Patna High Court
Case Details
Patna High Court CWJC No.10802 of 2013 (3) dt.04-09-2013 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.10802 of 2013 ====================================================== 1. Shukdeo Mandal Son Of Late Gaibi Nath Mandal Resident Of Mohalla - Rekabganj, P.O. Bhagalpur City, Police Station - Tatapur (Kotwali) District Bhagalpur 2. Gholti Ram Son Of Late Prithvi Ram @ Prithi Ram Resident Of Mohalla - Rekabganj, P.O. Bhagalpur City, Police Station - Tatapur (Kotwali) District Bhagalpur .... .... Petitioners Versus 1. Heeraman Mandal Son Of Late Samalu Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 2. Vinay Kumar Mandal Son Of Rajendra Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 3. Mukesh Kumar Mandal Son Of Rajendra Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 4. Sanjay Mandal Son Of Umesh Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 5. Dinesh Mandal Son Of Late Bharosi Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 6. Sunil Mandal Son Of Late Arun Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 7. Ramdeo Mandal Son Of Late Narayan Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 8. Kundan Kumar Son Of Khublal Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 9. Murari Kumar Son Of Rajendra Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 10. Vikash Kumar Son Of Rajendra Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 11. Ram Pukar Mandal Son Of Late Bilas Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 12. Gopal Mandal Son Of Sita Ram Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 13. Gopal Mandal Son Of Late Narayan Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 14. Nand Kishore Mandal Son Of Late Ramroop Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 15. Doman Mahto Son Of Late Nitaya Mahto Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 16. Horshil Mahto Son Of Upendra Singh Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 17. Suresh Mahto Son Of Late Anand Mahto Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 18. Naresh Paswan Son Of Late Arjun Paswan Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 19. Chhattu Ram Son Of Late Chandar Ram Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 20. Arjun Ram Son Of Nagresh Ram Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 21. Sandand Ram Son Of Late Chunni Ram Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 22. Bishundeo Ram Son Of Late Shoshi Ram Residing At Mohalla
Legal Reasoning
Patna High Court CWJC No.10802 of 2013 (3) dt.04-09-2013 Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 23. Dina Ram Son Of Late Garib Ram Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 24. Radha Devi Wife Of Laxmi Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 25. Basduki Mandal Son Of Late Bhumeshwar Das Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 26. Upendra Mandal Son Of Late Kesho Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 27. Kesho Das Son Of Late Bhumeshwar Das Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 28. Kaushal Kishore Mandal Son Of Late Ram Rup Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 29. Umesh Mandal Son Of Late Chhatri Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 30. Ramchandra Mandal Son Of Jaleshwar Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 31. Sadanand Rai Son Of Late Bishundeo Rai Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 32. Ajay Kumar Mandal Son Of Suresh Manda; Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 33. Rajendra Mandal Son Of Late Budhan Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 34. Vinod Mandal Son Of Late Bharoshi Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 35. Kundan Kumar Son Of Nageshwar Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 36. Ganesh Mandal Son Of Late Bindeshwari Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 37. Angad Mandal Son Of Late Dhaneshwar Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 38. Pankaj Mandal Son Of Babulal Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 39. Prakash Mandal Son Of Late Mahadeo Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 40. Jagdish Mandal Son Of Late Jangali Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 41. Ranjeet Mandal Son Of Chamak Lal Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 42. Jamali Mandal Son Of Kallu Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 43. Shoshal Mandal Son Of Late Harihar Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 44. Murari Mandal Son Of Umesh Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 45. Nepali Mandal Son Of Kameshwar Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 46. Samali Mandal Son Of Prasadi Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 47. Shankar Mandal Son Of Prasadi Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 48. Chama Lall Mandal Son Of Late Laxman Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 49. Mangal Mandal Son Of Somi Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Patna High Court CWJC No.10802 of 2013 (3) dt.04-09-2013
Legal Reasoning
Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 50. Dasarath Sah Son Of Late Jhimal Sah Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 51. Laxmi Mandal Son Of Sugdeo Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 52. Bauku Mandal Son Of Late Mahdeo Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 53. Paro Mandal Son Of Bauku Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 54. Ramesh Mandal Son Of Bindeshwari Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 55. Jeetan Mandal Son Of Bhola Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 56. Sikandra Mandal Son Of Raghu Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 57. Prem Lall Sharma Son Of Ramswaroop Sharma Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 58. Alok Mandal Son Of Prabhakar Sharma Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 59. Raju Mandal Son Of Late Mahadeo Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 60. Kampan Mandal Son Of Late Ganga Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 61. Kaushalaya Devi Wife Of Sri Jatadhari Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 62. Karu Lall Mandal Son Of Late Mahadeo Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 63. Sarwan Yadav Son Of Banwari Yadav Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 64. Dharam Raj Rajak Son Of Late Sarju Rajak Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 65. Shankar Mandal Son Of Late Jagdish Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 66. Yogesh Mandal Son Of Late Ganga Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 67. Shesher Kumar Sah Son Of Late Prakash Sah Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 68. Bihari Sah Son Of Late Narayan Sah Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 69. Manoj Mandal Son Of Lawo Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 70. Jawahar Mandal Son Of Late Bilash Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 71. Ganga Mandal Son Of Late Bilash Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 72. Rudal Mandal Son Of Jhorhu Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 73. Guneshwar Mandal Son Of Anandi Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 74. Bachaneshwar Mandal Son Of Mahadeo Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 75. Bullo Mandal Son Of Raushan Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 76. Kapil Deo Mandal Son Of Not Known Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Patna High Court CWJC No.10802 of 2013 (3) dt.04-09-2013 Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 77. Yogendra Mandal Son Of Not Known Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 78. Ghoghan Mandal Son Of Khonay Mandal Residing At Mohalla Rikabganj Kasawa, Police Station Kotwali, District – Bhagalpur Respondents 1st Set 79. Manorama Devi Daughter Of Late Prithi Ram Resident Of Village Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 80. Geeta Ram Son Of Gholti Ram Resident Of Village Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 81. Raju Ram Son Of Gholti Ram Resident Of Village Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 82. Ranjeet Ram Son Of Gholti Ram Resident Of Village Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 83. Basu Ram Son Of Gholti Ram Resident Of Village Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 84. Nageshwar Mandal Son Of Late Gaibi Resident Of Village Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 85. Praveen Kumar Son Of Sukhdeo Mandal Resident Of Village Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 86. Dilip Kumar Son Of Sukhdeo Mandal Resident Of Village Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 87. Rajeev Kumar Son Of Sukhdeo Mandal Resident Of Village Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District – Bhagalpur Respondents 2nd Set 88. Bauki Ram Son Of Late Munni Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 89. Fulo Ram Son Of Late Munni Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 90. Kailu Ram Son Of Late Munni Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 91. Bhoni Ram Son Of Late Munni Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 92. Pancho Devi Daughter Of Late Munni Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 93. Shambhu Ram Son Of Banki Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 94. Awadh Ram Son Of Fulo Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 95. Mainu Ram Son Of Fulo Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 96. Kartik Ram Son Of Kailu Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur 97. Pappu Ram Son Of Kailu Ram Resident Of Mohalla Rikabganj Police Station Kotwali, District - Bhagalpur .... .... Respondents 3rd Set ====================================================== Appearance : For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Abdul Wadood Mr. Kulanand Jha For the Respondent/s : None ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE CHAKRADHARI SHARAN SINGH Patna High Court CWJC No.10802 of 2013 (3) dt.04-09-2013 3 04-09-2013 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners. ORAL ORDER The petitioner is aggrieved by an order dated 06.05.2013 passed in Title Suit No. 420 of 2006 by learned Sub-Judge VII, Bhagalpur, whereby the Court below has rejected a petition filed on behalf of some of the defendants praying for deciding the maintainability of the suit on the ground of limitation as preliminary issue. From the impugned order it appears that the Court below has rejected the petition and has observed that issue of limitation will be decided alongwith other issues in course of trial. Such order needs no interference in a proceeding under Article 227 Constitution of India as the said order, even if erroneous cannot be said to be incapable of correction at this stage. This application is accordingly dismissed. Saif/- (Chakradhari Sharan Singh, J.)