Patna High Court · 2009

2.GOPAL PRASAD SINGH SON OF LATE LAL BAHADUR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAINA, P.S. MAHISHI, DISTRICT- SAHARSA WAS WORKING AS NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT SAHARSA 3.MOHAN JHA SON OF SRI MADHAV JHA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE & P.S. BANGAON, DISTRICT-SAHARSA WAS WORKING AS NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT, SAHARSA 4.GOPAL KRISHNA RAY SON OF SRI RATNESHWAR RAY, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-BAGHWA P.S. & DISTRICT SAHARSA WAS WORKING AS NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT, SAHARSA

5. HARERAM KAMAT SON OF LATE AJAB KAMAT, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAINA P.O. NAINAGRAM P.S. MAHISHI, DISTRICT- - 2 - SAHARSA WAS WORKING AS NIGHT GUARD AT C.C.A. DEPOT, SAHARSA

6.SATYANARAYAN CHOUDHARY SON OF SRI RAMGOVIND CHOUDHARY, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE & P.O. KARNPUR DISTRICT-SUPAUL WAS WORKING AS NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT KATIHAR

7.PUNIT PRASAD SON OF LATE KULDEEP PRASAD, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KHAGRA, P.O. BATSAR, VIA-GHOGHA P.S. DHORAIYA DISTRICT-BANKA WAS WORKING AS NIGHT GUARD AT C.C.A. DEPOT MADEPURA------APPELLANT LPA No.966 of 2008 SITA RAM SINGH,SON OF LATE TEJ NARAYAN SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE GOPALPUR, P.S. BIDUPUR, DISTRICT VAISHALI--- APPELLANT LPA No.938 of 2008 KALAKTOR SINGH,SON OF SRI RAM CHANDER SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE ASANI, P.S. UDWANT NAGAR,DISTRICT BHOJPUR--- APPELLANT LPA No.957 of 2008 PRADEEP KUMAR,SON OF SRI RAM SWAROOP BHAGAT, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE; KASBA PACHRUKKHI, P.O. AND P.S. AKBARPUR AND DISTRICT NAWADAH---APPELLANT. LPA No.952 of 2008 RAM SAGAR PANDEY @ RAM SAGAR PANDEY SON OF LATE RAMFAL PANDEY, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-HIRPUR, P.S. JANDAHA, DISTRICT-VAISHALI---APPELLANT LPA No.951 of 2008 DINESHWAR PRASAD SINGHSON OF LATE RAGHUBANSH SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BALBA KUARI, P.S. HAJIPUR SADAR, DISTRICT-VAISHALI---APPELLANT LPA No.962 of 2008 PRABHU NATH SINGH,SON OF LATE BHUP NARAYAN SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-PURKAHAULI P.S. LALGANJ, DISTRICT VAISHALI---APPELLANT LPA No.977 of 2008 SIYA RAM SHARMA,SON OF LATE DWARKA SHARMA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RUKUNPURA, P.S. GHOSHI, P.O. JAITIPUR KURWA, DISTRICT JEHANABAD---APPELLANT. LPA No.974 of 2008 UPENDRA KUMAR,SON OF SUWANSH SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE GOVINDPUR, P.S. BHANRWA, P.O. BOURHI AND DISTRICT PATNA-- -APPELLANT. LPA No.982 of 2008 - 3 - RAJESHWAR MANDALS/O LATE LAKHAN SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE LODIPUR P.S. JEHANABAD, DISTRICT JEHANABAD---APPELLANT. LPA No.994 of 2008 RAJENDRA MANDAL SON OF PARIKSHAN MANDAL, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAKHNAHA, TOLA LACHMINIA, P.S. BELSAND, DISTRICT- SITAMARHI POSTED AS NIGHT GUARD AT C.C.A. DEPOT SITAMARHI- --APPELLANT. LPA No.1012 of 2008

1. MAHENDRA PANDEY SON OF RAM BADAN PANDEY RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-DAHIGANA, P.O. ATTAON, P.S. DUMRAON, DISTRICT-BUXAR, NIGHTGUARD C.C.A. DEPOT, BUXAR 2. RABINDRA PRASAD SON OF LATE BABU RAM KESHARI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE & P.O. BARAKI KULHARIYA P.S. BUXAR MOFASSIL, DISTRICT-BUXAR 3. VIJAY KUMAR PRASAD SON OF LATE KALI PRASAD RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-DUMRAON RAJAI MISHRA KI GALI, WARD NO.14, TOWN & P.S DUMRAON RAJAI MISHRA KI GALI, WARD NO.14, TOWN & P.S.-DUMRAON, DISTRICT-BUXAR 4. RAM BHAJAN SINGH SON OF LATE BANSH ROPAN SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-EKDARWAN, P.O. MAHADAH, P.S. BUXAR MOFASSIL, DISTRICT-BUXAR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT BUXAR 5. DWARIKA PRASAD SON OF KEDAR PRASAD MOHALLA-THATHERI BUXAR DUMRAON, WARD NO.3, TOWN AND P.S. DUMRAON, DISTRICT BUXAR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT BUXAR. 6. BHAGWAN SINGH SON OF LATE RAM SUBHAG SINGH MOHALLA-STATION ROAD, PURANA DHARMSHALA, DUMRAON, WARD NO.13, TOWN & P.S. DUMRAON,DISTRICT-BUXAR, NIGH GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT, RAGHUNATHPUR, BUXAR 7. RANG NATH PANDEY SON OF RAM BADAN PANDEY RESIDENT OF DAHIGANA, P.O. ATTAON, P.S. DUMRAON, DISTRICT-BUXAR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT BUXAR. 8. RAMESHWAR SINGH SON OF LATE KAPILDEO SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-KATHAR, P.O. KATHAR, P.S. KRISHANA BRAHAN, DISTRICT BUXAR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT, RAGHUNATHPUR, BUXAR 9. AMRESH SINGH SON OF LATE RAM BILASH SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE & P.O. AMSARI, P.S. MURAR, DISTRICT BUXAR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT, BUXAR 10. BISHUN PRASAD SON OF LATE RAM YATAN PRASAD RESIDENT OF VILLAGE & PO DULAHPUR P.S. SIMARI, DISTRICT BUXAR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A DEPOT BUXAR. 11. OF VILLAGE & P.O. MEDANIPUR P.S. BABHNAUL, DISTRICT- BUXAR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT BUXAR. 12. HARDEO MISHRA SON OF LATE BASHISHTHA MISHRA RESIDENT OF VILLAGE & P.O. SONBARSHA, P.S. DULAHPUR, DISTRICT BUXAR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT, BALIHARI, BUXAR SHRI NIWAS SINGH SON OF LATE SARYUG SINGH RESIDENT - 4 - ASHOK KUMAR RAM SON OF LATE MOTI LAL RESIDENT OF

13. SHASHI RANJAN SRIVASTAVA SON OF LATE AWADHESH NARAIN SRIVASTAVA, MOHALLA SWAMI SATYA NAND COLONY, MAHABIR CHABUTARA, TOWN AND P.S.-DUMRA-ON, DISTRICT BUXAR NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT BALIHARI BUXAR. 14. BABAN SHARMA SON OF JAGJITAN SHARMA RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-JAITPUR P.O.-ASARI, P.S. UDWANT NAGAR, DISTRICT BHOJPUR, ARRAH, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT BUXAR 15. VILLAGE AND P.O. KALYANPUR, P.S. BIHIYAN, DISTRICT- BHOJPUR, ARRAH, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT BUXAR 16. PARMATMA PRASAD SON OF RAM DEEP SAH RESIDENT OF MOHALLA-BARI MILL ROAD, NAWADAH ARRAH, P.S. ARRAH MOFASIL, DISTRICT-BHOJPUR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT, CHAUSA, BUXAR 17. ITAHITOLA, BIHIYAN, P.S. BIHIYAN, DISTRICT-BHOJPUR, ARRAH, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT BUXAR 18. RAJ KISHORE RAM SON OF MUNARIKA RAM VILLAGE BARAHARA, P.S. DHIBARA (DEV), DISTRICT AURANGABAD, NIGHT GUARD, C.C.A. DEPOT 19. BANDHUR, NARANPUR, P.S. AZIYAONPUR BAZAR(PIRO) DISTRICT BHOJPUR, NIGHT GUARD C.C.A. DEPOT ARRAH, BHOJPUR---- APPELLANTS TARKESHWAR SINGH SON OF SHREE RAM SINGH VILLAGE- RAJ NATH SINGH SON OF LATE VAIDYA SINGH MOHALLA- LPA No.1034 of 2008

1. MANSOOR ALAM,SON OF LATE HAKIMUDDIN, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SATBOHA, P.S. PARKATTA, P.O. CHHTERGOACH AND DISTRICT KISHANGANJ, POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, GULABBAGH, PURNEA AS NIGHT GUARD.

2. MD. EQBAL HUSSAIN, SON OF MAD, BADRUZZAMA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KAJIPASTI, PATTA SHREE, P.S. AND P.O. THAKURGANJ AND DISTRICT KISHANGANJ POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, KISHANGANJ AS NIGHT GUARD.

3. AJIT KUAT SINGH ALIAS AJIT KUMAR, SON OF LATE GITA SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE, P.O. AND P.S. MEHUS AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA, POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, HALSI LAKHISARAI AS NIGHT GUARD.

4. SHEO KANT PRASAD SINGH, SON OF LATE NARAYAN SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KAMTA, P.O. HATHIAWAN, P.S. AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA, POSTED AT JHUMRA COLD STORAGE, HAZARIBAGH AS NIGHT GUARD----APPELLANTS LPA No.19 of 2009 ASHOK KUMAR SINGH,SON OF TAP NARAYAN SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHODAHI, P.O. NATHMALPUR P.S. BARHARA, DISTRICT BHOJPUR AT ARRAH---APPELLANT LPA No.22 of 2009 - 5 - GYAN CHAND PRASAD @ GYAN CHANDRA PRASAD SON OF LATE SHEO SHANKAR PRASAD RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. ASARI, P.S. UDWANT NAGAR, DISTRICT BHOJPUR AT ARRAH-----APPELLANT LPA No.24 of 2009 RAMESHWAR SINGH,SON OF LATE RAM PRASAD RAY, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE & P.O. TAR P.S. AGIYA BAZAR, DISTRICT BHOJPUR AT ARRAH---APPELLANT LPA No.25 of 2009 RAJENDRA PRASAD PASWAN SON OF RAM NARESH PASWAN RESIDENT OF VILLAGE DIGHA, P.O. CHAKAI P.S. DHANGAI, DISTRICT-BHOJPUR AT ARRAH-------APPELLANT LPA No.26 of 2009 PRABHU DAYAL PANDEYSON OF LATE BISHWA NATH PANDEY RESIDENT OF VILLAGE PANDITPUR P.S. BARHARA, DISTRICT BHOJPUR AT ARRAH---APPELLANT LPA No.27 of 2009 VIJAY BAHADUR SINGH SON OF ANIRUDHA SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O.SIYADIH P.S. CHARPOKHARI DISTRICT BHOJPUR AT ARRAH---APPELLANT LPA No.28 of 2009 INDRADEO PRASAD CHOUDHARY SON OF LATE BAKHORI CHOUDHARY RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-CHHATIHAR, P.O. CHHATIHAR P.S. HASHUA, DIST. NAWADA----APPELLANT LPA No.50 of 2009 DADAN SINGH SON OF LATE AWADHESH SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SAHAJANI, P.S. PIRO DISTRICT BHOJPUR AT ARRAH NIGHT GUARD CCA DEPOT, HASAN BAZAR AT ARRAH----APPELLANT LPA No.52 of 2009 PARSHURAM SHARMA SON OF LATE AMBIKA SHARMA RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BHALUA SADAWAH P.S. DULHIN BAZAR, DISTRICT PATNA NIGHT GUARD CCA DEPOT, ARRAH----APPELLANT LPA No.23 of 2009 NAGENDRA SINGH SON OF LATE BRIJ SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- DHANAON, P.S. NABINAGAR, DISTRICT AURANGABAD--APPELLANT LPA No.53 of 2009 SIDH NATH PATHAK SON OF RAMAKANT PATHAK RESIDENT OF VILLAGE YADAVPUR P.S. TIYAR DISTRICT BHOJPUR AT ARRAH---APPELLANT

1.RAJENDRA CHOUDHARY SON OF LATE BAUDHU CHAUDHARY, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KARHARA, P.S. AND P.O. CHOSI AND DISTRICT LPA No.54 of 2009 - 6 - JEHANABAD, AT PRESENT POSTED AS COLD STORAGE, JEHANABAD AS NIGHT GUARD. 2.DINA NATH SHARMA, SON OF LATE KAMESHWAR SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. DEORA, P.S. GHOSI AND DISTRICT JEHANABAD, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT JEHANABAD AS NIGHT GUARD. 3.SAKALDEO YADAV, SON OF LATE RAM LAKSHMAN YADAV, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE GHULAMICHAK, P.O. AND P.S. KAKO AND DISTRICT JEHANABAD, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, JEHANABAD AS NIGHT GUARD. 4. ASHOK KUMAR MISHRA, SON OF SUKHDEO MISHRA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. KORMA, P.S. GHOSI AND DISTRICT JEHANABAD, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, JEHANABAD AS NIGHT GUARD. 5. RAMA KANT TIWARI, SON OF LATE JAGDISH TIWARI, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE PACHETI, P.O. SARISTABAD, P.S. GHOSI AND DISTRICT JEHANABAD, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, HILSA. 6. KRISHAN NANDAN PRASAD SINGH, SON OF LATE RAM KESHWAR PRASAD, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE PARTHU MAKHDUMPUR, P.O. PARTHU, P.S. EKANGARSARAI AND DISTRICT NALANDA AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, HILSA AS NIGHT GUARD. 7. ARUN KUMAR PRASAD, SON OF LATE KARO LAL GARAI, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE PARTHU MAKHDUMPUR P.S. EKANGARSARAI AND DISTRICT NALANDA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, HILSA AS NIGHT GUARD. 8.ARJUN CHAUDHARY, SON OF LATE BHATTU CHAUDHARY, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE DHAMEPUR P.O. BANDHUGANJ, P.S. GHOSI AND DISTRICT JEHANABAD, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, JEHANABAD AS NIGHT GUARD. 9. UMA SHANKAR SINGH, SON OF LATE SAMUNDRA SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE DAULATPUR, P.O. AND P.S. JEHANABAD AND DISTRICT JEHANABD AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, BISCOMAUN, JEHANABAD AS NIGHT GUARD. 10. RAGHUPATI PATHAK, SON OF LATE GANESH DATT PATHAK, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE NAHMALPUR, P.O. KASI SARAI, P.S. KAKO AND DISTRICT JEHANABAD AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, JEHANABAD AS NIGHT GUARD. 11. PARAS PRASAD, SON OF SRI RAJESHWAR PRASAD RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. PAWA, P.S. DEEP NAGAR, AND DISTRICT NALANDA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT RANGE OFFICE, BIHARSHARIFF, NALANDA AT NIGHT GUARD. 12.DINESH PRASAD SINHA, SON OF LATE KAMTA PRASAD, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE DARIYAPUR P.O. CHAK NAWADAH P.S. BARH, DISTRICT PATNA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT RANAGE OFFICE, BIHAR SHARIFF, AS NIGHT GUARD. 13. ABODH KISHORE PANDEY, SON OF LATE PRAKASH PANDEY, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. MAHAMMADPUR, P.S. ASTHAN AND DISTRICT NALANDA AT PRESENT POSTED AT RANGE OFFICE, BIHARSHARIF AT NIGHT GUARD. 14. RAM KUMAR PRASAD SINGH, SON OF LATE RAJENDRA SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MASUADPUR, P.O. AND P.S. SAHJAHANPUR AND DISTRICT PATNA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT CHANDI(NALANDA) AS NIGHT GUARD. - 7 -

15. MAHESHWAR PRASAD, SON OF SRI SHEO NANDAN MISTRY, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SABALPUR, PO AND P.S. RAJGIR AND DISTRICT NALANDA AT PRESENT POSTED AT RANGE OFFICE, BIHARSHARIF AS NIGHT GUARD. 16. BINESHWARI PRASAD, SON OF LATE RAMAUTAR MALI, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE TADA-UDAYPUR P.O. RAJGIR, P.S. CHHABILAPUR AND DISTRICT NALANDA AT PRESENT POSTED AT RANGE OFFICE BIHARSHARIF AS NIGHT GUARD. 17. BINOY KUMAR SINGH, SON OF LATE NAWAL KISHORE SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SHEIKHPOOL, SIKHAURA, P.O. SITHAURA, P.S. RAJGIR AND DISTRICT NALANDA AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, RAJGIR, AS NIGHT GUARD. 18. NAWAL KISHORE SHARMA, SON OF LATE YUMNA SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE VANABIGHA, P.O. AND P.S. PARWALPUR AND DISTRICT NALANDA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, RAMCHANDRAPUR, BIHARSHARIF, AS NIGHT GUARD. 19. RAM NANDAN PRASAD SINGH, SON OF SRI MEGH RAJ PRASAD, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. PANGARI, P.S. WARSALIGANJ AND DISTRICT NALANDA AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, RAJGIR, BIHARSHARIF AS NIGHT GUARD. 20. INDRADEO PRASAD SON OF JAGDISH JAMADAR, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AHIAPUR, P.O. DAHPAR, P.S. NOOR SARAI AND DISTRICT NALANDA AT PRESENT POSTED AT RANGE OFFICE, BIHARSHARIF AS NIGHT GUARD. 21. ARJUN PRASAD SINGH, SON OF LATE RAGHUNANDAN PRASAD SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. GAWAN, P.S. SHEIKHPURA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA AT PRESENT POSTED AT RANGE OFFICE, BIHARSHARIF AS NIGHT GUARD. 22. BANKEY PRASAD, SON OF LATE AYODYA MAHTO, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MURTZAPUR P.O. ANDI P.S. BIND AND DISTRICT NALANDA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, ASTHAMA, NALANDA AT NIGHT GUARD. 23 RABINDRA PRASAD, SON OF LATE FAUZDARI MAHTO, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BASANPUR P.O. UTTERNAMA, P.S. RAHUI AND DISTRICT NALANDA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, RAMCHANDRAPUR, BIHARSHARIF AS NIGHT GUARD. 24. ARBIND SINGH, SON OF SRI RAM BRISH SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE TULLIBIGHA, P.O. KILLI, P.S. HULESGANJ AND DISTRICT JEHANABAD, DEPOT, ISLAMPUR(NALANDA) AS NIGHT GUARD. 25. KRISHNA KUMAR SINGH, SON OF SRI HARIDWAR SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE TULLI BIGHA, P.O. KLIL, P.S. HULASGANJ AND DISTRICT JEHANABAD, AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, ISLAMPUR(NALANDA) AT NIGHT GUARD. 26.DILIP KUMAR, SON OF LATE MOHAN PRASAD, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE, PO AND P.S. ISLAMPUR AND DISTRICT NALANDA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, ISLAMPUR(NALANDA) AS NIGHT GUARD. 27. RANJIT KUMAR, SON OF LATE BISHUNDEO SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE TANDAPAR, P.O. GIRNAMA, P.S. BENA AND DISTRICT PRESENT POSTED C.C.A. AT AT - 8 - NALANDA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, HATHIAMA, SHEIKHPURA AT NIGHT GUARD. 28. SURENDRA PRASAD SINGH, SON OF LATE ALAKHDEO SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. HATHIAWAN, P.S. SHEIKHPURA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, SARMERA, NALANDA AS NIGHT GUARD. 29.RAJENDRA PRASAD SINGH, SON OF LATE SUKHDEO PRASAD SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. MAYUR, P.S. BARBIGHA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, SARMERA, NALANDA AS NIGHT GUARD. 30. SUNIL PRASAD SINGH, SON OF SRI SURYU PRASAD, SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. HATHIAWAN, P.S. SHEIKHPURA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, HATHIAWAN, SHEIKHPURA AS NIGHT GUARD. 31. SURESH SHARMA, SON OF LATE LADDU SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KAMTA, P.O. HATHIAWAN AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, LAKHISARAI AS NIGHT GUARD. 32. UMESH PRASAD SINGH, SON OF SRI DEV NARAYAN SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. HATHIAWAN P.S. SHEIKHPURA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, ARIYARI AS NIGHT GUARD. 33. JANARDAN PRASAD SINGH, SON OF LATE SITA RAM SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. HATHIAWAN, P.S. SHEIKHPURA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, SIKANDRA AS NIGHT GUARD. 34. NARENDRA PRASAD SINGH, SON OF LATE RAM CHANDRA SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. HATHIAWAN P.S. SHEIKHPUJR AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT BARBIGHA AT NIGHT GUARD. 35.JANG BAHADUR SINGH, SON OF LATE BAUDHU SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE WARUNA, P.O. CHORBOR, P.S. ANYARI AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, ARIYARI AS NIGHT GUARD. 36. BIRENDRA SINGH, SON OF LATE JWALA SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. HATHIAWAN P.S. SHEIKHPURA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA DEPOT, BARBIGHA AS NIGHT GUARD. 37. SURENDRA SINGH, SON OF LATE TARNI SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. HATHIWAN, P.S. SHEIKHPURA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA AT PRESENT POSTED AT CCA HATHIAWAN AS NIGHT GUARD. 38.VIJAY KUMAR SINGH ALIAS VIJAY SINGH, SON OF LATE RAMAUTAR SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. HATHIAWAN, P.S. SHEIKHPURA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, SARMERA, NALANDA AS NIGHT GUARD. 39. PRAMOD KUMAR, SON OF LATE MUNESHWAR PRASAD, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE, P.O. AND P.S. BARACHATTI AND DISTRICT GAYA, AT PRESENT POSTED AT C.C.A. DEPOT, SHERGHATI, GAYA AS NIGHT GUARD.----APPELLANTS LPA No.57 of 2009 - 9 -

1.RAMUDIT SINGH SON OF SRI DASHRAT SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHESHPUR P.O. CHAWARA, P.S. KARANDEY AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA 2.SYED KAZIM RAZA RIZIVI, SON OF SYED ALI MUSTARA, RESIDENT OF MOHALLA DAHIYAWAN NEAR CHOTA IMAMBARA, P.O. CHAPRA, P.S. CHAPRA TOWN, DISTRICT SARAN 3.RAMANUJ SINGH SON OF LATE AMBIKA SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE PURA, P.S. AND P.O. WAZIRGANJ AND DISTRICT GAYA. 4. KANHAIYA KUMAR PATHAK, SON OF LATE KAMAKHAYA KUMAR PATHAK, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. PAKHARPUR, P.S. AND DISTRICT ARWAL 5. MITHILESH KUMAR MISHRA, SON OF RAM KISHORE MISHRA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BAUSI, P.S. KARPI, P.O. SONEBHEDRA AND DISTRICT ARWAL. 6.SRI SACHITA NAND SINGH, SON OF LATE RAMESHWARI SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KEMRA, P.S. AROAR P.O. EKRAINA AND DISTRICT MUNGER 7.RAM SHANKAR PRASAD SINGH, SON OF RAJDEO SINGH VILLAGE TETARPUR, PO AND P.S. BARBIGHA AND DISTRICT SHEIKHPURA--- APPELLANT RAM CHARITRA SINGH SON OF SITA SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- DHANAR, P.S. CHANDRADEEP DISTRICT MUNGER---APPELLANT LPA No.61 of 2009 LPA No.62 of 2009 SHAILENDRA KUMARSON OF LATE SITA RAM SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RUPUCHPUR, P.O. HAJARAT SAI P.S. DHANARUA, DISTRICT PATNA---APPELLANT . VERSUS

1.THE STATE OF BIHAR 2.THE SECRETARY OF DEPARTMENT OF CO-OPERATIVE, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 3.THE BIHAR STATE CO-OPERATIVE MARKETING UNION LTD. THROUGH ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR BISCOMAUN BUILDING PATNA.A 4.THE MANAGING DIRECTOR FOR BISCOMAUN, BISCOMAUN BUILDING PATNA 5.THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STATE CO-OPERATIVE MARKETING UNION LTD. BISCOMAUN BUILDING PATNA 6. THE CHAIRMAN, THE BIHAR STATE CO-OPERATIVE MARKETING UNION, BISCOMAUN BUILDING, PATNA. 7.THE DEPUTY MANAGING DIRECTOR, THE BIHAR STATE CO-OPERATIVE MARKETING UNION LTD. BISCOMAUN BUILDING LTD, PATNA. 8. THE SPECIAL OFFICER (ESTABLISHMENT) THE BIHAR STATE CO- OPERATIVE MARKETING UNION LTD. BISCOMAUN BUILDING, PATNA.--- RESPONDENTS( IN ALL THESE APPEALS. 2

16.01.2009 All these appeals arise out of an order dated Ist of - 10 - October, 2008 passed in CWJC No. 12645 of 2006 and analogous cases. We had the occasion to consider the validity of the said order in L.P.A. No. 1030 of 2008 and analogous cases and by order dated 12.1.2008 we have upheld the order of the learned Single Judge and dismissed the appeals. In view of aforesaid, these appeals will have the same fate and accordingly, they are dismissed in limine. (Chandramauli Kr.Prasad, ACJ.) (Dr.Ravi Ranjan,J.) A.Kumar