Patna High Court
Case Details
Patna High Court CWJC No.4843 of 2013 (3) dt.29-04-2013 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.4843 of 2013 ====================================================== 1. Sunil Yadav Son Of Ranjeet Yadav Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 2. Satendra Ray Son Of Late Chandrama Rai Resident Of Village Manikpur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 3. Manoj Kumar Yadav Son Of Shri Lalan Yadav Resident Of Village Chakki Lexan Dera, P.O.- Chakki, P.S.- Brahmpur, District- Buxar 4. Gopalji Yadav Son Of Shri Rama Shankar Yadav Resident Of Village- Tilak Ray Ke Hata, P.O.- Barka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 5. Jalim Yadav Son Of Shri Ram Shankar Yadav Resident Of Village Garka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 6. Santosh Kumar Son Of Harishankar Kumhar Resident Of Village- Chhotaka Rajupur, P.O.- Chhotaka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 7. Manoj Mishra Son Of Hridya Nand Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 8. Sanjay Kumar Paswan Son Of Jiut Ram Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 9. Rakesh Kumar Singh Son Of Bala Singh Resident Of Village- Dharahara, P.O.- Karhnsi, P.S.- Natwar, District- Rohtas 10. Ashok Kumar Singh Son Of Shri Kishori Prasad Singh Resident Of Village- Sukki, P.O.- Sukki, P.S.- Khajauli, District- Madhubani 11. Surya Narayan Singh Son Of Shri Kishori Singh Resident Of Village- Sukki, P.O.- Sukki, P.S.- Khajauli, District- Madhubani 12. Ranjan Kumar Singh Son Of Bindeshwari Singh Resident Of Village- Chhotaka Rajupur, P.O.- Chhotaka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 13. Syam Sundar Mishra Son Of Shri Gauri Shankar Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 14. Upendra Kumar Son Of Shri Ramashray Prasad Resident Of Village- Kamdeo Naga, Salempur, Mahadeva, P.O.- Siwan, P.S.- Mahadeva, District- Siwan 15. Harendra Prasad Son Of Charturgan Prasad Resident Of Village- Dhumrar Bhujurg, P.O.- Dhumrar Khurdh, P.S.- Dharaily, District- Siwan 16. Sunil Kumar Mishra Son Of Narvdeshwar Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 17. Rajesh Kumar Yadav Son Of Shri Kant Yadav Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 18. Ramesh Yadav Son Of Lalputi Yadav Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 19. Suresh Yadav Son Of Baban Yadav Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 20. Ram Babu Mishra Son Of Late Shiomuni Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 21. Chhatu Yadav Son Of Lakshman Yadav Resident Of Village- Chhotaka Rajupur, P.O.- Chhotaka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 22. Sunil Yadav Son Of Kuber Yadav Resident Of Village- Tilak Rai Ke Hata, P.O.- Badka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 23. Anil Kumar Yadav Son Of Ramashankar Yadav Resident Of Village- Chhotaka Rajupur, P.O.- Chhotaka Rajpur, P.S.- Brahmpur, District- Buxar 24. Niranjan Prasad Son Of Jagdish Prasad Resident Of Village- Badka Rajpur, P.O.- Badaka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari District- Buxar Patna High Court CWJC No.4843 of 2013 (3) dt.29-04-2013 25. Munna Kumar Ram Son Of Mahatma Ram Prasad Resident Of Village- Badka Rajpur, P.O.- Badaka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari District- Buxar 26. Dhanji Yadav Son Of Mani Yadav Prasad Resident Of Village- Badka Rajpur, P.O.- Badaka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari District- Buxar 27. Chandra Prakash Yadav Son Of Uma Yadav Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 28. Pintu Kumar Yadav Son Of Nand Kishor Yadav Resident Of Village- Munikpur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 29. Lal Saheb Yadav Son Of Bishwanath Yadav Resident Of Village Chhakki Bisheshwar Dera, P.O.- Chakki, P.S.- Brahmpur, District- Buxar 30. Pancharand Yadav Son Of Durga Yadav Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 31. Jitendra Yadav Son Of Ram Bahadur Yadav Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 32. Tej Narayan Yadav Son Of Bikrama Yadav Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 33. Nagendra Yadav Son Of Laloo Yadav Resident Of Village- Srikarpur, P.O.- Guthani, P.S.- Guthani, District- Siwan 34. Vijendra Kumar Pandey Son Of Late Pashupati Nath Pandey Resident Of Village- Pachrukhi Tola Mathia, P.O.- Pachrukhi, P.S. Pachrukhi, District- Siwan 35. Manoj Kumar Singh Son Of Shri Laxman Singh Resident Of Village- Chamukha, P.O.- Nayanpura, P.S.- Pacharukhi, District- Siwan 36. Nagendra Kumar Baitha Son Of Pardishi Baitha Resident Of Village- Baghara, P.O.- Khalishpur, P.S.- Muffasil, District- Siwan 37. Kamlesh Kumar Yadav Son Of Harendra Yadav Mishra Resident Of Village- Manikpur P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 38. Sugriv Yadav Son Of Shri Ram Nath Yadav Resident Of Village- Badaka Rajpur, P.O.- Badaka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 39. Nitesh Kumar Son Of Ramashish Thakur Resident Of Village- Bandhu Bigha, P.O.- Usri, P.S.- Mahandia, District- Arwal 40. Vidya Bhushan Mishra Son Of Shree Ram Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 41. Jagmohan Singh Son Of Munilal Singh Resident Of Village- Laxmipur (Kdritpura Pokhardha) P.O.- Kamar Pur, P.S.- Buxar Muffasil District- Buxar 42. Saroj Kumar Yadav Son Of Muni Nath Yadav Mishra Resident Of Village- Keshopur, P.O.- Keshopur, P.S.- Semari, District- Buxar 43. Kamlesh Kumar Yadav Son Of Late Triveni Yadav Resident Of Village- Badaka Drajpur, P.O.- Badaka Rajpur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 44. Pintu Ram Son Of Shri Suresh Ram Resident Of Village- More P.O.- More, P.S.- Mokama, District- Patna 45. Sheo Kumar Yadav Son Of Shri Bijhawan Yadav Resident Of Village- Dullahapur, P.O.- Dullahapur, P.S.- Simari, District- Buxar 46. Satya Prakash Singh Son Of Shri Raghunath Singh Resident Of Village Bariwaliya, P.O.- Itwa, P.S.- Pachrukhi, District- Siwan 47. Ramawadh Lal Yadav Son Of Lal Chand Yadav Resident Of Village- Bariwalia, P.O.- Itwa, P.S.- Pachrukhi, District- Siwan 48. Ajit Kumar Son Of Late Ram Rup Paswan Resident Of Village- Mokimpur, Billour, P.O.- Hajipur Billour, District- Patna .... .... Petitioner/s Patna High Court CWJC No.4843 of 2013 (3) dt.29-04-2013 Versus 1. The State Of Bihar, Through The Principal Secretary Government Of Bihar, Patna 2. The Director General Of Police Bihar, Patna 3. The Deputy Inspector General (Human Right) Bihar, Patna 4. The Inspector General B.M.P. Bihar, Patna 5. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Bhojpur (Arrah) 6. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Patna 7. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Jehanabad 8. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Muzaffarpur 9. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Bhagalpur 10. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, B.M.P.- 3, Gaya 11. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, B.M.P.- 6, Muzaffarpur 12. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, B.M.P.- 7 Jamalpur 13. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, B.M.P.- 10 14. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, B.M.P.- 7, Patna 15. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, B.M.P.- 14, Patna 16. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, B.M.P.- 20, Dumraon 17. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, B.M.P.- 13 18. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, B.M.P.- 21 19. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Nalanda 20. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Chhapra 21. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Sitamarhi 22. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Buxar 23. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Hajipur 24. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Darbhanga 25. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Buxar 26. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Siwan 27. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Motihari 28. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Patna Rail 29. The Chairman, Police Selection Board, Begusarai
Legal Reasoning
directions given by this Court in the case of Ajay Kumar (supra) will be at liberty to file his representation to the Chairman of the respective Recruitment Board within a period of one month from the date of issuance of the notification of the concerned Recruitment Board giving full details of his claim for such appointment and those representations will be disposed of by a speaking order by the Chairman of the respective Recruitment Board within a period of three months from the date of receipt of such representation. (iv) Such consideration by the Chairman of the Recruitment Board will be however confined only to fresh appointment to be made on those 507 posts in terms of the direction given by the Division Bench in the case of Ajay Kumar (supra). In other words, the earlier appointment made prior to 28.6.2011, the date on which Division Bench of this Court had issued directions in the case of Ajay Kumar (supra), on the basis of advertisement Nos. 1/2004, 2/2004 and 3/2004 as well as Advertisement Nos. 1/2009 and 2/2009 in respective districts/ Battalions shall not be reopened. (v) The exercise of filling up of remaining of Patna High Court CWJC No.4843 of 2013 (3) dt.29-04-2013 507 posts of constables, out of which 348 appointments have already been made, must be completed strictly on merit within a period of six months from today and thereafter any of the 507 vacancies which could not be filled up on account of non-availability of the candidates of the respective category will be filled up only on the basis of a fresh advertisement. Ranjan/- (Mihir Kumar Jha, J)
Arguments
.... .... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance : For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Rakesh Ranjan, Adv. For the Respondent/s : Mr. J.P Karn, AAG-4 ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MIHIR KUMAR JHA ORAL ORDER 02/ 29-04-2013 Heard learned counsel for the parties, who have submitted that this case is squarely covered by the reasoned order passed today in the leading case being C.W.J.C. No. 126 of 2013. 2. Thus in view of the order passed today in C.W.J.C Patna High Court CWJC No.4843 of 2013 (3) dt.29-04-2013 NO. 126 of 2013 having an identical prayer this writ application is also disposed of with the same observations and directions namely:- (i) The prayer of the petitioner for being appointed on the post of constable on the basis of process of selection undertaken in terms of advertisement no. 1/2004, 2/2004 and 3/2004 has to be considered only against 507 post of Constable as identified by the respondents in their supplementary counter affidavit inasmuch as now only 507 posts alone shall be filled up on the basis of Advertisement Nos. 1/2004, 2/2004 and 3/2004 by the respective Recruitment Board from amongst the candidates who had appeared in such selection and were also declared eligible and successful in all respect. (ii) Each Recruitment Board will notify the breakup number of 507 vacancies already filled up or sought to be filled up and the cut-off marks of the respective category on which the appointments have been or will be made pursuant to the directions of the Division Bench in the case of Ajay Kumar (supra). This exercise must be completed by Chairman of Respective Recruitment Board within a period of one month from the date of receipt of this order. (iii) Any of the applicant who had participated in the selection process of Advertisement no. 1/2004, 2/2004 and 3/2004 and had been declared eligible and successful, on finding himself to be eligible on the basis Patna High Court CWJC No.4843 of 2013 (3) dt.29-04-2013 of marks secured by him earlier pursuant to the earlier selection made in terms of those Advertisement Nos. 1/2004, 2/2004 and 3/2004 and also discovered from the aforesaid notification of the respective Recruitment Board that anyone in his/her category having either the same marks or less than him or her has been appointed against 348 posts after 28.6.2011 in terms of the