The High Court · 2025
Case Details
Acts & Sections
1. The State of Telangana Rep by rts Prrnciple Secretary' Rev'nrre r R--'r slIattor-rIt De"l.rarrIlent Secretariat Hyderaba0 z r i,-'n..qltirri or"criG Government of Telahgana.o/o The Corrrrrrrs5 u'rcr ,l,o t,,ri."tt, d"n",r nJq,ii"r'l'on and Stjmp lV. l l\'4arxet r1/der?3?'j E';;;lA,b;it;t6i, GJ"ii'r ualkqlgrr' D srrct [l'dchdl J Ihe Deputy Regtstra' 4. tr,4/s Shriranr Ragnavendri Ct-,riti put Ltd, Drlsukhnagar Branch Represented ...RES'oNDENTS "t [f ts Legal lVan6ger L4r K VenLr Gopal Rao Pettrort under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndra praving that irr the crrcumstances stated ln the affidavrt filed therewith lhe Hrgh Court nray be pieased to ssLle an appropriate Writ. Order or directlon nrore partrcularly one ln the Wlt of l\4andamus by declaring the award passed in Drspute No 433/2016 dt 311O5t2018 by the 3rd respondent acting as an arbitrator for an amount of Rs 7 03 4O0i against the petltioner including the issuance of the consequential recovery certrfrcate UiS 71 of the chit Fund Act without there berng any rrot;fication underSubSectionlofSection6lofChitFundAct,lgS2lsillegal.arbitraryand rvithout lrrisdictton consequently declare the 3rd respondent have no iurisdrction to entertarn and pass the Award in Dispute No 433/2016 dt 31/05/2018 at the rnstance of the 4th respondent without there being any Gazette nottftcatton as per sub sectionl of Section 61 and Rule 48 of A P Chit Fund Rules' 2008 and conseqLrentral executlon proceedings in E'P No' 156t2O2O on the file of the ll Sentor Ctvtl Judge Crty Civrl Court Hyderabad as filed by the 4th respondent are also rllegai and unlawful. LA NO 1 ()r. 2022 l-, ir .)| .,1,, s,,i i f l t5t {.1' ;h. t{,., l"e oi atii :ril:l .li ;r r-tr'r:ili - l I \cJ 1 r1q11 l,:rfl rlg: ' i ! r'l: "-'i' Exe6utl, Crty Crvl L:lLlrl .\t lly l'rral)'r'l il''rrl l'' :' ).r;. : ' 1',-,., praV n'l tt)ati1 tlre clrcJrlrstances stated rn :.'. on. tire Hrgh Joi.rrt nray 5e pleased to stay 'i tlr: ir.rpugrrerl awarl trassed irr Dispttte . .,i by ilre 4th responderrt rnclr'tding stay of )020.n the f'le of the ll Senror Civil Judge 1 drsposal of trc rrain \Vr t Petitlon' Counsel for the Petitioncr: SRI NARSI REDDY PESARA (NOT PRESENT) Counsel for the Rcspor'"it:'.'i No= t TO 3: Ms' DARA HARITHA KIRAN' FOR STAMPS AND REGISTRATION Counsel for the Responderrt No 4: -- . .'NCP The Cctrrn macle the follov'rrrg: ORDER THE HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE JUKANTI ANIL KUMAR WRIT PETITION No.8615 of 2022 ORDER: -i iris \\'rir Pctttiorr is iilccl sccliing the lollos'ir-rg pr:tvct ' lr) issLr( ;rtt itlrlltollliirle Wrll ()rdcr ot cliret ttotl rrrore prtt-ticttlitrlv ottL itl tlle \\:l.lL rlI Mitlrrl:rmtts lrr (lc( i,,L rtg tltr' ,trrrttd prissi:tl it.t Disllr-tte No 433,120 ltr rllrlL rj I I O5 ll) l8 lrr tlli 3"r rcsllortclt:tlt itctit'tg :ts itlt irrlr lr,rlor ftrt lttt itttloltttI oi Iis 7 03,400/ itgltillsL i)( lru()rt('l tttclrtclttrq tllc lssuilllco rlf lll( cor,si rtLtctrtrri r'((r()\'('t\ r'r'tlifit:ittt U/S 7l olthc Cllil l:irlli] \. i \\ rllt()lli 1ltt r,' llcitrg llil\. tlotificaliotr tttlclCt SLrl, >, r lion i i)l- S(-'( lii)ll (r I oI Cllit 1i.,,1r1 "\('1. Ic)S] \\itl)()Ltt .lltrisclit liorl ltrlrl rs r , !I]l (,,IL:.',irl( rrIi'. ,1, ( liIl(' LllL 3"1 tt sPotlrlcttt havt' tro illl(l Pilss tllc Awnrri ttt lLli'rsrlL( trolr ti) a lll('lliilll i)rsl,LrtL' \o. +.1.1/'20 li) clirtc([ 3i 05 20 lU at tlrc i,r.t,r,,,,.' oI tlir' '1'l' ttsPllLlrtcttt \\'itllour therc beirlg itrr\ (lilz('It( ltoli[lclttiotl :Ls llcr sub scction l of Sc, Li,,ri {,1 rutcl ltulr' 48 ol A P Chit Fu r.rc'l Rrrlcs' l0o,s ,Ln(l t itttscclttt tllt;t[ (]xe('Lltiotr prot:t:eclings irl t, l'\,, l.16 ,rl lOl0 otl tlri' ltlt rri tllc lI Sctlior Cirri ,lLrriLit L)irr LlLr rl Cottlr lllcleritllilrl its lllc(l llv thc :1 r' r'asl)r,rlal( nL .ut itlso rllcgal irncl rtrtlaw'[ul ittrcl pass "' ,r,lritt.lttr 2 I'lrcrc is lto r'('l)l.escllt:Itloll olr behalI oi petitiotlet
3.1{earcll\'ls.Darttl-larithal(iran,learnedAssisL:rtrL (lor crrirlcnt Plcaclcr for Stamps and Registrartion illl(l Rcr.c'tt uc arl)i)cilril.rg for t-csporldcnts
4. Mattcr Pe rl-airls l-o Chit- F und AcL, 1982 (for short' "tirc Act' ). Au,itrci pirsscd by Dcputy Rcgistrair of Chits' Mcclcl'ral Mall<ir.1grri, clirtccl 31.05.2018 for arr amount of Rs 7'03'400/ l ltL' iss-t.ltr:,, ol .ons,-.11,(,nLi.li rr,(.o\o11 cerlili(.i.rte is uncler rlr illcnl., iltc qr ,Lrncl ir;rli':r:tr is th:it thr.rt,is no (iazcLtC 1,,,,it,r. 1, .I s:r, I S,L, lt,': I s ( rl)11 6I ,,1-rl-rt, \ct itncl RL lr'.I\ \rrrlitr": J)r; ('l' :t i,, Lr r.l Iiu l.s, -lOi)S []t Tit.rt,rs l. rnir\. rrrr .ll ,!I ll)-1.i. tltis (.ortrt l)irssccl LIte l'.rl ,rr,, inq rrr il-.r l - \T I ., rlr,ir r' l, 'r'trl t, :l l, \,]' ;,r,,rl
1.., l '. I ill r I lie r lra 'lrt. rt rr': tt II ' ..s ('r n. r,lL\., ri ,ss r'\ str,l)s Lo tt..rtrstrrtl It L)lll( r' rs .ltr(,(:fe(l t() ltsL lr rr rr lril, r, '' lLl, , li, 9r:,, r 'r I rrr,l i lr, it a)t , Ir, r). On ltctr-t11 r.(.I'cr rc.i Io \1r'rliirtion. on(, \4r-. [r:rcinta Sh, rl it niipnlt !.\'irs rr\l)olnli,(i \lcrli.rtor-lTi-aincrl N,li.d iaro r) bi. l('tl.r, (lirtr'(l I l.(,r I?O( No (lo orclinitLrrr. ol Llrtriiarron Ctnlr.r, .lol; lr.llCr ad(ircss('cr Lo rir'rr:ii..r' l,rr-rrric'iur i) trr.t rrcdiatio, hers lrr:r:n ''St r, r r.sstLrl . Tl rt i , rlori i1;q IS :,1;rlCd irr lrcr 653, HC-N'lCt r')02J. The sclLlarn(.ltt algrce mcnt rrrrivcd at on I 1.09.2O2S. The br: t\\ een I)(,tllion(-r. .tnd rrsponcle n1s st'ttleme nt itgre(,lt.1 nt i.; rLs Iirllct,,r s l -l\'rriorr' .rrr,,t . r i.i,klts nii: r\ :r \\ P \o.8lrl,i ol 2l)22 lt.rl rl('l)osLle(l stlli:r , r, .inrt ,i .1 r] llra I-i)\!et' ( ()irr lo llr. \( ( ()trtrl ol Iil'",' I'lrl r laLrit ir'l llra !lI'[)r'o(('i.il]!1s Nirs k)r' lls i(),1) - - l.'rrl), r's 'l'cn s( \'( rl ,t.lrr.rl ;,lril scvcnr., st-\'ell (rrrl\l ,lt1(l (lt( flr,r ',ti- I rrr,r,. I rrr rIr, ,,]r ltirrl ,'r'iivc(l arr,rrr).)trrrl r)i r fir':r.,, , r l<s ; ' I l1)..1 , l1, ',c Sr'\(.r1 Lirklrs lrl-tr tlri(.,. ritorrsirn(l c'rr,.lr' irr rrrlrr' ,-L \r\1\ ( lqlrt ()nl\l rs l):lr(l tlr,ru!,,h ('oLlrl l) ;)l rrllr)lr ,llr(l lllL lrrl;trrcr' rLrrtorutl rrl ri:1,, s -flrr,'r' L.lklrs li)ll\ lls.l r I io,l lirLrr tlrorts;rrrrl o (, ll ,: ir, (i : rllt( ori '. 1 ts;rlr'r'arlr (lel)()sLI(,i irtlo llle l,l.l' .\i,,,rrrt r(, ()1 1()20. llrc (lotul ol ll St.Ctvil ,,1r.[!:(. ('lr\ ( r'. ](oLrr'1. llrrlr:r'rrlr:rrL Itrr: rcslxrrrtlcrrt rt'ill filr' ,,r , ir, rlr ' t,r'l,rL()rt 1r)r' tlle sirLrl(r artlolrrll [')x( ('ss i]|l]()Lir r; ;'1r" r ilrc I'l l' \i'a()Lult lll(' [)ctllror]( r' \\'(lLll(l (-l;ril]r 'i r', lti: | ,l rl)i i \r ('ss illIl()liiti ' r r. ,l r l:. \,
7. I)etitiorrr iincl i.L'(.r1 \1;rLlrgcr ol rcrsporrdt't'tt No.4 allixcd []rc'ir siqniltLli'!'s {)n :il i Ii( nr('n1 itqrccnrcnt
8. lrt vic-u ll' s('lil( nr( nI irgrecrrtcnt illld ltttcr stat]ng lhaL mecliation has bccn sLr('cr('sslLll, this CourL is of opil-rior-i t-hat no lLll-tlrer or.l('r's 11('e(l l>e pirssed in present Writ Petition arrd Wrrt PcIition ls accor(lrnqh closccl Nl i scclli Ln coLl s p(' Lr t iolr s, r f an.\' al'c l)cttdi ll!1, shi,rll stzrlld clos('cl. l'hcrc slrall lrc no orclct-as to cosls. sDr'r Ass ssflIrrvt*'tFRRX - ---- ---- //TRUE COPY// I SECTION OFFICER To ,1 2 I'SK I]\ o ne CC to SRI NARSI RED DY PESARA, Advoc o CCs to GP FOR STAt\ilP S AND REG na, at Hyderabad [OUT] State of Telanga Two CD CoPies $. OPUCI ISTRA toN , High Court for the I..tIGH COURT DATED .1311112025 ORDER WP.No.B615 of 2022 06 "'- s Te 2 3 lli 4[6 * trAT()r '-)' )() t CLOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS 6 -'{"'' ' i r'-