The High Court · 2025

83. Kurmachalam Srinivas S/o Ramaiah

84. Syed Samiullah S/o Habeeb

85. Sagi Sanjeeva Rao S/o Thirupathi Rao 86. Kumari Anila D/o Ganga Reddy

87. Vengala Ramakistaiah S/o Narayana 88.Boinpaili prakash Rao S/o Kondal Rao 89. Mohd. Abdul Subhani S/o M.A.Ghani

90. Kandukuri Kumaraswamy S/o Muthilingam

91. Rathan Kishan S/o Narsingam

92. Sangam Rajasekhar S/o Rajamouli

93. Bommagani Bheemaiah S/o Chandraiah

94. Dr.G.Ganga Reddy S/o Rijeshwar Reddy 95. Dommati Komaraiah S/o Narsaiah

96. Dr.S. Mahmood AIi S/o Syed lmam

97. Penchala Jaggaiah S/o Kistaiah

98. Yedla Rajeshwar Rao S/o Veeraiah

99. S.Laxman Rao, S/o Mahdev 100. Balakishan Mundada S/o Srikishan Mundada 101. Kanaparthi Narsinga Rao S/o Narayana 102. Patha Anjaiah S/o Hanumaiah

103. Renukunta Vishwanatham S/o.Laxmirajam 104- Patha Kishan S/o Hanumaiah

105. Gampa Hanumaiah S/o Buchaiah ...Respondents/claimants l.A. NO: 1 OF 200 CMP. NO:859 10F 2004 ) Petitionundersectionls,tofCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesStated in the affidavit filed in support of the petiiion, the High Court may be. pleased to of the decree date gi.nf .t"y of all further proceedings including iS-o-ZOOi made in OP No.4 of 1998 on the file of Senior Civil Judge, karimnagar pending disposal of the aPPeal. -execution X-OBJECTION S (SR No.3391 of2009

1. Vemula Satyanarayana, S/o Mallaiah, aged about 54 years' Rio H No l-5- 4'16, Laxminagar, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District'

2. Md. Maksood Ali, S/o Mahammed Ali, aged about 49 years' Rl/o H No 18-44' 4th Class Employees Colony, Huzurabad, Karimnagar District'

3. Gaddam Rajaiah, S/o Chandraiah, ' aged about 45 years' R/o Basanthnagar' Karimangar, Karimnagar Distriet.

4. Kamarapu Nirmala Devi, Wo Veera Bhadraiah, aged about 35 years' R/o H.No.7-5-99/2, Godavarikhani, Karimnagar District'

5. Busireddi iayarama Reddy, S/o Narasimha Reddy, aged about 50 years' R/o Basanthnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District'

6. Madishetty Satyanrayana, S/o Vemaiah, aged about 53 years' R/o H No 4-5- 125, Subashnagar, PeQdapalli' Karimnagar District'

7. Polasa Sharada, W/o Kondaiah, aged about 34 years' R/o H No CIl50' Basanthnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar Districl'

8. Chethi Rajeshwar Rao, S/o Ramaiah, aged about 52 years' R/o Kesoram Cements, basanathnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District'

9. Komroju Maniula, Wo Rajaram, aged about 39 years, R/o Kesoram Cements' Basanithnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District. 'l0.GanapathiBharath,WoLaxminarayana,agedabout3Tyears,R/oL-79' Kesoiam Cements, Basanathnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District' ll.Chinthakindi Laxmi, Wo Mallesham, aged about 34 years, R/o H Nog-45, Ganeshnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District.

12. Thangallapalli Satyanaryana, S/o Rama Swamy, aged about 34 years, R/o H.No. 7- 1-492, Mankammathota, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District' 13 llgl]ejrulr.ni_sa_Begum, Wo Mohammed Rafi, aged about 40 years, R/o H.No. D1195, Staff Colony, Basanthnagar, Karimnagiiiarimnagar Dtstrtct.

14.Marni Lenora, W/o Satheesh Babu, aged about 40 years, R/o.H.N o. C143, Basanthnagar, Karimnagar, KarimnagaiOistrict. -- 1S.safare Durgappa, s/o Na-gender Rao, aged about 44 years, R/o Kesoram Cements, Basanthnagar, Kirimnagar, frrirnrga bi.tri"t

16. BhoomadiRam Reddy, S/o Malla Reddy, aged about 49 years, R/o Kesoram Cements, Basanthnagar, Karimnagar, Xaiim"nalaioistrlct, lT.Thogati Narayan, s/o Brahmaiah, aged about 45 years, R/o H.No. r_14g2, Mankammathota, Karimnagar,

18. Puram Venkatanarsaiah, S/o Rami Choppadandi, Karimnagar District. 19 9lryfy Vjlkgt Raji Reddy, -S/o R/o. H. No. 1 -2- 1 46, peddapalli, Karimnagar Olstirci. Reddy, aged about 47 years, R/o Ram Reddy, ased aboput 3e years,

20..Nethetla Ramesh yadav, S/o Rajaiah, aged bout 3.1 years, R/o pediapalli, Karimnagar District. 21 ?r,.. ? Algnad Rao, S/o Ram Kistaiah, aged about 61 years, R/o Utnoor, Adilabad Diskict.

22.Dr. Baddam Venkat Ranga Reddy, S/o Hanmanth Reddy, aged about 5g years, R/o Armoor, Nizamabad Distiict.

23.Suddala Swamy, Sto N_11V1qa,.aged about 45 years, R/o H.No. 10_1_430, Santhoshnagar, Karimnagai, Karimiagar district.'

24.Dr. S.Athyutha Kumar,,S/o Kistaiah, aged about 60 years, Rl/o A.H.Depot, Shantinagar, Hyderabad.

25. M.d. Abdul Salam, S/o Jamaluddin, aged about 59 years, R/o Shah Saheb Street, Karimnagar, Karimnagar DiskicL 26 !!ojrd, Absul Salam, S/o.M.A.Khader, aged about 63 years, Rio H.No.3-3_ 195, Sawaran Street, Karimnagar, Karimriaga. Oirlii"t. 27.A.Ram Reddy, S/o Malla Reddy, aged about 48 years, - _ 28.Dr.GShankar. Reddy, S/o. Laxma Reddy, aged about Gaddapaka, Veenavanka Mandal, Karlmnagai Oiitrict. Velgatoor Mandal, Karimnagar Oistrlctl R/o Godiselpet, 34 years, R:/o

29. Syed Habeebullah, S/o. Syed A.H.Depot, Shantinagar, Hyderabad. .Rahmathullah, aged about 56 years, J.D.,

30. Dr. M.A.Aziz, S/o M.A.Khader, aged about 60 years, R/o H.no. 3-3-147, Sawaran Street, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

31.Shaik Zaheer Ahmed, S/o Shaik Ahmed, aged about 62 years, R/o H.No- 3-1- 51212, V avllalapalli, Karimnagar District.

32.Syed Naimathullah Hussaini, S/o Ahmed Hussaini, aged about 6'l years, R/o H.No. 12-2-8221712, Ayodya Nagar, Hyderabad.

33.Gunda Seenaiah, S/o Veeraiah, aged about 61 years, H.No- 9-4-21' Sringarcolony, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

34. G.Bhoomhaiah, S/o Lachaiah, aged about 34 years, H.No.9-4-21, Srinagar Colony, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

35.Dr. Md.Saleemuddin, S/o Md. Azeemuddin, aged about 45 years, R/o H.No' 3-3-99, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

36.Bathula Rajaveeru, S/o Venkataiah, aged about 51 years, H.No. 9-45, Ganeshnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District. 37,Dr. Abdul Rakeeb Ahmed, S/o M.A. Waheed, aged about 63 years, R/o. H.No. 3-3-58, Karimanagar.

38. R.Sanjeeva Kumar, S/o Mallaiah, aged about 43 years, R/o H.No. 94-21' Srinagarcolony, Karimangar, Karimnagar District,

39.Md. Abdul Rahman, S/o Mohd. Miran, aged aboul4T years, R/o. H.no. 16-16- 17 Bl 17 9, Usmanpura, Hyderabad.

40. Mohd. Mahmood Ali, S/o Md. Yakub Ali, aged about 48 years, R/o H No l-2- 51, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

41. Swargam Mallesham, S/o Ramachandram, aged about 48 years, R/o H-No. 3- 1-655, Karimangar, Karimnagar District.

42.P.Prabhakar, Sio Nagaiah, aged about 49 years, Rio H.No. 'l-3-7' Rio Old Bazar, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

43.Vemula Sathamma, S/o Satyanarayana, aged about 48 years, R/o H.No. 1-5- 416, Laxminagar, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

44.Md.Kursheed Ahmedn, S/o Shaik Ahmed, aged about 49 years, R/o H.No. 3- 3-195, Karlmnagar, Karimnagar District.

45. Kamatam Venkatesham, S/o Mallesham, aged about 48 years, R:/o H.No. 3- 1- 658, R/o Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

46. Bollam Naryan Reddy, S/o Ram Reedy, aged about 57 years, R/o Mallapur, V/o Boinapalli Mandal, Karimnagar District.

47. Lingam Ramchandra ,Reddy, S/o Aga Reddy, aged about 58 years, V.A.S., Animal Husbandry Depot, Goddavarikhani, Karimnagar District_

48.Syed Khamruddin, S/o Syed Sharfuddin, aged about 57 years, D.M, J.D., Animal Husbandry Depot, Karimnagar.

49. Bedarakota Nomraj, S/o Ramaswamy, aged about 46 years, V.A. D.D., Animal Husbandry, Karimangar.

50.Khaja Moinuddin Khan, S/o gulamDastagir Khan, aged about 58 years, H.No. 6-6-77, Karimangar.

51. Sana Prasad Ramulu, S/o Dhaarmaiah, aged about 61 years, R/o Thotappalli Village, Bejjanki Mandal, Karimnagar District.

52.Madupu Kistamma, Wo Prathap Reddy, aged about 53 years, R/o H.No. 2- '10-1530. Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

53.. Md. Raiazuddin, S/o Abdul Kareem, aged about 59 years, D.D., A.H., Depot, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

54. Miryala Bhoopathi Rao, S/o Venkatrao, aged about 39 years, R/o, R.Jalpathi Rao, V.A., O/o D.D., A.H.Depot, Karimnagar.

55.Modh. Younus, S/o lsamail, aged,about 35 years, Rio V.D.O., A.D., A. H.Dept, Karimnagar.

56.Anugu Mallesham, S/o Venkgaiah, aged about 54 years, J.V.O. A.D. A.H, Dept, Karimnagar.

57.Mohd. Abdul Ghani, S/o Abdul Rasool, aged bout 49 years, V.A., Oio A.D., A.H. Dept, Peddapalli, Karimnagar District.

58.Dr. Jan Mohd. Khan, S/o Gulkhan, aged about 60 years, H.No. 3-5-95, Azmathpura, Peddapalli, Karimnagar_ I

59.Nallagonda Bakkaiah, S/o Narsaiah, aged about 58 years, R/o H.No. 9-3-67, Siricilla, Karimnagar District.

60.Abdul Fazal Mohd. Fazalullah, S/o Mohd R/o H.No. 5-3-77 Karimnagar. Khaleelullah, aged about 59 years, 6l.Pothuri Parsharam, S/o Venkataiah, aged about 43 years, V.A., O/o A.D_, A.H.Dept, Karimangar.

62.Ganta Chandraiah, S/o Venkataiah, aged about 46 years, H.No. '10-4-95, Karimangar.

63.Goine Vinod Reddy, S/o Ramaiah, aged about 58 years, Sr. Assistant, O/o J.D., A.H.Dept., Karimnagar.

64.Gangili Karunandam, S/o Gangaram' aged about 59 years' H'No 6-8-108' Jagtial, Karimnagar District'

65.Dr. B.Jagan Mohan Reddy, S/o Anantha Reddy' aged about 45 yeas' H.No' -- 5-o-ss0,"Prot No. 302, ll Fioor, Himayathnagar' Hyderabad'

66. President, B.C.H.B. Society, Karimnagar' 67. Bioipalli Raghupathi Rao, S/o Thirupathi Rao' aged bout 63 years' R'/o H No 2-10.212, Jyothinagar, Karimnagar'

68.Bairi Shyamsunder, S/o Sanjeevarao' aged aboul 24 years' H No T-1-352' Mankammathota, Karimnagar' 6g.Gujarathi Rajeshwar, S/o Balasa, aged about 43 years' Sr' Asst ' O/o J D A.H. Dept., Adilabad, Adilabad District '

70.K. Adi Reddy, S/o Dammaiah, aged about 51 years' Rl/o H No' 5-6-3156/A' Kpuwada, Karimnagar'

71.Cheeti Satyanarayana Rao, E/o Ramchaader Rao' aged about 61 years' R/o H.No 2-8-i3ol4, Mukarampura, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District'

72.Dr.M.A.RaheemAktha,S/oM.A.Rahman,agedabout4Tyearc,woH.No' 2-7 -5O4, MukaramPura, Karimnagar'

73.Dr. Khaja Moinuddin, S/o Shaik Mohuddin, aged about 47 yeats' R/o H No 2- 7-397, KukaramPura, Karimnagar' T4.Velupula Prabhakar Rao, S/o Rangaiah, aged about 49 years' R/o H No T- 12412, Employees Colony, Jammikunta, T5.Vukanti Bhaskar Reddy, S/o Kukunda Reddy' aged about 61 years' R/o H'No 7 -2-665, Mankammathota, Karimnagar' T6.Vutukuri Narsimha Reddy, S/o Kista Reddy, aged about 48 years' VAS'' A H Dept., Kodimial, Karimnagar District' '

77.Shaik Baqur Hussain, S/o Shaik Ahmed Hussain, aged about 64 years' R/o H.No. 11-3-662, New Malkapalli' Hyderabad'

78.Akula Rajaiah, S/o Lalaiah, aged about 51 years, R/o V H Mulugu' Warangal Tg.Vennamneni Thirupathi Rao, S/o Rajeshwar Rao' aged about 58 years' J.V.O., A.H.DePt-, Karimnagar. SO.Vukanti Laxam Reddy, S/o Venkat Reddy, aged bout 57 years' J V O ' A H ' Dept., Karimnagar. ,,/ 8'1. Devulapalli Bhaiaranoabali, S/o Nrasaiah, aged about 51 years, R/o H.No. 1_ 545, Karimangir. S2.Kurmachalam Srinivas,-S/o Ramaiah, aged about 55 years, R/o H.No 7_4_ 222, yidy anagar, Jagityat, f a rim nagar' Oiiti"t. " -"

83.Syed Samiullah, S/o Habeeb, aged about 55 years, R/o Live Stock Asst., Veldurthi, Jagtial, Karimnagar District.

84.sagi sanjeeva Rao, s/o Thirupathi Rao, aged about 62 years, R/o H.No. 10_ 3-360, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

85. Kumari Anila, D/o Ganga Reddy, aged about 31 years, R/o H.No. 2-.12_ 1 036/4, Jyothinagar, Karimnagar. S6.Vengala Ramkakistaiah, S/o Narayana, aged about 59 years, R/o H.No. g4- 108/3, Sardarnagar, Siricilla, Karimnagar District. ST.Boinpalli Prakash Rao, S/o Kondal Rao, aged about 6.1 years, H.No.2_g-.t61, Karimangar.

88. Mohd. Abdut Subhani -Sl,itl9kli,. aged about 4s years, V.A , Veterniary ^ _ Hospital, Huzurabad. Karimnagar Districtl S9.Kandukuri Kumaraswamy, Slo- fr4rttiiinlur, aged about 46 years, R/o H.no. 7/46, Husnabad.

90.Rathan Kishan, S/o N1:ilgir,aged about 35 years, R/o H.No.5_6_86, 91.sangam Rajashekar, S/o Rajamouri, aged. about 4T years, H.No. 9_1_135/2, Kapuwada, Karimnagar District. Bhagathnagar, Karimnagar.

92. Bommagani Bheemaiah, S/o Chandraiah, aged about 56 years, H.No. 6_26, Choppadandi, Karimangar.

93.Dr.G.Ganga Reddy, S/o Rajeshwar Reddy, Aged about 62 years, R/o H.No 2- 1 0-1 0361 A, Jyothinagar, Karimnagar.

94. Dommati Komaraiah, rs/o Kapuwada, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District. Veeraiah, aged about 53 years, H.No. 5-4_42,

95.Penchala Jaggaiah, S1o Kistaiah, aged about 62 years, R/o Nagnoor, Karimnagar. I

96.Yedla Rajeshwar Rao, S/o Veeraiah, aged about 60 years, H.No,7_2_3gg, Mankammathota, Karimnagar.

97. S.Laxman Rao, S/o Mahdev, aged about 60 years, MpDO, Manthani, Karimnagar District. g8.BalakishanMundada,S/oNarayana,agedaboutSrikishanMundada, Karimnagar. gg.KanaparthinarsingaRao,s/oNarayana,agedabout59years,HNo-2-10- 241, Jyothinagar, Karimnagar. 100 -Patha Anjaiah, S/o Hanumaiah aged about 48 years, Health lnspector, Gollapalli (V & M), Karimnagar. 101 . Renukunta Vishwanatham, S/o Laxmirajyam, aged about 54 years, R/o Karimnagar- '102. Patha Kishan, S/o Hanumaiah, aged about 42 yea's, Gollapalli M & (M)' Karimnagar District.

103. Gampa Hanumaiah, S/o Buchaiah, aged about 44 years, Gollapalli (V) & (M), Karimnagar District. All are resident of Arepally village of Karimnagar Mandal & District' ..Cross Objectors/ResPondents AND The Special Deputy Collector/, Land Acquisition officer L.A.Unit, S.C.Railway, New B.G.Line Karimnagar. ...RespondenUAPPellant Counsel for the Appellant in A.S. and For Respondent in Cross Objections : Smt. T Suhasini Counsel for the Respondents in A-S. and For Cross Objector in Cross Objections : Sri VRAvula The Court delivered the following: Common Judgment A' HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KTIMAR SHAVILI AIID HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA Appeal Suit No.373 9 of 2OO3 AND X-Obiectio ns ISR No.3391 of 2(X)9 COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon'ble Smt. Justice Tirumala Deui Eada) This appeal, under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, (for short the Act) is preferred by the Special Deputy Collector, Karimnagar, aggrieved by the order and decree dated

13.06.2003 passed in O.P.No.4 of 1998 by the learned Senior Civil Judge at Karimnagar (hereinafter referred to as .the trial CourtJ.

2. The appellants - Special Deputy Collector is aggrieved by the order of the tria-l Court enhalcing the compensation from Rs. 18,OO0/- per acre that was granted by the Land Acquisition Officer to that of Rs.2,OO,000/- per acre.

3. X-Objections are filed by the respondents - claimants praying for enhancement of the market value of the acquired lands to Rs.4,OO,OOO/-. It is their,contention that the lands which were acquired are usefui for residential house purpose and that the Court below while enhancing the market value ought to have considered that the neighbouring Iands are sold for residential houses, medical, educational institutions, industrial and 2 AKSJ & EID,J 1 commercial establishments and documentary evidence was hled to the said effect. It is their further contention that the acquired lands were purchased by the claimants therein by forming into house building society and many places were sold in the year 1988 and that the acquisition has taken place when the construction was about to be started and that the lands in the vicinity were developed with rice mills, poultry farms and dairy farms' They further contended that the evidence of PWs 1 to 3 and the documentary evidence under Exs'Al to A2l ought to have been considered by the Court below That the lands acquired are situated nearer to Karimnagar Town and that they are just 1 KM away from the Government Hospital' Karimnagar and that during the pendency of the acquisition proceedings the area in which the acquired lands is situated, was brought under the purview of the Municipal Corporation of Karimnagar' Therefore' they prayed for enhancement of compensation to Rs'4'oo'000/- per acre' For convenience and clarity' the parties herein are referred to

4. as they were arrayed before the trial Court'

5. The facts of the case in brief are that based on the requisition made by the Deputy Chief Engineer South Central Railway, land to an extent of Ac' 1 1'O2 guntas situated in the limits of Arepalli village of Karimnagar Mandal and District was acquired' *-' ./ ,/..t-t 3 AXs,J & ETD,J for the purpose of laying railway line. A draft notiflcation was issued under Section a(1) and 6 of the Act on O2.11.1995 in the Gaz.ette and on 14.11.19gS in the local news paper. After conducting the due enquiry, the Land Acquisition Officer has fixed the market value of the land as Rs.lg,OOO/_ per acre. Aggrieved by the said award, the claimants have filed a petition for reference and the same was referred under Section 1g of the Act to the trial Court.

6. The trial Court hq" framed the following point for consideration: "Whether the claimants are entitled for enhancement of compensation, if so, at what rate?,,

7. The claimants before the trial Court got examined pWs t to 3 and Exs.Al to ,{21 were marked. One Sri Manzoor Ahmed, Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition Unit, S.C.Railway, Karimnagar got examined as RWl and Exs.Bl and 82 were marked.

8. Based on the evidence on record, the trial Court has enhanced the compensation from Rs, lg,O0O/_ per acre to Rs.2,OO,OOOI/- per acre. Aggrieved by the said enhancement, the Special Depuly Collector has preferred the present appeal. / / 4 AKS,J & ETD,J g. Heard the submissions of Smt'T'suhasini' learned Standing Counsel for the appellants and Sri V'R Avula' learned counsel for the respondents.

10. The learned appeilants counsel has argued that the trial Court has not considered the evidence let in by the respondents/ Land Acquisition Officer and that it has simply passed the award based on the sale deeds hled by the claimants and simply believed their evidence and has awarded the exorbitant amount and has therefore, prayed to set aside the award passed by the trial Court by allowing the appeal' 1 1. The learned respondents counsel' on the ol'her hand' hied cross objections and submitted that the trial Court granted a meager amount of compensation ' and that documentslrledbytheclaimantsarenotproperlyconsidered has therefore, prayed this Court to enhance the compensation'

12. Considering the above facts, the grounds raised in the appeal and the X-objections hled by the claimants, this Court frames the following points for consideration: 1 \2 \ Whether the claimants are entitled for enhancement of comPensation? Whether the trial Court's order and decree need any interference?

3. To what relieP

1., 5 Arc,., & ETD,J

13. POINT IYO.I: a) A perusal of the record reveals that for the purpose of laying a railway line, a vast extent of Ac. 1 1.O2 guntas situated in the limits of Arepalli Village of Karimnagar Mandai and District was acquired. Exs.A7 & Ag are the sale deeds relied upon by the claimants. The said sale deeds pertain to the years 1994 and 1995 and hence, the sarne can be considered while awarding compensation as they pertain to the preceding three years of the present acquisition. b) The evidence of pW1 discloses that the acquired land are situated by the side of pWD road i.e., National Highway leading from Hyderabad to Nagpur via Karminagar and Mancherial and that the said lands are situated near Abadi of Karimnagar cit5r which is a special Grade Municipality and that his lalds in survey Nos.233 to 23S are located at a distance of 2OO to250 yards from the said pWD road. It is further elicited through his evidence that there is one Matha Manikeshwari Temple, one of the biggest holy place of Karimnagar District and that there is a Housing Society by name Veerabhadriya Housing Colony developed in the year l99O ard $at his neighbouring lands were being sold for house plots tt'd .,ol,,,ott"ial purposes through sripriya Real Estates in the year 1990 at the rare of Rs.2O,OoO/_ per gunta. It is further elicited i t l 6 A(S,J & ETD,)' through him that there is a rice mill, junior college, poultry farm etc., in the vicinity of their lands. The Land Acquisition Ofhcer who was examined as RW t has deposed before the trial Court admitting that the present acquired land is situated at a distance of 1 KM from the Government Hospital, Karimnagar and that the entire lands acquired for laying the railway line are mostiy situated adjacent to the main road from Karimnagar to Mancherial and that remaining lands are situated at a distance from the road' Thus' it is clear from the evidence of PW1 and RW1 that the acquired lands are situated in a developed area and that it is at a distance of I KM from the Government Hospital and also that the land acquired has more potentiatity towards development into house plots' It is elicited from PWs 1 to 3 that there are many house plots in and around the acquired lands and in fact there are many housing societies, under which large extents of lands were converted into house plots. PW6 is the vendee of the sale deed dated 19'12'1994' PW7 is also a vendee of saie deed dated 26'12'1994 ' the sale transaction under Ex.A1 shows that an extent of Ac'0-02 guntas was sold in survey No.234 for a sale consideration of Rs 18'2OO/- which comes to a total value of Rs.3,60,OOO/- per acre 7 AKS,J & ETD,J c) Thus, considering the evidence adduced by the claimarts under Exs.Al to A21 ald also the sale transactions disclosed in the statistics under Ex.Bl, it is revealed that the lands at Arepalli village fetch more value, than what is awarded by the Land Abquisition Officer and hence, it is held that the claimants are entitled for enhancement in compensation and the amount awarded by the trial Court i.e. Rs.2,O0,O0O/_ is held to be justifiable amount. d) It was contended by the rearned apperiant counser that the sale tralsactions shown in bits and pieces calnot be taken as a staldard to hx the market value over a vast extent of land. It is relevant to refer to the judgments of the Honble Apex Court in La.nd Acquisition Officer, Reaenue Divisional OfJicer a. L.Kamalammar and ?Yisha la Jain a. Stdte of tlttaranchap. I e) In Land Acquisition offrcer, Reveaue Divisionar officer,s case (supra 1), the Hontrte Apex Court held as under: ?f ". *:", .6....when comparable land were available where large chunks of land had U..n sofa, ."e-.r'il.r-a i...r"""tio.r" in respect of smaller extent of hna coutJ-Ue* ,ik , .ro,, of "" indicating rhe Drice-:hal_il ;t of larrd by making approp.i.t. a.Or"ti5rrl such as for or targe tracts development of the sewe rs, d rai n s, * ?:.;!":i xJi#, L*,.J; ffi :, ", xffi :, h:::: Iump sum pryrn.nt .s .atso th.- *a,;;;,ffi;", required for "t' t"""' selling the sires that would be foprn.Ol" i;,;";;,."";I r 1t9s8; z supreme court cases 385 - l2o{u 6 scc 47 AKS,J & ETD,J 1 8 In Tfishala Jain a' State of tlttaranchal's case (supra 2)' 0 the Hon'ble APex Court held as under: "The sale instances even of smaller plots could be considered foi determining the market value of alarger chunk of land with some deduction t'tit"", tftttt was comparability in potential' utilization, amenities and infrastructure with hardly arty distinction. O' suctt principles each case would have to be considered on its own merits"' c) Thus, when no other comparable documents are available' the sale transactions involving smaller extents of land can be considered by allowing reasonable deductions' if they are similar in potentiality, utilization, amenities and infrastructure' Based on the said principle, the trial Court has enhanced the compensation from Rs.18,0OO/- to that of Rs'2,0O,000/- per acre Point No' 1 is answered accordinglY. r+ POINT NO.2: In view of the reasoned hnding arrived at Point No'l' this Court holds that the trial Court's order and decree do not need any interference

15. POINT NO.3: In the result, the appeal and the X-objections hled by the claimants are dismissed upholding the order and decree dated 13.06.2003 passed in O.P'No 4 of 1998 by the leal'ned Senior Civil \ Judgq at Karimnagar No costs 9 A(S,] & €TD,J I Miscellan eous Petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed. //TRUE COPYII To, i jiffi #ffisr#JJillHdi?:rs r anv, .'"?#?EBil!*t*. SECTION OFF,CER ADK/gh w HIGH COURT DATED:1 3tL?,l202s SiAI€ o L, iii5t? r$6 O * s PA:T coMMON JUDGMENT+DECREE AS.No.3739 of 2003 AND i-be.recrloNs (sR) No'3391 of 2oog 2 DRAFTS DISMISSING THE APPEAL SUITAND I:oEtJ Ecirb r.rs wlrHo ur cosrs

6.fe &--' IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THURSDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ABH]NAND KUMAR SHAVIL.I AND THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA APPEAL SUIT. No.3739 of 2003 AND X-OBJECTIO NS(SR) No.3391 of 2009 APPEAL SUIT.No. 3739 of 2003 Between: Karimnagar. 'l rhe special Deoutv coilector/, Land Acquisition offiber L.A.Unit, s.c.Rairway, , Raitway rep by its Generat Manger, Raitnitayam, JjSr;!:$roCentrat 2nd^Appe ant is impreaded .as per the Hon,bre court order dated 16t06t2014 made in lSrritp.tto.+ei & iOi'- " ...Appellants/Referring Officer AND

1. Vemula Satyanarayana S/o Arlallaiah

2. Md. Maksood Ali S/o Mohammed Ali 3. Gaddam Rajaiah Sio Chandraiah 4, Kamarapu Nirmala Devi Wo Veera Bhadraiah 5, Busireddi Jayaram Reddy S/o Narsimha Reddy 6. Madishetty Satyanarayana S/o Vemaiah

7. Polasa Sharada Wo Kondaiah

8. Chethi Rajeshwar Rao S/o Ramaiah 9. Komroju Manjula Wo Rajaram

10. Ganapathi Bharathi Wo Laxminarayana 1 'l . Chinthakindi Laxmi Wo Mallesham l2.Thangallapalli Satyanarayana S/o Ramaswamy 't 3. Meherunnisa Begum Wo Mohammed Rafi 14. Marni Lenora Wo Satheesh Babu 15. Safara Durgappa S/o Nagender Rao l6.Bhoomadi Ram Reddy S/o Malla Reddy lT.Thogati Narayana S/o Brahmaiah

18. K.sudhakar Rao S/o Raiesham 't9. Puram Venkatanarsaiah S/o Lachaiah 20.Cheruku Venkat Raji Reddy S/o Ram Reddy 21. Nethetla Ramesh Yadav S/o Raiaiah

22. Dr.D.Anand Rao, S/o Ram Kistaiah 23.Dr.Baddam Venkat Ranga Reddy S/o Hanmanth Reddy 24. Suddala SwamY S/o NaraYana

25. Dr.S.Athyutha Kumar S/o Kistaiah

26. Md. Ameenuddin S/o Jamaluddin 27.Mohd. Abdul Salam S/o M A Khader

28.A.Ram ReddY S/o Malla ReddY 29. Dr.G. Shankar Reddy S/o Laxma Reddy 30. Syed Habeebullah S/o Syed Rahmathullah 3'1. Dr.M.A.Aziz S/o M A Khader 32. Shaik Zaheer Ahmed S/o Shaik Ahmed 33.Syed Naimathullah Hussaini S/o Ahmed Hussaini 34. Gunda Seenaiah S/o Veeraiah

35. G. Bhoomaiah S7o Lachaiah l

36. Dr.Md. Saleemuddin S/o Mcl. Azeemuddin

37. Bathula Rajaveeru, S/o Venkataiah

38. Dr.Abdul Rakeeb Ahmed S/o M.A. Wahee 39. R.Sanjeeva Kumar S/o Mallaiah

40. Md. Abdul Rahman S/o Mohd. Miran 4'1. Mohd. Mahmood Ali S/o Md Yakub Ati

42. Swargam Mallesham S/o Ramchandram

43. P.Prabhakar S/o Nagaiah

44. Vemula Sathamma Wo Satyanarayana

45. Md. Kursheed Ahmed S/o Shaik Ahmed

46. Kamatam Venkatesham S/o Mallesham

47. Bollam Narayan Reddy S/o Ram Reddy

48. Lingam Ramchandra Reddy S/o Aga Reddy

49. Syed Khamruddin S/o Syed Sharfuddin

50. Bedarsakota Nomraj S/o Ramaswamy

51. Khaja Moinuddin Khan S/o Gulam Dastagir Khan

52. Sana Prasad Ramulu S/o Dharmaiah

53. Madupu Kistamma Wo Prathap Reddy

54. Md.Raiazuddin S/o Abdul Kareem

55. Miryala Bhoopathi Rao S/o Venkatrao

56. Mohd. Younus S/o lsmail

57.Anugu Mallesham S/o Vengaiah

58.Mohd. Abdul Ghani S/o Abdul Rasool

59.Dr.Jan Mohd. Khan S/o Gulkhan

60. Nallagonda Bakkaiah S/o Narsiah 6't.Abdul Fazal Mohd. Fazalullah S/o Mohd. Khateelultah

62. Pothuri Parsharam S/o Venkataiah

63. Ganta Chandraiah S/o Venkataiah

64. Gone Vinod ReddY S/o Ramaiah

65. Gangili Karunandam S/o Gangaram

66.Dr.B.Jagan Mohan Reddy S/o Anantha Reddy

67. President, B.C.H.B. Society, Karimnagar'

68. Boinpalli Raghupathi Rao S/o Thirupathi Rao

69. Bairi Shyamsunder S/o Sanjeevarao

70. Gujarathi Raieshwar S/o Balasa

71. K. Adi ReddY S/o Dammaiah

72. Cheeti Satyanarayana S/o Ramchander Rao

73.Dr.M.A.Raheem Akthar S/o M.A. Rahman

74.Dr. Khaia Moinuddin S/o Shaik Mohiuddin T5.Velupula Prabhakar Rao S/o Rangaiah T6.Vukanti Bhaskar Reddy S/o Mukunda Reddy TT.Vutukuri Narsimha Reddy S/o Kista Reddy

78. Shaik Baqur Hussain S/o Shaik Ahmed Hussain

79.Akula Rajaiah S/o Lalaiah B0.Vennamneni Thirupathi Rao S/o Raieshwar Rao Sl.Vukanti Laxma Reddy S/o Venkat Reddy

82. Devulapalli Bhajarangabali S/o Narsaiah

83. Kurmachalam Srinivas S/o Ramaiah

84. Syed Samiullah S/o Habeeb

85.Sagi Sanjeeva Rao S/o Thirupathi Rao

86. Kumari Anila D/o Ganga ReddY ST.Vengala Ramakistaiah S/o Narayana

88. Boinpalli Prakash Rao S/o Kondal Rao

89. Mohd. Abdul Subhani S/o M.A.Ghani

90. Kandukuri Kumaraswamy S/o Muthilingam

91. Rathan Kishan S/o Narsingam

92. Sangam Rajasekhar S/o Rajamouli

93. Bommagani Bheemaiah S/o Chandraiah

94. Dr.G.Ganga Reddy S/o Rajeshwar Reddy

95. Dommati Komaraiah S/o Narsaiah

96. Dr.S. Mahmood Ali S/o Syed lmam

97. Penchala Jaggaiah S/o Kistaiah

98. Yedla Rajeshwar Rao S/o Veeraiah

99. S.Laxman Rao, S/d Mahoev

100. Balakishan Mundada S/o Srikishan Mundada

101. Kanaparthi Narsinga Rao S/o Narayana

102. Palha Anjaiah S/o Hanumaiah

103. Renukunta Vish|vanatham S/o Laxmirajam .

104. Patha Kishah S/o Hanumaiah

105. Gampa Hanumaiah S/o Buchaiah ...Respondents/claimants / X-OBJECTI ONS (SRl No.3391 of 2009

1. Vemula Satyanarayana, S/o Mallaiah, aged about 54 years, Rio H No. 1-5- 416, Laxminagar, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

2. Md. Maksood Ali, S/o Mahammed Ali, aged about 49 years, R/o H.No 1B-44' 4th Class Employees Colony, Huzurabad, Karimnagar District.

3. Gaddam Rajaiah, S/o Chandraiah, 'aged about 45 years, R/o Basanthnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District.

4. Kamarapu Nirmala Devi, Wo Veera Bhadraiah, aged about 35 y'ears, R/o H.No.7-5-99/2, Godavarikhani, Karimnagar District.

5. Busireddi jayarama Reddy, S/o Narasimha Reddy, aged about 50 years' R/o Basanthnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District. 6- Madishetty Satyanrayana, S/o Vemaiah, aged about 53 years, R/o H,No- 4-5- 125, Subashnagar, Peddapalli, Karimnagar District.

7. Polasa Sharada, Wo Kondaiah, aged about 34 years, R/o H.No. C'1i50' Basanthnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District. L Chethi Rajeshwar Rao, S/o Ramaiah, aged about 52 years, R/o Kesoram Cements, Basanathnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District.

9. Komroju Manjula, Wo Rajaram, aged about 39 years, R/o Kesoram Cements, Basanathnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District. '10. Ganapathi Bharath, Wo Laxminarayana, aged about 37 years, R/o L-79, Kesoram Cements, Basanathnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District. ll.Chinthakindi Laxmi, Wo Mallesham, aged about 34 years, R/o H.No.9-45, Ganeshnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District.

12. Thangallapalli Satyanaryana, S/o Rama Swamy, aged about 34 years, R/o H.No. 7-1492, Mankammathota, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District. l3.Meherunnisq Begum, Wo Mohammed Rafi, aged about 40 years, R/o H.No. D1/95, Staff Colony, Basanthnagar, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District. '14. Marni Lenora, Wo Satheesh Babu, aged about 40 years, Rl/o.H-No. C143, Basanthnagar, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

15.Safare Durgappa, S/o Nagender Rao, aged about 44 years, R/o Kesoram Cements, Basanthnagar, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District. 'l6.Bhoomadi Ram Redrtv,'S/o Malla Red.dy, aged about 49 years, R/o Kesoram Cements, BasanthnagLr, Kanmnagar, Karimnagar District, lT.Thogati Narayan, S/o Brahmaiah, aged about 45 years, nfo H.No. 7_1492, Mankammathota, Karimnagar, '18. Puram Venkatanarsaia! :r" Rami Reddy, aged about 47 years, R/o Choppadandi, Karimnagar District. - -, ' *., l9.Cheruku Venkat Raii Reddy, S/o Ram Reddy, aged aboput 39 years, R/o.H.No. 1 -2-1 46, peoorpalri'xJr;ffi; r]#H ",*ll""t:iiil1;:,*o* s/o Rajaiah, ased bout 3'r vears, R:/o pediapaili, 2l.Dr. D.Ananad Rao, S/o Ram Kistaiah, aged about 61 years, R/o Utnoor, Adilabad District

22.Dr. Baddam Venkat Ranoa ngldy, S/o Hanmanth Reddy, aged about 5g rs, R/o Armoor, Nizamibad District. Santhoshnagar, Karimnagai, rcriirrrg"i di.tri"i

23.suddara swamy, s/o Narayana, aged about 4s years, R/o H.No. .10_1430, * Siri*fff#n1rfffI"" Kistaiah' ased about 60 vears, R/o A.H.Depot, 25.Md. Abdul Salam, S/o Jamaluddin, aged about 59 years, R/o Shah Saheb Street, Karimnagar, Karimnaga, Oi.iri"[-- --""'

26.Mohd. Absul Salam, S/o l\I.A.Khader, aged about 63 years, R/o H.No. 3_3_ 1 95, Sawa ra n Street, Karim naga r, f arirn ;, grri oisirtct

27. A.Ram Reddy, S/o Malla Reddy, aged about 48 years, R/o Godiselpet, ^^ Ytlg{gor. Mandal, Karimnagar District] 28.Dr.G.Shankar Reddv., S/o: Laxma-Reddy, aged about 34 years, R/o Gaddapaka, Veenavinka Mandal, k"rir""gii Dtir"t .

29. Syed Habeebullah, S/o. Syed Rahmathullah, aged about 56 years, J.D., .'-- -"-"' sv A.H.Depot, Shantinagar, UyOeraOaj.

30.Dr. M.A.Aziz, S/o M.A.Khade-r,.aged about 60 years, R/o H.no;3_3_147, Sawa ra n Street, Ka rim na gar, Xa rim"n"!"i;;i;;,

31. Shaik Zaheer Ahmed. S/o Shaik4hmed, aged about 62 years, R/o H. No. 3_1_ 51212, Vavilalapalli, Karimnagar District. "

32.Syed Naimathullah Hussaini,.S/o Ahmed Hussaini, aged about 61 years, R/o H.N o. 1 2-2-822t7 t2, Ay ody a r,r, gr r, iyJ.rr;"i." " "' j

33. Gunda Seenaiah, S/o Veeraiah, aged about 61 years, H.No. 94-21' Sringarcolony, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

34. G.Bhoomhaiah, S/o Lachaiah, aged about 34 years, H.No. 9-4-21, Srinagar Colony, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

35. Dr. Md.saleemuddin, S/o Md. Azeemuddin, aged about 45 years, R/o H.No. 3-3-99, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

36.Bathuta Rajaveeru, S/o Venkataiah, aged about 51 years, H,No. 9-45, Ganeshnagar, Karimangar, Karimnagar District.

37. Dr. Abdul Rakeeb Ahmed, S/o M.A. Waheed, aged about 63 years, R/o. H.No. 3-3-58, Karimanagar.

38. R.Sanjeeva Kumar, S/o Mallaiah, aged about 43 years, R/o H.No. 94-2 1, Srinagarcolony, Karimangar, Karimnagar District.

39.Md. Abdul Rahman, S/o Mohd. Miran, aged about 47 years, R/o. H.no. 16-16- 17 8l 179, Usmanpura, Hyderabad.

40.Mohd. Mahmood Ali, S/o Md. Yakub Ali, aged about 48 years, R/o H.No. 1-2- 51, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

41. Swargam Mallesham, S/o Ramachandram, aged about 48 years, R/o H.No. 3- 1-655, Karimangar, Karimnagar District.

42.P.Prabhakar, S/o Nagaiah, aged about 49 years, R/o H.No. 1-3-7, R/o Old Bazar, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

43.Vemula Sathamma, S/o Satyanarayana, aged about 48 years, Rio H.No. 1-5- 416, Laxminagar, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

44.Md.Kursheed Ahmedn, S/o Shaik Ahmed, aged about 49 years, R/o H.No. 3- 3-195, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

45. Kamatam Venkatesham, S/o Mallesham, aged about48 years, R/o H.No. 3-1- 658, R/o Karimnagar, Karimnagar District,

46.Bollam Naryan Reddy, S/o Ram Reedy, aged about 57 years, R/o Mallapur, V/o Boinapalli Mandal, Karimnagar District.

47.Lingam Ramchandra Reddy, S/o Aga Reddy, aged about 58 years, V.A.S., Animal Husbandry Depot, Goddavarikhani, Karimnagar District.

48. Syed Khamruddin, S/o Syed Sharfuddin, aged about 57 years, D.M, J.D., Animal Husbandry Depot, Karimnagar.

49. Bedarakota Nomraj, S/o Ramaswamy, aged about 46 years, V.A. D-D., Animal Husbandry, Karimangar. j

50.Khaja Moinuddin Khan, S/o gulamDastagir Khan, aged about 5g years, H.No. 6-6-77, Karimangar.

51.sana Prasad Ramulu, s/o Dhaarmaiah, aged about 61 years, Rr/o Thotappalli Village, Bejjanki Mandal, Karimnagar District.

52.Madupu Kistamma, Wo Prathap Reddy, aged about 53 years, R/o H.No 2_ '10-1530. Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

53.. Md. Raiazuddin, S/o Abdul Kareem, aged about 59 years, D.D., A.H., Depot, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

54. Miryala Bhoopathi Rao, S/o Venkatrao, aged about 39 years, Rl/o_ R.Jalpathi Rao, V.A., O/o D.D., A.H.Depot, Karimnagar.

55. Modh. Younus, S/o lsamail, aged about 35 years, R/o V.D.O., A.D., A. H.Dept, Karimnagar.

56.Anugu Mallesham, S/o Venkgaiah, aged about 54 years, J_V.O. A.D. A.H, Dept, Karimnagar.

57. Mohd. Abdul Ghani, S/o Abdul Rasool, aged bout 49 years, V.A., Oio A.D., A.H. Dept, Peddapalli, Karimnagar District. SB.Dr Jan Mohd. Khan, Slo Gulkhan, aged about 60 years, H,No. 3_5_95, Azmathpura, Peddapalli, Karimnagar.

59. Nallagonda Bakkaiah, S/o Narsaiah, aged about 58 years, R/o H.No. 9_3_67, Siricilla, Karimnagar District.

60.Abdul Fazal Mohd. Fazalullah, S/o Mohd. Khaleelullah, aged about 59 years, R:/o H.No. 5-3-77 Karimnagar.

61. Pothuri Parsharam, S/o Venkataiah, aged about 43 years, V.A., O/o A.D., A.H.Dept, Kar.imangar.

62. Ganta Chandraiah, S/o Venkataiah, aged about 46 years, H.No. 104-95, Karimangar.

63.Goine Vinod Reddy, S/o Ramaiah, aged about 5g years, Sr_ Assistant, O/o J.D., A.H-Dept., Karimnagar..

64.Gangili Karunandam, S/o Gangaram, aged about 5g years, H.No. 6-g_10g, Jagtial, Karimnagar Diskict. 65 !r, !.Jagan Mohan Reddy, S/o Anantha Reddy, aged about 45 yeas, H.No 3-6-590, Plot No. 302, ll Floor, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad.

66. President, B.C.H.B. Society, Karimnagar. 6T.Bioipalli Raghupathi Rao, S/o Thirupathi Rao, aged bout 63 years, R/o H.No 2-10-212, Jyothinagar, Karimnagar.

68.Bairi Shyamsunder, S/o Sanjeevarao, aged aboul 24 years, H.No. 7-1-352, Mankammathota, Karimnagar.

69.Gujarathi Rajeshwar, S/o Balasa, aged about 43 years, Sr. Asst., O/o J.D., A.H. Dept., Adilabad, Adilabad District.

70.K. Adi Reddy, S/o Dammaiah, aged about 51 years, R/o H.No.5-6-3156/4, Kpuwada, Karimnagar.

71.Cheeti Satyanarayana Rao, S/o Ramchaader Rao, aged about 61 years, R/o H.No. 2-8-130/4, Mukarampura, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

72.Dr. M.A. Raheem Aktha, S/o M.A. Rahman, aged about 47 yeas, R:/o H.No. 2-7 -504, Mukarampura, Karimnagar.

73. Dr. Khaja Moinuddin, S/o Shaik Mohuddin, aged about 47 years, R/o H.No. 2- 7-397, Kukarampura, Karimnagar. T4.Velupula Prabhakar Rao, S/o Rangaiah, aged about 49 years, R/o H.No. 7 12412, Employees Colony, Jammikunta, T5.Vukanti Bhaskar Reddy, S/o Kukunda Reddy, aged about 61 years, R/o H.No 7 -2-665, Mankammathota, Karimnagar. T6.Vutukuri Narsimha Reddy, S/o Kista Reddy, aged about 48 years, VAS., A.H., Dept., Kodimial, Karimnagar District.

77.Shaik Baqur Hussain, S/o Shaik Ahmed Hussain, aged about 64 years, R/o H.No. 11-3-662, New Malkapalli, Hyderabad.

78.Akula Rajaiah, S/o Lalaiah, aged about 51 years, Rl/o V.H. Mulugu, Warangal. T9.Vennamneni Thirupathi Rao, S/o Rajeshwar Rao, aged about 58 years, J.V.O., A.H.Dept., Karimnagar.

80.Vukanti Laxam Reddy, S/o Venkat Reddy, aged bout 57 years, J.V.O., A.H., Dept., Karimnagar,,

81. Devulapalli Bhajarangabali, S/o Nrasaiah, aged about 51 years, Rl/o H.No. 1 5-45, Karimangar. S2.Kurmachalam Srinivas, S/o Ramaiah, aged about 55 years, R:/o H.No 74- 222, Yidy anagar, Jag ityal, Kari m nagar D istrict.

83. Syed Samiullah, S/o Habeeb, aged about 55 years, Rl,/o Live Stock Asst., Veldurthi, Jagtial, Karimnagar District. I /

84.Sagi Sanjeeva Rao, S/o Thirupathi Rao, aged about 62 years, R/o H.No. 10- 3-360, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.

85. Kumari Anila, D/o Ganga Reddy, aged about 31 years, R/o H.No. 2_.12_ 1036/4, Jyothinagar, Karimnagar.

86. Vengala Ramkakistaiah, S/o Narayana, aged about 59 years, RUo H.No. B-4_ 108/3, Sardarnagar, Siricilla, Karimnagar District.

87. Boinpalli Prakash Rao, S/o Kondal Rao, aged about 61 years, H.No. 2_g-i 61 , Karimangar_

88. ltilohd- Abdul Subhani, S/o M.A.Ghani, aged about 45 years, V.A., Veterniary S9,Kandukuri Kumaraswamy, S/o Muthilingam, aged about 46 years, R/o H.no. Hospital, Huzurabad. Karimnagar District. 7/46, Husnabad.

90. Rathan Kishan, S/o Narsingam, aged about 35 years, R/o H.No. 5_6_86 Kapuwada, Karimnagar District.

91.Sangam Rajashekar, S/o Rajamouli, aged about 47 yea$, H.No. 9-1_.135/2, Bhagathnagar, Karimnagar.

92.Bommagani Bheemaiah, S/o Chandraiah, aged about 56 years, H.No_ 6_26, Choppadandi, Karimangai.

93.Dr.G.Ganga Reddy, S/o Rajeshwar Reddy, Aged about 62 years, R/o H.No. 2- 1 0-1 0361 A, Jyothinagar, Karimnagar.

94. Dommati Komaraiah, S/o Veeraiah, aged about 53 years, H.No. 5442, Kapuwada, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District. 95- Penchala Jaggaiah, S/o Kistaiah, aged about 62 years, R/o Nagnoor, Karimnagar.

96. Yedla Rajeshwar Rao, S/o Veeraiah, aged about 60 years, H.No.7_2_388, Mankammathota, Karimnagar

97. S.Laxman Rao, S/o Mahdev, aged about 60 years, MpDO, Manthani, Karimnagar District. 98'Balakishan Mundada, s/o Narayana, aged about srikishan Mundada, Karimnagar.

99. Kanaparthi narsinga Rao, S/o Narayana, aged about Sg years, H.No,2_10_ 241 , Jyothinagar, Karimnagar. -100 .PathaAnjaiah, s/o Hanumaiah aged about 4g years, Hearth rnspector, Gollapalli (V & M), Karimnagar. l. 101 . Renukunta Vishwanatham, s/o Laxmirajyam, aged about 54 years' R/o Karimnagar. .t02. patha Kishan, S/o Hanumaiah, aged about 42 yearc, Gollapalli (v) & (M), Karimnagar District.

103. Gampa Hanumaiah, S/o Buchaiah, aged about 44 years' Gollapalli (V) & (M). Karimnagar District. All are resident of Arepally village of Karimnagar Mandal & District' ..Cross Objectors/ResPondents AND The Special Deputy Collector/' Land Acquisition Officer L A Unit' S'C'Railway' New B.G.Line Karimnagar. ... RespondenUAPPellant Aooealundersection54ofLandAcquisitionActandMemorandumofCross ouiectiol'sJiieo inoei oioe, +1 Rule 22 of bPC against the Judgment and Decree 5;ffi''il_t62ooi rnio" , o p.No.4 0f .1998 0n the fite of the court of the senior Civil Judge, Karimnagar. This appeal and Cross Objections coming on for hearing and upon perusing thegroundsofappealandCrossobjectionstheJudgmentandDecreeofthe Tribunal and the material papers in the suit and upon hearing the arguments of smt' T Suhasini, Advocate for the Appellants in Appeal suit and for Respondents in Cross-objectionsandSriVRAvula'AdvocatefortheRespondentinAppealSuit and Cross Objector in Cross Objections. This Court doth Order and Decree as follows: .1. That the appeal and the X-objections filed by the claimants are dismissed ,upholdingtheorderanddecreedatedl3.06.2003passedino.P.No.4ofl998 by the learned Senior Civil Judge at Karimnagar ; 2. That there shall be no order as to costs in this appeal' /ITRUE COPY// i SD/- MOHD. ISMAIL EPUTY REGISTRAR SECTION OFFICER \D \' To,

1. The Senior Civil Judge, Karimnagar 2. Two CD Copies rft- HIGH COURT DATED:1 310212025 DECREE AS.No.3739 of 2003 AND X-OBJECTIONS (SR) No.3391 of 2009 DISMISSING THE APPEAL SUIT AND X.OE.'ECTIONS WITHOUT COSTS u .4"b &"