The High Court · 2025
Case Details
35. Dama Srinivas Sio Ashalu, aged 43 years (C-1550)
36. Nuneti Rajaiah S/o Ramaiah ,aged 44 years (C-1553)
37. Siravena Rajesham S/o ltilondaiah, aged 48 years (C-1554) 38 Siddu Odelu S/o Rajamallu, aged 48-years (C-1555)
39. Sagarla Sammaiah S/o Bhoomaiah, aged 48 years (C-1556) 40 Nagireddy Ganga Reddy S/o Rami Reddy aged 46 yrs ( C -1557)
41.|i/ittapalli Rajesham S/o [Vlondaiah, aged 43 years (C-1558)
42.Beerka Banaiah S/o Rayamallu ,aged 48 years (C-1559)
43. Dadi Gattamma Wo lvlunjaiah, aged 58 years (C-1560)
44. Nalivelli Lingaiah S/o Narayana, aged 48 years (C-'1561) 45 Gadipalli Shankaramma Wo Srinu ,aged 53 years (C-'1564)
46. Kurimilla Srinivas S/o Bhoomaiah, aged 46 years (C-1565) 47 Pesari Mallaiah S/o Ramaiah, aged 48 years (C-1566)
48. Pesari Sathaiah S/o Ramaiah ,aged 46 years (C-1567)
49. Pesari Srinivas S/o Rajaiah, aged 36 years (C-1568)
50. Kumbam Odelu S/o Ramaiah, aged 48 years (C-1569) ' 51 Kaleboina lVogili S/o Rajaiah ,aged 53 years (C-1570)
52.trllunja Parsha Ramulu S/o Venkataiaha, aged major (C-1571)
53. Gaddam lMallaiah S/o Rajaiah, age 53 years (C-1570)
54. Tirunahari Venkata Ramana S/o Laxminarayana, aged 58 years (C-1 573)
55.Toutam Narsimha Swamy S/o Kondandam, aged 53 years (C--1574)
56. Machagiri Gopal S/o Ven katana rsa iah, aged 53 years (C-'1575)
57. Tippani Anlaiah S/o Rajaram, aged 53 years (C-1 576)
58.Adderavena lt/allaiah S/o Venkatnarsaiah, aged 50 years (C-1578)
59. Aderavena Rajaiah S/o Venkat Narsaiah, aged 54 years (C-1 580)
60. Dama Rajaiah S/o Narsaiah, aged 43 years (C-158'1)
61. Dashralula Chandramouli S/o Venkat Narsaiah, aged z.: years (c-'1 582) (diedperL.R112)
62. Dasharajula Rajaiah S/o Venkat Narsaiah,aged 48 yea r ; (C- 1 583)
63.Vadakapuram Ramaiah Sio narayana, aged 48 years r( -1584)
64. Kunarapu Mallarah S/o Laxmaiah, aged 48 years (C-1li 5)
65. tVladduri Sathaiah S/o Venkataiah, aged 48 yers (C:15 3 ))
66. Basari Ramaiah S/o tt/lallaiah, aged 48-years (C-1587)
67. Akuthota Satyanarayana S/o Ram Reddy (Rajaiah,), a; rd 48 years (C-1588)
68. Togari Ralaiah Sio Ramulu, aged 48 years (C-1 589)
69. Dontharaveni Odelu S/o Ramaulu, aged 48 years (C-1 - )0)
70. Musthyala Rajaiha S/o Lachaiah, aged 58 years (C-15 )
71. Dantharaveni Bapu S/o Ramulu ,aged 38 years (C-15Si
72.Dhadi Rajaiah S/o Nambaiah ,aged 48 years (C-1594)
73. Veeraganti Sammaiah S/o Saraiah, aged 48 years (C- I ,95)
74. Nagindla Yellaiah Sio Venkaiah ,aged 48 years (C-159(
75. Madimadugula Venkat Reddy S/o lVlalla Reddy, aged t I years(C-.1 597)
76. Pesari Mallaiah S/o Ramaiah, aged 48 years (C-'1598)
77. Pinninti Ramachandra Reddy S/o Ram Reddy, aged 5,1 Tears(C-1599) 78. Pesari Komuraiah S/o Rajaiah, aged 58 years (C-1600
79.Pesari Rajamallu S/o Rajaiah, aged 56 years (C-1601)
80. IVlachagiri Sudhakar S/o Venkat Narsaiah, aged 38 yezrr ; (C-1602) 81, Sabbidi Laxma reddy S/o lValla Reddy, aged 58 years ( )-1603)
82.Singaravena Shankar S/o Odelu, aged 58-years (C-161 l)
83. Gade Venkati S/o Rajamallu ,aged 48 years (C-1605) S4.Vadakapuram Gangaram S/o Kistaiah, aged 54 years ,t 1606)
85. Deshirajula Sathaiah S/o Venkatanarsu, aged 53 years (C-1607)
86.lt4aredugonda Thirupathi S/o l\/allaiah, aged 48 years (C-.1608)
87. Kothapalli Srinivas Sio Laxminarsu, aged 48 years (C-1609)
88. Bondugula Swamy S/o Kistarah aged 46 years (C-1609) 89 Jakkula Komuraiah S/o Ramaiah, aged 48 years (C-161 1) 90 [r,4erugu IVlallaiah S/o Ramallngu, aged 48 years (C-1612)
91. Donikala Kanakarah S/o Ralanarsu, aged 54 years (C-1613)
92. Pudari Anjaiah S/o Venkati, aged 56 years (C-1614)
93. Polaveni Lachaiah S/o Narsaiah, aged 56 years (C-1615)
94. Keethi Pochamallu S/o l/adunarah, aged 56 yers (C-'16'16)
95. Rayamall 4 Choppari Rayamallu S/o l\/altaiah, aged 56 yers (C-1620)
96.Yadagiri Rayamallu S/o Nlallaiah, aged 56 years (C-1621) 97 Nampalli Shankar S/o Lingaiah, aged 47 years (C-1622)
98. Dontharavena Madhunaiah S/o Odelu, aged 64 years (C-1623)
99. Thogari Balaiah S/o Ram Dasu, aged 54 years (C-16124)
100. Lingannapet Narayana S/o Narsarah, aged 54 years (C-1625) 101. Pinglili Shanthamma Wo Narayana Reddy, aged 55 years (C-1626) 102. Korendla Chandra Reddy S/o Malia Reddy, aged 55 years (C-1627) 103. Sudireddy Krishna Reddy S/o Mutha Reddy, aged 54 years (C-1627) 1O4. Thalla Shankaraiah Sio Durgarah ,aged 54 years (C-1629) 1 05. Sunkari Narsaiah S/o Ramaiah ,aged 53 years (C- 1630) 1 06. 107. Thalla Shankaraiah S/o Dharmaiah aged 48 years (C-1632) Janna Ravi S/o Rajaiah. aged 30 years (C-1633)
108. Buram Mallaiah S/o Bakka tvtallaiah, aged 68-years (C-1634)
109. ltham Chandraiah S/o Mallaiah, aged 48-years (C-1635). I All are Agriculturisst R/o lvlaredupaka village of Ii rmaqundam [VIandal Karimnagar District) 110 111 112 113 The Land Acquisition Officer, Special Deputy Cc ;ctor, L.A.Unit, SCCO. Ltd Godavarikhani ,Karrmnagar District Mabbu Srrnivas , s/o Venkatrajam, aged 30 yrs ( L.R of dceased R -10 ) Desharajula Shankaramma, W/o Chandramoulr :;ed 42 yrs, (L.R. of deceased R -61 Janagama Shanthamma, w/o Rajr Reddy. aged,L yrs, R-1 1 1 to R-1 13 are R/o New lvlaredpaka village I arragundam ,4andal, karimnagar Respondents No.'1 11 to 113 are brought on re< :rd as L.Rs. of deceased Respondents No.10,61 and 28 as pr: court order dated 02-01-2012 madein LAAS.MP.Nos .2236,2237 er d 2238 ot 2011,repectively . ...Respondents Counsel for the Appellant : SRI P SRI HARSHA REDDY ,ti anding Counsel, FOR SINGARENI COLLIERIES ( O.LTD Counsel for Respondent Nos. 11,12,&24: SRI I AGA RED: / Counsel for Respondent Nos.1 to 9, 13 to 23,25,1o 27,29 tc iO, 62 to 1O9,112 &113 36, 55, 64 to 109, 112,113 Counsel for Respondent No.1 1O:None appeared : SRt MALLEST- AM M Counsel for Respondent No.111 : SRI S CHANDRAIAH The Court delivered the following: COMMON JUDGMENT i i l i THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI AND THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA L.A.A.S .No.431 OF 2()11 JUDGMENTI (Per lle l /orr'l.rle' Sn Ju-stlce Ablinarul Kumar Shar''[li) When the matter is taken up for l-rearing, learned Standing Counsel appearing for the appellant had submitted that the appeal may be disposed of by modifying the impugned order, dated 07'10'201O, accordance with thc report produced before the Reference Court in respect of the market value of the structures and wells assessed by the .Government Engineer, i.e., annexure-[l
2. On the other hand' learned counsei for the respondents, on instructions, had informed the Court that the order passed by the Reference Court may be modified in accordance ri'ith Annexure-ll, which was l-lled by the Government Engineer and marked as Ex'BS'
3. This Court, having considered the said submissions, is of the considered vien' that the present appeal can be disposed of by modifying the impugned order dated 07.I0.2O10 passed in O P'NoJ 1O of 2OO3 bv \ 2 the Senior Civil .Iudge, peddapally. Ac: trdingly, the order dated 07.IO.2OIO passed in O.p.No 0 of 20t)3 by the Senior Civil Judge, peddapally is r rodified and compensation for the structures and ra,ells . ; au,arcrccr in terms of Annexure_ll, i.e., based upon the narket r.:rlue assessed by the Government Engineer. 4 Accordingly, the appeal is disposerd ol. No ordcr- as to costs. As a sequel, miscellaneous alrplicatio r; pending if any, shall stand closed. SD/. I. /.S.S.C.S.M.SARMA orNr REGTSTRAR / f //TRUE COPY// l[-,o* oFFrcER To, any) 1 The Senior Civil Jduge, Peddapalli, Karimnagar Distriil With records, if 2 One CC to SRI P SRI HARSHA REDDY (SC FOR SIN(l \RENI COLLIERIES \ co LrD) IOPUC]
3. One CC to SRI MALLESHAIM M, Advocate IOPUC] 4. One CC to SRI IAGA REDDY, Advocate [OPUC] 5. One CC to SRI S CHANDRAIAH, Advocate [OPUC] ,l* 6. Two CD Cooies w ADKPSL r_ HIGH COURT DATED:2310712025 JUDGMENT+DECREE LAAS.No.431 of 2011 ,r .\ 3 e l4 L) )- 03 JAII ?u[ t \1. (.. \ \: I DRAFTS DISPOSING OF THE LAAS WITHOUT COSTS A^ f7)' I b \ IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JULY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI AND THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL SUIT NO: 431 OF 2011 Between: The General [\/anager, Singareni Collreries company Limited R.G.ll Area, Karimnagar Drstrict. ...Appellan UResponde nt No.2 AND
1. Rarsettr Kanakaiah, S/o Pullaiah, aged 48 years (C-1514) 2 Vangara Lingamurthhy, S/o Rajaiah, aged 46 years (C-1515)
3. Japaathi Vinoda W/o Shankaraiah ,aged 48; years (C-1.5'16) 4 Bonagiri Shankar S/o Komuraiah, aged 33 years (C-1 517)
5. Konthan Sammaiah S/o Sammaiah, aged 53 years (C-1518) 6 Gone Shankaraiah S/o Rajaiah, aged 38 years (C-1519)
7. Lokinr Sammu Wo Yellarah, aged 46 years (C- 1520)
8. Gudelli Shankaraiah S/o Mallaiah ,aged 48 years (C-1521)
9. tvlabbu Srinivas S/o Venkatrajam ,aged 38 years (C-1522) '10 lVabbu Venkatrajam S/o Bheemaiah aged 58years (C-1523 1 1. Gudelli Thirupathi S/o Rajaram aged 38 years (C-1524) l2.Ramagiri Narahari S/o Rajaiah aged 38 years (C-1525)
13. Bommana l\iladhava Rao S/o Yashwanth Rao, aged 48 years(C-1526)
14.Adpu Pochalu S/o Laxmi Raiam, aged 38 years (C-1527)
15. Madupu Bhoomaiah S/o Lingaiah ,aged 43 years (C-1528) 16 -Jakkula IVlalhah S/o Rajaiah aged 48 years (C-1 529) '17. Karupaka Laxnrrnarayan S/o Rajamallu, aged 43 years i )-'1 530) 18 Mabbu Mallaiah Sio Bhoomaiah. aged 48 years (C-15!' i 19 G.Venkat Ramreddy Sio lt4ohan Reddy, aged 48 years ( 11 532) 20 Goguru llaiah S/o Venkarah. aged 43 years (C-1533) 21 Olla Yellarah S/o Rajaran. aged 48-years (C-1534)
22.Gurrala Shanararah S/o Lachaiah, ma1or (C-1525) 23 Edula Gattaiah S/o Pochalu, aged 53 years (C-'1 536)
24. Dusa Sammaiah S/o tVlallaiah, aged 38 years (c-'1 537)
25.Adepu Ramulu S/o Lachaiah aged 43 years (c-1538)
26. Ramilla l\ilallesh S/o Lacharah, aged 33 years (C-1539)
27.Pittal Ralaiah S/o Ganga Ram, aged 38 years (C-1540t l 28, Janagam Raji Reddy S/o Ramakrishna Reddy, aged 48 ears (C-1541)( died perl. R-'1 13) 29 B.olishettr Chokkaiah S/o Mallaiah, aged 48 years (C-'154 l)
30. Katla IVallaiah S/o Rajaiah, aged 50 years (C-1543)
31. Macherla Lingaiah S/o Mallaiah, aged 48-years (C-15+t',
32. Gajula Vinjay Kumar S/o Odelu aged 48 years (C-1545)
33. Maturi Madunarah S/o Mallaiah, aged 48-years (C-1546) 34 Yenagandula Banaiah S/o Rajaiah, aged 48 years (C-1{i, 8) 35 Dama Srrnivas S/o Ashalu ,aged 43 years (C-1550)
36. Nuneti Rajaiah S/o Ramarah, aged 44 years (C-1553)
37. Siravena Rajesham S/o Mondaiah, aged 48 years (C-1 5 t 4) 38 Siddu Odelu S/o Rajamallu, aged 48-years (C-1555)
39. Sagarla Sammaiah S/o Bhoomarah, aged 48 years (C-1 i ;6) 40 Nagireddy Ganga Reddy S/o Rami Reddy aged 46 yrs ( C -1557) 41 tvlrttapalli Rajesham S/o lVlondaiah, aged 43 years (C-1558)
42.Beerka Banaiah S/o Rayamallu, aged 48 years (C-1559) 43 Dadi Gattamma W/o lVunjarah aged 58 years (C-1560) 44 Nalivelli Lrngarah S/o Narayana, aged 48 years (C-1561) 45 Gadipalli Shankaramma Wo Srinu aged 53 years (C-'l 564)
46. Kurimilla Srinivas S/o Bhoomaiah, aged 46 years (C-1565) 47 Pesari lt/allarah S/o Ramaiah, aged 48 years (C-1566) 48 Pesari Sathaiah S/o Ramaiah, aged 46 years (C-1567) 49 Pesari Srinivas S/o Rajaiah, aged 36 years (C-1568) 50 Kumbam Odelu S/o Ramaiah, aged 48 years (C-1569) 51 Kaleboina lvlogili S/o Rajaiah, aged 53 years (C-1570)
52.N4unja Parsha Ramulu S/o Venkataiaha, aged major (C-1571) 53 Gaddam Mallaiah S/o Rajaiah, age 53 years (C-1570)
54.Tirunahari Venkata Ramana S/o Laxminarayana ,aged 58 years (C-1573)
55. Toutam Narsimha Swamy S/o Kondandam, aged 53 years (C-1574)
56. Machagiri Gopal S/o Venkatanarsaiah, aged 53 years (C-1575) 57 Tippani Anlaiah S/o Rajaram, aged 53 years (C- 1576)
58.Adderavena Mallaiah S/o Venkatnarsarah, aged 50 years (C-1578) 5g.Aderavena Rajaiah S/o Venkat Narsaiah, aged 54 years (C-'1580)
60. Dama Rajaiah S/o Narsaiah, aged 43 years (C-1 581)
61. Dashrajula Chandramouli S/o Venkat Narsaiah, aged 43 years (C-'1582) ( died per L. R.112)
62. Dasharajula Rajaiah S/o Venkat Narsaiah, aged 48 years (C-1583)
63.Vadakapuam Ramaiah S/o Narayana, aged 48 years (( -1584) 64 Kunarapu Mallarah S/o Laxmaiah aged 48 years (C-'1 5t 65 Madduri Sathaiah S/o Venktaaiah, aged 48 years (C-1: l6) 66 Basarr Ramaiah S/o trrlallaiah ,aged 4B-years (C-i 587) 6T.Akuthota Satyanarayana S/o Ram Reddy (Ralaiah) ag: J 48 years (C-1588)
68. Togari Rajaiah S/o Ramulu ,aged 48 years (C-1589)
69. Dontharaveni Odelu Sio Ramaulu aged 48 years (C-11,1 0) 70 Musthyala Rajaiha S/o Lachaiah. aged 58 years (C-15l Tl.Dantharaveni Bapu S/o Ramulu, aged 38 years (C-15!:
72.Dhadi Rajaiah S/o Nambaiah, aged 48 years (C-1594) T3.Veeraganti Sammarah S/o Saraiah, aged 48 years (C e5) 74 Nagindla Yellaiah S/o Venkaiah, aged 48 years (C-159:
75. tVladimadugula Venkat Reddy S/o Malta Reddy, aged 5: years(C-1597) 76 Pesari Mallaiah S/o Ramaiah, aged 48 years (C-1598) 77 Finninti Ramachandra Reddy S/o Ram Reddy, aged 5z rears(C-.l5gg) 78. Pesari Komuraiah S/o Rajaiah, aged 58 yers (C-1600)
79. Pesarr Raiamallu S/o Rajaiah, aged 56 years (C-160 1) S0.Machagiri Sudhakar S/o Venkat Narsaiah, aged 38 year (C-1602)
81. Sabbidi Laxma reddy S/o Malla Reddy, aged 58 years (( -1603)
82. Singaravena Shankar S/o Odelu ,aged 58-years (C-16( . )
83.Gade Venkati S/o Rajamallu, aged 48 years (C-1605)
84. Vadakapuram Gangaram S/o Kistaiah, aged 54 years ( i 1606)
85. Deshirajula Sathaiah S/o Venkatanarsu. aged 53 years ( )-1607) 86 Maredugonda Thirupathi S/o Mallarah, aged 48 years (O 1608)
87. Kothapalli Srinivas S/o Laxmrnarsu, aged 48 years (C-1609) I
88. Bondugula Swamy S/o Kistaiah, aged 46 years (C-1609) 89 Jakkula Komuraiah S/o Ramaiah, aged 48 years (C-1611)
90.N/erugu li/allaiah S/o Ramalrngu ,aged 48 years (C-'1612)
91. Donikala Kanakaiah S/o Ralanarsu, aged 54 years (C-1613) 92 Pudari Anlaiah S/o Venkati .aged 56 years (C-'1614) 93 Polaveni Lachaiah S/o Narsaiah, aged 56 years (C-1615) 94 Keethi Pochamallu S/o Madunarah, aged 56 yers (C-1616)
95. Choppari Rayamallu S/o Mallaiah, aged 56 yers (C-1620)
96.Yadagiri Rayamallu S/o Mallaiah, aged 56 years (C-1621)
97. Nampalli Shankar S/o Lingaiah. aged 47 years (C-1622) 9S.Dontharavena Madhunaiah S/o Odelu, aged 64 years (C-1623) 99
100. 1 01 . Thogari Balaiah S/o Ram Dasu, aged 54 years (C-16124) Lingannapet Narayana S/o Narsaiah, aged 54 years (C-1625) Pinglili Shanthamma Wo Narayana Reddy ,aged 55 years (C-1626) 102 Korendla Chandra Reddy S/o Malia Reddy, aged 55 years (C-1627) '103 Sudireddy Krishna Reddy S/o l\4utha Reddy, aged 54 years (C-1627)
104. Thalla Shankaraiah S/o Durgaiah ,aged 54 years (C-1629)
105. Sunkarr Narsaiah S/o Ramaiah ,aged 53 years (C-1630)
106. Thalla Shankaraiah S/o Dharmaiah aged 48,years (C-1632) 1O7. Janna Ravi S/o Rajaiah, aged 30 years (C-1633) 108. Buram Mallaiah Sio Bakka Mallaiah, aged 68-years (C-1634)
109. ltham Chandraiah S/o Mallaiah, aged 48-years (C-1635). All are Agriculturrsts R/o Maredupaka village of Ramagundam Mandal Karimnagar District) 110 The Land Acquisitron Officer, Special Deputy C( I )ctor, L.A.Unit, 111 112 113 SCCO.Ltd., Godavarikhani Karimnagar District Mabbu Srinivas , s/o Venkatralam, aged 30 yrs i R. of dceased R -10 (LAAS MO 2236 of 2011) Desharajula Shankaramma, W/o Chandramouli, i ged 42 yrs, L.R. of deceased R -61 ([AAS tMO 2237 of 2011) Janagama Shanthamma, w/o Raji Reddy. aged a ) yrs, Above all are R/o New maredpaka, V/o Ramagur jam Mandal, karimnagar drstirct L R.of deceased R 28 ((Ll\\ ) MO.2238 of 2011) Respondents No.1'1't to 113 are brought on re( ord as L.R. of deceased Respondents No.10,61 and 28 as pl court order dated 02-01-2012 madein LAAS.MP.Nos .2236,2237 a d 2238 of 2011. ...Respondents Appeal under Section 54 of L.A. Act 1954 against the udgment and decree dated 07.10.2010 made in O.P No.1'10 of 2003 on the file of t e court of the Senior Civil Judge, Peddapalli, Karimnagar District. This appeal coming on for hearing and upon perusing t the Judgment and Decree of the Lower Court and the materr and upon hearing the arguments of SRI P SRI HARSf SINGARENI COLLIERIES CO.LTD) for the Appellant and cf Advocate for the Respondent Nos 11 ,12 & 24 and SRI MALI for the Respondent Nos 1 to g, '13 to 23, 25 to 27. 29 to 60 and SRI S CHANDRAIAH for the respondent No 111,anrj Respondent No.1 1 0 e grounds of appeal, I papers in the Case A REDDY(SC FOR SRI IAGA REDDY. SHAM M, Advocate i2 to 109, 112 & 113 none appearing for This Court doth Order and Decree as follows: 1 That the LAAS be and the same is hereby disposed of 2. That the order dated 071101201 0 passed in OP NO j l tt2OO3 by the Senior Civil Judge, Peddapally is modified awarding compens I ron for the structures and wells in terms of Annexure-ll based upon the mar< )t value assessed by the Government Engineer enclosed to the order d O7l1Ol2O1O in Op NO 110/2003
3. That there shall be no order as to costs in this appeal. SD/- A.V.S.S.C.S.M.SARMA JOINT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY' ECTION OFFICER To, he Senior Civil Jduge. Peddapalli, Karimnagar District wo CD Copres '1 T 2.r v ^DK/PSt- HIGH COURT DATED:2310712025 DECREE LAAS.No.431 of 2011 DISPOSING OF THE LAAS WITHOUT COSTS 1 t,