Patna High Court
Case Details
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.8727 of 2013 ====================================================== 1. Shakuntala Devi W/O Ramesh Yadav At Hankarpur, P.S. - Vijayeepur, District - Gopalganj 2. Sunaina Devi W/O Akhilesh Kumar Yadav At Chawamukha, P.S. - Vijayeepur, District - Gopalganj 3. Chanda Devi W/O Omprakash Yadav At R/O - Bhorpurawa, P.O. Bharpurawa, P.S. - Vijayeepur, District - Gopalganj 4. Maya Devi W/O Prakash Pandey At R/O Maheshpur, P.O. Maheshpur, P.S. Vijaipur, Distt. - Gopalganj 5. Rajkumari Devi W/O Heerdya Prasad Verma At R/O - Mushehari Bazar, P.S. Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 6. Manju Devi W/O Rajesh Kumar Verma At R/O Koharwalia, P.S. Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 7. Sangita Verma W/O Sunil Prasad Verma At R/O - Mushehari Bazar, P.S. Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 8. Kiran Devi W/O Jairam Yadav At Sarupai, P.S. Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 9. Premshila Devi W/O Jeetendra Tiwari At Rani Pur, P.S. Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 10. Prabhawati Devi W/O Jaiprakash Yadav At Jagadishpur, P.S. Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 11. Sobha Kushwaha W/O Sanjay Kushwaha At Harpur, P.S. Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 12. Nilu Mishra W/O Chandra Bhushan Mishra At Rasulpur, P.S. - Vijayeepur, District - Gopalganj 13. Binita Devi W/O Dhanjay Mishra At Bangara Bazar, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 14. Kanchan Lata Mishra W/O Sunil Kumar Ishra At Bangra Bazar, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 15. Poonam Devi W/O Atrayanath Tiwari At Kutia, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 16. Durgawati Devi W/O Rama Shankar Prasad Goda At Sabeya, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 17. Gyatri Pathak W/O Durgesh Tiwari At - Nawatan, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 18. Sunita Devi W/O Akhieshwar Gupta At Mishra Baghawara, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 19. Saroj Devi W/O Ashok Pandey At Mishra Baghawara, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 20. Sheea Mishra W/O Manu Kuma Mishra At Mishra Baghawara, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 21. Anju Sharma W/O Kapilmuni Sharma At Mishra Baghawara, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 22. Shail Devi W/O Anil Kumar At - Ronushana, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 23. Nilam Tiwari W/O Niraj Mishra At Aghawah Mishra, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj
Legal Reasoning
24. Meera Shrivastwa W/O Birendra Lal Shriwastwa At - Belawa, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 25. Pratima Devi W/O Nandlal Prasad At - Ranipur, P.S. - Vijaipur, Patna High Court CWJC No.8727 of 2013 (2) dt.10-05-2013 2/4 District - Gopalganj 26. Binda Devi W/O Jangbahadur Singh At Nawaka Tola, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 27. Sheela Devi W/O Vijay Pratap Mishra At - Buraina, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 28. Chandra Jyoti Devi W/O Purushotam Chaubey At - Dhanwati, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 29. Poonam Shukala W/O Vikash Shukla At - Rashulpur, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 30. Munni Devi W/O Mahavir Prasad Yadav At - Nawata, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 31. Sanju Devi W/O Awadhesh Mishra At - Aghaila Mishra, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 1. 32. Urmila Devi W/O Bhagwati Gupta At - Piparahi, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 32. Madhuri Mishra W/O Devendra Mishra At - Puraina, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 33. Sarika Mishra W/O Satendra Mishra At - Puraina, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 34. Mala Bernawal W/O Gopaljee Barnawal At - P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 35. Reshma Devi W/O Udayman Ram At - Piparahi, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 36. Sangita Devi @ Sangita Chaurasia W/O Angad Chaurasia At - Chitawan, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 37. Reena Devi W/O Dhaneshwar Tiwari At - Babhanawali, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 38. Gita Devi W/O Gopeshwar Tiwari At - Babhanawali, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 39. Sarita Devi W/O Basant Prasad At - Ramnagar, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 40. Chitra Yadav W/O Subash Yadav At - Nawatan, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 41. Usha Devi W/O Ajay Kumar Gupta P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 42. Sarsawati Devi W/O Kashinath Mishra At - Puraina, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 43. Rambha Devi W/O Brij Kishore Ram At - Nawatan Harinan Toli, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 44. Kushmawli Devi @ Kushmawli Yadav W/O Bharat Yadav R/O Village - Majhwalia, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 45. Poonam Devi W/O Heeralal Bharti At - Karmchar, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 46. Nilam Kumari W/O Ramtapashya Tiwari At - Symahuti, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 47. Premsheela Devi W/O Manoj Sharma At Sudama Chak, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 48. Sanju Singh W/O Pradeep Singh At - Sita Patti, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 49. Nirmala Devi W/O Madan Tiwari At - Samahuti, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 50. Ramawati Devi W/O Laljee Tiwari At - Pagra, P.S. - Vijaipur, District Patna High Court CWJC No.8727 of 2013 (2) dt.10-05-2013 3/4 - Gopalganj 51. Urmila Devi W/O Harendra Verma At - Vijaipur, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 52. Anjani Singh W/O Sharawaningh At - Basaha, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 53. Nirmala Devi W/O Sugriw Ishra At - Bangara Bazar, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 54. Sunita Devi W/O Arun Kumar Singh At - Marapi, P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj 55. Nandani Tiwari W/O Deep Narayan Tiwari At - P.S. - Vijaipur, District - Gopalganj .... .... Petitioners Versus 1. The State Of Bihar 2. The Director, Bihar Education Project Council, Patna 3. The District Education Officer, Gopalganj 4. The District Education Superintendent - Cum - Programme Codenator, Gopalganj 5. The District Programme Officer, Primary Siksha And Sarb Siksha Abhiyan, Gopalganj 6. The Block Education Officer, Vijaipur, Block - District - Gopalganj .... .... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance : For the Petitioner/s : Mr. For the Respondent/s : Mr. ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SAMARENDRA PRATAP SINGH ORAL ORDER 2 10-05-2013 Petitioners pray for quashing of the letter no. 4786 dated 19.9.2012 issued by respondent no.2 addressed to all the District Education Officers to retrench al Balbarg Didi from service and to close the all balbarg centers by 1.12.2012. Petitioners submit that the decision of the respondents would render many balbarg didis jobless who have served the institution for quite long time on honorarium basis. One such matter has already been decided in C.W.J.C.No. 21251/2012 disposed of on 11.4.2013 with observation that the Education Patna High Court CWJC No.8727 of 2013 (2) dt.10-05-2013 4/4 Department would consider the case of the petitioners whether it is possible to absorb them under any other scheme. The instant writ petition is disposed of in similar terms. Shashi. (Samarendra Pratap Singh, J)