High Court · 2025

s.srichand s/o Kevula, "U"*l*f iyears, secondary Grade- Teacher, Govt,D.N.T., U.P:School, Ankole Thanda, Kamareddy Dist. T.Padmaja Rani, D/o.Narayana, Age: 50 years, SGf, MPPS - Peddamallareddi, Biknur Mdl, Kamareddy dist. B.Geethanjali D/o Kishan, aged about 54 years, Secondary Grade Teacher, M.P.P.School, Kotha Armoor, Nizamabad Dist. Y.l.V Subbamma, D/o.Kurangapani, Age 49 years, SGT, I4PPS- Mallapalli Cfhanda), Biknur Mdl, Kamareddy dist. N.Srinaiah S/o Parandamulu, aged about 42 years, S.G.T., \ N1.P.P.School, Makkapally, Gurrampode mandal, Nalgonda Dist, D.Rajababu S/o Durgaiah, aged about 49 years, S.G.T., 14.P.P.S., Kashavarigudem, Thipparthy mandal, Nalgonda Dist. \-- Syed Rawoofuddin S/o Yousul aqed about 44 years, S.G.T., M.P.P.S. Garakunbpalem, Madgulapally mandal, Nalgonda Dist. Bhupathi Sing S/o Bachan Singh, aged about 49 years, S.G T., M.P.P.School, Gucha Tanda, Mahabubnagar Dist. / Dr.Ch.Gayathri Devi D/o Dr.Ch.Chandraiah, aged about 46 years, S.G.Teacher, Govt, Primary School, Yerravally, 14ahabubnagar Dist. (Urban) G.Krishnaiah S/o Narayana, aged about 52 years, S.G.Teacher, M.P.P.School, Gubbaiagudem Tanda, Mahabubnagar Dist. Saraswathi Bai D/o Ambajirao, aged about 55 years, S.G.Teacher, - M.P.P.School, Kothamolgara, Mahabubnagar Dist. P.Surya Kumari D/o P.L.Sarma, aged about 51 years, S.G,Teacher, M.P.P.School, 'l'ippapur, Kamareddy Dist. / D.Balaswamy S/o Sunkalaiah, aged about 49 years, S.G.Teacher, Ivl.P.P.School, Gunthatanda, Wanaparthy Dist. M.A.Akbar Pasha S/o M.A. Kareem Saheb, aged about 47 vears, S-G.T., M.P.P.S. Kodukuntla, Wanaparthy mandal, Wanaparthv D st. l.Ravi Raju S/o l.Yellaiah, aged about 46 years, S.G T, M.P.P.School; Kasnathanda, Wanaparthy mandal, Wanaparthv Drst. K.Niranjan S/o K.Narsimha, aged about 49 years, S G.T, I\'l.P.P S. Chinthakunta, Pangal mandal, Wanaparthy Dist. B.Srikanth S/o Buchanna, aged about 48 years, S.G.T., t'l P P.S. P.C. Raghavendranagar. Wanaparthy, Wanaparhty Dist. G.Prasad S/o Ramulu, aged about 48 years, S.G.Teacher, M.P.P.School, S.J.Colony, Pembetla, lagitval Dist, ./ i.1! ! ! l 1- -2- M.Shalaiah S/o Iayyanaa, aged about 54 yea$, S.G.Teaher, M.P,P.School, Yelluru, Nagarkurnool Dist. Suresh Kilari, S/o.Ramana Kilari, Age: 47 years, SGT, MPU Gudem Vill, Kamareddy Mdl. Kamareddy dist. Lrppari Raju, S/o.Limbaiah, Agei 42 YeaB, SGT, MPUPS Gudem Vill, lGmareddy Mdl, Kamareddy dist. ,/ Khuri Venkanna, S/o.Sayanna, Age: 49 years, SGT, MPUPS Gudem Vill, Kamareddy Mdl, Kamareddy dist. Vazir Ramesh, S/o.Hanamanth Rao, Age: 49 years, SGT, MPPS Brahmanpalli Vill, TMwai Mdl, Kamareddy dist. G. Gangamani, D/o.Erroji, Age: 43 years, SGT, at MPPS Ealaji NagEr Thanda, Yellareddy Mdl, Kamareddy dist.

36. '71

39. Syed Abdul Quadeer, S/o.Syed lainudden, Age: 41 years, SGT, MPPS Rajamma Thanda Vill, Ramareddy Mdl, Kamareddy dist.

40. K.Sujatha D/o Gangaram, aged about 52 years, S.G.T., M.P'P.S. Kalladi, Makloor mandal, Nizamabad Dist. /

41. G.Suresh Reddy S/o lagan Reddy, aged about 41 years, S.G.T., M.P.P.S, Madanapalli, S.C. wada, l"lakloor mandal, Nizamabad Dist'

42. P.Karuna Devi D/O Venkateasham, aged about 46 Years, S.G.T, G.P.S branch, Seetarampet, Nampally, Hyderabad. .,

43. ' R.Anitha D/o Srinivas Rao, aged about 49 years, S.G.T, . G P S, Sultan Bazar, Nampally, Hyderabad.

44. T.Veeranna S/o Venkatiah, aged about 55 years, 5.G.7 G P S, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad.

45. T.Rajani D/o Venkatramulu, aged about 45 years, S.G T, M,P.P.S, Ibrahimnagar, Md Gollapally, Dist lagitial.

46. Laxman Rao S/o Sreedhar Rao, aged about 48 Years, 5.G.T, .,. M.P.P.S, Gurur, Dist lanagaon.

47. K.Dayamani D/o Komuraiah, aged about 48 years, S.G.T, M.P.P.S, Karimnagar. 48 49 K.Rajashekar S/o Narayana, aged about 49 years, S G.T, M.P.P.S, W Nagar, Dist Medchal. V.Srilatha D/o Ramanaish, aqed about 50 years. S.G.T, M.P.U.P.S, Katanapalli, Dist Peddapaliy. 6 50 51 G.Rajesham S/o Nagashem, aged about 49 Years, S.G.T I\4.P. P.5, Chekkapa{ly, Dist Rajanna Sircilla. G.venkateshwarlu S/o Purushotam Rao, aged about 55 Years, S.G.T l'4.P.P.S, lameelapet, Dist Yadadribhongiri.

52. U.Surender Reddy S/o Venkat Reddy, aged about 50 Years, S.G.T. M.P.P.S, Gandhi Nagar Tanda, Dist Yadadribhongiri. 53 V.Ramadevi D/o Veera Reddy, aged about 50 Years, S.G.T M.P.P.S, Chintakunta, Dist Karimnagar. ..Petitioners And 01 02 03 04 05 06 a7 08 09 10 11 t-2 13 i1 15 16 The District Educational Officer, Nizamaad Dist.- The District Educational Officer, Kamareddy Dist. - The District Educational Officer, Suryapet district._ The District Educational OfFicer, Nalgonda Dist. .- The District Educational Officer, Mahabubnagar Dist. _ The District Educational Officer, Wanaparthy Dist- - The District Educational Officer, Jagityal Dist. The District Educational Officer, Nagarkurnool Dist. _ The District Educational omcer, t{izama$ist. ,- The District Educational Omcer, f#mnagar Dist - The District Educational Officer, Rajanna Sircilla Dist. -- The District Education Ofncer, Peddapally Dist. ,.' The District Educational Offcer, Janaga0n Dist. The District Educational Omcer, Yadadrib;oangiri Dist. -- The District Educational Officer, Medchal Dist. -,- The District Educational Officer, Hyderabad Dist. 1

17.The commissioner and Director of school Education, Govt. of Telangana, at f S. T6e-State of Telangana, rep., by its Prin6pal Secretary, School Education Hyderabad. Dept., Secretariat, HYderabad. / ...RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased to issue a writ order or order more in the nature of writ of Mandamus declare the impugned ac{ion of the respondents herein in not considering petitioners claim for promotion to the post of School Assistant (Language) which are existing as on 04-02-2021 by applying the principle of Y.V.Rangaiahs case, existed prior to the amended rules of Education subordinate Service Rules for the posts in Mandal parishad aM Zilla Parishad and Government Schools issu6d in G.O.Ms.No. 2 and 3 dt.o5.02.2021 though it is prospective effect and not filling the said vacancies as per Rules issued in G.o.Ms.No. 11 and 12 dt.23-01-2009 by combined seniority lists of s.G.Ts/Language Pandits as per the ratio law laid downbyApexCourtinY.V'Rangaiahandothers(1983(3SCC284andthis Hon,bleCourtjudgmentinW.P.No.232SSt2olTandbatchisillegal,UnjUStand unwarranted and consequently declare that the petitioners are entitled to be promoted as School Assistant (LangUages/Physical Educalion) as per pre- amended rules with all consequential benefits. z' lA NO: 1 OF 2021 Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to directtherespondentstoconsiderthecasesofthepetitionersforpromotlonaS School Assistants ( Languages/Physical Education) as per pre-amended rules in terms of the ratio laid down in Y.V.Rangaiahs case without reference to the G.O.Ms.No.2and3dt.05-O2.2O2lintheensuingcounselingpendingdisposalof the above writ petition. "' i lA NO: 2 oF 2021 Between: 1 The District Educational Officer, Nizamaad Dist. 2 The District Educational Officer, Ka mareddy Dist. 3 The District EducaUonal Offjcer, S u ryapet d istrict. 4 The District Educational OfFicer, Na lgon da Dist. 5 The District Educational Officer, Ivl aha bu bnaga r Dist. 6 The District Educationat OfFicer, / Wa na pa rthy Dist. 7 The District Educational Officer, lagityal Dist. 8 The District Educational Officer, Nagarkurnool Dist, 9 The District Educational Officer, Nrzamabad Dist. 10 The Drstrict Educational Officer, Kd rim na gar Dist. 11 The D strict Educational Otficer, Ralanna S ircilla Dist. 12 The District Education Officer, Peddaoally Dist. / 13 The Drstrict Educattonal Officer, Ianagaon Dist. 14 The District Educational Officer, Yadad-ibhoangiri Drst. l5 Tt-e Drstnct Educatronal Officer, lvlcCc 5a I D ist. 16 The District Educational Officer, Hyderabad Dist. 17 The Commissioner and Director of School Education Govt ot Telangana, at Hyderabad 18 The State of Telangana, rep by its principal Secretary, School Education Dept Secretariat, Hydera ba d Respondents /petitioners ND CD t lri'n'lirnu,un, ased about 42vear.' s G r',ZPH school ii"rr."ir. M villaqe and mandal' Nizamabad Dist 2 B Devula ' ill eiut.u, aged about45 vears' s GT' M? P s '-:H;;;, ;'i';ee and maftdal' Kamareddv Dist -t Ch Ramesh ' U"Tr"ti"nn, aged about 41 year-s' sGT' M P P s 4 M Ravinder - 6l""ooi vurii tqancat, t'li'amabad Dist sl"!nu"["., aged about 40 years'-S G T' M P P s il;;;;6,;' inanca, Nizamabad Dist I viiavkumar iio eanoutag, aged about 40 Yea ili.n"., u P i' stnoot, Nayabadi' I Vittal .^-*r.i. aqed about 49 Years, S vaini uanolt, Nizamabad Dist GT, P S lalalpur rs, Secondary Grade Nizamabad Dist 5 6 7 B Kavitha D/o Babunaik, (Telugu) F'l P U aoed about 39 years, Language Pandit -diinoor, Ambam, Nizamabad Dist 8 T Govardhan " s; ,i;;;;.urthv, ased about 55 vears' second?rv i;;;n";, u'P s;hoor' Jamlam' Nizamabad Dist o ( crin ivas ReddY ' il""'H."r.u.eddy, aged about 56 years' ;;; ;'"".;;;;; e;;u'i"u-'n"'' PrimarY schoor'. . . i"rr.".rl, i,wapet MaMal' Suryapet district . 10 Sha heda Begum '" ol" s n aazlk, aged about 50 Years' 11 Annabemoju Sharada " ;L:;;.;;e,;eieacner'zPHishs,.hoor' . -- iil""r-ri" Icn"vu mula Mandal' suryapet District / olo rluqnubnushanm, aged about 53 years' Il,I""oZ., c'"oe Teacher' M PU P School - ' 3'."rI"*riJ p"irv, Nakrekal Mandal' Nalgonda Dist '- 12 L LakYa ilo cinYu, aged about 40 vears' i'".,r-"J"?r'c-oe Teacher' u P School' sc wada eans*uoj, KamareddY Dist 13 I Ramesh '" iio-:ugurivu naik, aged about 35 years' iliolii.v ctuoe Teacher' Govt u P school' Ankole, KamareddY Dist 14 T Rajeswar ' slo 6ninnagangaram' aged about 47 Year's' ;i".;;;;;e;e reacn6r' M P u P schoor' NagePUr, Nizamad Dist 15 S Sricha nd S/o Kevula, aged about 4/ Yea$' S9c9n1?rv g:ade i;;:,;;;;;-D N r u P schoor' Ankore rhanda KamareddY Dist I i I l l ,l l 1 I I I I ( 16 T Padmaja Rani D,/o Narayana, Age 50 years, SGT, MPPS Pedda rna llareddi, Biknur Mdl, Kamareddy dist 17 B Geethanjali D/o Kishan, aged about 54 years, Secondary Grade Teacher, M P P School, Kotha Armoor, Nizamabad Dist lSYlVSubbamma D/o Kurangapani, Age 49 years, SGT, MPPS Mallapalli Thanda Biknur Mdl, Kamareddy dist 19 N Srinaiah S,/o Parandamulu, aged about 42 years, S G T M P P School, Makkapally, Gurrampode mandal Nalgonda Dist 20 D Rajababu '/' S/o Durgaiah, aged about 49 years, S G T, M P P S, Kashavarigudem, Thipparthy tvlandal, Nalgonda Dist 21 Syed Rawoofuddin S/o Yousuf, aged about 44 years, S G T M P P S, Garakuntapalem, Madgutapally mandal Nalgonda Dist 22 Bh u path i Sing S/o Bachan Singh, aqed about 49 years, S G T M P P Schoot, Gucha Tanda, Mahabubnagar Dist 23 Dr Ch Gayathri Devi /. D/o Dr Ch Chandrarah, aged about 46 years S G Tedcher, Govt Primary School, yerravally l'4a ha bu bn aga r Dist Urban 24 G Krishnaiah S/o Narayana, aged about 52 years, S G Teacher M P P School, cubbaiagudem Tanda, Mahabubnagar Drst 25 Saraswathi Bai D/o Ambajirao, aged about 55 years, S G Teacher |\1 P P School, Kothamolgara, t'.lahabubnagar Dist 26 P Suryd Kumari D/o P L Sarma, aged about 51 years, S G Teacher M P P School, Tippapur, Kamareddy Dist ./ 27 D Balas\,vamy S/o Sunkalaiah, aged about 49 years, S G Teacher M P P School, Gunthatanda, Wanaparthy Dist 23MAAkbarPasha S/o l'{ A Kareem Saheb, aged about 47 years, S G T Iq P P S, Kodukuntla, Wanaparthy !1andal, Wana pa rth y Dist 29 J Ravi Raju S/o I Yellajah, aged about 46 years, S G T lv1 P P School, Kasnathanda, Wanaparthy mandal Wanaparthy Dist 30 K N rra nja n S/c K Narsimha, aged about 49 years, S G T, f4 P P S, Chinthakunta, pangal I\4andal, / WanaParthy Dist 31 B srikanth S/o Buchanna, aged about 48 years, S G T t''i p ps, P C Raghavendra nagar, wanaparthy WanaParhtY Dist 32 G Prasad S/o Ramulu, aqed about 48 years, S G Teacher, t,i p p Scnoot, S I Colony, Pembetia, lagityal Distears -" 33 M Shalaiah s7o liyyanna, aged about 54 years, S G Teacher M P P School, Yelfuru, Nagsrkurnool Dist - 34 Suresh Kilari i/o namana Kilari, Age 47 years, SGT, MPUPS' 6udem Vill., Kamareddy Mdl., Kamareddy dist 35 Uppari Raju - sio Limoilan , Age 42 vears, SGT, MPUPS' dudem Vill, Kamareddy I'4d1, Kamareddy dist / 36 Kthuri Venkanna - - Sio Suyunnu, Age 49 vears, SGT MPUPS, Gudem Vill Kamareddy Mdl, Ka mareddy dist 37 Yaztr Ramesh S/o Hanamanth Rao, Age 49 years, S€T, MPPS Brahmanpalli Vill, Tadwai Mdl, Kamareddy dist 38 G Gangamani o/o frioli, Age 43 vears, SGT at MPPS' Balaji Nagar Tianda, Yetlireddy Mdl, Kamareddy dist 39 Syed Abdul Quadeer -- ifo syeo lainudden, Age 41 years, SGT, MPPS Rajamma Thanda Vill, Ramareddy Mdl, KamareddY dist 40 K Sujathd D/o 6angaram, aged about 52 years, S G T' f"l'p p S,"faf taOi, Makloor Mandal, Nizamabad Dist / 41 G Suresh Reddy - i/o;ugun Reddv, aged about 41 years' SG T'. Fi ; t6, Iladanapalii, s c wada, Makloor mandal Nizamabad Dist 42 P Karuna Devi .- Oio Vent<ateasham, aged about 46 Yea6' S G T' i p S b.un.n, Seetarampet, Nampally' Hyderabad 43 R Anitha D/o Sriniuut Rao, aged about 49 years' S G T' E'p s, srrtun Bazar, Nampally, Hyderabad 44 T Veeran na S/o Venkatrah, aged about 55 years' S G T' G e S,8anjara Hills, HYderabad 45 T Rajani D/o Venkatra mu lu, aged about 45 years, S G T' r',t p p S, IbrahimnagJr Md Gollapally, Dist lagit'tal 46 Laxman Rao S/o Sreedhar Rao, aged about 48 Years, S G T / P P S, Gurur, Dist lanagaon 47 K Dayamani O/o Komuraiah, aged about 4g years, S G T MPPS,Karimnagar 48 K Rajasheka r S/o Narayana, aged about 49 years, S G T, M p p S, VT Nagar, Dist Medchat 49 V Srilatha .- D/o Ramanaish, aged about 50 years, S G T, M P U P 5, Katanapa i, Dist peddapa[y 50 G Rajesham S/o Nagashem, aged about 49 years, S G T M P P S, Chekkapa y, Dist Rajanna Sirci a 51 G Venkateshwarlu S/o Purushotam Rao, aged about 55 years, S G T M P P S, lameelapet, Dist yadadribhongiri 52 LJ Surender Reddy .S1g Yelkgr Reddy, aged about 50 years, S G T, M P P S, Gandhi Nagar Tanda, Dist yadadribhongiri 53 V Ramadevi P_/9 ye-erg Reddy, aged abour 50 years, S G T, M P P S, Chintakunta, Dist Karimnagar / .... petitioners /Respondents Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to vacate the interim order dated 02lOOl2O21 made in t.A No. 1of 2O21 in W.P.No.3843/2021. Counsel for the Petitioners: SRt M.RAMGOPAL RAO Counsel for the Respondents: AGp FOR EDUCATTON FOR ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL The Court made the following: ORDER / i ,j i ; I : i I I I I ., f' B, I I t HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA WRIT E o 43 2 ORDER: a ppearing Heard Sri M.Ramgopal Rao. tearned counsel on behalf of the petitioners and learned Government Pleader representing learned Assistant Additional Advocate General appearing on behalf of the respondents on record' 'i :l I 2 The oetiti oners aDoroach ed the Cou seekino e Draver as follows: "......to issue a Writ order or order more in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declare the impugned action of the respondents herein in not considering petitioners claim for promotion to the post of bchool Assistant (Language) which are existing as on 04.02.2021 bv applying the principle of Y'V' Rangaiah's case, existed prior to the gntend:d rulei of Education Subordinate Service Rules for tne posts in Mandal. parishad and Zilla Parishad and Government Schools issued in G'O'Ms'No' 2 and 3 dt 05.02.2021 though it is prospective effect and not filling the said vacancies as per Rules issued in G.O.l'ts.t'lo 11 and 12 dt 23'01'2009 by combined senrority lists of S'G'Ts/Language Pandits as per the ratio law laid down by Apex Court in Y.V. Rangaiah and others (1983 (3 SCC 284 and this Honble Court judgment in W'P'No' )j,Zezlzott and batch is illegal unjust and unwarranted and consequently declare that the o"tition".t are entitled to be promoted as School inssistant La ng ua ges/Physica I Education) as per I I 2 pre-amended rules with all consequential benefits and pass...,,

3. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners fairly submits that the subject issue in the present Writ petition is squarely covered by the order of Division Bench of this Court dated 15,O3.2024 passed in W.A.Nos.1OZ4, LOLT ot 2023 & 116 of 2fl24 agaanst the petitioners, as confirmed by the Apex Court in SLp No.12782 ol 2O24, dated 14.c,6.2(.24, hence, the present writ petition needs to be dismissed in view of the order of Division Bench of th is Court dated 15.03.2024 passed in W.A.Nos.1OZ4, tOtT of 2O23 & LLG ol 2024.

4. Learned Assistant Government pteader appearang on behalf of the respondents does not dispute the saad submission made by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners.

5. Brining the said submissions of the learned counsel appearing on behatf of the petitioners and learned Assistant Government pleader appearing on ! l :l : l I ! It l SNJ behalf of the respondents on record, the Writ petitaon is dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs, Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand closed. To //TRUE COPY// "rrio';IaiSlHH ECTION OFFICER 1 One CC to SRI M.RAIMG OPAL RAO , Advocate loP 2. Two CCs to ADDL. ADV OCATE GE Telangana , at Hyderabad. [ourl Two CDCoptes NERAL, HighCo urt for the State of

3. PSK. GJP \ 'j-:r '- :i;L HIGH COURT DATED:0710412025 ORDER WP.No.3843 of 2021 -.--rr'1t--:'-'- - -- ./--1,. tt'e i": ',. - ' / 1' SEP 2[25 \$'i DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS b4z .-- /l .,/.?r/4{ t I t t ! t I I t a i II I f5 EI t E ? E n 3i t I ; $ t e f,' I i i ? a . a +t E Ei B