr]jilL ilrr' arr lr,rr iLir's fo (lo lollletlliilg st;,ti tr. itrlltosr's :r i( q;rl (lril\ orr Ihc attthot-iL\ rrttrl tlrr' aggriercrl parLr li-(' slar.lilc or rLllc to clrlirl( (' l1 'l llis ciassi.lal harl :r 1r:grrl riqltt trtt.le l_rosrr()rr ({,ir1IllLr('.. arrtl it L:l:rtlrlall;Lls.oLilrl noi ilr iisrll.rl ltr iil"'o,:l 'rl ii_,c rl,' .r:rlrloi|r':. enrplorr:ts catrrrol slrtu 1tar Lilt\ llirvc:tll Llrllotcr;llrlc t'g,al rigllt to lre to nrillia llrrlll rLr,(, L,rrr Lir, : rrr'r.rt ir) nr.rl.( ll(rir llle stal(l ls a llqal dltlr rr( r rlliLilr'rrL \, , rtlrsot-ilr'rl ol lhrl i)r' sll()\\'lr lllill D( rrlt;lll(rnii\ I lilil!i .r.l ( lra irslri .L rr/ r rrs lo llL .liltiiir'li f r.t,Ltl"t 'r', (irrr r'_r'r'ls rrl 'l il'r"'.ll apiloilllrir'll 'l lr'l-r' lrl;l! i)a . rrs.s -'\ ll' la lil ;,s (-\')li,iir.'rl ir' ,'l \' K'' l() \i i !:1i I 1_: i l,.! I I Nal-a!alIlalpLr'l . il '. i'lrllllLltlcirrPl)a ilrlal B.\. 'lrlLl ltir_a lli ttiro,,-. o ri.lh Lllrlr,illr:rl l)clslllls iil (lttlyi'rlr( Lii'il' l\ rlight ilrive ).raii i ,.ltii llLrtl til,'entplc-lees ltar'e r'tri'.1 iil'L' ti I ' ' -\r'ius (:i rrr,rr't i,i i \1 1ill,Lll ilri' llil(rI\ellL oll .)l r)l(l' rs Lll l]ilJliril,l ]t rtri:t t', I )rl ,,l llr,' :rililrli! ol s l.rli i tl ri'r'L :' rrl r' c,.r]lSi(lr'.c(li)[ ]rl, r']'s 'it liLt lip.llt ol llle pllircii)iils s''1i1.(ilr\ li (iis, s l i; r.r rL.i' lr'11 L(i ;111(l iil tlle lirlilt (,1 t - -i,11!lli'r" -'o ( il, ( Lll: lLtrii,t, tlll r.,)it,.\i. t]ls1r'L rrrL']lii.ii i.'s s tl,rti,j lull| sle!)s LLr iei'].Llliltt i.i. L)llt'i ll I Ltr, sr.r' ir.t,r; o :ti, ltrt\,'\\i,ili(il sltil(' 1,. it .ir ')l i i'i:!.)liijl\ r "-,r:: liill l,r iil,i)()r1rteal. \lio . trrit, Il;rt ;rr r i,t 1.._iit'l ciisi!1( tlr.it I r, r, rrlr iL ll \itl)( il()tir'(l ii(r'.]!. I ,i t , ' I t..',r Li' r'( '. I i . ,riit l l. r r'rlri ),rl l-l ri ,ittl, i 'i,, , ,'i 'io\\ !LrL( Ir:l,ru,r'(' ja)rt 1 r, r rl i,' ',', 'i]'\, lt'.,i tli)1 5t,rj i. .ilii' l: - ''i/(l'r.s lll'.tsl l)a s('t ill ltll-rl'lrrl "' Llrl,:i Lljiii 1(9,iLlili-isiL l(r:i I iL\ rI ll,'t'( tl')L I)t |'i('I){III('( )itil i, iil, lii l tlill iii I il-lefc sltt)-rirl l)r'lli) ltl|r.,'r l''.1)llsslllg oj ltll t'ol,slll-Lilrliliii I I llil' il? l)i !Illilr1t'1rt, t lrlse r' , :lr,l ilr)llrl !.irj'r ir'ril rr'!irlirl iir( i,,rrsiilt Lii).lili jr'i ('rr i, ll s,iso( -l I I ll l ij )SLS ,:r i. 1o. i i.l -r irt i.r' rs ( (rlL- ill I ir I rilL r, i r, ir' I 1l ! i'iras i',li:, ill(' . i,i t: :l r rli(r rlirs 'rlrL ir i 'i ii l irir, i cr rL : (,, I ir! lr|r' iriiii!(l 1Ill lllr)se deolli!orls \\l'llil ILI I'i'l i,r ilit i)iia( il).lL s( lil( (L Ll, llrr:i (i('( i:ri(jr, or' ;rr \\lLicll 'ijrL ( rr.r (r(:n, io \Llrril \\( ILrrrl \\lll starr,i (l{'lrli(1, ri ',1 lr, I ir.r't' rrclri pfe( ( aleltts i)

1.. :l,j!:)l-i ill (lil ill( i:ir r rl it,L' ( (1rl.ti lrrliil r-r|l1ii!,ri i:r i]r- 1r ilri'r lilll ii.l('il l'C,qll('Cii, r' lrli-rl: lrlr' r I ri-l 111r' l: I rl r't irilL ir:, lit,. r(' i\ ir:i i! :,( 11]L-lrirll I rr' .: i Lilir()il1 iii iit,)atiiIj rlL :lir,,l:(1, rli- lll(i li()i il' t tll-i.rri lil llL!- i'. i-ll-!:;i ,l(l j', iii,Or:,,.i's i1r-e l t-ttiljr.i i(, ij| ti.i ri illlrl([ ir Pl t tlrrItl I iirL jitr.t l:tirl tlo'.r ,' 'irt il lr irlr ,''',1)i > ('i)lift i:- { tilr ii' i. )lrl.rl)ir' iL) ilirr rit:,,- ':ri irLil ,.ll i'. lltrtl iitcl-i'il, lrlr r'r:itrir rl litr :,itltointnr'itis rjit lt{ ttl1ll-tct:l lltsis. Tlre {roirl.nii.)| .i Ri'spor.ldr:nt Compani is that Pctitioncrs loin<'ci tirc ,.'rr1-rlor rir,'ni i.rtrtl'ilg fitll.,, ..rcil ihiri litl]ir {. nlL1l()-\.1n( nI is tet.nltorair'. n()\\' calnt]ot turn atrolrit(l and clcm:rncl lor ,{ p.r'ntiinert apl;oirrintt,rrl.'lhis submrsstoit c:innot bc rr:cci.",ed. Coirfi Lraf i.)11 Cf l:)eiiiioltr'r-s ctt: acl Ltoc it:tsis is contra 1o thc iau. iaid dor,,'n b-r' the Hon blc Supreme Cc)urt, lnc tioned supra.

7. jrt lir:r. ili- ilic (iiscltssion nti..rlt, :11)ot{ . i,t( Wt'jt I)t'tilion i-s lrllov,'cii trs 1tr:rrccJ lor. Nr; cosLs. ( ilrr.r('(lirrrri r. ilr,- tlisccill,iiloits ,1ppiicrrir,r,s. ;f :rrr\ slrlll sir11(i ( los(al //TRUE COPY// SD/-MOHD. ISMAIL DEPUTY REGISTRAR SECTION OFFICER To,

1. The General lVlanager (HR), Bharat Ramachandrapuram, Hyderabad-502 032. He Electricals Limited

2. The lvledrcal Super ntendant. BHEL General Hospital, Ramachandrapuram Hyderabad 5O2 032.

3. One CC to SRI T KOTESWARA RAO, Advocate [OPUC] 4 One CC to SRI CH SAIVSON BABU, SC FOR BHEL [OPUC] 5. Two CD Copies BSR BS w r t,t HIGH COURT DATED:0310912025 : 16 SEP 2025 .1.. \.'t \:.- ,\ ORDER WP.No.30491 of 2017 \, ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION, WITHOUT COSTS 4(_t o Yt,--- .^q\J'